Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > sci.math > #510295 > unrolled thread

On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory

Started byWM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de>
First post2021-01-23 02:34 -0800
Last post2021-01-24 12:46 -0600
Articles 20 on this page of 65 — 10 participants

Back to article view | Back to sci.math


Contents

  On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-01-23 02:34 -0800
    Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-01-23 03:47 -0800
      Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-01-23 03:50 -0800
        Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-01-23 03:56 -0800
      Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-01-23 05:39 -0800
        Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-01-23 09:01 -0800
          Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-01-23 14:46 -0800
            Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Python <python@python.invalid> - 2021-01-24 00:31 +0100
              Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-01-23 17:34 -0600
                Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Graham Cooper <grahamcooper7@gmail.com> - 2021-01-23 16:42 -0800
                  Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-01-23 20:46 -0600
              Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-01-24 05:22 -0800
                Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Python <python@python.invalid> - 2021-01-24 17:30 +0100
                  Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-01-24 09:22 -0800
                    Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Python <python@python.invalid> - 2021-01-24 19:07 +0100
                      Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-01-24 10:41 -0800
                        Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Python <python@python.invalid> - 2021-01-24 19:44 +0100
                          Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-01-24 11:04 -0800
                            Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Python <python@python.invalid> - 2021-01-24 20:18 +0100
                            Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-01-25 04:32 -0800
                              Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Python <python@python.invalid> - 2021-01-25 15:05 +0100
                Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-01-25 04:26 -0800
                  Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-01-25 04:53 -0800
                    Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-01-25 08:58 -0600
                    Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-01-26 07:28 -0800
                      Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Python <python@python.invalid> - 2021-01-26 19:16 +0100
                        Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-01-26 10:38 -0800
                          Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Python <python@python.invalid> - 2021-01-26 19:44 +0100
                        Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-01-26 13:08 -0600
                      Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-01-27 04:25 -0800
                        Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-01-27 08:42 -0600
                        Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-01-27 10:28 -0800
                          Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-01-27 13:53 -0800
                            Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-01-28 04:37 -0800
                              Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-01-28 04:52 -0800
                                Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory konyberg <konyberg@online.no> - 2021-01-28 05:55 -0800
                                Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-01-28 06:11 -0800
                                  Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Graham Cooper <grahamcooper7@gmail.com> - 2021-01-28 06:55 -0800
                                  Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Richard Cranium <dickhead@hotmail.net> - 2021-01-28 07:38 -0800
                                  Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-01-28 08:59 -0800
                                    Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-01-28 11:24 -0800
                                      Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-01-28 14:38 -0800
                                        Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-01-29 12:29 -0800
                                          Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-01-29 14:13 -0800
                                            Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-01-30 04:43 -0800
                                            Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-01-31 09:16 -0600
                                          Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory "zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com> - 2021-01-31 22:21 -0800
                                      Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory "zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com> - 2021-01-28 22:18 -0800
                              Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory konyberg <konyberg@online.no> - 2021-01-28 05:52 -0800
                                Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-01-28 07:48 -0800
                                  Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-01-28 08:04 -0800
                                    Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Eram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com> - 2021-01-28 08:19 -0800
                                      Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Heywood Jablome <heywood@jablome.net> - 2021-01-28 12:12 -0800
                                    Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-01-28 09:05 -0800
                          Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory "zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com> - 2021-01-28 01:47 -0800
                      Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory "zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com> - 2021-01-27 06:16 -0800
        Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-01-23 13:48 -0600
      Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2021-01-23 06:23 -0800
        Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-01-23 13:53 -0600
      Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Dan Christensen <Dan_Christensen@sympatico.ca> - 2021-01-23 09:26 -0800
        WARNING TO STUDENTS: Don't be a victim of AP's fake math and science Dan Christensen <Dan_Christensen@sympatico.ca> - 2021-01-23 11:25 -0800
    Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Dan Christensen <Dan_Christensen@sympatico.ca> - 2021-01-23 09:21 -0800
    Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-01-23 13:34 -0600
    Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Dan Christensen <Dan_Christensen@sympatico.ca> - 2021-01-23 12:06 -0800
    Re: On the different limit notions in analysis and in set theory Sergio <invalid@invalid.com> - 2021-01-24 12:46 -0600

Page 3 of 4 — ← Prev page 1 2 [3] 4  Next page →


#510743

FromEram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com>
Date2021-01-28 11:24 -0800
Message-ID<e431c590-0031-406e-a32c-0724e4ba25fan@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#510733
On Thursday, 28 January 2021 at 11:59:17 UTC-5, WM wrote:
> Eram semper recta schrieb am Donnerstag, 28. Januar 2021 um 15:11:13 UTC+1: 
> > On Thursday, 28 January 2021 at 07:52:40 UTC-5, WM wrote: 
> 
> > > > Secondly, it DOES imply an actual infinity or ALL terms: 
> > > No, it does not. Proof is that in Newton's and Leibniz's times there was no actual infinity generally accepted but the limit was well known. 
> > It absolutely DOES imply actual infinity. 
> 
> > You're also wrong in your claim that "there was no actual infinity generally accepted " because infinity was used by both Newton and Leibniz.

> *Potential* infinity was used (Leibniz sometimes changed his position). Here are two quotes by Cantor, where he correctly describes the situation. 

I don't see how "infinity" could be used at all because it is a mythical concept. As for Cantor, I have often stated that he is the father of all mathematical cranks. So no use quoting anything he believed because it's garbage.

Also, whether Newton or Leibniz actually believed the concept was sound makes no difference to the argument. In any case, neither Newton nor Leibniz nor anyone who came before me actually understood why calculus works. I was the FIRST.

Never are all terms implied. This was made clear in Rudin's analysis:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/12oUJAfIMFMcXFb8DvgsYxuPfdaB99XYH

> 
> Daß das sogenannte potentiale oder synkategorematische Unendliche (Indefinitum) zu keiner derartigen Einteilung Veranlassung gibt, hat darin seinen Grund, daß es ausschließlich als Beziehungsbegriff, als Hilfsvorstellung unseres Denkens Bedeutung hat, für sich aber keine Idee bezeichnet; in jener Rolle hat es allerdings durch die von Leibniz und Newton erfundene Differential- und Integralrechnung seinen großen Wert als Erkenntnismittel und Instrument unseres Geistes bewiesen; eine weitergehende Bedeutung kann dasselbe nicht für sich in Anspruch nehmen. 
> 
> So hoch ich Cauchy als Mathematiker und Physiker schätze, so sympathisch mir seine Frömmigkeit ist und so sehr mir im besondern auch jene "Sept Lecons de physique générale", abgesehen von dem in Rede stehenden Irrtum gefallen, muß ich doch entschieden gegen seine Autorität protestieren da, wo er gefehlt hat. 
> Es sind jetzt gerade zwei Jahre her, daß mich Herr Rudolf Lipschitz in Bonn auf eine gewisse Stelle im Briefwechsel zwischen Gauß und Schumacher aufmerksam machte, wo ersterer gegen jede Heranziehung des Aktual-Unendlichen in die Mathematik sich ausspricht (Brief v. 12. Juli 1831); ich habe ausführlich geantwortet und die Autorität von Gauß, welche ich in allen anderen Beziehungen so hoch halte, in diesem Punkte abgelehnt, sowie ich heute das Zeugnis Cauchy's und wie ich in meinem Schriftchen "Grundlagen einer allgemeinen Mannigfaltigkeitslehre, Leipzig 1883" [hier III 4, Nr. 5, S. 165 ff.] u. a. auch die Autorität Leibnizens, der in dieser Frage eine merkwürdige Inkonsequenz begangen hat, zurückweise. 
> 
> Gauß refused actual infinity vehemently, like Cauchy and Kronecker. 

Gauss and Kronecker did, but not Cauchy and both were correct. Cauchy did not reject infinity.

> Did they not understand what analysis means? 

You don't understand it either.

> The only widely known proponents of actual infinity in these times were 
> 
> Emanuel Maignan (1601 - 1676) 
> Pierre Bayle (1647 -1706) 
> Bernard de Fontenelle (1657-1757) 
> Johann Schultz (1739 - 1805) 
> Bernard Bolzano (1781 - 1848)
> > The definition f'(x) = lim (h->0) [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h is equivalent to f'(x) = lim (n->oo) [f(x+h/n)-f(x)]/(h/n).
> Of course. But I explained already that 1/n (or h/n) has the limit 0 without actual infinity.

Infinity has nothing to do with the limit.

>  For every m > n, 1/m comes closer to 0 than 1/n. Never a negative value occurs. Every positive value can be undercut. 

Wow. You just don't get it, do you? To make a statement such as " For every m > n, 1/m comes closer to 0 than 1/n. "  means that you arrive at a conclusion analytically. The very act of showing that 1/m gets closer to 0 than 1/n but never reaches 0 means that there is an "infinite number" (in your terminology) of values between 0 and 1/n, just as there are innumerably many finite difference quotients  [f(x+h_i)-f(x)]/h_i between x+h_i and x, but NONE at x where it matters most!   f'(x) = lim (h->0) [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h  is fundamentally based on infinity and you cannot find the limit unless you use your flawed first principles method. You have NO valid systematic way of finding the derivative in the bogus mainstream formulation.  Moreover, to use f'(x) = lim (h->0) [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h  means  0<|x|<h -> |f(x)-L|<epsilon which is utter rubbish because you need to know the limit which IS the derivative. So it's circular at the offset. You don't get to find the limit except by your bogus first principles method. The epsilonics arguments are used to "verify" that your limit guess is true.

But there is NO guessing where the identity [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h = f ' (x) + Q(x,h) is concerned. It is 100% rigorous and uses no bullshit concepts such as limit theory, infinity or infinitesimals. Meaning limits are not required in calculus where either the derivative or integral are concerned.

So once again, the same reasoning applies to your set theory arguments.

> Therefore no aczual infinity is appearing here. Note that actual infinity allows to enukmerate or to remove all fractions from (10, 1/n) such that only 0 remains. 

Actual infinity does not allow anything because it does not exist. When you add the phrase "allows to enukmerate or to remove all fractions from (10, 1/n) such that only 0 remains.", that is merely your assertion showing your interpretation which is obviously wrong. On the one hand you claim infinity is not possible and on the other hand you claim it is possible to remove all fractions such that none remain.

Look, you can use the following two approaches to find the derivative of f(x)=x^2.

1.  [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h = 2x + h

You set h=0 which is the same as tossing away Q(x,h)=h because it is the difference in slopes. You can do this in one step.

2.  [f(x+h/n)-f(x)]/(h/n) = 2x + h/n

You can still throw away Q(x, h/n)= h/n because it is the difference in slopes, but if you choose limit theory, then you have a super task lying ahead of you, i.e. you need an n such that  h/n = 0. There is no such n. Please don't repeat your drivel about  "For every m > n, 1/m comes closer to 0 than 1/n." because that is analytical and it is supported by the FACT that between 0 and 1/n there are "infinitely many" fractions.


> The ellipsis means in potential infinity "and so on", there are all terms which can be defined. Always finite but no fixed largest. In actual infinity it means all terms larger than 0. But you are right that in no case the sum is 1. Only the limit is 1.

No. There is no such thing as potential or actual infinity because infinity is itself a junk concept. Preceding "infinity" with an adjective doesn't make it any more sensible. The Ancient Greeks rejected it in its entirety. The only ones who dabbled with the concept were second rate philosophers such as Aristotle, ia.

Potential means "having or showing the capacity to become or develop into something in the future".

... does NOT mean having the capacity to become "infinite".

"Actual infinity" is a redundancy. On its own, infinity is considered an ACTUAL concept. By using that very phrase, one unknowingly admits infinity is impossible. If the concept were sound, then it stands by itself. Can't you see that to accept "potential" or "actual" infinity requires that one first acknowledges infinity? But there is NO definition of infinity that makes even the slightest sense. 

... means able to carry on indefinitely if so desired. NOTHING about infinity there. Indefinite =/= Infinite.

No end =/= infinity
No last term =/= infinity

Because you cannot define any concept by an attribute it lacks. This will sound like a contradiction to the local idiots, but it is not a contradiction. A well-formed concept has boundaries that are known and clear.

Here the official mainstream doctrine is explained and it agrees with what I told you:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/12oUJAfIMFMcXFb8DvgsYxuPfdaB99XYH

> 
> Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510765

FromWM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de>
Date2021-01-28 14:38 -0800
Message-ID<824767ab-10df-46b3-8332-bdc46f3aafc2n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#510743
Eram semper recta schrieb am Donnerstag, 28. Januar 2021 um 20:24:23 UTC+1:
> On Thursday, 28 January 2021 at 11:59:17 UTC-5, WM wrote: 
> > Eram semper recta schrieb am Donnerstag, 28. Januar 2021 um 15:11:13 UTC+1: 
> > > On Thursday, 28 January 2021 at 07:52:40 UTC-5, WM wrote: 
> > 
> As for Cantor, I have often stated that he is the father of all mathematical cranks. So no use quoting anything he believed because it's garbage. 

But in order to show that you misunderstood him it is required to read what he said.
> 
> Also, whether Newton or Leibniz actually believed the concept was sound makes no difference to the argument.

But it shows you that you have misunderstood what they did.

> In any case, neither Newton nor Leibniz nor anyone who came before me actually understood why calculus works.

Might it be that you don't understand what they did?

> > Gauß refused actual infinity vehemently, like Cauchy and Kronecker.
> Gauss and Kronecker did, but not Cauchy and both were correct. Cauchy did not reject infinity.

You misunderstood Cauchy too: "We say that a variable quantity becomes infinitely small when its numerical value decreases indefinitely in such a way as to converge toward the limit zero."  [A.-L. Cauchy: "Cours d'analyse de l'Ecole Royale Polytechnique", Paris (1821) p. 26f]
> > Did they not understand what analysis means?
> You don't understand it either.

I am under the impression that I understand what they did. But everybody may misunderstand things from time to time.

> > Of course. But I explained already that 1/n (or h/n) has the limit 0 without actual infinity.
> Infinity has nothing to do with the limit.

That is a strange observation.

> > For every m > n, 1/m comes closer to 0 than 1/n. Never a negative value occurs. Every positive value can be undercut.
> Wow. You just don't get it, do you?

I explained what I understand. More I cannot do.

> To make a statement such as " For every m > n, 1/m comes closer to 0 than 1/n. " means that you arrive at a conclusion analytically.

Of course.

> The very act of showing that 1/m gets closer to 0 than 1/n but never reaches 0 means that there is an "infinite number" (in your terminology) of values between 0 and 1/n, just as there are innumerably many finite difference quotients [f(x+h_i)-f(x)]/h_i between x+h_i and x, but NONE at x where it matters most!

Why should that matter? The limit is not an f(x). It is simply a constant.

> f'(x) = lim (h->0) [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h is fundamentally based on infinity and you cannot find the limit unless you use your flawed first principles method. You have NO valid systematic way of finding the derivative in the bogus mainstream formulation.

I showed you how it works. You confimed that it supplies the same results as your new calculus. That is hardly an accident.
> 
> But there is NO guessing where the identity [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h = f ' (x) + Q(x,h) is concerned.

No, that is obvious.
> 
> Look, you can use the following two approaches to find the derivative of f(x)=x^2. 
> 
> 1. [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h = 2x + h 
> 
> You set h=0 which is the same as tossing away Q(x,h)=h because it is the difference in slopes. You can do this in one step. 
> 
> 2. [f(x+h/n)-f(x)]/(h/n) = 2x + h/n 
> 
> You can still throw away Q(x, h/n)= h/n because it is the difference in slopes, but if you choose limit theory, then you have a super task lying ahead of you, i.e. you need an n such that h/n = 0.

Here you misunderstand again. There is no such n in general. But it is not required.

> There is no such n. Please don't repeat your drivel about "For every m > n, 1/m comes closer to 0 than 1/n." because that is analytical and it is supported by the FACT that between 0 and 1/n there are "infinitely many" fractions.

Infinitely many means as many as you like. Not actual infinity. But you will hardly refuse that there are as many natural numbers as you like and then always one more. Same with prime numbers. Think of Euclid your great compatriot.

> > The ellipsis means in potential infinity "and so on", there are all terms which can be defined. Always finite but no fixed largest. In actual infinity it means all terms larger than 0. But you are right that in no case the sum is 1. Only the limit is 1.
> No. There is no such thing as potential or actual infinity because infinity is itself a junk concept. 

Do you deny that for every n there is n+1? If not, then you accept potential infinity.

> Preceding "infinity" with an adjective doesn't make it any more sensible.
You misunderstand again.

> The Ancient Greeks rejected it in its entirety.

We don't know much about the Greeks before Aristotle. But everybody who rejects that n implies n+1 is certainly not in agreement with Euclid. He did not talk about infinity, but he said that every given set of prime numbers can be increased. That means potential infinity.

> The only ones who dabbled with the concept were second rate philosophers such as Aristotle, ia.

He was the first to write about it. He understood the difference between infinities. And he took the right choice. 
> 
> Potential means "having or showing the capacity to become or develop into something in the future". 
> 
> ... does NOT mean having the capacity to become "infinite". 

Right. There is no state "infinite" in classical mathematics. Therefore there cannot exist an f(x) at the limit.
> 
> "Actual infinity" is a redundancy.

No.

> On its own, infinity is considered an ACTUAL concept. By using that very phrase, one unknowingly admits infinity is impossible. If the concept were sound, then it stands by itself. Can't you see that to accept "potential" or "actual" infinity requires that one first acknowledges infinity? 

Potential infinity does not mean to reach the state "infinite". It only means that for every n there exists n+1.

> But there is NO definition of infinity that makes even the slightest sense.

You should read the first chapter of https://www.hs-augsburg.de/~mueckenh/Transfinity/Transfinity/pdf.  
> 
> ... means able to carry on indefinitely if so desired. NOTHING about infinity there. Indefinite =/= Infinite. 
> 
> No end =/= infinity 
> No last term =/= infinity 

It is potential infinity.
> 
> Because you cannot define any concept by an attribute it lacks.

Then define it by what it does not lack: For every n there is n+1. That is a splendid explanation. Once it has been understood, it can be extended to other fields. But the natural numbers are the best and most obvious example.

Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510819

FromEram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com>
Date2021-01-29 12:29 -0800
Message-ID<88d83130-8903-4466-9622-95eb40f033f5n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#510765
On Thursday, 28 January 2021 at 17:38:30 UTC-5, WM wrote:
> Eram semper recta schrieb am Donnerstag, 28. Januar 2021 um 20:24:23 UTC+1: 
> > On Thursday, 28 January 2021 at 11:59:17 UTC-5, WM wrote: 
> > > Eram semper recta schrieb am Donnerstag, 28. Januar 2021 um 15:11:13 UTC+1: 
> > > > On Thursday, 28 January 2021 at 07:52:40 UTC-5, WM wrote: 
> > > 
> > As for Cantor, I have often stated that he is the father of all mathematical cranks. So no use quoting anything he believed because it's garbage.
> But in order to show that you misunderstood him it is required to read what he said.

The fact is that you are the one who misunderstands. All you are doing is focusing on a few select words here and there and basing your entire non-arguments on the same.

Even that idiots on this newsgroup with whom you are debating will agree with me that what Cantor meant wrt bijective cardinality is that the given set can be indexed. This is why Cantor initially chose the natural numbers - because they can be systematically named and hence used as an indexing set, ie. any set X is countable if it can be placed into a bijection with X.  This is what Cantor thought and meant. Nothing else. He wasn't a moron even thought his theories are absolutely useless.

> > 
> > Also, whether Newton or Leibniz actually believed the concept was sound makes no difference to the argument.
> But it shows you that you have misunderstood what they did.

It shows nothing of the sort.

> > In any case, neither Newton nor Leibniz nor anyone who came before me actually understood why calculus works.
> Might it be that you don't understand what they did?

Absolutely not. Misunderstanding is not a common attribute of mine. But I have shown that you do misunderstand repeatedly. 

> > > Gauß refused actual infinity vehemently, like Cauchy and Kronecker. 
> > Gauss and Kronecker did, but not Cauchy and both were correct. Cauchy did not reject infinity.

> You misunderstood Cauchy too: "We say that a variable quantity becomes infinitely small when its numerical value decreases indefinitely in such a way as to converge toward the limit zero." [A.-L. Cauchy: "Cours d'analyse de l'Ecole Royale Polytechnique", Paris (1821) p. 26f]

Thank you! That proves my point. If something is "infinitely small" (whatever that means because it is sheer nonsense), then it must be possible that something is infinitely great as in "infinity".  The concepts "infinity" and "infinitesimals" are not mutually exclusive.

> > > Did they not understand what analysis means? 
> > You don't understand it either.
> I am under the impression that I understand what they did.

Hm. Impressions are one thing, but reality  can be quite different.

> But everybody may misunderstand things from time to time.

Only stubborn people misunderstand after they have been corrected. 

> > > Of course. But I explained already that 1/n (or h/n) has the limit 0 without actual infinity. 
> > Infinity has nothing to do with the limit.
> That is a strange observation.

What is strange about it?  To know that the series 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/8 + ... has a limit of 1 is determined in a finite number of steps.

1.  S(n) =  (1/2 ) [1 - (1/2)^(n)  ]/1/2  =>   S(n)  = 1 - (1/2)^(n)
2.  As n increases indefinitely,  (1/2)^(n) decreases indefinitely so that its lower bound is 0.
3. Conclusion:  S(n->oo) = 1 - 0 = 1

> > > For every m > n, 1/m comes closer to 0 than 1/n. Never a negative value occurs. Every positive value can be undercut. 
> > Wow. You just don't get it, do you?
> I explained what I understand. More I cannot do.

It's more like what you fail to understand.

> > To make a statement such as " For every m > n, 1/m comes closer to 0 than 1/n. " means that you arrive at a conclusion analytically.

> Of course.

So we agree on this. However, this is not what is being discussed.

> > The very act of showing that 1/m gets closer to 0 than 1/n but never reaches 0 means that there is an "infinite number" (in your terminology) of values between 0 and 1/n, just as there are innumerably many finite difference quotients [f(x+h_i)-f(x)]/h_i between x+h_i and x, but NONE at x where it matters most!

> Why should that matter? The limit is not an f(x). It is simply a constant.

Facepalm. May I suggest a reread?  It's like I asked you the time and your response is "there are 2 lemons".  

> > f'(x) = lim (h->0) [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h is fundamentally based on infinity and you cannot find the limit unless you use your flawed first principles method. You have NO valid systematic way of finding the derivative in the bogus mainstream formulation.

> I showed you how it works. 

You showed me how you think it works and I have been telling you that you are wrong.

> You confimed that it supplies the same results as your new calculus. That is hardly an accident.

How is that even relevant to the discussion?

> > 
> > But there is NO guessing where the identity [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h = f ' (x) + Q(x,h) is concerned.

> No, that is obvious.

Now I am confused. Chuckle. If the above identity is obvious, then it proves that limit theory is not required in finding the derivative which is one of the main points I am trying to explain to you!

> > 
> > Look, you can use the following two approaches to find the derivative of f(x)=x^2. 
> > 
> > 1. [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h = 2x + h 
> > 
> > You set h=0 which is the same as tossing away Q(x,h)=h because it is the difference in slopes. You can do this in one step. 
> > 
> > 2. [f(x+h/n)-f(x)]/(h/n) = 2x + h/n 
> > 
> > You can still throw away Q(x, h/n)= h/n because it is the difference in slopes, but if you choose limit theory, then you have a super task lying ahead of you, i.e. you need an n such that h/n = 0.

> Here you misunderstand again. There is no such n in general. But it is not required.

Of course, such an n is required, because in your bogus formulation you have no way of making the constant Q(x, h/n) equal to zero. Hence the limiting process is not only redundant but flawed.


> > There is no such n. Please don't repeat your drivel about "For every m > n, 1/m comes closer to 0 than 1/n." because that is analytical and it is supported by the FACT that between 0 and 1/n there are "infinitely many" fractions.

> Infinitely many means as many as you like. 

"Infinitely many" is not the same as "indefinitely many". 

> Not actual infinity. But you will hardly refuse that there are as many natural numbers as you like and then always one more. Same with prime numbers. Think of Euclid your great compatriot.

There has never been an issue understanding the simple concept which states that you can always find a larger natural number or prime. But this has nothing to do with "infinity".  As for "actual infinity", it is utter nonsense - I am unsure but I think even Aristotle rejected it too.


> > > The ellipsis means in potential infinity "and so on", there are all terms which can be defined. Always finite but no fixed largest. In actual infinity it means all terms larger than 0. But you are right that in no case the sum is 1. Only the limit is 1. 
> > No. There is no such thing as potential or actual infinity because infinity is itself a junk concept.

> Do you deny that for every n there is n+1? If not, then you accept potential infinity.

No. Indefinite =/= Infinity

> > Preceding "infinity" with an adjective doesn't make it any more sensible.
> You misunderstand again.

You keep saying I misunderstand when I have told you that I consider it to be an insult. I am more intelligent than anyone I know. Is it helping your weak arguments to continue insulting me? Chuckle.

> > The Ancient Greeks rejected it in its entirety.
> We don't know much about the Greeks before Aristotle. 

Rubbish. You know little but I know a lot.

> But everybody who rejects that n implies n+1 is certainly not in agreement with Euclid. He did not talk about infinity, but he said that every given set of prime numbers can be increased. 

That is a classic "not a cause for a cause" fallacious argument.

>That means potential infinity.

That is a classic "affirming the consequent" fallacious argument.


> > The only ones who dabbled with the concept were second rate philosophers such as Aristotle, ia.
> He was the first to write about it. He understood the difference between infinities. And he took the right choice.
> > 
> > Potential means "having or showing the capacity to become or develop into something in the future". 
> > 
> > ... does NOT mean having the capacity to become "infinite".
> Right. There is no state "infinite" in classical mathematics. Therefore there cannot exist an f(x) at the limit.

And your point is ...?

> > 
> > "Actual infinity" is a redundancy.
> No.

Denial is not an argument.

> > On its own, infinity is considered an ACTUAL concept. By using that very phrase, one unknowingly admits infinity is impossible. If the concept were sound, then it stands by itself. Can't you see that to accept "potential" or "actual" infinity requires that one first acknowledges infinity?
> Potential infinity does not mean to reach the state "infinite". It only means that for every n there exists n+1.

No. That is only your misunderstanding. "For every n there exists an n+1" has absolutely nothing to do with "infinity", "actual infinity" or "potential infinity".

> > But there is NO definition of infinity that makes even the slightest sense.
> You should read the first chapter of https://www.hs-augsburg.de/~mueckenh/Transfinity/Transfinity/pdf.

I have. It states what you believe which is not altogether correct.

> > 
> > ... means able to carry on indefinitely if so desired. NOTHING about infinity there. Indefinite =/= Infinite. 
> > 
> > No end =/= infinity 
> > No last term =/= infinity
> It is potential infinity.

Um, no. No end =/= infinity  AND/OR  No last term =/= infinity does not imply anything about the idiotic phrase "potential infinity" which was rejected by Aristotle and more importantly is rejected by me.

> > 
> > Because you cannot define any concept by an attribute it lacks.
> Then define it by what it does not lack: For every n there is n+1. That is a splendid explanation. Once it has been understood, it can be extended to other fields. But the natural numbers are the best and most obvious example. 

Infinity can't be defined because it is an ill-formed concept. 

> 
> Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510828

FromWM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de>
Date2021-01-29 14:13 -0800
Message-ID<0790cd39-3778-43c6-8f82-775997fa8bcen@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#510819
Eram semper recta schrieb am Freitag, 29. Januar 2021 um 21:29:35 UTC+1:
> On Thursday, 28 January 2021 at 17:38:30 UTC-5, WM wrote: 


> > "We say that a variable quantity becomes infinitely small when its numerical value decreases indefinitely in such a way as to converge toward the limit zero." [A.-L. Cauchy: "Cours d'analyse de l'Ecole Royale Polytechnique", Paris (1821) p. 26f]
> Thank you! That proves my point. If something is "infinitely small" (whatever that means because it is sheer nonsense), then it must be possible that something is infinitely great as in "infinity". The concepts "infinity" and "infinitesimals" are not mutually exclusive.

Dear John, infinitely small is not 0.
Here is the difference again and for the last time:
Cauchy: The value of 1/n becomes infinitely small.
Cantor: The cardinality of the not enumerated fractions becomes 0.

> > Do you deny that for every n there is n+1? If not, then you accept potential infinity.
> No. Indefinite =/= Infinity

You can be sure that in my understanding this is the basic relation of potential infinity. And every author whom I have read and who accepts potential infinity holds this opinion too. You should accept it, because (1) it is common meaning and (2) indefiniteness has a broader meaning.

> > Potential infinity does not mean to reach the state "infinite". It only means that for every n there exists n+1.
> No. That is only your misunderstanding.

If it is a misunderstanding, then it is the misunderstanding of all except you. But no-one can force you to accept the definition of the majority.

> No last term =/= infinity does not imply anything about the idiotic phrase "potential infinity" which was rejected by Aristotle

That is not a matter of of taste but here you are definitely wrong.

Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510873

FromEram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com>
Date2021-01-30 04:43 -0800
Message-ID<ce11f134-41fd-4665-a6be-5c826b95c3a3n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#510828
On Friday, 29 January 2021 at 17:13:17 UTC-5, WM wrote:
> Eram semper recta schrieb am Freitag, 29. Januar 2021 um 21:29:35 UTC+1: 
> > On Thursday, 28 January 2021 at 17:38:30 UTC-5, WM wrote: 
> 
> 
> > > "We say that a variable quantity becomes infinitely small when its numerical value decreases indefinitely in such a way as to converge toward the limit zero." [A.-L. Cauchy: "Cours d'analyse de l'Ecole Royale Polytechnique", Paris (1821) p. 26f] 
> > Thank you! That proves my point. If something is "infinitely small" (whatever that means because it is sheer nonsense), then it must be possible that something is infinitely great as in "infinity". The concepts "infinity" and "infinitesimals" are not mutually exclusive.
> Dear John, infinitely small is not 0. 

Now you are using strawman arguments: I never said "infinitely small" is zero. I said it is nonsense.

> Here is the difference again and for the last time: 
> Cauchy: The value of 1/n becomes infinitely small. 
> Cantor: The cardinality of the not enumerated fractions becomes 0.

Both the above claims are utter rubbish. In the first, "infinitely small" is incomprehensible to any rational mind. The second is your interpretation of what Cantor claimed, which is pure assertion.

> > > Do you deny that for every n there is n+1? If not, then you accept potential infinity. 
> > No. Indefinite =/= Infinity
> You can be sure that in my understanding this is the basic relation of potential infinity. And every author whom I have read and who accepts potential infinity holds this opinion too. You should accept it, because (1) it is common meaning and (2) indefiniteness has a broader meaning.
> > > Potential infinity does not mean to reach the state "infinite". It only means that for every n there exists n+1. 
> > No. That is only your misunderstanding.
> If it is a misunderstanding, then it is the misunderstanding of all except you. 

This is false. There are a few other mainstream math professors who have seen the light.

> But no-one can force you to accept the definition of the majority.

Mathematics is not the opinion of the majority and is not done according to the whimsical understanding of the mob.

> > No last term =/= infinity does not imply anything about the idiotic phrase "potential infinity" which was rejected by Aristotle
> That is not a matter of of taste but here you are definitely wrong. 

No Wolfgang. I am absolutely correct. Firstly, whether Aristotle realised "potential infinity" or not, does not affect the truth. Secondly, nothing should be about taste or bias in mathematics, only of sound reason.

"Aristotle postulated that an actual infinity was impossible, because if it were possible, then something would have attained infinite magnitude, and would be "bigger than the heavens." - Your beloved Wikipedia.

Modern Greek academics are for the most part incorrigibly stupid because they are steeped in religion and superstition otherwise they would have backed me up. Aristotle was not a "god".  He was a philosopher first and foremost. He was not even a mathematician in any solid respect. His knowledge of mathematics was far less than that of his contemporaries. 

Thirdly, "potential infinity" does not mean for every n there is an n+1. This claim is pure **deductive** reasoning. You like to think that "potential infinity" = "for every n there is an n+1", but that is merely your assertion. In fact, there is no definition like this in any published text. Even if there were, I would reject it because it is wrong in every respect. "for every n there is an n+1" tells one nothing about "infinity", never mind "potential infinity".

What is "infinity"?

"Infinity represents something that is boundless or endless, or else something that is larger than any real or natural number." - Wikipedia

Is it a number? Is it space? Is it a series?  It's "something"? A unicorn? A clandestine spirit? A galactic banana? The ellipsis "..." ?

Just try putting "actual" before any of the above to see how idiotic it sounds!

No. It's just plain nonsense.

> 
> Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510972

FromSergio <invalid@invalid.com>
Date2021-01-31 09:16 -0600
Message-ID<rv6hl9$p8b$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#510828
On 1/29/2021 4:13 PM, WM wrote:
> Eram semper recta schrieb am Freitag, 29. Januar 2021 um 21:29:35 UTC+1:
>> On Thursday, 28 January 2021 at 17:38:30 UTC-5, WM wrote: 
> 
> 
>>> "We say that a variable quantity becomes infinitely small when its numerical value decreases indefinitely in such a way as to converge toward the limit zero." [A.-L. Cauchy: "Cours d'analyse de l'Ecole Royale Polytechnique", Paris (1821) p. 26f]
>> Thank you! That proves my point. If something is "infinitely small" (whatever that means because it is sheer nonsense), then it must be possible that something is infinitely great as in "infinity". The concepts "infinity" and "infinitesimals" are not mutually exclusive.
> 
> Dear John, infinitely small is not 0.

if you can't tell the difference, they are the same.




> Here is the difference again and for the last time:
> Cauchy: The value of 1/n becomes infinitely small.

you left out, " as n => oo "

[and no stopping either! that is *failed infinity*, not potential infinity]




> Cantor: The cardinality of the not enumerated fractions becomes 0.

total red herring.


> 
>>> Do you deny that for every n there is n+1? If not, then you accept potential infinity.
>> No. Indefinite =/= Infinity
> 
> You can be sure that in my understanding this is the basic relation of potential infinity. And every author whom I have read and who accepts potential infinity holds this opinion too. You should accept it, because (1) it is common meaning and (2) indefiniteness has a broader meaning.

so WM states potential infinity is the opinion of a few.
it has no definition in Math, ask WM to define it.

  potential = not





> 
>>> Potential infinity does not mean to reach the state "infinite". It only means that for every n there exists n+1.
>> No. That is only your misunderstanding.
> 
> If it is a misunderstanding, then it is the misunderstanding of all except you. But no-one can force you to accept the definition of the majority.

  WM is recruiting JG !!

    Will WM's math finally fix JG's math ?

        OR will JG's math cure WM's math ?

[millions, no Billions of world wide newsgroup lurkers want to know!
well, perhaps 3 or so]



> 
>> No last term =/= infinity does not imply anything about the idiotic phrase "potential infinity" which was rejected by Aristotle
> 
> That is not a matter of of taste but here you are definitely wrong.

 journal article
Aristotelian Infinity
Jaakko Hintikka

https://www.jstor.org/stable/2183083?seq=1

> 
> Regards, WM
> 

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#511040

From"zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com>
Date2021-01-31 22:21 -0800
Message-ID<1bfefbfa-eb5d-40c1-8caf-6588cdc5974bn@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#510819
>Absolutely not. Misunderstanding is not a common attribute of mine. But I have shown that you do misunderstand repeatedly. 

HAH! You misunderstand most of mathematics!

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510778

From"zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com>
Date2021-01-28 22:18 -0800
Message-ID<b1baaace-af66-4919-b829-375f51b86ea8n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#510743
>Because you cannot define any concept by an attribute it lacks.

Sure you can, that is what most "un-" and "im-" words are based on :)

Unpopular is defined in the lack of popularity.

But for sets we don't need to define it by what it lacks, we can define it in terms of an not surjective injective endomorphism.

>A well-formed concept has boundaries that are known and clear. 

So does negation of properties.

Because if "property X" has a clear boundary, then the moundary of "not property X" is equally clear, it is just broader.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510715

Fromkonyberg <konyberg@online.no>
Date2021-01-28 05:52 -0800
Message-ID<0dba0a64-c463-46bd-9726-d0758d714969n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#510710
torsdag 28. januar 2021 kl. 13:37:25 UTC+1 skrev Eram semper recta:
> On Wednesday, 27 January 2021 at 16:53:49 UTC-5, WM wrote: 
> > Eram semper recta schrieb am Mittwoch, 27. Januar 2021 um 19:28:47 UTC+1: 
> > > On Wednesday, 27 January 2021 at 07:25:42 UTC-5, WM wrote: 
> > > The analogy you use in your set theory argument is equivalent to taking the limit of a derivative. 
> > The limit of the derivative does not imply actual infinity or "all" terms.
> First of all, there is no such thing as "the limit of the derivative". The limit _IS_ the derivative. 
> Secondly, it DOES imply an actual infinity or ALL terms: 
> 
> [f(x+h_1)-f(x)]/h_1; [f(x+h_2)-f(x)]/h_2; [f(x+h_3)-f(x)]/h_3; ... [f(x+h_i)-f(x)]/h_i; ... [limit = ultimate ratio] 
> 
> Ironically, there is no ultimate ratio because 0/0 is garbage. 
> 
> The mainstream LIMIT definition does not even care if the function is defined at the point of tangency and that is why a stipulation is added that for the LIMIT to be the DERIVATIVE, it is required that f(c) be defined.
> > The claim of set theory that *all* terms can be indexed requires a state where this has been done.
> Not in any way different to the definition of limit in f'(x) = lim (h->0) [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h. 
> 
> 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/8 + ... = 1 does NOT require ALL the terms to be there or even to be there at all. 
> 
> So, set theory says exactly the same in BOTH cases. You can't cherry pick where you apply your arguments. Either you apply the same argument to ALL or to NONE. 
> 
> > 
> > Regards, WM
Just to be sure. What do you mean by "all the terms" ?
KON

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510726

FromWM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de>
Date2021-01-28 07:48 -0800
Message-ID<f1dad072-8428-4961-9d1f-806c2ed0ec09n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#510715
konyberg schrieb am Donnerstag, 28. Januar 2021 um 14:52:37 UTC+1:

> > 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/8 + ... = 1 does NOT require ALL the terms to be there or even to be there at all. 

> Just to be sure. What do you mean by "all the terms" ? 

None is missing.

Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510727

FromEram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com>
Date2021-01-28 08:04 -0800
Message-ID<37182572-7415-47f9-8718-de7378dd4ffan@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#510726
On Thursday, 28 January 2021 at 10:48:58 UTC-5, WM wrote:
> konyberg schrieb am Donnerstag, 28. Januar 2021 um 14:52:37 UTC+1: 
> 
> > > 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/8 + ... = 1 does NOT require ALL the terms to be there or even to be there at all.
> > Just to be sure. What do you mean by "all the terms" ?
> None is missing. 

In the above series, almost ALL the terms are missing. There are only three terms in that series. The ellipsis means that you can carry on indefinitely. Nothing about infinity there.

> 
> Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510728

FromEram semper recta <thenewcalculus@gmail.com>
Date2021-01-28 08:19 -0800
Message-ID<856d2b55-31d5-4f79-970f-3f0373f9aa63n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#510727
On Thursday, 28 January 2021 at 11:04:25 UTC-5, Eram semper recta wrote:
> On Thursday, 28 January 2021 at 10:48:58 UTC-5, WM wrote: 
> > konyberg schrieb am Donnerstag, 28. Januar 2021 um 14:52:37 UTC+1: 
> > 
> > > > 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/8 + ... = 1 does NOT require ALL the terms to be there or even to be there at all. 

To be certain, 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/8 + ... = 1   does not literally mean the LHS = RHS. This foolishness was introduced by Leonhard Euler and his infamous S = Lim S:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B-mOEooW03iLdmRRbFByd0M0QTA

> > > Just to be sure. What do you mean by "all the terms" ? 
> > None is missing.
> In the above series, almost ALL the terms are missing. There are only three terms in that series. The ellipsis means that you can carry on indefinitely. Nothing about infinity there. 
> 
> > 
> > Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510749

FromHeywood Jablome <heywood@jablome.net>
Date2021-01-28 12:12 -0800
Message-ID<ruv5r1$1oa1$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#510728
Get a brain you boring retarded lunatic.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510734

FromWM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de>
Date2021-01-28 09:05 -0800
Message-ID<896ee5cd-0144-4fc0-a231-3173a3eb8df2n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#510727
Eram semper recta schrieb am Donnerstag, 28. Januar 2021 um 17:04:25 UTC+1:
> On Thursday, 28 January 2021 at 10:48:58 UTC-5, WM wrote: 
> > konyberg schrieb am Donnerstag, 28. Januar 2021 um 14:52:37 UTC+1: 
> > 
> > > > 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/8 + ... = 1 does NOT require ALL the terms to be there or even to be there at all. 
> > > Just to be sure. What do you mean by "all the terms" ? 
> > None is missing.
> In the above series, almost ALL the terms are missing. There are only three terms in that series. The ellipsis means that you can carry on indefinitely. Nothing about infinity there. 

The ellipsis means in potential infinity "and so on",  there are all terms which can be defined. Always finite but no fixed largest. In actual infinity it means all terms larger than 0. But you are right that in no case the sum is 1. Only the limit is 1.

Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510698

From"zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com>
Date2021-01-28 01:47 -0800
Message-ID<3916fe47-1d33-4c1d-b2c6-8858fc45dc38n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#510644
onsdag 27 januari 2021 kl. 19:28:47 UTC+1 skrev Eram semper recta:
> On Wednesday, 27 January 2021 at 07:25:42 UTC-5, WM wrote: 
> > Eram semper recta schrieb am Dienstag, 26. Januar 2021 um 16:28:16 UTC+1: 
> > > On Monday, 25 January 2021 at 07:53:42 UTC-5, WM wrote: 
> > > > Eram semper recta schrieb am Montag, 25. Januar 2021 um 13:26:49 UTC+1: 
> > > > > On Sunday, 24 January 2021 at 08:22:24 UTC-5, WM wrote: 
> > > > 
> > > > > > When differentiating x^2, then we get lim (2xh + h^2)/h. This does not require to go the complete trace of h reaching 0. 
> > > > > The identity (f(x+h) - f(x))/h = f'(x) + Q(x, h) was conceived from the rigorous formulation of the New Calculus: 
> > > > The identity is not new. I learned it already 50 years ago. 
> > > Nowhere was this identity published as part of a theorem, so how could you have known about it 50 years ago? 
> > It is a triviality. (f(x+h) - f(x))/h is usually different from f'(x). This difference, depending on x and h, is denoted by a function of x and h. And if f(x) is a straight line, then Q is zero. I don't remember whether my professor at Göttingen called it Q. But that does not matter. A similar expression appears in estimating the error in Taylor approximations R(x, n). 
> > > > > 
> > > > You misunderstand the limit. 
> > > This is as good as insulting me. Did you even stop to think about this? You make a FALSE statement from what evidence? 
> > No. The statement is true because in the limit your Q disappears.
> Nonsense man! Q(x,h) never disappears. Nothing ever disappears. It is simply discarded as the ***difference in slopes***. If Newton and Leibniz knew these things, there would have been no vanishing quantities, ultimate ratios, infinitesimals and other bullshit. 
> 
> You should study that article I wrote which proves the theorem.
> > > > Here is the simplest explanation known to me and applied over 30 years of teaching practice: The limit of the sequence (1/n) is zero. This does *not* mean that it can be reached. On the contrary, after every n, there are infinitely many terms following. 
> > 
> > > You don't say?!! Chuckle. The problem is "infinitely many" which you so gleefully denigrate in set theory but can't see that you are doing precisely the same thing with f '(x) = Lim (h->0) [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h. 
> > No. 
> > > > It only means that every real number other than zero does not satisfy the conditions. 
> > > What is a "real number"? 
> > You should know that. But you can replace it by: every rational number other than zero does not satisfy the conditions.
> Again nonsense. This is what is called a tautology: you telling me in different words what a "real number" is not. You cannot tell me what is a "real number". You once called it a function, which I explained to you is utter rubbish.
> > > > 
> > > > In set theory, on the contrary, it is assumed that all n exist and can be applied and surpassed. That leads to the existence of a state beyond all. And that is nonsense or at least dark. 
> > 
> > > It is also assumed in the derivative definition that all the finite differences exist and can be applied and surpassed to the derivative which is formulated as a LIMIT. 
> 
> > You misunderstand. Unfortunately most set theorists misunderstand this in the same way and claim Cantor's completed infinity is necessary to have a sound base.
> The way set theorists understand is not the way I understand for otherwise, I wouldn't be talking about the historic geometric theorem which I proved for the FIRST time in January 2020.
> > No, John. There is no reason to accept that all n exist in order to know that (1/n) cannot have any other limit than 0.
> Your argument against set theorists is that YOU require all sequences to exist and what I am telling you is that this is exactly the same as the derivative or definite integral formulated in terms of a limit.
> > 
> > The simplest argument is this: For every m > n, 1/m comes closer to 0 than 1/n. Never a negative value occurs. Every positive value can be undercut.
> This is not what is being discussed. No one is taking issue with that statement. 
> 
> Once again: The analogy you use in your set theory argument is equivalent to taking the limit of a derivative. That is, your opponent can tell you that you are applying double standards - one to set theory and another to the derivative with limits. 
> 
> Try to understand it! 
> 
> > 
> > Regards, WM

>Again nonsense. This is what is called a tautology: you telling me in different words what a "real number" is not. You cannot tell me what is a "real number". You once called it a function, which I explained to you is utter rubbish. 

I'll do it for you then, an element in the terminal archimedian field :)

We can construct it in many ways, all isomorphic.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510631

From"zelos...@gmail.com" <zelos.malum@gmail.com>
Date2021-01-27 06:16 -0800
Message-ID<34aa7886-abc3-4a63-90f7-d0a9df9241c4n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#510557
>Nowhere was this identity published as part of a theorem, so how could you have known about it 50 years ago?

Not everything is put into theorems if they are considered sufficietnly self-evident from other more important theorems.

>This is as good as insulting me. Did you even stop to think about this? You make a FALSE statement from what evidence?

From countless observatinos about you behavior and demonstrations.

>What is a "real number"? Chuckle.

The elements of the terminal archimedian field.

WE can construct it in dozens fo different ways.

>Keep going you pathetic crank

The crank is you by definition.

>It is such fun making a fool of you but it gets boring quickly.

More that you hate being shown wrong as you can never rebute anything.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510345

FromSergio <invalid@invalid.com>
Date2021-01-23 13:48 -0600
Message-ID<ruhuiq$o1s$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#510307
On 1/23/2021 7:39 AM, WM wrote:
> Eram semper recta schrieb am Samstag, 23. Januar 2021 um 12:47:27 UTC+1:
>> On Saturday, 23 January 2021 at 05:34:17 UTC-5, WM wrote: 
> 
>> You say all of the above and yet you still cling to nonsense like f '(x) = lim (h->0) [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h which says precisely that a converging sequence of finite differences (slopes of non-parallel secant lines as per the idiots Newton and Leibniz) is produced at step h=0.
> 
> No John. It is the limit. It will never be produced.

only because you stopped.

Or you assign a finite amount of time for each number, which is boopus.

> Between every h and 0 there are infinitely many numbers, say of the form 1/n. All we know is convergence, i.e., approachimng the limit better and better. Only set theory claims that all of them can be passed or used to enumerate a comparable nonsensical set.
> 
>> So what's different, does McDuck apply selectively? Chuckle. 
> 
> Set theory with its claim that all natnumbers exist and can be used is obliged to produce a state where this has happenden. Otherwise the claim would be void. McDuck only shows that as soon as this has happened there is a big clash.
> 
> Regards, WM
> 

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510313

FromWM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de>
Date2021-01-23 06:23 -0800
Message-ID<e5853611-86a2-4bb9-b8b8-3a4943c3dd8an@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#510298
Eram semper recta schrieb am Samstag, 23. Januar 2021 um 12:47:27 UTC+1:

> Discovery of my historic geometric theorem in January 2020: 
> 
> https://drive.google.com/file/d/1RDulODvgncItTe7qNI1d8KTN5bl0aTXj 

I see your formula (f(x+h) - f(x))/h = f'(x) + Q(x, h). It is correct with no doubt. But your geometric way seems rather involved. What is its advantage? Do you also obtain the derivative 3x^2 of x^3? Can you show any example where your way yields a result differing from the usual calculus? 

Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510347

FromSergio <invalid@invalid.com>
Date2021-01-23 13:53 -0600
Message-ID<ruhur2$uit$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#510313
On 1/23/2021 8:23 AM, WM wrote:
> Eram semper recta schrieb am Samstag, 23. Januar 2021 um 12:47:27 UTC+1:
> 
>> Discovery of my historic geometric theorem in January 2020: 
>>
>> https://drive.google.com/file/d/1RDulODvgncItTe7qNI1d8KTN5bl0aTXj 
> 
> I see your formula (f(x+h) - f(x))/h = f'(x) + Q(x, h). It is correct with no doubt.

no, it is wrong.

   Q(x,h) is the Quack function, the fudge factor to fix major error in
JG flawed math.

> But your geometric way seems rather involved. What is its advantage? Do you also obtain the derivative 3x^2 of x^3? Can you show any example where your way yields a result differing from the usual calculus? 


> 
> Regards, WM
> 

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#510327

FromDan Christensen <Dan_Christensen@sympatico.ca>
Date2021-01-23 09:26 -0800
Message-ID<1cb8363b-dbd7-441f-ae08-8e30a548aa1an@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#510298
On Saturday, January 23, 2021 at 6:47:27 AM UTC-5, Eram semper recta wrote:
> On Saturday, 23 January 2021 at 05:34:17 UTC-5, WM wrote: 
> > The analytical limit of a strictly monotonic sequence (a_n) is not produced at any step n. Every term a_n differs from this constant. Infinitely many terms can be identified without producing the limit. But never *all* natnumbers could be applied. Here we have potential infinity. 
> > 
> > In the same way the limit of a strictly monotonic sequence of sets (s_n) is not produced at any step n. Every term s_n differs from this constant. Infinitely many terms can be identified without producing the limit. 
> > 
> > But all terms s_n exist such that none is missing. And the limit ω exists beyond which the sequence does not continue. That means between all n and ω+1 we have the limit. It is s_ω. 
> > 
> > According to set theory this limit can be reached. *All* natural numbers are available with no exception to enumerate *all* fractions with no exception. Set theory claims that all natnumbers exist and *can* be applied. This implies that there exists a state where all natnumbers *have* been applied. Otherwise the claim was void. But when all natnumbers have been applied, then the task has been finished and there are no natnumbers and no fractions remaining. This shows strict equinumerosity which disproved by mathematics. 
> > 
> > With special consideration of McDuck: It is not sufficient to show that every element is indexed without ever finishing. The bathtube picture is not sufficient. As soon as you claim that all steps and all natnumbers n exist and *can* be applied, you also claim that there is a state where all *have* been applied and run through. It is at ω. There happens the clash. 
> > 
> > Regards WM
> You say all of the above and yet you still cling to nonsense like f '(x) = lim (h->0) [f(x+h)-f(x)]/h which says precisely that a converging sequence of finite differences (slopes of non-parallel secant lines as per the idiots Newton and Leibniz) is produced at step h=0. Well, this is what moronic set theorists claim in their grand ignorance. So what's different, does McDuck apply selectively? Chuckle. 
> 
> Mainstream calculus is a fraud: 
> 
> Discovery of my historic geometric theorem in January 2020: 
> 

You "historic" theorem is a joke, Troll Boy. 


Because JG never did understand limit theory, his Wacky New Cal-CLUELESS lacks a workable definition of the derivative of a function. His goofy little system blows up even for functions as simple as f(x)=|x|. As any working scientist or engineer call tell you, in this case, the derivative is -1 for x<0, +1 for x>0 and undefined for x=0.

Sorry, Troll Boy, but your ridiculous patch banning 0 and negative numbers simply won't cut it with that crowd. Your Wacky New Cal-CLUELESS remains a dead end. After 30+ years of flogging this dead horse of yours, don't you think it is time to cut your losses and move on?

Even at his advanced age (60+?), John Gabriel is STILL struggling with basic, elementary-school arithmetic. As he has repeatedly posted here:

"Pi is NOT a number of ANY kind!"                         
--July 10, 2020

"1/2 not equal to 2/4"
--October 22, 2017

“1/3 does NOT mean 1 divided by 3 and never has meant that”
-- February 8, 2015      

"3 =< 4 is nonsense.”
--October 28, 2017     

"Zero is not a number."
-- Dec. 2, 2019

"0 is not required at all in mathematics, just like negative numbers."
-- Jan. 4, 2017 

“There is no such thing as an empty set.”  
--Oct. 4, 2019

“3 <=> 2 + 1  or  3 <=>  8 - 5, etc, are all propositions”   (actually all are meaningless gibberish)           
--Oct. 22, 2019

No math genius our JG, though he actually lists his job title as “mathematician” at Linkedin.com. Apparently, they do not verify your credentials. 


Though really quite disturbing, interested readers should see: “About the spamming troll John Gabriel in his own words...” (lasted updated March 10, 2020) at https://groups.google.com/forum/#!msg/sci.math/PcpAzX5pDeY/1PDiSlK_BwAJ 

Dan

Download my DC Proof 2.0 freeware at http://www.dcproof.com
Visit my Math Blog a http://www.dcproof.wordpress.com

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


Page 3 of 4 — ← Prev page 1 2 [3] 4  Next page →

Back to top | Article view | sci.math


csiph-web