Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]
| From | Sergio <invaled@invalid.com> |
|---|---|
| Newsgroups | sci.math |
| Subject | Re: A friendly challenge to Eram semper recta |
| Date | 2021-06-27 13:11 -0500 |
| Organization | Aioe.org NNTP Server |
| Message-ID | <sbaevp$qga$1@gioia.aioe.org> (permalink) |
| References | <2fd391d0-d27f-4845-bf04-1affd4c02bcen@googlegroups.com> |
On 6/27/2021 12:56 PM, Quantum Bubbles wrote: > [Opening Note: this is an amended version of a previously made challenge, due to certain complications with how Mensa in the US releases information to candidates, that I was not clued-up on sufficiently before. It is intended as a friendly challenge with a constructive purpose, not to be considered as mocking or aggressive]. > > The individual going under the name Eram semper recta, and often referred to by others as John Gabriel, is well known to users of this forum. He is known for his large multitude of posts and comments and for the often hostile content they contain or link to, either directed at mainstream academia in general or against specific individuals, or for containing a lot of self-promotion. > > In particular, he has often repeated a sentiment to the effect that he believes himself to be intellectually superior to the rest of us. Not in some small way, but a significant way. He has stated repeatedly that he is a genius, and recently has claimed it to be factually correct that he possesses an IQ over 160 (apparently in the sense of 4 standard deviations above average). He has stated that he is not a member of Mensa, but that his ‘official’ IQ score is over 160. > > He also seems to believe that some of his own discoveries and ideas are vastly more deserving of recognition and acceptance than what they have received to date, that his personal circumstances are not as he would wish, and that the hostility of mainstream academics or their representatives or supporters is to a significant extent responsible for this negative state of affairs. > > Given his claims in this regard, and his persistent presence on this forum, I think the time is more than overdue for Mr Gabriel to prove he is more than mere talk about his IQ really being very high. > > There are several ways he can prove that he really does have a very high IQ. Some are more fun than others. > > The simplest way would be to gain membership at one of the more exclusive high IQ societies. This would not just prove his claim, but it could also be to his personal benefit in several ways. > > If Mr Gabriel really has taken a widely recognised IQ test and obtained a result better 4 standard deviations, then his options are at least the following: > > - Mensa, top 2% (2 SD above average) > > - Intertel, top 1% (2.4 SD above average) > > - Triple Nine Society, top 0.1% (3 SD above average) > > - Prometheus Society, top 0.003% (4 SD above average) > > The Triple Nine Society seems to accept a wider variety of tests for membership applications than the Prometheus Society, and since IQ tests are often considered far less reliable once you start going beyond 3 standard deviations, I don’t think it is unreasonable to consider proof of TNS membership as sufficient for Mr Gabriel to establish his claims for this friendly challenge. > > But it would do more than that. Membership of either TNS or PS, would give Mr Gabriel a far more impressive platform for promoting his ideas or getting them considered seriously by a much, much, much wider audience. It would also enhance any attempts at self-promotion and help attract far more traffic to his YouTube channel, and could even enhance his employment prospects among those organisations that take this sort of thing seriously. > > So that’s one way he could do it. > > Failing that, there is a second way: taking an up-to-date Mensa Test and qualifying for membership, not just of Mensa, but also of the more exclusive high IQ society Intertel. Let me explain. > > I booked a place at a Mensa test session a while back for my own amusement, for late August. I should get my results in the post during the first week of September. The format of the test is described on the UK Mensa website: > > > https://www.mensa.org.uk/what-is-an-iq-test > > > From what I understand, the UK branch of Mensa apparently provides both scores and percentiles in their confirmation letters. > > By contrast, if I have understood correctly, the US branch of Mensa only confirms to candidates whether they reached at least the 98th percentile or not (apparently IQ scores fall under mental health information in Texas where they are based, or something like that). However, if I have understood the situation correctly, they apparently can release the performance details to Intertel if asked to, which would prove Mr Gabriel’s performance to be in the top 1% if he qualified for membership to Intertel. > > > https://www.us.mensa.org/ > > https://www.intertel-iq.org/join-us > > > I am most certainly not a genius of any sort. At best I hope to just barely qualify for Mensa, but it is quite possible that I will fall short. I have no serious expectations of qualifying for Intertel. I have a few degrees, but nothing super amazing, and I am not as quick as when I was an undergraduate. > > Therefore, if Mr Gabriel really is the 4+ sigma genius he claims to be, then at the very least he should have no trouble beating me outright on a Mensa test and obtaining a result high enough to qualify for Intertel. > > Stereotypes would suggest mathematicians are supposed to be able to do respectably on IQ tests. > > Given that Mr Gabriel has not shown many signs (in my experience) of having had a congenial tertiary education in mathematics by UK standards, if he can get into Intertel on an up-to-date test and I cannot, despite Mr Gabriel being roughly 60 whereas I am in my 30s, then I would have to conclude that Mr Gabriel’s inherent fluid intelligence was likely far greater than my own, likely considerably above IQ 135 (S=15), and when he was younger it would likely have been higher still. It might even be assumed to have been near Triple Nine Society levels, which is sufficient for the purposes of this friendly challenge. > > Is Mr Gabriel really that good? There is a way to find out!!!! > > Both Mr Gabriel and I can each take a new official Mensa test in our respective locations, and then we compare the results using the official certificates sent in the post by Mensa and Intertel by showing them on our respective YouTube channels. I will give the full breakdown of my results. Mr Gabriel has to prove his eligibility for membership into Mensa and Intertel based on an up-to-date test as described next. > > Not some silly online IQ test, or something allegedly taken when we were kids, or with a 'private psychologist'; it has to be an official Mensa test at an official group testing session overseen by an actual Mensa invigilator, and must be taken in the time period 15th August 2021 - 15th November 2021 [that's more than enough time to book a test and prepare for it if one feels the need]. > > The UK test is actually two tests. One is called Cattel III B and has a standard deviation of 24, and a maximum score of 161 (which is 2.5 standard deviations, or in other words equivalent to a score of IQ 138 on SD=15 tests). The second is a Culture Fair Test, which has a standard deviation of 16 and a maximum score of 183, which is slightly above 5 standard deviations. On a SD = 15 test that would equate to a score of about 177, so well above 160. > > > Admission to UK Mensa requires scoring at 98th percentile or above in one of these tests (doing so in both is not required, but both tests are taken regardless). That would be a score of 148 or better on the Cattell III B test, or a score of 132 or better on the Culture Fair Test. > > > The US Mensa test seems to be a single test in a given sitting (unless you insist on taking a culture fair alternative to the standard one), the SD of which I wasn't able to locate. Entry into US Mensa requires scoring at or above the 98th percentile in whichever test you take. > > > Even Mensa membership would provide Mr Gabriel with at least some personal and potentially professional benefits, even if not as much as TNS or PS membership. > > If he accepts this challenge, Mr Gabriel must provide proof of both Mensa eligibility as previously described and Intertel membership by 31st March 2022 in order to be eligible to ‘win’. This seems more than enough time to get all the paper work. > > So that’s the challenge. Here are the stakes concerning the Mensa based ‘competition’ option: > > ‘SPOILS OF WAR’, DEPENDING ON OUTCOMES > > > If my performance on BOTH of the UK Mensa tests is demonstrably better than Mr Gabriel’s performance on the US Mensa test, then I am declared the clear victor, and Mr Gabriel has been proven not to be a high IQ genius (because I am not). He is required to admit this on sci.math and is not allowed to complain if others call him out if he claims otherwise. If additionally Mr Gabriel qualifies for Mensa, then I will be required to acknowledge that he did respectably in an IQ test, even if he is not a high IQ genius. If however Mr Gabriel also fails to qualify for Mensa, then he is additionally required to delete all of his posts from sci.math and not return under any alias before 1st Jan 2023, which will give him time for some reflection and to consider alternative interests. > > If my performance is demonstrably better on one of my tests, but not both, then we call it a Pyrrhic victory for me. Mr Gabriel cannot call himself a high IQ genius, but I have to acknowledge that he did respectably on an IQ test compared to me. > > If we either both qualify for membership of the same level of high IQ society, or both fail to qualify for Mensa, then we do as follows: > > - Both qualify for Intertel: agree that neither are idiots, but Mr Gabriel is likely much smarter than me in IQ terms, even if it is not proven to what extent, he might be a high IQ genius. > > - Both qualify just for Mensa: agree that neither are idiots, but Mr Gabriel cannot claim to be a high IQ genius. I must however acknowledge that Mr Gabriel is a smart guy. > > - Both fail to qualify for Mensa: both of us have to delete all of our posts from sci.math and not return under any alias before 1st Jan 2023 if ever. Don’t worry Mr Gabriel, you have an IQ over 160 don’t you? so there’s no chance of that… > > > If Mr Gabriel’s performance in his test demonstrably beats BOTH of my test scores, then I will do ALL of the following: > > 1) delete all of my comments on sci.math, leaving only one new comment conceding that John Gabriel is my intellectual superior and that I was a self-indulgent fool to ever suggest otherwise. I will NEVER return to sci.math under any alias. > > > 2) I will make a £50 donation (approx 70 dollars US) for a one-off purchase of a charitable gift for citizens in a third world country from the charity ‘Good Gifts’, based in the UK, in John Gabriel's name. > > > To elaborate: Mr Gabriel chooses the gift in question from 3 options: > > > - Option 1: Vocational training for a young African villager (£45) > > > - Option 2: De-worming tablets for 1000 children (£50) > > > - Option 3: Delivery of 200 donated items to refugees (£40) > > > and notifies me on sci.math of his choice. I will then purchase the charity option from the Good Gifts charity and any spare change from the £50 will be donated directly to the Good Gifts charity to help with their admin costs. > > > I will receive a large(ish) thank you card from the Good Gifts charity in the mail within 2/3 weeks of purchase, which will have a message printed inside as 'this gift was made in the name of John Gabriel, the world's greatest mathematician' or something like that. I will then post a video of the card on my YouTube channel, and Mr Gabriel can mirror it for use on his channel, to demonstrate not just his intellectual superiority over me, but also that because of him a good thing was done for poor people somewhere. > > > To be clear: the purpose of this challenge is not to mock or insult Mr Gabriel. If he is as good as he thinks he is then this exercise will be to his benefit and will be rather straightforward. If he is not as good as he thinks he is, then given how much effort he seems to spend on his anti-mainstream academia and mathematics related activities, a reality check might also be to his benefit, depending on whether he takes a constructive attitude to it or not. Also, it’s a day out of the house, isn’t it? > > What about it Mr Gabriel? Are you willing to put your claims to the test (literally)? > > > Kind Regards > short note: it has been my experience in working with those with very high IQ, PHD in Physics, or above 140, about 1/2 are brilliant, and 1/2 are nuts. Mr Rectum may have high IQ, but he seems nuts. Since he refutes easy parts of math, it seems his IQ may be not enough. Yes testing is the next step.
Back to sci.math | Previous | Next — Previous in thread | Next in thread | Find similar | Unroll thread
A friendly challenge to Eram semper recta Quantum Bubbles <ross.probability@gmx.com> - 2021-06-27 10:56 -0700
Re: A friendly challenge to Eram semper recta Sergio <invaled@invalid.com> - 2021-06-27 13:11 -0500
Re: A friendly challenge to Eram semper recta "mitchr...@gmail.com" <mitchrae3323@gmail.com> - 2021-06-27 13:12 -0700
Re: A friendly challenge to Eram semper recta Dan Christensen <Dan_Christensen@sympatico.ca> - 2021-06-27 11:59 -0700
Re: A friendly challenge to Eram semper recta "Freda Parkins" <invalid@invalid.invalid> - 2021-06-27 17:56 -0400
Re: A friendly challenge to Eram semper recta Sergio <invaled@invalid.com> - 2021-06-27 18:28 -0500
Re: A friendly challenge to Eram semper recta "Freda Parkins" <invalid@invalid.invalid> - 2021-06-27 19:43 -0400
Re: A friendly challenge to Eram semper recta Sergio <invaled@invalid.com> - 2021-06-27 21:31 -0500
Re: A friendly challenge to Eram semper recta "Freda Parkins" <invalid@invalid.invalid> - 2021-06-27 22:40 -0400
Re: A friendly challenge to Eram semper recta Quantum Bubbles <ross.probability@gmx.com> - 2021-07-06 04:13 -0700
Re: A friendly challenge to Eram semper recta Quantum Bubbles <ross.probability@gmx.com> - 2021-07-20 01:54 -0700
csiph-web