Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > sci.math > #509290 > unrolled thread

The new Aleph; different than the old aleph...

Started byTimothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com>
First post2021-01-10 07:08 -0800
Last post2021-01-18 08:51 -0800
Articles 8 — 3 participants

Back to article view | Back to sci.math


Contents

  The new Aleph; different than the old aleph... Timothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com> - 2021-01-10 07:08 -0800
    Re: The new Aleph; different than the old aleph... Jim Burns <james.g.burns@att.net> - 2021-01-10 12:51 -0500
      Re: The new Aleph; different than the old aleph... Timothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com> - 2021-01-10 13:23 -0800
        Re: The new Aleph; different than the old aleph... Jim Burns <james.g.burns@att.net> - 2021-01-10 20:30 -0500
          Re: The new Aleph; different than the old aleph... Timothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com> - 2021-01-12 06:36 -0800
            Re: The new Aleph; different than the old aleph... Timothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com> - 2021-01-15 06:21 -0800
              Re: The new Aleph; different than the old aleph... Timothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com> - 2021-01-18 06:31 -0800
                Re: The new Aleph; different than the old aleph... Ebenezer Splooge <esplooge@hotmail.com> - 2021-01-18 08:51 -0800

#509290 — The new Aleph; different than the old aleph...

FromTimothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com>
Date2021-01-10 07:08 -0800
SubjectThe new Aleph; different than the old aleph...
Message-ID<e5b8e14c-fc17-4a15-a130-4c3f846ee0c7n@googlegroups.com>
Meet the new Aleph;
Different from the old Aleph;
Not every set gets one.
For if a set is not complete there can be no Aleph in it.
Perhaps...
Subsetting as Supersetting
can no longer hold true
under the new Aleph.
Why else do we have the natural numbers?
the real numbers?
the complex numbers?
the rational numbers?
the integers?
polysign numbers?

Is a subset merely an inverse superset?
No; not under the new Aleph.
If a set is incomplete then it can have no Aleph.
The Aleph is a mark of purity.
The Aleph is a mark of completion.
The Aleph is a mark of return.
The Aleph is an exceptional character.
It marks an exceptional position of a set.

Let it be known that one man's Omega is another man's Aleph.
That the modulo condition is not trivium.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trivium
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8VqQPBrhmaY

[toc] | [next] | [standalone]


#509295

FromJim Burns <james.g.burns@att.net>
Date2021-01-10 12:51 -0500
Message-ID<38497e23-6524-c1cb-559b-09260a79c914@att.net>
In reply to#509290
On 1/10/2021 10:08 AM, Timothy Golden wrote:

> Meet the new Aleph;
> Different from the old Aleph;

A Long, Long Time Ago
(several ice ages ago, measured in internet-time),
Henry Ford said, about the Model-T,
"You can have any color you want, as long as it is black".

So, you had a situation where,
| if X is a Model-T, then X is black.

It's obviously an error to treat that the same as
the situation where,
| if X is black, then X is a Model-T.

Here, you are making an error similar to that.

There are these things we are interested in,
whatever we call them. We call them "infinite cardinalities"
or "alephs" or "flying rainbow sparkle ponies".
The particular name we use (the particular color we paint them)
won't change the nature of the things we are interested in.

If _you_ call _some other thing_ "aleph", what _we_ are
interested in, what _we_ are talking about, hasn't changed.
Calling _something else_ "aleph" is like painting
_something else_ black, like a flagpole or a chicken coop,
and, I guess? feeling that what you have must therefore have
something like a Model-T.

If (a hypothetical) someone really pushed this line of argument,
the most that they could get out of it would be the claim that
this black chicken coop here is really an automobile. To that
(still hypothetical) someone: no, it isn't.

> Not every set gets one.
> For if a set is not complete there can be no Aleph in it.
> Perhaps...
> Subsetting as Supersetting
> can no longer hold true
> under the new Aleph.
> Why else do we have the natural numbers?
> the real numbers?
> the complex numbers?
> the rational numbers?
> the integers?
> polysign numbers?
> 
> Is a subset merely an inverse superset?
> No; not under the new Aleph.
> If a set is incomplete then it can have no Aleph.
> The Aleph is a mark of purity.
> The Aleph is a mark of completion.
> The Aleph is a mark of return.
> The Aleph is an exceptional character.
> It marks an exceptional position of a set.
> 
> Let it be known that one man's Omega is another man's Aleph.
> That the modulo condition is not trivium.
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trivium
> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8VqQPBrhmaY
> 

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#509332

FromTimothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com>
Date2021-01-10 13:23 -0800
Message-ID<92c5de9b-0dfc-47b2-b2bd-c154be8588a6n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#509295
On Sunday, January 10, 2021 at 12:51:51 PM UTC-5, Jim Burns wrote:
> On 1/10/2021 10:08 AM, Timothy Golden wrote: 
> 
> > Meet the new Aleph; 
> > Different from the old Aleph;
> A Long, Long Time Ago 
> (several ice ages ago, measured in internet-time), 
> Henry Ford said, about the Model-T, 
> "You can have any color you want, as long as it is black". 
> 
> So, you had a situation where, 
> | if X is a Model-T, then X is black. 
> 
> It's obviously an error to treat that the same as 
> the situation where, 
> | if X is black, then X is a Model-T. 
> 
> Here, you are making an error similar to that. 
> 
> There are these things we are interested in, 
> whatever we call them. We call them "infinite cardinalities" 
> or "alephs" or "flying rainbow sparkle ponies". 
> The particular name we use (the particular color we paint them) 
> won't change the nature of the things we are interested in. 
> 
> If _you_ call _some other thing_ "aleph", what _we_ are 
> interested in, what _we_ are talking about, hasn't changed. 
> Calling _something else_ "aleph" is like painting 
> _something else_ black, like a flagpole or a chicken coop, 
> and, I guess? feeling that what you have must therefore have 
> something like a Model-T. 
> 
> If (a hypothetical) someone really pushed this line of argument, 
> the most that they could get out of it would be the claim that 
> this black chicken coop here is really an automobile. To that 
> (still hypothetical) someone: no, it isn't.
> > Not every set gets one. 
> > For if a set is not complete there can be no Aleph in it. 
> > Perhaps... 
> > Subsetting as Supersetting 
> > can no longer hold true 
> > under the new Aleph. 
> > Why else do we have the natural numbers? 
> > the real numbers? 
> > the complex numbers? 
> > the rational numbers? 
> > the integers? 
> > polysign numbers? 
> > 
> > Is a subset merely an inverse superset? 
> > No; not under the new Aleph. 
> > If a set is incomplete then it can have no Aleph. 
> > The Aleph is a mark of purity. 
> > The Aleph is a mark of completion. 
> > The Aleph is a mark of return. 
> > The Aleph is an exceptional character. 
> > It marks an exceptional position of a set. 
> > 
> > Let it be known that one man's Omega is another man's Aleph. 
> > That the modulo condition is not trivium. 
> > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trivium 
> > https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8VqQPBrhmaY 
> >

Bullshit Jim.

Let me restate your statement:
   " A set with an aleph appended to its end is not a set"
Agree? This is going to be way too easy for me to win, and I know you play fair.
Game On Jim.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#509357

FromJim Burns <james.g.burns@att.net>
Date2021-01-10 20:30 -0500
Message-ID<24c119ea-ecc1-009e-9924-5f425b075f97@att.net>
In reply to#509332
On 1/10/2021 4:23 PM, Timothy Golden wrote:
> On Sunday, January 10, 2021 at 12:51:51 PM UTC-5,
> Jim Burns wrote:
>> On 1/10/2021 10:08 AM, Timothy Golden wrote:

>>> Meet the new Aleph;
>>> Different from the old Aleph;
>>
>> A Long, Long Time Ago
>> (several ice ages ago, measured in internet-time),
>> Henry Ford said, about the Model-T,
>> "You can have any color you want, as long as it is black".
>>
>> So, you had a situation where,
>> | if X is a Model-T, then X is black.
>>
>> It's obviously an error to treat that the same as
>> the situation where,
>> | if X is black, then X is a Model-T.
>>
>> Here, you are making an error similar to that.
>>
>> There are these things we are interested in,
>> whatever we call them. We call them "infinite cardinalities"
>> or "alephs" or "flying rainbow sparkle ponies".
>> The particular name we use (the particular color we paint them)
>> won't change the nature of the things we are interested in.
>>
>> If _you_ call _some other thing_ "aleph", what _we_ are
>> interested in, what _we_ are talking about, hasn't changed.
>> Calling _something else_ "aleph" is like painting
>> _something else_ black, like a flagpole or a chicken coop,
>> and, I guess? feeling that what you have must therefore have
>> something like a Model-T.
>>
>> If (a hypothetical) someone really pushed this line of argument,
>> the most that they could get out of it would be the claim that
>> this black chicken coop here is really an automobile. To that
>> (still hypothetical) someone: no, it isn't.

> Bullshit Jim.
> 
> Let me restate your statement:
> "A set with an aleph appended to its end is not a set"

Did you mean to say that's *my* statement?

I'm going to have to deny ownership of it.

I'm not sure I know what you mean by that sentence, but,
for every reasonable reading that occurs to me for
"Is one infinite set appended to another infinite set
a set?", the answer is "Yes, it is a set".

> Agree? This is going to be way too easy for me to win,
> and I know you play fair.

Uhm, thanks?
While I am willing to be praised for my honesty,
it's (honestly) not so extraordinary in this instance.

Mathematics is an open game, like chess or tic-tac-toe.
I only _need_ to be honest enough to not run a red light
_in front of a police car_

> Game On Jim.

If you like.

My point about calling something different "aleph"
also applies to calling something different "set".
You do not have it in your power to change _what we mean_
by "set".

There is a set operation known as _disjoint union_
We can use that to _append_ set B to set A.
({0}xA) U ({1}xB)

({0}xA) U ({1}xB) is a set of ordered pairs (i,x)
(hence, _a set_ ).
The first entry i is either 0 or 1, the second x is either
an element of A or an element of B.

I take it, from the way you're talking, that
sets A and B have internal orders. I'll write them as
x <' y if x and y are in A, and
x <" y if x and y are in B.

We can define an order on ({0}xA) U ({1}xB) as
(i,x) < (j,j)  if and only if
i < j, or
i = j and
(x <' y for x,y in A) or
(x <" y for x,y in B)

All the elements of B come after all the elements of A,
but otherwise they keep their same internal orders in A
and in B.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#509495

FromTimothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com>
Date2021-01-12 06:36 -0800
Message-ID<bc1c0d1d-e51c-4550-b9b5-a78c33c6707en@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#509357
On Sunday, January 10, 2021 at 8:31:10 PM UTC-5, Jim Burns wrote:
> On 1/10/2021 4:23 PM, Timothy Golden wrote: 
> > On Sunday, January 10, 2021 at 12:51:51 PM UTC-5, 
> > Jim Burns wrote: 
> >> On 1/10/2021 10:08 AM, Timothy Golden wrote: 
> 
> >>> Meet the new Aleph; 
> >>> Different from the old Aleph; 
> >> 
> >> A Long, Long Time Ago 
> >> (several ice ages ago, measured in internet-time), 
> >> Henry Ford said, about the Model-T, 
> >> "You can have any color you want, as long as it is black". 
> >> 
> >> So, you had a situation where, 
> >> | if X is a Model-T, then X is black. 
> >> 
> >> It's obviously an error to treat that the same as 
> >> the situation where, 
> >> | if X is black, then X is a Model-T. 
> >> 
> >> Here, you are making an error similar to that. 
> >> 
> >> There are these things we are interested in, 
> >> whatever we call them. We call them "infinite cardinalities" 
> >> or "alephs" or "flying rainbow sparkle ponies". 
> >> The particular name we use (the particular color we paint them) 
> >> won't change the nature of the things we are interested in. 
> >> 
> >> If _you_ call _some other thing_ "aleph", what _we_ are 
> >> interested in, what _we_ are talking about, hasn't changed. 
> >> Calling _something else_ "aleph" is like painting 
> >> _something else_ black, like a flagpole or a chicken coop, 
> >> and, I guess? feeling that what you have must therefore have 
> >> something like a Model-T. 
> >> 
> >> If (a hypothetical) someone really pushed this line of argument, 
> >> the most that they could get out of it would be the claim that 
> >> this black chicken coop here is really an automobile. To that 
> >> (still hypothetical) someone: no, it isn't.
> > Bullshit Jim. 
> > 
> > Let me restate your statement: 
> > "A set with an aleph appended to its end is not a set"
> Did you mean to say that's *my* statement? 
> 
> I'm going to have to deny ownership of it. 
> 
> I'm not sure I know what you mean by that sentence, but, 
> for every reasonable reading that occurs to me for 
> "Is one infinite set appended to another infinite set 
> a set?", the answer is "Yes, it is a set".
> > Agree? This is going to be way too easy for me to win, 
> > and I know you play fair.
> Uhm, thanks? 
> While I am willing to be praised for my honesty, 
> it's (honestly) not so extraordinary in this instance. 
> 
> Mathematics is an open game, like chess or tic-tac-toe. 

Indeed, and you seem to have a need to lean on the infinite form.
I have no need of such a lien.
If it works in n and it works in n+1 then we have sufficient room.

> I only _need_ to be honest enough to not run a red light 
> _in front of a police car_ 
> 
> > Game On Jim. 
> 
> If you like. 
> 
> My point about calling something different "aleph" 
> also applies to calling something different "set". 
> You do not have it in your power to change _what we mean_ 
> by "set". 

Ahh, but this is exactly what your first return is lacking in: exact falsification. You've built an analogy to cars and colors, but the translation of your interpretation remains to be exactly stated doesn't it? Wouldn't you care to correct the words that I put in your mouth? Perhaps you are doing this here, and that is good. You are good. What we mean by set versus what we mean by say the natural numbers... the real numbers... are we clear that there is quite some difference between the set of reals R versus the set
   R1 = { 1.23, 2.34, 3.45 } ? (where these are elements of R)

It is clear to me that R1 as a subset is lacking in quality to R. Some in fact worship the set R and make it their life's work to do something called real analysis. You want to talk about what we mean by real? Hah, side tracks alight...

The notion of a complete set versus a subset is a notion that I believe is lacking from the ordinary form of set theory. A set is a set is a set right? A subset of a set is a set. But when a set is complete what then? When a set is not complete what of it?

Come now; let's settle back to the finite form and allay your infinite fixation Jim. If I present you with 
   A1 = { a, b, c, d, e, f, ..., x, y, z }
should we explain that this is a complete set of the english alphabet circa 2021?

Next, if you cared to quibble over this alphabet wouldn't you care to name some specific element that I missed? Possibly the '@' character will be admitted into the alphabet at some point. Obviously the quantity of these alphabets is quite large in modernity. We are not of a single language here on Earth. There are reasons to believe that we ought to be, and unicode has come along to address some issues, but in truth these alphabets are controversial not just for their obscurity and for ignoramuses such as myself their sheer void of understanding... 
   https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_writing_systems

I do mean to halt this concern here and return to the alphabet that you and I do share, and with convention I need not declare A1... yet if there were contention we ought then to formally prefix or even suffix our elements and list them all individually without ellipses in order to be as clear as possible. Lastly all that I am demanding is one additional character that declares this set complete. It is not an element of the set. It is very much like replacing the closing bracket of your set with a special character that declares a particular set complete. That this character is entirely consistent with aleph as well as with omega of the world of Wolfgang Muckenhiem is not a coincidence.

A = { a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z &

Eliminating commas above I find relevant in that I am turning traditional set notation to taffy. But you see Jim if there is a conflict then you need to falsify that conflict directly. Please prove me wrong. Constructive freedom and interpretation do go hand in hand... hand in glove really.
I have a synthetic mind and probably come across as a poor listener, but this format does allow us to pontificate, elaborate, and even revise under way our system. 

I am confident that set theory in your mind is one of those done deals that is not on the table for dissection and reconstruction but would Kant? Would Descartes? Would Russell? Bohm? Feinman? Gamow? 

In a simplistic way you might quip that I have merely replaced a closing brace with an ampersand, but the interpretation is rather different. Under my constructive freedom, and believe me this is on the fly that this is coming into existence and out of thin air as all good constructions come, we cannot utter:
   A1 = { a b c & 
This simply is not true. We now have a false set. We now have a true set; something that you yourself seem to be quite obsessed with, particularly on the ordinal front. That you will refuse to admit the ordinals for instance as the naturals; each has their ampersand intact.

> 
> There is a set operation known as _disjoint union_ 
> We can use that to _append_ set B to set A. 
> ({0}xA) U ({1}xB) 

I'm sorry but we are into a much simpler concern than anything with any cross products in it. I'm assuming those X's are cartesian products, right?
Rather we ought to be concerned with what it means to be a superset of, and then too whether a subset of a superset can take the ampersand (or aleph in my interpretation)? I think not, and this means that when we intersect the real numbers to take just the natural numbers that they as a subset are lacking their aleph; that these are different universes due to the source of their construction; here we are getting into some thick territory.

Ordinary interpretation has
   N < M < Q < R < C ... (where M are two-signed integers and the rest are conventional)
These '<' symbols could be taking the meaning 'subset' here though the less than connotation isn't terrible is it?
These are infinite sets, and we are not actually using them here are we?
We have two sets that we work in here in elemental form. 
I've already named the English alphabet A. Next we need
   B = { 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 &
And now but for punctuation we can have our conversation.

Can you name a large number Jim?
Can you represent a million for me?
Oh, it's no problem right?
As to what is elemental and what actually is set;
As in set in stone;
As in dead and done;
As in all men are grass;
I can get a kick our of being crass
given the situation here.
But you are such a fair opponent and there will be no need.

> 
> ({0}xA) U ({1}xB) is a set of ordered pairs (i,x) 
> (hence, _a set_ ). 
> The first entry i is either 0 or 1, the second x is either 
> an element of A or an element of B. 
> 
> I take it, from the way you're talking, that 
> sets A and B have internal orders. I'll write them as 
> x <' y if x and y are in A, and 
> x <" y if x and y are in B. 

I've named my sets formally and I use their elements freely here.

> 
> We can define an order on ({0}xA) U ({1}xB) as 

No. I see no need to induce these annoying Cartesian products.

> (i,x) < (j,j) if and only if 
> i < j, or 
> i = j and 
> (x <' y for x,y in A) or 
> (x <" y for x,y in B) 
> 
> All the elements of B come after all the elements of A, 
> but otherwise they keep their same internal orders in A 
> and in B.

I don't really think we have a problem with order. I think we have a problem with grammar that we are going to have to engage in next.
We do in fact use our elements in multiplicity and their uniqueness is not actually in their order but in their combinations.
Again Jim I must ask you to pick a number.
A large number please.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#509693

FromTimothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com>
Date2021-01-15 06:21 -0800
Message-ID<cafb1585-f7d8-4334-a1e7-047cb1b3ab48n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#509495
On Tuesday, January 12, 2021 at 9:36:23 AM UTC-5, Timothy Golden wrote:
> On Sunday, January 10, 2021 at 8:31:10 PM UTC-5, Jim Burns wrote: 
> > On 1/10/2021 4:23 PM, Timothy Golden wrote: 
> > > On Sunday, January 10, 2021 at 12:51:51 PM UTC-5, 
> > > Jim Burns wrote: 
> > >> On 1/10/2021 10:08 AM, Timothy Golden wrote: 
> > 
> > >>> Meet the new Aleph; 
> > >>> Different from the old Aleph; 
> > >> 
> > >> A Long, Long Time Ago 
> > >> (several ice ages ago, measured in internet-time), 
> > >> Henry Ford said, about the Model-T, 
> > >> "You can have any color you want, as long as it is black". 
> > >> 
> > >> So, you had a situation where, 
> > >> | if X is a Model-T, then X is black. 
> > >> 
> > >> It's obviously an error to treat that the same as 
> > >> the situation where, 
> > >> | if X is black, then X is a Model-T. 
> > >> 
> > >> Here, you are making an error similar to that. 
> > >> 
> > >> There are these things we are interested in, 
> > >> whatever we call them. We call them "infinite cardinalities" 
> > >> or "alephs" or "flying rainbow sparkle ponies". 
> > >> The particular name we use (the particular color we paint them) 
> > >> won't change the nature of the things we are interested in. 
> > >> 
> > >> If _you_ call _some other thing_ "aleph", what _we_ are 
> > >> interested in, what _we_ are talking about, hasn't changed. 
> > >> Calling _something else_ "aleph" is like painting 
> > >> _something else_ black, like a flagpole or a chicken coop, 
> > >> and, I guess? feeling that what you have must therefore have 
> > >> something like a Model-T. 
> > >> 
> > >> If (a hypothetical) someone really pushed this line of argument, 
> > >> the most that they could get out of it would be the claim that 
> > >> this black chicken coop here is really an automobile. To that 
> > >> (still hypothetical) someone: no, it isn't. 
> > > Bullshit Jim. 
> > > 
> > > Let me restate your statement: 
> > > "A set with an aleph appended to its end is not a set" 
> > Did you mean to say that's *my* statement? 
> > 
> > I'm going to have to deny ownership of it. 
> > 
> > I'm not sure I know what you mean by that sentence, but, 
> > for every reasonable reading that occurs to me for 
> > "Is one infinite set appended to another infinite set 
> > a set?", the answer is "Yes, it is a set". 
> > > Agree? This is going to be way too easy for me to win, 
> > > and I know you play fair. 
> > Uhm, thanks? 
> > While I am willing to be praised for my honesty, 
> > it's (honestly) not so extraordinary in this instance. 
> > 
> > Mathematics is an open game, like chess or tic-tac-toe.
> Indeed, and you seem to have a need to lean on the infinite form. 
> I have no need of such a lien. 
> If it works in n and it works in n+1 then we have sufficient room.
> > I only _need_ to be honest enough to not run a red light 
> > _in front of a police car_ 
> > 
> > > Game On Jim. 
> > 
> > If you like. 
> > 
> > My point about calling something different "aleph" 
> > also applies to calling something different "set". 
> > You do not have it in your power to change _what we mean_ 
> > by "set".
> Ahh, but this is exactly what your first return is lacking in: exact falsification. You've built an analogy to cars and colors, but the translation of your interpretation remains to be exactly stated doesn't it? Wouldn't you care to correct the words that I put in your mouth? Perhaps you are doing this here, and that is good. You are good. What we mean by set versus what we mean by say the natural numbers... the real numbers... are we clear that there is quite some difference between the set of reals R versus the set 
> R1 = { 1.23, 2.34, 3.45 } ? (where these are elements of R) 
> 
> It is clear to me that R1 as a subset is lacking in quality to R. Some in fact worship the set R and make it their life's work to do something called real analysis. You want to talk about what we mean by real? Hah, side tracks alight... 
> 
> The notion of a complete set versus a subset is a notion that I believe is lacking from the ordinary form of set theory. A set is a set is a set right? A subset of a set is a set. But when a set is complete what then? When a set is not complete what of it? 
> 
> Come now; let's settle back to the finite form and allay your infinite fixation Jim. If I present you with 
> A1 = { a, b, c, d, e, f, ..., x, y, z } 
> should we explain that this is a complete set of the english alphabet circa 2021? 
> 
> Next, if you cared to quibble over this alphabet wouldn't you care to name some specific element that I missed? Possibly the '@' character will be admitted into the alphabet at some point. Obviously the quantity of these alphabets is quite large in modernity. We are not of a single language here on Earth. There are reasons to believe that we ought to be, and unicode has come along to address some issues, but in truth these alphabets are controversial not just for their obscurity and for ignoramuses such as myself their sheer void of understanding... 
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_writing_systems 
> 
> I do mean to halt this concern here and return to the alphabet that you and I do share, and with convention I need not declare A1... yet if there were contention we ought then to formally prefix or even suffix our elements and list them all individually without ellipses in order to be as clear as possible. Lastly all that I am demanding is one additional character that declares this set complete. It is not an element of the set. It is very much like replacing the closing bracket of your set with a special character that declares a particular set complete. That this character is entirely consistent with aleph as well as with omega of the world of Wolfgang Muckenhiem is not a coincidence. 
> 
> A = { a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z & 
> 
> Eliminating commas above I find relevant in that I am turning traditional set notation to taffy. But you see Jim if there is a conflict then you need to falsify that conflict directly. Please prove me wrong. Constructive freedom and interpretation do go hand in hand... hand in glove really. 
> I have a synthetic mind and probably come across as a poor listener, but this format does allow us to pontificate, elaborate, and even revise under way our system. 
> 
> I am confident that set theory in your mind is one of those done deals that is not on the table for dissection and reconstruction but would Kant? Would Descartes? Would Russell? Bohm? Feinman? Gamow? 
> 
> In a simplistic way you might quip that I have merely replaced a closing brace with an ampersand, but the interpretation is rather different. Under my constructive freedom, and believe me this is on the fly that this is coming into existence and out of thin air as all good constructions come, we cannot utter: 
> A1 = { a b c & 
> This simply is not true. We now have a false set. We now have a true set; something that you yourself seem to be quite obsessed with, particularly on the ordinal front. That you will refuse to admit the ordinals for instance as the naturals; each has their ampersand intact.
> > 
> > There is a set operation known as _disjoint union_ 
> > We can use that to _append_ set B to set A. 
> > ({0}xA) U ({1}xB)
> I'm sorry but we are into a much simpler concern than anything with any cross products in it. I'm assuming those X's are cartesian products, right? 
> Rather we ought to be concerned with what it means to be a superset of, and then too whether a subset of a superset can take the ampersand (or aleph in my interpretation)? I think not, and this means that when we intersect the real numbers to take just the natural numbers that they as a subset are lacking their aleph; that these are different universes due to the source of their construction; here we are getting into some thick territory. 
> 
> Ordinary interpretation has 
> N < M < Q < R < C ... (where M are two-signed integers and the rest are conventional) 
> These '<' symbols could be taking the meaning 'subset' here though the less than connotation isn't terrible is it? 
> These are infinite sets, and we are not actually using them here are we? 
> We have two sets that we work in here in elemental form. 
> I've already named the English alphabet A. Next we need 
> B = { 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 & 
> And now but for punctuation we can have our conversation. 
> 
> Can you name a large number Jim? 
> Can you represent a million for me? 
> Oh, it's no problem right? 
> As to what is elemental and what actually is set; 
> As in set in stone; 
> As in dead and done; 
> As in all men are grass; 
> I can get a kick our of being crass 
> given the situation here. 
> But you are such a fair opponent and there will be no need.
> > 
> > ({0}xA) U ({1}xB) is a set of ordered pairs (i,x) 
> > (hence, _a set_ ). 
> > The first entry i is either 0 or 1, the second x is either 
> > an element of A or an element of B. 
> > 
> > I take it, from the way you're talking, that 
> > sets A and B have internal orders. I'll write them as 
> > x <' y if x and y are in A, and 
> > x <" y if x and y are in B.
> I've named my sets formally and I use their elements freely here.
> > 
> > We can define an order on ({0}xA) U ({1}xB) as
> No. I see no need to induce these annoying Cartesian products.
> > (i,x) < (j,j) if and only if 
> > i < j, or 
> > i = j and 
> > (x <' y for x,y in A) or 
> > (x <" y for x,y in B) 
> > 
> > All the elements of B come after all the elements of A, 
> > but otherwise they keep their same internal orders in A 
> > and in B.
> I don't really think we have a problem with order. I think we have a problem with grammar that we are going to have to engage in next. 
> We do in fact use our elements in multiplicity and their uniqueness is not actually in their order but in their combinations. 
> Again Jim I must ask you to pick a number. 
> A large number please.

I guess I'm not being much fun here. Neither is Jim for that matter. You can only use him as a backboard so much before he just sits down and takes a nap. 

I want to investigate an ancillary topic here for the moment. The terminology of "conductors and insulators" and to what degree are we going to encounter the same structural needs within this conversation that I am attempting to have. The mathematical purist will wipe away any comparison for the terms I have introduced have to do with physics both in the heat realm as well as in the electrical realm. How does it come that two different realms can abide by the same exact representational terms? How well exactly does this relationship work? Shall we then extend onto magnetism? Onto gravity even? Ahh... even gravity carries its constant and while acclaimed universal no doubt it just is not true. Thus it is that I could argue the claim of gravitational insulators and gravitational conductors. It is by these means alone that I engage in such a prediction. This is a purely structural argument. If we have numerous qualities obeying the same restrictions ( construction, and please do spend a moment here on polarity ) then why oughtn't we to further their generality as a test of their integrity. Good gravy, if it holds then I would go down as great and even greater than Einstein for such a pure and simple recipe to reality.  Incidentally my mother did once pen a recipe book called Recipes Pure and Simple in which I discussed the gathering of beech nuts and a problem with their fertility which is remarkably poor. I now know Chinese chestnuts likewise have limited fertility, but much better I think than the beech that we have here in the NorthEast. That said we just had a remarkable beech year here two years ago when seeds sprouting could be found and eaten the next spring right on the path; all you can eat beech sprouts. How did that happen?  

We have the peculiar property
   F = ( m1 / r1 ) ( m2 / r2 )
where traditionally we use r1=r2, but to preserve symmetry this format seems entirely reasonable.
Entering in m3 and r3 we have
   H = ( m1/ r1 ) ( m2 / r2 ) ( m3 / r3 )
and now to end the noxious assumption we probably should enter (oh no, there is actually more in congruence with my statement above)
   m(n) g(n) / r(n) = a(n)
yes I am afraid I've got it now. So g here is now the gravitational constant, but is actually a square root of the traditional concept in the first simpleton form that recovers traditional gravitation. This is an imbedded polysign notation it turns out, though here the physical significance is rather suggestive. There is but one unital form that will have to be studies as well
   A = a1 m1 / r1
and clearly with no other point to refer to we will have to conclude that r1 is the distance to the origin. This origin is explicit only in this zero dimensional form. How else can it be everywhere all at once the particles have their said coordinates to work out their accelerations by? Each one a supercomputer doing the calculus... doing the trig... doing quantum computations... the solo is always the quintessential test of integrity. I do try but I will not be claiming this to be a success. I am open to falsification and I think that in the original set theoretic form there is rather quite a lot to discuss. That said, when we agree upon an alphabet transgressions upon that alphabet do deserve attack, discussion, and resolution.




   

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#509893

FromTimothy Golden <timbandtech@gmail.com>
Date2021-01-18 06:31 -0800
Message-ID<97b969d0-8697-439c-95bf-659c3f5b2069n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#509693
On Friday, January 15, 2021 at 9:21:19 AM UTC-5, Timothy Golden wrote:
> On Tuesday, January 12, 2021 at 9:36:23 AM UTC-5, Timothy Golden wrote: 
> > On Sunday, January 10, 2021 at 8:31:10 PM UTC-5, Jim Burns wrote: 
> > > On 1/10/2021 4:23 PM, Timothy Golden wrote: 
> > > > On Sunday, January 10, 2021 at 12:51:51 PM UTC-5, 
> > > > Jim Burns wrote: 
> > > >> On 1/10/2021 10:08 AM, Timothy Golden wrote: 
> > > 
> > > >>> Meet the new Aleph; 
> > > >>> Different from the old Aleph; 
> > > >> 
> > > >> A Long, Long Time Ago 
> > > >> (several ice ages ago, measured in internet-time), 
> > > >> Henry Ford said, about the Model-T, 
> > > >> "You can have any color you want, as long as it is black". 
> > > >> 
> > > >> So, you had a situation where, 
> > > >> | if X is a Model-T, then X is black. 
> > > >> 
> > > >> It's obviously an error to treat that the same as 
> > > >> the situation where, 
> > > >> | if X is black, then X is a Model-T. 
> > > >> 
> > > >> Here, you are making an error similar to that. 
> > > >> 
> > > >> There are these things we are interested in, 
> > > >> whatever we call them. We call them "infinite cardinalities" 
> > > >> or "alephs" or "flying rainbow sparkle ponies". 
> > > >> The particular name we use (the particular color we paint them) 
> > > >> won't change the nature of the things we are interested in. 
> > > >> 
> > > >> If _you_ call _some other thing_ "aleph", what _we_ are 
> > > >> interested in, what _we_ are talking about, hasn't changed. 
> > > >> Calling _something else_ "aleph" is like painting 
> > > >> _something else_ black, like a flagpole or a chicken coop, 
> > > >> and, I guess? feeling that what you have must therefore have 
> > > >> something like a Model-T. 
> > > >> 
> > > >> If (a hypothetical) someone really pushed this line of argument, 
> > > >> the most that they could get out of it would be the claim that 
> > > >> this black chicken coop here is really an automobile. To that 
> > > >> (still hypothetical) someone: no, it isn't. 
> > > > Bullshit Jim. 
> > > > 
> > > > Let me restate your statement: 
> > > > "A set with an aleph appended to its end is not a set" 
> > > Did you mean to say that's *my* statement? 
> > > 
> > > I'm going to have to deny ownership of it. 
> > > 
> > > I'm not sure I know what you mean by that sentence, but, 
> > > for every reasonable reading that occurs to me for 
> > > "Is one infinite set appended to another infinite set 
> > > a set?", the answer is "Yes, it is a set". 
> > > > Agree? This is going to be way too easy for me to win, 
> > > > and I know you play fair. 
> > > Uhm, thanks? 
> > > While I am willing to be praised for my honesty, 
> > > it's (honestly) not so extraordinary in this instance. 
> > > 
> > > Mathematics is an open game, like chess or tic-tac-toe. 
> > Indeed, and you seem to have a need to lean on the infinite form. 
> > I have no need of such a lien. 
> > If it works in n and it works in n+1 then we have sufficient room. 
> > > I only _need_ to be honest enough to not run a red light 
> > > _in front of a police car_ 
> > > 
> > > > Game On Jim. 
> > > 
> > > If you like. 
> > > 
> > > My point about calling something different "aleph" 
> > > also applies to calling something different "set". 
> > > You do not have it in your power to change _what we mean_ 
> > > by "set". 
> > Ahh, but this is exactly what your first return is lacking in: exact falsification. You've built an analogy to cars and colors, but the translation of your interpretation remains to be exactly stated doesn't it? Wouldn't you care to correct the words that I put in your mouth? Perhaps you are doing this here, and that is good. You are good. What we mean by set versus what we mean by say the natural numbers... the real numbers... are we clear that there is quite some difference between the set of reals R versus the set 
> > R1 = { 1.23, 2.34, 3.45 } ? (where these are elements of R) 
> > 
> > It is clear to me that R1 as a subset is lacking in quality to R. Some in fact worship the set R and make it their life's work to do something called real analysis. You want to talk about what we mean by real? Hah, side tracks alight... 
> > 
> > The notion of a complete set versus a subset is a notion that I believe is lacking from the ordinary form of set theory. A set is a set is a set right? A subset of a set is a set. But when a set is complete what then? When a set is not complete what of it? 
> > 
> > Come now; let's settle back to the finite form and allay your infinite fixation Jim. If I present you with 
> > A1 = { a, b, c, d, e, f, ..., x, y, z } 
> > should we explain that this is a complete set of the english alphabet circa 2021? 
> > 
> > Next, if you cared to quibble over this alphabet wouldn't you care to name some specific element that I missed? Possibly the '@' character will be admitted into the alphabet at some point. Obviously the quantity of these alphabets is quite large in modernity. We are not of a single language here on Earth. There are reasons to believe that we ought to be, and unicode has come along to address some issues, but in truth these alphabets are controversial not just for their obscurity and for ignoramuses such as myself their sheer void of understanding... 
> > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_writing_systems 
> > 
> > I do mean to halt this concern here and return to the alphabet that you and I do share, and with convention I need not declare A1... yet if there were contention we ought then to formally prefix or even suffix our elements and list them all individually without ellipses in order to be as clear as possible. Lastly all that I am demanding is one additional character that declares this set complete. It is not an element of the set. It is very much like replacing the closing bracket of your set with a special character that declares a particular set complete. That this character is entirely consistent with aleph as well as with omega of the world of Wolfgang Muckenhiem is not a coincidence. 
> > 
> > A = { a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z & 
> > 
> > Eliminating commas above I find relevant in that I am turning traditional set notation to taffy. But you see Jim if there is a conflict then you need to falsify that conflict directly. Please prove me wrong. Constructive freedom and interpretation do go hand in hand... hand in glove really. 
> > I have a synthetic mind and probably come across as a poor listener, but this format does allow us to pontificate, elaborate, and even revise under way our system. 
> > 
> > I am confident that set theory in your mind is one of those done deals that is not on the table for dissection and reconstruction but would Kant? Would Descartes? Would Russell? Bohm? Feinman? Gamow? 
> > 
> > In a simplistic way you might quip that I have merely replaced a closing brace with an ampersand, but the interpretation is rather different. Under my constructive freedom, and believe me this is on the fly that this is coming into existence and out of thin air as all good constructions come, we cannot utter: 
> > A1 = { a b c & 
> > This simply is not true. We now have a false set. We now have a true set; something that you yourself seem to be quite obsessed with, particularly on the ordinal front. That you will refuse to admit the ordinals for instance as the naturals; each has their ampersand intact. 
> > > 
> > > There is a set operation known as _disjoint union_ 
> > > We can use that to _append_ set B to set A. 
> > > ({0}xA) U ({1}xB) 
> > I'm sorry but we are into a much simpler concern than anything with any cross products in it. I'm assuming those X's are cartesian products, right? 
> > Rather we ought to be concerned with what it means to be a superset of, and then too whether a subset of a superset can take the ampersand (or aleph in my interpretation)? I think not, and this means that when we intersect the real numbers to take just the natural numbers that they as a subset are lacking their aleph; that these are different universes due to the source of their construction; here we are getting into some thick territory. 
> > 
> > Ordinary interpretation has 
> > N < M < Q < R < C ... (where M are two-signed integers and the rest are conventional) 
> > These '<' symbols could be taking the meaning 'subset' here though the less than connotation isn't terrible is it? 
> > These are infinite sets, and we are not actually using them here are we? 
> > We have two sets that we work in here in elemental form. 
> > I've already named the English alphabet A. Next we need 
> > B = { 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 & 
> > And now but for punctuation we can have our conversation. 
> > 
> > Can you name a large number Jim? 
> > Can you represent a million for me? 
> > Oh, it's no problem right? 
> > As to what is elemental and what actually is set; 
> > As in set in stone; 
> > As in dead and done; 
> > As in all men are grass; 
> > I can get a kick our of being crass 
> > given the situation here. 
> > But you are such a fair opponent and there will be no need. 
> > > 
> > > ({0}xA) U ({1}xB) is a set of ordered pairs (i,x) 
> > > (hence, _a set_ ). 
> > > The first entry i is either 0 or 1, the second x is either 
> > > an element of A or an element of B. 
> > > 
> > > I take it, from the way you're talking, that 
> > > sets A and B have internal orders. I'll write them as 
> > > x <' y if x and y are in A, and 
> > > x <" y if x and y are in B. 
> > I've named my sets formally and I use their elements freely here. 
> > > 
> > > We can define an order on ({0}xA) U ({1}xB) as 
> > No. I see no need to induce these annoying Cartesian products. 
> > > (i,x) < (j,j) if and only if 
> > > i < j, or 
> > > i = j and 
> > > (x <' y for x,y in A) or 
> > > (x <" y for x,y in B) 
> > > 
> > > All the elements of B come after all the elements of A, 
> > > but otherwise they keep their same internal orders in A 
> > > and in B. 
> > I don't really think we have a problem with order. I think we have a problem with grammar that we are going to have to engage in next. 
> > We do in fact use our elements in multiplicity and their uniqueness is not actually in their order but in their combinations. 
> > Again Jim I must ask you to pick a number. 
> > A large number please.
> I guess I'm not being much fun here. Neither is Jim for that matter. You can only use him as a backboard so much before he just sits down and takes a nap. 
> 
> I want to investigate an ancillary topic here for the moment. The terminology of "conductors and insulators" and to what degree are we going to encounter the same structural needs within this conversation that I am attempting to have. The mathematical purist will wipe away any comparison for the terms I have introduced have to do with physics both in the heat realm as well as in the electrical realm. How does it come that two different realms can abide by the same exact representational terms? How well exactly does this relationship work? Shall we then extend onto magnetism? Onto gravity even? Ahh... even gravity carries its constant and while acclaimed universal no doubt it just is not true. Thus it is that I could argue the claim of gravitational insulators and gravitational conductors. It is by these means alone that I engage in such a prediction. This is a purely structural argument. If we have numerous qualities obeying the same restrictions ( construction, and please do spend a moment here on polarity ) then why oughtn't we to further their generality as a test of their integrity. Good gravy, if it holds then I would go down as great and even greater than Einstein for such a pure and simple recipe to reality. Incidentally my mother did once pen a recipe book called Recipes Pure and Simple in which I discussed the gathering of beech nuts and a problem with their fertility which is remarkably poor. I now know Chinese chestnuts likewise have limited fertility, but much better I think than the beech that we have here in the NorthEast. That said we just had a remarkable beech year here two years ago when seeds sprouting could be found and eaten the next spring right on the path; all you can eat beech sprouts. How did that happen? 
> 
> We have the peculiar property 
> F = ( m1 / r1 ) ( m2 / r2 ) 
> where traditionally we use r1=r2, but to preserve symmetry this format seems entirely reasonable. 
> Entering in m3 and r3 we have 
> H = ( m1/ r1 ) ( m2 / r2 ) ( m3 / r3 ) 
> and now to end the noxious assumption we probably should enter (oh no, there is actually more in congruence with my statement above) 
> m(n) g(n) / r(n) = a(n) 
> yes I am afraid I've got it now. So g here is now the gravitational constant, but is actually a square root of the traditional concept in the first simpleton form that recovers traditional gravitation. This is an imbedded polysign notation it turns out, though here the physical significance is rather suggestive. There is but one unital form that will have to be studies as well 
> A = a1 m1 / r1 
> and clearly with no other point to refer to we will have to conclude that r1 is the distance to the origin. This origin is explicit only in this zero dimensional form. How else can it be everywhere all at once the particles have their said coordinates to work out their accelerations by? Each one a supercomputer doing the calculus... doing the trig... doing quantum computations... the solo is always the quintessential test of integrity. I do try but I will not be claiming this to be a success. I am open to falsification and I think that in the original set theoretic form there is rather quite a lot to discuss. That said, when we agree upon an alphabet transgressions upon that alphabet do deserve attack, discussion, and resolution.

To what degree is a set theory on a continuous form applicable on a discrete form? Should it be the exact same set theory? Modernity and history tell us yes; the same formalisms allow us to discuss either as the set S. Certainly we will not be having Dedekind cuts and so forth in the discrete form, though arguably the Dedekind cut is a sort of inversion that is making usage of the discrete form.

I don't know; it just seems to me that pattern recognition and redundancy are well and good and supported by reality. Orthogonality troubles me. Possibly playing in arbitrary angle representations did help me to discover polysign numbers. Earlier I had developed a segment map in the plane but of sectors... one sector two dimensional, two connected sectors with a particle presence in each sector satisfying general dimensional behavior. Also there is even a neat sector map of these playing out a dimensional climb:  1 2 3 1 4 2 5 4 3 5 1 ten sectors, sixes; did I ever make it there? doubt it. Arguably this is a ten point representation. Back at the 3D form we had a three point form, and in 4D an imperfect six point form (delete the fives and truncate the pattern; you'll have two 24 sectors). It's quite odd, and I'm not really for a holographic universe of this sort, but still it's not a fraud. An alternate representation of reality can exist here.

Func() the funcers; this is a bit more primitive thank you.
 
It happens that there is a clan who perceive polysign sign mechanics as going on in the plane. It does work but it is not their native geometry.
For instance P5 sign mechanics have
-, +, *, #, @, -, +, *, #, @, -, +, *, ...
What A Heck, as an old French girlfriend used to say, let's go all out:
   ... , -, +, *, #, @, -, +, *, #, @, -, +, *, ...
I don't really require any ellipsis system for polysign. P5 has no need of such gobbledy gook. It's just mod5 math. It happens to be rotationally behaved and it happens you can put 2pi/5 angles in the plane and get the sign mechanics going, but you'll never recover the proper balance in the plane.
 
Hey, there is still Russian Dressing on the Rigged Election Salad. Just Saying, Bernie's up on a cross and all that, just about ready to leap out from behind a rock in his running shoes after he gets the last staple out of his wrist... It's not pretty, but then, he's the one that said politics can be messy.
Here's to the Despoticratic Party, and thank you Barack, for giving us the cause to dance in the streets. It's been a long long show and the damn thing still isn't over... just like the Roman Empire.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#509898

FromEbenezer Splooge <esplooge@hotmail.com>
Date2021-01-18 08:51 -0800
Message-ID<ru4e9h$8bk$1@dont-email.me>
In reply to#509893
> It happens that there is a clan who perceive polysign sign mechanics as going on in the plane.

What the actual fuck are you blithering about. Get a brain.

[toc] | [prev] | [standalone]


Back to top | Article view | sci.math


csiph-web