Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > comp.theory > #33539 > unrolled thread

The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1

Started bywij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
First post2021-05-14 05:11 -0700
Last post2021-05-15 05:02 -0700
Articles 20 on this page of 85 — 7 participants

Back to article view | Back to comp.theory


Contents

  The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 05:11 -0700
    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-14 13:25 +0100
      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 09:03 -0700
        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-14 12:21 -0400
          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 09:51 -0700
            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-14 14:59 -0400
              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 17:24 -0700
                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-14 21:19 -0400
                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 19:28 -0700
                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-15 19:39 +0100
                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-15 23:37 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 07:17 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 07:06 -0700
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 10:37 -0700
                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 12:14 -0700
                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 13:29 -0700
                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 22:10 -0700
                              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-17 01:03 -0700
                                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-17 02:50 -0700
                                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-17 03:21 -0700
                                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-17 03:33 -0700
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-17 00:21 +0100
                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 23:47 -0700
                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-17 20:02 +0100
                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-18 01:50 -0700
                              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-20 19:18 +0100
                                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-20 20:10 -0700
                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-19 05:08 -0700
                              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-19 08:45 -0400
                                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-19 20:21 -0700
                                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-20 06:12 -0700
                                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-20 15:26 +0100
                                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-20 16:52 +0100
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-20 17:03 +0100
                                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Jeff Barnett <jbb@notatt.com> - 2021-05-20 12:48 -0600
                                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-20 19:26 -0700
                                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-20 22:24 -0700
                                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-21 21:18 -0400
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-22 00:36 -0700
                                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-22 09:21 -0400
                                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-22 11:55 -0700
                                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-22 13:10 +0100
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-23 17:08 -0700
                                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-09-10 04:36 -0700
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-22 12:23 -0700
                                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-22 22:59 +0100
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-23 19:45 +0100
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-22 19:52 -0400
                                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-22 15:58 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-16 12:11 +0100
        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-14 17:25 +0100
          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 10:09 -0700
            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-14 19:51 +0100
              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 18:13 -0700
                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-15 19:50 +0100
                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-15 23:19 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Jeff Barnett <jbb@notatt.com> - 2021-05-16 02:46 -0600
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 02:50 -0700
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 03:10 -0700
                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Jeff Barnett <jbb@notatt.com> - 2021-05-16 13:27 -0600
                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-16 21:40 +0100
                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-16 17:01 -0400
                            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Jeff Barnett <jbb@notatt.com> - 2021-05-16 22:16 -0600
                          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 21:53 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-16 11:39 +0100
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 04:19 -0700
                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-16 06:18 -0700
            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-14 20:16 +0100
              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 16:51 -0700
                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-15 01:59 +0100
                  Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 19:01 -0700
                    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-15 03:06 +0100
                      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 19:22 -0700
                        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Ben Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk> - 2021-05-15 13:44 +0100
            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Peter <peterxpercival@hotmail.com> - 2021-05-15 15:03 +0100
              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-15 10:14 -0700
                Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-15 19:06 +0100
    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Andy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk> - 2021-05-14 14:51 +0100
      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 09:10 -0700
    Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Richard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org> - 2021-05-14 10:28 -0400
      Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 09:31 -0700
        Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 10:18 -0700
          Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-14 10:46 -0700
            Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> - 2021-05-15 03:20 -0700
              Re: The Emperor's New Clothes: lim(n→∞){1/n}=0, and 0.999...=1 wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> - 2021-05-15 05:02 -0700

Page 3 of 5 — ← Prev page 1 2 [3] 4 5  Next page →


#34131

FromMalcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-22 11:55 -0700
Message-ID<29c2ec8f-a27e-4571-9c45-c3ff521b3ea8n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#34120
On Saturday, 22 May 2021 at 14:21:45 UTC+1, Richard Damon wrote:
> 
> What I am discussion is the 'The Reals' is a name for a particular set 
> of number, and only for that set of numbers. There are a lot of 
> different sets of numbers, and I listed some of them. 
> 
> The set of Numbers you have described is DIFFERENT than the set of 
> numbers that define what is called 'The Reals', so calling it 'The 
> Reals' is an error in definition.
>
It's a demand for a change in terminology. Which implies that the accepted
definition is deficient in some way. That's not normally a good way of
proceeeding, even if you are right, because then there will be a period where
you don't know whether people are using the old definition or the new definition.

Better to call them something else. However you'll probably find that the
same idea, or at least essentially the same idea, has been proposed before.
I found that when I "invented" "quantitative boolean logic". It was of course
just "fuzzy logic" and nothing new.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#34115

FromAndy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk>
Date2021-05-22 13:10 +0100
Message-ID<s8asb5$e2l$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#34053
On 21/05/2021 03:26, wij wrote:
> In every stage of education, time is scheduled/fixed. Students have
> to pass many exams. year after year... Both the teachers and students
> are left with no time to think back afterwards. After graduated,
> still very little time, if any, can actually be spent in studying
> something trivial/fundamental like "0.999...=1?".
	That sounds like a very poor education.  I don't recognise
your description in my own education, at any stage [and least of all
after graduation], nor in the education I delivered.

> In stead, to avoid unavoidable contradiction, 'Fabrication' (human 
> nature.  hearsay is also one) of more theories are REWARDED,  so long
> as the established ones not jeopardized, 'destructive' theory is not
> welcome, more or less. Stereotype thinking is as it is, not easy to
> change.
	Again, that may be true in some places;  it's not a feature
of any education I received or delivered.  Almost the opposite;  we
welcomed students who challenged what they were told and who tried
to extend examples and problems.  But many students simply wanted
to be told what they needed to know.

[...]
> I skip the "parrot knowledge", to focus on the phrase "The reals do
> not include infinity" which I often saw but do not understand.
> π/4=∑(n=0,∞) { 1^(-n)/(2n+1) }  // Gregory–Leibniz series
> e=lim(n->∞) { (1+1/n)^n }           // one definition of e
> Above, all the results are irrational numbers. If "real number do not
> include infinity", all rational terms add up to still rational number
> (not to say '∞' is present in the expression).
> What you say about this.

	Firstly, infinity is not banned from mathematics;  it is
present and well-understood [eg] in projective geometry and in
extensions of R.  In particular, it is present in specific
formulas of sums and limits with defined meanings;  but it is
never present in the arithmetic of R.

	Secondly, you still seem to be thinking that limits must
satisfy the properties of their partial sums.  Not so.  Indeed,
we see this in the most elementary version of decimals;  eg, in

   sqrt(2) == 1.4142135623730950488...

the approximations 1, 1.4, 1.41, 1.414, 1.4142, 1.41421, ... are
all rational, but it has been known for over 2500 years that the
limit of those approximations is irrational.

	Thirdly, you still seem to be claiming that the exclusion
of infinity from R is "dogma" or "parrot thinking".  Not so.  It
[or an equivalent axiom] is part of the /definition/ of R.  It
may not be part of what you were taught;  that's another matter.
If you add infinity, you no longer have R;  that's not dogma or
parroting, it's simply a trivial fact.  No-one is preventing you
from inventing or using number systems different from R;  but
you then need to re-examine any theorems relating to R that you
intend to use.  Similarly, it is a fact, not dogma or parroting,
that the C programming language does not include a "+-" operator.
No-one prevents you from adding syntax and semantics for such an
operator, but the resulting language is not C, and you can't
expect existing C compilers to understand it.  Worse, it is not
the responsibility of compiler writers to point out to you that
your new syntax is ambiguous, so that some correct C programs
are incorrect in your new language.  Go figure.

-- 
Andy Walker, Nottingham.
    Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music
    Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Ascher

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#34137

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-23 17:08 -0700
Message-ID<0ff34083-a1a2-458a-88ba-78f40d1b63d6n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#34115
On Monday, 24 May 2021 at 02:45:31 UTC+8, Andy Walker wrote:
> On 22/05/2021 23:58, wij wrote: 
> > I do not think ℝ is so well-defined enough to claim its copyright. To 
> > me, 'strandard definition' of ℝ, is like the standard model theory to 
> > the universe. No one actually using it to reject other usage of 
> > 'cosmos' or 'universe'. (assume ℝ^4=Universe, no one so far can 
> > define ℝ to any satisfactory degree) Rejecting anyone's 
> > interpretation but yours do not seem reasonable.
> But R /is/ well-defined, and you can find a definition in 
> any suitable text, such as the famous Hardy's "Pure Mathematics" 
> [other books are available]. Unlike a "standard model" of the 
> Universe, R is not subject to experiment. No-one is ever going 
> to show that there is an error in the 17th significant figure. 
> Whether R^4 is a good model for the Universe is a quite different 
> sort of question. To repeat -- if you have a number system that 
> includes infinitesimals, it may or may not be interesting, useful 
> or correct, but it is not R. Your system is not "rejected", it's 
> simply different. R is not /my/ system, btw; if I had been 
> alive 300 years ago it's possible I might have had some input, 
> but I wasn't and didn't.
> >> Secondly, you still seem to be thinking that limits must 
> >> satisfy the properties of their partial sums. Not so. Indeed, 
> >> we see this in the most elementary version of decimals; eg, in 
> >> sqrt(2) == 1.4142135623730950488... 
> >> the approximations 1, 1.4, 1.41, 1.414, 1.4142, 1.41421, ... are 
> >> all rational, but it has been known for over 2500 years that the 
> >> limit of those approximations is irrational. 
> > This a good start from more specific examples, rather than just words. 
> > 1.4142... cannot possibly end up to 'equal to' sqrt(2) in finite steps
> It's not expected to. But there are lots of interesting 
> sequences whose /limit/ is sqrt(2), even though each member of the 
> sequence is obtainable in finitely-many steps and is rational.
> > The same to 0.999...=1. Infinite steps?
> Of course not. Limits are not defined in terms of number 
> of steps. Again, any suitable text will define the concept of 
> "limit"; and again, this is not a matter of dogma -- if you want 
> to define some other property of "0.999..." and explain how it is 
> useful, no-one will stop you, but you shouldn't give the name 
> "limit" to your property.
> > still is no, otherwise 1/∞=0 
> > and density property may longer be true, beside "0.999..." is 
> > "ill-formed" as said.
> As /you/ said. For the rest of the world it's just a 
> notational convenience, an abbreviation of something more 
> complicated. But if you keep on introducing infinities into 
> formulas of R, then it is not surprising that you draw 
> conclusions that don't make sense in R. [They may perhaps 
> make sense in the surreals, but you seem to be resistant to 
> studying those. In the surreals, there are numbers "p" such 
> that "0.999...9 < p < 1" for any finite number of 9s, which 
> seems to be what you want.] 
> 
> [...]
> > I.e. lim(x->∞) {sin(1/x)}=0 is illusion if '=' is used (using the 
> > rail track example to understand.
> It's not an "illusion"; it's just the observation that 
> you can make "sin(1/x)" small by making "x" large. Everything 
> else is filling in some details in the definition of "limit". 
> You seem to be expecting the limit to be a value of "sin(1/x)"; 
> not so, it's just a number with a defined property.
> -- 
> Andy Walker, Nottingham. 
> Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music
> Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Liszt

I have no further questioning if the main consensus is established.
Any 'definition' is man-made, arbitrary.
You will find the rest if the goal is 'understanding' and what you said is true
"...we welcomed students who challenged what they were told and who tried
to extend examples and problems..."
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JOPNVdl6GRY

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#39262

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-09-10 04:36 -0700
Message-ID<694a1a94-1e57-4e89-87c0-be213db2d520n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#34137
On Monday, 24 May 2021 at 08:08:15 UTC+8, wij wrote:
> On Monday, 24 May 2021 at 02:45:31 UTC+8, Andy Walker wrote: 
> > On 22/05/2021 23:58, wij wrote: 
> > > I do not think ℝ is so well-defined enough to claim its copyright. To 
> > > me, 'strandard definition' of ℝ, is like the standard model theory to 
> > > the universe. No one actually using it to reject other usage of 
> > > 'cosmos' or 'universe'. (assume ℝ^4=Universe, no one so far can 
> > > define ℝ to any satisfactory degree) Rejecting anyone's 
> > > interpretation but yours do not seem reasonable. 
> > But R /is/ well-defined, and you can find a definition in 
> > any suitable text, such as the famous Hardy's "Pure Mathematics" 
> > [other books are available]. Unlike a "standard model" of the 
> > Universe, R is not subject to experiment. No-one is ever going 
> > to show that there is an error in the 17th significant figure. 
> > Whether R^4 is a good model for the Universe is a quite different 
> > sort of question. To repeat -- if you have a number system that 
> > includes infinitesimals, it may or may not be interesting, useful 
> > or correct, but it is not R. Your system is not "rejected", it's 
> > simply different. R is not /my/ system, btw; if I had been 
> > alive 300 years ago it's possible I might have had some input, 
> > but I wasn't and didn't. 
> > >> Secondly, you still seem to be thinking that limits must 
> > >> satisfy the properties of their partial sums. Not so. Indeed, 
> > >> we see this in the most elementary version of decimals; eg, in 
> > >> sqrt(2) == 1.4142135623730950488... 
> > >> the approximations 1, 1.4, 1.41, 1.414, 1.4142, 1.41421, ... are 
> > >> all rational, but it has been known for over 2500 years that the 
> > >> limit of those approximations is irrational. 
> > > This a good start from more specific examples, rather than just words. 
> > > 1.4142... cannot possibly end up to 'equal to' sqrt(2) in finite steps 
> > It's not expected to. But there are lots of interesting 
> > sequences whose /limit/ is sqrt(2), even though each member of the 
> > sequence is obtainable in finitely-many steps and is rational. 
> > > The same to 0.999...=1. Infinite steps? 
> > Of course not. Limits are not defined in terms of number 
> > of steps. Again, any suitable text will define the concept of 
> > "limit"; and again, this is not a matter of dogma -- if you want 
> > to define some other property of "0.999..." and explain how it is 
> > useful, no-one will stop you, but you shouldn't give the name 
> > "limit" to your property. 
> > > still is no, otherwise 1/∞=0 
> > > and density property may longer be true, beside "0.999..." is 
> > > "ill-formed" as said. 
> > As /you/ said. For the rest of the world it's just a 
> > notational convenience, an abbreviation of something more 
> > complicated. But if you keep on introducing infinities into 
> > formulas of R, then it is not surprising that you draw 
> > conclusions that don't make sense in R. [They may perhaps 
> > make sense in the surreals, but you seem to be resistant to 
> > studying those. In the surreals, there are numbers "p" such 
> > that "0.999...9 < p < 1" for any finite number of 9s, which 
> > seems to be what you want.] 
> > 
> > [...] 
> > > I.e. lim(x->∞) {sin(1/x)}=0 is illusion if '=' is used (using the 
> > > rail track example to understand. 
> > It's not an "illusion"; it's just the observation that 
> > you can make "sin(1/x)" small by making "x" large. Everything 
> > else is filling in some details in the definition of "limit". 
> > You seem to be expecting the limit to be a value of "sin(1/x)"; 
> > not so, it's just a number with a defined property. 
> > -- 
> > Andy Walker, Nottingham. 
> > Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music 
> > Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Liszt
> I have no further questioning if the main consensus is established. 
> Any 'definition' is man-made, arbitrary. 
> You will find the rest if the goal is 'understanding' and what you said is true 
> "...we welcomed students who challenged what they were told and who tried 
> to extend examples and problems..." 
> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JOPNVdl6GRY

I think I have developed enough materials for all your questions.
The full file is at
https://sourceforge.net/projects/cscall/files/MisFiles/NumberView-en.txt/download
For now, I am more concerned about the result D(sin(x)≠cos(x) as in Ex3.
Is there any "Logical" proof that D(sin(x)=cos(x) not relying on limit theory?

....
+---------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| Differentiation as the finding of the primitive function (divide-by-zero) |
+---------------------------------------------------------------------------+

Set of function expression 𝔽::= {f| f is an average mathematical function (not
    using ∞)}. For clarity reason, this sloppiness should be fine for the moment.

Set of infinitesimal ℍ::= {h| ∀q∈ℚ, |h|<|q|}

Neighborbood::= Set of neighborhood of a point x is defined as U(x)≡ {x+h| h∈ℍ}

Deleted neighborhood::= Set of deleted neborhood is defined as U'(x)≡ U(x) - {x}

Undefined-Point primitive function::= Function g' is a UP-primitive function of
    g <=> g is undefined at point a but g' is defined, beside this,
    ∀x (x≠a), g'(x)=g(x).
    IOW, g'(x,h) is a function of g(x,U'(x)). Because g is often undefined at
    point 0, g' may be referred to as its Zero-Point primitive function.

    Ex: Let f∈𝔽, g(x,h)≡ (f(x+h)-f(x))/h, h∈U'(x),  // two argument example
        If g'(x,h) is the UP-primitive of g(x,h) <=> g(x,0) is undefined but
        g'(x,0) is defined, beside this, g'(x,h)=g(x,h).

    Note: The result of g'(x,0) is similar to lim(h->0) g(x,h), but the theory
          of limit is very inconsistent (self-contradictory). Computers just
          do not have that kind of free will.

Derivative::= Generalized notion of the slope of a tangent line.
    Let function f∈𝔽, g(x,h)≡ (f(x+h)-f(x))/h. I.e. g(x,h) is the slope of all
    the straight lines passing point (x,f(x)) and (U'(x),f(U'(x))).
    If g'(x,h), the ZP-primitive of g(x,h), exists, g'(x,0) is the derivative of
    f(x).

Derivative function::= The function of derivative, noted as D(f(x)) or f'(x).
    Derivative function is sometimes referred to as derivative or
    differentiation, noted as (d/dx)f(x).

----
  Ex1: Power function f(x)= x^a
      From definition, g(x,h)= ((x+h)^a - x^a)/h, h∈U'(x)
      = (x^a + C(a,1)*x^(a-1)*h + C(a,2)*x^(a-2)*h^2 + ... + h^n - x^a)/h
        // Binomial expansion
      = C(a,1)*x^(a-1) + C(a,2)*x^(a-2)*h^1 + ... + h^(n-1)

      Because the denominator (zero) is eliminated, the ZP-primitive g' of g
      is the same: g'(x,h)= g(x,h).
      Therefore, the derivative of f(x)= f'(x)= g'(x,0)=C(a,1)*x^(a-1)= a*x^(a-1)

  Ex2: Exponential function f(x)= a^x
      From definition, g(x,h)= (a^(x+h)-a^x)/h = (a^x)*((a^h-1)/h), h∈U'(x)
      Assume g'(x,h)= s(x)+j(x,h) is the ZP primitive.
      (a^x)*[(a^h-1)/h]= s(x)+j(x,h)     // ZP term in square brackets
      <=> (a^x)*[(a^h-1)/h] - s(x) = j(x,h)
      While h=0, LHS has to be 0, therefore,
      (a^x)*[(a^h-1)/h] = s(x)
      Because [(a^h-1)/h] is a term that "converges" depending on a, we can
      "assume the ZP primitive of [(a^h-1)/h]" is in form of C+remainder
      (C=lim(h->0)(a^h-1)/h), then, the derivative of a^x= g'(x,0)= (a^x)*C

      ∴ g'(x,0)= C*a^x depends on the assumption of convergence

      [Note] The result indicates the previous definition of Euler's Constant
             e≡(1+1/∞)^∞ is still problematic, because this is the result of
             assuming h=1/∞, not h=0.
             "Value converges" is a confusing notion, fine for engineering
             mathematics but not in logic.

 Ex3: Trigonometric function f(x)= sin(x)
      From definition g(x,h)= (sin(x+h)-sin(x))/h, h∈U'(x)
      I am not able to deduce the ZP primitive, so assume g'(x,h)= cos(x)+j(x,h)
      <=> ((sin(x+h)-sin(x))/h) - cos(x)= j(x,h)
      <=> sin(x)*cos(h)+ cos(x)*sin(h) -sin(x) - h*cos(x) = h*j(x,h)
      <=> sin(x)*(cos(h)-1) + cos(x)*(sin(h)-h) = h*j(x,h)
      While h=0, LHS has to be 0, therefore,
      sin(x)*(1-cos(h)= cos(x)*(sin(h)-h)
      <=> tan(x)= [(sin(h)-h)/(1-cos(h))]
      <=> false (LHS and RHS are unrelated)  // may mean something different.

      ∴ Assumption g'(x,h)= cos(x) + j(x,h) is false.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#34139

FromMalcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-22 12:23 -0700
Message-ID<3f6bbf19-a741-4431-bc91-7b5bbd049f52n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#34115
On Saturday, 22 May 2021 at 13:10:19 UTC+1, Andy Walker wrote:
> 
> Thirdly, you still seem to be claiming that the exclusion 
> of infinity from R is "dogma" or "parrot thinking". Not so. It 
> [or an equivalent axiom] is part of the /definition/ of R. It 
> may not be part of what you were taught; that's another matter. 
> If you add infinity, you no longer have R; that's not dogma or 
> parroting, it's simply a trivial fact. No-one is preventing you 
> from inventing or using number systems different from R; but 
> you then need to re-examine any theorems relating to R that you 
> intend to use. Similarly, it is a fact, not dogma or parroting, 
> that the C programming language does not include a "+-" operator. 
> No-one prevents you from adding syntax and semantics for such an 
> operator, but the resulting language is not C, and you can't 
> expect existing C compilers to understand it. Worse, it is not 
> the responsibility of compiler writers to point out to you that 
> your new syntax is ambiguous, so that some correct C programs 
> are incorrect in your new language. Go figure.
>
Though C doesn't provide any easy way to represent real numbers. 
What is does provide is a set of 2^64 numbers, including all the integers
from 0 to 2**53, and values from about 10^300 to about 10^300, so
densely packed that the gaps between them are negligible for most
calcuations. Then you also have special representation for some very
tiny numbers lower than 10^-300. It also has infinity, and "not a number"
(so to be pedantic about it, it's not strictly a "set of numbers").

This set is extremely useful. It does however lead to problems in real-life
programs because the rules of real arithmetic don't hold. Sometimes
you get "not a number" cropping up unexectedly and unwelcomely, and
the formulae are right, but they demand an accuracy that the respresentation
cannot achieve.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#34211

FromBen Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk>
Date2021-05-22 22:59 +0100
Message-ID<87pmxipgzq.fsf@bsb.me.uk>
In reply to#34139
Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> writes:

> Though C doesn't provide any easy way to represent real numbers. 
> What [it] does provide is a set of 2^64 numbers,

You go on to describe what looks like IEEE double-precision floating
point but a C implementation is not guaranteed to to provide this set,
though it must tell you if it doesn't.

> including all the integers from 0 to 2**53,

All the integers from -2^53 to 2^53, one of them twice!

> and values from about 10^300 to about 10^300, so
> densely packed that the gaps between them are negligible for most
> calcuations. Then you also have special representation for some very
> tiny numbers lower than 10^-300.  It also has infinity,

Two of them.

> and "not a number"

2^53 - 2 "not a number"s.

> (so to be pedantic about it, it's not strictly a "set of numbers").

Given that 9,007,199,254,740,990 (and arguably 9,007,199,254,740,992) of
them are not numbers, I'd say that "not strictly" is a bit of an
understatement.

-- 
Ben.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#34162

FromAndy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk>
Date2021-05-23 19:45 +0100
Message-ID<s8e7s7$6jv$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#34115
On 22/05/2021 23:58, wij wrote:
> I do not think ℝ is so well-defined enough to claim its copyright. To
> me, 'strandard definition' of ℝ, is like the standard model theory to
> the universe. No one actually using it to reject other usage of
> 'cosmos' or 'universe'. (assume ℝ^4=Universe, no one so far can
> define ℝ to any satisfactory degree) Rejecting anyone's
> interpretation but yours do not seem reasonable.

	But R /is/ well-defined, and you can find a definition in
any suitable text, such as the famous Hardy's "Pure Mathematics"
[other books are available].  Unlike a "standard model" of the
Universe, R is not subject to experiment.  No-one is ever going
to show that there is an error in the 17th significant figure.
Whether R^4 is a good model for the Universe is a quite different
sort of question.  To repeat -- if you have a number system that
includes infinitesimals, it may or may not be interesting, useful
or correct, but it is not R.  Your system is not "rejected", it's
simply different.  R is not /my/ system, btw;  if I had been
alive 300 years ago it's possible I might have had some input,
but I wasn't and didn't.

>> Secondly, you still seem to be thinking that limits must
>> satisfy the properties of their partial sums. Not so. Indeed,
>> we see this in the most elementary version of decimals; eg, in
>>   sqrt(2) == 1.4142135623730950488...
>> the approximations 1, 1.4, 1.41, 1.414, 1.4142, 1.41421, ... are
>> all rational, but it has been known for over 2500 years that the
>> limit of those approximations is irrational.
> This a good start from more specific examples, rather than just words.
> 1.4142... cannot possibly end up to 'equal to' sqrt(2) in finite steps

	It's not expected to.  But there are lots of interesting
sequences whose /limit/ is sqrt(2), even though each member of the
sequence is obtainable in finitely-many steps and is rational.

> The same to 0.999...=1. Infinite steps?

	Of course not.  Limits are not defined in terms of number
of steps.  Again, any suitable text will define the concept of
"limit";  and again, this is not a matter of dogma -- if you want
to define some other property of "0.999..." and explain how it is
useful, no-one will stop you, but you shouldn't give the name
"limit" to your property.

>					  still is no, otherwise 1/∞=0
> and density property may longer be true, beside "0.999..." is
> "ill-formed" as said.

	As /you/ said.  For the rest of the world it's just a
notational convenience, an abbreviation of something more
complicated.  But if you keep on introducing infinities into
formulas of R, then it is not surprising that you draw
conclusions that don't make sense in R.  [They may perhaps
make sense in the surreals, but you seem to be resistant to
studying those.  In the surreals, there are numbers "p" such
that "0.999...9 < p < 1" for any finite number of 9s, which
seems to be what you want.]

[...]
> I.e. lim(x->∞) {sin(1/x)}=0 is illusion if '=' is used (using the
> rail track example to understand.

	It's not an "illusion";  it's just the observation that
you can make "sin(1/x)" small by making "x" large.  Everything
else is filling in some details in the definition of "limit".
You seem to be expecting the limit to be a value of "sin(1/x)";
not so, it's just a number with a defined property.

-- 
Andy Walker, Nottingham.
    Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music
    Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Liszt

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#34191

FromRichard Damon <Richard@Damon-Family.org>
Date2021-05-22 19:52 -0400
Message-ID<KOgqI.74186$5%7.70928@fx13.iad>
In reply to#34115
On 5/22/21 6:58 PM, wij wrote:
> I do not think ℝ is so well-defined enough to claim its copyright.
> To me, 'strandard definition' of ℝ, is like the standard model theory to the universe.
> No one actually using it to reject other usage of 'cosmos' or 'universe'.
> (assume ℝ^4=Universe, no one so far can define ℝ to any satisfactory degree)
> Rejecting anyone's interpretation but yours do not seem reasonable.
> 

Everything I have seen for anyone really working in the domain all seems
to agree on the same basic set. They may use different words or methods
to build that set, but they all define that exact same set which is
called R.

Maybe people not understanding it well enough don't see that the
different definition are all equivalent, but they are.

What YOU want to call The Reals, is NOT equivalent to that set, so it
doesn't match, so you shouldn't use the name.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#34194

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-22 15:58 -0700
Message-ID<5bd2cebf-94f8-4910-9adb-f56b7e71ce3dn@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#34115
On Saturday, 22 May 2021 at 20:10:19 UTC+8, Andy Walker wrote:
> On 21/05/2021 03:26, wij wrote: 
> > In every stage of education, time is scheduled/fixed. Students have 
> > to pass many exams. year after year... Both the teachers and students 
> > are left with no time to think back afterwards. After graduated, 
> > still very little time, if any, can actually be spent in studying 
> > something trivial/fundamental like "0.999...=1?".
> That sounds like a very poor education. I don't recognise 
> your description in my own education, at any stage [and least of all 
> after graduation], nor in the education I delivered.
> > In stead, to avoid unavoidable contradiction, 'Fabrication' (human 
> > nature. hearsay is also one) of more theories are REWARDED, so long 
> > as the established ones not jeopardized, 'destructive' theory is not 
> > welcome, more or less. Stereotype thinking is as it is, not easy to 
> > change.
> Again, that may be true in some places; it's not a feature 
> of any education I received or delivered. Almost the opposite; we 
> welcomed students who challenged what they were told and who tried 
> to extend examples and problems. But many students simply wanted 
> to be told what they needed to know. 
> 

School education in my country was a torture. These years it seems still
very exam.-oriented, so long as people believe passing-exam. is the real 
thing. Sadly, it is Practically true.

> [...]
> > I skip the "parrot knowledge", to focus on the phrase "The reals do 
> > not include infinity" which I often saw but do not understand. 
> > π/4=∑(n=0,∞) { 1^(-n)/(2n+1) } // Gregory–Leibniz series 
> > e=lim(n->∞) { (1+1/n)^n } // one definition of e 
> > Above, all the results are irrational numbers. If "real number do not 
> > include infinity", all rational terms add up to still rational number 
> > (not to say '∞' is present in the expression). 
> > What you say about this.
> Firstly, infinity is not banned from mathematics; it is 
> present and well-understood [eg] in projective geometry and in 
> extensions of R. In particular, it is present in specific 
> formulas of sums and limits with defined meanings; but it is 
> never present in the arithmetic of R. 
> 

I do not think ℝ is so well-defined enough to claim its copyright.
To me, 'strandard definition' of ℝ, is like the standard model theory to the universe.
No one actually using it to reject other usage of 'cosmos' or 'universe'.
(assume ℝ^4=Universe, no one so far can define ℝ to any satisfactory degree)
Rejecting anyone's interpretation but yours do not seem reasonable.

> Secondly, you still seem to be thinking that limits must 
> satisfy the properties of their partial sums. Not so. Indeed, 
> we see this in the most elementary version of decimals; eg, in 
> 
> sqrt(2) == 1.4142135623730950488... 
> 
> the approximations 1, 1.4, 1.41, 1.414, 1.4142, 1.41421, ... are 
> all rational, but it has been known for over 2500 years that the 
> limit of those approximations is irrational. 
> 

This a good start from more specific examples, rather than just words.
1.4142... cannot possibly end up to 'equal to' sqrt(2) in finite steps
The same to 0.999...=1. Infinite steps? still is no, otherwise 1/∞=0 and
density property may longer be true, beside "0.999..." is "ill-formed" as said.
You made a unconscious 'jump' from the normal logic to the conclusion (sqrt(2) or 1).

Another example: Two parallel lines T0,T1 (imagine as a rail track)
T0(x)=0
T1(x)=1
It can be 'shown' (or 'proved' by 'ε-δ theory') at the infinite distance, the
two ending points 'converge' to a point, but we know the track is still
parallel there (although 'some theory' can Define both the far ends meets).
Using this example, limit theory is the same as an amusing magic trick as in
measuring the end point of T0(∞),T1(∞) from 'appearance' from the original point. 
I.e. lim(x->∞) {sin(1/x)}=0 is illusion if '=' is used (using the rail track example
to understand.

> Thirdly, you still seem to be claiming that the exclusion 
> of infinity from R is "dogma" or "parrot thinking". 

Most of your previous reply were presented like "dogma".

> Not so. It 
> [or an equivalent axiom] is part of the /definition/ of R. It 
> may not be part of what you were taught; that's another matter. 
> If you add infinity, you no longer have R; that's not dogma or 
> parroting, it's simply a trivial fact. No-one is preventing you 
> from inventing or using number systems different from R; but 
> you then need to re-examine any theorems relating to R that you 
> intend to use. Similarly, it is a fact, not dogma or parroting, 
> that the C programming language does not include a "+-" operator. 
> No-one prevents you from adding syntax and semantics for such an 
> operator, but the resulting language is not C, and you can't 
> expect existing C compilers to understand it. Worse, it is not 
> the responsibility of compiler writers to point out to you that 
> your new syntax is ambiguous, so that some correct C programs 
> are incorrect in your new language. Go figure.
> -- 
> Andy Walker, Nottingham. 
> Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music
> Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Ascher

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33676

FromAndy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk>
Date2021-05-16 12:11 +0100
Message-ID<s7qukg$1a7j$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#33663
On 16/05/2021 07:37, wij wrote:
>>> My point in that section is to establish 1/∞≠0 (infinitesimal exists
>>> and not identical to zero)
>> You can't "establish" that. [...]
> Why can't I?

	Because there are perfectly acceptable arithmetics in which
that is true and perfectly acceptable arithmetics in which it is
false.  So neither its truth nor its falsity can be proven except
by taking it [or its converse] as an axiom;  in which case, it is
not "established", but merely an assumption.

>	       Every theory begins from postulate/proposition/axiom, whatever..

	Quite.  But such axioms only apply to that theory, not to any
other theories that start from other axioms.

> [Your standard reals] or [surreals] or others are probably no different from
> other 'pure theory', have the difficulty applying to the real line. Thus,
> what is the "obvious facts" and "rigorous investigation"?

	You seem to think that there is only one true, correct version
of maths.  "Die ganzen Zahlen hat der liebe Gott gemacht, alles andere
ist Menschenwerk" -- Kronecker.  So almost all of mathematics is man-
made, and largely a matter of choice.  Virtually all engineering [eg]
maths is preceded by an invisible "[Using the standard reals]", as
that is the common currency among virtually all non-mathematicians,
even if they don't know or understand it, and a large majority of
actual mathematicians [inc me, except when doing game theory].

> My theory of infinity is simple:
>   Definition of ∞:
>    1. ∀n∈ℕ, n<∞
>    2. The multiplicative inverse of ∞ is 1/∞, the additive inverse is -∞
> [Corollary] 1/∞≠0 (infinitesimal exists and not identical to zero)

	Sure, and versions of that theory are well known, starting
[seriously] with the debates about the foundations of calculus in
the 18thC.  But, for good reasons, they lost out to the standard
theory of real numbers, and all that followed in the 19thC when
Cauchy and others put maths on a rigorous basis.  So your theory
isn't "wrong", it's just not standard.  When you apply it, you can
get versions of calculus and all the rest of engineering maths.
But you don't get the same theorems as the rest of us, and it's
not easy, as you can easily verify by looking up "non-standard
analysis".  Which is why it's not taught to undergraduates.

-- 
Andy Walker, Nottingham.
    Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music
    Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Ketterer

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33556

FromBen Bacarisse <ben.usenet@bsb.me.uk>
Date2021-05-14 17:25 +0100
Message-ID<874kf5th87.fsf@bsb.me.uk>
In reply to#33550
wij <wyniijj@gmail.com> writes:

> On Friday, 14 May 2021 at 20:25:36 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote:
>> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
>> 
>> > Most young kids easily understand 0.999…≠1, and will be confused if the 
>> > opposite is told. But nowadays, it seems becoming globally common, 
>> > students are forced (educated) to believe and 'must' so answer in 
>> > exam.
>> In some of the better institutions, they will be given the tools to 
>> argue the point. Were you just told to believe it? Were you never 
>> given any justification for 0.999... = 1?
>
> I have seen various 'proves' in recent 10 years, just magic show, similar to
> olcott's way of proof/claim, inventing a obfuscate theory to explain desired
> result, ignoring simple/intuitive explanation.
> Or you can provided a LOGICAL proof (limit is no logic).

I am sorry you did not find any of the arguments you have seen
persuasive.  How you construct/define the real numbers?  Serious
question -- please don't be like all the other cran^H^H^H^H
unconventional posters and duck out when asked to say how you see the
underlying issue.

> I assume you did not read the file:
> https://sourceforge.net/projects/cscall/files/MisFiles/Infinity-en.txt/download

No.  I'm reading Usenet.  If you'd like people to read it, you should
quote the relevant parts here.

>> > 1. 1/3=0.333... (repeating decimals are rational numbers) 
>> > In the long division method, the digit rendering process is endless. In 
>> > computer science, the result of such a process is called undecidable.
>> No, that is not what "undecidable" means. 
>
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decidability_(logic)

That's not what undecidable means in computer science, which is the
meaning you referenced directly.  The link between the two meanings is
provided by Turing 1936 paper which explicitly permits "endless
processes" as "computable numbers".  Logic is undeciable because there
are uncomputable numbers, not because some processes for generating
digits would not end.

-- 
Ben.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33562

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-14 10:09 -0700
Message-ID<d9fe1580-706c-4069-8a80-2874cc336871n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33556
On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 00:25:47 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote:
> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
> 
> > On Friday, 14 May 2021 at 20:25:36 UTC+8, Ben Bacarisse wrote: 
> >> wij <wyn...@gmail.com> writes: 
> >> 
> >> > Most young kids easily understand 0.999…≠1, and will be confused if the 
> >> > opposite is told. But nowadays, it seems becoming globally common, 
> >> > students are forced (educated) to believe and 'must' so answer in 
> >> > exam. 
> >> In some of the better institutions, they will be given the tools to 
> >> argue the point. Were you just told to believe it? Were you never 
> >> given any justification for 0.999... = 1? 
> > 
> > I have seen various 'proves' in recent 10 years, just magic show, similar to 
> > olcott's way of proof/claim, inventing a obfuscate theory to explain desired 
> > result, ignoring simple/intuitive explanation. 
> > Or you can provided a LOGICAL proof (limit is no logic).
> I am sorry you did not find any of the arguments you have seen 
> persuasive. How you construct/define the real numbers? Serious 
> question -- please don't be like all the other cran^H^H^H^H 
> unconventional posters and duck out when asked to say how you see the 
> underlying issue.

Defining real number ℝ is not easy.
The most general idea of real number ℝ is 'real line'.
But I do not say further.

You ducked out the question: "provide a LOGICAL proof (limit is no logic)
that 0.999...=1"

> > I assume you did not read the file: 
> > https://sourceforge.net/projects/cscall/files/MisFiles/Infinity-en.txt/download
> No. I'm reading Usenet. If you'd like people to read it, you should 
> quote the relevant parts here.

I do not need to if you are not interested in.

> >> > 1. 1/3=0.333... (repeating decimals are rational numbers) 
> >> > In the long division method, the digit rendering process is endless. In 
> >> > computer science, the result of such a process is called undecidable. 
> >> No, that is not what "undecidable" means. 
> >
> > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decidability_(logic) 
> 
> That's not what undecidable means in computer science, which is the 
> meaning you referenced directly. The link between the two meanings is 
> provided by Turing 1936 paper which explicitly permits "endless 
> processes" as "computable numbers". Logic is undeciable because there 
> are uncomputable numbers, not because some processes for generating 
> digits would not end. 
> 
> -- 
> Ben.

This is a minor issue, I bypass this one, sorry.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33570

FromAndy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk>
Date2021-05-14 19:51 +0100
Message-ID<s7mgrv$1icr$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#33562
On 14/05/2021 18:09, wij wrote:
> Defining real number ℝ is not easy.

	That depends on what you mean by "easy".  It's not something
to be done with small children [unlike, eg, counting, and thereby
the positive integers].  It /is/ commonly done with first-year maths
undergraduates;  but typically not with [eg] engineers who "merely"
need practical ideas in [eg] calculus, at the 18thC level rather than
the late 19thC level.

> The most general idea of real number ℝ is 'real line'.

	But there is only one set of real numbers [though several
equivalent ways of defining it];  it doesn't "generalise" to any
other set of numbers.  OTOH, there are more general sets of numbers
than the real numbers [inc, eg, the surreals, if you still want a
number "line", but also, eg, complex numbers].

["You" == Ben]
> But I do not say further.
> You ducked out the question: "provide a LOGICAL proof (limit is no logic)
> that 0.999...=1"

	But what do you mean by "logical" [or even "LOGICAL"]?  What
is meant by "0.999..." if not some limit?  FTAOD, there are other
possible definitions, but if you're going to prove something from
them, you need to specify what the axioms are from which you intend
to proceed.  As previously noted, one of the axioms of the reals is
that there are no infinitesimals;  roughly equivalently, that for
every positive real, p, there is an integer N s.t. Nxp > 1.  If you
remove that axiom, then it is no longer necessarily true that
"0.999... == 1".  For example, there are surreal numbers that lie
strictly between 0.999...9 for any finite number of 9's and 1, and
games [that are not numbers but share many of their properties]
that lie strictly between any surreal number which is < 1 and 1.

	Your challenge to Ben is a bit like asking him to "provide
a LOGICAL proof (Euclid's parallel axiom is no logic) that parallel
lines never meet" when for the best part of 200 years we've known
that in non-Euclidean geometries parallel lines can meet.  Provide
us with the axioms you want us to use [no more, no less] and it may
either become possible to show "logically" that 0.999... = 1 or
that 0.999... < 1 or something else.  Without such hints, it's a
fool's errand.

-- 
Andy Walker, Nottingham.
    Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music
    Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Pridham

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33599

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-14 18:13 -0700
Message-ID<85688269-a505-411c-9e2a-7fa91b79e6b3n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33570
On Saturday, 15 May 2021 at 02:51:49 UTC+8, Andy Walker wrote:
> On 14/05/2021 18:09, wij wrote: 
> > Defining real number ℝ is not easy.
> That depends on what you mean by "easy". It's not something 
> to be done with small children [unlike, eg, counting, and thereby 
> the positive integers]. It /is/ commonly done with first-year maths 
> undergraduates; but typically not with [eg] engineers who "merely" 
> need practical ideas in [eg] calculus, at the 18thC level rather than 
> the late 19thC level.

Basically, I understand in your perspective. I am not a teacher nor a
mathematician but a practical programmer who found difficulties
of programming math. stuff conceptually consistently.

> > The most general idea of real number ℝ is 'real line'.
> But there is only one set of real numbers [though several 
> equivalent ways of defining it]; it doesn't "generalise" to any 
> other set of numbers. OTOH, there are more general sets of numbers 
> than the real numbers [inc, eg, the surreals, if you still want a 
> number "line", but also, eg, complex numbers]. 
 
Real number ℝ is still difficult to define. The commonly "established theory"
has difficulty to explain (or avoid to explain) density property...etc.


> ["You" == Ben]
> > But I do not say further. 
> > You ducked out the question: "provide a LOGICAL proof (limit is no logic) 
> > that 0.999...=1"
> But what do you mean by "logical" [or even "LOGICAL"]? 

Aristotle's logic or the ones in Elements

> What 
> is meant by "0.999..." if not some limit? FTAOD, there are other 
> possible definitions, but if you're going to prove something from 
> them, you need to specify what the axioms are from which you intend 
> to proceed. As previously noted, one of the axioms of the reals is 
> that there are no infinitesimals; 

I started by defining infinity.
To my knowledge, if no infinitesimals, irrational number is not possible.

> roughly equivalently, that for 
> every positive real, p, there is an integer N s.t. Nxp > 1. If you 
> remove that axiom, then it is no longer necessarily true that 
> "0.999... == 1". For example, there are surreal numbers that lie 
> strictly between 0.999...9 for any finite number of 9's and 1, and 
> games [that are not numbers but share many of their properties] 
> that lie strictly between any surreal number which is < 1 and 1. 
> 
> Your challenge to Ben is a bit like asking him to "provide 
> a LOGICAL proof (Euclid's parallel axiom is no logic) that parallel 
> lines never meet" when for the best part of 200 years we've known 
> that in non-Euclidean geometries parallel lines can meet. Provide 

Parallel postulate is an axiom to me, nothing to do with logic

> us with the axioms you want us to use [no more, no less] and it may 
> either become possible to show "logically" that 0.999... = 1 or 
> that 0.999... < 1 or something else. Without such hints, it's a 
> fool's errand.
> -- 
> Andy Walker, Nottingham. 
> Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music 
> Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Pridham

Don't conclude so soon.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33631

FromAndy Walker <anw@cuboid.co.uk>
Date2021-05-15 19:50 +0100
Message-ID<s7p567$irh$1@gioia.aioe.org>
In reply to#33599
On 15/05/2021 02:13, wij wrote:
> To my knowledge, if no infinitesimals, irrational number is not possible.

	You might have had some difficulty explaining that to the
Pythagoreans, who destroyed their own religion/philosophy by
discovering/proving that "sqrt(2)" is irrational [meaning both
"not a ratio" and "not reasonable"], long before there was any
concept of infinitesimal or of limits.  Perhaps you meant
something else?

[...]
> Parallel postulate is an axiom to me, nothing to do with logic

	You can apply logic only to propositions which are either
axioms or are themselves constructed by applying logic to other
propositions constructed by ....  No axioms, no logic.  That's
why if you want to discover something interesting about maths but
disallowing standard axioms, then it's hard to make progress by
logic unless you specify what axioms you do allow.  But you will,
in any case, not then be talking about the real numbers.

-- 
Andy Walker, Nottingham.
    Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music
    Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Mendelssohn

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33662

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-15 23:19 -0700
Message-ID<85937b42-d0ec-412d-9b38-a4c7132f177en@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33631
On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 02:50:51 UTC+8, Andy Walker wrote:
> On 15/05/2021 02:13, wij wrote: 
> > To my knowledge, if no infinitesimals, irrational number is not possible.
> You might have had some difficulty explaining that to the 
> Pythagoreans, who destroyed their own religion/philosophy by 
> discovering/proving that "sqrt(2)" is irrational [meaning both 
> "not a ratio" and "not reasonable"], long before there was any 
> concept of infinitesimal or of limits. Perhaps you meant 
> something else? 
> 
> [...]

Prop A: no infinitesimals, irrational number is not possible.
Prop B: Pythagoreans had the difficulty understanding non-rational number.

What is your propositional statement (or correlation) about?

> > Parallel postulate is an axiom to me, nothing to do with logic
> You can apply logic only to propositions which are either 
> axioms or are themselves constructed by applying logic to other 
> propositions constructed by .... No axioms, no logic. That's 
> why if you want to discover something interesting about maths but 
> disallowing standard axioms, then it's hard to make progress by 
> logic unless you specify what axioms you do allow. But you will, 
> in any case, not then be talking about the real numbers.
> -- 
> Andy Walker, Nottingham. 
> Andy's music pages: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music
> Composer of the day: www.cuboid.me.uk/andy/Music/Composers/Mendelssohn

Do you mean the theory removing parallel axiom from Euclid geometry is the
'real' one and do not have the complexity of your interpretation of 'logic'?

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33670

FromJeff Barnett <jbb@notatt.com>
Date2021-05-16 02:46 -0600
Message-ID<s7qm5i$t02$1@dont-email.me>
In reply to#33662
On 5/16/2021 12:19 AM, wij wrote:
> Prop A: no infinitesimals, irrational number is not possible.

So SQRT(2) is not possible unless there are infinitesimals? Same for pi? 
Wow!

> Prop B: Pythagoreans had the difficulty understanding non-rational number.
The had no trouble understanding irrationals; they did, however, fear 
that knowledge of their existence would call many of their foundational 
beliefs into question.

So the Pythagoreans grocked this area very well along with some 
interesting first class proofs over 2000 years ago. Yet here we are 
today with you still confused.

You can, of course, believe anything you want and use any system of 
axioms you want but neither your axioms and beliefs or mine are going to 
delineate any thing real. If you want to work with a different abstract 
model than most others AND still talk to others, you must decide on 
axioms, logic, and models so the conversations are not just hot air. The 
surreal, for examples, are not the reals but they are well defined and 
do or do not exist any more or less than the reals. However, the formal 
definitions of them make the conversations and comparisons possible.
-- 
Jeff Barnett

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33672

FromMalcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-16 02:50 -0700
Message-ID<3d855065-70c4-4436-96d1-3cd5a6553dc5n@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33670
On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 09:46:44 UTC+1, Jeff Barnett wrote:
> On 5/16/2021 12:19 AM, wij wrote: 
> > Prop A: no infinitesimals, irrational number is not possible.
> So SQRT(2) is not possible unless there are infinitesimals? Same for pi? 
> Wow!
>
In the West, SQRT(2) was understood to be irrational in the fifth century
BC. The infinitesimal was understood in a rudimentary sense in
astronomy (it was known that in relation to the fixed stars, the earth
was a geometrical point of no magnitude), and in mysticism (use of
the Hebrew letter yodh, a dot, to represent God). But it wasn't put on
a firm mathematical basis until the 17th century.

So you don't need to understand infinitesimals to have a good theory of
irrationals.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33674

Fromwij <wyniijj@gmail.com>
Date2021-05-16 03:10 -0700
Message-ID<1764141c-48d4-436f-a78a-003e1b768d0dn@googlegroups.com>
In reply to#33670
On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 16:46:44 UTC+8, Jeff Barnett wrote:
> On 5/16/2021 12:19 AM, wij wrote: 
> > Prop A: no infinitesimals, irrational number is not possible.
> So SQRT(2) is not possible unless there are infinitesimals? Same for pi? 
> Wow!

I know quite some of my sentences formed are not complete in their meaning, 
because otherwise, at least, they would be unnecessarily long and too technical
in the conversation.
It is very good that you see some defecting/suspicious examples, but applying 
it to the whole and deduce further is not wise.

> > Prop B: Pythagoreans had the difficulty understanding non-rational number.
> The had no trouble understanding irrationals; they did, however, fear 
> that knowledge of their existence would call many of their foundational 
> beliefs into question. 
> 
> So the Pythagoreans grocked this area very well along with some 
> interesting first class proofs over 2000 years ago. Yet here we are 
> today with you still confused. 
> 
> You can, of course, believe anything you want and use any system of 
> axioms you want but neither your axioms and beliefs or mine are going to 
> delineate any thing real. If you want to work with a different abstract 
> model than most others AND still talk to others, you must decide on 
> axioms, logic, and models so the conversations are not just hot air. 

So are you.

> The 
> surreal, for examples, are not the reals but they are well defined and 
> do or do not exist any more or less than the reals. However, the formal 
> definitions of them make the conversations and comparisons possible. 
> -- 
> Jeff Barnett

Keep on topic (as shown in the title) as possible.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#33713

FromJeff Barnett <jbb@notatt.com>
Date2021-05-16 13:27 -0600
Message-ID<s7rrmj$ka5$1@dont-email.me>
In reply to#33674
On 5/16/2021 4:10 AM, wij wrote:
> On Sunday, 16 May 2021 at 16:46:44 UTC+8, Jeff Barnett wrote:
>> On 5/16/2021 12:19 AM, wij wrote:
>>> Prop A: no infinitesimals, irrational number is not possible.
>> So SQRT(2) is not possible unless there are infinitesimals? Same for pi?
>> Wow!
> 
> I know quite some of my sentences formed are not complete in their meaning,
> because otherwise, at least, they would be unnecessarily long and too technical
> in the conversation.
> It is very good that you see some defecting/suspicious examples, but applying
> it to the whole and deduce further is not wise.
> 
>>> Prop B: Pythagoreans had the difficulty understanding non-rational number.
>> The had no trouble understanding irrationals; they did, however, fear
>> that knowledge of their existence would call many of their foundational
>> beliefs into question.
>>
>> So the Pythagoreans grocked this area very well along with some
>> interesting first class proofs over 2000 years ago. Yet here we are
>> today with you still confused.
>>
>> You can, of course, believe anything you want and use any system of
>> axioms you want but neither your axioms and beliefs or mine are going to
>> delineate any thing real. If you want to work with a different abstract
>> model than most others AND still talk to others, you must decide on
>> axioms, logic, and models so the conversations are not just hot air.
> 
> So are you.

I'm not sure what you mean by "So are you." I'm guessing that you mean 
that my view about infinitesimals suffers the same problem as yours. If 
so, I agree and that was what I was trying to convey. The difference is 
my views, which I have not stated, are backed by axioms, logic, and 
models. My secret is that I have accepted many different views that each 
has a proper mathematical definition and logic. Only one of them seems 
appropriate for engineering and all of them might be appropriate for 
science and philosophy or even just for fun.

Like I said above, you can accept anything you like. If you want 
intelligent conversation about your views it's up to you to present 
enough mathematics so it's clear what we will be talking about. 
Appealing to reality as a justification doesn't help or make sense. No 
one knows at this stage of the universe what reality is so we have all 
agreed as "intellectuals" to make mathematical methods the basis of our 
conversation. Not reality, not religion, and not wishes. We rely on 
logic and mathematical principals for the rules of conversation.

>> The
>> surreal, for examples, are not the reals but they are well defined and
>> do or do not exist any more or less than the reals. However, the formal
>> definitions of them make the conversations and comparisons possible.

> Keep on topic (as shown in the title) as possible.

I Think that was my suggestion to you. I think it was you who said "Prop 
A: no infinitesimals, irrational number is not possible." without proof. 
Even if you were proposing PROP A as an axiom, it's not in a form where 
one could deduce anything from it. So what was the point?
-- 
Jeff Barnett

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


Page 3 of 5 — ← Prev page 1 2 [3] 4 5  Next page →

Back to top | Article view | comp.theory


csiph-web