Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > uk.tech.broadcast > #71063 > unrolled thread

Alexandra Palace Anniversary

Started byJMB99 <mb@nospam.net>
First post2026-11-04 17:59 +0000
Last post2026-11-10 21:23 +0000
Articles 16 — 7 participants

Back to article view | Back to uk.tech.broadcast


Contents

  Alexandra Palace Anniversary JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> - 2026-11-04 17:59 +0000
    Re: Alexandra Palace Anniversary "J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> - 2026-11-04 22:36 +0000
      Re: Alexandra Palace Anniversary Clive Page <clive.g.page@gmail.com> - 2026-11-08 11:14 +0000
        Re: Alexandra Palace Anniversary JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> - 2026-11-08 11:16 +0000
          Re: Alexandra Palace Anniversary Clive Page <clive.g.page@gmail.com> - 2026-11-08 11:21 +0000
            Re: Alexandra Palace Anniversary Woody <harrogate3@ntlworld.com> - 2026-11-08 13:40 +0000
        Re: Alexandra Palace Anniversary "J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> - 2026-11-08 17:52 +0000
          Re: Alexandra Palace Anniversary John Williamson <johnwilliamson@btinternet.com> - 2026-11-08 18:16 +0000
            Re: Alexandra Palace Anniversary "J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> - 2026-11-08 18:28 +0000
          Re: Alexandra Palace Anniversary Clive Page <clive.g.page@gmail.com> - 2026-11-10 13:55 +0000
            Re: Alexandra Palace Anniversary liz@poppyrecords.invalid.invalid (Liz Tuddenham) - 2026-11-10 16:08 +0000
              Re: Alexandra Palace Anniversary "J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> - 2026-11-10 19:25 +0000
                Re: Alexandra Palace Anniversary liz@poppyrecords.invalid.invalid (Liz Tuddenham) - 2026-11-11 12:39 +0000
                  Re: Alexandra Palace Anniversary "J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> - 2026-11-11 13:08 +0000
                    Re: Alexandra Palace Anniversary Roderick Stewart <rjfs@escapetime.myzen.co.uk> - 2026-11-11 16:06 +0000
              Re: Alexandra Palace Anniversary Clive Page <clive.g.page@gmail.com> - 2026-11-10 21:23 +0000

#71063 — Alexandra Palace Anniversary

FromJMB99 <mb@nospam.net>
Date2026-11-04 17:59 +0000
SubjectAlexandra Palace Anniversary
Message-ID<11cfrq5$tk9d$1@dont-email.me>
There are series of programmes tonight for the anniversary of the start 
of broadcasts from Alexandra Palace.



Starts with


DOCUMENTARY: Television's Opening Night: How the Box Was Born
On: BBC Four
Date: Wednesday 4th November 2026 (starting in 3 hours and 4 minutes)
Time: 21:00 to 22:30 (1 hour and 30 minutes long)

Dallas Campbell, Professor Danielle George and Dr Hugh Hunt mark the 
80th anniversary of Britain's very first TV broadcast by trying to 
recreate the landmark event. The inaugural programme came live from 
Alexandria Palace on November 2, 1936, but there are no surviving 
recordings of the show. In response, the presenter trio set out to 
recreate every aspect of this first broadcast, from the variety acts 
featured right down to the camera equipment used, using authentic 
technology and filming techniques. Plus, pioneering TV engineer John 
Logie Baird's assistant - now aged 104 - is on hand to lend some 
technical assistance, and Dallas meets one of the performers who 
appeared on the first programme to find out what it is like to be part 
of TV history.
(Subtitles, Widescreen, Audio Described)

Director: Peter Gauvain
Starring: Dallas Campbell, Danielle George, Hugh Hunt

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Marked By: 'Category: Documentary' marker
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Excerpt taken from DigiGuide - the world's best TV guide available from 
http://www.getdigiguide.tv/?p=1&r=7346

Copyright (c) GipsyMedia Limited.

[toc] | [next] | [standalone]


#71065

From"J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk>
Date2026-11-04 22:36 +0000
Message-ID<11cgc26$13obc$1@dont-email.me>
In reply to#71063
On 2026/11/4 17:59:31, JMB99 wrote:
> There are series of programmes tonight for the anniversary of the start 
> of broadcasts from Alexandra Palace.
> 
> 
> 
> Starts with
> 
> 
> DOCUMENTARY: Television's Opening Night: How the Box Was Born
> On: BBC Four
> Date: Wednesday 4th November 2026 (starting in 3 hours and 4 minutes)
> Time: 21:00 to 22:30 (1 hour and 30 minutes long)
> 
> Dallas Campbell, Professor Danielle George and Dr Hugh Hunt mark the 
> 80th anniversary of Britain's very first TV broadcast by trying to 
> recreate the landmark event. The inaugural programme came live from 
> Alexandria Palace on November 2, 1936, but there are no surviving 
> recordings of the show. In response, the presenter trio set out to 
> recreate every aspect of this first broadcast, from the variety acts 
> featured right down to the camera equipment used, using authentic 
> technology and filming techniques. Plus, pioneering TV engineer John 

I hadn't realised they'd changed the scanning to horizontal by this
stage. I suppose, if receivers had to be switchable, that was much easier.
[]
I have always thought the mechanical system got a bad deal, in that - in
those days when every active device (valve, or at best envelopes with
rwo devices in, or three if one was e. g. a diode) cost a significant
amount, the mechanical _receivers_ were surely cheaper? (Not
dual-standard sets, which obviously had to be electronic anyway.) Or
were no 240-line mechanical receivers made? If that is the case,
presumably there was at least some distortion, as the mechanical scanner
would involve at least slightly curved lines, whereas I can't imagine an
electronic receiver doing so (intentionally, anyway!).
-- 
J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

User Error: Replace user, hit any key to continue.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#71069

FromClive Page <clive.g.page@gmail.com>
Date2026-11-08 11:14 +0000
Message-ID<11cplhr$86ds$1@dont-email.me>
In reply to#71065
On 04/11/2026 22:36, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
> On 2026/11/4 17:59:31, JMB99 wrote:
>> There are series of programmes tonight for the anniversary of the start
>> of broadcasts from Alexandra Palace.
>>
>>
>>
>> Starts with
>>
>>
>> DOCUMENTARY: Television's Opening Night: How the Box Was Born
>> On: BBC Four
>> Date: Wednesday 4th November 2026 (starting in 3 hours and 4 minutes)
>> Time: 21:00 to 22:30 (1 hour and 30 minutes long)
>>
>> Dallas Campbell, Professor Danielle George and Dr Hugh Hunt mark the
>> 80th anniversary of Britain's very first TV broadcast by trying to
>> recreate the landmark event. The inaugural programme came live from
>> Alexandria Palace on November 2, 1936, but there are no surviving
>> recordings of the show. In response, the presenter trio set out to
>> recreate every aspect of this first broadcast, from the variety acts
>> featured right down to the camera equipment used, using authentic
>> technology and filming techniques. Plus, pioneering TV engineer John
> 
> I hadn't realised they'd changed the scanning to horizontal by this
> stage. I suppose, if receivers had to be switchable, that was much easier.
> []
> I have always thought the mechanical system got a bad deal, in that - in
> those days when every active device (valve, or at best envelopes with
> rwo devices in, or three if one was e. g. a diode) cost a significant
> amount, the mechanical _receivers_ were surely cheaper? (Not
> dual-standard sets, which obviously had to be electronic anyway.) Or
> were no 240-line mechanical receivers made? If that is the case,
> presumably there was at least some distortion, as the mechanical scanner
> would involve at least slightly curved lines, whereas I can't imagine an
> electronic receiver doing so (intentionally, anyway!).

I always thought that it must have been obvious that the Baird system 
was hopeless, as it was completely unscaleable to higher resolutions or 
to broader broadcasting needs.  It was suitable only for studio 
broadcasts of a single talking head, and the conditions for that person 
seemed, from this programme, to be pretty uncomfortable.  For outside 
broadcasts the scanning beam was simply unusable with no technical 
solution that anyone could devise.  I expect that Heath Robinson was 
jealous that Logie Baird got there first.

I assume that this must have been evident in 1936 to all of those 
involved, except perhaps Baird himself and any others that he managed to 
brainwash, and that the BBC went through the charade of a comparison 
between systems only because they needed to have a public demonstration 
that the electronic system was vastly superior in all respects.


-- 
Clive Page

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#71070

FromJMB99 <mb@nospam.net>
Date2026-11-08 11:16 +0000
Message-ID<11cplm1$8kps$1@dont-email.me>
In reply to#71069
On 08/11/2026 11:14, Clive Page wrote:
> I always thought that it must have been obvious that the Baird system 
> was hopeless, as it was completely unscaleable to higher resolutions or 
> to broader broadcasting needs.  It was suitable only for studio 
> broadcasts of a single talking head, and the conditions for that person 
> seemed, from this programme, to be pretty uncomfortable.  For outside 
> broadcasts the scanning beam was simply unusable with no technical 
> solution that anyone could devise.  I expect that Heath Robinson was 
> jealous that Logie Baird got there first.
> 
> I assume that this must have been evident in 1936 to all of those 
> involved, except perhaps Baird himself and any others that he managed to 
> brainwash, and that the BBC went through the charade of a comparison 
> between systems only because they needed to have a public demonstration 
> that the electronic system was vastly superior in all respects.


He was a very good publicist - I always think of him as the Clive 
Sinclair of that period.  :-)


[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#71071

FromClive Page <clive.g.page@gmail.com>
Date2026-11-08 11:21 +0000
Message-ID<11cpm0h$86ds$2@dont-email.me>
In reply to#71070
On 08/11/2026 11:16, JMB99 wrote:
> On 08/11/2026 11:14, Clive Page wrote:
>> I always thought that it must have been obvious that the Baird system 
>> was hopeless, as it was completely unscaleable to higher resolutions 
>> or to broader broadcasting needs.  It was suitable only for studio 
>> broadcasts of a single talking head, and the conditions for that 
>> person seemed, from this programme, to be pretty uncomfortable.  For 
>> outside broadcasts the scanning beam was simply unusable with no 
>> technical solution that anyone could devise.  I expect that Heath 
>> Robinson was jealous that Logie Baird got there first.
>>
>> I assume that this must have been evident in 1936 to all of those 
>> involved, except perhaps Baird himself and any others that he managed 
>> to brainwash, and that the BBC went through the charade of a 
>> comparison between systems only because they needed to have a public 
>> demonstration that the electronic system was vastly superior in all 
>> respects.
> 
> 
> He was a very good publicist - I always think of him as the Clive 
> Sinclair of that period.  :-)

That's a good comparison.  But to do him justice there were one or two 
Sinclair products that were ok-ish, for example his pocket calculator 
and his wrist-watch.  I didn't buy any but some of my friends did.

In my opinion another "scientist" of the same type, though rather 
earlier, was Nicola Tesla.


-- 
Clive Page

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#71072

FromWoody <harrogate3@ntlworld.com>
Date2026-11-08 13:40 +0000
Message-ID<11cpu51$b4c1$2@dont-email.me>
In reply to#71071
On Sun 08/11/2026 11:21, Clive Page wrote:
> On 08/11/2026 11:16, JMB99 wrote:
>> On 08/11/2026 11:14, Clive Page wrote:
>>> I always thought that it must have been obvious that the Baird system 
>>> was hopeless, as it was completely unscaleable to higher resolutions 
>>> or to broader broadcasting needs.  It was suitable only for studio 
>>> broadcasts of a single talking head, and the conditions for that 
>>> person seemed, from this programme, to be pretty uncomfortable.  For 
>>> outside broadcasts the scanning beam was simply unusable with no 
>>> technical solution that anyone could devise.  I expect that Heath 
>>> Robinson was jealous that Logie Baird got there first.
>>>
>>> I assume that this must have been evident in 1936 to all of those 
>>> involved, except perhaps Baird himself and any others that he managed 
>>> to brainwash, and that the BBC went through the charade of a 
>>> comparison between systems only because they needed to have a public 
>>> demonstration that the electronic system was vastly superior in all 
>>> respects.
>>
>>
>> He was a very good publicist - I always think of him as the Clive 
>> Sinclair of that period.  :-)
> 
> That's a good comparison.  But to do him justice there were one or two 
> Sinclair products that were ok-ish, for example his pocket calculator 
> and his wrist-watch.  I didn't buy any but some of my friends did.
> 
> In my opinion another "scientist" of the same type, though rather 
> earlier, was Nicola Tesla.
> 
> 

Sinclair wasn't all bad. I once went to a lecture he gave at the 
Cambridge University Labs about his FM tuner and the first ever 
application of a phase-locked loop to make a relatively cheap and simple 
tuner totally stable and usable domestically. I got the chance to have a 
chat with him afterwards and he was undoubtedly a clever guy who had 
that innate ability to 'get it over.'
For the record I have a Sinclair Cambridge calculator sitting in its box 
on a shelf in front of me as I type - and it still works!! The great 
trick with those tiny LED numbers he used was the basis of a joke quiz 
question. Put 71077345 on display and then turn the whole unit upside 
down....

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#71073

From"J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk>
Date2026-11-08 17:52 +0000
Message-ID<11cqcsr$ij0j$1@dont-email.me>
In reply to#71069
On 2026/11/8 11:14:1, Clive Page wrote:
> On 04/11/2026 22:36, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
[]
>> I have always thought the mechanical system got a bad deal, in that - in
>> those days when every active device (valve, or at best envelopes with
>> rwo devices in, or three if one was e. g. a diode) cost a significant
>> amount, the mechanical _receivers_ were surely cheaper? (Not
>> dual-standard sets, which obviously had to be electronic anyway.) Or
>> were no 240-line mechanical receivers made? If that is the case,
>> presumably there was at least some distortion, as the mechanical scanner
>> would involve at least slightly curved lines, whereas I can't imagine an
>> electronic receiver doing so (intentionally, anyway!).
> 
> I always thought that it must have been obvious that the Baird system 
> was hopeless, as it was completely unscaleable to higher resolutions or 

Didn't they get to 240? (A lot of YouTube viewing is surely no better
than that, especially if not full-screen.)

> to broader broadcasting needs.  It was suitable only for studio 
> broadcasts of a single talking head, and the conditions for that person 
> seemed, from this programme, to be pretty uncomfortable.  For outside 
> broadcasts the scanning beam was simply unusable with no technical 
> solution that anyone could devise.  I expect that Heath Robinson was 
> jealous that Logie Baird got there first.

The scanning beam wasn't used for outside broadcasts - a mirror-drum was
used, at least for the Derby. (We had some discussions here a few years
ago as to whether that was the reason an OB van is referred to as a
"scanner"; many origins were suggested, but the Baird-origin one seemed
to win.)
> 
> I assume that this must have been evident in 1936 to all of those 
> involved, except perhaps Baird himself and any others that he managed to 
> brainwash, and that the BBC went through the charade of a comparison 
> between systems only because they needed to have a public demonstration 
> that the electronic system was vastly superior in all respects.
> 
> 
I'm inclined to agree that it probably _was_ inferior - certainly
wouldn't even consider it today, with the cheapness of modern
electronics. (Though I think there were almost some large public-display
systems [sports stadia and the like] that used mirror-drum scanning,
when powerful lasers became available, but that was overtaken.) But in
the days when a single valve cost a significant number of hours' work
for the ordinary man, I presume "televisors" were far cheaper for the
consumer than all-electronic sets - they only required a receiver (which
all-electronic sets did too) and a motor (which technology was
well-established by then); this doesn't seem to get _mentioned_ when the
subject comes up = the engineers and administrators preferring to use
the system that is (definitely - I'm not arguing there) best
technically, and also easier to use, and the poor consumer can go hang.
(An attitude that has continued ever since, and still prevails - the
only exception I can think of that went too far the other way was how
long system A was kept going.)
-- 
J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

There are a lot of things that children should be shielded from, but
"bad language" isn't one of them.

"Honey, we shouldn't say that when other people are around because some
grownups get upset about it.  No, I don't know why, they just do."
- "The Real Bev", in mozilla.general 2015-6-7

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#71074

FromJohn Williamson <johnwilliamson@btinternet.com>
Date2026-11-08 18:16 +0000
Message-ID<nlbsk6FjsaaU1@mid.individual.net>
In reply to#71073
On 08/11/2026 17:52, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
> On 2026/11/8 11:14:1, Clive Page wrote:
>> On 04/11/2026 22:36, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
> []
>>> I have always thought the mechanical system got a bad deal, in that - in
>>> those days when every active device (valve, or at best envelopes with
>>> rwo devices in, or three if one was e. g. a diode) cost a significant
>>> amount, the mechanical _receivers_ were surely cheaper? (Not
>>> dual-standard sets, which obviously had to be electronic anyway.) Or
>>> were no 240-line mechanical receivers made? If that is the case,
>>> presumably there was at least some distortion, as the mechanical scanner
>>> would involve at least slightly curved lines, whereas I can't imagine an
>>> electronic receiver doing so (intentionally, anyway!).
>>
>> I always thought that it must have been obvious that the Baird system
>> was hopeless, as it was completely unscaleable to higher resolutions or
>
> Didn't they get to 240? (A lot of YouTube viewing is surely no better
> than that, especially if not full-screen.)
>
They spent a lot of programme time explaining the fun that both they and 
Baird had getting the 240 line cameras to work in time for the broadcast.

The thing I learned was that it was the light spot that moved, and they 
used wide angle photocells to generate the signal. I'd always assumed 
that the spinning disc was between the lens and the photocell.

Then there was the fun of shooting and developing film in 54 seconds to 
go out "live" to air. Telecine in 1936...

The electronic version of the programme that went out immediately 
afterwards went out in real time using 405 lines...

>> to broader broadcasting needs.  It was suitable only for studio
>> broadcasts of a single talking head, and the conditions for that person
>> seemed, from this programme, to be pretty uncomfortable.  For outside
>> broadcasts the scanning beam was simply unusable with no technical
>> solution that anyone could devise.  I expect that Heath Robinson was
>> jealous that Logie Baird got there first.
>
> The scanning beam wasn't used for outside broadcasts - a mirror-drum was
> used, at least for the Derby. (We had some discussions here a few years
> ago as to whether that was the reason an OB van is referred to as a
> "scanner"; many origins were suggested, but the Baird-origin one seemed
> to win.)

I heard at the time when I followed such things that it referred to the 
video recorders they carried. The heads scanned the tape....

-- 
Tciao for Now!

John.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#71075

From"J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk>
Date2026-11-08 18:28 +0000
Message-ID<11cqf0t$jauh$1@dont-email.me>
In reply to#71074
On 2026/11/8 18:16:37, John Williamson wrote:
> On 08/11/2026 17:52, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
[]
>> The scanning beam wasn't used for outside broadcasts - a mirror-drum was
>> used, at least for the Derby. (We had some discussions here a few years
>> ago as to whether that was the reason an OB van is referred to as a
>> "scanner"; many origins were suggested, but the Baird-origin one seemed
>> to win.)
> 
> I heard at the time when I followed such things that it referred to the 
> video recorders they carried. The heads scanned the tape....
> 
When we had the discussion, there was plenty of evidence that the term
(for an OB van) was around well before video recording.
-- 
J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#71077

FromClive Page <clive.g.page@gmail.com>
Date2026-11-10 13:55 +0000
Message-ID<11cv7p2$21d3h$3@dont-email.me>
In reply to#71073
On 08/11/2026 17:52, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
> On 2026/11/8 11:14:1, Clive Page wrote:
>> On 04/11/2026 22:36, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
> []
>>> I have always thought the mechanical system got a bad deal, in that - in
>>> those days when every active device (valve, or at best envelopes with
>>> rwo devices in, or three if one was e. g. a diode) cost a significant
>>> amount, the mechanical _receivers_ were surely cheaper? (Not
>>> dual-standard sets, which obviously had to be electronic anyway.) Or
>>> were no 240-line mechanical receivers made? If that is the case,
>>> presumably there was at least some distortion, as the mechanical scanner
>>> would involve at least slightly curved lines, whereas I can't imagine an
>>> electronic receiver doing so (intentionally, anyway!).
>>
>> I always thought that it must have been obvious that the Baird system
>> was hopeless, as it was completely unscaleable to higher resolutions or
> 
> Didn't they get to 240? (A lot of YouTube viewing is surely no better
> than that, especially if not full-screen.)
> 
>> to broader broadcasting needs.  It was suitable only for studio
>> broadcasts of a single talking head, and the conditions for that person
>> seemed, from this programme, to be pretty uncomfortable.  For outside
>> broadcasts the scanning beam was simply unusable with no technical
>> solution that anyone could devise.  I expect that Heath Robinson was
>> jealous that Logie Baird got there first.
> 
> The scanning beam wasn't used for outside broadcasts - a mirror-drum was
> used, at least for the Derby. (We had some discussions here a few years
> ago as to whether that was the reason an OB van is referred to as a
> "scanner"; many origins were suggested, but the Baird-origin one seemed
> to win.)
>>
>> I assume that this must have been evident in 1936 to all of those
>> involved, except perhaps Baird himself and any others that he managed to
>> brainwash, and that the BBC went through the charade of a comparison
>> between systems only because they needed to have a public demonstration
>> that the electronic system was vastly superior in all respects.
>>
>>
> I'm inclined to agree that it probably _was_ inferior - certainly
> wouldn't even consider it today, with the cheapness of modern
> electronics. (Though I think there were almost some large public-display
> systems [sports stadia and the like] that used mirror-drum scanning,
> when powerful lasers became available, but that was overtaken.) But in
> the days when a single valve cost a significant number of hours' work
> for the ordinary man, I presume "televisors" were far cheaper for the
> consumer than all-electronic sets - they only required a receiver (which
> all-electronic sets did too) and a motor (which technology was
> well-established by then); this doesn't seem to get _mentioned_ when the
> subject comes up = the engineers and administrators preferring to use
> the system that is (definitely - I'm not arguing there) best
> technically, and also easier to use, and the poor consumer can go hang.
> (An attitude that has continued ever since, and still prevails - the
> only exception I can think of that went too far the other way was how
> long system A was kept going.)

I find it hard to believe that all it needed as receiver was a light, 
motor, and spinning disc.  That would indeed have been cheaper.

But surely there's a need for line and frame synchronisation, which the 
electronic system supported via line and frame sync pulses.  There must 
have been complicated mechanisms to keep the motor in sync at least. 
Maybe that could be done without expensive electronics, but I don't see how.


-- 
Clive Page

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#71078

Fromliz@poppyrecords.invalid.invalid (Liz Tuddenham)
Date2026-11-10 16:08 +0000
Message-ID<1s4d8aw.y3zhvofjcqkdN%liz@poppyrecords.invalid.invalid>
In reply to#71077
Clive Page <clive.g.page@gmail.com> wrote:

> On 08/11/2026 17:52, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
> > On 2026/11/8 11:14:1, Clive Page wrote:
> >> On 04/11/2026 22:36, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
> > []
> >>> I have always thought the mechanical system got a bad deal, in that - in
> >>> those days when every active device (valve, or at best envelopes with
> >>> rwo devices in, or three if one was e. g. a diode) cost a significant
> >>> amount, the mechanical _receivers_ were surely cheaper? (Not
> >>> dual-standard sets, which obviously had to be electronic anyway.) Or
> >>> were no 240-line mechanical receivers made? If that is the case,
> >>> presumably there was at least some distortion, as the mechanical scanner
> >>> would involve at least slightly curved lines, whereas I can't imagine an
> >>> electronic receiver doing so (intentionally, anyway!).
> >>
> >> I always thought that it must have been obvious that the Baird system
> >> was hopeless, as it was completely unscaleable to higher resolutions or
> > 
> > Didn't they get to 240? (A lot of YouTube viewing is surely no better
> > than that, especially if not full-screen.)
> > 
> >> to broader broadcasting needs.  It was suitable only for studio
> >> broadcasts of a single talking head, and the conditions for that person
> >> seemed, from this programme, to be pretty uncomfortable.  For outside
> >> broadcasts the scanning beam was simply unusable with no technical
> >> solution that anyone could devise.  I expect that Heath Robinson was
> >> jealous that Logie Baird got there first.
> > 
> > The scanning beam wasn't used for outside broadcasts - a mirror-drum was
> > used, at least for the Derby. (We had some discussions here a few years
> > ago as to whether that was the reason an OB van is referred to as a
> > "scanner"; many origins were suggested, but the Baird-origin one seemed
> > to win.)
> >>
> >> I assume that this must have been evident in 1936 to all of those
> >> involved, except perhaps Baird himself and any others that he managed to
> >> brainwash, and that the BBC went through the charade of a comparison
> >> between systems only because they needed to have a public demonstration
> >> that the electronic system was vastly superior in all respects.
> >>
> >>
> > I'm inclined to agree that it probably _was_ inferior - certainly
> > wouldn't even consider it today, with the cheapness of modern
> > electronics. (Though I think there were almost some large public-display
> > systems [sports stadia and the like] that used mirror-drum scanning,
> > when powerful lasers became available, but that was overtaken.) But in
> > the days when a single valve cost a significant number of hours' work
> > for the ordinary man, I presume "televisors" were far cheaper for the
> > consumer than all-electronic sets - they only required a receiver (which
> > all-electronic sets did too) and a motor (which technology was
> > well-established by then); this doesn't seem to get _mentioned_ when the
> > subject comes up = the engineers and administrators preferring to use
> > the system that is (definitely - I'm not arguing there) best
> > technically, and also easier to use, and the poor consumer can go hang.
> > (An attitude that has continued ever since, and still prevails - the
> > only exception I can think of that went too far the other way was how
> > long system A was kept going.)
> 
> I find it hard to believe that all it needed as receiver was a light,
> motor, and spinning disc.  That would indeed have been cheaper.
> 
> But surely there's a need for line and frame synchronisation, which the
> electronic system supported via line and frame sync pulses.  There must
> have been complicated mechanisms to keep the motor in sync at least. 
> Maybe that could be done without expensive electronics, but I don't see how.

The disc was spun by a motor with a rheostat to set the speed slightly
faster than required, then a phonic wheel, with its electromagnet in the
anode circuit of a valve in the vision channel, pulled the rotation into
sync.  There were no sync pulses as such, the black border of the
picture serving as a rough guide.  When they 'faded' the scene, a board
with black and white squares was slid in fromt of the camera to give a
signal sufficient to maintain synchronism. 

Later versions of the Baird system may have improved on this but I am
not aware of what those improvements might have been.

The blacker-than-black sync pulses were one of the innovations of
Blumlein's team, which made the EMI electronic system so much more
reliable.  They chose positive modulation because they considered that
the white spots cause by motor car ignition interference would be less
obtrusive than the loss of sync which the same interference would cause
if the modulation were negative.  Flywheel sync came later.


-- 
~ Liz Tuddenham ~
(Remove the ".invalid"s and add ".co.uk" to reply)
www.poppyrecords.co.uk

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#71079

From"J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk>
Date2026-11-10 19:25 +0000
Message-ID<11cvr3a$2eeiu$1@dont-email.me>
In reply to#71078
On 2026/11/10 16:8:46, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
[]
> The disc was spun by a motor with a rheostat to set the speed slightly
> faster than required, then a phonic wheel, with its electromagnet in the
> anode circuit of a valve in the vision channel, pulled the rotation into
> sync.  There were no sync pulses as such, the black border of the
> picture serving as a rough guide.  When they 'faded' the scene, a board
> with black and white squares was slid in fromt of the camera to give a
> signal sufficient to maintain synchronism. 

So am I right - a televisor was a lot cheaper than an all-electronic set?
> 
> Later versions of the Baird system may have improved on this but I am
> not aware of what those improvements might have been.
> 
> The blacker-than-black sync pulses were one of the innovations of
> Blumlein's team, which made the EMI electronic system so much more
> reliable.  They chose positive modulation because they considered that
> the white spots cause by motor car ignition interference would be less
> obtrusive than the loss of sync which the same interference would cause
> if the modulation were negative.  Flywheel sync came later.
> 
Ah, that makes sense! I always assumed system A used positive modulation
since that just seemed the obvious way to do it (brighter picture ->
more transmiiter power), and that turning ignition spots black was a
clever idea; it never occurred to me that the matter had been considered
and the choice made for that reason.
> 
Though thinking about it now, they could always have inverted the video
but not the sync pulses (thus making them "whiter-than-white")!
-- 
J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

A sleekzorp without a tornpee is like a quop without a fertsneet (sort of).

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#71086

Fromliz@poppyrecords.invalid.invalid (Liz Tuddenham)
Date2026-11-11 12:39 +0000
Message-ID<1s4etoh.vzazub2s9xhyN%liz@poppyrecords.invalid.invalid>
In reply to#71079
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:

> On 2026/11/10 16:8:46, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
> []
> > The disc was spun by a motor with a rheostat to set the speed slightly
> > faster than required, then a phonic wheel, with its electromagnet in the
> > anode circuit of a valve in the vision channel, pulled the rotation into
> > sync.  There were no sync pulses as such, the black border of the
> > picture serving as a rough guide.  When they 'faded' the scene, a board
> > with black and white squares was slid in fromt of the camera to give a
> > signal sufficient to maintain synchronism. 
> 
> So am I right - a televisor was a lot cheaper than an all-electronic set?
> > 
> > Later versions of the Baird system may have improved on this but I am
> > not aware of what those improvements might have been.
> > 
> > The blacker-than-black sync pulses were one of the innovations of
> > Blumlein's team, which made the EMI electronic system so much more
> > reliable.  They chose positive modulation because they considered that
> > the white spots cause by motor car ignition interference would be less
> > obtrusive than the loss of sync which the same interference would cause
> > if the modulation were negative.  Flywheel sync came later.
> > 
> Ah, that makes sense! I always assumed system A used positive modulation
> since that just seemed the obvious way to do it (brighter picture ->
> more transmiiter power), and that turning ignition spots black was a
> clever idea; it never occurred to me that the matter had been considered
> and the choice made for that reason.
> > 
> Though thinking about it now, they could always have inverted the video
> but not the sync pulses (thus making them "whiter-than-white")!
  
They could - but a super-bright white margin on the picture would be
more disturbing than a black one and the effect of a 'rolling' picture,
through loss of frame lock, would have been horrendous.


-- 
~ Liz Tuddenham ~
(Remove the ".invalid"s and add ".co.uk" to reply)
www.poppyrecords.co.uk

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#71087

From"J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk>
Date2026-11-11 13:08 +0000
Message-ID<11d1pcu$31vc8$1@dont-email.me>
In reply to#71086
On 2026/11/11 12:39:36, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
> J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
[]
>> So am I right - a televisor was a lot cheaper than an all-electronic set?
[]
>> Though thinking about it now, they could always have inverted the video
>> but not the sync pulses (thus making them "whiter-than-white")!
>   
> They could - but a super-bright white margin on the picture would be
> more disturbing than a black one and the effect of a 'rolling' picture,
> through loss of frame lock, would have been horrendous.
> 
> 
You're right about the rolling. When locked, though, it wouldn't have
been a problem in practice, because every CRT set I ever saw - even into
the days of FSTs (tubes with square corners) - was set to overscan,
often to a ridiculous extent.
-- 
J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

Just seen a Dyslexic Yorkshireman wearing a cat flap!

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#71091

FromRoderick Stewart <rjfs@escapetime.myzen.co.uk>
Date2026-11-11 16:06 +0000
Message-ID<6649fl5knrftpligabl87c79j7oej0dkqd@4ax.com>
In reply to#71087
On Wed, 11 Nov 2026 13:08:44 +0000, "J. P. Gilliver"
<G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:

>On 2026/11/11 12:39:36, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
>> J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
>[]
>>> So am I right - a televisor was a lot cheaper than an all-electronic set?
>[]
>>> Though thinking about it now, they could always have inverted the video
>>> but not the sync pulses (thus making them "whiter-than-white")!
>>   
>> They could - but a super-bright white margin on the picture would be
>> more disturbing than a black one and the effect of a 'rolling' picture,
>> through loss of frame lock, would have been horrendous.
>> 
>> 
>You're right about the rolling. When locked, though, it wouldn't have
>been a problem in practice, because every CRT set I ever saw - even into
>the days of FSTs (tubes with square corners) - was set to overscan,
>often to a ridiculous extent.

Thr super-white surround would still have to be very effectively
electronically blanked, otherwise the overscanned portion would be
reflected from the sides of the tube and fog the display. This
sometimes happened with test and teletext signals when the vertical
blanking circuitry in the TV was of  a simple design from before these
extra signals were added.

Rod.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#71080

FromClive Page <clive.g.page@gmail.com>
Date2026-11-10 21:23 +0000
Message-ID<11d020c$2gpja$3@dont-email.me>
In reply to#71078
On 10/11/2026 16:08, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
> Clive Page <clive.g.page@gmail.com> wrote:
> 
>> On 08/11/2026 17:52, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
>>> On 2026/11/8 11:14:1, Clive Page wrote:
>>>> On 04/11/2026 22:36, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
>>> []
>>>>> I have always thought the mechanical system got a bad deal, in that - in
>>>>> those days when every active device (valve, or at best envelopes with
>>>>> rwo devices in, or three if one was e. g. a diode) cost a significant
>>>>> amount, the mechanical _receivers_ were surely cheaper? (Not
>>>>> dual-standard sets, which obviously had to be electronic anyway.) Or
>>>>> were no 240-line mechanical receivers made? If that is the case,
>>>>> presumably there was at least some distortion, as the mechanical scanner
>>>>> would involve at least slightly curved lines, whereas I can't imagine an
>>>>> electronic receiver doing so (intentionally, anyway!).
>>>>
>>>> I always thought that it must have been obvious that the Baird system
>>>> was hopeless, as it was completely unscaleable to higher resolutions or
>>>
>>> Didn't they get to 240? (A lot of YouTube viewing is surely no better
>>> than that, especially if not full-screen.)
>>>
>>>> to broader broadcasting needs.  It was suitable only for studio
>>>> broadcasts of a single talking head, and the conditions for that person
>>>> seemed, from this programme, to be pretty uncomfortable.  For outside
>>>> broadcasts the scanning beam was simply unusable with no technical
>>>> solution that anyone could devise.  I expect that Heath Robinson was
>>>> jealous that Logie Baird got there first.
>>>
>>> The scanning beam wasn't used for outside broadcasts - a mirror-drum was
>>> used, at least for the Derby. (We had some discussions here a few years
>>> ago as to whether that was the reason an OB van is referred to as a
>>> "scanner"; many origins were suggested, but the Baird-origin one seemed
>>> to win.)
>>>>
>>>> I assume that this must have been evident in 1936 to all of those
>>>> involved, except perhaps Baird himself and any others that he managed to
>>>> brainwash, and that the BBC went through the charade of a comparison
>>>> between systems only because they needed to have a public demonstration
>>>> that the electronic system was vastly superior in all respects.
>>>>
>>>>
>>> I'm inclined to agree that it probably _was_ inferior - certainly
>>> wouldn't even consider it today, with the cheapness of modern
>>> electronics. (Though I think there were almost some large public-display
>>> systems [sports stadia and the like] that used mirror-drum scanning,
>>> when powerful lasers became available, but that was overtaken.) But in
>>> the days when a single valve cost a significant number of hours' work
>>> for the ordinary man, I presume "televisors" were far cheaper for the
>>> consumer than all-electronic sets - they only required a receiver (which
>>> all-electronic sets did too) and a motor (which technology was
>>> well-established by then); this doesn't seem to get _mentioned_ when the
>>> subject comes up = the engineers and administrators preferring to use
>>> the system that is (definitely - I'm not arguing there) best
>>> technically, and also easier to use, and the poor consumer can go hang.
>>> (An attitude that has continued ever since, and still prevails - the
>>> only exception I can think of that went too far the other way was how
>>> long system A was kept going.)
>>
>> I find it hard to believe that all it needed as receiver was a light,
>> motor, and spinning disc.  That would indeed have been cheaper.
>>
>> But surely there's a need for line and frame synchronisation, which the
>> electronic system supported via line and frame sync pulses.  There must
>> have been complicated mechanisms to keep the motor in sync at least.
>> Maybe that could be done without expensive electronics, but I don't see how.
> 
> The disc was spun by a motor with a rheostat to set the speed slightly
> faster than required, then a phonic wheel, with its electromagnet in the
> anode circuit of a valve in the vision channel, pulled the rotation into
> sync.  There were no sync pulses as such, the black border of the
> picture serving as a rough guide.  When they 'faded' the scene, a board
> with black and white squares was slid in fromt of the camera to give a
> signal sufficient to maintain synchronism.
> 
> Later versions of the Baird system may have improved on this but I am
> not aware of what those improvements might have been.
> 
> The blacker-than-black sync pulses were one of the innovations of
> Blumlein's team, which made the EMI electronic system so much more
> reliable.  They chose positive modulation because they considered that
> the white spots cause by motor car ignition interference would be less
> obtrusive than the loss of sync which the same interference would cause
> if the modulation were negative.  Flywheel sync came later.
> 
> 
Thanks for the explanation.

Regards

-- 
Clive Page

[toc] | [prev] | [standalone]


Back to top | Article view | uk.tech.broadcast


csiph-web