Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > sci.physics > #813419 > unrolled thread

Wind turbines- blade area or swept area for power?

Started byDave <dwickford@yahoo.com>
First post2020-12-28 12:47 +0000
Last post2021-04-02 09:36 +0530
Articles 13 — 6 participants

Back to article view | Back to sci.physics


Contents

  Wind turbines- blade area or swept area for power? Dave <dwickford@yahoo.com> - 2020-12-28 12:47 +0000
    Re: Wind turbines- blade area or swept area for power? Andy Everett <andyeverett57@gmail.com> - 2020-12-28 05:29 -0800
    Re: Wind turbines- blade area or swept area for power? Andy Everett <andyeverett57@gmail.com> - 2020-12-28 05:55 -0800
    Re: Wind turbines- blade area or swept area for power? Andy Everett <andyeverett57@gmail.com> - 2020-12-28 05:55 -0800
      Re: Wind turbines- blade area or swept area for power? Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2020-12-28 08:20 -0600
        Re: Wind turbines- blade area or swept area for power? Andy Everett <andyeverett57@gmail.com> - 2020-12-28 06:23 -0800
          Re: Wind turbines- blade area or swept area for power? moroney@world.std.spaamtrap.com (Michael Moroney) - 2020-12-28 18:03 +0000
            Re: Wind turbines- blade area or swept area for power? Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2020-12-28 12:26 -0600
    Re: Wind turbines- blade area or swept area for power? Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2020-12-28 08:19 -0600
    Re: Wind turbines- blade area or swept area for power? Dave <dwickford@yahoo.com> - 2020-12-28 23:52 +0000
      Re: Wind turbines- blade area or swept area for power? "edpr...@gmail.com" <edprochak@gmail.com> - 2020-12-29 13:02 -0800
        Re: Wind turbines- blade area or swept area for power? Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2020-12-30 21:32 -0600
      Re: Wind turbines- blade area or swept area for power? mike <this@address.is.invalid> - 2021-04-02 09:36 +0530

#813419 — Wind turbines- blade area or swept area for power?

FromDave <dwickford@yahoo.com>
Date2020-12-28 12:47 +0000
SubjectWind turbines- blade area or swept area for power?
Message-ID<rsck5t$j2f$1@dont-email.me>
Looking at 
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbine_design#cite_note-10 and 
https://web.archive.org/web/20120426062213/http://www.renewwisconsin.org/wind/Toolbox-Homeowners/Back%20to%20the%20basics%205-Collector%20Size.pdf, 
there seems to be an oversimplification about wind turbines.

How exactly is power output proportional to blade length squared if the 
blades get shorter as they get longer?  This seems counter intuitive 
which is often correct for human scale. My impression is that turbine 
design is going for size (not height) because of macho needs, in the 
same way as city skyscrapers.   Have they tried putting tips on the 
blades to increase the area?  This was done by Westland helicopters back 
in the 1980s to break world records.

In the same vein I am trying to work through if many smallish turbines 
on gantries high up would be a good idea.  It certainly would be for 
maintability, since 4 people could change one with a hoist and winch, 
without needing a USD 40,000 per day barge and crane.  Still haven't 
worked through changing the angle to face into the wind from all angles, 
since they would block each other when side on.  Might be OK is places 
with a prevailing wind direction, and you could vary the angle by +/- 30 
degrees or so.  With gantry arrays you could always be sure of getting 
something, since they don't all need to face the same way. There would 
be a pillar on a tripod support.  Each pillar would have about 7 beams 
to the other pillar and each beam would have poles for turbines, one up, 
one down each with a 12 kW turbine. The poles are needed to allow for a 
certain amount of rotation.  So 14 on each gantry 7 up, 7 down.  In 
total about 1.1MW with 98 turbines you can buy as commodities on-line. 
(e.g. 8kW turbine is GBP 1,500). There might be vibration challenges if 
they all spin at the same speed, so might need to ensure slightly 
different speeds for each. Problem probably is the amount of steel 
needed, so after an initial prototype you might want to put them on 
cables, and have a power web.

[toc] | [next] | [standalone]


#813423

FromAndy Everett <andyeverett57@gmail.com>
Date2020-12-28 05:29 -0800
Message-ID<b75830ef-b9d5-4cd7-91c5-4f750cd9fcebn@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#813419
On Monday, December 28, 2020 at 7:48:02 AM UTC-5, Dave wrote:
> Looking at 
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbine_design#cite_note-10 and 
> https://web.archive.org/web/20120426062213/http://www.renewwisconsin.org/wind/Toolbox-Homeowners/Back%20to%20the%20basics%205-Collector%20Size.pdf, 
> there seems to be an oversimplification about wind turbines. 
> 
> How exactly is power output proportional to blade length squared if the 
> blades get shorter as they get longer? This seems counter intuitive 
> which is often correct for human scale. My impression is that turbine 
> design is going for size (not height) because of macho needs, in the 
> same way as city skyscrapers. Have they tried putting tips on the 
> blades to increase the area? This was done by Westland helicopters back 
> in the 1980s to break world records. 
> 
> In the same vein I am trying to work through if many smallish turbines 
> on gantries high up would be a good idea. It certainly would be for 
> maintability, since 4 people could change one with a hoist and winch, 
> without needing a USD 40,000 per day barge and crane. Still haven't 
> worked through changing the angle to face into the wind from all angles, 
> since they would block each other when side on. Might be OK is places 
> with a prevailing wind direction, and you could vary the angle by +/- 30 
> degrees or so. With gantry arrays you could always be sure of getting 
> something, since they don't all need to face the same way. There would 
> be a pillar on a tripod support. Each pillar would have about 7 beams 
> to the other pillar and each beam would have poles for turbines, one up, 
> one down each with a 12 kW turbine. The poles are needed to allow for a 
> certain amount of rotation. So 14 on each gantry 7 up, 7 down. In 
> total about 1.1MW with 98 turbines you can buy as commodities on-line. 
> (e.g. 8kW turbine is GBP 1,500). There might be vibration challenges if 
> they all spin at the same speed, so might need to ensure slightly 
> different speeds for each. Problem probably is the amount of steel 
> needed, so after an initial prototype you might want to put them on 
> cables, and have a power web.

It is an interesting question. So a little reading and it looks like the maximum power is proportional to the swept area of the wind turbine, pi times r^2. Why is that, well it has to be some function of r, right? Now it may be that this is only a very good approximation? Most wind farms are built with very large three bladed turbines. Because a lot of money is involved you should expect that most likely this is done for a very good reason. You might look into the Betz Limit, it is the theoretical maximum power you can extract from the wind for a given turbine size.

https://www.google.com/search?q=Betz+Limit&safe=off&sxsrf=ALeKk02z0FONU0snGO2QJPa0EtICXKX8hQ:1609161149548&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjUzNG14PDtAhUK2VkKHQbqDKIQ_AUoAXoECB0QAw&biw=1280&bih=579

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#813424

FromAndy Everett <andyeverett57@gmail.com>
Date2020-12-28 05:55 -0800
Message-ID<1946aebe-fb9f-4576-8db6-f1b454e92325n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#813419
On Monday, December 28, 2020 at 7:48:02 AM UTC-5, Dave wrote:
> Looking at 
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbine_design#cite_note-10 and 
> https://web.archive.org/web/20120426062213/http://www.renewwisconsin.org/wind/Toolbox-Homeowners/Back%20to%20the%20basics%205-Collector%20Size.pdf, 
> there seems to be an oversimplification about wind turbines. 
> 
> How exactly is power output proportional to blade length squared if the 
> blades get shorter as they get longer? This seems counter intuitive 
> which is often correct for human scale. My impression is that turbine 
> design is going for size (not height) because of macho needs, in the 
> same way as city skyscrapers. Have they tried putting tips on the 
> blades to increase the area? This was done by Westland helicopters back 
> in the 1980s to break world records. 
> 
> In the same vein I am trying to work through if many smallish turbines 
> on gantries high up would be a good idea. It certainly would be for 
> maintability, since 4 people could change one with a hoist and winch, 
> without needing a USD 40,000 per day barge and crane. Still haven't 
> worked through changing the angle to face into the wind from all angles, 
> since they would block each other when side on. Might be OK is places 
> with a prevailing wind direction, and you could vary the angle by +/- 30 
> degrees or so. With gantry arrays you could always be sure of getting 
> something, since they don't all need to face the same way. There would 
> be a pillar on a tripod support. Each pillar would have about 7 beams 
> to the other pillar and each beam would have poles for turbines, one up, 
> one down each with a 12 kW turbine. The poles are needed to allow for a 
> certain amount of rotation. So 14 on each gantry 7 up, 7 down. In 
> total about 1.1MW with 98 turbines you can buy as commodities on-line. 
> (e.g. 8kW turbine is GBP 1,500). There might be vibration challenges if 
> they all spin at the same speed, so might need to ensure slightly 
> different speeds for each. Problem probably is the amount of steel 
> needed, so after an initial prototype you might want to put them on 
> cables, and have a power web.

I am posting again as my first message does not appear to be formatted right. 

It is an interesting question. So a little reading and it looks like the maximum power is proportional to the swept area of the wind turbine, pi times r^2. Why is that, well it has to be some function of r, right? Now it may be that this is only a very good approximation? Most wind farms are built with very large three bladed turbines. Because a lot of money is involved you should expect that most likely this is done for a very good reason. You might look into the Betz Limit, it is the theoretical maximum power you can extract from the wind for a given turbine size.

https://www.google.com/search?q=Betz+Limit&safe=off&sxsrf=ALeKk02z0FONU0snGO2QJPa0EtICXKX8hQ:1609161149548&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjUzNG14PDtAhUK2VkKHQbqDKIQ_AUoAXoECB0QAw&biw=1280&bih=579

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#813425

FromAndy Everett <andyeverett57@gmail.com>
Date2020-12-28 05:55 -0800
Message-ID<4e0a911c-7ea0-4679-a74c-2c28ea8c2e74n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#813419
On Monday, December 28, 2020 at 7:48:02 AM UTC-5, Dave wrote:
> Looking at 
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbine_design#cite_note-10 and 
> https://web.archive.org/web/20120426062213/http://www.renewwisconsin.org/wind/Toolbox-Homeowners/Back%20to%20the%20basics%205-Collector%20Size.pdf, 
> there seems to be an oversimplification about wind turbines. 
> 
> How exactly is power output proportional to blade length squared if the 
> blades get shorter as they get longer? This seems counter intuitive 
> which is often correct for human scale. My impression is that turbine 
> design is going for size (not height) because of macho needs, in the 
> same way as city skyscrapers. Have they tried putting tips on the 
> blades to increase the area? This was done by Westland helicopters back 
> in the 1980s to break world records. 
> 
> In the same vein I am trying to work through if many smallish turbines 
> on gantries high up would be a good idea. It certainly would be for 
> maintability, since 4 people could change one with a hoist and winch, 
> without needing a USD 40,000 per day barge and crane. Still haven't 
> worked through changing the angle to face into the wind from all angles, 
> since they would block each other when side on. Might be OK is places 
> with a prevailing wind direction, and you could vary the angle by +/- 30 
> degrees or so. With gantry arrays you could always be sure of getting 
> something, since they don't all need to face the same way. There would 
> be a pillar on a tripod support. Each pillar would have about 7 beams 
> to the other pillar and each beam would have poles for turbines, one up, 
> one down each with a 12 kW turbine. The poles are needed to allow for a 
> certain amount of rotation. So 14 on each gantry 7 up, 7 down. In 
> total about 1.1MW with 98 turbines you can buy as commodities on-line. 
> (e.g. 8kW turbine is GBP 1,500). There might be vibration challenges if 
> they all spin at the same speed, so might need to ensure slightly 
> different speeds for each. Problem probably is the amount of steel 
> needed, so after an initial prototype you might want to put them on 
> cables, and have a power web.

Still not formatted right, help!

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#813429

FromSergio <invalid@invalid.com>
Date2020-12-28 08:20 -0600
Message-ID<rscpjd$u1h$3@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#813425
On 12/28/2020 7:55 AM, Andy Everett wrote:
> On Monday, December 28, 2020 at 7:48:02 AM UTC-5, Dave wrote:
>> Looking at 
>> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbine_design#cite_note-10 and 
>> https://web.archive.org/web/20120426062213/http://www.renewwisconsin.org/wind/Toolbox-Homeowners/Back%20to%20the%20basics%205-Collector%20Size.pdf, 
>> there seems to be an oversimplification about wind turbines. 
>>
>> How exactly is power output proportional to blade length squared if the 
>> blades get shorter as they get longer? This seems counter intuitive 
>> which is often correct for human scale. My impression is that turbine 
>> design is going for size (not height) because of macho needs, in the 
>> same way as city skyscrapers. Have they tried putting tips on the 
>> blades to increase the area? This was done by Westland helicopters back 
>> in the 1980s to break world records. 
>>
>> In the same vein I am trying to work through if many smallish turbines 
>> on gantries high up would be a good idea. It certainly would be for 
>> maintability, since 4 people could change one with a hoist and winch, 
>> without needing a USD 40,000 per day barge and crane. Still haven't 
>> worked through changing the angle to face into the wind from all angles, 
>> since they would block each other when side on. Might be OK is places 
>> with a prevailing wind direction, and you could vary the angle by +/- 30 
>> degrees or so. With gantry arrays you could always be sure of getting 
>> something, since they don't all need to face the same way. There would 
>> be a pillar on a tripod support. Each pillar would have about 7 beams 
>> to the other pillar and each beam would have poles for turbines, one up, 
>> one down each with a 12 kW turbine. The poles are needed to allow for a 
>> certain amount of rotation. So 14 on each gantry 7 up, 7 down. In 
>> total about 1.1MW with 98 turbines you can buy as commodities on-line. 
>> (e.g. 8kW turbine is GBP 1,500). There might be vibration challenges if 
>> they all spin at the same speed, so might need to ensure slightly 
>> different speeds for each. Problem probably is the amount of steel 
>> needed, so after an initial prototype you might want to put them on 
>> cables, and have a power web.
> 
> Still not formatted right, help!
> 

this is text forum, your browser/newsreader may be trying to post in html

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#813431

FromAndy Everett <andyeverett57@gmail.com>
Date2020-12-28 06:23 -0800
Message-ID<421bfcf8-76e4-40e7-a230-a2b4e294a2dfn@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#813429
On Monday, December 28, 2020 at 9:20:35 AM UTC-5, Sergio wrote:
> On 12/28/2020 7:55 AM, Andy Everett wrote: 
> > On Monday, December 28, 2020 at 7:48:02 AM UTC-5, Dave wrote: 
> >> Looking at 
> >> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbine_design#cite_note-10 and 
> >> https://web.archive.org/web/20120426062213/http://www.renewwisconsin.org/wind/Toolbox-Homeowners/Back%20to%20the%20basics%205-Collector%20Size.pdf, 
> >> there seems to be an oversimplification about wind turbines. 
> >> 
> >> How exactly is power output proportional to blade length squared if the 
> >> blades get shorter as they get longer? This seems counter intuitive 
> >> which is often correct for human scale. My impression is that turbine 
> >> design is going for size (not height) because of macho needs, in the 
> >> same way as city skyscrapers. Have they tried putting tips on the 
> >> blades to increase the area? This was done by Westland helicopters back 
> >> in the 1980s to break world records. 
> >> 
> >> In the same vein I am trying to work through if many smallish turbines 
> >> on gantries high up would be a good idea. It certainly would be for 
> >> maintability, since 4 people could change one with a hoist and winch, 
> >> without needing a USD 40,000 per day barge and crane. Still haven't 
> >> worked through changing the angle to face into the wind from all angles, 
> >> since they would block each other when side on. Might be OK is places 
> >> with a prevailing wind direction, and you could vary the angle by +/- 30 
> >> degrees or so. With gantry arrays you could always be sure of getting 
> >> something, since they don't all need to face the same way. There would 
> >> be a pillar on a tripod support. Each pillar would have about 7 beams 
> >> to the other pillar and each beam would have poles for turbines, one up, 
> >> one down each with a 12 kW turbine. The poles are needed to allow for a 
> >> certain amount of rotation. So 14 on each gantry 7 up, 7 down. In 
> >> total about 1.1MW with 98 turbines you can buy as commodities on-line. 
> >> (e.g. 8kW turbine is GBP 1,500). There might be vibration challenges if 
> >> they all spin at the same speed, so might need to ensure slightly 
> >> different speeds for each. Problem probably is the amount of steel 
> >> needed, so after an initial prototype you might want to put them on 
> >> cables, and have a power web. 
> > 
> > Still not formatted right, help! 
> >
> this is text forum, your browser/newsreader may be trying to post in html

I think I am using Google Chrome. I can manually hit the return but it should
(hits return) automatic? Thank you.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#813435

Frommoroney@world.std.spaamtrap.com (Michael Moroney)
Date2020-12-28 18:03 +0000
Message-ID<rsd6l0$6j8$1@pcls7.std.com>
In reply to#813431
Andy Everett <andyeverett57@gmail.com> writes:

>On Monday, December 28, 2020 at 9:20:35 AM UTC-5, Sergio wrote:
>> On 12/28/2020 7:55 AM, Andy Everett wrote: 
>> > On Monday, December 28, 2020 at 7:48:02 AM UTC-5, Dave wrote: 
>> >> Looking at 
>> >> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbine_design#cite_note-10 and 
>> >> https://web.archive.org/web/20120426062213/http://www.renewwisconsin.org/wind/Toolbox-Homeowners/Back%20to%20the%20basics%205-Collector%20Size.pdf, 
>> >> there seems to be an oversimplification about wind turbines. 
>> >> 
>> >> How exactly is power output proportional to blade length squared if the 
>> >> blades get shorter as they get longer? This seems counter intuitive 
>> >> which is often correct for human scale.

While common sense frequently doesn't work in science, I always wondered why 
turbines didn't use more blades than 3 to capture the wind energy away from
the blades, but here it's mentioned it's the swept area which matters.
I have to wonder how the wind away from the blades contributes to the energy.
Hydroelectric turbines frequently have dozens of elements per turbine to
extract energy from water flow.

>> > Still not formatted right, help! 
>> >
>> this is text forum, your browser/newsreader may be trying to post in html

>I think I am using Google Chrome. I can manually hit the return but it should
>(hits return) automatic? Thank you.

You are posting using Giggle Groups.  It's known for screwing up Usenet
royally sometimes.  Every time Google updates it, it seems to get worse.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#813436

FromSergio <invalid@invalid.com>
Date2020-12-28 12:26 -0600
Message-ID<rsd806$ed0$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#813435
On 12/28/2020 12:03 PM, Michael Moroney wrote:
> Andy Everett <andyeverett57@gmail.com> writes:
> 
>> On Monday, December 28, 2020 at 9:20:35 AM UTC-5, Sergio wrote:
>>> On 12/28/2020 7:55 AM, Andy Everett wrote: 
>>>> On Monday, December 28, 2020 at 7:48:02 AM UTC-5, Dave wrote: 
>>>>> Looking at 
>>>>> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbine_design#cite_note-10 and 
>>>>> https://web.archive.org/web/20120426062213/http://www.renewwisconsin.org/wind/Toolbox-Homeowners/Back%20to%20the%20basics%205-Collector%20Size.pdf, 
>>>>> there seems to be an oversimplification about wind turbines. 
>>>>>
>>>>> How exactly is power output proportional to blade length squared if the 
>>>>> blades get shorter as they get longer? This seems counter intuitive 
>>>>> which is often correct for human scale.
> 
> While common sense frequently doesn't work in science, I always wondered why 
> turbines didn't use more blades than 3 to capture the wind energy away from
> the blades, but here it's mentioned it's the swept area which matters.
> I have to wonder how the wind away from the blades contributes to the energy.
> Hydroelectric turbines frequently have dozens of elements per turbine to
> extract energy from water flow.

more blades, more mass, more structure to support them,
blade energy capture is dependent upon wind speed too
I am sure they have optomized the heck out of them, it would be great to
see that optomization too!

the wind after the blades is turbulent and can cause disruption to the
next set on down,


> 
>>>> Still not formatted right, help! 
>>>>
>>> this is text forum, your browser/newsreader may be trying to post in html
> 
>> I think I am using Google Chrome. I can manually hit the return but it should
>> (hits return) automatic? Thank you.
> 
> You are posting using Giggle Groups.  It's known for screwing up Usenet
> royally sometimes.  Every time Google updates it, it seems to get worse.
> 

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#813428

FromSergio <invalid@invalid.com>
Date2020-12-28 08:19 -0600
Message-ID<rscphg$u1h$2@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#813419
On 12/28/2020 6:47 AM, Dave wrote:
> 
> Looking at
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbine_design#cite_note-10 and
> https://web.archive.org/web/20120426062213/http://www.renewwisconsin.org/wind/Toolbox-Homeowners/Back%20to%20the%20basics%205-Collector%20Size.pdf,
> there seems to be an oversimplification about wind turbines.
> 
> How exactly is power output proportional to blade length squared if the
> blades get shorter as they get longer?  

it is simply swept area, the area the blade covers,
so the length of a blade is the radius of the circle, r,
A = r^2


> This seems counter intuitive
> which is often correct for human scale. My impression is that turbine
> design is going for size (not height) because of macho needs, in the
> same way as city skyscrapers.   Have they tried putting tips on the
> blades to increase the area?  This was done by Westland helicopters back
> in the 1980s to break world records.

the height is needed to get to faster moving air, and keep away from
ground turbulance.

> 
> In the same vein I am trying to work through if many smallish turbines
> on gantries high up would be a good idea.  It certainly would be for
> maintability, since 4 people could change one with a hoist and winch,
> without needing a USD 40,000 per day barge and crane.  Still haven't
> worked through changing the angle to face into the wind from all angles,
> since they would block each other when side on.  Might be OK is places
> with a prevailing wind direction, and you could vary the angle by +/- 30
> degrees or so.  With gantry arrays you could always be sure of getting
> something, since they don't all need to face the same way. There would
> be a pillar on a tripod support.  Each pillar would have about 7 beams
> to the other pillar and each beam would have poles for turbines, one up,
> one down each with a 12 kW turbine. The poles are needed to allow for a
> certain amount of rotation.  So 14 on each gantry 7 up, 7 down.  In
> total about 1.1MW with 98 turbines you can buy as commodities on-line.
> (e.g. 8kW turbine is GBP 1,500). There might be vibration challenges if
> they all spin at the same speed, so might need to ensure slightly
> different speeds for each. Problem probably is the amount of steel
> needed, so after an initial prototype you might want to put them on
> cables, and have a power web.

need to get maps of average wind speed, and wind speed varance, and
direction for your site. there may or may not be enough wind to cover
the cost of putting the thing up. There are probably maps on the
internet somewhere that have the best places for wind energy, west texas
is one.

Then, you have to look at maintenance costs for the long haul, if it
costs 1 million to put up, and you get 1 million in electricity over 5
years then you have to replace 20 percent of it....

maintenance costs ate up the South Point wind farm in Hawaii, it was un
affordable in the long haul.



[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#813474

FromDave <dwickford@yahoo.com>
Date2020-12-28 23:52 +0000
Message-ID<rsdr4r$jap$1@dont-email.me>
In reply to#813419
On 28/12/2020 12:47, Dave wrote:
> 
> Looking at 
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbine_design#cite_note-10 and 
> https://web.archive.org/web/20120426062213/http://www.renewwisconsin.org/wind/Toolbox-Homeowners/Back%20to%20the%20basics%205-Collector%20Size.pdf, 
> there seems to be an oversimplification about wind turbines.
> 
> How exactly is power output proportional to blade length squared if the 
> blades get shorter as they get longer?  This seems counter intuitive 
> which is often correct for human scale. My impression is that turbine 
> design is going for size (not height) because of macho needs, in the 
> same way as city skyscrapers.   Have they tried putting tips on the 
> blades to increase the area?  This was done by Westland helicopters back 
> in the 1980s to break world records.
> 
> In the same vein I am trying to work through if many smallish turbines 
> on gantries high up would be a good idea.  It certainly would be for 
> maintability, since 4 people could change one with a hoist and winch, 
> without needing a USD 40,000 per day barge and crane.  Still haven't 
> worked through changing the angle to face into the wind from all angles, 
> since they would block each other when side on.  Might be OK is places 
> with a prevailing wind direction, and you could vary the angle by +/- 30 
> degrees or so.  With gantry arrays you could always be sure of getting 
> something, since they don't all need to face the same way. There would 
> be a pillar on a tripod support.  Each pillar would have about 7 beams 
> to the other pillar and each beam would have poles for turbines, one up, 
> one down each with a 12 kW turbine. The poles are needed to allow for a 
> certain amount of rotation.  So 14 on each gantry 7 up, 7 down.  In 
> total about 1.1MW with 98 turbines you can buy as commodities on-line. 
> (e.g. 8kW turbine is GBP 1,500). There might be vibration challenges if 
> they all spin at the same speed, so might need to ensure slightly 
> different speeds for each. Problem probably is the amount of steel 
> needed, so after an initial prototype you might want to put them on 
> cables, and have a power web.

Couple more points.  The idea in paragraph 2 kind of reflects the 
mainframe/ commodity server decision which made Google such a success. 
I saw you can get 240V AC generators (a washing machine engine), and 
240V is OK for 10s of meters.  It would be interesting electrical 
engineering to put all the ACs together, but again, I think this can be 
done with solid state without windings like a modern power supply.  Also 
the name power web would be better called "power cloud".  Over land you 
would want everything to fit into a 3.5 tonne van, so the blade length 
would want to be 3.5 meters of so to fit.

Other points I need to look into are wind resistance with increasing 
blade speed.  Turbulent flow makes things more complicated, so you 
probably want to put everything into the computer and run a simulation.

Base construction costs and size needed are something else, but 
generally with steel and cables, a well designed structure supports 
itself. Not sure if anchoring with cables is a good idea, corroding 
cables is always something to keep an eye on. Might be OK on land. 
Having towers which make a circle would make it self supporting, a bit 
like the antennas you used to see from the train. The larger the better 
so you generate from both sides where the wind comes from.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#813540

From"edpr...@gmail.com" <edprochak@gmail.com>
Date2020-12-29 13:02 -0800
Message-ID<09d4b9f8-3ba8-4142-b8dd-d7c435ce39e3n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#813474
On Monday, December 28, 2020 at 6:53:04 PM UTC-5, Dave wrote:
> On 28/12/2020 12:47, Dave wrote: 
> > 
> > Looking at 
> > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbine_design#cite_note-10 and 
> > https://web.archive.org/web/20120426062213/http://www.renewwisconsin.org/wind/Toolbox-Homeowners/Back%20to%20the%20basics%205-Collector%20Size.pdf, 
> > there seems to be an oversimplification about wind turbines. 
> > 
> > How exactly is power output proportional to blade length squared if the 
> > blades get shorter as they get longer? This seems counter intuitive 
> > which is often correct for human scale. My impression is that turbine 
> > design is going for size (not height) because of macho needs, in the 
> > same way as city skyscrapers. Have they tried putting tips on the 
> > blades to increase the area? This was done by Westland helicopters back 
> > in the 1980s to break world records. 
> > 
> > In the same vein I am trying to work through if many smallish turbines 
> > on gantries high up would be a good idea. It certainly would be for 
> > maintability, since 4 people could change one with a hoist and winch, 
> > without needing a USD 40,000 per day barge and crane. Still haven't 
> > worked through changing the angle to face into the wind from all angles, 
> > since they would block each other when side on. Might be OK is places 
> > with a prevailing wind direction, and you could vary the angle by +/- 30 
> > degrees or so. With gantry arrays you could always be sure of getting 
> > something, since they don't all need to face the same way. There would 
> > be a pillar on a tripod support. Each pillar would have about 7 beams 
> > to the other pillar and each beam would have poles for turbines, one up, 
> > one down each with a 12 kW turbine. The poles are needed to allow for a 
> > certain amount of rotation. So 14 on each gantry 7 up, 7 down. In 
> > total about 1.1MW with 98 turbines you can buy as commodities on-line. 
> > (e.g. 8kW turbine is GBP 1,500). There might be vibration challenges if 
> > they all spin at the same speed, so might need to ensure slightly 
> > different speeds for each. Problem probably is the amount of steel 
> > needed, so after an initial prototype you might want to put them on 
> > cables, and have a power web.
> Couple more points. The idea in paragraph 2 kind of reflects the 
> mainframe/ commodity server decision which made Google such a success. 
> I saw you can get 240V AC generators (a washing machine engine), and 
> 240V is OK for 10s of meters. It would be interesting electrical 
> engineering to put all the ACs together, but again, I think this can be 
> done with solid state without windings like a modern power supply. Also 
> the name power web would be better called "power cloud". Over land you 
> would want everything to fit into a 3.5 tonne van, so the blade length 
> would want to be 3.5 meters of so to fit. 
> 
> Other points I need to look into are wind resistance with increasing 
> blade speed. Turbulent flow makes things more complicated, so you 
> probably want to put everything into the computer and run a simulation. 
> 
> Base construction costs and size needed are something else, but 
> generally with steel and cables, a well designed structure supports 
> itself. Not sure if anchoring with cables is a good idea, corroding 
> cables is always something to keep an eye on. Might be OK on land. 
> Having towers which make a circle would make it self supporting, a bit 
> like the antennas you used to see from the train. The larger the better 
> so you generate from both sides where the wind comes from.

Hey, thanks for the interesting topic. I don't have much more to contribute except to say
this is still a complex problem. As discussed, there are some rule-of-thumb guidelines,
but precise solutions will require complex fluid flow modeling. 

Thanks again for the good topic.
Enjoy,
  Ed

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#813658

FromSergio <invalid@invalid.com>
Date2020-12-30 21:32 -0600
Message-ID<rsjgok$1do5$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#813540
On 12/29/2020 3:02 PM, edpr...@gmail.com wrote:
> On Monday, December 28, 2020 at 6:53:04 PM UTC-5, Dave wrote:
>> On 28/12/2020 12:47, Dave wrote: 
>>>
>>> Looking at 
>>> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbine_design#cite_note-10 and 
>>> https://web.archive.org/web/20120426062213/http://www.renewwisconsin.org/wind/Toolbox-Homeowners/Back%20to%20the%20basics%205-Collector%20Size.pdf, 
>>> there seems to be an oversimplification about wind turbines. 
>>>
>>> How exactly is power output proportional to blade length squared if the 
>>> blades get shorter as they get longer? This seems counter intuitive 
>>> which is often correct for human scale. My impression is that turbine 
>>> design is going for size (not height) because of macho needs, in the 
>>> same way as city skyscrapers. Have they tried putting tips on the 
>>> blades to increase the area? This was done by Westland helicopters back 
>>> in the 1980s to break world records. 
>>>
>>> In the same vein I am trying to work through if many smallish turbines 
>>> on gantries high up would be a good idea. It certainly would be for 
>>> maintability, since 4 people could change one with a hoist and winch, 
>>> without needing a USD 40,000 per day barge and crane. Still haven't 
>>> worked through changing the angle to face into the wind from all angles, 
>>> since they would block each other when side on. Might be OK is places 
>>> with a prevailing wind direction, and you could vary the angle by +/- 30 
>>> degrees or so. With gantry arrays you could always be sure of getting 
>>> something, since they don't all need to face the same way. There would 
>>> be a pillar on a tripod support. Each pillar would have about 7 beams 
>>> to the other pillar and each beam would have poles for turbines, one up, 
>>> one down each with a 12 kW turbine. The poles are needed to allow for a 
>>> certain amount of rotation. So 14 on each gantry 7 up, 7 down. In 
>>> total about 1.1MW with 98 turbines you can buy as commodities on-line. 
>>> (e.g. 8kW turbine is GBP 1,500). There might be vibration challenges if 
>>> they all spin at the same speed, so might need to ensure slightly 
>>> different speeds for each. Problem probably is the amount of steel 
>>> needed, so after an initial prototype you might want to put them on 
>>> cables, and have a power web.
>> Couple more points. The idea in paragraph 2 kind of reflects the 
>> mainframe/ commodity server decision which made Google such a success. 
>> I saw you can get 240V AC generators (a washing machine engine), and 
>> 240V is OK for 10s of meters. It would be interesting electrical 
>> engineering to put all the ACs together, but again, I think this can be 
>> done with solid state without windings like a modern power supply. Also 
>> the name power web would be better called "power cloud". Over land you 
>> would want everything to fit into a 3.5 tonne van, so the blade length 
>> would want to be 3.5 meters of so to fit. 
>>
>> Other points I need to look into are wind resistance with increasing 
>> blade speed. Turbulent flow makes things more complicated, so you 
>> probably want to put everything into the computer and run a simulation. 
>>
>> Base construction costs and size needed are something else, but 
>> generally with steel and cables, a well designed structure supports 
>> itself. Not sure if anchoring with cables is a good idea, corroding 
>> cables is always something to keep an eye on. Might be OK on land. 
>> Having towers which make a circle would make it self supporting, a bit 
>> like the antennas you used to see from the train. The larger the better 
>> so you generate from both sides where the wind comes from.
> 
> Hey, thanks for the interesting topic. I don't have much more to contribute except to say
> this is still a complex problem. As discussed, there are some rule-of-thumb guidelines,
> but precise solutions will require complex fluid flow modeling. 
> 
> Thanks again for the good topic.
> Enjoy,
>   Ed
> 

ck it out;

https://www.esig.energy/wiki-main-page/modeling-of-type-4-wind-turbine-generators/


https://www.cgtrader.com/free-3d-models/wind-turbine


https://www.researchgate.net/publication/319136680_Modeling_and_Simulation_of_Wind_Turbine_Generator_Using_Matlab-Simulink

https://www.intechopen.com/books/modeling-of-turbomachines-for-control-and-diagnostic-applications/modeling-and-simulation-of-the-variable-speed-wind-turbine-based-on-a-doubly-fed-induction-generator


google is your fiend =>  modeling of wind generators

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#819012

Frommike <this@address.is.invalid>
Date2021-04-02 09:36 +0530
Message-ID<s4657v$tv4$1@solani.org>
In reply to#813474
On 29-12-2020 05:22 Dave <dwickford@yahoo.com> wrote:

>  It would be interesting electrical 
> engineering to put all the ACs together, but again, I think this can be 
> done with solid state without windings like a modern power supply.

Any new info on this project?
�
-- 
�

[toc] | [prev] | [standalone]


Back to top | Article view | sci.physics


csiph-web