Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica > #14471 > unrolled thread

Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!

Started by"djmpark" <djmpark@comcast.net>
First post2013-05-12 07:28 +0000
Last post2013-06-04 03:14 +0000
Articles 20 on this page of 83 — 28 participants

Back to article view | Back to comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica


Contents

  Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! "djmpark" <djmpark@comcast.net> - 2013-05-12 07:28 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! psycho_dad <s.nesseris@gmail.com> - 2013-05-13 07:47 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! psycho_dad <s.nesseris@gmail.com> - 2013-05-13 09:40 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! "Nasser M. Abbasi" <nma@12000.org> - 2013-05-14 07:14 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Szabolcs Horvát <szhorvat@gmail.com> - 2013-05-15 06:54 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Szabolcs Horvát <szhorvat@gmail.com> - 2013-05-16 07:28 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Peter Klamser <klamser@googlemail.com> - 2013-05-16 07:28 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2013-05-17 08:34 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Murray Eisenberg <murray@math.umass.edu> - 2013-05-17 08:34 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Peter Klamser <klamser@googlemail.com> - 2013-05-17 08:34 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2013-05-18 06:38 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Peter Klamser <klamser@googlemail.com> - 2013-05-18 06:37 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Murray Eisenberg <murray@math.umass.edu> - 2013-05-19 09:46 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! paulmchale7@gmail.com - 2013-05-19 09:47 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! paulmchale7@gmail.com - 2013-05-19 09:47 +0000
      Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Szabolcs Horvát <szhorvat@gmail.com> - 2013-05-23 07:51 +0000
      Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! "djmpark" <djmpark@comcast.net> - 2013-05-24 09:26 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! ?iso-8859-1?Q?J=E1nos_L=F6bb?= <janos@lobb.com> - 2013-05-19 09:47 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2013-05-20 09:03 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2013-05-20 09:03 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! "Ernst H.K. Stelzer" <ernst.stelzer@physikalischebiologie.de> - 2013-05-20 09:03 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Ingolf Dahl <ingolf.dahl@telia.com> - 2013-05-20 09:03 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! David Annetts <david.annetts@iinet.net.au> - 2013-05-20 09:03 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! "mathgroup " <fizzymath@knology.net> - 2013-05-22 06:18 +0000
      expanding the use of symbolic computation in engineering .. was Re: Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-05-23 07:51 +0000
      Re: expanding the use of symbolic computation in engineering .. was Re: W Craig Carter <ccarter@MIT.EDU> - 2013-05-24 09:23 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! "djmpark" <djmpark@comcast.net> - 2013-05-23 07:54 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! "mathgroup " <fizzymath@knology.net> - 2013-05-23 07:56 +0000
      Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-05-24 09:27 +0000
      Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! "djmpark" <djmpark@comcast.net> - 2013-05-25 09:35 +0000
      Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Richard Fateman <fateman@eecs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-05-25 09:35 +0000
      Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! "djmpark" <djmpark@comcast.net> - 2013-05-25 09:35 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! "mathgroup " <fizzymath@knology.net> - 2013-05-24 09:28 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Murray Eisenberg <murray@math.umass.edu> - 2013-05-24 09:23 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! "djmpark" <djmpark@comcast.net> - 2013-05-24 09:26 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2013-05-25 09:34 +0000
      Warsaw Univ. course,  was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-05-26 08:38 +0000
      more problems in Warsaw plan? Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-05-26 08:36 +0000
      Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! David Bailey <dave@removedbailey.co.uk> - 2013-05-28 07:47 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! John Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com> - 2013-05-27 08:21 +0000
      Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! David Bailey <dave@removedbailey.co.uk> - 2013-06-02 04:24 +0000
    Re: Warsaw Univ. course,  was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! John Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com> - 2013-05-27 08:21 +0000
      Re: Warsaw Univ. course,  was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-05-28 07:49 +0000
        Re: Warsaw Univ. course,  was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! David Bailey <dave@removedbailey.co.uk> - 2013-05-31 07:19 +0000
          Re: Warsaw Univ. course,  was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-06-01 10:06 +0000
            Re: Warsaw Univ. course,  was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! David Bailey <dave@removedbailey.co.uk> - 2013-06-02 04:22 +0000
              Re: Warsaw Univ. course,  was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-06-03 07:25 +0000
                Re: Warsaw Univ. course,  was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! David Bailey <dave@removedbailey.co.uk> - 2013-06-04 03:14 +0000
                Re: Warsaw Univ. course,  was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2013-06-04 09:59 +0000
          Re: Warsaw Univ. course, was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Richard Fateman <fateman@eecs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-06-04 03:15 +0000
    Re: Warsaw Univ. course,  was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Ingolf Dahl <ingolf.dahl@telia.com> - 2013-05-27 08:21 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! fd <fdimer@gmail.com> - 2013-05-28 07:46 +0000
      Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! David Bailey <dave@removedbailey.co.uk> - 2013-05-31 07:19 +0000
    Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! fd <felipe.dimer-de-oliveira@mq.edu.au> - 2013-05-28 07:47 +0000
    Re: Warsaw Univ. course,  was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! fd <fdimer@gmail.com> - 2013-05-29 07:47 +0000
    Re: Warsaw Univ. course,  was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2013-05-29 07:48 +0000
    Re: Warsaw Univ. course,  was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! János Löbb <janos@lobb.com> - 2013-05-30 10:07 +0000
      Re: Warsaw Univ. course,  was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! "Nasser M. Abbasi" <nma@12000.org> - 2013-05-31 07:15 +0000
    Re: Warsaw Univ. course,  was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen! Murray Eisenberg <murray@math.umass.edu> - 2013-05-30 10:08 +0000
    Applying Mathematica to practical problems John Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com> - 2013-05-30 10:09 +0000
      Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-05-31 07:15 +0000
      Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems "Kevin J. McCann" <kjm@KevinMcCann.com> - 2013-05-31 07:18 +0000
    Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2013-05-31 07:16 +0000
      Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-06-01 10:07 +0000
      Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-06-01 10:07 +0000
      Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2013-06-02 04:23 +0000
        Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-06-03 07:24 +0000
        Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2013-06-04 03:11 +0000
        Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2013-06-04 03:11 +0000
        Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems Richard Fateman <fateman@eecs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-06-04 03:10 +0000
        Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2013-06-04 03:11 +0000
        Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2013-06-04 03:13 +0000
    Mathematica numerics and... Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems Daniel Lichtblau <danl@wolfram.com> - 2013-06-01 10:06 +0000
      Interval vs default,  was Re: Mathematica numerics and... Re: Applying Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-06-02 04:24 +0000
    Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2013-06-02 04:23 +0000
    Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems James Stein <mathgroup@stein.org> - 2013-06-02 04:26 +0000
    Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems Mark McClure <mcmcclur@unca.edu> - 2013-06-02 04:23 +0000
      Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-06-03 07:25 +0000
      Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems Joe Gwinn <joegwinn@comcast.net> - 2013-06-03 07:26 +0000
    Re: Applying Mathematica to practical problems Waclaw Kusnierczyk <waku@idi.ntnu.no> - 2013-06-03 07:24 +0000
    Re: Warsaw Univ. course, was Re: Work on Basic Leonid Shifrin <lshifr@gmail.com> - 2013-06-04 03:12 +0000
    Re: Warsaw Univ. course, was Re: Work on Basic Leonid Shifrin <lshifr@gmail.com> - 2013-06-04 03:13 +0000
    Re: Interval vs default, was Re: Mathematica numerics and... Re: Applying Daniel Lichtblau <danl@wolfram.com> - 2013-06-04 03:14 +0000

Page 2 of 5 — ← Prev page 1 [2] 3 4 5  Next page →


#14549

From"Ernst H.K. Stelzer" <ernst.stelzer@physikalischebiologie.de>
Date2013-05-20 09:03 +0000
Message-ID<kncosq$n2b$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14471
This is a very good suggestion.  Stackexchange addresses this issue to a certain extent, particulalrly when questioneers and answerees continue to edit their questions/answers and point to the most complete answer.  However, the editors are very sensitive to to simply providing the code for a reasonable problem if it is not phrased as a question, which I appreciate and do not wish to discuss here.

Whenever I find interesting code here on mathgroup or on Stackexchange I copy it into one of my MathGroupTippsAndTricks notebooks and make sure it is in a format I will understand months or years later.  However, this concept fails once the notebooks contain too many dynamic entries and become excessively large.

I have also started to write more complete packages (.m) with comments and full names.  But how do I share them with the community?

There are also many sites for C-programmers looking for snippets of various kinds, but I have yet to come across one that can be searched ...

I agree with Paul, sharing notebooks, functions and code-snippets is a very serious task where Wolfram has to make an effort and either do it themselves or via supporting the community and where a good search functionality is absolutely essential.  The demonstrations project is by no means sufficient, particulalrly since it does not allow code that imports and exports data.

Sincerely

     Ernst

(possibly quite short, since sent via Outlook Web Access)

Prof. Dr. Ernst H.K. Stelzer
Physikalische Biologie/Physical Biology (FB 15, IZN)
Buchmann Institute for Molecular Life Sciences (BMLS)
Centre of Excellence Macromeolecular Complexes (CEF-MC)
Goethe Universit=E4t Frankfurt am Main (Campus Riedberg)
Max-von-Laue Stra=DFe 15
D-60438 Frankfurt am Main, Germany

http://www.bmls.de http://www.uni-frankfurt.de
http://www.researcherid.com/rid/A-7648-2011
http://www.physikalischebiologie.de
________________________________________
From: paulmchale7@gmail.com [paulmchale7@gmail.com]
Sent: 19 May 2013 11:51
Subject: Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!

Another "missing item" is toolbox.wolfram.com.  There are many functions people write that would be amazing useful to others but will never be shared. I have shared some potential toolbox entries here like a function that receives evenly spaced time/data pairs and returns FFT in terms of Hz.  Handy to have laying around.  I started a Toolbox.nb that I refer to often.  It would be great to have an "open source" sharing mechanism to have the community support each other.  Some of the things in my toolbox:

1. Cool graphing functions with very simple legends
2. Canned functions for unique file formats
3. Easier ways to measure time than Timing[]
4. Database access routines
5. Initialization stuff
6. Functions to communicate over Ethernet
7. Functions to talk to external COTS test equipment

It would be cool to have a community place to store and share this stuff.  Like a sourceforge model for Mathematica.  Peer reviewed notebooks or external applications to extend Mathematica.

Any chance of this?

Thanks,
paul

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14552

FromIngolf Dahl <ingolf.dahl@telia.com>
Date2013-05-20 09:03 +0000
Message-ID<kncote$n2m$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14471
Paul, have you checked http://library.wolfram.com/? There you could submit
your toolboxes. If you put your tools somewhere else, e.g. on your own web
page, you might post a link at 
http://www.mathematica-users.org/webMathematica/wiki/wiki.jsp?pageName=Links
, 
or if you have a whole "Application package" to advertise, you might
announce it at 
http://www.mathematica-users.org/webMathematica/wiki/wiki.jsp?pageName=Packa
ges . 
On my computer, I have during the years collected around 75 such packages
from different contributors. 

Best regards

Ingolf Dahl
Sweden

> -----Original Message-----
> From: paulmchale7@gmail.com [mailto:paulmchale7@gmail.com]
> Sent: den 19 maj 2013 11:51
> To: mathgroup@smc.vnet.net
> Subject: Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!
> 
> Another "missing item" is toolbox.wolfram.com.  There are many functions
people write that
> would be amazing useful to others but will never be shared.  I have shared
some potential
> toolbox entries here like a function that receives evenly spaced time/data
pairs and returns
> FFT in terms of Hz.  Handy to have laying around.  I started a Toolbox.nb
that I refer to
> often.  It would be great to have an "open source" sharing mechanism to
have the
> community support each other.  Some of the things in my toolbox:
> 
> 1. Cool graphing functions with very simple legends 2. Canned functions
for unique file
> formats 3. Easier ways to measure time than Timing[] 4. Database access
routines 5.
> Initialization stuff 6. Functions to communicate over Ethernet 7.
Functions to talk to
> external COTS test equipment
> 
> It would be cool to have a community place to store and share this stuff.
Like a sourceforge
> model for Mathematica.  Peer reviewed notebooks or external applications
to extend
> Mathematica.
> 
> Any chance of this?
> 
> Thanks,
> paul


[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14554

FromDavid Annetts <david.annetts@iinet.net.au>
Date2013-05-20 09:03 +0000
Message-ID<kncos6$n20$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14471
Hi Paul,

Before WRI went off on their demonstrations trip (...), there was 
MathSource.  Remanents are here : http://library.wolfram.com/.

D.

On 19/05/2013 17:51, paulmchale7@gmail.com wrote:
> Another "missing item" is toolbox.wolfram.com.  There are many functions people write that would be amazing useful to others but will never be shared.  I have shared some potential toolbox entries here like a function that receives evenly spaced time/data pairs and returns FFT in terms of Hz.  Handy to have laying around.  I started a Toolbox.nb that I refer to often.  It would be great to have an "open source" sharing mechanism to have the community support each other.  Some of the things in my toolbox:
>
> 1. Cool graphing functions with very simple legends
> 2. Canned functions for unique file formats
> 3. Easier ways to measure time than Timing[]
> 4. Database access routines
> 5. Initialization stuff
> 6. Functions to communicate over Ethernet
> 7. Functions to talk to external COTS test equipment
>
> It would be cool to have a community place to store and share this stuff.  Like a sourceforge model for Mathematica.  Peer reviewed notebooks or external applications to extend Mathematica.
>
> Any chance of this?
>
> Thanks,
> paul
>

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14570

From"mathgroup " <fizzymath@knology.net>
Date2013-05-22 06:18 +0000
Message-ID<knhnvd$9k6$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14471
I want to comment on my experience , limited of course, with  students of
Engineering, Engineers and Professors of Engineering.....my background is
Physics...

First,  I get the impression that , in the main, Symbolic Computation, etc.
is not something they are really interested in......After I retired, I took
several courses in Electromagnetics, one Graduate and the other
Undergraduate......No one suggested the use of or taught the potential
applications of Mathematica....Even in the Graduate course, I was the only
student using Symbolic software ......in fact, the students did everything
by hand and whenever something required software, such as Antenna patterns,
out came M-------b with some code , etc....and that was the end of it....So,
the students knew no better....and the Professors didn’t care or werent
interested themselves in the benefits of learning and solving problems
Symbolically....I asked one Professor if I could give a class lecture on the
use of Mathematica for Electromagnetics...He agreed but than said   'I can
only give you about ten minutes'....I respectfully declined the offer....

So, how does WRI expand its market?....IMO, there have to be dedicated
Teachers on how to use Mathematica in what I'll call the Research Mode not
just define given functions from the text and plot it.......from what I have
seen of the attitude of Instructors and Professors I'm anything but
Optimistic....I went to our local Colleges and suggested a sequence of
courses in Mathematica  ending with Animation and Simulation....That got me
nowhere especially with the Math Depts...so, in part, I see people who are
stuck in pencil and paper and refuse to get out of it....

Again, of course, this is my limited experience...Perhaps others have had
different and better ones...

Jerry Blimbaum



-----Original Message----- 
From: paulmchale7@gmail.com
Sent: Sunday, May 19, 2013 4:50 AM
Subject: Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!

I have (maybe) a minority perspective on Mathematica being an engineer.  I
used it long ago at university at version 1.  The next time I would use it
would be a wolfram approved ebay purchase of version 4.  I have used it ever
since, but am still rookie in some ways.

I believe WRI is attempting to broaden the user base rather than deepen the
product.  They are doing this by adding (from our perspective) non-value add
features to lure people in.  The argument is the learning curve is less
which should lead to greater sales.  This is not how it works at any place I
have been.

The only engineering sales force that matters is engineers.  If they can't
argue for the product, it will not happen.  Engineers can't argue for
something they are unable use until after purchase and additional training.
If you want engineers to demonstrate something or argue for it, you have to
do more than offer wizards and connections to WolframAlpha which only apply
after the sale.  Engineers need to show understanding and capability.
Managers have to show accounting they are saving money by buying
Mathematica.  Improvements in quality of OUR products or ability to address
greater problems is not quantifiable to the brigade of MBAs who run modern
businesses.  There has to be quantifiable savings.  This has to be
demonstrated by engineering staff before purchase and framed in terms of
reduced need for time (salary expense).

I think this can only be achieved by making the online education material
targeted to a specific audience.  This material must solve real problems in
a way that conveys the underlying capability.

I have been told by WRI that most users will only use 5% (at most) of
Mathematicas total ability.  LoL, if only everyone would use the same 5%.

If you want us to be able to sell it, you have to provide training for free
so we can get started solving engineering problems prior to purchase.
Combine this with a 60 day trial and you could save a lot of WRI development
dollars on bells and whistles that won't increase sales. Help us help you!
Stop trying to treat sales tools as a profit center! 

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14584 — expanding the use of symbolic computation in engineering .. was Re:

FromRichard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu>
Date2013-05-23 07:51 +0000
Subjectexpanding the use of symbolic computation in engineering .. was Re:
Message-ID<knkhqr$icv$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14570
On 5/21/2013 11:18 PM, mathgroup wrote:
> I want to comment on my experience , limited of course, with  students of
> Engineering, Engineers and Professors of Engineering.....my background is
> Physics...
>
> First,  I get the impression that , in the main, Symbolic Computation, etc.
> is not something they are really interested in...
...
> Again, of course, this is my limited experience...Perhaps others have had
> different and better ones...
>
> Jerry Blimbaum
>
>

I think your experience is typical, and that the "sweet spot" for 
engineering computation is not in symbolic computation nor Mathematica
in particular. Certainly educators don't view symbolic computation
as key to any particular course that is in the core curriculum. See
for example...

my own institution, University of California at Berkeley describes the
curriculum here:
http://coe.berkeley.edu/students/current-undergraduates/handouts-and-items-for-main-page/2011-12%20Announcement.pdf

no mention of Mathematica, though a numeric program is mentioned
in the TITLE of one course on computer programming.

Searching through the whole ME web site reveals that a few courses
allow that proficiency in some programming language, which could be
in Mathematica, is recommended or required. Proficiency in Mathematica
as a job skill... uh, monster.com lists 19 jobs with a keyword of
Mathematica.  at least 6 of them are at Mathematica Policy Research,
unrelated to the program.  Over 1000 for some others.

Usually the "killer app" for computer algebra is thought to be something 
related to education or perhaps testing.  There are too
few actual "mathematical researchers" to make much of a market.

So one strategy for WRI is to make Mathematica competitive in areas
that have little or nothing to do with symbolic computation. And
that is what it is doing.

Web design and service
Knowledge, uh, stuff. Data base
Graphics, animation, games,
Numerics, statistics, traditional application packages (e.g. signals,
materials, control...)
Business "analytics"


So all you people who say that SW should buckle down and do
the symbolic math right  (or do the arbitrary precision
arithmetic or intervals or other fundamentals right).

yeah, you can ask for that, but don't hold your breath. WRI
is a commercial operation.

RJF






[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14601 — Re: expanding the use of symbolic computation in engineering .. was Re:

FromW Craig Carter <ccarter@MIT.EDU>
Date2013-05-24 09:23 +0000
SubjectRe: expanding the use of symbolic computation in engineering .. was Re:
Message-ID<knnbir$qpj$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14570
I can only comment about my experience as well, but I beg to differ.

I believe my Mathematica-intensive sophomore course for materials 
scientists has resulted in Mathematica as being the tool of choice for 
the remainder of a student's undergraduate education---and know of many 
cases where students continue to use Mathematica as a tool for graduate 
research and private sector careers.

I've been teaching this course for about 12 years and have won MIT's 
institute-wide teaching award and the school of engineering teaching 
award; both awards derive primarily from the results of this course.

I only have student accounts and letters, and off-hand comments from 
other faculty about the benefits of my course; these are uniformly 
positive but the sample is probably biased. I am hoping to get an 
objective critical assessment of the educational benefits of this 
course---resources to get assessment are rare.

Helen Read and Murray Eisenberg, I believe, also teach  successful 
Mathematica-Intensive courses; they may have obtained objective 
assessment.

W Craig Carter
Professor of Materials Science, MIT



On May 23, 13, at 4:06 AM, Richard Fateman wrote:

> On 5/21/2013 11:18 PM, mathgroup wrote:
>> I want to comment on my experience , limited of course, with  students of
>> Engineering, Engineers and Professors of Engineering.....my background is
>> Physics...
>>
>> First,  I get the impression that , in the main, Symbolic Computation, etc.
>> is not something they are really interested in...
> ...
>> Again, of course, this is my limited experience...Perhaps others have had
>> different and better ones...
>>
>> Jerry Blimbaum
>>
>>
>
> I think your experience is typical, and that the "sweet spot" for
> engineering computation is not in symbolic computation nor Mathematica
> in particular. Certainly educators don't view symbolic computation
> as key to any particular course that is in the core curriculum. See
> for example...


[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14593

From"djmpark" <djmpark@comcast.net>
Date2013-05-23 07:54 +0000
Message-ID<knkhvt$ids$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14471
It will be done by example. Several people will work together, 
exchanging Mathematica notebooks or working on a common notebook. The 
notebooks will be what I call "literate"; they will look something like 
a technical paper or report, but they will take advantage of all the 
active and dynamic features of Mathematica, and contain generated 
knowledge in the form of active and immediately accessible routines and 
definitions developed in the course of the effort.

The notebooks will be of higher integrity than paper and pencil work, or 
using Mathematica as a programmed calculator and copying out because of 
all the self-proofing and additional checks that can be performed. (Of 
course, one can still make errors but they should be rarer and not the 
common variety.)

That all this can be done in a single application is a tremendous 
advantage.

Someday other people will see what they are doing and the advantages are 
so great they will want to do the same thing. The task is getting more 
people to write and use good examples.


David Park
djmpark@comcast.net
http://home.comcast.net/~djmpark/index.html




From: mathgroup [mailto:fizzymath@knology.net]

I want to comment on my experience , limited of course, with  students of Engineering, Engineers and Professors of Engineering.....my background is Physics...

First,  I get the impression that , in the main, Symbolic Computation, etc.
is not something they are really interested in......After I retired, I took several courses in Electromagnetics, one Graduate and the other Undergraduate......No one suggested the use of or taught the potential applications of Mathematica....Even in the Graduate course, I was the only student using Symbolic software ......in fact, the students did everything by hand and whenever something required software, such as Antenna patterns, out came M-------b with some code , etc....and that was the end of it....So, the students knew no better....and the Professors didnC3=A2=E2=82=AC=E2=84=A2t care or werent interested themselves in the benefits of learning and solving problems Symbolically....I asked one Professor if I could give a class lecture on the
use of Mathematica for Electromagnetics...He agreed but than said   'I can
only give you about ten minutes'....I respectfully declined the offer....

So, how does WRI expand its market?....IMO, there have to be dedicated Teachers on how to use Mathematica in what I'll call the Research Mode not just define given functions from the text and plot it.......from what I have seen of the attitude of Instructors and Professors I'm anything but Optimistic....I went to our local Colleges and suggested a sequence of courses in Mathematica  ending with Animation and Simulation....That got me nowhere especially with the Math Depts...so, in part, I see people who are stuck in pencil and paper and refuse to get out of it....

Again, of course, this is my limited experience...Perhaps others have had different and better ones...

Jerry Blimbaum



-----Original Message-----
From: paulmchale7@gmail.com
Sent: Sunday, May 19, 2013 4:50 AM
Subject: Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!

I have (maybe) a minority perspective on Mathematica being an engineer.  I used it long ago at university at version 1.  The next time I would use it would be a wolfram approved ebay purchase of version 4.  I have used it ever since, but am still rookie in some ways.

I believe WRI is attempting to broaden the user base rather than deepen the product.  They are doing this by adding (from our perspective) non-value add features to lure people in.  The argument is the learning curve is less which should lead to greater sales.  This is not how it works at any place I have been.

The only engineering sales force that matters is engineers.  If they can't argue for the product, it will not happen.  Engineers can't argue for something they are unable use until after purchase and additional training.
If you want engineers to demonstrate something or argue for it, you have to do more than offer wizards and connections to WolframAlpha which only apply after the sale.  Engineers need to show understanding and capability.
Managers have to show accounting they are saving money by buying Mathematica.  Improvements in quality of OUR products or ability to address greater problems is not quantifiable to the brigade of MBAs who run modern businesses.  There has to be quantifiable savings.  This has to be demonstrated by engineering staff before purchase and framed in terms of reduced need for time (salary expense).

I think this can only be achieved by making the online education material targeted to a specific audience.  This material must solve real problems in a way that conveys the underlying capability.

I have been told by WRI that most users will only use 5% (at most) of Mathematicas total ability.  LoL, if only everyone would use the same 5%.

If you want us to be able to sell it, you have to provide training for free so we can get started solving engineering problems prior to purchase.
Combine this with a 60 day trial and you could save a lot of WRI development dollars on bells and whistles that won't increase sales. Help us help you!
Stop trying to treat sales tools as a profit center!


[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14598

From"mathgroup " <fizzymath@knology.net>
Date2013-05-23 07:56 +0000
Message-ID<knki33$if1$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14471
David...

But that was exactly my point...I tried so hard with our Community College 
and University to get Mathematica into the curriculum....or, as I said, to 
give some lectures and examples on the use of Mathematica....and ALL of 
them,  Engineering, Math and Physics Depts said  'Thanks but No Thanks', as 
if they have something against Mathematica....It seemed that the idea that 
students would not use pencil and paper in as laborious a manner as possible 
really bothered them....Not once did they think perhaps this might lead to a 
real enjoyment of technical subjects and perhaps to much better 
understanding of their course work......even when I was working I was 
affectionately known as 'The Mathematica Nut'...although, I'm reminded of 
something that Nietzsche said....

"Overzealousness on the part of one person can lead the others to 
Apostasy".....

jerry blimbaum

-----Original Message----- 
From: djmpark
Sent: Wednesday, May 22, 2013 9:28 AM
To: 'mathgroup ' ; mathgroup@smc.vnet.net
Subject: Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!

It will be done by example. Several people will work together, exchanging 
Mathematica notebooks or working on a common notebook. The notebooks will be 
what I call "literate"; they will look something like a technical paper or 
report, but they will take advantage of all the active and dynamic features 
of Mathematica, and contain generated knowledge in the form of active and 
immediately accessible routines and definitions developed in the course of 
the effort.

The notebooks will be of higher integrity than paper and pencil work, or 
using Mathematica as a programmed calculator and copying out because of all 
the self-proofing and additional checks that can be performed. (Of course, 
one can still make errors but they should be rarer and not the common 
variety.)

That all this can be done in a single application is a tremendous advantage.

Someday other people will see what they are doing and the advantages are so 
great they will want to do the same thing. The task is getting more people 
to write and use good examples.


David Park
djmpark@comcast.net
http://home.comcast.net/~djmpark/index.html




From: mathgroup [mailto:fizzymath@knology.net]

I want to comment on my experience , limited of course, with  students of 
Engineering, Engineers and Professors of Engineering.....my background is 
Physics...

First,  I get the impression that , in the main, Symbolic Computation, etc.
is not something they are really interested in......After I retired, I took 
several courses in Electromagnetics, one Graduate and the other 
Undergraduate......No one suggested the use of or taught the potential 
applications of Mathematica....Even in the Graduate course, I was the only 
student using Symbolic software ......in fact, the students did everything 
by hand and whenever something required software, such as Antenna patterns, 
out came M-------b with some code , etc....and that was the end of it....So, 
the students knew no better....and the Professors didn’t care or werent 
interested themselves in the benefits of learning and solving problems 
Symbolically....I asked one Professor if I could give a class lecture on the
use of Mathematica for Electromagnetics...He agreed but than said   'I can
only give you about ten minutes'....I respectfully declined the offer....

So, how does WRI expand its market?....IMO, there have to be dedicated 
Teachers on how to use Mathematica in what I'll call the Research Mode not 
just define given functions from the text and plot it.......from what I have 
seen of the attitude of Instructors and Professors I'm anything but 
Optimistic....I went to our local Colleges and suggested a sequence of 
courses in Mathematica  ending with Animation and Simulation....That got me 
nowhere especially with the Math Depts...so, in part, I see people who are 
stuck in pencil and paper and refuse to get out of it....

Again, of course, this is my limited experience...Perhaps others have had 
different and better ones...

Jerry Blimbaum



-----Original Message-----
From: paulmchale7@gmail.com
Sent: Sunday, May 19, 2013 4:50 AM
Subject: Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!

I have (maybe) a minority perspective on Mathematica being an engineer.  I 
used it long ago at university at version 1.  The next time I would use it 
would be a wolfram approved ebay purchase of version 4.  I have used it ever 
since, but am still rookie in some ways.

I believe WRI is attempting to broaden the user base rather than deepen the 
product.  They are doing this by adding (from our perspective) non-value add 
features to lure people in.  The argument is the learning curve is less 
which should lead to greater sales.  This is not how it works at any place I 
have been.

The only engineering sales force that matters is engineers.  If they can't 
argue for the product, it will not happen.  Engineers can't argue for 
something they are unable use until after purchase and additional training.
If you want engineers to demonstrate something or argue for it, you have to 
do more than offer wizards and connections to WolframAlpha which only apply 
after the sale.  Engineers need to show understanding and capability.
Managers have to show accounting they are saving money by buying 
Mathematica.  Improvements in quality of OUR products or ability to address 
greater problems is not quantifiable to the brigade of MBAs who run modern 
businesses.  There has to be quantifiable savings.  This has to be 
demonstrated by engineering staff before purchase and framed in terms of 
reduced need for time (salary expense).

I think this can only be achieved by making the online education material 
targeted to a specific audience.  This material must solve real problems in 
a way that conveys the underlying capability.

I have been told by WRI that most users will only use 5% (at most) of 
Mathematicas total ability.  LoL, if only everyone would use the same 5%.

If you want us to be able to sell it, you have to provide training for free 
so we can get started solving engineering problems prior to purchase.
Combine this with a 60 day trial and you could save a lot of WRI development 
dollars on bells and whistles that won't increase sales. Help us help you!
Stop trying to treat sales tools as a profit center!

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14609

FromRichard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu>
Date2013-05-24 09:27 +0000
Message-ID<knnbp8$qql$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14598
On 5/23/2013 12:56 AM, mathgroup wrote:
> David...
>
> But that was exactly my point...I tried so hard with our Community College
> and University to get Mathematica into the curriculum....or, as I said, to
> give some lectures and examples on the use of Mathematica....and ALL of
> them,  Engineering, Math and Physics Depts said  'Thanks but No Thanks', as
> if they have something against Mathematica....It seemed that the idea that
> students would not use pencil and paper in as laborious a manner as possible
> really bothered them....Not once did they think perhaps this might lead to a
> real enjoyment of technical subjects and perhaps to much better
> understanding of their course work......even when I was working I was
> affectionately known as 'The Mathematica Nut'...although, I'm reminded of
> something that Nietzsche said....

People are naturally interested in optimizing their jobs.
Teachers don't want to change their courses, learn new things, make hard 
decisions like what to REMOVE from the course to make
space for Mathematica, or deal with Nuts.

  If a teacher is shown a program that does the same thing as what he 
(or she) teaches, it strongly suggests that it is not worth teaching.
Also it strongly
suggests to the student that it is not worth learning.

Regarding djmpark's vision.. do we believe that notebooks based on 
Mathematica will have higher integrity?  Possibly lower, at
least to the extent that the author is explicitly dependent on 
Mathematica, bugs and all, rather than clear presentation that can
be understood and read by other humans.  Would you believe a theorem
that was "proved" by Mathematica using methods that you could not
understand and might in fact be secret as well as erroneous?

A traditional presentation could implicitly be based on Mathematica or
other computer programs, but would have to be refined and endorsed
by humans.

Or it could be done entirely by hand. The background might
contain an alternative "proof by computer"  or "data files / method to
reproduce results".  Or the background and foreground could be 
interleaved as literate programming.  Evidence to date is that most
programmers are unable to write correct code most of the time.
Demanding that they write literate code is a step beyond correct.

Incidentally, fostering a library of free contributed code has
difficulties.

  Most code contributed by users is poor.  Even if it works for
the particular application that prompted the user to program it, it
is unlikely to be general, bug-free, efficient, etc.   Most users
are poor programmers.

Also, why should it be free?  Should Wolfram be the only person to 
profit from the sale of programs?

>

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14629

From"djmpark" <djmpark@comcast.net>
Date2013-05-25 09:35 +0000
Message-ID<knq0km$5a4$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14598
Yes, I believe if Mathematica notebooks are written using reasonable
procedures they will definitely have higher integrity. Hand written or
transcribed documents contain significant levels of error and omission. V.I.
Arnold wrote: "Every working mathematician knows that if one does not
control oneself (best of all by examples), then after some ten pages half of
all the signs in formulae will be wrong and twos will find their way from
denominators into numerators." I believe that Stephen Wolfram wrote
something in the Mathematica Book to the effect that when you do things by
hand you can be sloppy and fix things up as you go along but with
Mathematica you have to be precise and complete from the start. For those of
us not as quick minded as Stephen maybe the sloppiness never does get fixed
up. That's one of the advantages of Mathematica, but perhaps not the most
important advantage.

In explaining methods or presenting proofs or derivations to a reader or
student it IS very useful to be precise and complete from the start. Does
the reader know what the objects are that the discussion is about? Does he
have any experience with them? There are zillions of cases where Mathematica
could be used to generate object examples and present them in various ways
before we started reasoning about them. I'm certain that mathematicians
usually work with concrete examples and become quite familiar with them
before they transcend them for abstract proofs. Suppose you want to teach
contraction of concrete tensor arrays. In the books you will seldom see
examples beyond a couple of matrices, or maybe rarely a 3rd order tensor in
two or three dimensions. They take too much space. What good is an example
if it runs over two or three printed pages? With Mathematica one can easily
generate and manipulate such examples. One could extract or highlight
particular parts of an array to clarify operations. One could do various
examples, which one might eschew in a written document because of the space
requirement. And of course these kind of things are particularly susceptible
to copying and misprint errors.

Does the reader know what the starting point is? Does he know clearly what
is given? Does he know the axioms and tools he can use in doing
calculations, derivations or proofs? Could the reader bring up the axioms in
a separate window to inspect them when needed? Does he have them in an
active form so he could apply them to expressions or see them applied by the
writer?

The criterion for a reasonable procedure for writing notebooks for the
purpose of conveying information to another person is: CALCULATE EVERYTHING.
Do not do calculation by word processing. This requires a hierarchical depth
in your routines. (How much hierarchical depth? Enough to do the job.) You
must be able to work at the various levels of calculation needed in
understanding the material. Mathematica does not always, or even often,
provide hierarchical depth. The Mathematica Integrate routine is a poor tool
if you are teaching integration techniques to calculus students.
Nevertheless, Mathematica has the facilities for providing hierarchical
depth where needed - so just do it. 

Mathematica notebooks are better because material can be presented in
understandable steps, with annotation and explanation, and since everything
is calculated and the results presented in various forms, there is a great
deal of self-proofing in the document. Also active routines are provided for
the reader to provide additional checks.

That is higher integrity.


David Park
djmpark@comcast.net 
http://home.comcast.net/~djmpark/index.html 







From: Richard Fateman [mailto:fateman@cs.berkeley.edu] 

Regarding djmpark's vision.. do we believe that notebooks based on
Mathematica will have higher integrity?  Possibly lower, at least to the
extent that the author is explicitly dependent on Mathematica, bugs and all,
rather than clear presentation that can be understood and read by other
humans.  Would you believe a theorem that was "proved" by Mathematica using
methods that you could not understand and might in fact be secret as well as
erroneous?

A traditional presentation could implicitly be based on Mathematica or other
computer programs, but would have to be refined and endorsed by humans.

Or it could be done entirely by hand. The background might contain an
alternative "proof by computer"  or "data files / method to reproduce
results".  Or the background and foreground could be interleaved as literate
programming.  Evidence to date is that most programmers are unable to write
correct code most of the time.
Demanding that they write literate code is a step beyond correct.


[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14630

FromRichard Fateman <fateman@eecs.berkeley.edu>
Date2013-05-25 09:35 +0000
Message-ID<knq0la$5a8$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14598
On 5/24/2013 10:07 AM, djmpark wrote:
> Yes, I believe if Mathematica notebooks are written using reasonable
> procedures they will definitely have higher integrity
<snip>
>   That's one of the advantages of Mathematica, but perhaps not the most
> important advantage.
there is an interesting and controversial article by  Demillo and Lipton 
on Social
Processes and Proofs.. easily found on the web, but also see the 
rejoinders etc.

Can you imagine the reception of you running down the hall to show your 
academic colleagues or co-researchers your "proof by Mathematica"?

(note: not "result from Mathematica"  but proof.)

Personally I would especially hesitate to believe any numerical result 
that was not entirely done by computation in integers.

I have no particular issue with an appendix, carefully annotated etc 
that allows one to reproduce a computation.  Mathematica's rule-based paradigm might be less readable than some other schemes.

RJF

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14631

From"djmpark" <djmpark@comcast.net>
Date2013-05-25 09:35 +0000
Message-ID<knq0lu$5aa$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14598
I didn't say anything at all about a "proof by Mathematica". Mathematica is
just a writing and communication medium and it's far better and has higher
integrity than anything you know how to use.

David Park
djmpark@comcast.net 
http://home.comcast.net/~djmpark/index.html 


From: Richard Fateman [mailto:fateman@eecs.berkeley.edu] 


On 5/24/2013 10:07 AM, djmpark wrote:
> Yes, I believe if Mathematica notebooks are written using reasonable 
> procedures they will definitely have higher integrity
<snip>
>   That's one of the advantages of Mathematica, but perhaps not the 
> most important advantage.
there is an interesting and controversial article by  Demillo and Lipton on
Social Processes and Proofs.. easily found on the web, but also see the
rejoinders etc.

Can you imagine the reception of you running down the hall to show your
academic colleagues or co-researchers your "proof by Mathematica"?

(note: not "result from Mathematica"  but proof.)

Personally I would especially hesitate to believe any numerical result that
was not entirely done by computation in integers.

I have no particular issue with an appendix, carefully annotated etc that
allows one to reproduce a computation.  Mathematica's rule-based paradigm
might be less readable than some other schemes.

RJF

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14614

From"mathgroup " <fizzymath@knology.net>
Date2013-05-24 09:28 +0000
Message-ID<knnbsf$qr3$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14471
I had to chuckle at your use of the word 'conceal'.....unfortunately, I 
agree with your comment....mentioning Mathematica seems akin to 
treason.....that was the reaction I felt...


jb


-----Original Message----- 
From: Murray Eisenberg
Sent: Thursday, May 23, 2013 10:00 AM
To: mathgroup
Subject: Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!

This is not an uncommon situation at colleges and universities.

Too many of the old fogies -- and, more dangerously, the "young fogies" --  
know about Ma. . t. .b and cannot imagine why anybody who needs to do 
computing would use anything else. After all, it was good enough for them. 
(Exception: Canadians who thing the same about M . . . e.)

Similarly, too many mathematicians cannot see why their students should not 
learn how to carry out long and complex symbolic calculations, e.g., 
symbolic integration, with paper and pencil; after all, they had to do it. 
Oddly enough, some of these same mathematicians use powerful symbolic 
programs to do their own research in number theory, algebraic geometry, etc.

But I'm sympathetic to the view that there shouldn't be a course in a 
mathematics department on Mathematica per se. Just as there shouldn't be a 
course there in LaTeX per se. Just as Computer Science departments say they 
don't have a course in any programming language.

So if one is to make any headway, then one has to almost conceal the 
Mathematica within a mathematics course whose subject is some mathematical 
topics, or an engineering course whose subject is some engineering topic, 
etc. Just as, e.g., in some "junior year writing" courses taught by math 
departments, LaTeX is introduced and students have to do some or all of 
their papers in LaTeX. Or a mathematics department course in complex 
analysis where small teams of students do projects presenting some topic via 
a Mathematica notebook (where a couple of the projects might be teaching 
some Mathematica basics).

Perhaps this "sneaky" way is not the most efficient way for teaching and 
learning Mathematica, but it can work. In fact, Stephen Wolfram wrote in 
"The Mathematica Book" some years ago that, after learning a few basics and 
trying some simple examples from the book (today, the Documentation Center), 
"You will probably find it best to start by picking a specific problem to 
work on. Pick a problem that you understand well. . . Then go through each 
step in solving the problem, learning what you need to know about 
Mathematica to do it."


On May 23, 2013, at 4:10 AM, mathgroup <fizzymath@knology.net> wrote:

> David...
>
> But that was exactly my point...I tried so hard with our Community College
> and University to get Mathematica into the curriculum....or, as I said, to
> give some lectures and examples on the use of Mathematica....and ALL of
> them,  Engineering, Math and Physics Depts said  'Thanks but No Thanks', 
> as
> if they have something against Mathematica....It seemed that the idea that
> students would not use pencil and paper in as laborious a manner as 
> possible
> really bothered them....Not once did they think perhaps this might lead to 
> a
> real enjoyment of technical subjects and perhaps to much better
> understanding of their course work......even when I was working I was
> affectionately known as 'The Mathematica Nut'...although, I'm reminded of
> something that Nietzsche said....
>
> "Overzealousness on the part of one person can lead the others to
> Apostasy".....
>
> jerry blimbaum
>
> -----Original Message----- 
> From: djmpark
> Sent: Wednesday, May 22, 2013 9:28 AM
> To: 'mathgroup ' ; mathgroup@smc.vnet.net
> Subject: Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!
>
> It will be done by example. Several people will work together, exchanging
> Mathematica notebooks or working on a common notebook. The notebooks will 
> be
> what I call "literate"; they will look something like a technical paper or
> report, but they will take advantage of all the active and dynamic 
> features
> of Mathematica, and contain generated knowledge in the form of active and
> immediately accessible routines and definitions developed in the course of
> the effort.
>
> The notebooks will be of higher integrity than paper and pencil work, or
> using Mathematica as a programmed calculator and copying out because of 
> all
> the self-proofing and additional checks that can be performed. (Of course,
> one can still make errors but they should be rarer and not the common
> variety.)
>
> That all this can be done in a single application is a tremendous 
> advantage.
>
> Someday other people will see what they are doing and the advantages are 
> so
> great they will want to do the same thing. The task is getting more people
> to write and use good examples.
>
>
> David Park
> djmpark@comcast.net
> http://home.comcast.net/~djmpark/index.html
>
>
>
>
> From: mathgroup [mailto:fizzymath@knology.net]
>
> I want to comment on my experience , limited of course, with  students of
> Engineering, Engineers and Professors of Engineering.....my background is
> Physics...
>
> First,  I get the impression that , in the main, Symbolic Computation, 
> etc.
> is not something they are really interested in......After I retired, I 
> took
> several courses in Electromagnetics, one Graduate and the other
> Undergraduate......No one suggested the use of or taught the potential
> applications of Mathematica....Even in the Graduate course, I was the only
> student using Symbolic software ......in fact, the students did everything
> by hand and whenever something required software, such as Antenna 
> patterns,
> out came M-------b with some code , etc....and that was the end of 
> it....So,
> the students knew no better....and the Professors didn’t care or werent
> interested themselves in the benefits of learning and solving problems
> Symbolically....I asked one Professor if I could give a class lecture on 
> the
> use of Mathematica for Electromagnetics...He agreed but than said   'I can
> only give you about ten minutes'....I respectfully declined the offer....
>
> So, how does WRI expand its market?....IMO, there have to be dedicated
> Teachers on how to use Mathematica in what I'll call the Research Mode not
> just define given functions from the text and plot it.......from what I 
> have
> seen of the attitude of Instructors and Professors I'm anything but
> Optimistic....I went to our local Colleges and suggested a sequence of
> courses in Mathematica  ending with Animation and Simulation....That got 
> me
> nowhere especially with the Math Depts...so, in part, I see people who are
> stuck in pencil and paper and refuse to get out of it....
>
> Again, of course, this is my limited experience...Perhaps others have had
> different and better ones...
>
> Jerry Blimbaum
>
>
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: paulmchale7@gmail.com
> Sent: Sunday, May 19, 2013 4:50 AM
> To: mathgroup@smc.vnet.net
> Subject: Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!
>
> I have (maybe) a minority perspective on Mathematica being an engineer.  I
> used it long ago at university at version 1.  The next time I would use it
> would be a wolfram approved ebay purchase of version 4.  I have used it 
> ever
> since, but am still rookie in some ways.
>
> I believe WRI is attempting to broaden the user base rather than deepen 
> the
> product.  They are doing this by adding (from our perspective) non-value 
> add
> features to lure people in.  The argument is the learning curve is less
> which should lead to greater sales.  This is not how it works at any place 
> I
> have been.
>
> The only engineering sales force that matters is engineers.  If they can't
> argue for the product, it will not happen.  Engineers can't argue for
> something they are unable use until after purchase and additional 
> training.
> If you want engineers to demonstrate something or argue for it, you have 
> to
> do more than offer wizards and connections to WolframAlpha which only 
> apply
> after the sale.  Engineers need to show understanding and capability.
> Managers have to show accounting they are saving money by buying
> Mathematica.  Improvements in quality of OUR products or ability to 
> address
> greater problems is not quantifiable to the brigade of MBAs who run modern
> businesses.  There has to be quantifiable savings.  This has to be
> demonstrated by engineering staff before purchase and framed in terms of
> reduced need for time (salary expense).
>
> I think this can only be achieved by making the online education material
> targeted to a specific audience.  This material must solve real problems 
> in
> a way that conveys the underlying capability.
>
> I have been told by WRI that most users will only use 5% (at most) of
> Mathematicas total ability.  LoL, if only everyone would use the same 5%.
>
> If you want us to be able to sell it, you have to provide training for 
> free
> so we can get started solving engineering problems prior to purchase.
> Combine this with a 60 day trial and you could save a lot of WRI 
> development
> dollars on bells and whistles that won't increase sales. Help us help you!
> Stop trying to treat sales tools as a profit center!
>

---
Murray Eisenberg                                    murray@math.umass.edu
Mathematics & Statistics Dept.
Lederle Graduate Research Tower            phone 413 549-1020 (H)
University of Massachusetts                               413 545-2838 (W)
710 North Pleasant Street                         fax   413 545-1801
Amherst, MA 01003-9305




[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14618

FromMurray Eisenberg <murray@math.umass.edu>
Date2013-05-24 09:23 +0000
Message-ID<knnbi6$qpe$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14471
This is not an uncommon situation at colleges and universities.

Too many of the old fogies -- and, more dangerously, the "young fogies" 
-- know about Ma. . t. .b and cannot imagine why anybody who needs to do 
computing would use anything else. After all, it was good enough for 
them. (Exception: Canadians who thing the same about M . . . e.)

Similarly, too many mathematicians cannot see why their students should 
not learn how to carry out long and complex symbolic calculations, e.g., 
symbolic integration, with paper and pencil; after all, they had to do 
it. Oddly enough, some of these same mathematicians use powerful 
symbolic programs to do their own research in number theory, algebraic 
geometry, etc.

But I'm sympathetic to the view that there shouldn't be a course in a 
mathematics department on Mathematica per se. Just as there shouldn't be 
a course there in LaTeX per se. Just as Computer Science departments say 
they don't have a course in any programming language.

So if one is to make any headway, then one has to almost conceal the 
Mathematica within a mathematics course whose subject is some 
mathematical topics, or an engineering course whose subject is some 
engineering topic, etc. Just as, e.g., in some "junior year writing" 
courses taught by math departments, LaTeX is introduced and students 
have to do some or all of their papers in LaTeX. Or a mathematics 
department course in complex analysis where small teams of students do 
projects presenting some topic via a Mathematica notebook (where a 
couple of the projects might be teaching some Mathematica basics).

Perhaps this "sneaky" way is not the most efficient way for teaching and 
learning Mathematica, but it can work. In fact, Stephen Wolfram wrote in 
"The Mathematica Book" some years ago that, after learning a few basics 
and trying some simple examples from the book (today, the Documentation 
Center), "You will probably find it best to start by picking a specific 
problem to work on. Pick a problem that you understand well. . . Then go 
through each step in solving the problem, learning what you need to know 
about Mathematica to do it."


On May 23, 2013, at 4:10 AM, mathgroup <fizzymath@knology.net> wrote:

> David...
>
> But that was exactly my point...I tried so hard with our Community College
> and University to get Mathematica into the curriculum....or, as I said, to
> give some lectures and examples on the use of Mathematica....and ALL of
> them,  Engineering, Math and Physics Depts said  'Thanks but No Thanks', as
> if they have something against Mathematica....It seemed that the idea that
> students would not use pencil and paper in as laborious a manner as possible
> really bothered them....Not once did they think perhaps this might lead to a
> real enjoyment of technical subjects and perhaps to much better
> understanding of their course work......even when I was working I was
> affectionately known as 'The Mathematica Nut'...although, I'm reminded of
> something that Nietzsche said....
>
> "Overzealousness on the part of one person can lead the others to
> Apostasy".....
>
> jerry blimbaum
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: djmpark
> Sent: Wednesday, May 22, 2013 9:28 AM
> To: 'mathgroup ' ; mathgroup@smc.vnet.net
> Subject: Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!
>
> It will be done by example. Several people will work together, exchanging
> Mathematica notebooks or working on a common notebook. The notebooks will be
> what I call "literate"; they will look something like a technical paper or
> report, but they will take advantage of all the active and dynamic features
> of Mathematica, and contain generated knowledge in the form of active and
> immediately accessible routines and definitions developed in the course of
> the effort.
>
> The notebooks will be of higher integrity than paper and pencil work, or
> using Mathematica as a programmed calculator and copying out because of all
> the self-proofing and additional checks that can be performed. (Of course,
> one can still make errors but they should be rarer and not the common
> variety.)
>
> That all this can be done in a single application is a tremendous advantage.
>
> Someday other people will see what they are doing and the advantages are so
> great they will want to do the same thing. The task is getting more people
> to write and use good examples.
>
>
> David Park
> djmpark@comcast.net
> http://home.comcast.net/~djmpark/index.html
>
>
>
>
> From: mathgroup [mailto:fizzymath@knology.net]
>
> I want to comment on my experience , limited of course, with  students of
> Engineering, Engineers and Professors of Engineering.....my background is
> Physics...
>
> First,  I get the impression that , in the main, Symbolic Computation, etc.
> is not something they are really interested in......After I retired, I took
> several courses in Electromagnetics, one Graduate and the other
> Undergraduate......No one suggested the use of or taught the potential
> applications of Mathematica....Even in the Graduate course, I was the only
> student using Symbolic software ......in fact, the students did everything
> by hand and whenever something required software, such as Antenna patterns,
> out came M-------b with some code , etc....and that was the end of it....So,
> the students knew no better....and the Professors didn't care or weren't
> interested themselves in the benefits of learning and solving problems
> Symbolically....I asked one Professor if I could give a class lecture on the
> use of Mathematica for Electromagnetics...He agreed but than said   'I can
> only give you about ten minutes'....I respectfully declined the offer....
>
> So, how does WRI expand its market?....IMO, there have to be dedicated
> Teachers on how to use Mathematica in what I'll call the Research Mode not
> just define given functions from the text and plot it.......from what I have
> seen of the attitude of Instructors and Professors I'm anything but
> Optimistic....I went to our local Colleges and suggested a sequence of
> courses in Mathematica  ending with Animation and Simulation....That got me
> nowhere especially with the Math Depts...so, in part, I see people who are
> stuck in pencil and paper and refuse to get out of it....
>
> Again, of course, this is my limited experience...Perhaps others have had
> different and better ones...
>
> Jerry Blimbaum
>
>
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: paulmchale7@gmail.com
> Sent: Sunday, May 19, 2013 4:50 AM
> To: mathgroup@smc.vnet.net
> Subject: Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!
>
> I have (maybe) a minority perspective on Mathematica being an engineer.  I
> used it long ago at university at version 1.  The next time I would use it
> would be a wolfram approved ebay purchase of version 4.  I have used it ever
> since, but am still rookie in some ways.
>
> I believe WRI is attempting to broaden the user base rather than deepen the
> product.  They are doing this by adding (from our perspective) non-value add
> features to lure people in.  The argument is the learning curve is less
> which should lead to greater sales.  This is not how it works at any place I
> have been.
>
> The only engineering sales force that matters is engineers.  If they can't
> argue for the product, it will not happen.  Engineers can't argue for
> something they are unable use until after purchase and additional training.
> If you want engineers to demonstrate something or argue for it, you have to
> do more than offer wizards and connections to WolframAlpha which only apply
> after the sale.  Engineers need to show understanding and capability.
> Managers have to show accounting they are saving money by buying
> Mathematica.  Improvements in quality of OUR products or ability to address
> greater problems is not quantifiable to the brigade of MBAs who run modern
> businesses.  There has to be quantifiable savings.  This has to be
> demonstrated by engineering staff before purchase and framed in terms of
> reduced need for time (salary expense).
>
> I think this can only be achieved by making the online education material
> targeted to a specific audience.  This material must solve real problems in
> a way that conveys the underlying capability.
>
> I have been told by WRI that most users will only use 5% (at most) of
> Mathematicas total ability.  LoL, if only everyone would use the same 5%.
>
> If you want us to be able to sell it, you have to provide training for free
> so we can get started solving engineering problems prior to purchase.
> Combine this with a 60 day trial and you could save a lot of WRI development
> dollars on bells and whistles that won't increase sales. Help us help you!
> Stop trying to treat sales tools as a profit center!
>

---
Murray Eisenberg                                    murray@math.umass.edu
Mathematics & Statistics Dept.      
Lederle Graduate Research Tower            phone 413 549-1020 (H)
University of Massachusetts                               413 545-2838 (W)
710 North Pleasant Street                         fax   413 545-1801
Amherst, MA 01003-9305





[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14620

From"djmpark" <djmpark@comcast.net>
Date2013-05-24 09:26 +0000
Message-ID<knnbn9$qqd$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14471
Well it is frustrating but we can't just say that we could write great
documents using Mathematica but we have to actually do it and then try to
show them to a few individuals. Then maybe some of them will say: "That's
great, I want to do that also." Then maybe it will grow. I like to say: "The
great masterpieces have yet to be written."

But maybe the barriers are just too high.

Then, what is the purpose of the notebook interface and all the types of
dynamic display? Is it only for users private enjoyment?


David Park
djmpark@comcast.net 
http://home.comcast.net/~djmpark/index.html 







From: mathgroup [mailto:fizzymath@knology.net] 


David...

But that was exactly my point...I tried so hard with our Community College
and University to get Mathematica into the curriculum....or, as I said, to
give some lectures and examples on the use of Mathematica....and ALL of
them,  Engineering, Math and Physics Depts said  'Thanks but No Thanks', as
if they have something against Mathematica....It seemed that the idea that
students would not use pencil and paper in as laborious a manner as possible
really bothered them....Not once did they think perhaps this might lead to a
real enjoyment of technical subjects and perhaps to much better
understanding of their course work......even when I was working I was
affectionately known as 'The Mathematica Nut'...although, I'm reminded of
something that Nietzsche said....

"Overzealousness on the part of one person can lead the others to
Apostasy".....

jerry blimbaum


[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14628

FromAndrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com>
Date2013-05-25 09:34 +0000
Message-ID<knq0k1$59u$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14471
Well, to disappoint everyone I have to confess that here, at Warsaw 
University, we are going to have a university wide course in 
Mathematica, open to all students of mathematics, natural sciences, 
economics and finance and even (oh horror!) computer science (in fact, I 
am not in the process of trying to "sell" this course to my the students 
in my analysis for computer science class). We have actually received a 
grant, quite substantial by Polish standards, to implement such a 
course, and, of course, since everyone likes extra money, this has meant 
that there has been no opposition or grumbling about it from any "old 
fogies" (except perhaps one guy who complained that Mathematica was not 
open source but we quickly stifled him).

An even greater heresy: the course also is going to involve some 
knowledge of Wolfram Alpha: in fact it is entitled "Mathematics with 
Mathematica and Wolfram Alpha". (To RJF - no, we are not going to teach 
anything about any other CAS. If anyone likes to use something other 
than Mathematica they can learn it itself, but won't get any credit for 
it). Actually, our course is going to be a "supervised, self-study and 
Internet based course". In other words, we (the project authors, who are 
getting paid for designing and realising it) will prepare study 
materials (scripts, videos, problems in different disciplines that can 
be solved with the help of Mathematica or Wolfram|Alpha, tests, etc. but 
there won't be any lectures. There will however be tests and students 
will be able to get credit for passing them - otherwise, of course, it 
would be hard to get them interested.

A large part of the grant is for buying a fairly large number of copies 
of Mathematica (in addition to the ones that are already here).

Our motives for designing this project are quite selfish (and I don't 
only mean the fact that we are going to be paid for this). There are 
several of us who want to use Mathematica in our courses and it is a 
pain to have to waste time on teaching students the basics of 
Mathematica. Soon there will be several new courses available to math 
and science students in which Mathematica will be used. One of them is a 
new course on the differential geometry of curves and surfaces, which 
will be offered in addition to the already existing one which does not 
use any computer software. (Students will be able to take both 
sequentially - they are going to be sufficiently different for this to 
make sense). There is also a course that I have taught in the past, for 
which there has been a big demand among students of finance - on 
modelling jump processes. Contrary to the strange ideas RJF got from my 
earlier post, this is not something that statistics packages have been 
doing for years, actually it involves things that are pretty new (so 
much that there are still unresolved problems with some of the 
algorithms) and, in fact, I am proud to admit to having played a certain 
role in this implementation in Mathematica.

We actually have quite a few people here who although they themselves 
don't use Mathematica or CAS systems at all, have shown a lot of 
interest in having students learn such things. The main interest is, in 
fact, not so much in symbolic computation but in graphics used to 
illustrate various phenomena in topology, complex analysis etc. Although 
one might expect that there should already be lots of such illustrations 
available on the Internet (or even on Wolfram's Demonstrations Site" 
this does not seem to be actually the case.

Of course, all of this is at this time only in its infancy. About a year 
from now I should be able to say something about the success or failure 
of this project. At this time the thing that worries me the most is the 
amount of work I foresee in trying to realise all we have promised in 
the proposal.

Andrzej Kozlowski



On 24 May 2013, at 12:27, mathgroup <fizzymath@knology.net> wrote:

> I had to chuckle at your use of the word 'conceal'.....unfortunately, I
> agree with your comment....mentioning Mathematica seems akin to
> treason.....that was the reaction I felt...
>
>
> jb
>
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Murray Eisenberg
> Sent: Thursday, May 23, 2013 10:00 AM
> To: mathgroup
> Subject: Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!
>
> This is not an uncommon situation at colleges and universities.
>
> Too many of the old fogies -- and, more dangerously, the "young fogies" -- 
> know about Ma. . t. .b and cannot imagine why anybody who needs to do
> computing would use anything else. After all, it was good enough for them.
> (Exception: Canadians who thing the same about M . . . e.)
>
> Similarly, too many mathematicians cannot see why their students should not
> learn how to carry out long and complex symbolic calculations, e.g.,
> symbolic integration, with paper and pencil; after all, they had to do it.
> Oddly enough, some of these same mathematicians use powerful symbolic
> programs to do their own research in number theory, algebraic geometry, etc.
>
> But I'm sympathetic to the view that there shouldn't be a course in a
> mathematics department on Mathematica per se. Just as there shouldn't be a
> course there in LaTeX per se. Just as Computer Science departments say they
> don't have a course in any programming language.
>
> So if one is to make any headway, then one has to almost conceal the
> Mathematica within a mathematics course whose subject is some mathematical
> topics, or an engineering course whose subject is some engineering topic,
> etc. Just as, e.g., in some "junior year writing" courses taught by math
> departments, LaTeX is introduced and students have to do some or all of
> their papers in LaTeX. Or a mathematics department course in complex
> analysis where small teams of students do projects presenting some topic via
> a Mathematica notebook (where a couple of the projects might be teaching
> some Mathematica basics).
>
> Perhaps this "sneaky" way is not the most efficient way for teaching and
> learning Mathematica, but it can work. In fact, Stephen Wolfram wrote in
> "The Mathematica Book" some years ago that, after learning a few basics and
> trying some simple examples from the book (today, the Documentation Center),
> "You will probably find it best to start by picking a specific problem to
> work on. Pick a problem that you understand well. . . Then go through each
> step in solving the problem, learning what you need to know about
> Mathematica to do it."
>
>
> On May 23, 2013, at 4:10 AM, mathgroup <fizzymath@knology.net> wrote:
>
>> David...
>>
>> But that was exactly my point...I tried so hard with our Community College
>> and University to get Mathematica into the curriculum....or, as I said, to
>> give some lectures and examples on the use of Mathematica....and ALL of
>> them,  Engineering, Math and Physics Depts said  'Thanks but No Thanks',
>> as
>> if they have something against Mathematica....It seemed that the idea that
>> students would not use pencil and paper in as laborious a manner as
>> possible
>> really bothered them....Not once did they think perhaps this might lead to
>> a
>> real enjoyment of technical subjects and perhaps to much better
>> understanding of their course work......even when I was working I was
>> affectionately known as 'The Mathematica Nut'...although, I'm reminded of
>> something that Nietzsche said....
>>
>> "Overzealousness on the part of one person can lead the others to
>> Apostasy".....
>>
>> jerry blimbaum
>>
>> -----Original Message-----
>> From: djmpark
>> Sent: Wednesday, May 22, 2013 9:28 AM
>> To: 'mathgroup ' ; mathgroup@smc.vnet.net
>> Subject: Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!
>>
>> It will be done by example. Several people will work together, exchanging
>> Mathematica notebooks or working on a common notebook. The notebooks will
>> be
>> what I call "literate"; they will look something like a technical paper or
>> report, but they will take advantage of all the active and dynamic
>> features
>> of Mathematica, and contain generated knowledge in the form of active and
>> immediately accessible routines and definitions developed in the course of
>> the effort.
>>
>> The notebooks will be of higher integrity than paper and pencil work, or
>> using Mathematica as a programmed calculator and copying out because of
>> all
>> the self-proofing and additional checks that can be performed. (Of course,
>> one can still make errors but they should be rarer and not the common
>> variety.)
>>
>> That all this can be done in a single application is a tremendous
>> advantage.
>>
>> Someday other people will see what they are doing and the advantages are
>> so
>> great they will want to do the same thing. The task is getting more people
>> to write and use good examples.
>>
>>
>> David Park
>> djmpark@comcast.net
>> http://home.comcast.net/~djmpark/index.html
>>
>>
>>
>>
>> From: mathgroup [mailto:fizzymath@knology.net]
>>
>> I want to comment on my experience , limited of course, with  students of
>> Engineering, Engineers and Professors of Engineering.....my background is
>> Physics...
>>
>> First,  I get the impression that , in the main, Symbolic Computation,
>> etc.
>> is not something they are really interested in......After I retired, I
>> took
>> several courses in Electromagnetics, one Graduate and the other
>> Undergraduate......No one suggested the use of or taught the potential
>> applications of Mathematica....Even in the Graduate course, I was the only
>> student using Symbolic software ......in fact, the students did everything
>> by hand and whenever something required software, such as Antenna
>> patterns,
>> out came M-------b with some code , etc....and that was the end of
>> it....So,
>> the students knew no better....and the Professors didn't care or weren't
>> interested themselves in the benefits of learning and solving problems
>> Symbolically....I asked one Professor if I could give a class lecture on
>> the
>> use of Mathematica for Electromagnetics...He agreed but than said   'I can
>> only give you about ten minutes'....I respectfully declined the offer....
>>
>> So, how does WRI expand its market?....IMO, there have to be dedicated
>> Teachers on how to use Mathematica in what I'll call the Research Mode not
>> just define given functions from the text and plot it.......from what I
>> have
>> seen of the attitude of Instructors and Professors I'm anything but
>> Optimistic....I went to our local Colleges and suggested a sequence of
>> courses in Mathematica  ending with Animation and Simulation....That got
>> me
>> nowhere especially with the Math Depts...so, in part, I see people who are
>> stuck in pencil and paper and refuse to get out of it....
>>
>> Again, of course, this is my limited experience...Perhaps others have had
>> different and better ones...
>>
>> Jerry Blimbaum
>>
>>
>>
>> -----Original Message-----
>> From: paulmchale7@gmail.com
>> Sent: Sunday, May 19, 2013 4:50 AM
>> To: mathgroup@smc.vnet.net
>> Subject: Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!
>>
>> I have (maybe) a minority perspective on Mathematica being an engineer.  I
>> used it long ago at university at version 1.  The next time I would use it
>> would be a wolfram approved ebay purchase of version 4.  I have used it
>> ever
>> since, but am still rookie in some ways.
>>
>> I believe WRI is attempting to broaden the user base rather than deepen
>> the
>> product.  They are doing this by adding (from our perspective) non-value
>> add
>> features to lure people in.  The argument is the learning curve is less
>> which should lead to greater sales.  This is not how it works at any place
>> I
>> have been.
>>
>> The only engineering sales force that matters is engineers.  If they can't
>> argue for the product, it will not happen.  Engineers can't argue for
>> something they are unable use until after purchase and additional
>> training.
>> If you want engineers to demonstrate something or argue for it, you have
>> to
>> do more than offer wizards and connections to WolframAlpha which only
>> apply
>> after the sale.  Engineers need to show understanding and capability.
>> Managers have to show accounting they are saving money by buying
>> Mathematica.  Improvements in quality of OUR products or ability to
>> address
>> greater problems is not quantifiable to the brigade of MBAs who run modern
>> businesses.  There has to be quantifiable savings.  This has to be
>> demonstrated by engineering staff before purchase and framed in terms of
>> reduced need for time (salary expense).
>>
>> I think this can only be achieved by making the online education material
>> targeted to a specific audience.  This material must solve real problems
>> in
>> a way that conveys the underlying capability.
>>
>> I have been told by WRI that most users will only use 5% (at most) of
>> Mathematicas total ability.  LoL, if only everyone would use the same 5%.
>>
>> If you want us to be able to sell it, you have to provide training for
>> free
>> so we can get started solving engineering problems prior to purchase.
>> Combine this with a 60 day trial and you could save a lot of WRI
>> development
>> dollars on bells and whistles that won't increase sales. Help us help you!
>> Stop trying to treat sales tools as a profit center!
>>
>
> ---
> Murray Eisenberg                                    murray@math.umass.edu
> Mathematics & Statistics Dept.
> Lederle Graduate Research Tower            phone 413 549-1020 (H)
> University of Massachusetts                               413 545-2838 (W)
> 710 North Pleasant Street                         fax   413 545-1801
> Amherst, MA 01003-9305
>
>
>
>
>

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14640 — Warsaw Univ. course, was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!

FromRichard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu>
Date2013-05-26 08:38 +0000
SubjectWarsaw Univ. course, was Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!
Message-ID<knshlv$c7o$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14628
On 5/25/2013 2:34 AM, Andrzej Kozlowski wrote:
> Well, to disappoint everyone I have to confess that here, at Warsaw
> University, we are going to have a university wide course in
> Mathematica, open to all students of mathematics, natural sciences,
> economics and finance and even (oh horror!) computer science (in fact, I
> am not in the process of trying to "sell" this course to my the students
> in my analysis for computer science class).

Do you have courses that are not open to all students?

As has been pointed out in the past, Mathematica has numerous
disadvantages for use in computer science. For example, it
misconstrues common terms like List. Its algorithms are secret.
Its arithmetic is unique.

<snip>

>
> Of course, all of this is at this time only in its infancy. About a year
> from now I should be able to say something about the success or failure
> of this project.

Do you have some kind of plan in place to evaluate its success or failure?
Most "innovations" in education are not evaluated and are just
replaced by other "innovations."

I think it is unfortunate that you are spending resources
  to pay for Mathematica licenses. I would hope that WRI would grant
licenses as its part in this experiment.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14643 — more problems in Warsaw plan? Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!

FromRichard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu>
Date2013-05-26 08:36 +0000
Subjectmore problems in Warsaw plan? Re: Work on Basic Mathematica Stephen!
Message-ID<knshiq$c77$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14628
On 5/25/2013 2:34 AM, Andrzej Kozlowski wrote:
<snip>

  (except perhaps one guy who complained that Mathematica was not
> open source but we quickly stifled him).
Really? Easily?
See
http://www.zdnet.com/open-sources-fortunes-in-poland-could-be-about-to-change-thanks-to-education-7000008611/

>
> An even greater heresy: the course also is going to involve some
> knowledge of Wolfram Alpha: in fact it is entitled "Mathematics with
> Mathematica and Wolfram Alpha". (To RJF - no, we are not going to teach
> anything about any other CAS. If anyone likes to use something other
> than Mathematica they can learn it itself, but won't get any credit for
> it).

Since such a variety of mathematical computations are included in
Mathematica, I would be curious as to what parts of Mathematics are 
selected. Will the course mention how Mathematica is implemented, or
will it be used as a "black box"?

  Actually, our course is going to be a "supervised, self-study and
> Internet based course". In other words, we (the project authors, who are
> getting paid for designing and realising it) will prepare study
> materials (scripts, videos, problems in different disciplines that can
> be solved with the help of Mathematica or Wolfram|Alpha, tests, etc. but
> there won't be any lectures.

Sounds like a good idea. After the material is constructed, you will
presumably be able to drop your involvement and let students interact
with the material without you. And you can go do something else. You
could even be fired!

  There will however be tests and students
> will be able to get credit for passing them - otherwise, of course, it
> would be hard to get them interested.

An interesting problem that comes up with MOOCs  is how to assign credit
for people taking courses on the internet, remotely. Would you expect
students to take exams in person?  Would they have access to a computer?
Would the computer be on the internet?  Would they cheat?
Just asking.

>
> A large part of the grant is for buying a fairly large number of copies
> of Mathematica (in addition to the ones that are already here).
A shame.

>
> Our motives for designing this project are quite selfish (and I don't
> only mean the fact that we are going to be paid for this). There are
> several of us who want to use Mathematica in our courses and it is a
> pain to have to waste time on teaching students the basics of
> Mathematica.

So this course on Mathematica is a required prerequisite for these 
courses?  Or if they need only the basics, why would you need to spend
any time on it in your course?

Soon there will be several new courses available to math
> and science students in which Mathematica will be used. One of them is a
> new course on the differential geometry of curves and surfaces, which
> will be offered in addition to the already existing one which does not
> use any computer software.

  Will students in the two versions take the same exams?  Could you 
compare the results?


  (Students will be able to take both
> sequentially - they are going to be sufficiently different for this to
> make sense).

I would be surprised if there was so much demand for differential 
geometry courses.  How many students are we talking about?  10? 100? 1000?

  There is also a course that I have taught in the past, for
> which there has been a big demand among students of finance - on
> modelling jump processes.


Contrary to the strange ideas RJF got from my
> earlier post, this is not something that statistics packages have been
> doing for years, actually it involves things that are pretty new (so
> much that there are still unresolved problems with some of the
> algorithms) and, in fact, I am proud to admit to having played a certain
> role in this implementation in Mathematica.
>
See
http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/EMJumpDiffusion/EMJumpDiffusion.pdf

or
http://www.proba.jussieu.fr/pageperso/tankov/tankov_voltchkova.pdf

To see what statistics packages have been doing for years.

If Mathematica is so great with this stuff, why is there a new feature 
of a link to R?

My take on R is that it is more or less the lingua franca of statistics.
I am not a statistician by training, and I have not used R.


> We actually have quite a few people here who although they themselves
> don't use Mathematica or CAS systems at all, have shown a lot of
> interest in having students learn such things.

Can you be more quantitative?  Quite a few = 5? 10? people = faculty? 
staff? graduate students?

  The main interest is, in
> fact, not so much in symbolic computation but in graphics used to
> illustrate various phenomena in topology, complex analysis etc.

This is quite revelatory.  If the big selling point for Mathematica is
graphics, what other graphics packages are available? To me the graphics
is not central to symbolic computation, just a user-friendly 
easy-to-demo component added on.  I think of symbolic computation as 
fundamentally the representation and manipulation of non-numeric 
"formula" data. But some people view graphics = symbolic.

  Although
> one might expect that there should already be lots of such illustrations
> available on the Internet (or even on Wolfram's Demonstrations Site"
> this does not seem to be actually the case.

Google finds 205,000 pages mentioning gnuplot examples. There
are many other programs for scientific visualization, some free.

>
> Of course, all of this is at this time only in its infancy. About a year
> from now I should be able to say something about the success or failure
> of this project. At this time the thing that worries me the most is the
> amount of work I foresee in trying to realise all we have promised in
> the proposal.

Is any part of the proposal available online in English so as to see 
what you actually promised?

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14657

FromDavid Bailey <dave@removedbailey.co.uk>
Date2013-05-28 07:47 +0000
Message-ID<ko1ner$r3h$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14628
On 25/05/2013 10:34, Andrzej Kozlowski wrote:
> Well, to disappoint everyone I have to confess that here, at Warsaw
> University, we are going to have a university wide course in
> Mathematica, open to all students of mathematics, natural sciences,
> economics and finance and even (oh horror!) computer science (in fact, I
> am not in the process of trying to "sell" this course to my the students
> in my analysis for computer science class). We have actually received a
> grant, quite substantial by Polish standards, to implement such a
> course, and, of course, since everyone likes extra money, this has meant
> that there has been no opposition or grumbling about it from any "old
> fogies" (except perhaps one guy who complained that Mathematica was not
> open source but we quickly stifled him).
>
> An even greater heresy: the course also is going to involve some
> knowledge of Wolfram Alpha: in fact it is entitled "Mathematics with
> Mathematica and Wolfram Alpha". (To RJF - no, we are not going to teach
> anything about any other CAS. If anyone likes to use something other
> than Mathematica they can learn it itself, but won't get any credit for
> it). Actually, our course is going to be a "supervised, self-study and
> Internet based course". In other words, we (the project authors, who are
> getting paid for designing and realising it) will prepare study
> materials (scripts, videos, problems in different disciplines that can
> be solved with the help of Mathematica or Wolfram|Alpha, tests, etc. but
> there won't be any lectures. There will however be tests and students
> will be able to get credit for passing them - otherwise, of course, it
> would be hard to get them interested.
>

I think that is an absolutely wonderful decision. I wish I was of 
student age (and spoke Polish!) to avail myself of it, and the 
associated maths courses.

I think mathematicians, and more particularly, users of maths, have a 
range of styles of thought, and the every concrete approach, which 
Mathematica encourages, would certainly have appealed to me.

To give a specific example, I remember trying to learn about group 
theory. For a long time, groups seemed somehow vague to me. I learned 
the axioms of what counted as a group, and thought "Yeah well - so 
what!". I learned (or tried to learn) assorted other definitions, such 
as "normal subgroup", and of course, I looked at various tiny examples 
of groups. However, what I really needed was software which would let me 
make examples that were big enough to begin to see why all those 
definitions were any use - software that let me explore. I am the sort 
of person who finds it hard to learn something that doesn't seem any use 
- even if I know that everyone says it really will be useful once I get 
to understand it!

As to the issue of alternative CAS software, I did chemistry, and nobody 
worried about the fact that all our NMR machines were Varian, or that 
the infra red machines were made by Perkin Elmer, or that we learned to 
program the type of computer owned by the university - a technical 
university course inevitably focuses its students on certain products.

You say the focus will be on graphics rather than symbolic computation, 
but I must say, I think symbolic computation is the more exciting part - 
because it opens up entirely new possibilities.

Take symbolic integration as an example. I know there are those who 
would say students should be told to solve all their integrals with 
Mathematica (and take a calculator to add their bills when they shop) 
but I am not thinking that way. It is easy to make a construct in 
Mathematica that displays like an integral, but doesn't evaluate. Using 
this, students could explore strategies such as change of variable - 
simply using pattern replacement and simplification. Mathematica would 
be contributing no skills that the students didn't already know - simply 
adding some muscle to help explore more substantial problems.

I wish you success!

David Bailey
http://www.dbaileyconsultancy.co.uk




[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14647

FromJohn Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com>
Date2013-05-27 08:21 +0000
Message-ID<knv529$j91$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14471
I'm another Mathematica old-timer. In early versions, Mathematica had a simple basic vocabulary of definitions, augmentable by "add-ons". This was a good thing. The basics could be covered by an actual book you could hold in your hand. But now, Mathematica has a vast flat vocabulary supported by vast flat documentation. This is not a big problem for those of us who are already familiar with it, but I can't see how a new user can cope.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


Page 2 of 5 — ← Prev page 1 [2] 3 4 5  Next page →

Back to top | Article view | comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica


csiph-web