Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > comp.theory > #33539 > unrolled thread

The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1

Started bywij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
First post2021-05-14 05:11 -0700
Last post2021-05-15 05:02 -0700
Articles 20 on this page of 85 — 7 participants

Back to article view | Back to comp.theory


Contents

  The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 05:11 -0700
    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-14 13:25 +0100
      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 09:03 -0700
        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-14 12:21 -0400
          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 09:51 -0700
            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-14 14:59 -0400
              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 17:24 -0700
                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-14 21:19 -0400
                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 19:28 -0700
                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-15 19:39 +0100
                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-15 23:37 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 07:17 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 07:06 -0700
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 10:37 -0700
                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 12:14 -0700
                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 13:29 -0700
                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 22:10 -0700
                              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-17 01:03 -0700
                                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-17 02:50 -0700
                                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-17 03:21 -0700
                                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-17 03:33 -0700
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-17 00:21 +0100
                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 23:47 -0700
                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-17 20:02 +0100
                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-18 01:50 -0700
                              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-20 19:18 +0100
                                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-20 20:10 -0700
                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-19 05:08 -0700
                              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-19 08:45 -0400
                                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-19 20:21 -0700
                                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-20 06:12 -0700
                                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-20 15:26 +0100
                                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-20 16:52 +0100
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-20 17:03 +0100
                                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Jeff Barnett <jbb@notatt.com> - 2021-05-20 12:48 -0600
                                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-20 19:26 -0700
                                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-20 22:24 -0700
                                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-21 21:18 -0400
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-22 00:36 -0700
                                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-22 09:21 -0400
                                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-22 11:55 -0700
                                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-22 13:10 +0100
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-23 17:08 -0700
                                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-09-10 04:36 -0700
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-22 12:23 -0700
                                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-22 22:59 +0100
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-23 19:45 +0100
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-22 19:52 -0400
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-22 15:58 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-16 12:11 +0100
        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-14 17:25 +0100
          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 10:09 -0700
            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-14 19:51 +0100
              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 18:13 -0700
                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-15 19:50 +0100
                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-15 23:19 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Jeff Barnett <jbb@notatt.com> - 2021-05-16 02:46 -0600
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 02:50 -0700
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 03:10 -0700
                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Jeff Barnett <jbb@notatt.com> - 2021-05-16 13:27 -0600
                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-16 21:40 +0100
                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-16 17:01 -0400
                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Jeff Barnett <jbb@notatt.com> - 2021-05-16 22:16 -0600
                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 21:53 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-16 11:39 +0100
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 04:19 -0700
                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 06:18 -0700
            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-14 20:16 +0100
              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 16:51 -0700
                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-15 01:59 +0100
                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 19:01 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-15 03:06 +0100
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 19:22 -0700
                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-15 13:44 +0100
            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Peter <peterxpercival@hotmail.com> - 2021-05-15 15:03 +0100
              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-15 10:14 -0700
                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-15 19:06 +0100
    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-14 14:51 +0100
      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 09:10 -0700
    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-14 10:28 -0400
      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 09:31 -0700
        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 10:18 -0700
          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 10:46 -0700
            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-15 03:20 -0700
              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-15 05:02 -0700

Page 1 of 5  [1] 2 3 4 5  Next page →


#33539 — The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-14 05:11 -0700
SubjectThe Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1
Message-ID<350afdc3-f706-49d7-aae5-e23da949fc5bn@googlegroups.com>
Most young kids easily understand 0.999…≠1, and will be confused if the 
opposite is told. But nowadays, it seems becoming globally common, 
students are forced (educated) to believe and 'must' so answer in exam. 
that lim(n→∞) {1/n}=0 and 0.999...=1. There are many ways approaching
the truth.
I just list my simple answers from basic intuition, no need resorting to 
academic formalism (which novice trust more), though the implication can
be very deep and very broad.

1. 1/3=0.333... (repeating decimals are rational numbers)
In the long division method, the digit rendering process is endless. In
computer science, the result of such a process is called undecidable. From
logic point of view, the infinite repeating process is caused by the 
existence of non-zero remainder. If 1/3 is determined to be the answer of 
0.333..., the remainder of the division must be zero. Then, how could the 
infinite repeating 3 be possible?
This problem is similar to the differences of range (0,1) and (0,1] and the
density property notion. All the people I know agree that range (0,1),(0,1] 
are different and the density property is true. While realizing a<b,∃c such 
that a<c<b, and simultaneously believe (no valid logic) c will eventually 
'equal to' b without breaking the density property.

Also, the process is similar to Zeno's paradox 
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zeno%27s_paradoxes#Achilles_and_the_tortoise
In the logic presented, Achilles can never out run the tortoise (note: 'time' 
is not 'forever', implied by 'never', but is actually converged, infinitely 
closing to some value).

2. In the view of differential calculus, all curves are made up of 
infinitesimal bent (or zigzag) lines, there is no such thing as 'real curve'. 
Therefore, in integral calculus, the enclosed/calculated area is actually the
sum of infinite number of rectangles.

The analytic 'approach' (or limit) model substituted the conceptual reality.
Then, the first trouble is that the definition and property of a circle 
becomes problematic, e.g the angles in the circle.

Note: I am not qualified to say the expression "lim(n→∞){1/n}=0" is 
invalid,  I was talking about its meaning.

'Number' has no scale issues. Different numbers are simply different.
There is no such thing that error being too small equals to zero (no 
difference).

The following file is a draft written about 2 years ago, basically talking 
about infinity. Several places are not right, but leaving to improve.
https://sourceforge.net/projects/cscall/files/MisFiles/Infinity-en.txt/download

[toc] | [next] | [standalone]


#33541

FromBen Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk>
Date2021-05-14 13:25 +0100
Message-ID<87tun5tsch.fsf@bsb.me.uk>
In reply to#33539
wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> writes:

> Most young kids easily understand 0.999…≠1, and will be confused if the 
> opposite is told. But nowadays, it seems becoming globally common, 
> students are forced (educated) to believe and 'must' so answer in
> exam.

In some of the better institutions, they will be given the tools to
argue the point.  Were you just told to believe it?  Were you never
given any justification for 0.999... = 1?

> 1. 1/3=0.333... (repeating decimals are rational numbers)
> In the long division method, the digit rendering process is endless. In
> computer science, the result of such a process is called undecidable.

No, that is not what "undecidable" means.

-- 
Ben.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33550

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-14 09:03 -0700
Message-ID<eaa02c60-df7d-443c-81bc-0c54bfd5efb5n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33541
On Friday, 14 May 2021 at 20:25:36 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote:
> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
> 
> > Most young kids easily understand 0.999…≠1, and will be confused if the 
> > opposite is told. But nowadays, it seems becoming globally common, 
> > students are forced (educated) to believe and 'must' so answer in 
> > exam.
> In some of the better institutions, they will be given the tools to 
> argue the point. Were you just told to believe it? Were you never 
> given any justification for 0.999... = 1?

I have seen various 'proves' in recent 10 years, just magic show, similar to
olcott's way of proof/claim, inventing a obfuscate theory to explain desired
result, ignoring simple/intuitive explanation.
Or you can provided a LOGICAL proof (limit is no logic).

I assume you did not read the file:
https://sourceforge.net/projects/cscall/files/MisFiles/Infinity-en.txt/download

> > 1. 1/3=0.333... (repeating decimals are rational numbers) 
> > In the long division method, the digit rendering process is endless. In 
> > computer science, the result of such a process is called undecidable.
> No, that is not what "undecidable" means. 
> 
> -- 
> Ben.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decidability_(logic)

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33555

FromRichard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org>
Date2021-05-14 12:21 -0400
Message-ID<bsxnI.131784$Y87.72485@fx08.iad>
In reply to#33550
On 5/14/21 12:03 PM, wij wrote:
> On Friday, 14 May 2021 at 20:25:36 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote:
>> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
>>
>>> Most young kids easily understand 0.999…≠1, and will be confused if the 
>>> opposite is told. But nowadays, it seems becoming globally common, 
>>> students are forced (educated) to believe and 'must' so answer in 
>>> exam.
>> In some of the better institutions, they will be given the tools to 
>> argue the point. Were you just told to believe it? Were you never 
>> given any justification for 0.999... = 1?
> 
> I have seen various 'proves' in recent 10 years, just magic show, similar to
> olcott's way of proof/claim, inventing a obfuscate theory to explain desired
> result, ignoring simple/intuitive explanation.
> Or you can provided a LOGICAL proof (limit is no logic).
> 
> I assume you did not read the file:
> https://sourceforge.net/projects/cscall/files/MisFiles/Infinity-en.txt/download
> 

I will comment that your 'exponent amplification' technique violates the
principles of limit theory. Just because f(n) approaches 1 as a limit
does NOT mean that f(n)^n also approaches 1, even though 1^n is 1.

Higher order limit theory talks about how fast something approaches the
limit, and doing things like that can be used as tests for the speed of
convergence.

All you have shown is that 1/n does not approach 0 as fast as an
exponential.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33560

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-14 09:51 -0700
Message-ID<10bf7d4b-80ea-4cb2-9c46-3277168fe74an@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33555
On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 00:21:31 UTC+8, Richard Damon wrote:
> On 5/14/21 12:03 PM, wij wrote: 
> > On Friday, 14 May 2021 at 20:25:36 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote: 
> >> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
> >> 
> >>> Most young kids easily understand 0.999…≠1, and will be confused if the 
> >>> opposite is told. But nowadays, it seems becoming globally common, 
> >>> students are forced (educated) to believe and 'must' so answer in 
> >>> exam. 
> >> In some of the better institutions, they will be given the tools to 
> >> argue the point. Were you just told to believe it? Were you never 
> >> given any justification for 0.999... = 1? 
> > 
> > I have seen various 'proves' in recent 10 years, just magic show, similar to 
> > olcott's way of proof/claim, inventing a obfuscate theory to explain desired 
> > result, ignoring simple/intuitive explanation. 
> > Or you can provided a LOGICAL proof (limit is no logic). 
> > 
> > I assume you did not read the file: 
> > https://sourceforge.net/projects/cscall/files/MisFiles/Infinity-en.txt/download 
> >
> I will comment that your 'exponent amplification' technique violates the 
> principles of limit theory. Just because f(n) approaches 1 as a limit 
> does NOT mean that f(n)^n also approaches 1, even though 1^n is 1. 
> 
> Higher order limit theory talks about how fast something approaches the 
> limit, and doing things like that can be used as tests for the speed of 
> convergence. 
> 

There is a sentence in related section: "...This proposition should be 1/∞≠0 but
for capturing people's attention. This proposition can not be legitimately denied,
but OK as a notice. limit has its own logic problems."

> All you have shown is that 1/n does not approach 0 as fast as an 
> exponential.

A(n)= (1+1/n)^n = (1.000...1)^n ... approaches e (Euler constant) when n approaches ∞ 
B(n)= (1-1/n)^n  = (0.999...)^n ... approaches 1/e when n approaches ∞

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33568

FromRichard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org>
Date2021-05-14 14:59 -0400
Message-ID<RLznI.93251$v3H9.78712@fx01.iad>
In reply to#33560
On 5/14/21 12:51 PM, wij wrote:
> On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 00:21:31 UTC+8, Richard Damon wrote:
>> On 5/14/21 12:03 PM, wij wrote: 
>>> On Friday, 14 May 2021 at 20:25:36 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote: 
>>>> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
>>>>
>>>>> Most young kids easily understand 0.999…≠1, and will be confused if the 
>>>>> opposite is told. But nowadays, it seems becoming globally common, 
>>>>> students are forced (educated) to believe and 'must' so answer in 
>>>>> exam. 
>>>> In some of the better institutions, they will be given the tools to 
>>>> argue the point. Were you just told to believe it? Were you never 
>>>> given any justification for 0.999... = 1? 
>>>
>>> I have seen various 'proves' in recent 10 years, just magic show, similar to 
>>> olcott's way of proof/claim, inventing a obfuscate theory to explain desired 
>>> result, ignoring simple/intuitive explanation. 
>>> Or you can provided a LOGICAL proof (limit is no logic). 
>>>
>>> I assume you did not read the file: 
>>> https://sourceforge.net/projects/cscall/files/MisFiles/Infinity-en.txt/download 
>>>
>> I will comment that your 'exponent amplification' technique violates the 
>> principles of limit theory. Just because f(n) approaches 1 as a limit 
>> does NOT mean that f(n)^n also approaches 1, even though 1^n is 1. 
>>
>> Higher order limit theory talks about how fast something approaches the 
>> limit, and doing things like that can be used as tests for the speed of 
>> convergence. 
>>
> 
> There is a sentence in related section: "...This proposition should be 1/∞≠0 but
> for capturing people's attention. This proposition can not be legitimately denied,
> but OK as a notice. limit has its own logic problems."
> 
>> All you have shown is that 1/n does not approach 0 as fast as an 
>> exponential.
> 
> A(n)= (1+1/n)^n = (1.000...1)^n ... approaches e (Euler constant) when n approaches ∞ 
> B(n)= (1-1/n)^n  = (0.999...)^n ... approaches 1/e when n approaches ∞
> 

Right, but your are doing an operation that limit theory doesn't say
works. Nothing says that limits and composition are swapable.

the fact that the limit(n->inf) f(n) = 1 does NOT mean that you can also
say that lim(n->inf) g(f(n)) = g(1), thus your statements don't rally
say anything, except to show that you cant do that.

Would you expect sin(cos(x)) to be cos(sin(x)) ?

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33594

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-14 17:24 -0700
Message-ID<460b3c21-7dce-43d8-bf5a-c3d706ac04d5n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33568
On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 02:59:02 UTC+8, Richard Damon wrote:
> On 5/14/21 12:51 PM, wij wrote: 
> > On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 00:21:31 UTC+8, Richard Damon wrote: 
> >> On 5/14/21 12:03 PM, wij wrote: 
> >>> On Friday, 14 May 2021 at 20:25:36 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote: 
> >>>> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
> >>>> 
> >>>>> Most young kids easily understand 0.999…≠1, and will be confused if the 
> >>>>> opposite is told. But nowadays, it seems becoming globally common, 
> >>>>> students are forced (educated) to believe and 'must' so answer in 
> >>>>> exam. 
> >>>> In some of the better institutions, they will be given the tools to 
> >>>> argue the point. Were you just told to believe it? Were you never 
> >>>> given any justification for 0.999... = 1? 
> >>> 
> >>> I have seen various 'proves' in recent 10 years, just magic show, similar to 
> >>> olcott's way of proof/claim, inventing a obfuscate theory to explain desired 
> >>> result, ignoring simple/intuitive explanation. 
> >>> Or you can provided a LOGICAL proof (limit is no logic). 
> >>> 
> >>> I assume you did not read the file: 
> >>> https://sourceforge.net/projects/cscall/files/MisFiles/Infinity-en.txt/download 
> >>> 
> >> I will comment that your 'exponent amplification' technique violates the 
> >> principles of limit theory. Just because f(n) approaches 1 as a limit 
> >> does NOT mean that f(n)^n also approaches 1, even though 1^n is 1. 
> >> 
> >> Higher order limit theory talks about how fast something approaches the 
> >> limit, and doing things like that can be used as tests for the speed of 
> >> convergence. 
> >> 
> > 
> > There is a sentence in related section: "...This proposition should be 1/∞≠0 but 
> > for capturing people's attention. This proposition can not be legitimately denied, 
> > but OK as a notice. limit has its own logic problems." 
> > 
> >> All you have shown is that 1/n does not approach 0 as fast as an 
> >> exponential. 
> > 
> > A(n)= (1+1/n)^n = (1.000...1)^n ... approaches e (Euler constant) when n approaches ∞ 
> > B(n)= (1-1/n)^n = (0.999...)^n ... approaches 1/e when n approaches ∞ 
> >
> Right, but your are doing an operation that limit theory doesn't say 
> works. Nothing says that limits and composition are swapable. 
> 
> the fact that the limit(n->inf) f(n) = 1 does NOT mean that you can also 
> say that lim(n->inf) g(f(n)) = g(1), thus your statements don't rally 
> say anything, except to show that you cant do that. 
> 

In the section, probably your question is from, I deliberately avoid using limit.
My point in that section is to establish 1/∞≠0 (infinitesimal exists and not identical to zero)

> Would you expect sin(cos(x)) to be cos(sin(x)) ?

What does it mean?

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33600

FromRichard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org>
Date2021-05-14 21:19 -0400
Message-ID<EkFnI.361957$2A5.62839@fx45.iad>
In reply to#33594
On 5/14/21 8:24 PM, wij wrote:
> On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 02:59:02 UTC+8, Richard Damon wrote:
>> On 5/14/21 12:51 PM, wij wrote: 
>>> On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 00:21:31 UTC+8, Richard Damon wrote: 
>>>> On 5/14/21 12:03 PM, wij wrote: 
>>>>> On Friday, 14 May 2021 at 20:25:36 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote: 
>>>>>> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Most young kids easily understand 0.999…≠1, and will be confused if the 
>>>>>>> opposite is told. But nowadays, it seems becoming globally common, 
>>>>>>> students are forced (educated) to believe and 'must' so answer in 
>>>>>>> exam. 
>>>>>> In some of the better institutions, they will be given the tools to 
>>>>>> argue the point. Were you just told to believe it? Were you never 
>>>>>> given any justification for 0.999... = 1? 
>>>>>
>>>>> I have seen various 'proves' in recent 10 years, just magic show, similar to 
>>>>> olcott's way of proof/claim, inventing a obfuscate theory to explain desired 
>>>>> result, ignoring simple/intuitive explanation. 
>>>>> Or you can provided a LOGICAL proof (limit is no logic). 
>>>>>
>>>>> I assume you did not read the file: 
>>>>> https://sourceforge.net/projects/cscall/files/MisFiles/Infinity-en.txt/download 
>>>>>
>>>> I will comment that your 'exponent amplification' technique violates the 
>>>> principles of limit theory. Just because f(n) approaches 1 as a limit 
>>>> does NOT mean that f(n)^n also approaches 1, even though 1^n is 1. 
>>>>
>>>> Higher order limit theory talks about how fast something approaches the 
>>>> limit, and doing things like that can be used as tests for the speed of 
>>>> convergence. 
>>>>
>>>
>>> There is a sentence in related section: "...This proposition should be 1/∞≠0 but 
>>> for capturing people's attention. This proposition can not be legitimately denied, 
>>> but OK as a notice. limit has its own logic problems." 
>>>
>>>> All you have shown is that 1/n does not approach 0 as fast as an 
>>>> exponential. 
>>>
>>> A(n)= (1+1/n)^n = (1.000...1)^n ... approaches e (Euler constant) when n approaches ∞ 
>>> B(n)= (1-1/n)^n = (0.999...)^n ... approaches 1/e when n approaches ∞ 
>>>
>> Right, but your are doing an operation that limit theory doesn't say 
>> works. Nothing says that limits and composition are swapable. 
>>
>> the fact that the limit(n->inf) f(n) = 1 does NOT mean that you can also 
>> say that lim(n->inf) g(f(n)) = g(1), thus your statements don't rally 
>> say anything, except to show that you cant do that. 
>>
> 
> In the section, probably your question is from, I deliberately avoid using limit.
> My point in that section is to establish 1/∞≠0 (infinitesimal exists and not identical to zero)
> 
>> Would you expect sin(cos(x)) to be cos(sin(x)) ?
> 
> What does it mean?
> 

You are making the argument that:

lim(n→∞) { (1+1/n)= 1 }

and that 1^n = 1 so therefore we can say that

[ lim(n→∞){ (1+1/n)} } ] ^n would somehow imply that

 lim(n→∞) { (1+1/n)^n } = 1^n = 1

That implies that you think you can swap the order of doing the
exponentiation and the limit.

I am pointing out that is about as crasy as assuming you can swap the
order of calling sin and cos nested.



[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33604

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-14 19:28 -0700
Message-ID<4a1d5ced-9a9d-4189-a35a-6262f210f06cn@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33600
On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 09:19:37 UTC+8, Richard Damon wrote:
> On 5/14/21 8:24 PM, wij wrote: 
> > On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 02:59:02 UTC+8, Richard Damon wrote: 
> >> On 5/14/21 12:51 PM, wij wrote: 
> >>> On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 00:21:31 UTC+8, Richard Damon wrote: 
> >>>> On 5/14/21 12:03 PM, wij wrote: 
> >>>>> On Friday, 14 May 2021 at 20:25:36 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote: 
> >>>>>> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
> >>>>>> 
> >>>>>>> Most young kids easily understand 0.999…≠1, and will be confused if the 
> >>>>>>> opposite is told. But nowadays, it seems becoming globally common, 
> >>>>>>> students are forced (educated) to believe and 'must' so answer in 
> >>>>>>> exam. 
> >>>>>> In some of the better institutions, they will be given the tools to 
> >>>>>> argue the point. Were you just told to believe it? Were you never 
> >>>>>> given any justification for 0.999... = 1? 
> >>>>> 
> >>>>> I have seen various 'proves' in recent 10 years, just magic show, similar to 
> >>>>> olcott's way of proof/claim, inventing a obfuscate theory to explain desired 
> >>>>> result, ignoring simple/intuitive explanation. 
> >>>>> Or you can provided a LOGICAL proof (limit is no logic). 
> >>>>> 
> >>>>> I assume you did not read the file: 
> >>>>> https://sourceforge.net/projects/cscall/files/MisFiles/Infinity-en.txt/download 
> >>>>> 
> >>>> I will comment that your 'exponent amplification' technique violates the 
> >>>> principles of limit theory. Just because f(n) approaches 1 as a limit 
> >>>> does NOT mean that f(n)^n also approaches 1, even though 1^n is 1. 
> >>>> 
> >>>> Higher order limit theory talks about how fast something approaches the 
> >>>> limit, and doing things like that can be used as tests for the speed of 
> >>>> convergence. 
> >>>> 
> >>> 
> >>> There is a sentence in related section: "...This proposition should be 1/∞≠0 but 
> >>> for capturing people's attention. This proposition can not be legitimately denied, 
> >>> but OK as a notice. limit has its own logic problems." 
> >>> 
> >>>> All you have shown is that 1/n does not approach 0 as fast as an 
> >>>> exponential. 
> >>> 
> >>> A(n)= (1+1/n)^n = (1.000...1)^n ... approaches e (Euler constant) when n approaches ∞ 
> >>> B(n)= (1-1/n)^n = (0.999...)^n ... approaches 1/e when n approaches ∞ 
> >>> 
> >> Right, but your are doing an operation that limit theory doesn't say 
> >> works. Nothing says that limits and composition are swapable. 
> >> 
> >> the fact that the limit(n->inf) f(n) = 1 does NOT mean that you can also 
> >> say that lim(n->inf) g(f(n)) = g(1), thus your statements don't rally 
> >> say anything, except to show that you cant do that. 
> >> 
> > 
> > In the section, probably your question is from, I deliberately avoid using limit. 
> > My point in that section is to establish 1/∞≠0 (infinitesimal exists and not identical to zero) 
> > 
> >> Would you expect sin(cos(x)) to be cos(sin(x)) ? 
> > 
> > What does it mean? 
> >
> You are making the argument that: 
> 
> lim(n→∞) { (1+1/n)= 1 } 
> 
> and that 1^n = 1 so therefore we can say that 
> 
> [ lim(n→∞){ (1+1/n)} } ] ^n would somehow imply that 
> 
> lim(n→∞) { (1+1/n)^n } = 1^n = 1 
> 
> That implies that you think you can swap the order of doing the 
> exponentiation and the limit. 
> 
> I am pointing out that is about as crasy as assuming you can swap the 
> order of calling sin and cos nested.

Thank you to point out the crasy part in that section.
But it is easy to see that it is not the part of the subject.
I take it as one of reader's response to that file.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33630

FromAndy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk>
Date2021-05-15 19:39 +0100
Message-ID<s7p4h5$94h$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#33594
On 15/05/2021 01:24, wij wrote:
> My point in that section is to establish 1/∞≠0 (infinitesimal exists
> and not identical to zero)

	You can't "establish" that.  In the standard reals, there are,
/by axiom/, no infinitesimals and no infinities [limits "to infinity"
are special constructs with specific definitions].  OTOH, there are
plenty of other number systems in which there are indeed infinities
and infinitesimals with properties that more-or-less correspond to
intuition.  But these other systems are not "the real numbers", and
you soon get into difficulties if you take over "obvious" facts
without rigorous investigation.

	As previously referenced, the other system that I personally
find of most interest is the surreals

   https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surreal_number

which arise most naturally as a subset of games and thus are Quite
Interesting to write computer programs for.  The Wiki article is
of highly variable difficulty;  an alternative start point is

   https://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/sn.html

[which also references the seminal texts by the late, great John
Conway, RIP].

-- 
Andy Walker, Nottingham.
    Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music
    Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Mendelssohn

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33663

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-15 23:37 -0700
Message-ID<baa60717-24e7-4289-972f-9651ff4d7707n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33630
On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 02:39:37 UTC+8, Andy Walker wrote:
> On 15/05/2021 01:24, wij wrote: 
> > My point in that section is to establish 1/∞≠0 (infinitesimal exists 
> > and not identical to zero)
> You can't "establish" that. In the standard reals, there are, 
> /by axiom/, no infinitesimals and no infinities [limits "to infinity" 
> are special constructs with specific definitions]. OTOH, there are 
> plenty of other number systems in which there are indeed infinities 
> and infinitesimals with properties that more-or-less correspond to 
> intuition. But these other systems are not "the real numbers", and 
> you soon get into difficulties if you take over "obvious" facts 
> without rigorous investigation. 
> 
> As previously referenced, the other system that I personally 
> find of most interest is the surreals 
> 
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surreal_number 
> 
> which arise most naturally as a subset of games and thus are Quite 
> Interesting to write computer programs for. The Wiki article is 
> of highly variable difficulty; an alternative start point is 
> 
> https://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/sn.html 
> 
> [which also references the seminal texts by the late, great John 
> Conway, RIP].
> -- 
> Andy Walker, Nottingham. 
> Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music 
> Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Mendelssohn

Why can't I? Every theory begins from postulate/proposition/axiom, whatever.
[Your standard reals] or [surreals] or others are probably no different from 
other 'pure theory', have the difficulty applying to the real line. Thus,
what is the "obvious facts" and "rigorous investigation"?

My theory of infinity is simple:

 Definition of ∞: 
  1. ∀n∈ℕ, n<∞
  2. The multiplicative inverse of ∞ is 1/∞, the additive inverse is -∞

[Corollary] 1/∞≠0 (infinitesimal exists and not identical to zero)

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33666

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-16 07:17 -0700
Message-ID<67bacd62-17e7-4fa1-a6ee-6901e2616b89n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33663
On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 22:06:26 UTC+8, wij wrote:
> On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 19:11:16 UTC+8, Andy Walker wrote: 
> > On 16/05/2021 07:37, wij wrote: 
> > >>> My point in that section is to establish 1/∞≠0 (infinitesimal exists 
> > >>> and not identical to zero) 
> > >> You can't "establish" that. [...] 
> > > Why can't I? 
> > 
> > Because there are perfectly acceptable arithmetics in which 
> > that is true and perfectly acceptable arithmetics in which it is 
> > false. So neither its truth nor its falsity can be proven except 
> > by taking it [or its converse] as an axiom; in which case, it is 
> > not "established", but merely an assumption. 
> > 
> > > Every theory begins from postulate/proposition/axiom, whatever.. 
> > 
> > Quite. But such axioms only apply to that theory, not to any 
> > other theories that start from other axioms.
> My definition of infinity applies in algebra, not some uncommon theory. 
> "1/∞≠0" is a corollary as had been shown, not an assumption.
> > > [Your standard reals] or [surreals] or others are probably no different from 
> > > other 'pure theory', have the difficulty applying to the real line. Thus, 
> > > what is the "obvious facts" and "rigorous investigation"? 
> > You seem to think that there is only one true, correct version 
> > of maths. "Die ganzen Zahlen hat der liebe Gott gemacht, alles andere 
> > ist Menschenwerk" -- Kronecker. So almost all of mathematics is man- 
> > made, and largely a matter of choice. Virtually all engineering [eg] 
> > maths is preceded by an invisible "[Using the standard reals]", as 
> > that is the common currency among virtually all non-mathematicians, 
> > even if they don't know or understand it, and a large majority of 
> > actual mathematicians [inc me, except when doing game theory].
> I do not believe one truth theory. 
> There are more problems in the 'established' calculation of infinite series.
> > > My theory of infinity is simple: 
> > > Definition of ∞: 
> > > 1. ∀n∈ℕ, n<∞ 
> > > 2. The multiplicative inverse of ∞ is 1/∞, the additive inverse is -∞ 
> > > [Corollary] 1/∞≠0 (infinitesimal exists and not identical to zero) 
> > Sure, and versions of that theory are well known, starting 
> > [seriously] with the debates about the foundations of calculus in 
> > the 18thC. But, for good reasons, they lost out to the standard 
> > theory of real numbers, and all that followed in the 19thC when 
> > Cauchy and others put maths on a rigorous basis. So your theory 
> > isn't "wrong", it's just not standard. When you apply it, you can 
> > get versions of calculus and all the rest of engineering maths. 
> > But you don't get the same theorems as the rest of us, and it's 
> > not easy, as you can easily verify by looking up "non-standard 
> > analysis". Which is why it's not taught to undergraduates. 
> > -- 
> > Andy Walker, Nottingham. 
> > Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music 
> > Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Ketterer
> I would like to say something in perspective of education. 
> In calculating the derivative of f(x)=x^2: 
> 
> lim(d->0) { ((x+d)^2-x^2)/d }= 2x+d = 2x 
> 
> d is removed. The process shows 'approach', not 'equal'. 
> The conclusion 'equal' is based on an 'improvised', 'standardized' theory(IMO), 
> and the density property is lost or re-explained in a strange way. 
> So I would suggest the writing "lim(d->0) f(x) -> 2x" would be more 
> appropriate, closer to reality. But my problem is that: 
> 1. The above does not prove that the result of derivative is wrong. 
> 2. The relation between derivative and integration should be exactly correct.

Correction:
1. The above does not prove that the result of derivative is wrong in the general cases.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33668

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-16 07:06 -0700
Message-ID<58743cf1-3ef1-4099-96e2-f0fbe51aa4d7n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33663
On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 19:11:16 UTC+8, Andy Walker wrote:
> On 16/05/2021 07:37, wij wrote: 
> >>> My point in that section is to establish 1/∞≠0 (infinitesimal exists 
> >>> and not identical to zero)
> >> You can't "establish" that. [...] 
> > Why can't I? 
> 
> Because there are perfectly acceptable arithmetics in which 
> that is true and perfectly acceptable arithmetics in which it is 
> false. So neither its truth nor its falsity can be proven except 
> by taking it [or its converse] as an axiom; in which case, it is 
> not "established", but merely an assumption. 
> 
> > Every theory begins from postulate/proposition/axiom, whatever.. 
> 
> Quite. But such axioms only apply to that theory, not to any 
> other theories that start from other axioms.

My definition of infinity applies in algebra, not some uncommon theory.
"1/∞≠0" is a corollary as had been shown, not an assumption.

> > [Your standard reals] or [surreals] or others are probably no different from 
> > other 'pure theory', have the difficulty applying to the real line. Thus, 
> > what is the "obvious facts" and "rigorous investigation"?
> You seem to think that there is only one true, correct version 
> of maths. "Die ganzen Zahlen hat der liebe Gott gemacht, alles andere 
> ist Menschenwerk" -- Kronecker. So almost all of mathematics is man- 
> made, and largely a matter of choice. Virtually all engineering [eg] 
> maths is preceded by an invisible "[Using the standard reals]", as 
> that is the common currency among virtually all non-mathematicians, 
> even if they don't know or understand it, and a large majority of 
> actual mathematicians [inc me, except when doing game theory].

I do not believe one truth theory.
There are more problems in the 'established' calculation of infinite series.

> > My theory of infinity is simple: 
> > Definition of ∞: 
> > 1. ∀n∈ℕ, n<∞ 
> > 2. The multiplicative inverse of ∞ is 1/∞, the additive inverse is -∞ 
> > [Corollary] 1/∞≠0 (infinitesimal exists and not identical to zero)
> Sure, and versions of that theory are well known, starting 
> [seriously] with the debates about the foundations of calculus in 
> the 18thC. But, for good reasons, they lost out to the standard 
> theory of real numbers, and all that followed in the 19thC when 
> Cauchy and others put maths on a rigorous basis. So your theory 
> isn't "wrong", it's just not standard. When you apply it, you can 
> get versions of calculus and all the rest of engineering maths. 
> But you don't get the same theorems as the rest of us, and it's 
> not easy, as you can easily verify by looking up "non-standard 
> analysis". Which is why it's not taught to undergraduates.
> -- 
> Andy Walker, Nottingham. 
> Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music
> Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Ketterer

I would like to say something in perspective of education.
In calculating the derivative of f(x)=x^2:

lim(d->0) { ((x+d)^2-x^2)/d }= 2x+d = 2x

d is removed. The process shows 'approach', not 'equal'.
The conclusion 'equal' is based on an 'improvised', 'standardized' theory(IMO),
and the density property is lost or re-explained in a strange way.
So I would suggest the writing "lim(d->0) f(x) -> 2x" would be more
appropriate, closer to reality. But my problem is that:
1. The above does not prove that the result of derivative is wrong.
2. The relation between derivative and integration should be exactly correct.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33699

FromMalcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-16 10:37 -0700
Message-ID<16a4b27d-7a75-4487-ab5c-c038d1179695n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33668
On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 15:06:26 UTC+1, wij wrote:
>
> I would like to say something in perspective of education. 
> In calculating the derivative of f(x)=x^2: 
> 
> lim(d->0) { ((x+d)^2-x^2)/d }= 2x+d = 2x 
> 
> d is removed. The process shows 'approach', not 'equal'. 
>
However you can do it like this. Instead of f(x), call it y because
we're graphing the function on graph paper.

y = x^2

Now we make a small step

delta y = (x + delta x)^2 - x^2

delta y = x^2 + 2*delta x *x + (delta x^2) - x^2
delta y = 2 * delta x * x + (delta x)^2

but delta x is vanishingly tiny. So what is delta x squared going to be?
Surely we can just say that it nothing.

delta y = 2 * delta x * x;

delta y / delta x is the step in y for a step in x, and equals 2x. So when x is 
negative, the graph slopes down, when x is exactly zero the graph is at its
minimum, and when x is positive the graph slopes up.

But these are exact equations for the slope at a point. The strategy of saying
"delta x squared equals zero", which looks a bit dubious, hasn't in fact 
introduced an inaccuracy.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33711

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-16 12:14 -0700
Message-ID<f6a8182d-666a-4013-96cc-9c7592ed0412n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33699
On Monday, 17 May 2021 at 01:37:34 UTC+8, malcolm.ar...@gmail.com wrote:
> On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 15:06:26 UTC+1, wij wrote: 
> > 
> > I would like to say something in perspective of education. 
> > In calculating the derivative of f(x)=x^2: 
> > 
> > lim(d->0) { ((x+d)^2-x^2)/d }= 2x+d = 2x 
> > 
> > d is removed. The process shows 'approach', not 'equal'. 
> >
> However you can do it like this. Instead of f(x), call it y because 
> we're graphing the function on graph paper. 
> 
> y = x^2 
> 
> Now we make a small step 
> 
> delta y = (x + delta x)^2 - x^2 
> 
> delta y = x^2 + 2*delta x *x + (delta x^2) - x^2 
> delta y = 2 * delta x * x + (delta x)^2 
> 
> but delta x is vanishingly tiny. So what is delta x squared going to be? 
> Surely we can just say that it nothing. 
> 
> delta y = 2 * delta x * x; 
> 
> delta y / delta x is the step in y for a step in x, and equals 2x. So when x is 
> negative, the graph slopes down, when x is exactly zero the graph is at its 
> minimum, and when x is positive the graph slopes up. 
> 

Firstly, d (delta) can not be zero, which is also the 1st requirement of limit.
(I should avoid using limit, but the basic idea fits appropriately)

Secondly, I had expressed somewhere in the past an opinion that 'Number' has
no scale issues. Different numbers are simply just different.
There is no such thing that "error/difference being too small" equals to or is zero.

> But these are exact equations for the slope at a point. The strategy of saying 
> "delta x squared equals zero", which looks a bit dubious, hasn't in fact 
> introduced an inaccuracy.

How are the "exact equations" derived from?
"slope at A point" makes no sense.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33722

FromMalcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-16 13:29 -0700
Message-ID<2c8d6955-c7ab-4225-bc71-414d9598caf4n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33711
On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 20:14:04 UTC+1, wij wrote:
> On Monday, 17 May 2021 at 01:37:34 UTC+8, malcolm.ar...@gmail.com wrote: 
>
> How are the "exact equations" derived from? 
> "slope at A point" makes no sense.
>
You mean a slope is surely a property of two points, with a height difference
between them?
That's true of a physical hill - whilst a large ball will roll down it, a very small
sphere will not, because at small scales there are discontinuities and local
minima.
On the other hand, drop a stone (strictly you should use a vacuum tube) 
and plot its velocity over time. You should derive a straight line with a
slope of 9.8 m per second per second. There are no obvious reasons
for any discontinuity in that plot.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33760

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-16 22:10 -0700
Message-ID<fe33c73b-1f99-46c8-a49f-976a474618d1n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33722
On Monday, 17 May 2021 at 04:29:35 UTC+8, malcolm.ar...@gmail.com wrote:
> On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 20:14:04 UTC+1, wij wrote: 
> > On Monday, 17 May 2021 at 01:37:34 UTC+8, malcolm.ar...@gmail.com wrote: 
> > 
> > How are the "exact equations" derived from? 
> > "slope at A point" makes no sense. 
> >
> You mean a slope is surely a property of two points, with a height difference 
> between them? 

"So far" yes, slope is defined by two different points. Speed is measured from
two different points. If the conclusion (speed/slop) is made from a point, the
interval (to another point) is actually arbitrary, result would contain infinitesimal
uncertainty. Although, I do think there is an exact value at the minima/maxima
of a curve.

> That's true of a physical hill - whilst a large ball will roll down it, a very small 
> sphere will not, because at small scales there are discontinuities and local 
> minima. 
> On the other hand, drop a stone (strictly you should use a vacuum tube) 
> and plot its velocity over time. You should derive a straight line with a 
> slope of 9.8 m per second per second. There are no obvious reasons 
> for any discontinuity in that plot.

That is still qualified as average speed, even one call it 'instantaneous'.
Continuity is vague in microscopic level. In mathematics, I am afraid that
'continuous' is a cyclic definition, not very clear to me.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33762

FromMalcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-17 01:03 -0700
Message-ID<5a826b44-d826-4752-8b33-eb33d3fec71cn@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33760
On Monday, 17 May 2021 at 06:10:53 UTC+1, wij wrote:
> On Monday, 17 May 2021 at 04:29:35 UTC+8, malcolm.ar...@gmail.com wrote: 
> > On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 20:14:04 UTC+1, wij wrote: 
> > > On Monday, 17 May 2021 at 01:37:34 UTC+8, malcolm.ar...@gmail.com wrote: 
> > > 
> > > How are the "exact equations" derived from? 
> > > "slope at A point" makes no sense. 
> > > 
> > You mean a slope is surely a property of two points, with a height difference 
> > between them?
> "So far" yes, slope is defined by two different points. Speed is measured from 
> two different points. If the conclusion (speed/slop) is made from a point, the 
> interval (to another point) is actually arbitrary, result would contain infinitesimal 
> uncertainty. Although, I do think there is an exact value at the minima/maxima 
> of a curve.
> > That's true of a physical hill - whilst a large ball will roll down it, a very small 
> > sphere will not, because at small scales there are discontinuities and local 
> > minima. 
> > On the other hand, drop a stone (strictly you should use a vacuum tube) 
> > and plot its velocity over time. You should derive a straight line with a 
> > slope of 9.8 m per second per second. There are no obvious reasons 
> > for any discontinuity in that plot.
> That is still qualified as average speed, even one call it 'instantaneous'. 
> Continuity is vague in microscopic level. In mathematics, I am afraid that 
> 'continuous' is a cyclic definition, not very clear to me.
>
So this is Zeno's paradox. In one version, an arrow is in motion, but at any
instant of time, it must be still. You've applied it to a slope.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33766

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-17 02:50 -0700
Message-ID<b41a1390-80f3-458c-8ca4-463b92ed1131n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33762
On Monday, 17 May 2021 at 16:03:58 UTC+8, malcolm.ar...@gmail.com wrote:
> On Monday, 17 May 2021 at 06:10:53 UTC+1, wij wrote: 
> > On Monday, 17 May 2021 at 04:29:35 UTC+8, malcolm.ar...@gmail.com wrote: 
> > > On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 20:14:04 UTC+1, wij wrote: 
> > > > On Monday, 17 May 2021 at 01:37:34 UTC+8, malcolm.ar...@gmail.com wrote: 
> > > > 
> > > > How are the "exact equations" derived from? 
> > > > "slope at A point" makes no sense. 
> > > > 
> > > You mean a slope is surely a property of two points, with a height difference 
> > > between them? 
> > "So far" yes, slope is defined by two different points. Speed is measured from 
> > two different points. If the conclusion (speed/slop) is made from a point, the 
> > interval (to another point) is actually arbitrary, result would contain infinitesimal 
> > uncertainty. Although, I do think there is an exact value at the minima/maxima 
> > of a curve. 
> > > That's true of a physical hill - whilst a large ball will roll down it, a very small 
> > > sphere will not, because at small scales there are discontinuities and local 
> > > minima. 
> > > On the other hand, drop a stone (strictly you should use a vacuum tube) 
> > > and plot its velocity over time. You should derive a straight line with a 
> > > slope of 9.8 m per second per second. There are no obvious reasons 
> > > for any discontinuity in that plot. 
> > That is still qualified as average speed, even one call it 'instantaneous'. 
> > Continuity is vague in microscopic level. In mathematics, I am afraid that 
> > 'continuous' is a cyclic definition, not very clear to me. 
> >
> So this is Zeno's paradox. In one version, an arrow is in motion, but at any 
> instant of time, it must be still. You've applied it to a slope.

I would say point or position, not slope.
I guess you mean "at any given time the speed of arrow is zero".
But, you should have predicted my answer: "one point, no speed measure".
The ways of Zeno's questioning are basically language 'traps' to me.
Would you make the analogy clearer?

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33767

FromMalcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-17 03:21 -0700
Message-ID<1027cee9-cccc-433f-b310-10c54f69d14dn@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33766
On Monday, 17 May 2021 at 10:50:42 UTC+1, wij wrote:
> On Monday, 17 May 2021 at 16:03:58 UTC+8, malcolm.ar...@gmail.com wrote: 
> > On Monday, 17 May 2021 at 06:10:53 UTC+1, wij wrote: 
> > > On Monday, 17 May 2021 at 04:29:35 UTC+8, malcolm.ar...@gmail.com wrote: 
> > > > On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 20:14:04 UTC+1, wij wrote: 
> > > > > On Monday, 17 May 2021 at 01:37:34 UTC+8, malcolm.ar...@gmail.com wrote: 
> > > > > 
> > > > > How are the "exact equations" derived from? 
> > > > > "slope at A point" makes no sense. 
> > > > > 
> > > > You mean a slope is surely a property of two points, with a height difference 
> > > > between them? 
> > > "So far" yes, slope is defined by two different points. Speed is measured from 
> > > two different points. If the conclusion (speed/slop) is made from a point, the 
> > > interval (to another point) is actually arbitrary, result would contain infinitesimal 
> > > uncertainty. Although, I do think there is an exact value at the minima/maxima 
> > > of a curve. 
> > > > That's true of a physical hill - whilst a large ball will roll down it, a very small 
> > > > sphere will not, because at small scales there are discontinuities and local 
> > > > minima. 
> > > > On the other hand, drop a stone (strictly you should use a vacuum tube) 
> > > > and plot its velocity over time. You should derive a straight line with a 
> > > > slope of 9.8 m per second per second. There are no obvious reasons 
> > > > for any discontinuity in that plot. 
> > > That is still qualified as average speed, even one call it 'instantaneous'. 
> > > Continuity is vague in microscopic level. In mathematics, I am afraid that 
> > > 'continuous' is a cyclic definition, not very clear to me. 
> > > 
> > So this is Zeno's paradox. In one version, an arrow is in motion, but at any 
> > instant of time, it must be still. You've applied it to a slope.
> I would say point or position, not slope. 
> I guess you mean "at any given time the speed of arrow is zero". 
> But, you should have predicted my answer: "one point, no speed measure". 
> The ways of Zeno's questioning are basically language 'traps' to me. 
> Would you make the analogy clearer?
>
Yes, Zeno's arrow paradox states that, at any moment, the arrow must be at
rest in one position. Since time is a series of moments, when we move to 
the next "moment" the arrow must still be at rest. Therefore the arrow cannot
move.
You're applying this to a slope. A slope is a height difference between two points.
However at any one point, there can be no slope.  

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


Page 1 of 5  [1] 2 3 4 5  Next page →

Back to top | Article view | comp.theory


csiph-web