Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > sci.math > #540598

Re: Choosing a Point II

From Mike Terry <news.dead.person.stones@darjeeling.plus.com>
Newsgroups sci.math
Subject Re: Choosing a Point II
Date 2021-09-28 01:22 +0100
Organization Aioe.org NNTP Server
Message-ID <sitn88$13ch$1@gioia.aioe.org> (permalink)
References (1 earlier) <sio8ht$p93$1@dont-email.me> <sip3uc$ic$1@dont-email.me> <siphj6$md8$1@dont-email.me> <c5634cc5-94e2-6085-2147-4231051a4d53@att.net> <sit5qp$df9$1@dont-email.me>

Show all headers | View raw


On 27/09/2021 20:24, FromTheRafters wrote:
> Jim Burns formulated the question :
>> On 9/26/2021 6:21 AM, FromTheRafters wrote:
>>> James Waldby formulated on Sunday :
>>>> FromTheRafters <erratic@nomail.afraid.org> wrote:
>>>>> Earle Jones formulated the question :
>>
>>>>>> Select a point on a line.  Call it A.
>>>>>> Select another point on a line.  Call it B.
>>>>>> Select another point on a line.  Call it C.
>>>>>> What is the probability that C is between A and B?
>>>>
>>>>> Nearly zero.
>>>>
>>>> How do you see that?  It seems like 1/3 is plausible, as follows:
>>>> Suppose the points are selected at random in some way, with A,B,C
>>>> i.i.d, and distinct with probability 1.  Then there are six possible
>>>> orderings of A, B, C, each equally likely.  Two of those orderings
>>>> have C between A and B.
>>>
>>> The distance between A and B is finite.
>>
>> On average, the distance between A and B is infinite.

Well, that depends entirely on the distribution for A and B.  Some 
distributions give infinite expectation, some finite.

>>
>> I suggest that we fill in the blank places in the question
>> by tipping a delta function over on its side.
>> Define the distribution of the points to be flat between
>> -M/2 and +M/2, zero outside, answer the question for that,
>> and then let M --> +inf
>>
>> We get the probability of C between A and B to be 1/3.
>> Also, we get the average distance between A and B
>> to be M/3.
>>
>> ----
>> There are other ways to fill in the blank places.
>> My first thoughts ran to an exponential "decay" or a power law.
>> However, that symmetry argument looks very good.
>> I haven't worked out any other answer. I bet they'll be 1/3 also.

Yes, with a couple of extra assumptions:
a) one fixed distibution (the same one) for each of A, B, C
b) A, B, C distributions are independent
c) no "discrete" component in the distibutions, so the probability
    of and of A, B, C coinciding is zero.

I'd say this is the most reasonable way to go, because in practice 
someone suggesting this experiment can be challenged to say what they 
mean by "select a point on a line", and if we press them, hopefully they 
would come up with some pseudo-mechanical process for generating the 
point, which will hopefully have some well defined distribution we could 
apply, meeting the criteria (a)(b)(c).  Then the symmetry argument works.

E.g. "put a spinner 1m from the line and spin it around.  [AKA let the 
angle the spinner points be evenly distributed on [0, 2Pi)].  Extend a 
line through where the spinner stops, and the selected point on the 
original line is where that line intersects the spinner line.

> 
> I suggest, naively, that there are just as many points within the 
> segment as there are without, so one half could be a (useless IMO) 
> answer too.

Probability is not based on "the number of points", so that would indeed 
be a useless answer.  :)  (..and one not justified by probability 
arguments..)

Mike.

Back to sci.math | Previous | Next — Previous in thread | Next in thread | Find similar | Unroll thread


Thread

Choosing a Point II Earle Jones <earle.jones@comcast.net> - 2021-09-25 21:51 +0000
  Re: Choosing a Point II FromTheRafters <erratic@nomail.afraid.org> - 2021-09-25 18:40 -0400
    Re: Choosing a Point II James Waldby <j-waldby@no.no> - 2021-09-26 06:28 +0000
      Re: Choosing a Point II FromTheRafters <erratic@nomail.afraid.org> - 2021-09-26 06:21 -0400
        RE: Re: Choosing a Point II Earle Jones <earle.jones@comcast.net> - 2021-09-27 17:39 +0000
          Re: Choosing a Point II FromTheRafters <erratic@nomail.afraid.org> - 2021-09-27 14:41 -0400
        Re: Choosing a Point II Jim Burns <james.g.burns@att.net> - 2021-09-27 14:51 -0400
          Re: Choosing a Point II FromTheRafters <erratic@nomail.afraid.org> - 2021-09-27 15:24 -0400
            Re: Choosing a Point II Mike Terry <news.dead.person.stones@darjeeling.plus.com> - 2021-09-28 01:22 +0100
              Re: Choosing a Point II FromTheRafters <erratic@nomail.afraid.org> - 2021-09-28 05:26 -0400
                Re: Choosing a Point II "Ross A. Finlayson" <ross.finlayson@gmail.com> - 2021-09-28 08:00 -0700
                Re: Choosing a Point II "mitchr...@gmail.com" <mitchrae3323@gmail.com> - 2021-09-28 12:13 -0700
                Re: Choosing a Point II James Waldby <j-waldby@no.no> - 2021-09-29 04:11 +0000
                Re: Choosing a Point II FromTheRafters <erratic@nomail.afraid.org> - 2021-09-29 04:23 -0400
                Re: Choosing a Point II Jim Burns <james.g.burns@att.net> - 2021-09-29 07:18 -0400
          Re: Choosing a Point II "markus...@gmail.com" <markusklyver@gmail.com> - 2021-09-27 12:54 -0700
  RE: Choosing a Point II Earle Jones <earle.jones@comcast.net> - 2021-09-25 23:59 +0000
  Re: Choosing a Point II Alan Mackenzie <acm@muc.de> - 2021-09-26 09:17 +0000
  Re: Choosing a Point II Peter <peterxpercival@hotmail.com> - 2021-09-26 15:12 +0100
    Re: Choosing a Point II Mike Terry <news.dead.person.stones@darjeeling.plus.com> - 2021-09-26 16:13 +0100
      Re: Choosing a Point II "mitchr...@gmail.com" <mitchrae3323@gmail.com> - 2021-09-26 12:01 -0700
  Re: Choosing a Point II "markus...@gmail.com" <markusklyver@gmail.com> - 2021-09-27 09:00 -0700
    Re: Choosing a Point II FromTheRafters <erratic@nomail.afraid.org> - 2021-09-27 14:49 -0400
      Re: Choosing a Point II Mike Terry <news.dead.person.stones@darjeeling.plus.com> - 2021-09-28 02:37 +0100

csiph-web