Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > sci.math > #517326 > unrolled thread

Dedekind was a crank.

Started byEram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com>
First post2021-04-10 05:34 -0700
Last post2021-04-30 20:19 +0000
Articles 20 on this page of 147 — 19 participants

Back to article view | Back to sci.math


Contents

  Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-10 05:34 -0700
    Re: Dedekind was a crank. Quantum Bubbles <ross.probability@gmx.com> - 2021-04-10 06:10 -0700
      Re: Dedekind was a crank. Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-04-10 09:15 -0500
        Re: Dedekind was a crank. Quantum Bubbles <ross.probability@gmx.com> - 2021-04-10 07:21 -0700
          Re: Dedekind was a crank. Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-04-10 09:57 -0500
            Re: Dedekind was a crank. Quantum Bubbles <ross.probability@gmx.com> - 2021-04-10 08:01 -0700
        Re: Dedekind was a crank. "mitchr...@gmail.com" <mitchrae3323@gmail.com> - 2021-04-11 18:10 -0700
      Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-10 11:10 -0700
        Re: Dedekind was a crank. Quantum Bubbles <ross.probability@gmx.com> - 2021-04-11 06:12 -0700
          Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-11 09:27 -0700
            Re: Dedekind was a crank. Mostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com> - 2021-04-11 09:37 -0700
              Re: Dedekind was a crank. Mostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com> - 2021-04-11 09:41 -0700
                Re: Dedekind was a crank. Mostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com> - 2021-04-11 09:48 -0700
            Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-11 10:57 -0700
              Re: Dedekind was a crank. Mostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com> - 2021-04-11 12:37 -0700
                Re: Dedekind was a crank. Mostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com> - 2021-04-11 12:46 -0700
                  Re: Dedekind was a crank. Mostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com> - 2021-04-11 12:47 -0700
            Re: Dedekind was a crank. Quantum Bubbles <ross.probability@gmx.com> - 2021-04-11 14:51 -0700
              Re: Dedekind was a crank. Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-04-11 19:36 -0500
              Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-22 12:04 -0700
                Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-22 16:09 -0700
                  Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-23 01:39 -0700
                    Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-23 05:38 -0700
                      Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-23 06:17 -0700
                        Re: Dedekind was a crank. Mostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com> - 2021-04-23 06:51 -0700
                          Re: Dedekind was a crank. Mostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com> - 2021-04-23 06:54 -0700
                            Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-23 10:21 -0700
                        Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-24 06:58 -0700
                          Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-24 11:24 -0700
                            Re: Dedekind was a crank. Mostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com> - 2021-04-24 12:07 -0700
                              Re: Dedekind was a crank. Mostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com> - 2021-04-24 12:10 -0700
                                Re: Dedekind was a crank. FredJeffries <fredjeffries@gmail.com> - 2021-04-24 13:09 -0700
                                  Re: Dedekind was a crank. Mostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com> - 2021-04-24 13:16 -0700
                                    Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-25 04:43 -0700
                            Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-25 04:42 -0700
                              Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-25 04:43 -0700
                              Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-25 04:52 -0700
                                Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-25 06:38 -0700
                                  Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-25 07:01 -0700
                                    Re: Dedekind was a crank. "zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com> - 2021-04-25 22:31 -0700
                                      Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-26 11:13 -0700
                                        Re: Dedekind was a crank. "zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com> - 2021-04-26 22:36 -0700
                                          Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-27 04:31 -0700
                                            Re: Dedekind was a crank. Alan Mackenzie <acm@muc.de> - 2021-04-27 12:06 +0000
                                              Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-27 12:22 -0700
                                                Re: Dedekind was a crank. Alan Mackenzie <acm@muc.de> - 2021-04-28 09:03 +0000
                                                  Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-28 05:38 -0700
                                                    Re: Dedekind was a crank. Timothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com> - 2021-04-28 06:10 -0700
                                                      Re: Dedekind was a crank. Timothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com> - 2021-05-01 05:02 -0700
                                                    Re: Dedekind was a crank. Alan Mackenzie <acm@muc.de> - 2021-04-28 14:54 +0000
                                                      Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-28 11:51 -0700
                                                        Re: Dedekind was a crank. Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-04-28 14:41 -0500
                                                        Re: Dedekind was a crank. Alan Mackenzie <acm@muc.de> - 2021-04-28 21:10 +0000
                                                          Re: Dedekind was a crank. Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-04-28 22:15 -0500
                                                          Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-29 09:19 -0700
                                                            Re: Dedekind was a crank. Alan Mackenzie <acm@muc.de> - 2021-04-30 08:59 +0000
                                                              Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-30 08:40 -0700
                                                                Re: Dedekind was a crank. Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-04-30 10:54 -0500
                                                              Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-30 10:56 -0700
                                                                Re: Dedekind was a crank. Timothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com> - 2021-04-30 14:23 -0700
                                                            Re: Dedekind was a crank. Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-04-30 08:58 -0500
                                                              Re: Dedekind was a crank. FromTheRafters <erratic@nomail.afraid.org> - 2021-04-30 10:18 -0400
                                                              Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-30 08:19 -0700
                                                                Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-30 11:00 -0700
                                                                  Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-30 14:12 -0700
                                                                    Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-05-01 10:02 -0700
                                                                      Re: Dedekind was a crank. Timothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com> - 2021-05-03 03:40 -0700
                                                                        Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-05-03 11:11 -0700
                                                                          Re: Dedekind was a crank. Python <python@python.invalid> - 2021-05-03 20:43 +0200
                                                                            Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-05-03 16:32 -0700
                                                                              Re: Dedekind was a crank. Python <python@python.invalid> - 2021-05-04 06:49 +0200
                                                                                Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-05-04 04:38 -0700
                                                                          Re: Dedekind was a crank. Timothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com> - 2021-05-03 14:16 -0700
                                                                            Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-05-03 16:34 -0700
                                                                              Re: Dedekind was a crank. Ezekiel Petrov-Slonimsky <ezepetslon@msky.net> - 2021-05-03 18:01 -0700
                                                    Re: Dedekind was a crank. FromTheRafters <erratic@nomail.afraid.org> - 2021-04-28 11:37 -0400
                                                    Re: Dedekind was a crank. Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-04-28 11:01 -0500
                                                      Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-28 09:11 -0700
                                                      Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-28 11:59 -0700
                                                        Re: Dedekind was a crank. Timothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com> - 2021-04-28 12:34 -0700
                                                          Re: Dedekind was a crank. Timothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com> - 2021-04-28 13:50 -0700
                                                        Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-29 06:50 -0700
                                            Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-27 09:50 -0700
                                            Re: Dedekind was a crank. "zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com> - 2021-04-27 21:47 -0700
                                              Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-28 05:18 -0700
                                                Re: Dedekind was a crank. "zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com> - 2021-04-29 00:26 -0700
                                                  Re: Dedekind was a crank. Timothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com> - 2021-04-29 04:46 -0700
                                                  Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-29 06:54 -0700
                                                    Re: Dedekind was a crank. "zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com> - 2021-04-29 22:11 -0700
                                                      Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-30 10:53 -0700
                                                        Re: Dedekind was a crank. "zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com> - 2021-05-02 22:17 -0700
                                                          Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-05-03 11:03 -0700
                                                            Re: Dedekind was a crank. "zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com> - 2021-05-04 01:26 -0700
                                                              Re: Dedekind was a crank. Timothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com> - 2021-05-04 04:22 -0700
                                                                Re: Dedekind was a crank. "zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com> - 2021-05-04 04:32 -0700
                                                                  Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-05-04 04:39 -0700
                                                                Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-05-04 04:48 -0700
                                                                  Re: Dedekind was a crank. Timothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com> - 2021-05-04 07:18 -0700
                                                                    Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-05-04 08:40 -0700
                                                                      Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-05-04 08:45 -0700
                                                  Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-29 09:23 -0700
                                                    Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-29 18:14 -0700
                                                    Re: Dedekind was a crank. "zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com> - 2021-04-29 22:12 -0700
                                                      Re: Dedekind was a crank. Timothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com> - 2021-04-30 06:16 -0700
                                              Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-28 08:48 -0700
                                    Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-26 08:13 -0700
                                      Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-26 11:18 -0700
                                        Re: Dedekind was a crank. Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-04-26 14:02 -0500
                                        Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-27 09:47 -0700
                                          Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-27 12:28 -0700
                                            Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-28 08:44 -0700
                          Re: Dedekind was a crank. Dan Christensen <Dan_Christensen@sympatico.ca> - 2021-04-24 14:44 -0700
                      Re: Dedekind was a crank. Dan Christensen <Dan_Christensen@sympatico.ca> - 2021-04-24 14:39 -0700
                  Re: Dedekind was a crank. Alan Mackenzie <acm@muc.de> - 2021-04-27 11:50 +0000
          Re: Dedekind was a crank. FredJeffries <fredjeffries@gmail.com> - 2021-04-22 16:13 -0700
            Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-22 17:32 -0700
              Re: Dedekind was a crank. Mostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com> - 2021-04-22 18:03 -0700
            Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-23 01:41 -0700
              Re: Dedekind was a crank. Python <python@python.invalid> - 2021-04-23 11:15 +0200
    Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-10 06:49 -0700
    Re: Dedekind was a crank. sobriquet <dohduhdah@yahoo.com> - 2021-04-10 09:54 -0700
      Re: Dedekind was a crank. Quantum Bubbles <ross.probability@gmx.com> - 2021-04-10 11:17 -0700
        Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-10 11:29 -0700
          Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-10 18:27 -0700
            Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-11 03:59 -0700
              Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-11 04:42 -0700
      Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-10 18:22 -0700
        Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-11 03:04 -0700
          Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-11 04:32 -0700
            Re: Dedekind was a crank. Mostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com> - 2021-04-11 04:43 -0700
              Re: Dedekind was a crank. Mostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com> - 2021-04-11 05:01 -0700
              Re: Dedekind was a crank. FromTheRafters <erratic@nomail.afraid.org> - 2021-04-11 09:54 -0400
            Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-11 05:02 -0700
              Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-11 06:07 -0700
                Re: Dedekind was a crank. WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-04-11 07:10 -0700
                  Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-11 07:43 -0700
                  Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-11 07:45 -0700
    Re: Dedekind was a crank. Python <python@python.invalid> - 2021-04-10 20:40 +0200
    RE: Dedekind was a crank. earle <earle.jones@comcast.net> - 2021-04-11 00:00 +0000
    Re: Dedekind was a crank. Dan Christensen <Dan_Christensen@sympatico.ca> - 2021-04-11 07:04 -0700
      Re: Dedekind was a crank. Peter <peterxpercival@hotmail.com> - 2021-04-11 15:29 +0100
        Re: Dedekind was a crank. Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-04-11 07:54 -0700
    Re: Dedekind was a crank. "zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com> - 2021-04-12 01:05 -0700
    JG is and always will be a kook, a crank and a troll! Dan Christensen <Dan_Christensen@sympatico.ca> - 2021-04-22 21:59 -0700
    Re: Dedekind was a crank. Kristjan Robam <he12457@hotmail.com> - 2021-04-28 04:29 -0700
    Re: Dedekind was a crank. Mostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com> - 2021-04-30 12:45 -0700
      Re: Dedekind was a crank. Lloyd Oberwise <lloob@essacrt.mx> - 2021-04-30 20:19 +0000

Page 1 of 8  [1] 2 3 4 5 6 7 8  Next page →


#517326 — Dedekind was a crank.

FromEram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com>
Date2021-04-10 05:34 -0700
SubjectDedekind was a crank.
Message-ID<68c7cb00-b0c8-4af6-962e-80643312f2fan@googlegroups.com>

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B-mOEooW03iLSTROakNyVXlQUEU

Your comments are drivel and will be ignored.

[toc] | [next] | [standalone]


#517331

FromQuantum Bubbles <ross.probability@gmx.com>
Date2021-04-10 06:10 -0700
Message-ID<5f33d637-ce0c-4996-84e3-542ccc07f139n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#517326
On Saturday, April 10, 2021 at 1:34:44 PM UTC+1, Eram semper recta wrote:
> https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B-mOEooW03iLSTROakNyVXlQUEU 
> 
> Your comments are drivel and will be ignored.

Whilst Dedekind's views concerning the philosophy of mathematics have been the subject of much scholarly discussion, with some being more sympathetic than others and some more critical than others, Dedekind's philosophical beliefs are generally respectable by any sensible standard. Such would be the view of qualified judges, even if they disagreed with them. Certainly not a crank.

Dedekind's approach to understanding the real line analytically is a beautiful accomplishment in the history of mathematical thought. Students would be well advised to consult a book written by the late physicist Stephen Hawking titled "God Made the Integers", which contains a number of translations of historically important contributions to mathematics including Dedekind's approach to irrational numbers. 

Dedekind's approach is well understood by mathematicians and can be safely used to great effect in understanding calculus. For example, the wonderful introduction to real analysis by G.H Hardy "A Course of Pure Mathematics" (centenary edition), whilst not the easiest textbook to learn real analysis from (but not the hardest either) uses it in an elementary manner, which would be well complemented by reading it alongside Dedekind's contribution to Stephen Hawking's book mentioned above. This is a far more beneficial use of any student's time than trying to wade through Mr Gabriel's document.

Students visiting this page would be well advised to ignore Mr Gabriel's views on Dedekind as they are not based on a good understanding of the literature. An example of a professionally done piece of Dedekind related scholarship, written by an actual expert on Dedekind's thought would be the contribution to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy on Richard Dedekind given here:

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/dedekind-foundations/

The website in question is an internationally respected source on such matters.

Kind Regards

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#517335

FromSergio <invalid@invalid.com>
Date2021-04-10 09:15 -0500
Message-ID<s4sbtf$17r4$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#517331
On 4/10/2021 8:10 AM, Quantum Bubbles wrote:
> On Saturday, April 10, 2021 at 1:34:44 PM UTC+1, Eram semper recta wrote:
>> https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B-mOEooW03iLSTROakNyVXlQUEU 
>>
>> Your comments are drivel and will be ignored.
> 
> Whilst Dedekind's views concerning the philosophy of mathematics have been the subject of much scholarly discussion, with some being more sympathetic than others and some more critical than others, Dedekind's philosophical beliefs are generally respectable by any sensible standard. Such would be the view of qualified judges, even if they disagreed with them. Certainly not a crank.
> 
> Dedekind's approach to understanding the real line analytically is a beautiful accomplishment in the history of mathematical thought. Students would be well advised to consult a book written by the late physicist Stephen Hawking titled "God Made the Integers", which contains a number of translations of historically important contributions to mathematics including Dedekind's approach to irrational numbers. 
> 
> Dedekind's approach is well understood by mathematicians and can be safely used to great effect in understanding calculus. For example, the wonderful introduction to real analysis by G.H Hardy "A Course of Pure Mathematics" (centenary edition), whilst not the easiest textbook to learn real analysis from (but not the hardest either) uses it in an elementary manner, which would be well complemented by reading it alongside Dedekind's contribution to Stephen Hawking's book mentioned above. This is a far more beneficial use of any student's time than trying to wade through Mr Gabriel's document.
> 
> Students visiting this page would be well advised to ignore Mr Gabriel's views on Dedekind as they are not based on a good understanding of the literature. An example of a professionally done piece of Dedekind related scholarship, written by an actual expert on Dedekind's thought would be the contribution to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy on Richard Dedekind given here:
> 
> https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/dedekind-foundations/
> 
> The website in question is an internationally respected source on such matters.
> 
> Kind Regards
> 


the book "God Made the Integers" seems cool!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_Created_the_Integers

God Created the Integers: The Mathematical Breakthroughs That Changed
History is a 2005 anthology, edited by Stephen Hawking, of "excerpts
from thirty-one of the most important works in the history of
mathematics."[1]

The title of the book is a reference to a quotation attributed to
mathematician Leopold Kronecker, who once wrote that "God made the
integers; all else is the work of man."[2]
Content

The works are grouped by author and ordered chronologically. Each
section is prefaced by notes on the mathematician's life and work. The
anthology includes works by the following mathematicians:

    Euclid
    Archimedes
    Diophantus
    René Descartes
    Isaac Newton
    Leonhard Euler
    Pierre-Simon Laplace
    Joseph Fourier
    Carl Friedrich Gauss
    Augustin-Louis Cauchy
    Nikolai Ivanovich Lobachevsky
    János Bolyai
    Évariste Galois
    George Boole
    Bernhard Riemann
    Karl Weierstrass
    Richard Dedekind
    Georg Cantor
    Henri Lebesgue
    Kurt Gödel
    Alan Turing

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#517336

FromQuantum Bubbles <ross.probability@gmx.com>
Date2021-04-10 07:21 -0700
Message-ID<8b3d75c7-df6c-4aa1-b8ba-becfcc8bf1e4n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#517335
On Saturday, April 10, 2021 at 3:15:26 PM UTC+1, Sergio wrote:
> On 4/10/2021 8:10 AM, Quantum Bubbles wrote: 
> > On Saturday, April 10, 2021 at 1:34:44 PM UTC+1, Eram semper recta wrote: 
> >> https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B-mOEooW03iLSTROakNyVXlQUEU 
> >> 
> >> Your comments are drivel and will be ignored. 
> > 
> > Whilst Dedekind's views concerning the philosophy of mathematics have been the subject of much scholarly discussion, with some being more sympathetic than others and some more critical than others, Dedekind's philosophical beliefs are generally respectable by any sensible standard. Such would be the view of qualified judges, even if they disagreed with them. Certainly not a crank. 
> > 
> > Dedekind's approach to understanding the real line analytically is a beautiful accomplishment in the history of mathematical thought. Students would be well advised to consult a book written by the late physicist Stephen Hawking titled "God Made the Integers", which contains a number of translations of historically important contributions to mathematics including Dedekind's approach to irrational numbers. 
> > 
> > Dedekind's approach is well understood by mathematicians and can be safely used to great effect in understanding calculus. For example, the wonderful introduction to real analysis by G.H Hardy "A Course of Pure Mathematics" (centenary edition), whilst not the easiest textbook to learn real analysis from (but not the hardest either) uses it in an elementary manner, which would be well complemented by reading it alongside Dedekind's contribution to Stephen Hawking's book mentioned above. This is a far more beneficial use of any student's time than trying to wade through Mr Gabriel's document. 
> > 
> > Students visiting this page would be well advised to ignore Mr Gabriel's views on Dedekind as they are not based on a good understanding of the literature. An example of a professionally done piece of Dedekind related scholarship, written by an actual expert on Dedekind's thought would be the contribution to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy on Richard Dedekind given here: 
> > 
> > https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/dedekind-foundations/ 
> > 
> > The website in question is an internationally respected source on such matters. 
> > 
> > Kind Regards 
> >
> the book "God Made the Integers" seems cool! 
> 
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_Created_the_Integers 
> 
> God Created the Integers: The Mathematical Breakthroughs That Changed 
> History is a 2005 anthology, edited by Stephen Hawking, of "excerpts 
> from thirty-one of the most important works in the history of 
> mathematics."[1] 
> 
> The title of the book is a reference to a quotation attributed to 
> mathematician Leopold Kronecker, who once wrote that "God made the 
> integers; all else is the work of man."[2] 
> Content 
> 
> The works are grouped by author and ordered chronologically. Each 
> section is prefaced by notes on the mathematician's life and work. The 
> anthology includes works by the following mathematicians: 
> 
> Euclid 
> Archimedes 
> Diophantus 
> René Descartes 
> Isaac Newton 
> Leonhard Euler 
> Pierre-Simon Laplace 
> Joseph Fourier 
> Carl Friedrich Gauss 
> Augustin-Louis Cauchy 
> Nikolai Ivanovich Lobachevsky 
> János Bolyai 
> Évariste Galois 
> George Boole 
> Bernhard Riemann 
> Karl Weierstrass 
> Richard Dedekind 
> Georg Cantor 
> Henri Lebesgue 
> Kurt Gödel 
> Alan Turing

Oops, my apologies, it is of course: "God Created the Integers" rather than "God made the integers"  :-) .  But yes it is an excellent book. Although the edition I have doesn't include contributions by Euler, Galois, Lobachevsky or Bolyai.

Kind Regards

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#517338

FromSergio <invalid@invalid.com>
Date2021-04-10 09:57 -0500
Message-ID<s4seco$d27$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#517336
On 4/10/2021 9:21 AM, Quantum Bubbles wrote:
> On Saturday, April 10, 2021 at 3:15:26 PM UTC+1, Sergio wrote:
>> On 4/10/2021 8:10 AM, Quantum Bubbles wrote: 
>>> On Saturday, April 10, 2021 at 1:34:44 PM UTC+1, Eram semper recta wrote: 
>>>> https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B-mOEooW03iLSTROakNyVXlQUEU 
>>>>
>>>> Your comments are drivel and will be ignored. 
>>>
>>> Whilst Dedekind's views concerning the philosophy of mathematics have been the subject of much scholarly discussion, with some being more sympathetic than others and some more critical than others, Dedekind's philosophical beliefs are generally respectable by any sensible standard. Such would be the view of qualified judges, even if they disagreed with them. Certainly not a crank. 
>>>
>>> Dedekind's approach to understanding the real line analytically is a beautiful accomplishment in the history of mathematical thought. Students would be well advised to consult a book written by the late physicist Stephen Hawking titled "God Made the Integers", which contains a number of translations of historically important contributions to mathematics including Dedekind's approach to irrational numbers. 
>>>
>>> Dedekind's approach is well understood by mathematicians and can be safely used to great effect in understanding calculus. For example, the wonderful introduction to real analysis by G.H Hardy "A Course of Pure Mathematics" (centenary edition), whilst not the easiest textbook to learn real analysis from (but not the hardest either) uses it in an elementary manner, which would be well complemented by reading it alongside Dedekind's contribution to Stephen Hawking's book mentioned above. This is a far more beneficial use of any student's time than trying to wade through Mr Gabriel's document. 
>>>
>>> Students visiting this page would be well advised to ignore Mr Gabriel's views on Dedekind as they are not based on a good understanding of the literature. An example of a professionally done piece of Dedekind related scholarship, written by an actual expert on Dedekind's thought would be the contribution to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy on Richard Dedekind given here: 
>>>
>>> https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/dedekind-foundations/ 
>>>
>>> The website in question is an internationally respected source on such matters. 
>>>
>>> Kind Regards 
>>>
>> the book "God Made the Integers" seems cool! 
>>
>> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_Created_the_Integers 
>>
>> God Created the Integers: The Mathematical Breakthroughs That Changed 
>> History is a 2005 anthology, edited by Stephen Hawking, of "excerpts 
>> from thirty-one of the most important works in the history of 
>> mathematics."[1] 
>>
>> The title of the book is a reference to a quotation attributed to 
>> mathematician Leopold Kronecker, who once wrote that "God made the 
>> integers; all else is the work of man."[2] 
>> Content 
>>
>> The works are grouped by author and ordered chronologically. Each 
>> section is prefaced by notes on the mathematician's life and work. The 
>> anthology includes works by the following mathematicians: 
>>
>> Euclid 
>> Archimedes 
>> Diophantus 
>> René Descartes 
>> Isaac Newton 
>> Leonhard Euler 
>> Pierre-Simon Laplace 
>> Joseph Fourier 
>> Carl Friedrich Gauss 
>> Augustin-Louis Cauchy 
>> Nikolai Ivanovich Lobachevsky 
>> János Bolyai 
>> Évariste Galois 
>> George Boole 
>> Bernhard Riemann 
>> Karl Weierstrass 
>> Richard Dedekind 
>> Georg Cantor 
>> Henri Lebesgue 
>> Kurt Gödel 
>> Alan Turing
> 
> Oops, my apologies, it is of course: "God Created the Integers" rather than "God made the integers"  :-) .  But yes it is an excellent book. Although the edition I have doesn't include contributions by Euler, Galois, Lobachevsky or Bolyai.
> 
> Kind Regards
> 

I think Above is second edition, or something like that. At one time I
had a huge set of books from a 2nd hand place, 6 feet across, that had
many of the original works (in English) by above mathematicians. It was
very impressive to read, these people were highly intelligent, clear,
detailed, deep insight, and well written. If living today they would
still be head and shoulders above most.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#517340

FromQuantum Bubbles <ross.probability@gmx.com>
Date2021-04-10 08:01 -0700
Message-ID<5b61c8a2-e809-49a1-9907-d63a4148f5bdn@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#517338
On Saturday, April 10, 2021 at 3:57:40 PM UTC+1, Sergio wrote:
> On 4/10/2021 9:21 AM, Quantum Bubbles wrote: 
> > On Saturday, April 10, 2021 at 3:15:26 PM UTC+1, Sergio wrote: 
> >> On 4/10/2021 8:10 AM, Quantum Bubbles wrote: 
> >>> On Saturday, April 10, 2021 at 1:34:44 PM UTC+1, Eram semper recta wrote: 
> >>>> https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B-mOEooW03iLSTROakNyVXlQUEU 
> >>>> 
> >>>> Your comments are drivel and will be ignored. 
> >>> 
> >>> Whilst Dedekind's views concerning the philosophy of mathematics have been the subject of much scholarly discussion, with some being more sympathetic than others and some more critical than others, Dedekind's philosophical beliefs are generally respectable by any sensible standard. Such would be the view of qualified judges, even if they disagreed with them. Certainly not a crank. 
> >>> 
> >>> Dedekind's approach to understanding the real line analytically is a beautiful accomplishment in the history of mathematical thought. Students would be well advised to consult a book written by the late physicist Stephen Hawking titled "God Made the Integers", which contains a number of translations of historically important contributions to mathematics including Dedekind's approach to irrational numbers. 
> >>> 
> >>> Dedekind's approach is well understood by mathematicians and can be safely used to great effect in understanding calculus. For example, the wonderful introduction to real analysis by G.H Hardy "A Course of Pure Mathematics" (centenary edition), whilst not the easiest textbook to learn real analysis from (but not the hardest either) uses it in an elementary manner, which would be well complemented by reading it alongside Dedekind's contribution to Stephen Hawking's book mentioned above. This is a far more beneficial use of any student's time than trying to wade through Mr Gabriel's document. 
> >>> 
> >>> Students visiting this page would be well advised to ignore Mr Gabriel's views on Dedekind as they are not based on a good understanding of the literature. An example of a professionally done piece of Dedekind related scholarship, written by an actual expert on Dedekind's thought would be the contribution to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy on Richard Dedekind given here: 
> >>> 
> >>> https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/dedekind-foundations/ 
> >>> 
> >>> The website in question is an internationally respected source on such matters. 
> >>> 
> >>> Kind Regards 
> >>> 
> >> the book "God Made the Integers" seems cool! 
> >> 
> >> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_Created_the_Integers 
> >> 
> >> God Created the Integers: The Mathematical Breakthroughs That Changed 
> >> History is a 2005 anthology, edited by Stephen Hawking, of "excerpts 
> >> from thirty-one of the most important works in the history of 
> >> mathematics."[1] 
> >> 
> >> The title of the book is a reference to a quotation attributed to 
> >> mathematician Leopold Kronecker, who once wrote that "God made the 
> >> integers; all else is the work of man."[2] 
> >> Content 
> >> 
> >> The works are grouped by author and ordered chronologically. Each 
> >> section is prefaced by notes on the mathematician's life and work. The 
> >> anthology includes works by the following mathematicians: 
> >> 
> >> Euclid 
> >> Archimedes 
> >> Diophantus 
> >> René Descartes 
> >> Isaac Newton 
> >> Leonhard Euler 
> >> Pierre-Simon Laplace 
> >> Joseph Fourier 
> >> Carl Friedrich Gauss 
> >> Augustin-Louis Cauchy 
> >> Nikolai Ivanovich Lobachevsky 
> >> János Bolyai 
> >> Évariste Galois 
> >> George Boole 
> >> Bernhard Riemann 
> >> Karl Weierstrass 
> >> Richard Dedekind 
> >> Georg Cantor 
> >> Henri Lebesgue 
> >> Kurt Gödel 
> >> Alan Turing 
> > 
> > Oops, my apologies, it is of course: "God Created the Integers" rather than "God made the integers" :-) . But yes it is an excellent book. Although the edition I have doesn't include contributions by Euler, Galois, Lobachevsky or Bolyai. 
> > 
> > Kind Regards 
> >
> I think Above is second edition, or something like that. At one time I 
> had a huge set of books from a 2nd hand place, 6 feet across, that had 
> many of the original works (in English) by above mathematicians. It was 
> very impressive to read, these people were highly intelligent, clear, 
> detailed, deep insight, and well written. If living today they would 
> still be head and shoulders above most.

Indeed they would be, and their works are still an inspiration. 

I suspect you are right about the above being a later edition (mine is quite old as I got it shortly after the book was first published).

Kind Regards

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#517532

From"mitchr...@gmail.com" <mitchrae3323@gmail.com>
Date2021-04-11 18:10 -0700
Message-ID<51c66bb7-7d71-480c-a50f-aa528ec8bcfen@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#517335
On Saturday, April 10, 2021 at 7:15:26 AM UTC-7, Sergio wrote:
> On 4/10/2021 8:10 AM, Quantum Bubbles wrote: 
> > On Saturday, April 10, 2021 at 1:34:44 PM UTC+1, Eram semper recta wrote: 
> >> https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B-mOEooW03iLSTROakNyVXlQUEU 
> >> 
> >> Your comments are drivel and will be ignored. 
> > 
> > Whilst Dedekind's views concerning the philosophy of mathematics have been the subject of much scholarly discussion, with some being more sympathetic than others and some more critical than others, Dedekind's philosophical beliefs are generally respectable by any sensible standard. Such would be the view of qualified judges, even if they disagreed with them. Certainly not a crank. 
> > 
> > Dedekind's approach to understanding the real line analytically is a beautiful accomplishment in the history of mathematical thought. Students would be well advised to consult a book written by the late physicist Stephen Hawking titled "God Made the Integers", which contains a number of translations of historically important contributions to mathematics including Dedekind's approach to irrational numbers. 
> > 
> > Dedekind's approach is well understood by mathematicians and can be safely used to great effect in understanding calculus. For example, the wonderful introduction to real analysis by G.H Hardy "A Course of Pure Mathematics" (centenary edition), whilst not the easiest textbook to learn real analysis from (but not the hardest either) uses it in an elementary manner, which would be well complemented by reading it alongside Dedekind's contribution to Stephen Hawking's book mentioned above. This is a far more beneficial use of any student's time than trying to wade through Mr Gabriel's document. 
> > 
> > Students visiting this page would be well advised to ignore Mr Gabriel's views on Dedekind as they are not based on a good understanding of the literature. An example of a professionally done piece of Dedekind related scholarship, written by an actual expert on Dedekind's thought would be the contribution to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy on Richard Dedekind given here: 
> > 
> > https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/dedekind-foundations/ 
> > 
> > The website in question is an internationally respected source on such matters. 
> > 
> > Kind Regards 
> >
> the book "God Made the Integers" seems cool! 
> 
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_Created_the_Integers 
> 
> God Created the Integers:

The integers are built by an infinite sequence
of the infinitely small. add one more infinitely
small to .999 repeating and you get an integer.

Mitchell Raemsch

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#517367

FromWM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de>
Date2021-04-10 11:10 -0700
Message-ID<5337b4f1-90ee-4b7a-b655-2589cc428e18n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#517331
Quantum Bubbles schrieb am Samstag, 10. April 2021 um 15:10:18 UTC+2:

> Dedekind's approach to understanding the real line analytically is a beautiful accomplishment in the history of mathematical thought. 

But is it widely known that he supported potential infinity? where his Dedekind-definition of infinite collection makes sense.

Gauß' last doctoral student Richard Dedekind, although contributing a lot to set theory and accepting the actual infinite, tended to potential infinity nevertheless. "Every time when there is a cut (A1, A2) which is not produced by a rational number, we create a new, an irrational number α which we consider to be completely defined by this cut (A1, A2);" [R. Dedekind: "Stetigkeit und irrationale Zahlen", 6th ed., Vieweg, Braunschweig (1960) p. 13] This is clearly potential infinity, because never more than a finite number of cuts can have been created.
	"There are infinite systems. Proof (a similar reflection can be found in § 13 of the Paradoxien des Unendlichen by Bolzano (Leipzig 1851)) . The world of my thoughts, i.e., the collection S of all things which can be objects of my thinking, is infinite. For, if s is an element of S, then the thought s' that s can be an object of my thinking is itself an object of my thinking." [R. Dedekind: "Was sind und was sollen die Zahlen?", 8th ed., Vieweg, Braunschweig (1960) p. 14] This is potential infinity too, because never more than a finite number of thoughts can have been thought.
My translation, https://www.hs-augsburg.de/~mueckenh/Transfinity/Transfinity/pdf

Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#517439

FromQuantum Bubbles <ross.probability@gmx.com>
Date2021-04-11 06:12 -0700
Message-ID<4803c45d-9a67-4e39-97a4-34d8782a655bn@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#517367
On Saturday, April 10, 2021 at 7:10:51 PM UTC+1, WM wrote:
> Quantum Bubbles schrieb am Samstag, 10. April 2021 um 15:10:18 UTC+2: 
> 
> > Dedekind's approach to understanding the real line analytically is a beautiful accomplishment in the history of mathematical thought.
> But is it widely known that he supported potential infinity? where his Dedekind-definition of infinite collection makes sense. 
> 
> Gauß' last doctoral student Richard Dedekind, although contributing a lot to set theory and accepting the actual infinite, tended to potential infinity nevertheless. "Every time when there is a cut (A1, A2) which is not produced by a rational number, we create a new, an irrational number α which we consider to be completely defined by this cut (A1, A2);" [R. Dedekind: "Stetigkeit und irrationale Zahlen", 6th ed., Vieweg, Braunschweig (1960) p. 13] This is clearly potential infinity, because never more than a finite number of cuts can have been created. 
> "There are infinite systems. Proof (a similar reflection can be found in § 13 of the Paradoxien des Unendlichen by Bolzano (Leipzig 1851)) . The world of my thoughts, i.e., the collection S of all things which can be objects of my thinking, is infinite. For, if s is an element of S, then the thought s' that s can be an object of my thinking is itself an object of my thinking." [R. Dedekind: "Was sind und was sollen die Zahlen?", 8th ed., Vieweg, Braunschweig (1960) p. 14] This is potential infinity too, because never more than a finite number of thoughts can have been thought. 
> My translation, https://www.hs-augsburg.de/~mueckenh/Transfinity/Transfinity/pdf 
> 
> Regards, WM


I thank Professor Mueckenheim for taking the time to respond to my comment. 

I disagree with Professor Mueckenheim that Dedekind was a sceptic about transfinite set theory. There are various arguments that could be given for my position, but a good starting point I think is that it seems contrary to the role he is regarded in playing in the development of early set theory:

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/settheory-early/

and in his support for Cantor, such as persuading Cantor not to withdraw one of his most amazing papers that explicitly involved the actual infinite.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georg_Cantor

It is true that doubts arose due to paradoxes in early set theory, but Dedekind didn’t seem to renounce set theory, rather he seems to have worked to try and fix it. 

The Dedekind quote provided by Professor Mueckenheim in his 366 page document:Transfinity: a source book, 

“the numbers are free creations of the human mind” 

does not seem to commit Dedekind to a philosophy of mathematics that is sceptical of the actual infinite. The word “free” seems to play an important role here. 

As an illustration: if Dedekind believed that potential infinity was the only valid use of infinity in mathematical argumentation, then it would be mysterious that he did not produce a version of real analysis along constructivist lines similar to Errett Bishop, which gives quite a different presentation of results such as the Intermediate Value Theorem.

Kind Regards

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#517465

FromWM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de>
Date2021-04-11 09:27 -0700
Message-ID<e509e326-ad8d-48ca-ad84-3fe38181c1b6n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#517439
Quantum Bubbles schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 15:12:54 UTC+2:

> I thank Professor Mueckenheim for taking the time to respond to my comment. 

It was a pleasure.

> There are various arguments that could be given for my position, but a good starting point I think is that it seems contrary to the role he is regarded in playing in the development of early set theory: 

Of course Dedeking did quite a lot there.
> 
> and in his support for Cantor, such as persuading Cantor not to withdraw one of his most amazing papers that explicitly involved the actual infinite.

Things are not as straight as Wikipedia presents them.

Dedekind first warned Cantor not to publish his finding without carefully realizing and mentioning the implications of complety interrupting the continuity of the square:
"die Ausfüllung der Lücken zwingt Sie, eine grauenhafte, Schwindel erregende Unstetigkeit in der Correspondenz eintreten zu lassen, durch welche Alles in Atome aufgelöst wird, so dass jeder noch so kleine stetig zusammenhängende Theil des einen Gebietes in seinem Bilde als durchaus zerrissen, unstetig erscheint.
	Ich hoffe, mich deutlich genug ausgedrückt zu haben ; die Absicht meines Schreibens besteht nur darin Sie zu bitten, nicht ohne eine gründliche Prüfung meines Einwandes gegen die bisher für wahr gehaltenen Glaubensartikel der Mannigfaltigkeitslehre öffentlich zu polemisieren." [Dedekind, 2 Jul 1877]

When Cantor asked Dedekind for supporting a publication at Vieweg, Dedekind's publisher, Dedekind explained the problems arising there (he himself had payed the printing expenses of his book and Vieweg was reluctant to publish small pieces like Cantor's paper) and the small readership to be expected. 

"Für den Fall, daß Sie Ihre Arbeit dem Journal für Mathematik ganz entziehen und als besondere Schrift erscheinen lassen wollten, werde ich mir gewiß gern Mühe geben, dieselbe bei Vieweg als Verlags-Artikel zu empfehlen. Allein ich weiß im Voraus, daß ich dabei auf Schwierigkeiten stoßen würde ; schon seit langen Jahren habe ich Vieweg oder seine Vertreter in gelegentlichen Gesprächen die größte Abneigung aussprechen hören, Schriften von so kleinem Umfange in Verlag zu nehmen. Diese Kenntniss hat mich auch bewogen, meine Abhandlung über Stetigkeit und irrationale Zahlen durchaus auf meine Kosten drucken zu lassen, obgleich ich dem Viewegschen Verlage unzählige kleine Gefälligkeiten erwiesen hatte. Der Vertrieb ist dann, wie es scheint, ein äußerst lästiger gewesen; man hat sich wahrscheinlich nicht einmal die Mühe gegeben (ich freilich auch nicht), die Schrift an irgend eine kritische Zeitschrift zu versenden, und ich habe selten oder gar nicht bemerkt, daß die Schrift auf den Umschlägen der Vieweg'schen Bücher angezeigt wäre; nachdem Vieweg die Druckkosten u. s. w. erhalten, bekommt er von jedem verkauften Exemplar die Hälfte des Preises.
	Aus diesen Gründen, namentlich aber wegen der äußerst geringen Verbreitung, die Ihre Abhandlung erfahren würde, wenn sie in ähnlicher Weise von Vieweg behandelt würde, kann ich Ihnen nicht sehr zurathen, sich darauf einzulassen. Sobald Sie es aber doch wünschen, werde ich gern Alles thun, um die günstigsten Bedingungen für Sie bei Vieweg zu erwirken. Es ist sehr unangenehm, wenn die Veröffentlichung im Journal sich verzögert ; aber dafür gewährt dies Journal mehr als jedes andere die Gewißheit, daß ein in ihm niedergelegter Gedanke die größte Verbreitung erfährt. Deshalb und auch in Rücksicht auf künftige Fälle möchte ich Ihnen mehr dazu rathen, Ihre Abhandlung nicht zurückzuziehen. Auf meine vollständige Verschwiegenheit dürfen Sie sich in jedem Falle verlassen."(Dedkind, 14 Nov 1877)

The small readership is Dedekind's main argument. That's not quite the same as pushing Cantor's paper at Crelle.

> It is true that doubts arose due to paradoxes in early set theory, but Dedekind didn’t seem to renounce set theory, rather he seems to have worked to try and fix it. 

Here is what he should have recognized: Every Dedekind-cut needs a finite description. There are only countably many finite descriptions.

Or this: Every real number is the limit of (at least) one Cauchy-sequence of rational numbers. Different real numbers have different Cauchy-sequences. (It is impossible that one and the same Cauchy sequence has two different real limits.)  Therefore every limit has at least one rational term different from every other limit. Therefore there cannot be more real limits than rational terms.

> The Dedekind quote provided by Professor Mueckenheim in his 366 page document:Transfinity: a source book, 
> 
> “the numbers are free creations of the human mind” 
> 
> does not seem to commit Dedekind to a philosophy of mathematics that is sceptical of the actual infinite. The word “free” seems to play an important role here. 

The word "creation" seems to play an important role too.
> 
> As an illustration: if Dedekind believed that potential infinity was the only valid use of infinity in mathematical argumentation, then it would be mysterious that he did not produce a version of real analysis along constructivist lines similar to Errett Bishop, which gives quite a different presentation of results such as the Intermediate Value Theorem. 

Couldn't it be that at those times the difference between infinities had  not yet been completely understood? Of course Cantor had! - but all the others? Unfortunately even modern set theorists are boasting that they don't know the difference or that potential infinity does not exist. "You use terms like completed versus potential infinity, which are not part of the modern vernacular." [P.L. Clark, https://www.hs-augsburg.de/~mueckenh/Transfinity/Transfinity/pdf, p. 11]

Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#517466

FromMostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com>
Date2021-04-11 09:37 -0700
Message-ID<bbad7e93-d0c1-4d5d-8aeb-dae5211a11ccn@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#517465
Recent history of set theory didn't deal with arcane notion such
as "You use terms like completed versus potential infinity, 
which are not part of the modern vernacular."

Other notions were already formed, probably starting with
Peano who used the term "class". In a nutshell the modern
development went along these lines:

"The notion of a collection is as old as counting, and
logical ideas about classes have existed since at
least the “tree of Porphyry” (3rd century CE). Thus it
becomes difficult to sort out the origins of the concept
of set. But sets are neither collections in the everyday
sense of this word, nor “classes” in the sense of logicians
before the mid-19th century. The key missing element
is objecthood — a set is a mathematical object, to be
operated upon just like any other object (the set N is as
much ‘a thing’ as number 3). To clarify this point, Russell
employed the useful distinction between a class-as-many
(this is the traditional idea) and a class-as-one (or set)."
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/settheory-early/ 

WM schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 18:27:17 UTC+2:
> Quantum Bubbles schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 15:12:54 UTC+2: 
> 
> > I thank Professor Mueckenheim for taking the time to respond to my comment.
> It was a pleasure.
> > There are various arguments that could be given for my position, but a good starting point I think is that it seems contrary to the role he is regarded in playing in the development of early set theory:
> Of course Dedeking did quite a lot there.
> > 
> > and in his support for Cantor, such as persuading Cantor not to withdraw one of his most amazing papers that explicitly involved the actual infinite.
> Things are not as straight as Wikipedia presents them. 
> 
> Dedekind first warned Cantor not to publish his finding without carefully realizing and mentioning the implications of complety interrupting the continuity of the square: 
> "die Ausfüllung der Lücken zwingt Sie, eine grauenhafte, Schwindel erregende Unstetigkeit in der Correspondenz eintreten zu lassen, durch welche Alles in Atome aufgelöst wird, so dass jeder noch so kleine stetig zusammenhängende Theil des einen Gebietes in seinem Bilde als durchaus zerrissen, unstetig erscheint. 
> Ich hoffe, mich deutlich genug ausgedrückt zu haben ; die Absicht meines Schreibens besteht nur darin Sie zu bitten, nicht ohne eine gründliche Prüfung meines Einwandes gegen die bisher für wahr gehaltenen Glaubensartikel der Mannigfaltigkeitslehre öffentlich zu polemisieren." [Dedekind, 2 Jul 1877] 
> 
> When Cantor asked Dedekind for supporting a publication at Vieweg, Dedekind's publisher, Dedekind explained the problems arising there (he himself had payed the printing expenses of his book and Vieweg was reluctant to publish small pieces like Cantor's paper) and the small readership to be expected. 
> 
> "Für den Fall, daß Sie Ihre Arbeit dem Journal für Mathematik ganz entziehen und als besondere Schrift erscheinen lassen wollten, werde ich mir gewiß gern Mühe geben, dieselbe bei Vieweg als Verlags-Artikel zu empfehlen. Allein ich weiß im Voraus, daß ich dabei auf Schwierigkeiten stoßen würde ; schon seit langen Jahren habe ich Vieweg oder seine Vertreter in gelegentlichen Gesprächen die größte Abneigung aussprechen hören, Schriften von so kleinem Umfange in Verlag zu nehmen. Diese Kenntniss hat mich auch bewogen, meine Abhandlung über Stetigkeit und irrationale Zahlen durchaus auf meine Kosten drucken zu lassen, obgleich ich dem Viewegschen Verlage unzählige kleine Gefälligkeiten erwiesen hatte. Der Vertrieb ist dann, wie es scheint, ein äußerst lästiger gewesen; man hat sich wahrscheinlich nicht einmal die Mühe gegeben (ich freilich auch nicht), die Schrift an irgend eine kritische Zeitschrift zu versenden, und ich habe selten oder gar nicht bemerkt, daß die Schrift auf den Umschlägen der Vieweg'schen Bücher angezeigt wäre; nachdem Vieweg die Druckkosten u. s. w. erhalten, bekommt er von jedem verkauften Exemplar die Hälfte des Preises. 
> Aus diesen Gründen, namentlich aber wegen der äußerst geringen Verbreitung, die Ihre Abhandlung erfahren würde, wenn sie in ähnlicher Weise von Vieweg behandelt würde, kann ich Ihnen nicht sehr zurathen, sich darauf einzulassen. Sobald Sie es aber doch wünschen, werde ich gern Alles thun, um die günstigsten Bedingungen für Sie bei Vieweg zu erwirken. Es ist sehr unangenehm, wenn die Veröffentlichung im Journal sich verzögert ; aber dafür gewährt dies Journal mehr als jedes andere die Gewißheit, daß ein in ihm niedergelegter Gedanke die größte Verbreitung erfährt. Deshalb und auch in Rücksicht auf künftige Fälle möchte ich Ihnen mehr dazu rathen, Ihre Abhandlung nicht zurückzuziehen. Auf meine vollständige Verschwiegenheit dürfen Sie sich in jedem Falle verlassen."(Dedkind, 14 Nov 1877) 
> 
> The small readership is Dedekind's main argument. That's not quite the same as pushing Cantor's paper at Crelle.
> > It is true that doubts arose due to paradoxes in early set theory, but Dedekind didn’t seem to renounce set theory, rather he seems to have worked to try and fix it.
> Here is what he should have recognized: Every Dedekind-cut needs a finite description. There are only countably many finite descriptions. 
> 
> Or this: Every real number is the limit of (at least) one Cauchy-sequence of rational numbers. Different real numbers have different Cauchy-sequences. (It is impossible that one and the same Cauchy sequence has two different real limits.) Therefore every limit has at least one rational term different from every other limit. Therefore there cannot be more real limits than rational terms.
> > The Dedekind quote provided by Professor Mueckenheim in his 366 page document:Transfinity: a source book, 
> > 
> > “the numbers are free creations of the human mind” 
> > 
> > does not seem to commit Dedekind to a philosophy of mathematics that is sceptical of the actual infinite. The word “free” seems to play an important role here.
> The word "creation" seems to play an important role too.
> > 
> > As an illustration: if Dedekind believed that potential infinity was the only valid use of infinity in mathematical argumentation, then it would be mysterious that he did not produce a version of real analysis along constructivist lines similar to Errett Bishop, which gives quite a different presentation of results such as the Intermediate Value Theorem.
> Couldn't it be that at those times the difference between infinities had not yet been completely understood? Of course Cantor had! - but all the others? Unfortunately even modern set theorists are boasting that they don't know the difference or that potential infinity does not exist. "You use terms like completed versus potential infinity, which are not part of the modern vernacular." [P.L. Clark, https://www.hs-augsburg.de/~mueckenh/Transfinity/Transfinity/pdf, p. 11] 
> 
> Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#517468

FromMostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com>
Date2021-04-11 09:41 -0700
Message-ID<82818c1a-5fce-4991-9c60-1a956a79b047n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#517466
The first class logic in the strict sense was created by Giuseppe Peano 
in 1889 as the basis for his arithmetic (Peano Axioms). He introduced 
the class term, which formally correctly describes classes through a 
property of their elements. Today the class term is denoted in the form 
{x|A(x)}, where A(x) is an arbitrary statement, which all class members 
x meet. Peano axiomatized the class term for the first time and used it fully.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Class_logic

Mostowski Collapse schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 18:37:48 UTC+2:
> Recent history of set theory didn't deal with arcane notion such 
> as "You use terms like completed versus potential infinity,
> which are not part of the modern vernacular."
> Other notions were already formed, probably starting with 
> Peano who used the term "class". In a nutshell the modern 
> development went along these lines: 
> 
> "The notion of a collection is as old as counting, and 
> logical ideas about classes have existed since at 
> least the “tree of Porphyry” (3rd century CE). Thus it 
> becomes difficult to sort out the origins of the concept 
> of set. But sets are neither collections in the everyday 
> sense of this word, nor “classes” in the sense of logicians 
> before the mid-19th century. The key missing element 
> is objecthood — a set is a mathematical object, to be 
> operated upon just like any other object (the set N is as 
> much ‘a thing’ as number 3). To clarify this point, Russell 
> employed the useful distinction between a class-as-many 
> (this is the traditional idea) and a class-as-one (or set)." 
> https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/settheory-early/
> WM schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 18:27:17 UTC+2: 
> > Quantum Bubbles schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 15:12:54 UTC+2: 
> > 
> > > I thank Professor Mueckenheim for taking the time to respond to my comment. 
> > It was a pleasure. 
> > > There are various arguments that could be given for my position, but a good starting point I think is that it seems contrary to the role he is regarded in playing in the development of early set theory: 
> > Of course Dedeking did quite a lot there. 
> > > 
> > > and in his support for Cantor, such as persuading Cantor not to withdraw one of his most amazing papers that explicitly involved the actual infinite. 
> > Things are not as straight as Wikipedia presents them. 
> > 
> > Dedekind first warned Cantor not to publish his finding without carefully realizing and mentioning the implications of complety interrupting the continuity of the square: 
> > "die Ausfüllung der Lücken zwingt Sie, eine grauenhafte, Schwindel erregende Unstetigkeit in der Correspondenz eintreten zu lassen, durch welche Alles in Atome aufgelöst wird, so dass jeder noch so kleine stetig zusammenhängende Theil des einen Gebietes in seinem Bilde als durchaus zerrissen, unstetig erscheint. 
> > Ich hoffe, mich deutlich genug ausgedrückt zu haben ; die Absicht meines Schreibens besteht nur darin Sie zu bitten, nicht ohne eine gründliche Prüfung meines Einwandes gegen die bisher für wahr gehaltenen Glaubensartikel der Mannigfaltigkeitslehre öffentlich zu polemisieren." [Dedekind, 2 Jul 1877] 
> > 
> > When Cantor asked Dedekind for supporting a publication at Vieweg, Dedekind's publisher, Dedekind explained the problems arising there (he himself had payed the printing expenses of his book and Vieweg was reluctant to publish small pieces like Cantor's paper) and the small readership to be expected. 
> > 
> > "Für den Fall, daß Sie Ihre Arbeit dem Journal für Mathematik ganz entziehen und als besondere Schrift erscheinen lassen wollten, werde ich mir gewiß gern Mühe geben, dieselbe bei Vieweg als Verlags-Artikel zu empfehlen. Allein ich weiß im Voraus, daß ich dabei auf Schwierigkeiten stoßen würde ; schon seit langen Jahren habe ich Vieweg oder seine Vertreter in gelegentlichen Gesprächen die größte Abneigung aussprechen hören, Schriften von so kleinem Umfange in Verlag zu nehmen. Diese Kenntniss hat mich auch bewogen, meine Abhandlung über Stetigkeit und irrationale Zahlen durchaus auf meine Kosten drucken zu lassen, obgleich ich dem Viewegschen Verlage unzählige kleine Gefälligkeiten erwiesen hatte. Der Vertrieb ist dann, wie es scheint, ein äußerst lästiger gewesen; man hat sich wahrscheinlich nicht einmal die Mühe gegeben (ich freilich auch nicht), die Schrift an irgend eine kritische Zeitschrift zu versenden, und ich habe selten oder gar nicht bemerkt, daß die Schrift auf den Umschlägen der Vieweg'schen Bücher angezeigt wäre; nachdem Vieweg die Druckkosten u. s. w. erhalten, bekommt er von jedem verkauften Exemplar die Hälfte des Preises. 
> > Aus diesen Gründen, namentlich aber wegen der äußerst geringen Verbreitung, die Ihre Abhandlung erfahren würde, wenn sie in ähnlicher Weise von Vieweg behandelt würde, kann ich Ihnen nicht sehr zurathen, sich darauf einzulassen. Sobald Sie es aber doch wünschen, werde ich gern Alles thun, um die günstigsten Bedingungen für Sie bei Vieweg zu erwirken. Es ist sehr unangenehm, wenn die Veröffentlichung im Journal sich verzögert ; aber dafür gewährt dies Journal mehr als jedes andere die Gewißheit, daß ein in ihm niedergelegter Gedanke die größte Verbreitung erfährt. Deshalb und auch in Rücksicht auf künftige Fälle möchte ich Ihnen mehr dazu rathen, Ihre Abhandlung nicht zurückzuziehen. Auf meine vollständige Verschwiegenheit dürfen Sie sich in jedem Falle verlassen."(Dedkind, 14 Nov 1877) 
> > 
> > The small readership is Dedekind's main argument. That's not quite the same as pushing Cantor's paper at Crelle. 
> > > It is true that doubts arose due to paradoxes in early set theory, but Dedekind didn’t seem to renounce set theory, rather he seems to have worked to try and fix it. 
> > Here is what he should have recognized: Every Dedekind-cut needs a finite description. There are only countably many finite descriptions. 
> > 
> > Or this: Every real number is the limit of (at least) one Cauchy-sequence of rational numbers. Different real numbers have different Cauchy-sequences. (It is impossible that one and the same Cauchy sequence has two different real limits.) Therefore every limit has at least one rational term different from every other limit. Therefore there cannot be more real limits than rational terms. 
> > > The Dedekind quote provided by Professor Mueckenheim in his 366 page document:Transfinity: a source book, 
> > > 
> > > “the numbers are free creations of the human mind” 
> > > 
> > > does not seem to commit Dedekind to a philosophy of mathematics that is sceptical of the actual infinite. The word “free” seems to play an important role here. 
> > The word "creation" seems to play an important role too. 
> > > 
> > > As an illustration: if Dedekind believed that potential infinity was the only valid use of infinity in mathematical argumentation, then it would be mysterious that he did not produce a version of real analysis along constructivist lines similar to Errett Bishop, which gives quite a different presentation of results such as the Intermediate Value Theorem. 
> > Couldn't it be that at those times the difference between infinities had not yet been completely understood? Of course Cantor had! - but all the others? Unfortunately even modern set theorists are boasting that they don't know the difference or that potential infinity does not exist. "You use terms like completed versus potential infinity, which are not part of the modern vernacular." [P.L. Clark, https://www.hs-augsburg.de/~mueckenh/Transfinity/Transfinity/pdf, p. 11] 
> > 
> > Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#517469

FromMostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com>
Date2021-04-11 09:48 -0700
Message-ID<174c5acc-c4b9-4ce5-81f4-ac5a21d9f108n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#517468
Also you typically apply separation of concern. Classes can be
also finite. So the combination "potential infinite" does mix two
concerns, this is why it should be avoided.

Mostowski Collapse schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 18:41:17 UTC+2:
> The first class logic in the strict sense was created by Giuseppe Peano 
> in 1889 as the basis for his arithmetic (Peano Axioms). He introduced 
> the class term, which formally correctly describes classes through a 
> property of their elements. Today the class term is denoted in the form 
> {x|A(x)}, where A(x) is an arbitrary statement, which all class members 
> x meet. Peano axiomatized the class term for the first time and used it fully. 
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Class_logic
> Mostowski Collapse schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 18:37:48 UTC+2: 
> > Recent history of set theory didn't deal with arcane notion such 
> > as "You use terms like completed versus potential infinity, 
> > which are not part of the modern vernacular." 
> > Other notions were already formed, probably starting with 
> > Peano who used the term "class". In a nutshell the modern 
> > development went along these lines: 
> > 
> > "The notion of a collection is as old as counting, and 
> > logical ideas about classes have existed since at 
> > least the “tree of Porphyry” (3rd century CE). Thus it 
> > becomes difficult to sort out the origins of the concept 
> > of set. But sets are neither collections in the everyday 
> > sense of this word, nor “classes” in the sense of logicians 
> > before the mid-19th century. The key missing element 
> > is objecthood — a set is a mathematical object, to be 
> > operated upon just like any other object (the set N is as 
> > much ‘a thing’ as number 3). To clarify this point, Russell 
> > employed the useful distinction between a class-as-many 
> > (this is the traditional idea) and a class-as-one (or set)." 
> > https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/settheory-early/ 
> > WM schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 18:27:17 UTC+2: 
> > > Quantum Bubbles schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 15:12:54 UTC+2: 
> > > 
> > > > I thank Professor Mueckenheim for taking the time to respond to my comment. 
> > > It was a pleasure. 
> > > > There are various arguments that could be given for my position, but a good starting point I think is that it seems contrary to the role he is regarded in playing in the development of early set theory: 
> > > Of course Dedeking did quite a lot there. 
> > > > 
> > > > and in his support for Cantor, such as persuading Cantor not to withdraw one of his most amazing papers that explicitly involved the actual infinite. 
> > > Things are not as straight as Wikipedia presents them. 
> > > 
> > > Dedekind first warned Cantor not to publish his finding without carefully realizing and mentioning the implications of complety interrupting the continuity of the square: 
> > > "die Ausfüllung der Lücken zwingt Sie, eine grauenhafte, Schwindel erregende Unstetigkeit in der Correspondenz eintreten zu lassen, durch welche Alles in Atome aufgelöst wird, so dass jeder noch so kleine stetig zusammenhängende Theil des einen Gebietes in seinem Bilde als durchaus zerrissen, unstetig erscheint. 
> > > Ich hoffe, mich deutlich genug ausgedrückt zu haben ; die Absicht meines Schreibens besteht nur darin Sie zu bitten, nicht ohne eine gründliche Prüfung meines Einwandes gegen die bisher für wahr gehaltenen Glaubensartikel der Mannigfaltigkeitslehre öffentlich zu polemisieren." [Dedekind, 2 Jul 1877] 
> > > 
> > > When Cantor asked Dedekind for supporting a publication at Vieweg, Dedekind's publisher, Dedekind explained the problems arising there (he himself had payed the printing expenses of his book and Vieweg was reluctant to publish small pieces like Cantor's paper) and the small readership to be expected. 
> > > 
> > > "Für den Fall, daß Sie Ihre Arbeit dem Journal für Mathematik ganz entziehen und als besondere Schrift erscheinen lassen wollten, werde ich mir gewiß gern Mühe geben, dieselbe bei Vieweg als Verlags-Artikel zu empfehlen. Allein ich weiß im Voraus, daß ich dabei auf Schwierigkeiten stoßen würde ; schon seit langen Jahren habe ich Vieweg oder seine Vertreter in gelegentlichen Gesprächen die größte Abneigung aussprechen hören, Schriften von so kleinem Umfange in Verlag zu nehmen. Diese Kenntniss hat mich auch bewogen, meine Abhandlung über Stetigkeit und irrationale Zahlen durchaus auf meine Kosten drucken zu lassen, obgleich ich dem Viewegschen Verlage unzählige kleine Gefälligkeiten erwiesen hatte. Der Vertrieb ist dann, wie es scheint, ein äußerst lästiger gewesen; man hat sich wahrscheinlich nicht einmal die Mühe gegeben (ich freilich auch nicht), die Schrift an irgend eine kritische Zeitschrift zu versenden, und ich habe selten oder gar nicht bemerkt, daß die Schrift auf den Umschlägen der Vieweg'schen Bücher angezeigt wäre; nachdem Vieweg die Druckkosten u. s. w. erhalten, bekommt er von jedem verkauften Exemplar die Hälfte des Preises. 
> > > Aus diesen Gründen, namentlich aber wegen der äußerst geringen Verbreitung, die Ihre Abhandlung erfahren würde, wenn sie in ähnlicher Weise von Vieweg behandelt würde, kann ich Ihnen nicht sehr zurathen, sich darauf einzulassen. Sobald Sie es aber doch wünschen, werde ich gern Alles thun, um die günstigsten Bedingungen für Sie bei Vieweg zu erwirken. Es ist sehr unangenehm, wenn die Veröffentlichung im Journal sich verzögert ; aber dafür gewährt dies Journal mehr als jedes andere die Gewißheit, daß ein in ihm niedergelegter Gedanke die größte Verbreitung erfährt. Deshalb und auch in Rücksicht auf künftige Fälle möchte ich Ihnen mehr dazu rathen, Ihre Abhandlung nicht zurückzuziehen. Auf meine vollständige Verschwiegenheit dürfen Sie sich in jedem Falle verlassen."(Dedkind, 14 Nov 1877) 
> > > 
> > > The small readership is Dedekind's main argument. That's not quite the same as pushing Cantor's paper at Crelle. 
> > > > It is true that doubts arose due to paradoxes in early set theory, but Dedekind didn’t seem to renounce set theory, rather he seems to have worked to try and fix it. 
> > > Here is what he should have recognized: Every Dedekind-cut needs a finite description. There are only countably many finite descriptions. 
> > > 
> > > Or this: Every real number is the limit of (at least) one Cauchy-sequence of rational numbers. Different real numbers have different Cauchy-sequences. (It is impossible that one and the same Cauchy sequence has two different real limits.) Therefore every limit has at least one rational term different from every other limit. Therefore there cannot be more real limits than rational terms. 
> > > > The Dedekind quote provided by Professor Mueckenheim in his 366 page document:Transfinity: a source book, 
> > > > 
> > > > “the numbers are free creations of the human mind” 
> > > > 
> > > > does not seem to commit Dedekind to a philosophy of mathematics that is sceptical of the actual infinite. The word “free” seems to play an important role here. 
> > > The word "creation" seems to play an important role too. 
> > > > 
> > > > As an illustration: if Dedekind believed that potential infinity was the only valid use of infinity in mathematical argumentation, then it would be mysterious that he did not produce a version of real analysis along constructivist lines similar to Errett Bishop, which gives quite a different presentation of results such as the Intermediate Value Theorem. 
> > > Couldn't it be that at those times the difference between infinities had not yet been completely understood? Of course Cantor had! - but all the others? Unfortunately even modern set theorists are boasting that they don't know the difference or that potential infinity does not exist. "You use terms like completed versus potential infinity, which are not part of the modern vernacular." [P.L. Clark, https://www.hs-augsburg.de/~mueckenh/Transfinity/Transfinity/pdf, p. 11] 
> > > 
> > > Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#517480

FromEram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com>
Date2021-04-11 10:57 -0700
Message-ID<c2f9811a-a75f-45d8-a1a2-6d70689bbd26n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#517465
On Sunday, 11 April 2021 at 12:27:17 UTC-4, WM wrote:
> Quantum Bubbles schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 15:12:54 UTC+2: 
> 
> > I thank Professor Mueckenheim for taking the time to respond to my comment.
> It was a pleasure.
> > There are various arguments that could be given for my position, but a good starting point I think is that it seems contrary to the role he is regarded in playing in the development of early set theory:
> Of course Dedeking did quite a lot there.
> > 
> > and in his support for Cantor, such as persuading Cantor not to withdraw one of his most amazing papers that explicitly involved the actual infinite.
> Things are not as straight as Wikipedia presents them. 
> 
> Dedekind first warned Cantor not to publish his finding without carefully realizing and mentioning the implications of complety interrupting the continuity of the square: 
> "die Ausfüllung der Lücken zwingt Sie, eine grauenhafte, Schwindel erregende Unstetigkeit in der Correspondenz eintreten zu lassen, durch welche Alles in Atome aufgelöst wird, so dass jeder noch so kleine stetig zusammenhängende Theil des einen Gebietes in seinem Bilde als durchaus zerrissen, unstetig erscheint. 
> Ich hoffe, mich deutlich genug ausgedrückt zu haben ; die Absicht meines Schreibens besteht nur darin Sie zu bitten, nicht ohne eine gründliche Prüfung meines Einwandes gegen die bisher für wahr gehaltenen Glaubensartikel der Mannigfaltigkeitslehre öffentlich zu polemisieren." [Dedekind, 2 Jul 1877] 
> 
> When Cantor asked Dedekind for supporting a publication at Vieweg, Dedekind's publisher, Dedekind explained the problems arising there (he himself had payed the printing expenses of his book and Vieweg was reluctant to publish small pieces like Cantor's paper) and the small readership to be expected. 
> 
> "Für den Fall, daß Sie Ihre Arbeit dem Journal für Mathematik ganz entziehen und als besondere Schrift erscheinen lassen wollten, werde ich mir gewiß gern Mühe geben, dieselbe bei Vieweg als Verlags-Artikel zu empfehlen. Allein ich weiß im Voraus, daß ich dabei auf Schwierigkeiten stoßen würde ; schon seit langen Jahren habe ich Vieweg oder seine Vertreter in gelegentlichen Gesprächen die größte Abneigung aussprechen hören, Schriften von so kleinem Umfange in Verlag zu nehmen. Diese Kenntniss hat mich auch bewogen, meine Abhandlung über Stetigkeit und irrationale Zahlen durchaus auf meine Kosten drucken zu lassen, obgleich ich dem Viewegschen Verlage unzählige kleine Gefälligkeiten erwiesen hatte. Der Vertrieb ist dann, wie es scheint, ein äußerst lästiger gewesen; man hat sich wahrscheinlich nicht einmal die Mühe gegeben (ich freilich auch nicht), die Schrift an irgend eine kritische Zeitschrift zu versenden, und ich habe selten oder gar nicht bemerkt, daß die Schrift auf den Umschlägen der Vieweg'schen Bücher angezeigt wäre; nachdem Vieweg die Druckkosten u. s. w. erhalten, bekommt er von jedem verkauften Exemplar die Hälfte des Preises. 
> Aus diesen Gründen, namentlich aber wegen der äußerst geringen Verbreitung, die Ihre Abhandlung erfahren würde, wenn sie in ähnlicher Weise von Vieweg behandelt würde, kann ich Ihnen nicht sehr zurathen, sich darauf einzulassen. Sobald Sie es aber doch wünschen, werde ich gern Alles thun, um die günstigsten Bedingungen für Sie bei Vieweg zu erwirken. Es ist sehr unangenehm, wenn die Veröffentlichung im Journal sich verzögert ; aber dafür gewährt dies Journal mehr als jedes andere die Gewißheit, daß ein in ihm niedergelegter Gedanke die größte Verbreitung erfährt. Deshalb und auch in Rücksicht auf künftige Fälle möchte ich Ihnen mehr dazu rathen, Ihre Abhandlung nicht zurückzuziehen. Auf meine vollständige Verschwiegenheit dürfen Sie sich in jedem Falle verlassen."(Dedkind, 14 Nov 1877) 
> 
> The small readership is Dedekind's main argument. That's not quite the same as pushing Cantor's paper at Crelle.
> > It is true that doubts arose due to paradoxes in early set theory, but Dedekind didn’t seem to renounce set theory, rather he seems to have worked to try and fix it.
> Here is what he should have recognized: Every Dedekind-cut needs a finite description. 

Dedekind cuts are stated with a fixed number of symbols, you pathetic crank! "Finite description" is a phrase that just makes you look more stupid every time you use it.

> There are only countably many finite descriptions. 
> 
> Or this: Every real number is the limit of (at least) one Cauchy-sequence of rational numbers. 

How is this ANY different from a Dedekind Cut? It is in principle exactly the same thing!

Look moron:

Given a cut (L,H) where L is the lower set and H is the upper set, it is pretty clear that the lower set converges to some limit, in other words, NO DIFFERENT to a converging sequence (no need to call this Cauchy because Cauchy is of zero importance in this respect).

Now IF a converging sequence represents some imaginary "real number", then ALL real numbers are by definition rational. How many times have you yourself said that the limit may not be part of the sequence?? Cherry picking is a typical crank attribute.

So the sequence 0.3; 0.33; 0.333; ... converges to a rational number 1/3, but this does not mean that the "real number" 1/3 is represented by 0.333... as a bullshit infinite decimal expansion. After all, 1/3 DOES NOT even have a measure in base 10, you silly man!

The sequence 3.14159... does not represent any number, because if it did, then whatever is the limit, it cannot be a number of any kind, but some immeasurable magnitude.

> Different real numbers have different Cauchy-sequences. (It is impossible that one and the same Cauchy sequence has two different real limits.) Therefore every limit has at least one rational term different from every other limit. Therefore there cannot be more real limits than rational terms.

And your point here is what exactly? Ah, you don't have a point.

> > The Dedekind quote provided by Professor Mueckenheim in his 366 page document:Transfinity: a source book, 

> > 
> > “the numbers are free creations of the human mind” 

Whoever said this, is an absolute imbecile who knows nothing about psychology or even the human mind, much less anything about philosophy.

> > 
> > does not seem to commit Dedekind to a philosophy of mathematics that is sceptical of the actual infinite. The word “free” seems to play an important role here.
> The word "creation" seems to play an important role too.
> > 
> > As an illustration: if Dedekind believed that potential infinity was the only valid use of infinity in mathematical argumentation, then it would be mysterious that he did not produce a version of real analysis along constructivist lines similar to Errett Bishop, which gives quite a different presentation of results such as the Intermediate Value Theorem.
> Couldn't it be that at those times the difference between infinities had not yet been completely understood? Of course Cantor had! - but all the others? Unfortunately even modern set theorists are boasting that they don't know the difference or that potential infinity does not exist. "You use terms like completed versus potential infinity, which are not part of the modern vernacular." [P.L. Clark, https://www.hs-augsburg.de/~mueckenh/Transfinity/Transfinity/pdf, p. 11] 
> 
> Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#517500

FromMostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com>
Date2021-04-11 12:37 -0700
Message-ID<2d1aef5e-cc4a-4189-b103-fa6e1fdbde05n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#517480
A Cauchy Sequence (p1,p2,p3,...) and a Dedekind Cut (L,H) are
not directly the same. Take to rational numbers p and q from L.
There are infinitely many rational numbers r such that

p < r and r < q also in L. But for a Cauchy Sequence with p=pj
and q=pk there are only finitely many r=pi with j < i and i < k.
You need to adjust your mental picture, you don't seem to 

understand the idea of a Cauchy Sequence or Dedekind Cut or both.

Eram semper recta schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 19:57:31 UTC+2:
> On Sunday, 11 April 2021 at 12:27:17 UTC-4, WM wrote: 
> > Quantum Bubbles schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 15:12:54 UTC+2: 
> > 
> > > I thank Professor Mueckenheim for taking the time to respond to my comment. 
> > It was a pleasure. 
> > > There are various arguments that could be given for my position, but a good starting point I think is that it seems contrary to the role he is regarded in playing in the development of early set theory: 
> > Of course Dedeking did quite a lot there. 
> > > 
> > > and in his support for Cantor, such as persuading Cantor not to withdraw one of his most amazing papers that explicitly involved the actual infinite. 
> > Things are not as straight as Wikipedia presents them. 
> > 
> > Dedekind first warned Cantor not to publish his finding without carefully realizing and mentioning the implications of complety interrupting the continuity of the square: 
> > "die Ausfüllung der Lücken zwingt Sie, eine grauenhafte, Schwindel erregende Unstetigkeit in der Correspondenz eintreten zu lassen, durch welche Alles in Atome aufgelöst wird, so dass jeder noch so kleine stetig zusammenhängende Theil des einen Gebietes in seinem Bilde als durchaus zerrissen, unstetig erscheint. 
> > Ich hoffe, mich deutlich genug ausgedrückt zu haben ; die Absicht meines Schreibens besteht nur darin Sie zu bitten, nicht ohne eine gründliche Prüfung meines Einwandes gegen die bisher für wahr gehaltenen Glaubensartikel der Mannigfaltigkeitslehre öffentlich zu polemisieren." [Dedekind, 2 Jul 1877] 
> > 
> > When Cantor asked Dedekind for supporting a publication at Vieweg, Dedekind's publisher, Dedekind explained the problems arising there (he himself had payed the printing expenses of his book and Vieweg was reluctant to publish small pieces like Cantor's paper) and the small readership to be expected. 
> > 
> > "Für den Fall, daß Sie Ihre Arbeit dem Journal für Mathematik ganz entziehen und als besondere Schrift erscheinen lassen wollten, werde ich mir gewiß gern Mühe geben, dieselbe bei Vieweg als Verlags-Artikel zu empfehlen. Allein ich weiß im Voraus, daß ich dabei auf Schwierigkeiten stoßen würde ; schon seit langen Jahren habe ich Vieweg oder seine Vertreter in gelegentlichen Gesprächen die größte Abneigung aussprechen hören, Schriften von so kleinem Umfange in Verlag zu nehmen. Diese Kenntniss hat mich auch bewogen, meine Abhandlung über Stetigkeit und irrationale Zahlen durchaus auf meine Kosten drucken zu lassen, obgleich ich dem Viewegschen Verlage unzählige kleine Gefälligkeiten erwiesen hatte. Der Vertrieb ist dann, wie es scheint, ein äußerst lästiger gewesen; man hat sich wahrscheinlich nicht einmal die Mühe gegeben (ich freilich auch nicht), die Schrift an irgend eine kritische Zeitschrift zu versenden, und ich habe selten oder gar nicht bemerkt, daß die Schrift auf den Umschlägen der Vieweg'schen Bücher angezeigt wäre; nachdem Vieweg die Druckkosten u. s. w. erhalten, bekommt er von jedem verkauften Exemplar die Hälfte des Preises. 
> > Aus diesen Gründen, namentlich aber wegen der äußerst geringen Verbreitung, die Ihre Abhandlung erfahren würde, wenn sie in ähnlicher Weise von Vieweg behandelt würde, kann ich Ihnen nicht sehr zurathen, sich darauf einzulassen. Sobald Sie es aber doch wünschen, werde ich gern Alles thun, um die günstigsten Bedingungen für Sie bei Vieweg zu erwirken. Es ist sehr unangenehm, wenn die Veröffentlichung im Journal sich verzögert ; aber dafür gewährt dies Journal mehr als jedes andere die Gewißheit, daß ein in ihm niedergelegter Gedanke die größte Verbreitung erfährt. Deshalb und auch in Rücksicht auf künftige Fälle möchte ich Ihnen mehr dazu rathen, Ihre Abhandlung nicht zurückzuziehen. Auf meine vollständige Verschwiegenheit dürfen Sie sich in jedem Falle verlassen."(Dedkind, 14 Nov 1877) 
> > 
> > The small readership is Dedekind's main argument. That's not quite the same as pushing Cantor's paper at Crelle. 
> > > It is true that doubts arose due to paradoxes in early set theory, but Dedekind didn’t seem to renounce set theory, rather he seems to have worked to try and fix it. 
> > Here is what he should have recognized: Every Dedekind-cut needs a finite description.
> Dedekind cuts are stated with a fixed number of symbols, you pathetic crank! "Finite description" is a phrase that just makes you look more stupid every time you use it.
> > There are only countably many finite descriptions. 
> > 
> > Or this: Every real number is the limit of (at least) one Cauchy-sequence of rational numbers.
> How is this ANY different from a Dedekind Cut? It is in principle exactly the same thing! 
> 
> Look moron: 
> 
> Given a cut (L,H) where L is the lower set and H is the upper set, it is pretty clear that the lower set converges to some limit, in other words, NO DIFFERENT to a converging sequence (no need to call this Cauchy because Cauchy is of zero importance in this respect). 
> 
> Now IF a converging sequence represents some imaginary "real number", then ALL real numbers are by definition rational. How many times have you yourself said that the limit may not be part of the sequence?? Cherry picking is a typical crank attribute. 
> 
> So the sequence 0.3; 0.33; 0.333; ... converges to a rational number 1/3, but this does not mean that the "real number" 1/3 is represented by 0.333... as a bullshit infinite decimal expansion. After all, 1/3 DOES NOT even have a measure in base 10, you silly man! 
> 
> The sequence 3.14159... does not represent any number, because if it did, then whatever is the limit, it cannot be a number of any kind, but some immeasurable magnitude.
> > Different real numbers have different Cauchy-sequences. (It is impossible that one and the same Cauchy sequence has two different real limits.) Therefore every limit has at least one rational term different from every other limit. Therefore there cannot be more real limits than rational terms.
> And your point here is what exactly? Ah, you don't have a point.
> > > The Dedekind quote provided by Professor Mueckenheim in his 366 page document:Transfinity: a source book, 
> 
> > > 
> > > “the numbers are free creations of the human mind”
> Whoever said this, is an absolute imbecile who knows nothing about psychology or even the human mind, much less anything about philosophy.
> > > 
> > > does not seem to commit Dedekind to a philosophy of mathematics that is sceptical of the actual infinite. The word “free” seems to play an important role here. 
> > The word "creation" seems to play an important role too. 
> > > 
> > > As an illustration: if Dedekind believed that potential infinity was the only valid use of infinity in mathematical argumentation, then it would be mysterious that he did not produce a version of real analysis along constructivist lines similar to Errett Bishop, which gives quite a different presentation of results such as the Intermediate Value Theorem. 
> > Couldn't it be that at those times the difference between infinities had not yet been completely understood? Of course Cantor had! - but all the others? Unfortunately even modern set theorists are boasting that they don't know the difference or that potential infinity does not exist. "You use terms like completed versus potential infinity, which are not part of the modern vernacular." [P.L. Clark, https://www.hs-augsburg.de/~mueckenh/Transfinity/Transfinity/pdf, p. 11] 
> > 
> > Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#517501

FromMostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com>
Date2021-04-11 12:46 -0700
Message-ID<d1dc2535-ef9a-421b-9483-e09752bc7201n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#517500
L is closed downwards:

If x , y ∈ Q, x < y, and y ∈ A, then x ∈ A. ( A is "closed downwards".)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dedekind_cut#Definition

So as soon as q in L, for any r < q, we have also r in L.
Likewise if p < r. But there are infinitely many r with p < r
and r < q. Basically you don't need to define an equivalence

relation between Dedekind Cuts anymore. The extensionality
and equality of pairs of sets (L1,H1) = (L2,H2) iff L1=L2 & H1=H2
is then enough to have an equality, which then corresponds

to equality of real numbers. For Cauchy Sequences of rational
numbers equality need to be separately defined. And real numbers 
become an equivalence classes over Cauchy Sequences.

Mostowski Collapse schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 21:37:33 UTC+2:
> A Cauchy Sequence (p1,p2,p3,...) and a Dedekind Cut (L,H) are 
> not directly the same. Take to rational numbers p and q from L. 
> There are infinitely many rational numbers r such that 
> 
> p < r and r < q also in L. But for a Cauchy Sequence with p=pj 
> and q=pk there are only finitely many r=pi with j < i and i < k. 
> You need to adjust your mental picture, you don't seem to 
> 
> understand the idea of a Cauchy Sequence or Dedekind Cut or both.
> Eram semper recta schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 19:57:31 UTC+2: 
> > On Sunday, 11 April 2021 at 12:27:17 UTC-4, WM wrote: 
> > > Quantum Bubbles schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 15:12:54 UTC+2: 
> > > 
> > > > I thank Professor Mueckenheim for taking the time to respond to my comment. 
> > > It was a pleasure. 
> > > > There are various arguments that could be given for my position, but a good starting point I think is that it seems contrary to the role he is regarded in playing in the development of early set theory: 
> > > Of course Dedeking did quite a lot there. 
> > > > 
> > > > and in his support for Cantor, such as persuading Cantor not to withdraw one of his most amazing papers that explicitly involved the actual infinite. 
> > > Things are not as straight as Wikipedia presents them. 
> > > 
> > > Dedekind first warned Cantor not to publish his finding without carefully realizing and mentioning the implications of complety interrupting the continuity of the square: 
> > > "die Ausfüllung der Lücken zwingt Sie, eine grauenhafte, Schwindel erregende Unstetigkeit in der Correspondenz eintreten zu lassen, durch welche Alles in Atome aufgelöst wird, so dass jeder noch so kleine stetig zusammenhängende Theil des einen Gebietes in seinem Bilde als durchaus zerrissen, unstetig erscheint. 
> > > Ich hoffe, mich deutlich genug ausgedrückt zu haben ; die Absicht meines Schreibens besteht nur darin Sie zu bitten, nicht ohne eine gründliche Prüfung meines Einwandes gegen die bisher für wahr gehaltenen Glaubensartikel der Mannigfaltigkeitslehre öffentlich zu polemisieren." [Dedekind, 2 Jul 1877] 
> > > 
> > > When Cantor asked Dedekind for supporting a publication at Vieweg, Dedekind's publisher, Dedekind explained the problems arising there (he himself had payed the printing expenses of his book and Vieweg was reluctant to publish small pieces like Cantor's paper) and the small readership to be expected. 
> > > 
> > > "Für den Fall, daß Sie Ihre Arbeit dem Journal für Mathematik ganz entziehen und als besondere Schrift erscheinen lassen wollten, werde ich mir gewiß gern Mühe geben, dieselbe bei Vieweg als Verlags-Artikel zu empfehlen. Allein ich weiß im Voraus, daß ich dabei auf Schwierigkeiten stoßen würde ; schon seit langen Jahren habe ich Vieweg oder seine Vertreter in gelegentlichen Gesprächen die größte Abneigung aussprechen hören, Schriften von so kleinem Umfange in Verlag zu nehmen. Diese Kenntniss hat mich auch bewogen, meine Abhandlung über Stetigkeit und irrationale Zahlen durchaus auf meine Kosten drucken zu lassen, obgleich ich dem Viewegschen Verlage unzählige kleine Gefälligkeiten erwiesen hatte. Der Vertrieb ist dann, wie es scheint, ein äußerst lästiger gewesen; man hat sich wahrscheinlich nicht einmal die Mühe gegeben (ich freilich auch nicht), die Schrift an irgend eine kritische Zeitschrift zu versenden, und ich habe selten oder gar nicht bemerkt, daß die Schrift auf den Umschlägen der Vieweg'schen Bücher angezeigt wäre; nachdem Vieweg die Druckkosten u. s. w. erhalten, bekommt er von jedem verkauften Exemplar die Hälfte des Preises. 
> > > Aus diesen Gründen, namentlich aber wegen der äußerst geringen Verbreitung, die Ihre Abhandlung erfahren würde, wenn sie in ähnlicher Weise von Vieweg behandelt würde, kann ich Ihnen nicht sehr zurathen, sich darauf einzulassen. Sobald Sie es aber doch wünschen, werde ich gern Alles thun, um die günstigsten Bedingungen für Sie bei Vieweg zu erwirken. Es ist sehr unangenehm, wenn die Veröffentlichung im Journal sich verzögert ; aber dafür gewährt dies Journal mehr als jedes andere die Gewißheit, daß ein in ihm niedergelegter Gedanke die größte Verbreitung erfährt. Deshalb und auch in Rücksicht auf künftige Fälle möchte ich Ihnen mehr dazu rathen, Ihre Abhandlung nicht zurückzuziehen. Auf meine vollständige Verschwiegenheit dürfen Sie sich in jedem Falle verlassen."(Dedkind, 14 Nov 1877) 
> > > 
> > > The small readership is Dedekind's main argument. That's not quite the same as pushing Cantor's paper at Crelle. 
> > > > It is true that doubts arose due to paradoxes in early set theory, but Dedekind didn’t seem to renounce set theory, rather he seems to have worked to try and fix it. 
> > > Here is what he should have recognized: Every Dedekind-cut needs a finite description. 
> > Dedekind cuts are stated with a fixed number of symbols, you pathetic crank! "Finite description" is a phrase that just makes you look more stupid every time you use it. 
> > > There are only countably many finite descriptions. 
> > > 
> > > Or this: Every real number is the limit of (at least) one Cauchy-sequence of rational numbers. 
> > How is this ANY different from a Dedekind Cut? It is in principle exactly the same thing! 
> > 
> > Look moron: 
> > 
> > Given a cut (L,H) where L is the lower set and H is the upper set, it is pretty clear that the lower set converges to some limit, in other words, NO DIFFERENT to a converging sequence (no need to call this Cauchy because Cauchy is of zero importance in this respect). 
> > 
> > Now IF a converging sequence represents some imaginary "real number", then ALL real numbers are by definition rational. How many times have you yourself said that the limit may not be part of the sequence?? Cherry picking is a typical crank attribute. 
> > 
> > So the sequence 0.3; 0.33; 0.333; ... converges to a rational number 1/3, but this does not mean that the "real number" 1/3 is represented by 0.333... as a bullshit infinite decimal expansion. After all, 1/3 DOES NOT even have a measure in base 10, you silly man! 
> > 
> > The sequence 3.14159... does not represent any number, because if it did, then whatever is the limit, it cannot be a number of any kind, but some immeasurable magnitude. 
> > > Different real numbers have different Cauchy-sequences. (It is impossible that one and the same Cauchy sequence has two different real limits.) Therefore every limit has at least one rational term different from every other limit. Therefore there cannot be more real limits than rational terms. 
> > And your point here is what exactly? Ah, you don't have a point. 
> > > > The Dedekind quote provided by Professor Mueckenheim in his 366 page document:Transfinity: a source book, 
> > 
> > > > 
> > > > “the numbers are free creations of the human mind” 
> > Whoever said this, is an absolute imbecile who knows nothing about psychology or even the human mind, much less anything about philosophy. 
> > > > 
> > > > does not seem to commit Dedekind to a philosophy of mathematics that is sceptical of the actual infinite. The word “free” seems to play an important role here. 
> > > The word "creation" seems to play an important role too. 
> > > > 
> > > > As an illustration: if Dedekind believed that potential infinity was the only valid use of infinity in mathematical argumentation, then it would be mysterious that he did not produce a version of real analysis along constructivist lines similar to Errett Bishop, which gives quite a different presentation of results such as the Intermediate Value Theorem. 
> > > Couldn't it be that at those times the difference between infinities had not yet been completely understood? Of course Cantor had! - but all the others? Unfortunately even modern set theorists are boasting that they don't know the difference or that potential infinity does not exist. "You use terms like completed versus potential infinity, which are not part of the modern vernacular." [P.L. Clark, https://www.hs-augsburg.de/~mueckenh/Transfinity/Transfinity/pdf, p. 11] 
> > > 
> > > Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#517502

FromMostowski Collapse <bursejan@gmail.com>
Date2021-04-11 12:47 -0700
Message-ID<546d2c8f-ea64-4442-b2da-efdea7b6cf11n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#517501
Possibly you are confused John Gabriel, and never 
understood Cauchy Sequence or Dedekind Cut.

LMAO!

Mostowski Collapse schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 21:46:20 UTC+2:
> L is closed downwards: 
> 
> If x , y ∈ Q, x < y, and y ∈ A, then x ∈ A. ( A is "closed downwards".) 
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dedekind_cut#Definition 
> 
> So as soon as q in L, for any r < q, we have also r in L. 
> Likewise if p < r. But there are infinitely many r with p < r 
> and r < q. Basically you don't need to define an equivalence 
> 
> relation between Dedekind Cuts anymore. The extensionality 
> and equality of pairs of sets (L1,H1) = (L2,H2) iff L1=L2 & H1=H2 
> is then enough to have an equality, which then corresponds 
> 
> to equality of real numbers. For Cauchy Sequences of rational 
> numbers equality need to be separately defined. And real numbers 
> become an equivalence classes over Cauchy Sequences.
> Mostowski Collapse schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 21:37:33 UTC+2: 
> > A Cauchy Sequence (p1,p2,p3,...) and a Dedekind Cut (L,H) are 
> > not directly the same. Take to rational numbers p and q from L. 
> > There are infinitely many rational numbers r such that 
> > 
> > p < r and r < q also in L. But for a Cauchy Sequence with p=pj 
> > and q=pk there are only finitely many r=pi with j < i and i < k. 
> > You need to adjust your mental picture, you don't seem to 
> > 
> > understand the idea of a Cauchy Sequence or Dedekind Cut or both. 
> > Eram semper recta schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 19:57:31 UTC+2: 
> > > On Sunday, 11 April 2021 at 12:27:17 UTC-4, WM wrote: 
> > > > Quantum Bubbles schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 15:12:54 UTC+2: 
> > > > 
> > > > > I thank Professor Mueckenheim for taking the time to respond to my comment. 
> > > > It was a pleasure. 
> > > > > There are various arguments that could be given for my position, but a good starting point I think is that it seems contrary to the role he is regarded in playing in the development of early set theory: 
> > > > Of course Dedeking did quite a lot there. 
> > > > > 
> > > > > and in his support for Cantor, such as persuading Cantor not to withdraw one of his most amazing papers that explicitly involved the actual infinite. 
> > > > Things are not as straight as Wikipedia presents them. 
> > > > 
> > > > Dedekind first warned Cantor not to publish his finding without carefully realizing and mentioning the implications of complety interrupting the continuity of the square: 
> > > > "die Ausfüllung der Lücken zwingt Sie, eine grauenhafte, Schwindel erregende Unstetigkeit in der Correspondenz eintreten zu lassen, durch welche Alles in Atome aufgelöst wird, so dass jeder noch so kleine stetig zusammenhängende Theil des einen Gebietes in seinem Bilde als durchaus zerrissen, unstetig erscheint. 
> > > > Ich hoffe, mich deutlich genug ausgedrückt zu haben ; die Absicht meines Schreibens besteht nur darin Sie zu bitten, nicht ohne eine gründliche Prüfung meines Einwandes gegen die bisher für wahr gehaltenen Glaubensartikel der Mannigfaltigkeitslehre öffentlich zu polemisieren." [Dedekind, 2 Jul 1877] 
> > > > 
> > > > When Cantor asked Dedekind for supporting a publication at Vieweg, Dedekind's publisher, Dedekind explained the problems arising there (he himself had payed the printing expenses of his book and Vieweg was reluctant to publish small pieces like Cantor's paper) and the small readership to be expected. 
> > > > 
> > > > "Für den Fall, daß Sie Ihre Arbeit dem Journal für Mathematik ganz entziehen und als besondere Schrift erscheinen lassen wollten, werde ich mir gewiß gern Mühe geben, dieselbe bei Vieweg als Verlags-Artikel zu empfehlen. Allein ich weiß im Voraus, daß ich dabei auf Schwierigkeiten stoßen würde ; schon seit langen Jahren habe ich Vieweg oder seine Vertreter in gelegentlichen Gesprächen die größte Abneigung aussprechen hören, Schriften von so kleinem Umfange in Verlag zu nehmen. Diese Kenntniss hat mich auch bewogen, meine Abhandlung über Stetigkeit und irrationale Zahlen durchaus auf meine Kosten drucken zu lassen, obgleich ich dem Viewegschen Verlage unzählige kleine Gefälligkeiten erwiesen hatte. Der Vertrieb ist dann, wie es scheint, ein äußerst lästiger gewesen; man hat sich wahrscheinlich nicht einmal die Mühe gegeben (ich freilich auch nicht), die Schrift an irgend eine kritische Zeitschrift zu versenden, und ich habe selten oder gar nicht bemerkt, daß die Schrift auf den Umschlägen der Vieweg'schen Bücher angezeigt wäre; nachdem Vieweg die Druckkosten u. s. w. erhalten, bekommt er von jedem verkauften Exemplar die Hälfte des Preises. 
> > > > Aus diesen Gründen, namentlich aber wegen der äußerst geringen Verbreitung, die Ihre Abhandlung erfahren würde, wenn sie in ähnlicher Weise von Vieweg behandelt würde, kann ich Ihnen nicht sehr zurathen, sich darauf einzulassen. Sobald Sie es aber doch wünschen, werde ich gern Alles thun, um die günstigsten Bedingungen für Sie bei Vieweg zu erwirken. Es ist sehr unangenehm, wenn die Veröffentlichung im Journal sich verzögert ; aber dafür gewährt dies Journal mehr als jedes andere die Gewißheit, daß ein in ihm niedergelegter Gedanke die größte Verbreitung erfährt. Deshalb und auch in Rücksicht auf künftige Fälle möchte ich Ihnen mehr dazu rathen, Ihre Abhandlung nicht zurückzuziehen. Auf meine vollständige Verschwiegenheit dürfen Sie sich in jedem Falle verlassen."(Dedkind, 14 Nov 1877) 
> > > > 
> > > > The small readership is Dedekind's main argument. That's not quite the same as pushing Cantor's paper at Crelle. 
> > > > > It is true that doubts arose due to paradoxes in early set theory, but Dedekind didn’t seem to renounce set theory, rather he seems to have worked to try and fix it. 
> > > > Here is what he should have recognized: Every Dedekind-cut needs a finite description. 
> > > Dedekind cuts are stated with a fixed number of symbols, you pathetic crank! "Finite description" is a phrase that just makes you look more stupid every time you use it. 
> > > > There are only countably many finite descriptions. 
> > > > 
> > > > Or this: Every real number is the limit of (at least) one Cauchy-sequence of rational numbers. 
> > > How is this ANY different from a Dedekind Cut? It is in principle exactly the same thing! 
> > > 
> > > Look moron: 
> > > 
> > > Given a cut (L,H) where L is the lower set and H is the upper set, it is pretty clear that the lower set converges to some limit, in other words, NO DIFFERENT to a converging sequence (no need to call this Cauchy because Cauchy is of zero importance in this respect). 
> > > 
> > > Now IF a converging sequence represents some imaginary "real number", then ALL real numbers are by definition rational. How many times have you yourself said that the limit may not be part of the sequence?? Cherry picking is a typical crank attribute. 
> > > 
> > > So the sequence 0.3; 0.33; 0.333; ... converges to a rational number 1/3, but this does not mean that the "real number" 1/3 is represented by 0.333... as a bullshit infinite decimal expansion. After all, 1/3 DOES NOT even have a measure in base 10, you silly man! 
> > > 
> > > The sequence 3.14159... does not represent any number, because if it did, then whatever is the limit, it cannot be a number of any kind, but some immeasurable magnitude. 
> > > > Different real numbers have different Cauchy-sequences. (It is impossible that one and the same Cauchy sequence has two different real limits.) Therefore every limit has at least one rational term different from every other limit. Therefore there cannot be more real limits than rational terms. 
> > > And your point here is what exactly? Ah, you don't have a point. 
> > > > > The Dedekind quote provided by Professor Mueckenheim in his 366 page document:Transfinity: a source book, 
> > > 
> > > > > 
> > > > > “the numbers are free creations of the human mind” 
> > > Whoever said this, is an absolute imbecile who knows nothing about psychology or even the human mind, much less anything about philosophy. 
> > > > > 
> > > > > does not seem to commit Dedekind to a philosophy of mathematics that is sceptical of the actual infinite. The word “free” seems to play an important role here. 
> > > > The word "creation" seems to play an important role too. 
> > > > > 
> > > > > As an illustration: if Dedekind believed that potential infinity was the only valid use of infinity in mathematical argumentation, then it would be mysterious that he did not produce a version of real analysis along constructivist lines similar to Errett Bishop, which gives quite a different presentation of results such as the Intermediate Value Theorem. 
> > > > Couldn't it be that at those times the difference between infinities had not yet been completely understood? Of course Cantor had! - but all the others? Unfortunately even modern set theorists are boasting that they don't know the difference or that potential infinity does not exist. "You use terms like completed versus potential infinity, which are not part of the modern vernacular." [P.L. Clark, https://www.hs-augsburg.de/~mueckenh/Transfinity/Transfinity/pdf, p. 11] 
> > > > 
> > > > Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#517516

FromQuantum Bubbles <ross.probability@gmx.com>
Date2021-04-11 14:51 -0700
Message-ID<efab700d-e06d-4994-8411-61d769d9c56cn@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#517465
On Sunday, April 11, 2021 at 5:27:17 PM UTC+1, WM wrote:
> Quantum Bubbles schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 15:12:54 UTC+2: 
> 
> > I thank Professor Mueckenheim for taking the time to respond to my comment.
> It was a pleasure.
> > There are various arguments that could be given for my position, but a good starting point I think is that it seems contrary to the role he is regarded in playing in the development of early set theory:
> Of course Dedeking did quite a lot there.
> > 
> > and in his support for Cantor, such as persuading Cantor not to withdraw one of his most amazing papers that explicitly involved the actual infinite.
> Things are not as straight as Wikipedia presents them. 
> 
> Dedekind first warned Cantor not to publish his finding without carefully realizing and mentioning the implications of complety interrupting the continuity of the square: 
> "die Ausfüllung der Lücken zwingt Sie, eine grauenhafte, Schwindel erregende Unstetigkeit in der Correspondenz eintreten zu lassen, durch welche Alles in Atome aufgelöst wird, so dass jeder noch so kleine stetig zusammenhängende Theil des einen Gebietes in seinem Bilde als durchaus zerrissen, unstetig erscheint. 
> Ich hoffe, mich deutlich genug ausgedrückt zu haben ; die Absicht meines Schreibens besteht nur darin Sie zu bitten, nicht ohne eine gründliche Prüfung meines Einwandes gegen die bisher für wahr gehaltenen Glaubensartikel der Mannigfaltigkeitslehre öffentlich zu polemisieren." [Dedekind, 2 Jul 1877] 
> 
> When Cantor asked Dedekind for supporting a publication at Vieweg, Dedekind's publisher, Dedekind explained the problems arising there (he himself had payed the printing expenses of his book and Vieweg was reluctant to publish small pieces like Cantor's paper) and the small readership to be expected. 
> 
> "Für den Fall, daß Sie Ihre Arbeit dem Journal für Mathematik ganz entziehen und als besondere Schrift erscheinen lassen wollten, werde ich mir gewiß gern Mühe geben, dieselbe bei Vieweg als Verlags-Artikel zu empfehlen. Allein ich weiß im Voraus, daß ich dabei auf Schwierigkeiten stoßen würde ; schon seit langen Jahren habe ich Vieweg oder seine Vertreter in gelegentlichen Gesprächen die größte Abneigung aussprechen hören, Schriften von so kleinem Umfange in Verlag zu nehmen. Diese Kenntniss hat mich auch bewogen, meine Abhandlung über Stetigkeit und irrationale Zahlen durchaus auf meine Kosten drucken zu lassen, obgleich ich dem Viewegschen Verlage unzählige kleine Gefälligkeiten erwiesen hatte. Der Vertrieb ist dann, wie es scheint, ein äußerst lästiger gewesen; man hat sich wahrscheinlich nicht einmal die Mühe gegeben (ich freilich auch nicht), die Schrift an irgend eine kritische Zeitschrift zu versenden, und ich habe selten oder gar nicht bemerkt, daß die Schrift auf den Umschlägen der Vieweg'schen Bücher angezeigt wäre; nachdem Vieweg die Druckkosten u. s. w. erhalten, bekommt er von jedem verkauften Exemplar die Hälfte des Preises. 
> Aus diesen Gründen, namentlich aber wegen der äußerst geringen Verbreitung, die Ihre Abhandlung erfahren würde, wenn sie in ähnlicher Weise von Vieweg behandelt würde, kann ich Ihnen nicht sehr zurathen, sich darauf einzulassen. Sobald Sie es aber doch wünschen, werde ich gern Alles thun, um die günstigsten Bedingungen für Sie bei Vieweg zu erwirken. Es ist sehr unangenehm, wenn die Veröffentlichung im Journal sich verzögert ; aber dafür gewährt dies Journal mehr als jedes andere die Gewißheit, daß ein in ihm niedergelegter Gedanke die größte Verbreitung erfährt. Deshalb und auch in Rücksicht auf künftige Fälle möchte ich Ihnen mehr dazu rathen, Ihre Abhandlung nicht zurückzuziehen. Auf meine vollständige Verschwiegenheit dürfen Sie sich in jedem Falle verlassen."(Dedkind, 14 Nov 1877) 
> 
> The small readership is Dedekind's main argument. That's not quite the same as pushing Cantor's paper at Crelle.
> > It is true that doubts arose due to paradoxes in early set theory, but Dedekind didn’t seem to renounce set theory, rather he seems to have worked to try and fix it.
> Here is what he should have recognized: Every Dedekind-cut needs a finite description. There are only countably many finite descriptions. 
> 
> Or this: Every real number is the limit of (at least) one Cauchy-sequence of rational numbers. Different real numbers have different Cauchy-sequences. (It is impossible that one and the same Cauchy sequence has two different real limits.) Therefore every limit has at least one rational term different from every other limit. Therefore there cannot be more real limits than rational terms.
> > The Dedekind quote provided by Professor Mueckenheim in his 366 page document:Transfinity: a source book, 
> > 
> > “the numbers are free creations of the human mind” 
> > 
> > does not seem to commit Dedekind to a philosophy of mathematics that is sceptical of the actual infinite. The word “free” seems to play an important role here.
> The word "creation" seems to play an important role too.
> > 
> > As an illustration: if Dedekind believed that potential infinity was the only valid use of infinity in mathematical argumentation, then it would be mysterious that he did not produce a version of real analysis along constructivist lines similar to Errett Bishop, which gives quite a different presentation of results such as the Intermediate Value Theorem.
> Couldn't it be that at those times the difference between infinities had not yet been completely understood? Of course Cantor had! - but all the others? Unfortunately even modern set theorists are boasting that they don't know the difference or that potential infinity does not exist. "You use terms like completed versus potential infinity, which are not part of the modern vernacular." [P.L. Clark, https://www.hs-augsburg.de/~mueckenh/Transfinity/Transfinity/pdf, p. 11] 
> 
> Regards, WM


I thank Professor Mueckenheim for kindly taking the time to respond to my comment.

I have rechecked some of the mathematical historical books I have, as well as better internet resources. I cannot find any strong evidence that Dedekind supported potential infinity over actual infinity, but did find evidence that he strongly believed in actual infinity.

I think many of the issues are addressed in the entry to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy on Dedekind's contributions to the foundations of mathematics.

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/dedekind-foundations/

I will try to respond to Professor Mueckenheim's other query which concerned finitism as a philosophy of mathematics, tomorrow.

Kind Regards

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#517530

FromSergio <invalid@invalid.com>
Date2021-04-11 19:36 -0500
Message-ID<s504mi$1dou$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#517516
On 4/11/2021 4:51 PM, Quantum Bubbles wrote:
> On Sunday, April 11, 2021 at 5:27:17 PM UTC+1, WM wrote:
>> Quantum Bubbles schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 15:12:54 UTC+2: 
>>
>>> I thank Professor Mueckenheim for taking the time to respond to my comment.
>> It was a pleasure.
>>> There are various arguments that could be given for my position, but a good starting point I think is that it seems contrary to the role he is regarded in playing in the development of early set theory:
>> Of course Dedeking did quite a lot there.
>>>
>>> and in his support for Cantor, such as persuading Cantor not to withdraw one of his most amazing papers that explicitly involved the actual infinite.
>> Things are not as straight as Wikipedia presents them. 
>>
>> Dedekind first warned Cantor not to publish his finding without carefully realizing and mentioning the implications of complety interrupting the continuity of the square: 
>> "die Ausfüllung der Lücken zwingt Sie, eine grauenhafte, Schwindel erregende Unstetigkeit in der Correspondenz eintreten zu lassen, durch welche Alles in Atome aufgelöst wird, so dass jeder noch so kleine stetig zusammenhängende Theil des einen Gebietes in seinem Bilde als durchaus zerrissen, unstetig erscheint. 
>> Ich hoffe, mich deutlich genug ausgedrückt zu haben ; die Absicht meines Schreibens besteht nur darin Sie zu bitten, nicht ohne eine gründliche Prüfung meines Einwandes gegen die bisher für wahr gehaltenen Glaubensartikel der Mannigfaltigkeitslehre öffentlich zu polemisieren." [Dedekind, 2 Jul 1877] 
>>
>> When Cantor asked Dedekind for supporting a publication at Vieweg, Dedekind's publisher, Dedekind explained the problems arising there (he himself had payed the printing expenses of his book and Vieweg was reluctant to publish small pieces like Cantor's paper) and the small readership to be expected. 
>>
>> "Für den Fall, daß Sie Ihre Arbeit dem Journal für Mathematik ganz entziehen und als besondere Schrift erscheinen lassen wollten, werde ich mir gewiß gern Mühe geben, dieselbe bei Vieweg als Verlags-Artikel zu empfehlen. Allein ich weiß im Voraus, daß ich dabei auf Schwierigkeiten stoßen würde ; schon seit langen Jahren habe ich Vieweg oder seine Vertreter in gelegentlichen Gesprächen die größte Abneigung aussprechen hören, Schriften von so kleinem Umfange in Verlag zu nehmen. Diese Kenntniss hat mich auch bewogen, meine Abhandlung über Stetigkeit und irrationale Zahlen durchaus auf meine Kosten drucken zu lassen, obgleich ich dem Viewegschen Verlage unzählige kleine Gefälligkeiten erwiesen hatte. Der Vertrieb ist dann, wie es scheint, ein äußerst lästiger gewesen; man hat sich wahrscheinlich nicht einmal die Mühe gegeben (ich freilich auch nicht), die Schrift an irgend eine kritische Zeitschrift zu versenden, und ich habe selten oder gar nicht bemerkt, daß die Schrift auf den Umschlägen der Vieweg'schen Bücher angezeigt wäre; nachdem Vieweg die Druckkosten u. s. w. erhalten, bekommt er von jedem verkauften Exemplar die Hälfte des Preises. 
>> Aus diesen Gründen, namentlich aber wegen der äußerst geringen Verbreitung, die Ihre Abhandlung erfahren würde, wenn sie in ähnlicher Weise von Vieweg behandelt würde, kann ich Ihnen nicht sehr zurathen, sich darauf einzulassen. Sobald Sie es aber doch wünschen, werde ich gern Alles thun, um die günstigsten Bedingungen für Sie bei Vieweg zu erwirken. Es ist sehr unangenehm, wenn die Veröffentlichung im Journal sich verzögert ; aber dafür gewährt dies Journal mehr als jedes andere die Gewißheit, daß ein in ihm niedergelegter Gedanke die größte Verbreitung erfährt. Deshalb und auch in Rücksicht auf künftige Fälle möchte ich Ihnen mehr dazu rathen, Ihre Abhandlung nicht zurückzuziehen. Auf meine vollständige Verschwiegenheit dürfen Sie sich in jedem Falle verlassen."(Dedkind, 14 Nov 1877) 
>>
>> The small readership is Dedekind's main argument. That's not quite the same as pushing Cantor's paper at Crelle.
>>> It is true that doubts arose due to paradoxes in early set theory, but Dedekind didn’t seem to renounce set theory, rather he seems to have worked to try and fix it.
>> Here is what he should have recognized: Every Dedekind-cut needs a finite description. There are only countably many finite descriptions. 
>>
>> Or this: Every real number is the limit of (at least) one Cauchy-sequence of rational numbers. Different real numbers have different Cauchy-sequences. (It is impossible that one and the same Cauchy sequence has two different real limits.) Therefore every limit has at least one rational term different from every other limit. Therefore there cannot be more real limits than rational terms.
>>> The Dedekind quote provided by Professor Mueckenheim in his 366 page document:Transfinity: a source book, 
>>>
>>> “the numbers are free creations of the human mind” 
>>>
>>> does not seem to commit Dedekind to a philosophy of mathematics that is sceptical of the actual infinite. The word “free” seems to play an important role here.
>> The word "creation" seems to play an important role too.
>>>
>>> As an illustration: if Dedekind believed that potential infinity was the only valid use of infinity in mathematical argumentation, then it would be mysterious that he did not produce a version of real analysis along constructivist lines similar to Errett Bishop, which gives quite a different presentation of results such as the Intermediate Value Theorem.
>> Couldn't it be that at those times the difference between infinities had not yet been completely understood? Of course Cantor had! - but all the others? Unfortunately even modern set theorists are boasting that they don't know the difference or that potential infinity does not exist. "You use terms like completed versus potential infinity, which are not part of the modern vernacular." [P.L. Clark, https://www.hs-augsburg.de/~mueckenh/Transfinity/Transfinity/pdf, p. 11] 
>>
>> Regards, WM
> 
> 
> I thank Professor Mueckenheim for kindly taking the time to respond to my comment.
> 
> I have rechecked some of the mathematical historical books I have, as well as better internet resources. I cannot find any strong evidence that Dedekind supported potential infinity over actual infinity, but did find evidence that he strongly believed in actual infinity.
> 
> I think many of the issues are addressed in the entry to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy on Dedekind's contributions to the foundations of mathematics.
> 
> https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/dedekind-foundations/
> 
> I will try to respond to Professor Mueckenheim's other query which concerned finitism as a philosophy of mathematics, tomorrow.
> 
> Kind Regards
> 

good reference, from Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

here is table of contents, huge # of items

https://plato.stanford.edu/contents.html

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#518932

FromWM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de>
Date2021-04-22 12:04 -0700
Message-ID<544bc6c5-15b3-4d07-9247-8b61436fee13n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#517516
Quantum Bubbles schrieb am Sonntag, 11. April 2021 um 23:51:08 UTC+2:

> I thank Professor Mueckenheim for kindly taking the time to respond to my comment. 
> 
> I have rechecked some of the mathematical historical books I have, as well as better internet resources. I cannot find any strong evidence that Dedekind supported potential infinity over actual infinity, but did find evidence that he strongly believed in actual infinity.

Could you report some of this evidence?
> 
> I think many of the issues are addressed in the entry to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy on Dedekind's contributions to the foundations of mathematics. 
> 
> https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/dedekind-foundations/ 

Dedekind seems to have found out about such problems from Cantor in the late 1890s (who informed him that the collection of all ordinal numbers is an “inconsistent totality”, as is the collection of all “objects of thought”). This news shocked him initially, so much that he delayed republication of Was sind und was sollen die Zahlen?

This should have shocked every defender of actual infinity. Either infinity is actual, then all sets exist and form the set of all sets, or infinity is potential, at least on this scale.
> 
> I will try to respond to Professor Mueckenheim's other query which concerned finitism as a philosophy of mathematics, tomorrow. 

My philosophy is not finitism (this remark in Wikipedia is incorrect, but they believe to know better than me what I think) but classical mathematics with potential infinity. Nevertheless I am interested in your response.

Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


Page 1 of 8  [1] 2 3 4 5 6 7 8  Next page →

Back to top | Article view | sci.math


csiph-web