Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica > #14263 > unrolled thread

Re: Speak errors (was Re: audio)

Started byClif McInnis <c_mcinnis@hotmail.com>
First post2013-04-21 09:17 +0000
Last post2013-05-06 06:25 +0000
Articles 9 — 5 participants

Back to article view | Back to comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica

This discussion starts older than the indexed window; earlier articles aren't shown. The article labeled Started by below is the oldest one visible, not the original post.


Contents

  Re: Speak errors  (was Re: audio) Clif McInnis <c_mcinnis@hotmail.com> - 2013-04-21 09:17 +0000
    Re: Speak errors  (was Re: audio) Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-04-22 07:13 +0000
    Re: Speak errors  (was Re: audio) Murray Eisenberg <murray@math.umass.edu> - 2013-04-24 10:16 +0000
      Mathematica-assisted learning   was .. Re: Speak errors  (was Re: Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-04-25 06:51 +0000
      Re: Mathematica-assisted learning   was .. Re: Speak errors  (was Re: Murray Eisenberg <murray@math.umass.edu> - 2013-04-26 08:24 +0000
      Re: Mathematica-assisted learning   was .. Re: Speak errors Richard Fateman <fateman@eecs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-04-26 08:24 +0000
        Re: Mathematica-assisted learning   was .. Re: Speak errors Helen Read <readhpr@gmail.com> - 2013-04-28 04:58 +0000
          Re: Mathematica-assisted learning   was .. Re: Speak errors Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> - 2013-04-28 09:17 +0000
            Re: Mathematica-assisted learning   was .. Re: Speak errors Helen Read <readhpr@gmail.com> - 2013-05-06 06:25 +0000

#14263 — Re: Speak errors (was Re: audio)

FromClif McInnis <c_mcinnis@hotmail.com>
Date2013-04-21 09:17 +0000
SubjectRe: Speak errors (was Re: audio)
Message-ID<kl0arj$l43$1@smc.vnet.net>
"On the larger issue, of getting kindergarten children to pronounce the numbers from 1 to 10.  Uh, do you really need to use a computer? Running Mathematica?"

Not meaning to disregard the top part of your post, however the last two questions are important to me. I would like to get your opinion as I see that you are a well cited author of over 1100 documents on the Mathematica site.

I hope that I am interpreting your question correctly. I would say I hope a student would not need a computer to run the manipulate, and if I am under standing the way CDF's, such as those on the demonstrations project, work it could be run on a smart phone, a pad, or other such device, (w/o the player) that the student may be using while riding in the back seat of the car, or at other non-productive times.

Now if the question addresses the only necessity of the pronunciation of numerals, then I would say that it would be a good addition to a demonstration that targets an age group that are multi-sensory, but I guess not a bsolutely essential. I would also hope that such an instructional method would only be supplemental to more personal , probably tactile-engaging, methods of presenting the concept. 

Reality, of 35 years teaching, says that there will be many students that will for whatever reason miss the point that numerals represent numbers, and come away with the idea that 3, whether written or spoken is two backwards c's stacked on top of each other.  Given that as a foundation on which we would like to build the rest of their mathematical understanding is it any wonder that by the time that they are ready to do more complex mathematics many become discouraged?

I think that if this app can include audio, without disrupting the learning flow by showing x number of objects on the screen while speaking the number y, it would be more worthwhile to students in this age range.

[toc] | [next] | [standalone]


#14271

FromRichard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu>
Date2013-04-22 07:13 +0000
Message-ID<kl2nvb$2de$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14263
On 4/21/2013 2:17 AM, Clif McInnis wrote:
> "On the larger issue, of getting kindergarten children to pronounce the numbers from 1 to 10.
Uh, do you really need to use a computer? Running Mathematica?"
>
> Not meaning to disregard the top part of your post, however the last two questions are important to me.
I would like to get your opinion as I see that you are a well cited 
author of over 1100 documents on the Mathematica site.
>
> I hope that I am interpreting your question correctly. I would say I hope a student would not need a
computer to run the manipulate, and if I am under standing the way 
CDF's, such as those on the demonstrations project,
  work it could be run on a smart phone, a pad, or other such device, 
(w/o the player) that the student may be
  using while riding in the back seat of the car, or at other 
non-productive times.
>
> Now if the question addresses the only necessity of the pronunciation of numerals, then I would say that
it would be a good addition to a demonstration that targets an age group 
that are multi-sensory, but I guess not
  a bsolutely essential. I would also hope that such an instructional 
method would only be supplemental
to more personal , probably tactile-engaging, methods of presenting the 
concept.
>
> Reality, of 35 years teaching, says that there will be many students that will for whatever
reason miss the point that numerals represent numbers, and come away 
with the idea that 3,
whether written or spoken is two backwards c's stacked on top of each 
other.  Given that as
  foundation on which we would like to build the rest of their 
mathematical understanding is
it any wonder that by the time that they are ready to do more complex 
mathematics many become
  discouraged?
>
> I think that if this app can include audio, without disrupting the learning flow by showing x
  number of objects on the screen while speaking the number y, it would 
be more worthwhile to
students in this age range.
>
.............

Historically, experiments at higher educational levels to introduce a 
computer algebra system into a math course have resulted in consequences 
like this:
1. Students, on average, resented having to learn "something else" (i.e. 
using computer program) that wasn't "on the final".
2. On average they learned "no less" than students in the control group 
not using computers.  But "no more" either.

We are now wondering whether introducing computers will work for 
kindergarten students (in 2013) learning number shapes.  Two significant 
changes.  (a) much younger students  (b) a different attitude toward 
computers/smart phones -- these having been ubiquitous.

Now I am hardly an expert in very early childhood education, but I have 
seen some games aimed at children. Your game sounds pretty boring, but I 
have seen something like it.  Showing 4 ducks. Click on each one. Game 
says "4 ducks" and shows a "4".  Another requires tracing out of the 
digits in the right directions of the strokes.

These are probably directed to children of age 3 with access to iPad or 
similar. Children of age 5 in the US who cannot count to 10 and/or think
that 3 is two backwards C's stacked, are probably rare.

However, I am not actually >> objecting << to the educational 
experiment. At worst you will be exposing children to a boring game that 
they will simply not play.

What I am pointing out is that better software technology for all the 
parts needed is so readily available and cheap.  Using Mathematica seems 
totally ill-advised.  Possibly depriving kids of human contact -- 
Johnny, you have to learn your 3's.  Sit in the back of the car and use 
the computer..

Just because something Could Be Done with Mathematica does not mean
(a) it should be done with Mathematica.  (b) should be done at all.

RJF

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14283

FromMurray Eisenberg <murray@math.umass.edu>
Date2013-04-24 10:16 +0000
Message-ID<kl8bed$no7$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14263
See interspersed responses:
On Apr 22, 2013, at 3:10 AM, Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> wrote:

> Historically, experiments at higher educational levels to introduce a
> computer algebra system into a math course have resulted in consequences
> like this:
> 1. Students, on average, resented having to learn "something else" (i.e.
> using computer program) that wasn't "on the final".

Simple solution: let students use the computer for all exams, too. (I've done that.)

> 2. On average they learned "no less" than students in the control group
> not using computers.  But "no more" either.

What, exactly, does that mean? By what standards is this being judged? E.g., when comparing with a conventionally taught control group, does the comparison test asking what-if questions that require simulation or calculations, etc., beyond the normal capabilities of paper and pencil?

---
Murray Eisenberg                                    murray@math.umass.edu
Mathematics & Statistics Dept.      
Lederle Graduate Research Tower            phone 413 549-1020 (H)
University of Massachusetts                               413 545-2838 (W)
710 North Pleasant Street                         fax   413 545-1801
Amherst, MA 01003-9305





[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14296 — Mathematica-assisted learning was .. Re: Speak errors (was Re:

FromRichard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu>
Date2013-04-25 06:51 +0000
SubjectMathematica-assisted learning was .. Re: Speak errors (was Re:
Message-ID<klajot$39c$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14283
On 4/24/2013 3:16 AM, Murray Eisenberg wrote:
> See interspersed responses:
> On Apr 22, 2013, at 3:10 AM, Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> wrote:
>
>> Historically, experiments at higher educational levels to introduce a
>> computer algebra system into a math course have resulted in consequences
>> like this:
>> 1. Students, on average, resented having to learn "something else" (i.e.
>> using computer program) that wasn't "on the final".
>
> Simple solution: let students use the computer for all exams, too. (I've done that.)
Finding a room with (say) 350 computers, all running (say) mathematica, 
all DISconnected from the internet to avoid collusion, (etc)  presents 
certain physical and electronic problems.
>
>> 2. On average they learned "no less" than students in the control group
>> not using computers.  But "no more" either.
>
> What, exactly, does that mean? By what standards is this being judged?

I think there are a number of peer-reviewed papers in this area; I 
recall one that had to do with a "modern algebra" type course.
Or this report (1991) regarding calculus and Mathematica

http://library.wolfram.com/infocenter/Articles/3227/

and how students performed in a physics course, it found

" a nonsignificant difference in the mean grades of the two groups "


  E.g., when comparing with a conventionally taught control group, does 
the comparison test asking

what-if questions that require simulation or calculations, etc.,

beyond the normal capabilities of paper and pencil?

I think the comparisons are generally with control groups that were 
being taught the same material but without "benefit" of computers.  It 
seems to me that comparing the two groups of students on their ability 
to write programs would not be pertinent to the question of whether the 
two groups learned (say) calculus equally well.

If you are making the point that you think that students gain something 
by learning to write program for computers, generally, that is something 
I agree with.  However, there is scant evidence that introducing 
computers into a conventional course improves learning of that 
conventional course material.   You can accuse the instructors of 
lacking imagination, or the students of lacking in ambition, interest, 
curiosity, or the curriculum specifications of lacking in flexibility, 
or the testing process bogus, or the selection of control groups wrong, 
or any other hypothesis that you can come up with to invalidate the 
published results. But other than the anecdotal comments from students
who really liked (but some hated...) the course, what can you do?
>

I'm all in favor of technological aids to teaching that work. Finding 
them is not so easy. Proving that they work is hard too. Evidence that 
consists solely of anecdotes from enthusiasts doesn't count. Making neat 
demos is fun for the instructor, but that's not the question here...


RJF


[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14319 — Re: Mathematica-assisted learning was .. Re: Speak errors (was Re:

FromMurray Eisenberg <murray@math.umass.edu>
Date2013-04-26 08:24 +0000
SubjectRe: Mathematica-assisted learning was .. Re: Speak errors (was Re:
Message-ID<klddje$d0f$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14283
On Apr 25, 2013, at 2:51 AM, Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> wrote:

> I think the comparisons are generally with control groups that were being taught
> the same material but without "benefit" of computers.  It
> seems to me that comparing the two groups of students on their ability
> to write programs would not be pertinent to the question of whether the
> two groups learned (say) calculus equally well."

If you think that what I'm suggesting is to "write programs" then you simply don't understand the issues here. It's learning mathematical ideas vs. learning to do (largely mindless) mechanical manipulations of symbols.

> On 4/24/2013 3:16 AM, Murray Eisenberg wrote:
>> See interspersed responses:
>> On Apr 22, 2013, at 3:10 AM, Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> wrote:
>>
>>> Historically, experiments at higher educational levels to introduce a
>>> computer algebra system into a math course have resulted in consequences
>>> like this:
>>> 1. Students, on average, resented having to learn "something else" (i.e.
>>> using computer program) that wasn't "on the final".
>>
>> Simple solution: let students use the computer for all exams, too. (I've done that.)
> Finding a room with (say) 350 computers, all running (say) mathematica,
> all DISconnected from the internet to avoid collusion, (etc)  presents
> certain physical and electronic problems.
>>
>>> 2. On average they learned "no less" than students in the control group
>>> not using computers.  But "no more" either.
>>
>> What, exactly, does that mean? By what standards is this being judged?
>
> I think there are a number of peer-reviewed papers in this area; I
> recall one that had to do with a "modern algebra" type course.
> Or this report (1991) regarding calculus and Mathematica
>
> http://library.wolfram.com/infocenter/Articles/3227/
>
> and how students performed in a physics course, it found
>
> " a nonsignificant difference in the mean grades of the two groups "
>
>
>  E.g., when comparing with a conventionally taught control group, does
> the comparison test asking
>
> what-if questions that require simulation or calculations, etc.,
>
> beyond the normal capabilities of paper and pencil?
>
> I think the comparisons are generally with control groups that were
> being taught the same material but without "benefit" of computers.  It
> seems to me that comparing the two groups of students on their ability
> to write programs would not be pertinent to the question of whether the
> two groups learned (say) calculus equally well.
>
> If you are making the point that you think that students gain something
> by learning to write program for computers, generally, that is something
> I agree with.  However, there is scant evidence that introducing
> computers into a conventional course improves learning of that
> conventional course material.   You can accuse the instructors of
> lacking imagination, or the students of lacking in ambition, interest,
> curiosity, or the curriculum specifications of lacking in flexibility,
> or the testing process bogus, or the selection of control groups wrong,
> or any other hypothesis that you can come up with to invalidate the
> published results. But other than the anecdotal comments from students
> who really liked (but some hated...) the course, what can you do?
>>
>
> I'm all in favor of technological aids to teaching that work. Finding
> them is not so easy. Proving that they work is hard too. Evidence that
> consists solely of anecdotes from enthusiasts doesn't count. Making neat
> demos is fun for the instructor, but that's not the question here...
>
>
> RJF
>
>

---
Murray Eisenberg                                    murray@math.umass.edu
Mathematics & Statistics Dept.      
Lederle Graduate Research Tower            phone 413 549-1020 (H)
University of Massachusetts                               413 545-2838 (W)
710 North Pleasant Street                         fax   413 545-1801
Amherst, MA 01003-9305





[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14323 — Re: Mathematica-assisted learning was .. Re: Speak errors

FromRichard Fateman <fateman@eecs.berkeley.edu>
Date2013-04-26 08:24 +0000
SubjectRe: Mathematica-assisted learning was .. Re: Speak errors
Message-ID<klddjp$d0o$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14283
On 4/25/2013 6:46 AM, Murray Eisenberg wrote:
> On Apr 25, 2013, at 2:51 AM, Richard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu> wrote:
>
>> I think the comparisons are generally with control groups that were being taught
>> the same material but without "benefit" of computers.  It
>> seems to me that comparing the two groups of students on their ability
>> to write programs would not be pertinent to the question of whether the
>> two groups learned (say) calculus equally well."
> If you think that what I'm suggesting is to "write programs" then you simply don't understand the issues here. It's learning mathematical ideas vs. learning to do (largely mindless) mechanical manipulations of symbols.
>
I was being somewhat facetious in describing  the other benefits of 
introducing computers as
learning to write programs.  Certainly there is a prospect that students 
would learn, as a consequence
of the computer-related stuff to have a higher appreciation of (say) 
algorithmic / procedural
thought processes, even  "ideas"  (however defined by you)   vs rote 
repetition.  I am not aware
of any peer-reviewed research papers  validating such a hypothesis. 
Occasional anecdotes
notwithstanding.

You might or might not recall that the standard methods in calculus 
courses (and I suspect in
physics/ etc courses)  consist largely in teaching mindless mechanical 
manipulations. Worse,
they are taught by repeated examples, not as fixed algorithms by which 
any of the problems
can be done by following those algorithms. Then students are graded on 
their ability to
perform the mindless manipulations.

It is my own cynical view that the real value in compulsory calculus is 
that it is mighty tough
to do those manipulations without a firm grasp of the (mindless) 
manipulations of algebra and
perhaps trigonometry.  Therefore the calculus, which is itself vital to 
10% of the students and
useless to 90%, has the effect of reinforcing knowledge of algebra, 
which is somewhat more
relevant to people. (e.g. financial matters...)

Perhaps somewhere there is a calculus course that does not depend on 
such an approach.
One time I taught part of a calculus course at MIT  (circa 1972) -- an 
added computer "lab"
in which I explained the fundamentals of the Risch integration procedure 
to students in course 18.001,
which was a more "applied" calculus.  The students seemed to like that.
   The main instructional themes and senior faculty lecturers were 
unaffected by it. In that
year, or so far as I know, in any future year.

I note that the MIT regular calculus, 18.01
http://math.mit.edu/classes/18.01/Spring2013/
apparently uses a computer algebra system, but not Mathematica.
I do not see how it is used or how it could be used on the exams.

In the previous century (1987 ish)  there were reform efforts regarding
"Calculus for the New Century"
which is presumably THIS century.  Big news.  Graphing calculators..

It occurs to me that we have had a similar conversation previously.
Indeed ...  21 Jan 2010..

http://forums.wolfram.com/mathgroup/archive/2010/Jan/msg00643.html

Regards
RJF




http://www.eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/search/detailmini.jsp?_nfpb=true&_&ERICExtSearch_SearchValue_0=ED300252&ERICExtSearch_SearchType_0=no&accno=ED300252



[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14338 — Re: Mathematica-assisted learning was .. Re: Speak errors

FromHelen Read <readhpr@gmail.com>
Date2013-04-28 04:58 +0000
SubjectRe: Mathematica-assisted learning was .. Re: Speak errors
Message-ID<klia9d$s97$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14323
On 4/26/2013 4:24 AM, Richard Fateman wrote:
>
>
> I note that the MIT regular calculus, 18.01
> http://math.mit.edu/classes/18.01/Spring2013/
> apparently uses a computer algebra system, but not Mathematica.
> I do not see how it is used or how it could be used on the exams.

I teach calculus in a classroom (we have two such rooms) equipped with a 
computer for each student. We use Mathematica routinely throughout the 
semester, in and out of class, and most of the students like having it 
and using it. We have a site license that allows the students to install 
Mathematica on their own laptops so they can use it outside of class.

I try to present things with the "rule of three" when possible, looking 
at things from the numerical, graphical, and analytic points of view. 
Obviously Mathematica is a big help for the numerical and graphical 
approaches. One of my favorite examples is introducing series, where 
give the students some examples and have them make tables and plots of 
partial sums and try to guess whether or not the series converges (of 
course I give them some examples where it's difficult to tell), and 
after a bit of this they practically beg to be taught analytic tests of 
convergence. We continue with the numerical/graphical/analytic approach 
throughout the chapter, using analytic tests to prove that a series 
converges and then using numerical methods (with the help of 
Mathematica) to approximate the limit of partial sums. I find that 
overall they seem to end up with a better understanding of series than 
my students did years ago when all we did was paper-and-pencil 
convergence (which the students found to be terribly abstract).

My students do use Mathematica on exams, but not for everything. I make 
up exams in two parts. Part 1 is paper and pencil only, and I keep the 
computers "locked" (using monitoring software installed on all the 
student computers). When a student finishes Part 1, s/he hands it in and 
I unlock that particular computer (which I can do remotely from the 
instructor's desk), and the student has full use of Mathematica for Part 
2. I can monitor what the students are doing on their computers from the 
instructor's station (and of course I get up and walk around and answer 
questions if they get stuck on something like a missing comma). We have 
a printer in the room so that the students can print their work and 
staple it to their test paper when they hand it in.

I've been teaching this way since the late 1990s, and wouldn't dream of 
going back to doing it without technology.

Helen Read
University of Vermont

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14351 — Re: Mathematica-assisted learning was .. Re: Speak errors

FromRichard Fateman <fateman@cs.berkeley.edu>
Date2013-04-28 09:17 +0000
SubjectRe: Mathematica-assisted learning was .. Re: Speak errors
Message-ID<klipeg$11h$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14338
On 4/27/2013 9:58 PM, Helen Read wrote:
> On 4/26/2013 4:24 AM, Richard Fateman wrote:
>>
>>
>> I note that the MIT regular calculus, 18.01
>> http://math.mit.edu/classes/18.01/Spring2013/
>> apparently uses a computer algebra system, but not Mathematica.
>> I do not see how it is used or how it could be used on the exams.
>

> I teach calculus in a classroom (we have two such rooms) equipped with a
> computer for each student. We use Mathematica routinely throughout the
> semester, in and out of class, and most of the students like having it
> and using it. We have a site license that allows the students to install
> Mathematica on their own laptops so they can use it outside of class.

I was speaking of how the MIT course could use computer algebra.  If you 
look at the review problems
http://math.mit.edu/classes/18.01/Spring2013/Supplementary%20notes/01rp1.pdf
you see that quite a few of them are trivial if you just type them in to
a computer algebra system, and presumably would not be much of a 
learning experience if in fact they were just typed in. Others require
explain/prove/give examples.

I have no doubt that a calculus course could be constructed using 
computer algebra systems --- I would hope it would be quite different, 
emphasizing (say) the calculational aspects of the subject and then 
observing the symbolic, almost coincidental, solutions to the same
evaluations.  It sounds like you are doing something along those lines.

It does not surprise me that MIT is still doing the same old thing; when
I was covering recitation sections, the main lecturer was Arthur 
Mattuck. In 1971.  The notes used in 2013 are apparently by Arthur Mattuck.

It is presumably possible to do things at U. Vermont without overcoming 
such massive inertia.  I have encountered substantial inertia at UC 
Berkeley in mathematics and engineering, too.

On the other hand, the question remains for any of these courses as to 
whether one can objectively demonstrate that students learn calculus 
more than those in a control group not using computers.  I am not 
doubting for a moment that instructors who like computers prefer 
teaching using them. (Including me.)  Yet there are still math 
instructors who, for whatever reason, prefer not.
>
>
<snip> ....
>  I find that
> overall they seem to end up with a better understanding of series than
> my students did years ago when all we did was paper-and-pencil
> convergence (which the students found to be terribly abstract).

Can you quantify this? (This is somewhat unfair -- you are stating your 
own observations and I'm asking you to be an expert on human factors, 
learning, etc.  I've often seen and participated in "innovation" in 
teaching and rarely tried to prove the innovation had positive results!
Nevertheless, it would be nice to have "evidence".)
>
> My students do use Mathematica on exams, but not for everything. I make
> up exams in two parts. Part 1 is paper and pencil only, and I keep the
> computers "locked" (using monitoring software installed on all the
> student computers). When a student finishes Part 1, s/he hands it in and
> I unlock that particular computer (which I can do remotely from the
> instructor's desk), and the student has full use of Mathematica for Part
> 2. I can monitor what the students are doing on their computers from the
> instructor's station (and of course I get up and walk around and answer
> questions if they get stuck on something like a missing comma). We have
> a printer in the room so that the students can print their work and
> staple it to their test paper when they hand it in.

I have no doubt that there are interesting calculations that are vastly
easier to do with the help of a computer algebra system.

I would be interested to see what kinds of questions you can ask on a 
calculus exam that (a) test something that students are expected to know 
from a calculus course and (b) require (or are substantially assisted 
by) Mathematica.
>
> I've been teaching this way since the late 1990s, and wouldn't dream of
> going back to doing it without technology.

Another question, based on my own observations ...  If you are on 
sabbatical and not available to teach this course, does someone else 
pick it up and teach it the same way?  What I've seen is that when the 
computer enthusiast is not available, the course reverts to something 
rather more traditional.

RJF

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#14421 — Re: Mathematica-assisted learning was .. Re: Speak errors

FromHelen Read <readhpr@gmail.com>
Date2013-05-06 06:25 +0000
SubjectRe: Mathematica-assisted learning was .. Re: Speak errors
Message-ID<km7icd$ic8$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#14351
On 4/28/2013 5:17 AM, Richard Fateman wrote:
> On 4/27/2013 9:58 PM, Helen Read wrote:
>> On 4/26/2013 4:24 AM, Richard Fateman wrote:
>>>
>>>
>>> I note that the MIT regular calculus, 18.01
>>> http://math.mit.edu/classes/18.01/Spring2013/
>>> apparently uses a computer algebra system, but not Mathematica.
>>> I do not see how it is used or how it could be used on the exams.
>>
>
>> I teach calculus in a classroom (we have two such rooms) equipped with a
>> computer for each student. We use Mathematica routinely throughout the
>> semester, in and out of class, and most of the students like having it
>> and using it. We have a site license that allows the students to install
>> Mathematica on their own laptops so they can use it outside of class.
>
> I was speaking of how the MIT course could use computer algebra.  If you
> look at the review problems
> http://math.mit.edu/classes/18.01/Spring2013/Supplementary%20notes/01rp1.pdf
> you see that quite a few of them are trivial if you just type them in to
> a computer algebra system, and presumably would not be much of a
> learning experience if in fact they were just typed in. Others require
> explain/prove/give examples.
>
> I have no doubt that a calculus course could be constructed using
> computer algebra systems --- I would hope it would be quite different,
> emphasizing (say) the calculational aspects of the subject and then
> observing the symbolic, almost coincidental, solutions to the same
> evaluations.  It sounds like you are doing something along those lines.
>
> It does not surprise me that MIT is still doing the same old thing; when
> I was covering recitation sections, the main lecturer was Arthur
> Mattuck. In 1971.  The notes used in 2013 are apparently by Arthur Mattuck.
>
> It is presumably possible to do things at U. Vermont without overcoming
> such massive inertia.  I have encountered substantial inertia at UC
> Berkeley in mathematics and engineering, too.
>
> On the other hand, the question remains for any of these courses as to
> whether one can objectively demonstrate that students learn calculus
> more than those in a control group not using computers.  I am not
> doubting for a moment that instructors who like computers prefer
> teaching using them. (Including me.)  Yet there are still math
> instructors who, for whatever reason, prefer not.

It's a difficult thing to measure. Many, many years ago I developed a 
"reform" version of the "baby" calculus at UVM. (This is our 
two-semester, easier, calculus sequence taken by students whose majors 
require them to take calculus but not at the level that is required by 
say math or engineering majors. It is taken by more students at UVM than 
any other course, including English 001, and many of the students have 
terrible deficits in pre-calculus skills such as algebra and 
trigonometry.) For the "new wave" version of the course we used a 
textbook written by some folks at Clemson University that emphasized 
concepts over algebra, and used data driven examples to motivate the 
concepts. The emphasis was on understanding and interpretation, using 
graphing calculators to handle the drudge work. Almost everything was a 
"word problem" and rote skill-and-drill problems were downplayed (though 
we still assigned some). Many of the faculty freaked out over this 
approach, and we ended up with two separate tracks taught by different 
faculty.

One semester we did make an attempt to compare outcomes by putting some 
common questions on the final exams, but the more conceptual questions 
that those of us teaching the "new wave" course proposed were rejected 
by those teaching the traditional course as "unfair" questions that 
their students should not be expected to answer. Which tells you 
something right there. In the end we found no statistical difference 
between the two groups on the skill questions (e.g., product rule), and 
on the (very few) mildly conceptual questions that we were permitted to 
ask the students in the "reform" group outperformed (in a statistically 
significant way) the students from the traditional group. Nonetheless, 
there was so much faculty resistance that the "reform" version ended up 
being given a separate course number, and was eventually killed off 
because almost all of the client departments continued to require the 
original traditional version.

I haven't taught the baby calculus in ages (I stopped when the reform 
version was discontinued) and don't really know what they are doing with 
it these days, but my sense is that it is somewhere in between the two 
versions, but closer to the old traditional way.


> <snip> ....
>>   I find that
>> overall they seem to end up with a better understanding of series than
>> my students did years ago when all we did was paper-and-pencil
>> convergence (which the students found to be terribly abstract).
>
> Can you quantify this? (This is somewhat unfair -- you are stating your
> own observations and I'm asking you to be an expert on human factors,
> learning, etc.  I've often seen and participated in "innovation" in
> teaching and rarely tried to prove the innovation had positive results!
> Nevertheless, it would be nice to have "evidence".)

Unfortunately I have nothing more than anecdotal evidence.

>> My students do use Mathematica on exams, but not for everything. I make
>> up exams in two parts. Part 1 is paper and pencil only, and I keep the
>> computers "locked" (using monitoring software installed on all the
>> student computers). When a student finishes Part 1, s/he hands it in and
>> I unlock that particular computer (which I can do remotely from the
>> instructor's desk), and the student has full use of Mathematica for Part
>> 2. I can monitor what the students are doing on their computers from the
>> instructor's station (and of course I get up and walk around and answer
>> questions if they get stuck on something like a missing comma). We have
>> a printer in the room so that the students can print their work and
>> staple it to their test paper when they hand it in.
>
> I have no doubt that there are interesting calculations that are vastly
> easier to do with the help of a computer algebra system.
>
> I would be interested to see what kinds of questions you can ask on a
> calculus exam that (a) test something that students are expected to know
> from a calculus course and (b) require (or are substantially assisted
> by) Mathematica.
>>
>> I've been teaching this way since the late 1990s, and wouldn't dream of
>> going back to doing it without technology.
>
> Another question, based on my own observations ...  If you are on
> sabbatical and not available to teach this course, does someone else
> pick it up and teach it the same way?  What I've seen is that when the
> computer enthusiast is not available, the course reverts to something
> rather more traditional.

My department enacted a policy that requires some use of Mathematica 
throughout the three semester "grown up" calculus sequence, and drew up 
a document of minimum Mathematica competence that should be achieved by 
all students. From my point of view Mathematica competence in and of 
itself isn't really the main point, it's just a means to a greater end. 
Still, most of the faculty are on board with this, and many are very 
enthusiastic and integrate Mathematica in ways that we believe benefit 
the students (again, no hard evidence -- but I don't have hard evidence 
for lots of the choices I make in teaching; all I have is years of 
experience and observation). If I were not around, there are enough 
others to carry on.

-- 
HPR

[toc] | [prev] | [standalone]


Back to top | Article view | comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica


csiph-web