Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > comp.theory > #33539 > unrolled thread

The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1

Started bywij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
First post2021-05-14 05:11 -0700
Last post2021-05-15 05:02 -0700
Articles 20 on this page of 85 — 7 participants

Back to article view | Back to comp.theory


Contents

  The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 05:11 -0700
    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-14 13:25 +0100
      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 09:03 -0700
        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-14 12:21 -0400
          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 09:51 -0700
            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-14 14:59 -0400
              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 17:24 -0700
                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-14 21:19 -0400
                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 19:28 -0700
                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-15 19:39 +0100
                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-15 23:37 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 07:17 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 07:06 -0700
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 10:37 -0700
                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 12:14 -0700
                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 13:29 -0700
                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 22:10 -0700
                              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-17 01:03 -0700
                                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-17 02:50 -0700
                                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-17 03:21 -0700
                                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-17 03:33 -0700
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-17 00:21 +0100
                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 23:47 -0700
                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-17 20:02 +0100
                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-18 01:50 -0700
                              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-20 19:18 +0100
                                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-20 20:10 -0700
                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-19 05:08 -0700
                              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-19 08:45 -0400
                                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-19 20:21 -0700
                                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-20 06:12 -0700
                                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-20 15:26 +0100
                                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-20 16:52 +0100
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-20 17:03 +0100
                                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Jeff Barnett <jbb@notatt.com> - 2021-05-20 12:48 -0600
                                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-20 19:26 -0700
                                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-20 22:24 -0700
                                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-21 21:18 -0400
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-22 00:36 -0700
                                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-22 09:21 -0400
                                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-22 11:55 -0700
                                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-22 13:10 +0100
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-23 17:08 -0700
                                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-09-10 04:36 -0700
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-22 12:23 -0700
                                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-22 22:59 +0100
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-23 19:45 +0100
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-22 19:52 -0400
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-22 15:58 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-16 12:11 +0100
        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-14 17:25 +0100
          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 10:09 -0700
            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-14 19:51 +0100
              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 18:13 -0700
                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-15 19:50 +0100
                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-15 23:19 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Jeff Barnett <jbb@notatt.com> - 2021-05-16 02:46 -0600
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 02:50 -0700
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 03:10 -0700
                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Jeff Barnett <jbb@notatt.com> - 2021-05-16 13:27 -0600
                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-16 21:40 +0100
                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-16 17:01 -0400
                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Jeff Barnett <jbb@notatt.com> - 2021-05-16 22:16 -0600
                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 21:53 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-16 11:39 +0100
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 04:19 -0700
                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 06:18 -0700
            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-14 20:16 +0100
              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 16:51 -0700
                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-15 01:59 +0100
                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 19:01 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-15 03:06 +0100
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 19:22 -0700
                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-15 13:44 +0100
            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Peter <peterxpercival@hotmail.com> - 2021-05-15 15:03 +0100
              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-15 10:14 -0700
                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-15 19:06 +0100
    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-14 14:51 +0100
      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 09:10 -0700
    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-14 10:28 -0400
      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 09:31 -0700
        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 10:18 -0700
          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 10:46 -0700
            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-15 03:20 -0700
              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-15 05:02 -0700

Page 4 of 5 — ← Prev page 1 2 3 [4] 5  Next page →


#33723

FromAndy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk>
Date2021-05-16 21:40 +0100
Message-ID<s7s009$4gh$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#33713
On 16/05/2021 20:27, Jeff Barnett wrote:
[...]
> Appealing to reality as a justification doesn't help or make sense.
> No one knows at this stage of the universe what reality is so we have
> all agreed as "intellectuals" to make mathematical methods the basis
> of our conversation.

	Even that's a step too far.  We know for sure that Newtonian
mechanics does not reflect reality, and nor does Euclidean geometry;
but it would be ridiculous to solve elementary mechanics problems in
general-relativistic tensor and curved-space forms, and almost as
silly to preface every solution with "To 17 significant figures, we
can assume that ..." followed by deriving the simpler forms.  We all
know that Newtonian mechanics and flat space is entirely adequate for
solving simple projectile problems, and even for most celestial
mechanics.

	The point is that the standard mathematics of real numbers
[and complex numbers based on R^2], including standard calculus as
taught to scientists for the best part of 200 years, is more useful
than the complexities of trying to solve differential equations in
more [or even less!] general number systems.  So however interesting
[or otherwise] Wij's ideas may be, they're not going to displace the
standard methodology.  We spent ~100 painful years getting from the
Archimedean/Newtonian/Leibnizean view of calculus, via Euler and
others, to the Gauss/Cauchy/... view.  Adding infinities and
infinitesimals to that is not new or original, and it has its place,
not least in game theory [where there are actual finite and playable
games that have infinite/infinitesimal values], but it does nothing
to help engineers and physicists, and adds complexity, so it has,
quite correctly IMO, been dropped from applied mathematics.

-- 
Andy Walker, Nottingham.
    Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music
    Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Ketterer

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33725

FromRichard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org>
Date2021-05-16 17:01 -0400
Message-ID<GKfoI.84706$qy1.75460@fx26.iad>
In reply to#33723
On 5/16/21 4:40 PM, Andy Walker wrote:
> On 16/05/2021 20:27, Jeff Barnett wrote:
> [...]
>> Appealing to reality as a justification doesn't help or make sense.
>> No one knows at this stage of the universe what reality is so we have
>> all agreed as "intellectuals" to make mathematical methods the basis
>> of our conversation.
> 
>     Even that's a step too far.  We know for sure that Newtonian
> mechanics does not reflect reality, and nor does Euclidean geometry;
> but it would be ridiculous to solve elementary mechanics problems in
> general-relativistic tensor and curved-space forms, and almost as
> silly to preface every solution with "To 17 significant figures, we
> can assume that ..." followed by deriving the simpler forms.  We all
> know that Newtonian mechanics and flat space is entirely adequate for
> solving simple projectile problems, and even for most celestial
> mechanics.
> 
>     The point is that the standard mathematics of real numbers
> [and complex numbers based on R^2], including standard calculus as
> taught to scientists for the best part of 200 years, is more useful
> than the complexities of trying to solve differential equations in
> more [or even less!] general number systems.  So however interesting
> [or otherwise] Wij's ideas may be, they're not going to displace the
> standard methodology.  We spent ~100 painful years getting from the
> Archimedean/Newtonian/Leibnizean view of calculus, via Euler and
> others, to the Gauss/Cauchy/... view.  Adding infinities and
> infinitesimals to that is not new or original, and it has its place,
> not least in game theory [where there are actual finite and playable
> games that have infinite/infinitesimal values], but it does nothing
> to help engineers and physicists, and adds complexity, so it has,
> quite correctly IMO, been dropped from applied mathematics.
> 

While we may be able to say that reality doesn't match Newtonian
Mechanics or Euclidean geometry, that doesn't say that Euclidean
geometry doesn't exist.

Geometry, is at is core, and abstract system. It is NOT tied to the
physical universe. We can talk about Euclidean Geometry in 2, 3, 4 or
more dimensions without needing to ask if the 'real' Universe has that
many dimension.

As such, it DOES exist as a theoretical basis.

The same holds for the Real Number system. Real Numbers don't actually
exist as actual things in the physical universe. So we can't actually
ask if they match the model of reality.

They are a theoretical system that we USE to talk about the physical
universe.

No one really says that the Reals are only number system worth talking
about, but when we start to talk about some of these esoteric concepts,
we need to be careful to define WHICH number system we are using.

When we are talking about the actual Real Number System R, the value
infinity ISN'T a value in the system. It exists as a concept for things
like limits, but it isn't a member of R.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33764

FromJeff Barnett <jbb@notatt.com>
Date2021-05-16 22:16 -0600
Message-ID<s7sqn0$rr3$1@dont-email.me>
In reply to#33723
On 5/16/2021 2:40 PM, Andy Walker wrote:
> On 16/05/2021 20:27, Jeff Barnett wrote:
> [...]
>> Appealing to reality as a justification doesn't help or make sense.
>> No one knows at this stage of the universe what reality is so we have
>> all agreed as "intellectuals" to make mathematical methods the basis
>> of our conversation.
> 
>      Even that's a step too far.  We know for sure that Newtonian
> mechanics does not reflect reality, and nor does Euclidean geometry;
> but it would be ridiculous to solve elementary mechanics problems in
> general-relativistic tensor and curved-space forms, and almost as
> silly to preface every solution with "To 17 significant figures, we
> can assume that ..." followed by deriving the simpler forms.  We all
> know that Newtonian mechanics and flat space is entirely adequate for
> solving simple projectile problems, and even for most celestial
> mechanics.

Forget numbers for a minute. If we actually understood reality (whatever 
the hell that might mean) we would represent that understanding using 
symbols to express relations. Plugging numbers in is a step down from 
that and: Not all relations are about numbers, many are about individual 
objects, e.g., particles, or organizations of individuals as we study in 
chemistry. The point is that we do not know enough to accurately know 
what those relations entail or what type of abstract measures (e.g., 
real numbers) we actually need to express them. Therefore, in our early 
stages of massive ignorance about the stuff of reality, we can't use our 
faint impressions to argue about what is THE CORRECT NUMBER SYSTEM. For 
the time being, we will use what ever seems to fit the current models 
and in the future we will change our mind.

>      The point is that the standard mathematics of real numbers
> [and complex numbers based on R^2], including standard calculus as
> taught to scientists for the best part of 200 years, is more useful
> than the complexities of trying to solve differential equations in
> more [or even less!] general number systems.  So however interesting
> [or otherwise] Wij's ideas may be, they're not going to displace the
> standard methodology.  We spent ~100 painful years getting from the
> Archimedean/Newtonian/Leibnizean view of calculus, via Euler and
> others, to the Gauss/Cauchy/... view.  Adding infinities and
> infinitesimals to that is not new or original, and it has its place,
> not least in game theory [where there are actual finite and playable
> games that have infinite/infinitesimal values], but it does nothing
> to help engineers and physicists, and adds complexity, so it has,
> quite correctly IMO, been dropped from applied mathematics.
You never know whose beliefs will eventually appear as the new rage. 
Lets consider a little bit of reasonably current growth in science. We 
start with the Michelson–Morley experiment that showed the speed of 
light was not well understood and/or hard to measure. A possible 
explanation with proposed by Lorentz (contraction of matter in direction 
of motion) along with a set of measure transformations that did that 
contraction. That work was interesting and certainly publishable but had 
no real effect on every day science work. A little later Einstein 
proposed his special theory of relativity that just happened to use the 
Lorentz transformations just as Lorentz had proposed. Einstein had a 
completely different explanation as to why those transformations were 
part of a proper theory.

Suddenly that math was a key to a revolution in our understanding of the 
universe. If that math introduced some new math concepts (it didn't) 
those concepts would have become part of our standard model. The general 
theory introduced tensors to a large audience. This theory was important 
enough that now a days every body sort of knows what a tensor is and 
they are now an integral part of mathematics and physics. I could go on 
but wont though I'll mention one more jerk forward in our models: 
awareness of quantum structures has caused discrete mathematics to bloom 
into the nature of the universe as we see it. I'm thinking of more than 
groups, I'm thinking of integrals with "controlled" discontinuities, 
small but can't be zero measures, etc.
-- 
Jeff Barnett

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33759

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-16 21:53 -0700
Message-ID<684836b3-b98b-4379-b437-d570106c517fn@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33713
On Monday, 17 May 2021 at 03:27:17 UTC+8, Jeff Barnett wrote:
> On 5/16/2021 4:10 AM, wij wrote: 
> > On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 16:46:44 UTC+8, Jeff Barnett wrote: 
> >> On 5/16/2021 12:19 AM, wij wrote: 
> >>> Prop A: no infinitesimals, irrational number is not possible. 
> >> So SQRT(2) is not possible unless there are infinitesimals? Same for pi? 
> >> Wow! 
> > 
> > I know quite some of my sentences formed are not complete in their meaning, 
> > because otherwise, at least, they would be unnecessarily long and too technical 
> > in the conversation. 
> > It is very good that you see some defecting/suspicious examples, but applying 
> > it to the whole and deduce further is not wise. 
> > 
> >>> Prop B: Pythagoreans had the difficulty understanding non-rational number. 
> >> The had no trouble understanding irrationals; they did, however, fear 
> >> that knowledge of their existence would call many of their foundational 
> >> beliefs into question. 
> >> 
> >> So the Pythagoreans grocked this area very well along with some 
> >> interesting first class proofs over 2000 years ago. Yet here we are 
> >> today with you still confused. 
> >> 
> >> You can, of course, believe anything you want and use any system of 
> >> axioms you want but neither your axioms and beliefs or mine are going to 
> >> delineate any thing real. If you want to work with a different abstract 
> >> model than most others AND still talk to others, you must decide on 
> >> axioms, logic, and models so the conversations are not just hot air. 
> > 
> > So are you.
> I'm not sure what you mean by "So are you." I'm guessing that you mean 
> that my view about infinitesimals suffers the same problem as yours. If 
> so, I agree and that was what I was trying to convey. The difference is 
> my views, which I have not stated, are backed by axioms, logic, and 
> models. My secret is that I have accepted many different views that each 
> has a proper mathematical definition and logic. Only one of them seems 
> appropriate for engineering and all of them might be appropriate for 
> science and philosophy or even just for fun. 
> 
> Like I said above, you can accept anything you like. If you want 
> intelligent conversation about your views it's up to you to present 
> enough mathematics so it's clear what we will be talking about. 
> Appealing to reality as a justification doesn't help or make sense. No 
> one knows at this stage of the universe what reality is so we have all 
> agreed as "intellectuals" to make mathematical methods the basis of our 
> conversation. Not reality, not religion, and not wishes. We rely on 
> logic and mathematical principals for the rules of conversation.

Basically, The amount and quality of English I can perceive and convey is
limited in such short period of conversions in less one day time. To some
degree, we all can make unintentional 'false' statement in someone's eye...

Simply put, there are far too many irrational numbers, even proper definition
is hard to come by. Let's try to make things/subjects simple.

> >> The 
> >> surreal, for examples, are not the reals but they are well defined and 
> >> do or do not exist any more or less than the reals. However, the formal 
> >> definitions of them make the conversations and comparisons possible.
> > Keep on topic (as shown in the title) as possible.
> I Think that was my suggestion to you. I think it was you who said "Prop 
> A: no infinitesimals, irrational number is not possible." without proof. 
> Even if you were proposing PROP A as an axiom, it's not in a form where 
> one could deduce anything from it. So what was the point? 
> -- 
> Jeff Barnett

I do not intend to propose an official definition of the real number, or irrational
number. But, I think using surreal as example should be more cautious.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33675

FromAndy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk>
Date2021-05-16 11:39 +0100
Message-ID<s7qspm$he0$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#33662
On 16/05/2021 07:19, wij wrote:
> Prop A: no infinitesimals, irrational number is not possible.
> Prop B: Pythagoreans had the difficulty understanding non-rational number.
> What is your propositional statement (or correlation) about?

	As Jeff and Malcolm have pointed out, Prop A is false, as
irrational numbers were known, with facts proved about them, long
before people understood infinitesimals.  Prop B is debatable;  I
don't know how "difficult" they found it, but discovering things
thought [but not proved] to be impossible changes your outlook on
life.

[...]
> Do you mean the theory removing parallel axiom from Euclid geometry is the
> 'real' one and do not have the complexity of your interpretation of 'logic'?

	No.  But it shows that non-Euclidian geometries are possible,
and so that you need to specify what system of geometry you are using
before quoting theorems.

-- 
Andy Walker, Nottingham.
    Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music
    Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Ketterer

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33677

FromMalcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-16 04:19 -0700
Message-ID<372685e5-7556-4bc1-9b74-a9c34c44aac9n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33675
On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 11:39:54 UTC+1, Andy Walker wrote:
> On 16/05/2021 07:19, wij wrote: 
> > Prop A: no infinitesimals, irrational number is not possible. 
> > Prop B: Pythagoreans had the difficulty understanding non-rational number. 
> > What is your propositional statement (or correlation) about?
> As Jeff and Malcolm have pointed out, Prop A is false, as 
> irrational numbers were known, with facts proved about them, long 
> before people understood infinitesimals. Prop B is debatable; I 
> don't know how "difficult" they found it, but discovering things 
> thought [but not proved] to be impossible changes your outlook on 
> life. 
>
We know that the concept of irrational numbers caused huge theoretical
problems for the Pythagoreans. It wasn't easy at all to accept that a
quanity could exist that wasn't expressible by two whole numbers.

In fact they kept the discovery that root 2 was irrational a secret for quite 
some time, so embarrassing was it for their system.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33680

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-16 06:18 -0700
Message-ID<a1f36fea-f1b3-4fb4-ae12-e9abdd621e9cn@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33677
On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 19:19:08 UTC+8, malcolm.ar...@gmail.com wrote:
> On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 11:39:54 UTC+1, Andy Walker wrote: 
> > On 16/05/2021 07:19, wij wrote: 
> > > Prop A: no infinitesimals, irrational number is not possible. 
> > > Prop B: Pythagoreans had the difficulty understanding non-rational number. 
> > > What is your propositional statement (or correlation) about? 
> > As Jeff and Malcolm have pointed out, Prop A is false, as 
> > irrational numbers were known, with facts proved about them, long 
> > before people understood infinitesimals. Prop B is debatable; I 
> > don't know how "difficult" they found it, but discovering things 
> > thought [but not proved] to be impossible changes your outlook on 
> > life. 
> >
> We know that the concept of irrational numbers caused huge theoretical 
> problems for the Pythagoreans. It wasn't easy at all to accept that a 
> quanity could exist that wasn't expressible by two whole numbers. 
> 

Furthermore,  Pythagoreans did not know none of their music note (except 8-octave)
were non-harmonic at all, and still pursuing for 'perfection', lasting for hundreds years

> In fact they kept the discovery that root 2 was irrational a secret for quite 
> some time, so embarrassing was it for their system.

I think infinitesimal (the existence of particles (even universe) with zero size ) is
accepted in modern physics (and mathematics, silently changing).

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33575

FromBen Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk>
Date2021-05-14 20:16 +0100
Message-ID<87k0o1ruqr.fsf@bsb.me.uk>
In reply to#33562
wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> writes:

> On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 00:25:47 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote:
>> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
>> 
>> > On Friday, 14 May 2021 at 20:25:36 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote: 
>> >> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
>> >> 
>> >> > Most young kids easily understand 0.999…≠1, and will be confused if the 
>> >> > opposite is told. But nowadays, it seems becoming globally common, 
>> >> > students are forced (educated) to believe and 'must' so answer in 
>> >> > exam. 
>> >> In some of the better institutions, they will be given the tools to 
>> >> argue the point. Were you just told to believe it? Were you never 
>> >> given any justification for 0.999... = 1? 
>> > 
>> > I have seen various 'proves' in recent 10 years, just magic show, similar to 
>> > olcott's way of proof/claim, inventing a obfuscate theory to explain desired 
>> > result, ignoring simple/intuitive explanation. 
>> > Or you can provided a LOGICAL proof (limit is no logic).
>> I am sorry you did not find any of the arguments you have seen 
>> persuasive. How you construct/define the real numbers? Serious 
>> question -- please don't be like all the other cran^H^H^H^H 
>> unconventional posters and duck out when asked to say how you see the 
>> underlying issue.
>
> Defining real number ℝ is not easy.
> The most general idea of real number ℝ is 'real line'.
> But I do not say further.

Ah.  You don't see a problem with that?

> You ducked out the question: "provide a LOGICAL proof (limit is no logic)
> that 0.999...=1"

You asked an illogical question.  The notation 0.999... is the notation
for or a limit.  If I can't proof a limit using the theory of limits, I
won't even try.  Would you like to declare that you've "won"?  That
would be fine with me.

>> > I assume you did not read the file: 
>> > https://sourceforge.net/projects/cscall/files/MisFiles/Infinity-en.txt/download
>> No. I'm reading Usenet. If you'd like people to read it, you should 
>> quote the relevant parts here.
>
> I do not need to if you are not interested in.

Agreed.

-- 
Ben.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33592

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-14 16:51 -0700
Message-ID<f19dd4bf-320c-4ba5-b928-3371890c45fdn@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33575
On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 03:16:46 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote:
> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
> 
> > On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 00:25:47 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote: 
> >> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
> >> 
> >> > On Friday, 14 May 2021 at 20:25:36 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote: 
> >> >> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
> >> >> 
> >> >> > Most young kids easily understand 0.999…≠1, and will be confused if the 
> >> >> > opposite is told. But nowadays, it seems becoming globally common, 
> >> >> > students are forced (educated) to believe and 'must' so answer in 
> >> >> > exam. 
> >> >> In some of the better institutions, they will be given the tools to 
> >> >> argue the point. Were you just told to believe it? Were you never 
> >> >> given any justification for 0.999... = 1? 
> >> > 
> >> > I have seen various 'proves' in recent 10 years, just magic show, similar to 
> >> > olcott's way of proof/claim, inventing a obfuscate theory to explain desired 
> >> > result, ignoring simple/intuitive explanation. 
> >> > Or you can provided a LOGICAL proof (limit is no logic). 
> >> I am sorry you did not find any of the arguments you have seen 
> >> persuasive. How you construct/define the real numbers? Serious 
> >> question -- please don't be like all the other cran^H^H^H^H 
> >> unconventional posters and duck out when asked to say how you see the 
> >> underlying issue. 
> > 
> > Defining real number ℝ is not easy. 
> > The most general idea of real number ℝ is 'real line'. 
> > But I do not say further.
> Ah. You don't see a problem with that?

I see further, that is beyond common acknowledge and not the topic for the
moment.

> > You ducked out the question: "provide a LOGICAL proof (limit is no logic) 
> > that 0.999...=1"
> You asked an illogical question. The notation 0.999... is the notation 
> for or a limit. If I can't proof a limit using the theory of limits, I 
> won't even try. Would you like to declare that you've "won"? That 
> would be fine with me.

If my question for you is illogical, yours for me is neither.
If your understanding (if not reciting from text book, or hearsay) is based on limit, 
OK, I probably has won, but that is not my point. I would like to shrink the question 
for you to ask something about limit.

Q1: Let A=lim(n->1) {n}=1.
Ask: 3 disjoint region (0,1), [1,1] and (1,2). If A is a number,  which region 
A is in?

Q2: As most people acknowledge there are infinite infinities (Cantor's theory).
Let B=lim(n->∞) {1/n}=0
B0=lim(n->ℵ0) {1/n}=0
B1=lim(n->ℵ1) {1/n}=0
B2=lim(n->ℵ2) {2/n}=0
Ask: whether B is Exactly Equal to B0, B1, or B2

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33596

FromBen Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk>
Date2021-05-15 01:59 +0100
Message-ID<87h7j4rev1.fsf@bsb.me.uk>
In reply to#33592
wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> writes:

> OK, I probably has won, but that is not my point. I would like to
> shrink the question for you to ask something about limit.
>
> Q1: Let A=lim(n->1) {n}=1.
> Ask: 3 disjoint region (0,1), [1,1] and (1,2). If A is a number,  which region 
> A is in?

The second.

> Q2: As most people acknowledge there are infinite infinities (Cantor's theory).
> Let B=lim(n->∞) {1/n}=0
> B0=lim(n->ℵ0) {1/n}=0
> B1=lim(n->ℵ1) {1/n}=0
> B2=lim(n->ℵ2) {2/n}=0
> Ask: whether B is Exactly Equal to B0, B1, or B2

Only the first limit has a conventional formal meaning, but I can answer
your question anyway because you've answered it yourself.  I adhere to
the rather boring notion that equal quantities are equal (and that
"exactly" is redundant), so yes, according you they are all equal.

-- 
Ben.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33601

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-14 19:01 -0700
Message-ID<2efe0c93-319a-4e3d-a785-0501597076e4n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33596
On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 08:59:48 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote:
> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
> 
> > OK, I probably has won, but that is not my point. I would like to 
> > shrink the question for you to ask something about limit. 
> > 
> > Q1: Let A=lim(n->1) {n}=1. 
> > Ask: 3 disjoint region (0,1), [1,1] and (1,2). If A is a number, which region 
> > A is in?
> The second.

1. The definition of limit says n approaches 1 but cannot be 1, so what is
   the logic where 1 is from.
2. Consider n may be approaching from above and below 1. E.g. lim(n->1) {1/(n-1)}
we would need different definition again, depending on trial which one make our
subject 'linear' or 'continuous' or pragmatical sense.

> > Q2: As most people acknowledge there are infinite infinities (Cantor's theory). 
> > Let B=lim(n->∞) {1/n}=0 
> > B0=lim(n->ℵ0) {1/n}=0 
> > B1=lim(n->ℵ1) {1/n}=0 
> > B2=lim(n->ℵ2) {2/n}=0 
> > Ask: whether B is Exactly Equal to B0, B1, or B2
> Only the first limit has a conventional formal meaning, but I can answer 
> your question anyway because you've answered it yourself. I adhere to 
> the rather boring notion that equal quantities are equal (and that 
> "exactly" is redundant), so yes, according you they are all equal. 
> 
> -- 
> Ben.

None of them is an uniquely assured number, all with some level of uncertainty.
By using algebra, remove lim, all are different (you may say this is my view).

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33602

FromBen Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk>
Date2021-05-15 03:06 +0100
Message-ID<87zgwwpx6u.fsf@bsb.me.uk>
In reply to#33601
wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> writes:

> On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 08:59:48 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote:
>> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
>> 
>> > OK, I probably has won, but that is not my point. I would like to 
>> > shrink the question for you to ask something about limit. 
>> > 
>> > Q1: Let A=lim(n->1) {n}=1. 
>> > Ask: 3 disjoint region (0,1), [1,1] and (1,2). If A is a number,
>> > which region A is in?
>>
>> The second.
>
> 1. The definition of limit says n approaches 1 but cannot be 1, so what is
>    the logic where 1 is from.

You told me A=1 and then asked if A was in (0,1), [1,1] or (1,2).  How
does a limit come into it?

>> > Q2: As most people acknowledge there are infinite infinities
>> > (Cantor's theory).
>> > Let B=lim(n->∞) {1/n}=0 
>> > B0=lim(n->ℵ0) {1/n}=0 
>> > B1=lim(n->ℵ1) {1/n}=0 
>> > B2=lim(n->ℵ2) {2/n}=0 
>> > Ask: whether B is Exactly Equal to B0, B1, or B2
>> Only the first limit has a conventional formal meaning, but I can answer 
>> your question anyway because you've answered it yourself. I adhere to 
>> the rather boring notion that equal quantities are equal (and that 
>> "exactly" is redundant), so yes, according you they are all equal. 
>> 
> None of them is an uniquely assured number, all with some level of
> uncertainty.

I think you don't know what = means in mathematics.

> By using algebra, remove lim, all are different (you may
> say this is my view).

Can you say why someone might be interested in your view?

-- 
Ben.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33603

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-14 19:22 -0700
Message-ID<588bfac8-63ea-4e9c-9df2-06bec231088dn@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33602
On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 10:06:51 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote:
> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
> 
> > On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 08:59:48 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote: 
> >> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
> >> 
> >> > OK, I probably has won, but that is not my point. I would like to 
> >> > shrink the question for you to ask something about limit. 
> >> > 
> >> > Q1: Let A=lim(n->1) {n}=1. 
> >> > Ask: 3 disjoint region (0,1), [1,1] and (1,2). If A is a number, 
> >> > which region A is in? 
> >> 
> >> The second. 
> > 
> > 1. The definition of limit says n approaches 1 but cannot be 1, so what is 
> > the logic where 1 is from.
> You told me A=1 and then asked if A was in (0,1), [1,1] or (1,2). How 
> does a limit come into it?
> >> > Q2: As most people acknowledge there are infinite infinities 
> >> > (Cantor's theory). 
> >> > Let B=lim(n->∞) {1/n}=0 
> >> > B0=lim(n->ℵ0) {1/n}=0 
> >> > B1=lim(n->ℵ1) {1/n}=0 
> >> > B2=lim(n->ℵ2) {2/n}=0 
> >> > Ask: whether B is Exactly Equal to B0, B1, or B2 
> >> Only the first limit has a conventional formal meaning, but I can answer 
> >> your question anyway because you've answered it yourself. I adhere to 
> >> the rather boring notion that equal quantities are equal (and that 
> >> "exactly" is redundant), so yes, according you they are all equal. 
> >>
> > None of them is an uniquely assured number, all with some level of 
> > uncertainty.
> I think you don't know what = means in mathematics.
> > By using algebra, remove lim, all are different (you may 
> > say this is my view).
> Can you say why someone might be interested in your view? 
> 
> -- 
> Ben.

To be short.
Those seeking for consistency, working in the frontier of math. logicians, 
philosophers, those try to dealing with infinity, and probably physic theorists,
at least.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33612

FromBen Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk>
Date2021-05-15 13:44 +0100
Message-ID<87tun4p3nn.fsf@bsb.me.uk>
In reply to#33603
wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> writes:

> On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 10:06:51 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote:
>> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
>> 
>> > On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 08:59:48 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote: 
>> >> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
>> >> 
>> >> > OK, I probably has won, but that is not my point. I would like to 
>> >> > shrink the question for you to ask something about limit. 
>> >> > 
>> >> > Q1: Let A=lim(n->1) {n}=1. 
>> >> > Ask: 3 disjoint region (0,1), [1,1] and (1,2). If A is a number, 
>> >> > which region A is in? 
>> >> 
>> >> The second. 
>> > 
>> > 1. The definition of limit says n approaches 1 but cannot be 1, so what is 
>> > the logic where 1 is from.
>> You told me A=1 and then asked if A was in (0,1), [1,1] or (1,2). How 
>> does a limit come into it?
>> >> > Q2: As most people acknowledge there are infinite infinities 
>> >> > (Cantor's theory). 
>> >> > Let B=lim(n->∞) {1/n}=0 
>> >> > B0=lim(n->ℵ0) {1/n}=0 
>> >> > B1=lim(n->ℵ1) {1/n}=0 
>> >> > B2=lim(n->ℵ2) {2/n}=0 
>> >> > Ask: whether B is Exactly Equal to B0, B1, or B2 
>> >> Only the first limit has a conventional formal meaning, but I can answer 
>> >> your question anyway because you've answered it yourself. I adhere to 
>> >> the rather boring notion that equal quantities are equal (and that 
>> >> "exactly" is redundant), so yes, according you they are all equal. 
>> >>
>> > None of them is an uniquely assured number, all with some level of 
>> > uncertainty.
>> I think you don't know what = means in mathematics.
>> > By using algebra, remove lim, all are different (you may 
>> > say this is my view).
>> Can you say why someone might be interested in your view? 
>
> To be short.  Those seeking for consistency, working in the frontier
> of math. logicians, philosophers, those try to dealing with infinity,
> and probably physic theorists, at least.

I asked why, not who.

Someone who says that A = 1 then queries that A might be in [1,1] is
unlikely to have much to say to logicians unless they had previously
explained their novel notion of equality.

Anyway, you seem reluctant to engage with that rather central point, so
I wish you well in finding these people.

-- 
Ben.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33616

FromPeter <peterxpercival@hotmail.com>
Date2021-05-15 15:03 +0100
Message-ID<s7okb6$2fc$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#33562
wij wrote:


> Defining real number ℝ is not easy.
> The most general idea of real number ℝ is 'real line'.
> But I do not say further.

There is more than one definition of real number, and lines have nothing 
to do with any of them


-- 
Just as 'beautiful' points the way for aesthetics and 'good' for ethics,
so do words like 'true' for logic.  All sciences have truth as their
goal; but logic is also concerned with it in a quite different way:
logic has much the same relation to truth as physics has to weight or
heat.                               Frege in 'Thoughts' (Der Gedanke)

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33625

FromMalcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-15 10:14 -0700
Message-ID<26c50fd7-ea9d-4e0e-9ea3-26a0e9a0ff58n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33616
On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 15:03:22 UTC+1, Peter wrote:
> wij wrote: 
> 
> 
> > Defining real number ℝ is not easy. 
> > The most general idea of real number ℝ is 'real line'. 
> > But I do not say further.
> There is more than one definition of real number, and lines have nothing 
> to do with any of them 
> 
For counting numbers you get a  collection of tokens, e.g stones, then
the number of stones in the pile represents your number. For real
numbers you draw a line from a point you designate as "zero" and
another point you designate as the maximum number you want to be 
able to represent. A mark on that line then represents your real number.

I don't see a problem with that.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33629

FromAndy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk>
Date2021-05-15 19:06 +0100
Message-ID<s7p2ip$1b55$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#33625
On 15/05/2021 18:14, Malcolm McLean wrote:
> [...]  For real
> numbers you draw a line from a point you designate as "zero" and
> another point you designate as the maximum number you want to be
> able to represent. A mark on that line then represents your real number.
> I don't see a problem with that.

	What is going to be your test for whether some "thing" is a
"real number"?  Most reals are uncomputable [and unconstructable
and indescribable];  are those reals marked on your line?  How?  What
about [eg] those surreal numbers that are not [also] real?  Why are
they /not/ marked on your line even though [if "your" reals are the
same as everyone else's, in some sense] lots of much less useful
numbers are?  Of course, some of these problems are equally so for
the reals as usually defined [what use is an indescribable number?],
but nonetheless they are problems.

	[FTAOD, I don't particularly want answers.  I merely claim
that there are lots of problems with number systems.  Even with the
rationals.  We learn about rationals and reals at school, and gloss
over the problems;  and most of us never revisit them -- and never
learn properly about the weird and whacky world of numbers (quite a
lot of which is accessible even to children).]

-- 
Andy Walker, Nottingham.
    Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music
    Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Mendelssohn

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33545

FromAndy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk>
Date2021-05-14 14:51 +0100
Message-ID<s7lv8a$k70$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#33539
On 14/05/2021 13:11, wij wrote:
> Most young kids easily understand 0.999…≠1, and will be confused if the
> opposite is told. But nowadays, it seems becoming globally common,
> students are forced (educated) to believe and 'must' so answer in exam.
> that lim(n→∞) {1/n}=0 and 0.999...=1. There are many ways approaching
> the truth.

	That is because those results are true for [so-called] real
numbers;  which include, as an axiom, that there are no infinitesimal
real numbers.  That, in turn, comes from the attempt in the 19thC to
formalise mathematics.  If you read 18thC mathematics, you find an
intuitive approach to such questions, and a /lot/ of problems as a
consequence.  So there are sound reasons why students are educated
into believing that 0.999... = 1, etc.

	After that, most students would find it very confusing to be
taught /also/ that there are number systems in which 0.999... < 1.
Students generally crave certainty, not doubt, esp when preparing
for exams.  Further, most scientists and engineers who use maths
don't want also to spend lots of time exploring those doubts;  they
typically want to be able to get results "in the sense of numerical
analysis" -- they want to find some number "to 5 significant figures"
or to solve [meaning, get a formula for] some differential equation
that helps them with their problem in celestial mechanics or building
a bridge or analysing the results of an experiment.

	If, OTOH, you /want/ to learn about modern approaches to
analysis, and [eg] to other number systems, then there is much to
have a go at.  Some of it is even quite easy [the sort of stuff you
can discuss with young children], but it quite soon gets harder, and
a lot really needs postgraduate-level mathematics.  Try [so-called]
"non-standard analysis".  Or, for something more intuitive, try
"combinatorial game theory", and/or "surreal numbers".  But if you
want to get away from "0.999... = 1", you are no longer dealing
with the real [or even complex] numbers;  you need to be prepared
for some strange ["surreal"!] results.

> The following file is a draft written about 2 years ago, basically talking
> about infinity. Several places are not right, but leaving to improve.
> https://sourceforge.net/projects/cscall/files/MisFiles/Infinity-en.txt/download

	I had a quick look, but sadly initially the download didn't
work, and when it did, it dumped a lot of weird characters onto my
screen and was unreadable.  I expect it might have worked as a PDF
or some such?

-- 
Andy Walker, Nottingham.
    Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music
    Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Pridham

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33551

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-14 09:10 -0700
Message-ID<7d2b6fc6-0d58-4e6a-91be-fe8b99a389b6n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33545
On Friday, 14 May 2021 at 21:51:16 UTC+8, Andy Walker wrote:
> On 14/05/2021 13:11, wij wrote: 
> > Most young kids easily understand 0.999…≠1, and will be confused if the 
> > opposite is told. But nowadays, it seems becoming globally common, 
> > students are forced (educated) to believe and 'must' so answer in exam. 
> > that lim(n→∞) {1/n}=0 and 0.999...=1. There are many ways approaching 
> > the truth.
> That is because those results are true for [so-called] real 
> numbers; which include, as an axiom, that there are no infinitesimal 
> real numbers. That, in turn, comes from the attempt in the 19thC to 
> formalise mathematics. If you read 18thC mathematics, you find an 
> intuitive approach to such questions, and a /lot/ of problems as a 
> consequence. So there are sound reasons why students are educated 
> into believing that 0.999... = 1, etc. 
> 
> After that, most students would find it very confusing to be 
> taught /also/ that there are number systems in which 0.999... < 1. 
> Students generally crave certainty, not doubt, esp when preparing 
> for exams. Further, most scientists and engineers who use maths 
> don't want also to spend lots of time exploring those doubts; they 
> typically want to be able to get results "in the sense of numerical 
> analysis" -- they want to find some number "to 5 significant figures" 
> or to solve [meaning, get a formula for] some differential equation 
> that helps them with their problem in celestial mechanics or building 
> a bridge or analysing the results of an experiment. 
> 
> If, OTOH, you /want/ to learn about modern approaches to 
> analysis, and [eg] to other number systems, then there is much to 
> have a go at. Some of it is even quite easy [the sort of stuff you 
> can discuss with young children], but it quite soon gets harder, and 
> a lot really needs postgraduate-level mathematics. Try [so-called] 
> "non-standard analysis". Or, for something more intuitive, try 
> "combinatorial game theory", and/or "surreal numbers". But if you 
> want to get away from "0.999... = 1", you are no longer dealing 
> with the real [or even complex] numbers; you need to be prepared 
> for some strange ["surreal"!] results.
> > The following file is a draft written about 2 years ago, basically talking 
> > about infinity. Several places are not right, but leaving to improve. 
> > https://sourceforge.net/projects/cscall/files/MisFiles/Infinity-en.txt/download
> I had a quick look, but sadly initially the download didn't 
> work, and when it did, it dumped a lot of weird characters onto my 
> screen and was unreadable. I expect it might have worked as a PDF 
> or some such? 
> 
> -- 
> Andy Walker, Nottingham. 
> Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music 
> Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Pridham

For now, I can only suggest to try again. I successfully downloaded twice with 
different method. If requested, I can post it (317 lines, UTF8 encoding)
This is a difficult topic, I postpone my reply to your opinion until you read it all.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33546

FromRichard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org>
Date2021-05-14 10:28 -0400
Message-ID<VNvnI.354182$J_5.59721@fx46.iad>
In reply to#33539
On 5/14/21 8:11 AM, wij wrote:
> Most young kids easily understand 0.999…≠1, and will be confused if the 
> opposite is told. But nowadays, it seems becoming globally common, 
> students are forced (educated) to believe and 'must' so answer in exam. 
> that lim(n→∞) {1/n}=0 and 0.999...=1. There are many ways approaching
> the truth.
> I just list my simple answers from basic intuition, no need resorting to 
> academic formalism (which novice trust more), though the implication can
> be very deep and very broad.
> 
> 1. 1/3=0.333... (repeating decimals are rational numbers)
> In the long division method, the digit rendering process is endless. In
> computer science, the result of such a process is called undecidable. From
> logic point of view, the infinite repeating process is caused by the 
> existence of non-zero remainder. If 1/3 is determined to be the answer of 
> 0.333..., the remainder of the division must be zero. Then, how could the 
> infinite repeating 3 be possible?
> This problem is similar to the differences of range (0,1) and (0,1] and the
> density property notion. All the people I know agree that range (0,1),(0,1] 
> are different and the density property is true. While realizing a<b,∃c such 
> that a<c<b, and simultaneously believe (no valid logic) c will eventually 
> 'equal to' b without breaking the density property.
> 
> Also, the process is similar to Zeno's paradox 
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zeno%27s_paradoxes#Achilles_and_the_tortoise
> In the logic presented, Achilles can never out run the tortoise (note: 'time' 
> is not 'forever', implied by 'never', but is actually converged, infinitely 
> closing to some value).
> 
> 2. In the view of differential calculus, all curves are made up of 
> infinitesimal bent (or zigzag) lines, there is no such thing as 'real curve'. 
> Therefore, in integral calculus, the enclosed/calculated area is actually the
> sum of infinite number of rectangles.
> 
> The analytic 'approach' (or limit) model substituted the conceptual reality.
> Then, the first trouble is that the definition and property of a circle 
> becomes problematic, e.g the angles in the circle.
> 
> Note: I am not qualified to say the expression "lim(n→∞){1/n}=0" is 
> invalid,  I was talking about its meaning.
> 
> 'Number' has no scale issues. Different numbers are simply different.
> There is no such thing that error being too small equals to zero (no 
> difference).
> 
> The following file is a draft written about 2 years ago, basically talking 
> about infinity. Several places are not right, but leaving to improve.
> https://sourceforge.net/projects/cscall/files/MisFiles/Infinity-en.txt/download
> 

I think a key point to consider is that there are many ways to look at
the 'real' numbers when we start to augment them with infinites and
infinitesimals. Dfferent ways of looking at thes extensions give
different interpretations of certain concepts. When these concepts are
first taught, trying to explain all this detail can be over the head of
the students, and just would confuse them, so presenting just the
'classical' view seems reasonable, and then at higher levels we explain
things are different. Just like we start with saying that sqrt(-1) isn't
defined, and then later we expand and say that we can now define
something that IS the undefined operation, and get the complex number
plain. (And then expand again to get the Quaternions)

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


Page 4 of 5 — ← Prev page 1 2 3 [4] 5  Next page →

Back to top | Article view | comp.theory


csiph-web