Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > sci.logic > #167647 > unrolled thread

WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox

Started byGeorge Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu>
First post2017-11-30 22:58 -0800
Last post2018-01-11 20:02 -0800
Articles 20 on this page of 95 — 11 participants

Back to article view | Back to sci.logic


Contents

  WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-11-30 22:58 -0800
    Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-01 02:14 -0800
      Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Julio Di Egidio <julio@diegidio.name> - 2017-12-01 07:13 -0800
        Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-01 11:27 -0800
          Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Julio Di Egidio <julio@diegidio.name> - 2017-12-01 11:59 -0800
            Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-01 14:14 -0800
              Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox bursejan@gmail.com - 2017-12-01 14:17 -0800
                Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-01 21:07 -0800
          Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2017-12-02 00:16 +0000
            Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-01 21:12 -0800
              Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Zeit Geist <Tucsondrew@me.com> - 2017-12-01 22:04 -0800
      Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-01 20:50 -0800
        Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-01 21:17 -0800
          Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-02 13:57 -0800
            Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-02 14:17 -0800
              Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-02 18:32 -0800
          Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-02 14:00 -0800
            Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-03 00:03 -0800
          Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-02 18:58 -0800
            Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-03 00:07 -0800
          Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-02 19:00 -0800
            Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-03 00:12 -0800
            Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Julio Di Egidio <julio@diegidio.name> - 2017-12-06 08:39 -0800
              Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-31 22:35 -0800
      Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-01 20:54 -0800
        Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-01 21:20 -0800
          Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2017-12-03 01:58 +0000
            Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-03 00:27 -0800
              Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2017-12-04 01:40 +0000
                Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-04 10:21 -0800
                  Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-04 13:15 -0800
                    Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-04 13:41 -0800
                  Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2017-12-05 00:36 +0000
                    Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-05 13:53 -0800
                      Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2017-12-06 02:21 +0000
                        Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-05 20:40 -0800
              Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Alan Smaill <smaill@SPAMinf.ed.ac.uk> - 2017-12-04 11:33 +0000
                Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-04 10:10 -0800
                  Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Alan Smaill <smaill@SPAMinf.ed.ac.uk> - 2017-12-05 13:43 +0000
                Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-04 12:09 -0800
                  Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Jim Burns <james.g.burns@att.net> - 2017-12-04 15:42 -0500
                    Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-04 13:12 -0800
                      Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Jim Burns <james.g.burns@att.net> - 2017-12-04 18:14 -0500
                  Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Alan Smaill <smaill@SPAMinf.ed.ac.uk> - 2017-12-05 13:26 +0000
            Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-13 08:31 -0800
              Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2017-12-14 02:27 +0000
              Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-14 00:03 -0800
                Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-15 11:29 -0800
                Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-15 11:33 -0800
                  Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-16 04:26 -0800
      Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-01 21:00 -0800
        Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-01 21:34 -0800
          Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-13 08:15 -0800
            Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Julio Di Egidio <julio@diegidio.name> - 2017-12-13 09:39 -0800
              Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-31 22:29 -0800
            Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-14 00:08 -0800
            Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-14 01:12 -0800
              Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Julio Di Egidio <julio@diegidio.name> - 2017-12-14 02:59 -0800
                Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-15 02:49 -0800
                Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-15 02:55 -0800
                  Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Julio Di Egidio <julio@diegidio.name> - 2017-12-15 03:06 -0800
                    Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-15 09:58 -0800
                      Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Julio Di Egidio <julio@diegidio.name> - 2017-12-15 10:39 -0800
                        Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-15 11:25 -0800
                          Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Julio Di Egidio <julio@diegidio.name> - 2017-12-15 23:44 -0800
                            Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-17 09:26 -0800
                              Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Julio Di Egidio <julio@diegidio.name> - 2017-12-17 12:01 -0800
                                Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-31 22:25 -0800
                                Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-31 22:26 -0800
      Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-04 13:20 -0800
        Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-04 13:44 -0800
          Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-05 20:43 -0800
            Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Newberry <newberryxy@gmail.com> - 2017-12-05 22:22 -0800
            Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-06 10:19 -0800
              Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-10 23:57 -0800
                Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-11 10:16 -0800
              Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-11 00:02 -0800
                Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-11 10:16 -0800
                  Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-11 15:49 -0800
                    Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-11 23:34 -0800
      Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-04 13:25 -0800
        Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-04 13:49 -0800
          Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-05 13:56 -0800
            Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-06 07:02 -0800
              Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Peter Percival <peterxpercival@hotmail.com> - 2017-12-06 15:51 +0000
                Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox FredJeffries <fredjeffries@gmail.com> - 2017-12-06 08:08 -0800
                Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-06 10:05 -0800
              Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-13 08:02 -0800
        Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Peter Percival <peterxpercival@hotmail.com> - 2017-12-06 13:43 +0000
          Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-06 12:09 -0800
          Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-06 12:11 -0800
    Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox Julio Di Egidio <julio@diegidio.name> - 2017-12-01 07:09 -0800
    Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2017-12-03 21:28 -0800
      Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> - 2017-12-04 10:17 -0800
    Re: WM vs. Ross-Litlewood paradox George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> - 2018-01-11 20:02 -0800

Page 2 of 5 — ← Prev page 1 [2] 3 4 5  Next page →


#167736

FromGeorge Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu>
Date2017-12-02 19:00 -0800
Message-ID<bb4ffa67-847b-4b9f-afa5-7f453ac57531@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#167695
On Saturday, December 2, 2017 at 12:17:47 AM UTC-5, WM wrote:
> A change from "there are always infinitely many numbers
> following" to "there are no numbers following" does never occur.

It never occurs AT OR ON ANY PARTICULAR natural number, but that does not stop it from occurring. It doesn't occur at any finite step of the process, but
since THE PROCESS ENDS, and we're talking about what happens AFTER it's over, what is happening while IT IS NOT YET over does NOT matter.
This process does NOT HAVE a last step!

Should we switch to the Lamp paradox?

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167740

FromWM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de>
Date2017-12-03 00:12 -0800
Message-ID<1f0e3379-ebdf-4b32-b29f-dbc27a6b07f3@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#167736
Am Sonntag, 3. Dezember 2017 04:00:49 UTC+1 schrieb George Greene:
> On Saturday, December 2, 2017 at 12:17:47 AM UTC-5, WM wrote:
> > A change from "there are always infinitely many numbers
> > following" to "there are no numbers following" does never occur.
> 
> It never occurs AT OR ON ANY PARTICULAR natural number, but that does not stop it from occurring.

That is Matheology.

> It doesn't occur at any finite step of the process,

There is never an infinite step. Every natural number is finite. Every step has a natural index.

> but
> since THE PROCESS ENDS, and we're talking about what happens AFTER it's over, what is happening while IT IS NOT YET over does NOT matter.
> This process does NOT HAVE a last step!

See my other answer. It seems that mathematics depends on physics.
See MatheRealism, p. 351-365 in https://www.hs-augsburg.de/~mueckenh/Transfinity/Transfinity/pdf 

Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167854

FromJulio Di Egidio <julio@diegidio.name>
Date2017-12-06 08:39 -0800
Message-ID<97ab3289-0fe7-4bd4-8115-00026493929f@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#167736
On Sunday, December 3, 2017 at 4:00:49 AM UTC+1, George Greene wrote:

> since THE PROCESS ENDS, and we're talking about what happens AFTER it's over, what is happening while IT IS NOT YET over does NOT matter.
> This process does NOT HAVE a last step!

That is a *complete utter fraud*.

The answer to *any* such problems lies in taking some *limit*, and
the reason why the vase ends up empty by the standard is indeed due
to how the standard set-limits work.

Your logic on the other hand is only a fucking hallucination and then a
*lie*: it's a supertask it's not a supertask, it's at t=1 it's not at t=1,
and so on: that has *nothing* to do with any mathematics, not even the
standard one, it's just you bullshitting and lying.

> Should we switch to the Lamp paradox?

So that you can bullshit about that, too??

FUCK YOU

Julio

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#169154

FromGeorge Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu>
Date2017-12-31 22:35 -0800
Message-ID<e7929a5a-de32-4b38-abe7-c5c630694114@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#167854
On Wednesday, December 6, 2017 at 11:39:40 AM UTC-5, Julio Di Egidio wrote:
> On Sunday, December 3, 2017 at 4:00:49 AM UTC+1, George Greene wrote:
> 
> > since THE PROCESS ENDS, and we're talking about what happens AFTER it's over, what is happening while IT IS NOT YET over does NOT matter.
> > This process does NOT HAVE a last step!
> 
> That is a *complete utter fraud*.

You CAN"T EVEN HOPE to support that!  You do not even BEGIN to EXPLAIN WHY
there might be anything "fraudulent" about what I said!  And your use of that
term IS ITself fraudulent.  Fraud involves presenting some situation as one
way when it is in fact another.  Nothing remotely like that is happening
here.  The situation, for all its inherent paradoxicality, is being presented
exactly as it is.

> The answer to *any* such problems lies in taking some *limit*, 

Well, yes, but "some" limit IS A WEASEL-WORD and precisely what DIFFERENT
kinds of limits there are and how they may permissibly interact is what
the whole debate is about.

> and  the reason why the vase ends up empty by the standard is indeed due
> to how the standard set-limits work.

Oh, HORSE-SHIT.  THE SET of balls in the vase gets BIGGER AND BIGGER as time
goes by and "how the standard set-limits work" WOULD REQUIRE the limit TO BE
BIG!  THAT IS WHY there is a paradox!  The universal generalization inference
rule requires THE EXACT OPPOSITE!  BOTH of these involve limits but they
are giving OPPOSITE RESULTS!  That is why there is a paradox AND that is why
one of the other related threads that spawned this one is called "Different results of universal quantification"!

> Your logic on the other hand is only a fucking hallucination

The universal generalization inference rule IS NOT a hallucination.
It's generally broadly excepted.  You once claimed to know more logic
than I did.  You are disproving that here.

> and then a
> *lie*: it's a supertask it's not a supertask, it's at t=1 it's not at t=1,
> and so on: that has *nothing* to do with any mathematics, not even the
> standard one, it's just you bullshitting and lying.

QUOTE me or shut THE FUCK up.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167691

FromGeorge Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu>
Date2017-12-01 20:54 -0800
Message-ID<eee82b6a-5205-44cd-a5d7-28be7986100a@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#167650
On Friday, December 1, 2017 at 5:14:35 AM UTC-5, WM wrote:
> The universal quantifier cannot be applied to infinite sets

In that case, the existential one can't either, because Ax[whatever] just MEANS
~Ex[~whatever].  Anything with universal quantifiers can be rewritten with existential ones instead.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167696

FromWM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de>
Date2017-12-01 21:20 -0800
Message-ID<28f6daac-496e-432c-8f0e-ee8c26c732bf@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#167691
Am Samstag, 2. Dezember 2017 05:54:18 UTC+1 schrieb George Greene:
> On Friday, December 1, 2017 at 5:14:35 AM UTC-5, WM wrote:
> > The universal quantifier cannot be applied to infinite sets
> 
> In that case, the existential one can't either, because Ax[whatever] just MEANS
> ~Ex[~whatever].  Anything with universal quantifiers can be rewritten with existential ones instead.

I think that does not hold in potential infinity. But please give an example so that we can discuss it.

Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167733

FromBen Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk>
Date2017-12-03 01:58 +0000
Message-ID<871skca7yd.fsf@bsb.me.uk>
In reply to#167696
WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> writes:

> Am Samstag, 2. Dezember 2017 05:54:18 UTC+1 schrieb George Greene:
>> On Friday, December 1, 2017 at 5:14:35 AM UTC-5, WM wrote:
>> > The universal quantifier cannot be applied to infinite sets
>> 
>> In that case, the existential one can't either, because Ax[whatever]
>> just MEANS ~Ex[~whatever].  Anything with universal quantifiers can
>> be rewritten with existential ones instead.
>
> I think that does not hold in potential infinity. But please give an
> example so that we can discuss it.

Amazing!  That's exactly your job -- to give an example where the magic
word "potential" actually makes a difference -- and yet you pass the
buck.  *Any* example fits the bill for us since Ax is *defined* in terms
of Ex (or vice versa) yet you expect George (or someone else) to provide
example after example until they hit on one that you consider to be
false!

So can *you* give a set S to quantify over and a predicate P such that
(in your world) Ax[P(x)] =/= ~Ex[~P(x)]?

-- 
Ben.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167741

FromWM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de>
Date2017-12-03 00:27 -0800
Message-ID<7e9a3ef2-176c-402d-8ede-53ffc42fc3a0@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#167733
Am Sonntag, 3. Dezember 2017 02:58:20 UTC+1 schrieb Ben Bacarisse:
> WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> writes:
> 
> > Am Samstag, 2. Dezember 2017 05:54:18 UTC+1 schrieb George Greene:
> >> On Friday, December 1, 2017 at 5:14:35 AM UTC-5, WM wrote:
> >> > The universal quantifier cannot be applied to infinite sets
> >> 
> >> In that case, the existential one can't either, because Ax[whatever]
> >> just MEANS ~Ex[~whatever].  Anything with universal quantifiers can
> >> be rewritten with existential ones instead.
> >
> > I think that does not hold in potential infinity. But please give an
> > example so that we can discuss it.
> 
> Amazing!  That's exactly your job -- to give an example where the magic
> word "potential" actually makes a difference -- and yet you pass the
> buck.  *Any* example fits the bill for us since Ax is *defined* in terms
> of Ex (or vice versa) yet you expect George (or someone else) to provide
> example after example until they hit on one that you consider to be
> false!
> 
> So can *you* give a set S to quantify over and a predicate P such that
> (in your world) Ax[P(x)] =/= ~Ex[~P(x)]?
> 
Current logic holds for qualitative statements (i.e., statements about properties of the general or typical representant) like:

∀n ∈ |N: n can be expressed as a fraction with denominator 1.
∀n ∈ |N: n is followed by infinitely many natural numbers.

There does not exist an exception. ∀x [P(x)] is equivalent to ~∃x [~P(x)].

Universal quantification is not possible for quantitative statements (i.e., about the whole infinite set) like

∀n ∈ |N: At 12 o'clock n has left the urn.

That does not mean we could say
~∃n ∈ |N: n is in the urn

Correct is that we cannot *name* such an n, because every n that we can name has left the urn. But *every* n belongs to a tiny finite ser and is followed by (potentially) infinitely many natural numbers.

Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167765

FromBen Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk>
Date2017-12-04 01:40 +0000
Message-ID<87bmjf8e4v.fsf@bsb.me.uk>
In reply to#167741
WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> writes:

> Am Sonntag, 3. Dezember 2017 02:58:20 UTC+1 schrieb Ben Bacarisse:
>> WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> writes:
>> 
>> > Am Samstag, 2. Dezember 2017 05:54:18 UTC+1 schrieb George Greene:
>> >> On Friday, December 1, 2017 at 5:14:35 AM UTC-5, WM wrote:
>> >> > The universal quantifier cannot be applied to infinite sets
>> >> 
>> >> In that case, the existential one can't either, because Ax[whatever]
>> >> just MEANS ~Ex[~whatever].  Anything with universal quantifiers can
>> >> be rewritten with existential ones instead.
>> >
>> > I think that does not hold in potential infinity. But please give an
>> > example so that we can discuss it.
>> 
>> Amazing!  That's exactly your job -- to give an example where the magic
>> word "potential" actually makes a difference -- and yet you pass the
>> buck.  *Any* example fits the bill for us since Ax is *defined* in terms
>> of Ex (or vice versa) yet you expect George (or someone else) to provide
>> example after example until they hit on one that you consider to be
>> false!
>> 
>> So can *you* give a set S to quantify over and a predicate P such that
>> (in your world) Ax[P(x)] =/= ~Ex[~P(x)]?
>> 
> Current logic holds for qualitative statements (i.e., statements about
> properties of the general or typical representant) like:
>
> ∀n ∈ |N: n can be expressed as a fraction with denominator 1.
> ∀n ∈ |N: n is followed by infinitely many natural numbers.
>
> There does not exist an exception. ∀x [P(x)] is equivalent to ~∃x [~P(x)].
>
> Universal quantification is not possible for quantitative statements
> (i.e., about the whole infinite set) like
>
> ∀n ∈ |N: At 12 o'clock n has left the urn.
>
> That does not mean we could say
> ~∃n ∈ |N: n is in the urn

Ah.  You mean it only fails for waffle cases.  George said

  "Ax[whatever] just MEANS ~Ex[~whatever]"

and you said that does not hold for potential infinity.  But now you say
it holds for formulas -- essentially for every case except when the
"whatever" is some waffle words.  Can you confirm there is no exception
for potential infinity when a well-defined formula is involved?

<snip>
-- 
Ben.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167779

FromWM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de>
Date2017-12-04 10:21 -0800
Message-ID<b73aa0c3-1d9f-4099-b82e-cbb67fb4cf42@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#167765
Am Montag, 4. Dezember 2017 02:40:01 UTC+1 schrieb Ben Bacarisse:


> > That does not mean we could say
> > ~∃n ∈ |N: n is in the urn
> 
> Ah.  You mean it only fails for waffle cases.  George said
> 
>   "Ax[whatever] just MEANS ~Ex[~whatever]"
> 
> and you said that does not hold for potential infinity.  But now you say
> it holds for formulas -- essentially for every case except when the
> "whatever" is some waffle words.  Can you confirm there is no exception
> for potential infinity when a well-defined formula is involved?
> 
There is no exception when we define: n goes out not before n+1 has come in. This excludes an empty container. 

But the same is trzeue for the natural numbers. If you consider n, then it is clear in advance that n+1 exists. See https://www.hs-augsburg.de/homes/mueckenh/HI*/ see lesson HI12.PPT (in English) Frames 49 to 52.

Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167791

FromGeorge Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu>
Date2017-12-04 13:15 -0800
Message-ID<ea5387bc-14fa-473b-b4cf-98fa09e3fa23@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#167779
On Monday, December 4, 2017 at 1:21:22 PM UTC-5, WM wrote:
> There is no exception when we define: n goes out
> not before n+1 has come in. This excludes an empty container.

No, it doesn't.
Seriously, why WOULD YOU EVEN THINK it would? It excludes an empty container
WHILE THIS IS HAPPENING, but the QUESTION is about what HAS happened at THE END,
AFTER all that HAS FINISHED happening!
 
For every rational t<1, you can define how many balls are in the container,
and it is, by standard human standards, a big number once t gets near 1 (it
gets farther and farther from 0, the closer t gets to 1).  But we're NOT TALKING ABOUT t<1 -- we're TALKING about t*=*1 !

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167795

FromWM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de>
Date2017-12-04 13:41 -0800
Message-ID<76c08d56-37f9-428e-ac07-9c4a05decac1@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#167791
Am Montag, 4. Dezember 2017 22:15:41 UTC+1 schrieb George Greene:
> On Monday, December 4, 2017 at 1:21:22 PM UTC-5, WM wrote:
> > There is no exception when we define: n goes out
> > not before n+1 has come in. This excludes an empty container.
> 
> No, it doesn't.

Then you are violating mathematical definitions.
Thought so. You need it for your matheology.

> Seriously, why WOULD YOU EVEN THINK it would?

Because it is true. Every natural number is followed by another one.

> It excludes an empty container

Of course. In doubt use mathematics. Lim Card, not Card Lim.

> WHILE THIS IS HAPPENING, but the QUESTION is about what HAS happened at THE END,
> AFTER all that HAS FINISHED happening!

The answer is that this cannot be determined by the idea that the infinite (or here t = 1) can be reached by your steps.
>  
> For every rational t<1, you can define how many balls are in the container,
> and it is, by standard human standards, a big number once t gets near 1 (it
> gets farther and farther from 0, the closer t gets to 1).  But we're NOT TALKING ABOUT t<1 -- we're TALKING about t*=*1 !

That cannot be reached by the sequence (1/n). It is impossible to talk it. It is obvious that set theory is wrong.

Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167807

FromBen Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk>
Date2017-12-05 00:36 +0000
Message-ID<87tvx6nh7z.fsf@bsb.me.uk>
In reply to#167779
WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> writes:

> Am Montag, 4. Dezember 2017 02:40:01 UTC+1 schrieb Ben Bacarisse:
>
>
>> > That does not mean we could say
>> > ~∃n ∈ |N: n is in the urn
>> 
>> Ah.  You mean it only fails for waffle cases.  George said
>> 
>>   "Ax[whatever] just MEANS ~Ex[~whatever]"
>> 
>> and you said that does not hold for potential infinity.  But now you say
>> it holds for formulas -- essentially for every case except when the
>> "whatever" is some waffle words.  Can you confirm there is no exception
>> for potential infinity when a well-defined formula is involved?
>> 
> There is no exception when we define: n goes out not before n+1 has
> come in.

I am trying to get an answer to my question: Can you confirm there is no
exception for potential infinity when a well-defined formula is
involved?  It's fine if you can't think of one.  In fact I would be
surprised if you could!

<snip>
-- 
Ben.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167833

FromGeorge Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu>
Date2017-12-05 13:53 -0800
Message-ID<0cdc6809-4596-4e9c-8ae2-b07b6967fe25@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#167807
On Monday, December 4, 2017 at 7:36:34 PM UTC-5, Ben Bacarisse wrote:
> I am trying to get an answer to my question:

I must continue to insist that it is just pedagogically WRONG to ask questions of cranks.

> Can you confirm there is no
> exception for potential infinity

Potential infinity IS BULLSHIT.
You don't HELP anything by asking anyone to "explain" it.

> when a well-defined formula is  involved?

Well-defined formulas ARE NOT involved here.
You CANNOT QUANTIFY over *JUST* N in first-order logic.
You qauntify over THE DOMAIN and the domain could be ANY class of objects isomoprhic to N, or even a NON-standard model of any traditional first-order
axiomatization of N like PA.  You could sort-of do it in first-order Z since
you can emulate 2nd-order with the powerset of N, but even in that case, 
defining an element of N as a finite ordinal still might not be enough.

The real issues here are about things like The Frame Problem and possibly even The Compactness Theorem (again, quantifying over all and exactly N is hard
enough that you may have to settle for the conjunction of the infinitely
many actions for the individual n's, and that clearly WON'T work).

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167835

FromBen Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk>
Date2017-12-06 02:21 +0000
Message-ID<87tvx438b8.fsf@bsb.me.uk>
In reply to#167833
George Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu> writes:

> On Monday, December 4, 2017 at 7:36:34 PM UTC-5, Ben Bacarisse wrote:
>> I am trying to get an answer to my question:
>
> I must continue to insist that it is just pedagogically WRONG to ask
> questions of cranks.

OK.

>> Can you confirm there is no
>> exception for potential infinity
>
> Potential infinity IS BULLSHIT.
> You don't HELP anything by asking anyone to "explain" it.

I disagree.  WM can't answer the question precisely because potential
infinity is nonsense.  Adding the word "potential" does not stop
Ax[P(x)] being the same as ~Ex[~P(x)] and the only "examples" WM will be
able to come up with will involve waffle.

>> when a well-defined formula is  involved?
>
> Well-defined formulas ARE NOT involved here.

I think this depends on what you mean by "here".  WM's supposed example
depended on a pile of hand-waving waffle.  You are doing a great job of
looking after the big picture (which I doubt his students can follow)
but on the detail of a case where Ax[P(x)] = ~Ex[~P(x)] does not hold, a
formula would be essential.

Maybe if his students read this they will see that he can not give a set
and a predicate where the usual approach of defining Ax[P(x)] as
~Ex[~P(x)] causes any problems.

It's similar to an old strategy of asking for a theorem of WMaths that
does not hold in mathematics (or vice-versa).  All his supposed examples
were word-salad.

<snip>
-- 
Ben.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167839

FromGeorge Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu>
Date2017-12-05 20:40 -0800
Message-ID<f674fe9b-f374-4320-bd4c-1ac6154b521e@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#167835
On Tuesday, December 5, 2017 at 9:21:34 PM UTC-5, Ben Bacarisse wrote:
> but on the detail of a case where Ax[P(x)] = ~Ex[~P(x)]
> does not hold, a
> formula would be essential.

Wait a minute, did I just MISS one?  Did he SAY that they were not eqUivalent??
*YOU*CAN'T*ARGUE* with a DEFINITION!!!!

Is he going to allege that Ex[whatever] can sometimes be proved but can NEVER be DISproved??

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167772

FromAlan Smaill <smaill@SPAMinf.ed.ac.uk>
Date2017-12-04 11:33 +0000
Message-ID<fwefu8q7mnz.fsf@foxtrot.inf.ed.ac.uk>
In reply to#167741
WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> writes:

> Universal quantification is not possible for quantitative statements
> (i.e., about the whole infinite set) like
>
> ∀n ∈ |N: At 12 o'clock n has left the urn.
>
> That does not mean we could say
> ~∃n ∈ |N: n is in the urn

Well, no: there is no mention of 12 o'clock.

> Correct is that we cannot *name* such an n, because every n that we
> can name has left the urn.

So, n is *undefinable*.

But every sober mind knows that undefinable entities are the height of nonsense
and must be banned from real mathematics.

> Regards, WM
>

-- 
Alan Smaill

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167777

FromWM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de>
Date2017-12-04 10:10 -0800
Message-ID<da89fb54-96f0-4b14-9cb5-25cb7c78e77d@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#167772
Am Montag, 4. Dezember 2017 12:35:04 UTC+1 schrieb Alan Smaill:


> > Correct is that we cannot *name* such an n, because every n that we
> > can name has left the urn.
> 
> So, n is *undefinable*.

Every n that we can name is followed by infinitely many others. WE can name every n but this does not change the situation.
> 
> But every sober mind knows that undefinable entities are the height of nonsense
> and must be banned from real mathematics.

These numbers are not yet existing. So they are not part of mathematics. As soon as they are existing, we cam name them. But this does not change the situation.

Regards, WM

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167818

FromAlan Smaill <smaill@SPAMinf.ed.ac.uk>
Date2017-12-05 13:43 +0000
Message-ID<fwe609ls32d.fsf@greyhound.inf.ed.ac.uk>
In reply to#167777
WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> writes:

> Am Montag, 4. Dezember 2017 12:35:04 UTC+1 schrieb Alan Smaill:
>
>> > Correct is that we cannot *name* such an n, because every n that we
>> > can name has left the urn.
>> 
>> So, n is *undefinable*.
>
> Every n that we can name is followed by infinitely many others. WE can
> name every n but this does not change the situation.

You cannot define the n in question (whose attempted characterisation
you have of course wisely snipped).

And there are no undefinable entities in mathemetics (copyright WM).

So you are literally talking nonsense.

> Regards, WM
>

-- 
Alan Smaill

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#167787

FromGeorge Greene <greeneg@email.unc.edu>
Date2017-12-04 12:09 -0800
Message-ID<f3316a89-4017-4cea-8517-fcf2e73d3ffc@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#167772
On Monday, December 4, 2017 at 6:35:04 AM UTC-5, Alan Smaill wrote:
> WM <wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de> writes:
> 
> > Universal quantification is not possible for quantitative statements
> > (i.e., about the whole infinite set) like
> >
> > ∀n ∈ |N: At 12 o'clock n has left the urn.
> >
> > That does not mean we could say
> > ~∃n ∈ |N: n is in the urn
> 
> Well, no: there is no mention of 12 o'clock.
> 
> > Correct is that we cannot *name* such an n, because every n that we
> > can name has left the urn.
> 
> So, n is *undefinable*.

The n being talked about here is NOT A NATURAL NUMBER and therefore NOT properly abbreviated "n" -- and more to the point, it may (or may not) be mentioned among the axioms that require ball#n to come out, if n is not a number and the balls are numbered.
> 
> But every sober mind knows
> that undefinable entities are the height of nonsense

You CAN'T KEEP saying shit like that.  If you can't DERIVE A CONTRADICTION from it then you DON'T GET to dismiss it as nonsense.  If you can't derive a contradiction from it then THERE IS IN FACT A MODEL where it not only is not nonsense, BUT IS FACTUALLY TRUE.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


Page 2 of 5 — ← Prev page 1 [2] 3 4 5  Next page →

Back to top | Article view | sci.logic


csiph-web