Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > sci.physics > #814006 > unrolled thread

Re: Concepts of Space, Time, and Consciousness in Ancient India- I

Started bywhodat <whodaat@void.nowgere.com>
First post2021-01-05 18:28 -0600
Last post2021-01-06 11:07 -0800
Articles 2 — 2 participants

Back to article view | Back to sci.physics

This discussion starts older than the indexed window; earlier articles aren't shown. The article labeled Started by below is the oldest one visible, not the original post.


Contents

  Re: Concepts of Space, Time, and Consciousness in Ancient India- I whodat <whodaat@void.nowgere.com> - 2021-01-05 18:28 -0600
    Re: Concepts of Space, Time, and Consciousness in Ancient India- I "mitchr...@gmail.com" <mitchrae3323@gmail.com> - 2021-01-06 11:07 -0800

#814006 — Re: Concepts of Space, Time, and Consciousness in Ancient India- I

Fromwhodat <whodaat@void.nowgere.com>
Date2021-01-05 18:28 -0600
SubjectRe: Concepts of Space, Time, and Consciousness in Ancient India- I
Message-ID<i5kehrFsi28U3@mid.individual.net>

So guess who this is...




On 1/5/2021 3:45 PM, FBInCIAnNSATerroristSlayer wrote:
> 
> My Indian Hindu Ancestors were the most advanced civilization in human 
> history. They understood and wrote concepts of TIME, SPACE and 
> CONSCIOUSNESS three to four thousand years ago when the western whites 
> were still sucking each other genitals and living like BARBARIANS.
> 
> 
> ==========================================================================
> 
> http://indiafacts.org/concepts-space-time-consciousness-ancient-india/
> 
> Concepts of Space, Time, and Consciousness in Ancient India- I
> 
> Part 1 of a 2-part article describing Indian ideas of the early- 
> Purana/Mahabharata times (centuries BC) on the nature of space, time and 
> consciousness
> 
> AddThis Sharing Buttons
> 
> Share to Facebook
> 
> Share to TwitterShare to PrintShare to EmailShare to More72
> 
>   Subhash Kak
> 
> Indology | 09-10-2017
> 
> Introduction
> 
> Ancient Indian ideas of physics, available to us through a variety of 
> sources, are generally not known in the physics world. Indian 
> astronomer/physicists, starting with a position that sought to unify 
> space, time, matter, and consciousness, argued for relativity of space 
> and time, cyclic and recursively defined universes, and a 
> non-anthropocentric view. The two most astonishing numerical claims from 
> the ancient Indians are: a cyclic system of creation  of the universe 
> with a period of 8.64 billion years, although there exist longer cycles 
> as well; and, speed of light to be 4,404 yojanas per nimes.a, which is 
> almost exactly 186,000 miles per second (Kak, 1998a)!
> 
> A critic would see the numbers as no more than idle coincidences. But 
> within the Indian tradition it is believed that reality, as a kind of a 
> universal state function, transcends the separate categories of space, 
> time, matter, and
> observation. In this function, called Brahman in the literature, inhere 
> all categories including knowledge. The conditioned mind can, by 
> “tuning” in to Brahman, obtain knowledge, although it can only be 
> expressed in terms
> of the associations already experienced by the mind. Within the Indian 
> tradition, scientific knowledge describes as much aspects of outer 
> reality as the topography of the mindscape. Furthermore, there are 
> connections between
> the outer and the inner: we can comprehend reality only because we are 
> already equipped to do so! My own papers listed in the bibliography can 
> serve as an introduction to these ideas and point to further references 
> for the reader to examine.
> 
> Two philosophical systems at the basis of Indian physics—and 
> metaphysics—are Samkhya and Vaisesika. Samkhya, which is an ancient 
> system that goes back to the 3rd millennium BC, posits 25 basic 
> categories together with 3 constituent qualities, which evolve in 
> different ways to create the universe at the microcosmic as well as the 
> macrocosmic levels. It also presupposes a “potential” (tanmatra) to be 
> more basic than the material entity. Vaisesika is a later system which 
> is an atomic theory with the non-atomic ground of ether, space, and time 
> upon which rest four different classes of indestructible atoms which 
> combine in a variety of ways to constitute all matter; it also considers 
> mind to be atomic (Kak, 1999). These systems presuppose genesis and 
> evolution both at the cosmic and psychological levels. They also accept 
> cyclic and multiple universes, and centrality of observers.
> 
> Unfortunately, historians of science are generally oblivious of Indian 
> physics, astronomy or cosmology. Amongst popular books, Paul Halpern’s 
> The Cyclical Serpent (1995) is unusual in that it places modern 
> speculations regarding an oscillating universe within the context of the 
> cyclic cosmology of the Puranas, but even this book doesn’t define a 
> context for the Indian ideas.
> 
> In this paper we present, in a capsule form, the basic Indian ideas on 
> space, time, and observation from the age of the epics and the early 
> Puranas. The ideas of these period seem to belong to last centuries BC 
> and they are described in the Mahabharata, Puranas, and the early 
> Siddhantas. To keep  our sources to a minimum, we mainly use 
> Yoga-Vasistha (YV), an ancient Indian text, over 29,000 verses long, 
> traditionally attributed to Valmiki, author of the epic Ramayana, which 
> is over two thousand years old.
> Vedic and Puranic Cosmology
> 
> We first look at Vedic cosmology. The Vedas are texts that represent the 
> ancient knowledge tradition of India. While their compilations go back 
> to at least the third millennium, some of their contents might be even 
> older. The Vedic tradition is a part of the Indian culture tradition 
> that has been traced back, archaeologically, to about 8000 BC 
> (Feuerstein et al, 1995). The antiquity of the Vedic texts is, in part, 
> confirmed by their celebration of the Sarasvati river as the greatest 
> river of their age, and modern hydrological studies have established 
> that this river dried up around 2000 BC. The kinglists in the Puranas 
> take us to several millennia before the period of the drying up of the 
> Sarasvati. There is also a rock art tradition in India that has been 
> traced to about 40000 BC (Wakankar, 1992).
> 
> There are several statements in the Vedic texts about the universe being 
> infinite, while at the same time the finite distance to the sun is 
> explicitly mentioned (Kak, 1998a-d). Aditi, the great mother of the 
> gods, is a personification of the concept of infinity. A famous mantra 
> speaks of how taking infinity out of infinity leaves it unchanged. This 
> indicates that paradoxical properties of the notion of infinity were known.
> 
> In a reference to mapping the outer world into an altar made of bricks, 
> the Yajurveda (hymn 17) names numbers in multiples of ten that go upto 
> ten hundred thousand million. This also suggests a belief in a very 
> large universe.
> The Satapatha Brahmana, a commentatorial prose text on the Veda, that 
> most likely goes back to the early centuries of the second millennium 
> BC, provides an overview of some broad aspects of Vedic cosmology. The 
> sixth chapter of the book, entitled “Creation of the Universe”, speaks 
> of the creation of the earth later than that of other stars. Creation is 
> seen to proceed under the aegis of the Prajapati (reference either to a 
> star or to abstract time) with the emergence of Asva, Rasabha, Aja and 
> Kurma before the emergence of the earth. Visvanatha Vidyalankara 
> suggests that these are the sun (Asva), Gemini (Rasabha), Aja 
> (Capricorn) and Kurma (Cassiopeia).
> 
> This identification is supported by etymological considerations. The 
> Rgveda 1.164.2 and Nirukta 4.4.27 define Asva as the sun. Rasabha which 
> literally means the twin asses are defined in Nighant.u 1.15 as A´svinau 
> which later usage suggests are Castor and Pollux in Gemini. In Western 
> astronomy the twin asses are to be found in the next constellation of 
> Cancer as Asellus Borealis and Asellus Australis. Aja (goat) is defined 
> by Nighantu 1.15 as a
> sun and owing to the continuity that we see in the Vedic and later 
> European names for constellations (as in the case of the Great Bear) it 
> is reasonable to identify it as the constellation Capricorn (caper goat 
> + cornu horn). Kurma is a synonym of Kasyapa (tortoise) which is like 
> Cassiopeia (from Greek Kassiopeia), and it is appropriate because it is 
> near the pole.
> 
> The Puranas view the universe to have a diameter of about 500 million 
> yojanas, but beyond the universe lies the limitless Pradhana, that has 
> within it countless other universes (Kak, 1998a)
> The Yoga-Vasistha
> 
> The internal evidence of the Yoga-Vasistha (YV) indicates that it was 
> authored or compiled later than the Ramayana. Chapple (1984) summarizes 
> the views of various scholars who date it variously as early as the 
> sixth century AD or as late as the 13th or the 14th century. Dasgupta 
> (1975, 1932) dated it about the sixth century AD on the basis that one 
> of its verses appears to be copied from one of Kalidasa’s plays 
> considering Kalidasa to have lived around the fifth century. The 
> traditional date of Kalidasa is 50 BC and new arguments (Kak 1990) 
> support this earlier date so that the estimates regarding the age of YV 
> are further muddled and it is possible that this text could be 2000 
> years old.
> 
> YV may be viewed as a book of philosophy or as a philosophical novel. It 
> describes the instruction given by Vasistha to Rama, the hero of the 
> epic Ramayana. Its premise may be termed radical idealism and it is 
> couched in a fashion that has many parallels with the notion of a 
> participatory universe argued by Wheeler and others. Its most 
> interesting passages from the scientific point of view relate to the 
> description of the nature of space, time, matter, and consciousness. It 
> should be emphasized that the YV ideas do not stand in isolation. 
> Similar ideas are to be found in the earlier Vedic books. At its deepest 
> level the Vedic conception is to view reality in a monist manner; at the 
> next level one may speak of the dichotomy of mind and matter. Ideas 
> similar to those found in YV are also encountered in Puranas and Tantric 
> literature.
> 
> YV is a text that belongs to the mainstream of the ancient Vedic 
> tradition that professes to deal with knowledge. Astronomical references 
> in the Vedic texts take us back to the 4th or 5th millennium BC or even 
> earlier (e.g. Kak 1994-6).
> 
> Roughly speaking, the Vedic system speaks of an interconnectedness 
> between the observer and the observed. A similar conception appears to 
> have informed many ancient peoples including the Greeks.
> 
> The Vedic system of knowledge is based on a tripartite approach to the 
> universe where connections exist in triples in categories of one group 
> and across groups: sky, atmosphere, earth; object, medium, subject; 
> future, present, past; and so on. Beyond the triples lies the 
> transcendental “fourth”.
> 
> Three kinds of motion are alluded to in the Vedic books: these are the 
> translational motion, sound, and light which are taken to be 
> “equivalent” to earth, air, and sky. The fourth motion is assigned to 
> consciousness; and this is considered to be infinite in speed.
> 
> At least one of the founders of quantum theory was directly inspired by 
> the Vedic system of knowledge. Schr¨odinger (1961) claims that the Vedic 
> slogan “All in One and One in All” was an idea that led him to the 
> creation of quantum mechanics (see also Moore, 1989). Even before 
> Schrodinger, the idealist philosophical tradition in Europe had long 
> been moulded by Vedic ideas. It should also be noted that many parts of 
> the Vedic literature are still not properly understood although 
> considerable progress has recently taken place in the study of Vedic 
> science.
> 
> It is most interesting that the books in this Indian tradition speak 
> about the relativity of time and space in a variety of ways. The 
> medieval books call the Puranas speak of countless universes, time 
> flowing at different rates for different observers and so on.
> 
> Universes defined recursively are described in the famous episode of 
> Indra and the ants in Brahmavaivarta Purana 4.47.100-160, the 
> Mahabharata 12.187, and elsewhere. These flights of imagination are to 
> be traced to more than a straightforward generalization of the motions 
> of the planets into a cyclic universe. They must be viewed in the 
> background of an amazingly sophisticated tradition of cognitive and 
> analytical thought (see e.g. Staal 1988; Rao and Kak 1998).
> 
> To be Continued…
> 
> Adapted from a chapter in “The Wishing Tree.”

[toc] | [next] | [standalone]


#814043

From"mitchr...@gmail.com" <mitchrae3323@gmail.com>
Date2021-01-06 11:07 -0800
Message-ID<58e1d7fd-9aa7-43e1-b0d5-bc96e7031f11n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#814006
On Tuesday, January 5, 2021 at 4:28:48 PM UTC-8, whodat wrote:
> So guess who this is...
> On 1/5/2021 3:45 PM, FBInCIAnNSATerroristSlayer wrote: 
> > 
> > My Indian Hindu Ancestors were the most advanced civilization in human 
> > history. They understood and wrote concepts of TIME, SPACE and 
> > CONSCIOUSNESS three to four thousand years ago when the western whites 
> > were still sucking each other genitals and living like BARBARIANS. 
> > 
> > 
> > ========================================================================== 
> > 
> > http://indiafacts.org/concepts-space-time-consciousness-ancient-india/ 
> > 
> > Concepts of Space, Time, and Consciousness in Ancient India- I 
> > 
> > Part 1 of a 2-part article describing Indian ideas of the early- 
> > Purana/Mahabharata times (centuries BC) on the nature of space, time and 
> > consciousness 
> > 
> > AddThis Sharing Buttons 
> > 
> > Share to Facebook 
> > 
> > Share to TwitterShare to PrintShare to EmailShare to More72 
> > 
> > Subhash Kak 
> > 
> > Indology | 09-10-2017 
> > 
> > Introduction 
> > 
> > Ancient Indian ideas of physics, available to us through a variety of 
> > sources, are generally not known in the physics world. Indian 
> > astronomer/physicists, starting with a position that sought to unify 
> > space, time, matter, and consciousness, argued for relativity of space 
> > and time, cyclic and recursively defined universes, and a 
> > non-anthropocentric view. The two most astonishing numerical claims from 
> > the ancient Indians are: a cyclic system of creation of the universe 
> > with a period of 8.64 billion years, although there exist longer cycles 
> > as well; and, speed of light to be 4,404 yojanas per nimes.a, which is 
> > almost exactly 186,000 miles per second (Kak, 1998a)! 
> > 
> > A critic would see the numbers as no more than idle coincidences. But 
> > within the Indian tradition it is believed that reality, as a kind of a 
> > universal state function, transcends the separate categories of space, 
> > time, matter, and 
> > observation. In this function, called Brahman in the literature, inhere 
> > all categories including knowledge. The conditioned mind can, by 
> > “tuning” in to Brahman, obtain knowledge, although it can only be 
> > expressed in terms 
> > of the associations already experienced by the mind. Within the Indian 
> > tradition, scientific knowledge describes as much aspects of outer 
> > reality as the topography of the mindscape. Furthermore, there are 
> > connections between 
> > the outer and the inner: we can comprehend reality only because we are 
> > already equipped to do so! My own papers listed in the bibliography can 
> > serve as an introduction to these ideas and point to further references 
> > for the reader to examine. 
> > 
> > Two philosophical systems at the basis of Indian physics—and 
> > metaphysics—are Samkhya and Vaisesika. Samkhya, which is an ancient 
> > system that goes back to the 3rd millennium BC, posits 25 basic 
> > categories together with 3 constituent qualities, which evolve in 
> > different ways to create the universe at the microcosmic as well as the 
> > macrocosmic levels. It also presupposes a “potential” (tanmatra) to be 
> > more basic than the material entity. Vaisesika is a later system which 
> > is an atomic theory with the non-atomic ground of ether, space, and time 
> > upon which rest four different classes of indestructible atoms which 
> > combine in a variety of ways to constitute all matter; it also considers 
> > mind to be atomic (Kak, 1999). These systems presuppose genesis and 
> > evolution both at the cosmic and psychological levels. They also accept 
> > cyclic and multiple universes, and centrality of observers. 
> > 
> > Unfortunately, historians of science are generally oblivious of Indian 
> > physics, astronomy or cosmology. Amongst popular books, Paul Halpern’s 
> > The Cyclical Serpent (1995) is unusual in that it places modern 
> > speculations regarding an oscillating universe within the context of the 
> > cyclic cosmology of the Puranas, but even this book doesn’t define a 
> > context for the Indian ideas. 
> > 
> > In this paper we present, in a capsule form, the basic Indian ideas on 
> > space, time, and observation from the age of the epics and the early 
> > Puranas. The ideas of these period seem to belong to last centuries BC 
> > and they are described in the Mahabharata, Puranas, and the early 
> > Siddhantas. To keep our sources to a minimum, we mainly use 
> > Yoga-Vasistha (YV), an ancient Indian text, over 29,000 verses long, 
> > traditionally attributed to Valmiki, author of the epic Ramayana, which 
> > is over two thousand years old. 
> > Vedic and Puranic Cosmology 
> > 
> > We first look at Vedic cosmology. The Vedas are texts that represent the 
> > ancient knowledge tradition of India. While their compilations go back 
> > to at least the third millennium, some of their contents might be even 
> > older. The Vedic tradition is a part of the Indian culture tradition 
> > that has been traced back, archaeologically, to about 8000 BC 
> > (Feuerstein et al, 1995). The antiquity of the Vedic texts is, in part, 
> > confirmed by their celebration of the Sarasvati river as the greatest 
> > river of their age, and modern hydrological studies have established 
> > that this river dried up around 2000 BC. The kinglists in the Puranas 
> > take us to several millennia before the period of the drying up of the 
> > Sarasvati. There is also a rock art tradition in India that has been 
> > traced to about 40000 BC (Wakankar, 1992). 
> > 
> > There are several statements in the Vedic texts about the universe being 
> > infinite, while at the same time the finite distance to the sun is 
> > explicitly mentioned (Kak, 1998a-d). Aditi, the great mother of the 
> > gods, is a personification of the concept of infinity. A famous mantra 
> > speaks of how taking infinity out of infinity leaves it unchanged. This 
> > indicates that paradoxical properties of the notion of infinity were known. 
> > 
> > In a reference to mapping the outer world into an altar made of bricks, 
> > the Yajurveda (hymn 17) names numbers in multiples of ten that go upto 
> > ten hundred thousand million. This also suggests a belief in a very 
> > large universe. 
> > The Satapatha Brahmana, a commentatorial prose text on the Veda, that 
> > most likely goes back to the early centuries of the second millennium 
> > BC, provides an overview of some broad aspects of Vedic cosmology. The 
> > sixth chapter of the book, entitled “Creation of the Universe”, speaks 
> > of the creation of the earth later than that of other stars. Creation is 
> > seen to proceed under the aegis of the Prajapati (reference either to a 
> > star or to abstract time) with the emergence of Asva, Rasabha, Aja and 
> > Kurma before the emergence of the earth. Visvanatha Vidyalankara 
> > suggests that these are the sun (Asva), Gemini (Rasabha), Aja 
> > (Capricorn) and Kurma (Cassiopeia). 
> > 
> > This identification is supported by etymological considerations. The 
> > Rgveda 1.164.2 and Nirukta 4.4.27 define Asva as the sun. Rasabha which 
> > literally means the twin asses are defined in Nighant.u 1.15 as A´svinau 
> > which later usage suggests are Castor and Pollux in Gemini. In Western 
> > astronomy the twin asses are to be found in the next constellation of 
> > Cancer as Asellus Borealis and Asellus Australis. Aja (goat) is defined 
> > by Nighantu 1.15 as a 
> > sun and owing to the continuity that we see in the Vedic and later 
> > European names for constellations (as in the case of the Great Bear) it 
> > is reasonable to identify it as the constellation Capricorn (caper goat 
> > + cornu horn). Kurma is a synonym of Kasyapa (tortoise) which is like 
> > Cassiopeia (from Greek Kassiopeia), and it is appropriate because it is 
> > near the pole. 
> > 
> > The Puranas view the universe to have a diameter of about 500 million 
> > yojanas, but beyond the universe lies the limitless Pradhana, that has 
> > within it countless other universes (Kak, 1998a) 
> > The Yoga-Vasistha 
> > 
> > The internal evidence of the Yoga-Vasistha (YV) indicates that it was 
> > authored or compiled later than the Ramayana. Chapple (1984) summarizes 
> > the views of various scholars who date it variously as early as the 
> > sixth century AD or as late as the 13th or the 14th century. Dasgupta 
> > (1975, 1932) dated it about the sixth century AD on the basis that one 
> > of its verses appears to be copied from one of Kalidasa’s plays 
> > considering Kalidasa to have lived around the fifth century. The 
> > traditional date of Kalidasa is 50 BC and new arguments (Kak 1990) 
> > support this earlier date so that the estimates regarding the age of YV 
> > are further muddled and it is possible that this text could be 2000 
> > years old. 
> > 
> > YV may be viewed as a book of philosophy or as a philosophical novel. It 
> > describes the instruction given by Vasistha to Rama, the hero of the 
> > epic Ramayana. Its premise may be termed radical idealism and it is 
> > couched in a fashion that has many parallels with the notion of a 
> > participatory universe argued by Wheeler and others. Its most 
> > interesting passages from the scientific point of view relate to the 
> > description of the nature of space, time, matter, and consciousness. It 
> > should be emphasized that the YV ideas do not stand in isolation. 
> > Similar ideas are to be found in the earlier Vedic books. At its deepest 
> > level the Vedic conception is to view reality in a monist manner; at the 
> > next level one may speak of the dichotomy of mind and matter. Ideas 
> > similar to those found in YV are also encountered in Puranas and Tantric 
> > literature. 
> > 
> > YV is a text that belongs to the mainstream of the ancient Vedic 
> > tradition that professes to deal with knowledge. Astronomical references 
> > in the Vedic texts take us back to the 4th or 5th millennium BC or even 
> > earlier (e.g. Kak 1994-6). 
> > 
> > Roughly speaking, the Vedic system speaks of an interconnectedness 
> > between the observer and the observed. A similar conception appears to 
> > have informed many ancient peoples including the Greeks. 
> > 
> > The Vedic system of knowledge is based on a tripartite approach to the 
> > universe where connections exist in triples in categories of one group 
> > and across groups: sky, atmosphere, earth; object, medium, subject; 
> > future, present, past; and so on. Beyond the triples lies the 
> > transcendental “fourth”. 
> > 
> > Three kinds of motion are alluded to in the Vedic books: these are the 
> > translational motion, sound, and light which are taken to be 
> > “equivalent” to earth, air, and sky. The fourth motion is assigned to 
> > consciousness; and this is considered to be infinite in speed. 
> > 
> > At least one of the founders of quantum theory was directly inspired by 
> > the Vedic system of knowledge. Schr¨odinger (1961) claims that the Vedic 
> > slogan “All in One and One in All” was an idea that led him to the 
> > creation of quantum mechanics (see also Moore, 1989). Even before 
> > Schrodinger, the idealist philosophical tradition in Europe had long 
> > been moulded by Vedic ideas. It should also be noted that many parts of 
> > the Vedic literature are still not properly understood although 
> > considerable progress has recently taken place in the study of Vedic 
> > science. 
> > 
> > It is most interesting that the books in this Indian tradition speak 
> > about the relativity of time and space in a variety of ways. The 
> > medieval books call the Puranas speak of countless universes, time 
> > flowing at different rates for different observers and so on. 
> > 
> > Universes defined recursively are described in the famous episode of 
> > Indra and the ants in Brahmavaivarta Purana 4.47.100-160, the 
> > Mahabharata 12.187, and elsewhere. These flights of imagination are to 
> > be traced to more than a straightforward generalization of the motions 
> > of the planets into a cyclic universe. They must be viewed in the 
> > background of an amazingly sophisticated tradition of cognitive and 
> > analytical thought (see e.g. Staal 1988; Rao and Kak 1998). 
> > 
> > To be Continued… 
> > 
> > Adapted from a chapter in “The Wishing Tree.”

The place your at is important... even in time....

[toc] | [prev] | [standalone]


Back to top | Article view | sci.physics


csiph-web