Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica > #6089

Re: Assumptions - an issue. Does mathematica store it?

From Daniel Lichtblau <danl@wolfram.com>
Newsgroups comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica
Subject Re: Assumptions - an issue. Does mathematica store it?
Date 2011-11-01 05:02 +0000
Organization Steven M. Christensen and Associates, Inc and MathTensor, Inc.
Message-ID <j8nuh4$ect$1@smc.vnet.net> (permalink)
References <201110311150.GAA28310@smc.vnet.net> <4EAEC1D5.7050804@wolfram.com> <CAB8Fy-Nms=27OF-ibqWH3EjiNr6cSGxHOX_5ck+JTqDwt2q7zw@mail.gmail.com>

Show all headers | View raw


On 10/31/2011 10:47 AM, Sumesh P.T. wrote:
> Thanks Daniel. Looks like it is related to some intermediate results
> only, because I see the same behavior. So is there a way to tell
> Mathematica to produce only the final result and not the intermediate
> ones?
>
> regards,
> sumesh

I do not understand the question. Let me try to clarify. Mathematica is 
not producing intermediate results. It is producing differing final 
results (that is, different Out[] results). The likely cause is the 
caching state of intermediate computations (not results) affecting later 
computations.

I am not aware of any way to prevent results from changing on 
recomputation, or even to recognize in any general way that this might 
happen.

Daniel lichtblau
Wolfram Research

> On Mon, Oct 31, 2011 at 9:12 PM, Daniel Lichtblau<danl@wolfram.com>  wrote:
>> On 10/31/2011 06:50 AM, Sumesh PT wrote:
>>>
>>> Hi,
>>> I have come across a peculiar situation in Mathematica where the same
>>> expression integrated twice with the same set of assumptions gives me two
>>> different answers (the answers are same on simplification). However I am
>>> wondering how can the software decided to do the integration in two
>>> different methods and does it have anything to do with the assumptions that
>>> once uses. An example code is given below. It might be a good idea to paste
>>> it in a note book so that you can know what I am talking about. Answers at1
>>> and at2 in the code should be same ,but they look different. Can anybody
>>> explain it?
>>>
>>> Thanks,
>>> sumesh
>>> In[35]:= ClearAll[x]
>>>
>>> In[36]:= att = (25  (x^4) \[Rho] )/(4 (x^2 + \[Rho]^2)^(7/2)) - (
>>>     75  (x^2) (\[Rho]^3) )/(16 (x^2 + \[Rho]^2)^(7/2)) - (
>>>     75  (\[Rho]^5) )/(64  (x^2 + \[Rho]^2)^(7/2)) - (
>>>     15  (x^2) \[Rho] )/(4  (x^2 + \[Rho]^2)^(5/2)) + (
>>>     15  (\[Rho]^3) )/(8  (x^2 + \[Rho]^2)^(5/2)) - (
>>>     75  (x^4) (zp^3) \[Rho] )/(
>>>     8  (x^2 + \[Rho]^2)^(7/2) (zp^2 + \[Rho]^2)^(5/2)) + (
>>>     75  (x^4) zp (\[Rho]^3) )/(
>>>     16  (x^2 + \[Rho]^2)^(7/2) (zp^2 + \[Rho]^2)^(5/2)) + (
>>>     75  (x^3) (zp^2) (\[Rho]^3) )/(
>>>     4  (x^2 + \[Rho]^2)^(7/2) (zp^2 + \[Rho]^2)^(5/2)) + (
>>>     225  (x^2) (zp^3) (\[Rho]^3) )/(
>>>     16  (x^2 + \[Rho]^2)^(7/2) (zp^2 + \[Rho]^2)^(5/2)) + (
>>>     225  (xzp^2) (\[Rho]^5) )/(
>>>     32  (x^2 + \[Rho]^2)^(7/2) (zp^2 + \[Rho]^2)^(5/2));
>>>
>>> In[37]:= at1 =
>>>   Integrate[att, {\[Rho], 0, \[Infinity]},
>>>    Assumptions ->    {x \[Element] Reals, x^2>    0, zp^2>    0}]
>>>
>>> Out[37]= (1/(24 x^4 zp^4 (x^2 -
>>>     zp^2)^5))(-30 x^4 zp^4 (12 x^6 zp + 48 x^5 zp^2 + 80 x^3 zp^4 -
>>>       15 xzp^2 zp^4 - 3 x^4 (xzp^2 - 40 zp^3) -
>>>       30 x^2 zp^2 (xzp^2 - 2 zp^3)) +
>>>    Abs[x]^3 (30 zp^4 (10 x^7 + 60 x^6 zp + 90 x^5 zp^2 + 30 x^3 zp^4 -
>>>          3 xzp^2 zp^4 - 2 x zp^6 - 15 x^4 (xzp^2 - 8 zp^3) -
>>>          6 x^2 (5 xzp^2 zp^2 - 2 zp^5)) Abs[
>>>         zp] + (x^2 -
>>>          zp^2)^5 (12 zp^4 Hypergeometric2F1[1, 2, -(3/2), x^2/
>>>            zp^2] + (16 x^2 zp^2 - 21 zp^4) Hypergeometric2F1[2,
>>>            2, -(1/2), x^2/zp^2] +
>>>          32 x^4 Hypergeometric2F1[2, 3, 1/2, x^2/zp^2] -
>>>          168 x^2 zp^2 Hypergeometric2F1[2, 3, 1/2, x^2/zp^2] +
>>>          9 zp^4 Hypergeometric2F1[2, 3, 1/2, x^2/zp^2] +
>>>          504 x^4 Hypergeometric2F1[2, 4, 3/2, x^2/zp^2] -
>>>          108 x^2 zp^2 Hypergeometric2F1[2, 4, 3/2, x^2/zp^2] +
>>>          144 x^4 Hypergeometric2F1[2, 5, 5/2, x^2/zp^2])))
>>>
>>> In[38]:= at2 =
>>>   Integrate[att, {\[Rho], 0, \[Infinity]},
>>>    Assumptions ->    {x \[Element] Reals&&    x^2>    0&&    zp^2>    0}]
>>>
>>> Out[38]= (1/(4 x^2 (x^2 - zp^2)^5))5 (-12 x^8 zp - 48 x^7 zp^2 -
>>>     80 x^5 zp^4 + 15 x^2 xzp^2 zp^4 + 3 x^6 (xzp^2 - 40 zp^3) +
>>>     30 x^4 zp^2 (xzp^2 - 2 zp^3) + (10 x^7 + 60 x^6 zp + 90 x^5 zp^2 +
>>>        30 x^3 zp^4 - 3 xzp^2 zp^4 - 2 x zp^6 -
>>>        15 x^4 (xzp^2 - 8 zp^3) + 6 x^2 zp^2 (-5 xzp^2 + 2 zp^3)) Abs[
>>>       x] Abs[zp])
>>
>> Probably partial caching of intermediate results. See
>>
>> http://forums.wolfram.com/mathgroup/archive/2010/Jan/msg00253.html
>>
>> I did not replicate the behavior you are seeing above, by the way. But that
>> too could depend on vagaries such as specific version or machine speed.
>>
>> Daniel Lichtblau
>> Wolfram Research
>>
>
>
>

Back to comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica | Previous | Next | Find similar | Unroll thread


Thread

Re: Assumptions - an issue. Does mathematica store it? Daniel Lichtblau <danl@wolfram.com> - 2011-11-01 05:02 +0000

csiph-web