Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]
Groups > comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica > #12087 > unrolled thread
| Started by | dr DanW <dmaxwarren@gmail.com> |
|---|---|
| First post | 2012-10-17 02:50 +0000 |
| Last post | 2012-10-18 06:43 +0000 |
| Articles | 3 — 1 participant |
Back to article view | Back to comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica
Nonlinear curve fit as a Button function fails quietly dr DanW <dmaxwarren@gmail.com> - 2012-10-17 02:50 +0000
Re: Nonlinear curve fit as a Button function fails quietly dr DanW <dmaxwarren@gmail.com> - 2012-10-18 06:42 +0000
Re: Nonlinear curve fit as a Button function fails quietly dr DanW <dmaxwarren@gmail.com> - 2012-10-18 06:43 +0000
| From | dr DanW <dmaxwarren@gmail.com> |
|---|---|
| Date | 2012-10-17 02:50 +0000 |
| Subject | Nonlinear curve fit as a Button function fails quietly |
| Message-ID | <k5l6e1$cn9$1@smc.vnet.net> |
All,
I apologize in advance for the complexity of the code I will paste below. I tried to simplify it as much as possible, but if I simplify it too much it does not replicate the problem.
I am building a Maniplate in which I can manually shape a function until I have a reasonable approximation of a set of data. Once a reasonable approximation is found, I press a button and FindFit finishes off the job. This works only some of the time. When it doesn't work, pushing the button just appears to have no effect. I have verified that FindFit on its own returns a value in about 7 to 8 seconds on my computer. It also throws a FindFit::eit Message, complaining that the fit does not converge to the tolerance.
The code pasted below takes several seconds to print the "started" message, then appears to do nothing else. The symbol fff never gets a value.
Any suggestions would be quite welcome.
Version 8.0.4 on Mac OSX 10.8.
---- snip ----
Button["doit", Print["started"];
fff = FindFit[{{0.009817477042468103, -49.25189827863107},
{0.019634954084936207, -37.90562180443017}, {0.02945243112740431,
-31.513750095697066}, {0.039269908169872414, -27.036391847757564},
{0.04908738521234052, -23.56126670467896}, {0.05890486225480862,
-20.726453130124064}, {0.06872233929727672, -18.31925814576376},
{0.07853981633974483, -16.206465382815864}, {0.08835729338221293,
-14.325235300806058}, {0.09817477042468103, -12.628441835613662},
{0.10799224746714915, -11.06358693639666}, {0.11780972450961724,
-9.585921921208962}, {0.12762720155208535, -8.286186108571872},
{0.13744467859455345, -6.988551136111462}, {0.14726215563702155,
-5.748879315763792}, {0.15707963267948966, -4.5584683769560295},
{0.16689710972195776, -3.3956796056204306}, {0.17671458676442586,
-2.2530914985657704}, {0.18653206380689397, -1.1219363808775793},
{0.19634954084936207, 0.}, {0.20616701789183017, 1.1306324051574126},
{0.2159844949342983, 2.271271620353366}, {0.2258019719767664,
3.4322379150665796}, {0.23561944901923448, 4.61170622835966},
{0.2454369260617026, 5.828520928043911}, {0.2552544031041707,
7.088175349770548}, {0.2650718801466388, 8.410939067615722},
{0.2748893571891069, 9.778099451675669}, {0.284706834231575,
11.205191339349081}, {0.2945243112740431, 12.70574426792714},
{0.3043417883165112, 14.26926111125274}, {0.3141592653589793,
15.90266532920084}, {0.3239767424014474, 17.58445219321284},
{0.3337942194439155, 19.27981048196874}, {0.3436116964863836,
20.88648054765454}, {0.3534291735288517, 22.27505717829864},
{0.36324665057131983, 23.319344994596342}, {0.37306412761378793,
23.952938596366238}, {0.38288160465625604, 24.22004147547884},
{0.39269908169872414, 24.051179133133438}, {0.4025165587411922,
23.863719286857844}, {0.41233403578366035, 23.753427902576338},
{0.42215151282612845, 23.42605746808244}, {0.4319689898685966,
22.93369858422324}, {0.44178646691106466, 22.176037849104638},
{0.4516039439535328, 21.21089090242164}, {0.46142142099600086,
20.082738010398042}, {0.47123889803846897, 18.855325390853338},
{0.4810563750809371, 17.60549450679254}, {0.4908738521234052,
16.373195129322042}, {0.5006913291658733, 15.188769264995043},
{0.5105088062083414, 14.062388719060541}, {0.5203262832508094,
12.94059301342994}, {0.5301437602932776, 11.887518378554141},
{0.5399612373357456, 10.88982440186189}, {0.5497787143782138, 9.94655597639831},
{0.559596191420682, 9.035721808943318}, {0.56941366846315, 8.223406932317982},
{0.5792311455056182, 7.4304441360343985}, {0.5890486225480862,
6.708713816889741}, {0.5988660995905544, 6.00755283947401},
{0.6086835766330224, 5.35194137521387}, {0.6185010536754905, 4.69189109838896},
{0.6283185307179586, 4.07070926952911}, {0.6381360077604268,
3.5186920461085904}, {0.6479534848028948, 2.9734855713242787},
{0.657770961845363, 2.473945725585539}, {0.667588438887831, 2.0007741956414544},
{0.6774059159302992, 1.555106763053056}, {0.6872233929727672,
1.115631305988963}, {0.6970408700152354, 0.7051256747666311},
{0.7068583470577035, 0.29146373072983967}, {0.7166758241001715,
-0.11881558761636021}, {0.7264933011426397, -0.5389487361897404},
{0.7363107781851077, -0.9320380384483707}, {0.7461282552275759,
-1.2837540840602313}, {0.755945732270044, -1.6614633793729408},
{0.7657632093125121, -2.0018935483060316}, {0.7755806863549802,
-2.350265149405491}, {0.7853981633974483, -2.6427115074562897},
{0.7952156404399163, -2.920780495671072}, {0.8050331174823844,
-3.1741625603067227}, {0.8148505945248526, -3.3751902938779086},
{0.8246680715673207, -3.536692513644942}, {0.8344855486097889,
-3.6838354992325995}, {0.8443030256522569, -3.8052491493034983},
{0.8541205026947251, -3.88827302979538}, {0.8639379797371932,
-3.980075960541421}, {0.8737554567796613, -4.002074991564381},
{0.8835729338221293, -4.040176770016652}, {0.8933904108645974,
-4.01856531264624}, {0.9032078879070656, -4.035856194674391},
{0.9130253649495337, -4.015754927472921}, {0.9228428419920017,
-3.9983714759968207}, {0.9326603190344698, -3.9312910594433994},
{0.9424777960769379, -3.8372724645213396}, {0.9522952731194061,
-3.7504776505626807}, {0.9621127501618743, -3.5831085707394204},
{0.9719302272043423, -3.4399539035920905}, {0.9817477042468103,
-3.23538340696767}, {0.9915651812892784, -3.0196018226054795},
{1.0013826583317467, -2.7229772167546114}, {1.0112001353742148,
-2.427596950647602}, {1.0210176124166828, -2.05765823225498},
{1.030835089459151, -1.7090437133754608}, {1.0406525665016189,
-1.3201973455027713}, {1.0504700435440872, -0.8810356339889912},
{1.0602875205865552, -0.3373457652665709}, {1.0701049976290233,
0.2764964214559994}, {1.0799224746714913, 1.0090920657956444},
{1.0897399517139594, 1.7437025552366012}, {1.0995574287564276,
2.485254754875705}, {1.1093749057988957, 3.17849269648283},
{1.119192382841364, 3.6184801969386498}, {1.1290098598838318,
3.6256568799760487}, {1.1388273369263, 3.1467928990289207},
{1.1486448139687682, 2.145877334813474}, {1.1584622910112363,
0.9588677967566638}, {1.1682797680537043, -0.47974972042532066},
{1.1780972450961724, -1.9397596881504104}, {1.1879147221386406,
-3.29916090267474}, {1.1977321991811087, -4.565281407310572},
{1.207549676223577, -5.64671142426318}, {1.2173671532660448, -6.63535403325776},
{1.227184630308513, -7.6253761329055925}, {1.237002107350981,
-8.534972941932661}, {1.2468195843934493, -9.45529160775786},
{1.2566370614359172, -10.278484593535861}, {1.2664545384783854,
-11.032847033066862}, {1.2762720155208536, -11.844270053735361},
{1.2860894925633215, -12.636051209685462}, {1.2959069696057897,
-13.49019820535946}, {1.3057244466482578, -14.257955065594361},
{1.315541923690726, -14.959347360567063}, {1.325359400733194,
-15.622911413801262}, {1.335176877775662, -16.28079359033076},
{1.3449943548181302, -16.883381684852765}, {1.3548118318605984,
-17.48456917564956}, {1.3646293089030663, -18.25867812914986},
{1.3744467859455345, -18.860826252564962}, {1.3842642629880026,
-19.49135991821976}, {1.3940817400304708, -20.15420254097076},
{1.403899217072939, -20.80965139184066}, {1.413716694115407,
-21.46401633016016}, {1.423534171157875, -22.06927516742266},
{1.433351648200343, -22.79840998311286}, {1.4431691252428114,
-23.366757548681065}, {1.4529866022852793, -23.931929096927163},
{1.4628040793277475, -24.453785905403862}, {1.4726215563702154,
-24.957289253122063}, {1.4824390334126836, -25.178711377439562},
{1.4922565104551517, -25.32658692213666}, {1.50207398749762,
-25.52380930463276}, {1.511891464540088, -25.838724103753563},
{1.521708941582556, -26.15674719359836}, {1.5315264186250241,
-26.396955542045163}, {1.5413438956674923, -26.550540832227263},
{1.5511613727099605, -26.68810321786346}, {1.5609788497524284,
-26.644987316887764}},
{(1/Log[10])*(20*Log[10^(Re[gain]/20)*Abs[\[Omega]^2/((I*\[Omega] - xx[1])*
((I*\[Omega] - xx[2])^2 + yy[2]^2)*((I*\[Omega] - xx[3])^2 + yy[3]^2)*
((I*\[Omega] - xx[4])^2 + yy[4]^2)*((I*\[Omega] - xx[5])^2 + yy[5]^2))]]),
{xx[1] < 0, xx[2] < 0, xx[3] < 0, xx[4] < 0, xx[5] < 0, 0 < yy[2] < Pi,
0 < yy[3] < Pi, 0 < yy[4] < Pi, 0 < yy[5] < Pi}}, {{gain, 24.200000000000003},
{xx[1], -0.44399999999999995}, {xx[2], -0.08199999999999985}, {yy[2], 0.71},
{xx[3], -0.13199999999999967}, {yy[3], 0.865}, {xx[4], -0.06599999999999984},
{yy[4], 1.7850000000000001}, {xx[5], -0.11599999999999966}, {yy[5], 2.63}},
\[Omega]]; Print[fff]; ]
[toc] | [next] | [standalone]
| From | dr DanW <dmaxwarren@gmail.com> |
|---|---|
| Date | 2012-10-18 06:42 +0000 |
| Message-ID | <k5o8d7$ibj$1@smc.vnet.net> |
| In reply to | #12087 |
>From Wolfram tech support, the Method->"Queued" option on Button prevents the timeout. I scoured the Doc Center, never would have found this on my own. I have another post describing a related problem that this fixes. Once it show up in the forum I will repeat this solution. Daniel
[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]
| From | dr DanW <dmaxwarren@gmail.com> |
|---|---|
| Date | 2012-10-18 06:43 +0000 |
| Message-ID | <k5o8ek$ibr$1@smc.vnet.net> |
| In reply to | #12087 |
I appreciate the replies I have received so far. One thing I failed to emphasize is the intermittency of this problem. It appears to be related to the Messaging system in a subtle way. If FindFit doesn't have a problem (as it apparently did not on some of your computers) it does not try to throw a message and the fit parameters get returned correctly. The particular example I pasted does not converge in 500 iterations (on my computer) and FindFit tries to throw the Message. I think it may be a failure of Message, not the function itself, that is the source of the problem. This morning, I have a fresh session and I deleted the cache. When FindFit throws the message, a pink Message notebook opens with the message, as expected behavior. I think somehow I buggered the windowing system, so Mathematica gets confused as to where to put the Message. Maybe it is out there somewhere, I just do not see it. This is very hard for me to diagnose. For now, I have reduced the Accuracy and Precision goals and keep my fingers crossed. However, since I am developing this as a tool for other engineers, I have to find a resolution for this. Regards, Daniel
[toc] | [prev] | [standalone]
Back to top | Article view | comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica
csiph-web