Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > sci.physics > #670441 > unrolled thread

Re: Not Newton but Gauss

Started byThomas 'PointedEars' Lahn <PointedEars@web.de>
First post2018-02-11 06:52 +0100
Last post2018-02-12 13:05 +0000
Articles 10 — 6 participants

Back to article view | Back to sci.physics

This discussion starts older than the indexed window; earlier articles aren't shown. The article labeled Started by below is the oldest one visible, not the original post.


Contents

  Re: Not Newton but Gauss Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn <PointedEars@web.de> - 2018-02-11 06:52 +0100
    Re: Not Newton but Gauss SolomonW <SolomonW@citi.com> - 2018-02-11 18:37 +1100
      Re: Not Newton but Gauss Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn <PointedEars@web.de> - 2018-02-11 10:43 +0100
        Re: Not Newton but Gauss john <johnsefton288@gmail.com> - 2018-02-11 07:01 -0800
          Re: Not Newton but Gauss moroney@world.std.spaamtrap.com (Michael Moroney) - 2018-02-11 15:28 +0000
            Re: Not Newton but Gauss Lofty Goat <rlwatkins@gmail.com> - 2018-02-11 11:33 -0600
              Re: Not Newton but Gauss Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn <PointedEars@web.de> - 2018-02-12 05:01 +0100
                Re: Not Newton but Gauss Libor 'Poutnik' Stříž <poutnik@privacy.net> - 2018-02-12 08:21 +0100
                  Re: Not Newton but Gauss Libor 'Poutnik' Stříž <poutnik@privacy.net> - 2018-02-12 08:51 +0100
              Re: Not Newton but Gauss moroney@world.std.spaamtrap.com (Michael Moroney) - 2018-02-12 13:05 +0000

#670441 — Re: Not Newton but Gauss

FromThomas 'PointedEars' Lahn <PointedEars@web.de>
Date2018-02-11 06:52 +0100
SubjectRe: Not Newton but Gauss
Message-ID<1777469.usQuhbGJ8B@PointedEars.de>
SolomonW wrote:

> How fool does this help you here if you do not know what the length of the
> astronomical unit (AU) is and you need that to calculate G which is
> defined here in terms of AU as you do not have our sun's mass (M).

    [This has nothing to do with relativity.  You are off-topic.]

You have not the slightest clue what you are talking about.

Simple trigonometry based on observation (parallax, transits of inner 
planets) suffices to determine the Terra–Sol distance.  Eratosthenes of 
Cyrene did it sometime between 276–194 BCE, Cassini in 1672 (CE), and 
Lalande in 1771.

Kepler’s third law (1609/1621) can provide additional assurance:

      1 AU ≈ R_E = ∛((1 a)² R_P³∕T_P²),

where the Rs are distances from Sol, the Ts are orbital periods, E means 
Earth, and P means an inner planet (usually Venus).

    [Newton used Kepler’s laws to find his law of universal gravitation;
     NOT the other way around.]

For more precise measurements, we use radar and space probe telemetry since 
1961.

<http://curious.astro.cornell.edu/about-us/41-our-solar-system/the-earth/orbit/87-how-do-you-measure-the-distance-between-earth-and-the-sun-intermediate>

What we now call the *Newtonian* gravitational constant, G, was not even 
known to Newton (he used “specific gravity” instead of “mass”).  It was 
implicitly determined from the forces between test masses, and between each 
test mass and Terra, in the Cavendish experiment in 1797/1798.  The average 
density of Terra, the mass of Terra and that of Sol (“our sun”) was 
*calculated* from the results of that experiment.

NOT the other way around.

<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cavendish_experiment>

The IAU *has used* a definition of 1 AU until 2012 based on the *Gaussian* 
gravitational constant, k.  The Gaussian constant was obsoleted then, and 
the IAU definition of 1 AU is now solely based on the metre, which in turn 
is based on the constant speed of light in vacuum and the SI base unit of 
time, the second, since 1983.

<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaussian_gravitational_constant#Definition_of_the_astronomical_unit>

Shut up, go away, and *study*.


Score adjusted

PointedEars
-- 
Q: Why is electricity so dangerous?  
A: It doesn't conduct itself.

(from: WolframAlpha)

[toc] | [next] | [standalone]


#670450

FromSolomonW <SolomonW@citi.com>
Date2018-02-11 18:37 +1100
Message-ID<3npwhhwrxzar$.8ygg9oasuekg.dlg@40tude.net>
In reply to#670441
On Sun, 11 Feb 2018 06:52:42 +0100, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:

> SolomonW wrote:
> 
>> How fool does this help you here if you do not know what the length of the
>> astronomical unit (AU) is and you need that to calculate G which is
>> defined here in terms of AU as you do not have our sun's mass (M).
> 
>     [This has nothing to do with relativity.  You are off-topic.]
 
I did not start the discussion, and you kept it going.



> 
> You have not the slightest clue what you are talking about.


Mmmmmmm

> 
> Simple trigonometry based on observation (parallax, transits of inner 
> planets) suffices to determine the Terra–Sol distance.  Eratosthenes of 
> Cyrene did it sometime between 276–194 BCE, Cassini in 1672 (CE), and 
> Lalande in 1771.


It's only with the last person you mention on the "Transit of Venus," that
we get a creditable figure.


> 
> Kepler’s third law (1609/1621) can provide additional assurance:
> 
>       1 AU ≈ R_E = ∛((1 a)² R_P³∕T_P²),
> 
> where the Rs are distances from Sol, the Ts are orbital periods, E means 
> Earth, and P means an inner planet (usually Venus).
> 
>     [Newton used Kepler’s laws to find his law of universal gravitation;
>      NOT the other way around.]

NO. Based on Newton's assumptions as we know them you do not need this
Kepler law to derive Newton's theory. Furthermore, nowhere does Kepler
actually state this law in much detail, what we are doing is out of his
book, finding an observation. 

Probably what happened is that Newton or someone close to him told him
about this Kepler observation and then Newton proved that it derived from
his theory.



> 
> For more precise measurements, we use radar and space probe telemetry since 
> 1961.

Good luck for that in Newton and even Gauss's time

> 
> > > What we now call the *Newtonian* gravitational constant, G, was not even > known to Newton (he used “specific gravity” instead of “mass”).  It was 
> implicitly determinedfrom the forces between test masses, and between each 
> testmass and Terra, inthe Cavendish experiment in 1797/1798.  The average > density of Terra, themass of Terra and that of Sol (“oursun”) was > *calculated* fromthe results of that experiment.

Which is what we weare talking about. 

What you are missing is that wou need to know G and since G here is
determined in terms of theastronomical unit (AU), you need to know that
too.

> > NOTthe other way around.>> > > The IAU *has used* a definitionof 1 AU until2012 based on the *Gaussian* 
> gravitationalconstant, k. The Gaussianconstant was obsoleted then, and> the IAU definition of 1 AU is now solely based on the metre, which in turn 
> is based on the constant speed of light in vacuum and the SI base unitof > time, the second, since 1983.

Irrelevant to Newton and Gauss's time.

<snip a troll>

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#670453

FromThomas 'PointedEars' Lahn <PointedEars@web.de>
Date2018-02-11 10:43 +0100
Message-ID<3101986.QJadu78ljV@PointedEars.de>
In reply to#670450
SolomonW wrote:

> On Sun, 11 Feb 2018 06:52:42 +0100, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
>> SolomonW wrote:
>>> How fool does this help you here if you do not know what the length of
>>> the astronomical unit (AU) is and you need that to calculate G which is
>>> defined here in terms of AU as you do not have our sun's mass (M).
>>     [This has nothing to do with relativity.  You are off-topic.]
>  
> I did not start the discussion,

That is a lie.  It was *you* who posted this pseudo-scientific nonsense:

,-<news:6ht5q7l63qgt.ptd9hrdykukn$.dlg@40tude.net>
| 
| […] the astronomical unit of a foreign binary star was not known either
| till much later, to calculate it now we often use G.

> and you kept it going.

Irrelevant.  You should have directed the discussion to another newsgroup in 
the first place.

>> Simple trigonometry based on observation (parallax, transits of inner
>> planets) suffices to determine the Terra–Sol distance.  Eratosthenes of
>> Cyrene did it sometime between 276–194 BCE, Cassini in 1672 (CE), and
>> Lalande in 1771.
> 
> It's only with the last person you mention on the "Transit of Venus," that
> we get a creditable figure.

If you had read what I referred you to, you would have known at the latest 
that Cassini’s result is ca. 149'668'992 km.  The current measurements yield 
a semi-major axis of 149'598'023 km.  So Cassini was over it by only ca. 
0.05 %.

That is orders of magnitude less than the blatant errors in your statements.  
Humility is a virtue.
  
>> Kepler’s third law (1609/1621) can provide additional assurance:
>> 
>>       1 AU ≈ R_E = ∛((1 a)² R_P³∕T_P²),
>> 
>> where the Rs are distances from Sol, the Ts are orbital periods, E means
>> Earth, and P means an inner planet (usually Venus).
>> 
>>     [Newton used Kepler’s laws to find his law of universal gravitation;
>>      NOT the other way around.]
> 
> NO.

Yes, he did.

> Based on Newton's assumptions as we know them you do not need this
> Kepler law to derive Newton's theory.

Utter nonsense.  Newton had only Galilei’s observations, Huygens’ 
calculation on circular motion, and his F = m a (in different form).  
Kepler’s third law, which in turn was based on Brahe’s meticulous precise 
observations is the key component to formulate a correct law of universal 
gravitation.  Thus Newton wrote (translated to modern English): “If I have 
seen farther than others then only because I have been standing on the 
shoulders of giants”.

> Furthermore, nowhere does Kepler actually state this law in much detail,
> what we are doing is out of his book, finding an observation.

Nonsense.  If only you would know how to read.
 
> Probably […]

Your *uneducated* *guesses* are hopeless.  Science is based on fact.

>> For more precise measurements, we use radar and space probe telemetry
>> since 1961.
> 
> Good luck for that in Newton and even Gauss's time

Which part of “trigonometry”, “parallax” or “transit of inner planets” did 
you not understand?

>> > > What we now call the *Newtonian* gravitational constant, G, was not
>> > > even > known to Newton (he used “specific gravity” instead of
>> > > “mass”).  It was
>> implicitly determinedfrom the forces between test masses, and between
>> eachtestmass and Terra, inthe Cavendish experiment in 1797/1798.  The 
>> average
>> > density of Terra, themass of Terra and that of Sol (“oursun”) was >
>> *calculated* fromthe results of that experiment.

That is _not_ how I wrote it.  Get a proper newreader.
 
> Which is what we weare talking about.
> 
> What you are missing is that wou need to know G and since G here is
> determined in terms of theastronomical unit (AU),

Repeating nonsense does not make it true.  G is _not_ determined in terms of 
the astronomical unit.  It *never* has been.

> you need to know that too.

/Ex falso quodlibet./
 
>> > NOTthe other way around.>> > > The IAU *has used* a definitionof 1 AU
>> > until2012 based on the *Gaussian*
>> gravitationalconstant, k. The Gaussianconstant was obsoleted then, and>
>> the IAU definition of 1 AU is now solely based on the metre, which in
>> turn is based on the constant speed of light in vacuum and the SI base
>> unitof > time, the second, since 1983.

That is also _not_ how I wrote it.
 
> Irrelevant to Newton and Gauss's time.

Which part of “trigonometry”, “parallax”, or “transit of inner planets” did 
you not understand?

What has changed is only how the distance to an inner planet is determined; 
the method of calculating the distance Terra–Sol is the same since more than 
2000 years.

Only you are ignorant of trigonometry, astronomy, and physics, and are 
arguing from that ignorance.  You are ill-equipped to win this argument.
 
> <snip a troll>

It takes one to know one.


PointedEars
-- 
“Science is empirical: knowing the answer means nothing;
 testing your knowledge means everything.”
   —Dr. Lawrence M. Krauss, theoretical physicist,
    in “A Universe from Nothing” (2009)

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#670471

Fromjohn <johnsefton288@gmail.com>
Date2018-02-11 07:01 -0800
Message-ID<d0f72468-5443-4cf5-9652-5da0e85bc0fc@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#670453
PointedEars 
'Obsoleted'  should be 'made obsolete'.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#670475

Frommoroney@world.std.spaamtrap.com (Michael Moroney)
Date2018-02-11 15:28 +0000
Message-ID<p5pnfp$cb9$1@pcls7.std.com>
In reply to#670471
john <johnsefton288@gmail.com> writes:

>PointedEars 
>'Obsoleted'  should be 'made obsolete'.

Either way is correct, but 'obsoleted' is less common.

I work in software development, and I just obsoleted some old, unnecessary
features in a product.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#670494

FromLofty Goat <rlwatkins@gmail.com>
Date2018-02-11 11:33 -0600
Message-ID<8hv08dhg1ienpga7ccofrfcvmncbr6ua7v@4ax.com>
In reply to#670475
On Sun, 11 Feb 2018 15:28:57 +0000 (UTC),
moroney@world.std.spaamtrap.com (Michael Moroney) wrote:

>john <johnsefton288@gmail.com> writes:
>
>>PointedEars 
>>'Obsoleted'  should be 'made obsolete'.
>
>Either way is correct, but 'obsoleted' is less common.
>
>I work in software development, and I just obsoleted some old, unnecessary
>features in a product.

As Calvin once pointed out to Hobbes, "Verbing weirds language."

"Made obsolete" is correct.

-- 
Goat

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#670574

FromThomas 'PointedEars' Lahn <PointedEars@web.de>
Date2018-02-12 05:01 +0100
Message-ID<3866265.ejJDZkT8p0@PointedEars.de>
In reply to#670494
Lofty Goat wrote:

> moroney@world.std.spaamtrap.com (Michael Moroney) wrote:
>> john <johnsefton288@gmail.com> writes:
>>> 'Obsoleted'  should be 'made obsolete'.
>> Either way is correct, but 'obsoleted' is less common.
>>
>> I work in software development, and I just obsoleted some old, 
>> unnecessary features in a product.
> 
> As Calvin once pointed out to Hobbes, "Verbing weirds language."
> 
> "Made obsolete" is correct.

<https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5536> (and many others), third line,
first column.

Usage defines language.


PointedEars
-- 
Q: What happens when electrons lose their energy?  
A: They get Bohr'ed.

(from: WolframAlpha)

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#670594

FromLibor 'Poutnik' Stříž <poutnik@privacy.net>
Date2018-02-12 08:21 +0100
Message-ID<p5rf9m$jo7$1@dont-email.me>
In reply to#670574
Dne 12/02/2018 v 05:01 Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn napsal(a):
> Lofty Goat wrote:
> 
>> moroney@world.std.spaamtrap.com (Michael Moroney) wrote:
>>> john <johnsefton288@gmail.com> writes:
>>>> 'Obsoleted'  should be 'made obsolete'.
>>> Either way is correct, but 'obsoleted' is less common.
>>>
>>> I work in software development, and I just obsoleted some old, 
>>> unnecessary features in a product.
>>
>> As Calvin once pointed out to Hobbes, "Verbing weirds language."
>>
>> "Made obsolete" is correct.
> 
> <https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5536> (and many others), third line,
> first column.
> 
> Usage defines language.

It is a misleading shortcut.

Is the grammar addressed by RFCs now ?
Are RFCs the authoritative source for the grammar usage in science ?

Grammar structures are matter of philology, not of technical articles.
Including the scientific language and common spoken language.




-- 
Poutnik ( The Pilgrim, Der Wanderer )

A wise man guards words he says,
as they say about him more,
than he says about the subject.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#670598

FromLibor 'Poutnik' Stříž <poutnik@privacy.net>
Date2018-02-12 08:51 +0100
Message-ID<p5rh2s$ss1$1@dont-email.me>
In reply to#670594
Dne 12/02/2018 v 08:21 Libor 'Poutnik' Stříž napsal(a):
> Dne 12/02/2018 v 05:01 Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn napsal(a):
>> Lofty Goat wrote:
>>
>>> moroney@world.std.spaamtrap.com (Michael Moroney) wrote:
>>>> john <johnsefton288@gmail.com> writes:
>>>>> 'Obsoleted'  should be 'made obsolete'.
>>>> Either way is correct, but 'obsoleted' is less common.
>>>>
>>>> I work in software development, and I just obsoleted some old, 
>>>> unnecessary features in a product.
>>>
>>> As Calvin once pointed out to Hobbes, "Verbing weirds language."
>>>
>>> "Made obsolete" is correct.
>>
>> <https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5536> (and many others), third line,
>> first column.
>>
>> Usage defines language.
> 
> It is a misleading shortcut.
> 
> Is the grammar addressed by RFCs now ?
> Are RFCs the authoritative source for the grammar usage in science ?
> 
> Grammar structures are matter of philology, not of technical articles.
> Including the scientific language and common spoken language.
> 

Obsolete is both an adjective and a verb,
so made obsolete and obsoleted are equivalent, proper terms.
However, the former seems to me to be used more.

http://www.dictionary.com/browse/obsoleted
https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/obsolete
http://www.learnersdictionary.com/definition/obsolete

The M-W does not even list it as a verb.

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/obsolete


-- 
Poutnik ( The Pilgrim, Der Wanderer )

A wise man guards words he says,
as they say about him more,
than he says about the subject.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#670605

Frommoroney@world.std.spaamtrap.com (Michael Moroney)
Date2018-02-12 13:05 +0000
Message-ID<p5s3ei$nkc$2@pcls7.std.com>
In reply to#670494
Lofty Goat <rlwatkins@gmail.com> writes:

>On Sun, 11 Feb 2018 15:28:57 +0000 (UTC),
>moroney@world.std.spaamtrap.com (Michael Moroney) wrote:

>>john <johnsefton288@gmail.com> writes:
>>
>>>PointedEars 
>>>'Obsoleted'  should be 'made obsolete'.
>>
>>Either way is correct, but 'obsoleted' is less common.
>>
>>I work in software development, and I just obsoleted some old, unnecessary
>>features in a product.

>As Calvin once pointed out to Hobbes, "Verbing weirds language."

>"Made obsolete" is correct.

I agree in general with the Calvin and Hobbes reference, however it 
appears that "obsoleted" is older than most verbed adjectives & nouns.
Mid level engineering management is often guilty of too much verbing...
:-)

[toc] | [prev] | [standalone]


Back to top | Article view | sci.physics


csiph-web