Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica > #11548 > unrolled thread

Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach...

Started byAlexei Boulbitch <Alexei.Boulbitch@iee.lu>
First post2012-08-30 08:08 +0000
Last post2012-09-18 07:53 +0000
Articles 20 — 6 participants

Back to article view | Back to comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica


Contents

  Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... Alexei Boulbitch <Alexei.Boulbitch@iee.lu> - 2012-08-30 08:08 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... John Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com> - 2012-08-31 08:06 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2012-09-01 06:27 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... János Löbb <janos@lobb.com> - 2012-09-02 08:36 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... Vince Virgilio <blueschi@gmail.com> - 2012-09-06 08:18 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... János Löbb <janos@lobb.com> - 2012-09-07 08:55 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... John Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com> - 2012-09-07 09:01 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... János Löbb <janos@lobb.com> - 2012-09-08 07:09 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... John Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com> - 2012-09-08 07:48 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... Ralph Dratman <ralph.dratman@gmail.com> - 2012-09-09 09:13 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... John Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com> - 2012-09-11 06:33 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2012-09-12 07:02 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2012-09-12 07:29 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... John Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com> - 2012-09-15 07:44 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... John Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com> - 2012-09-15 07:45 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2012-09-16 07:21 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2012-09-16 07:22 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... János Löbb <janos@lobb.com> - 2012-09-17 04:22 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2012-09-18 07:53 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2012-09-18 07:53 +0000

#11548 — Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach...

FromAlexei Boulbitch <Alexei.Boulbitch@iee.lu>
Date2012-08-30 08:08 +0000
SubjectRe: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach...
Message-ID<k1n71e$e5m$1@smc.vnet.net>
On Wednesday, August 15, 2012 1:31:53 AM UTC-6, Andrzej Kozlowski wrote:

> I agree with your interpretation of Landau's letter but I also think your

> remarks about mathematics miss the point of what mathematicians do.



I know what mathematicians do. Finding connections between ideas is at the core of mathematics. The best mathematicians (von Neumann, for example)follow those connections wherever they lead, and don't stop at arbitrary borders. http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=rethinking-labels-boosts-creativity has some relevance here.



> Mathematicians do not concern themselves with the physical universe - if

> they did they would be something else. The results which they prove are

> meaningful within their own realm. The exact nature of this "meaning" is

> complicated, but it essentially relates to "procedures" (how arguments

> are conducted) than any physical reality. A great deal of mathematics

> (for example, almost all of probability theory) is concerned with

> "infinity", which arguably has no physical meaning at all.



Except that in many cases, it has been physical scientists who *introduced*mathematicians to various uses of infinity (differentials, Fourier analysis, delta functions, ...). But that's history.



It is also clear from history that mathematics developed from very concrete foundations in things like counting and measurement. It is incomprehensibl e to me that many mathematicians wish to deny this, preferring to believe in Platonic fairy tales. A nasty consequence of this denial was the 1960's "New Math" curriculum for American schoolchildren. Supposed to strengthen math comprehension, it did exactly the opposite.



I cringe when I hear a mathematician talk about Fourier analysis as being about functions in L2. That notion ignores out a large part of the application space: "carrier waves", "flicker noise", delta functions, ... Here we see mathematicians willfully avoiding *meaningful* infinity.



...

...

...



Let me just point out that the origin of this interesting and passionate discussion was the question of what should be the content and tools of the mathematical education for students in non-mathematical specialities at present, observing that since long computers have become the reality of our world.



Best, Alexei




Alexei BOULBITCH, Dr., habil.
IEE S.A.
ZAE Weiergewan,
11, rue Edmond Reuter,
L-5326 Contern, LUXEMBOURG

Office phone :  +352-2454-2566
Office fax:       +352-2454-3566
mobile phone:  +49 151 52 40 66 44

e-mail: alexei.boulbitch@iee.lu<mailto:alexei.boulbitch@iee.lu>

[toc] | [next] | [standalone]


#11575

FromJohn Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com>
Date2012-08-31 08:06 +0000
Message-ID<k1pr9u$k1u$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
On Thursday, August 30, 2012 2:09:19 AM UTC-6, Alexei Boulbitch wrote:

> Let me just point out that the origin of this interesting and passionate discussion was the
> question of what should be the content and tools of the mathematical education for students in
> non-mathematical specialities at present, observing that since long computers have become the
> reality of our world.

The nature of mathematics is very relevant here. If mathematics is the product of a magical sense that detects objects in a supernatural world, then it is impossible to scientifically approach the problem of teaching mathematics. But if mathematics is a product of the natural processes of cognition that humans use to find their way in the world, teaching mathematics is similar to other kinds of teaching. Then, the methods and insights of cognitive science are likely to be of use in answering your question.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11578

FromAndrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com>
Date2012-09-01 06:27 +0000
Message-ID<k1s9sh$og1$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
On 31 Aug 2012, at 09:57, John Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com> wrote:

> On Thursday, August 30, 2012 2:09:19 AM UTC-6, Alexei Boulbitch wrote:
>
>> Let me just point out that the origin of this interesting and passionate discussion was the
>> question of what should be the content and tools of the mathematical education for students in
>> non-mathematical specialities at present, observing that since long computers have become the
>> reality of our world.
>
> The nature of mathematics is very relevant here. If mathematics is the product of a magical sense that detects objects in a supernatural world, then it is impossible to scientifically approach the problem of teaching mathematics. But if mathematics is a product of the natural processes of cognition that humans use to find their way in the world, teaching mathematics is similar to other kinds of teaching. Then, the methods and insights of cognitive science are likely to be of use in answering your question.
>

The question of how human beings learn mathematics and whether the natural (not "super-natural") world is governed by laws which can be described by means of mathematics are two quite different (although related) questions. Mathematical "pPlatonism" is only concerned with the latter question, it asserts that mathematical theorems (in some sense) hold in the real world and not just in human minds. How human beings learn and discover them is a rather different matter.

 To idea that human beings acquire mathematics as part of a "natural processes of cognition that humans use to find their way in the world" and at the same time mathematics "has nothing to do" with this world, sounds to me like a very feeble one, but since the issue is metaphysical, probably harmless. However the idea that by using "insights of cognitive science" you can turn people who have trouble adding fractions into Riemann's and Poincare's sounds to me about as "useful" as Marx's idea that once you "abolish" private property  all human beings will become geniuses and  every kitchen maid will be able to run the State. And, if you are not claiming that everyone can be a Newton, Gauss, Riemann,  or Poincare etc. (with proper, "cognitive science" guided education) then why not? Is it possible that mathematical ability may be largely inherited? Why, what evolutionary purpose would that serve?


Andrzej Kozlowski

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11590

FromJános Löbb <janos@lobb.com>
Date2012-09-02 08:36 +0000
Message-ID<k1v5q1$590$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
On Sep 1, 2012, at 2:27 AM, Andrzej Kozlowski wrote:

>
> On 31 Aug 2012, at 09:57, John Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com> wrote:
>
>> On Thursday, August 30, 2012 2:09:19 AM UTC-6, Alexei Boulbitch wrote:
>>
>>> Let me just point out that the origin of this interesting and passionate discussion was the
>>> question of what should be the content and tools of the mathematical education for students in
>>> non-mathematical specialities at present, observing that since long computers have become the
>>> reality of our world.
>>
>> The nature of mathematics is very relevant here. If mathematics is 
the product of a magical sense that detects objects in a supernatural 
world, then it is impossible to scientifically approach the problem of 
teaching mathematics. But if mathematics is a product of the natural 
processes of cognition that humans use to find their way in the world, 
teaching mathematics is similar to other kinds of teaching. Then, the 
methods and insights of cognitive science are likely to be of use in 
answering your question.
>>
>
> The question of how human beings learn mathematics and whether the 
natural (not "super-natural") world is governed by laws which can be 
described by means of mathematics are two quite different (although 
related) questions. Mathematical "pPlatonism" is only concerned with the 
latter question, it asserts that mathematical theorems (in some sense) 
hold in the real world and not just in human minds. How human beings 
learn and discover them is a rather different matter.
>
> To idea that human beings acquire mathematics as part of a "natural 
processes of cognition that humans use to find their way in the world" 
and at the same time mathematics "has nothing to do" with this world, 
sounds to me like a very feeble one, but since the issue is 
metaphysical, probably harmless. However the idea that by using 
"insights of cognitive science" you can turn people who have trouble 
adding fractions into Riemann's and Poincare's sounds to me about as 
"useful" as Marx's idea that once you "abolish" private property  all 
human beings will become geniuses and  every kitchen maid will be able 
to run the State. And, if you are not claiming that everyone can be a 
Newton, Gauss, Riemann,  or Poincare etc. (with proper, "cognitive 
science" guided education) then why not? Is it possible that 
mathematical ability may be largely inherited? Why, what evolutionary 
purpose would that serve?
>
>
> Andrzej Kozlowski
>

I do not know how long this answer would be, so my advise to the serious 
reader is to stop reading this right now and rather read the New York 
Times.

Now, that I have just the attention of nut cases like myself, I can dive 
into it :-)

If I go back about 4.5 billion years and look the Solar System, I see 
just a mixture of different kind of materials, mixed together by 
electromagnetism, gravitation, weak interaction and the strong 
interaction.  Earth is about 2000K at the surface, there is no sign of 
life as we know it and consequently (??) no mathematical axioms, 
theorems of any kind.  Just reality.  Is this Solar System with its hot 
Earth unique at that time ?  Hardly.  There are millions of it, 
mass-produced by cosmic forces just in the Milky way Galaxy.  Even the 
Milky Way Galaxy is not unique at that time, millions or even billions 
of similar Galaxies could have been seen by an intelligent eye, if such 
eye would be in existence 4.5 billion years ago.  Then what is the real 
ingredient, that if we just give 4.5 billion years to this Solar system, 
to make about 18 rotation around the nucleus of this Milky way Galaxy, 
in a Galaxy where seemingly nothing happens, except some fat stars blow 
themselves up from time to time, that life appears and 
accidentally/ultimately human beings with mathematical ideas in their 
head came to existence.
Can something be created that is not there to start with ?  Here is 
short story from S. Lem:

<nyissz>
One day Trurl the constructor put together a machine that could create 
anything starting with n. When it was ready, he tried it out, ordering 
it to make needles, then nankeens and negligees, which it did, then nail 
the lot to narghiles filled with nepenthe and numerous other narcotics. 
The machine carried out his instructions to the letter. Still not 
completely sure of its ability, he had it produce, one after the other, 
nimbuses, noodles, nuclei, neutrons, naphtha, noses, nymphs, naiads, and 
natrium. 'This last it could not do, and Trurl, considerably irritated, 
demanded an explanation.

"Never heard of it," said the machine. 

"What? But it's only sodium. You know, the metal, the element..."

"Sodium starts with an s, and I work only in n."

"But in Latin it's natrium."

"Look, old boy," said the machine, "if I could do everything starting 
with n in every possible language, I'd be a Machine That Could Do 
Everything in the Whole Alphabet, since any item you care to mention 
undoubtedly starts with n in one foreign language or another. It's not 
that easy. I can't go beyond what you programmed. So no sodium."
<nyassz>

Then we have to take it to heart, that whatever we see around us today, 
or any time in the future, had to be there in the Solar System 4.5 
billion years ago, but not necessarily in the same shape and form we see 
it today.  Even mathematical ideas should have been there embodied in 
some manner.  A  process, called evolution built them up to the present 
form in the last 4.5 billion years.  Yeah, but what is evolution ?  Well 
there is many good description of it, most originate from biology,  
although astrophysics and astronomy also have used the word evolution to 
describe the "life cycle" of astronomical objects and.or processes with 
no connection to earthly biological life.  Even the Solar System as a 
whole has been going through some 'evolutionary process' in the last 4.5 
billion years.  The question is if today's objects and ideas are already 
embodied at any time in the past, then how it is done, what shape and 
form the embodiment takes place, what are the laws governing this 
embodiment, etc.,,

On the big scale we can see galaxy clusters placed on filaments, showing 
a not apparent distribution in space, governed by gravity and 
electromagnetism.  On scale of the individual elemental particles it is 
all the strong and weak nuclear forces with some play of 
electromagnetism.  Neither scale shows anything that would seem an 
obvious component for this embodiment.
Then we might have to do a salto mortale and make all those that look 
essential inessential, and whatever it is inessential to make essential. 
 /I told you I will be a not case !! /
Let's assume for a moment that all the material Reality that we see 
around us is inessential, that it is not essential, it is a byproduct of 
a process and try the grasp that something that is essential and present 
at every  level of this inessential material Reality.

I call it the Information Ocean.  Where does it exist ?  Above the 
Planck scale, but below the elemental particle level.  /Above the 
elemental particle level are the nuclear, atomic, chemical, nano, 
biological, cell, multi cell, etc.../  It is the Information Ocean that 
creates matter.  But why ?  Because it stuck between the Plank scale and 
the elementary particles' scale.  It is the Information Ocean that 
creates such powerful attributes as spin, charge and mass.  According to 
Landau, a proton in the nucleus has a speed of c/4, where c is the speed 
of light.  Even in the nucleus of the Hydrogen atom, that consist only 
of one proton, this lonly proton achieves this c/4 speed.  Every atom in 
every one of us contains minimum one proton and those protons are moving 
with c/4 in their own confinement.  The speed of light was known and 
measured before the proton was known and measured.  But which one is the 
more important for the embodiment, proton or photon ?  Looks like both 
are equally important and that is shown with the c/4 speed of the proton 
in the nucleus.
When the Information Ocean creates a proton with spin, charge and mass 
and the forces attached to it to govern it in space and time at the 
elementary particle level, some kind of balance is broken.  To 
compensate for this brokenness another entity has to be created, but in 
this entity the mass, charge and spin might not be separated, but rather 
tied together closer to the Plank scale and show only one of the 
component from the three /or more/ and we might perceive it is "dark 
matter" or "dark energy".

The Information Ocean is where all the information can be found.  Past 
present future.  No exception.  It is the Information Ocean that builds 
up the material world, the material Reality to help himself out from his 
prison stuck between the Plank scale and the elementary particle scale, 
like baron M=FCnchhausen, who pulled himself out from the mud by 
grabbing his own hair.  Material Reality is for Information Ocean as the 
hair is for baron M=FCnchhausen, to pull up.  There are some 
consequences.  One of them is, that all what Information Ocean builds it 
builds from information first.  It is not by chance that the meaning of 
a point is getting very fuzzy as we approach the Planck scale from the 
macro worlds.  Already at the elementary particle level it is very 
troublesome to speak about the location of an electron, or making bets 
where the electron can be found just in a moment.  In the case of a 
photon we cannot even attach a local coordinate system to it, and in 
every other coordinate systems the photon speed is c, independently how 
these coordinate systems are moving to each other.

So when the Bible says that God separated Earth from haven, the real 
meaning of it is  that material Reality everywhere in the Universe was 
separated by Information Ocean from another reality that is between 
Information Ocean and the Plank scale.

As Information Ocean created the elementary particles from information, 
it retained a connection to them.  We can look every elementary particle 
as a chunk of structured information, and this structure gives birth to 
the different attributes of the elementary particles. Every elementary 
particle has connection to every other particle via those connections 
the Information Ocean retained for itself.  Quantum mechanical 
exhibition of it is the entanglement.

If I look the World as a place where Information Ocean tries to express 
itself by creating and building a scaffolding for itself, then I can see 
clearly that this material Reality skeleton is there exactly for that 
purpose for Information Ocean to come to the macro world from its 
present level.  Then it is obvious that mathematical ideas are there at 
2000K Earth 4.5 billion years ago.  Every structure from the electron to 
 a galaxy cluster is the exoskeleton of Information Ocean and 
Information Ocean is where all the information can be found, among the 
many the mathematical ideas too.

Evolution = The way how Information Ocean expressing itself via the 
material Reality exoskeleton scaffolding. 

There are peaks and volleys in evolution.  It is not a strait line, 
because the structures created has to find each other, has to work 
together and has to play with each other.  That takes time.  So, 
evolutions flattens out and speeds up from time to time.

Now if I am looking biological beings, than there is the brain that has 
a unique purpose.  Everyone will tell you that the brain is the seat for 
human creativity and ingenuity, etc=85.  I see it differently.  The 
brain is that exoskeleton piece  that is "evolutionary" suited for 
direct communication to and from the Information Ocean.  See my 
definition above for evolution.  If I am looking just human beings, it 
is obvious that everyone has a totally different brain structure, even 
if for first glance - from a distance of a few meters - every exposed 
human brain looks alike.  These differences are obvious for everyone - 
except politicians, that is why we have the democratic one person one 
vote -, and it manifests itself in different capabilities.  From my 
point of view these manifestations are not really important.  Only one 
difference is important and it is the capability of the brain to have a 
direct connection to Information Ocean.  When do we experience such 
direct connection ?  In three cases:

- In dreams.  In my dreams in 1988 I could speak fluently in English, 
although I hardly could put a full sentence together in real life.
- In the creative moment.  My favorite example for it is how the idea of 
the book of "One Hundred Year Solitude" came to the mind of Gabriel 
Grac=EDa M=E1rguez.  He was  driving in Mexico on the transAmerican 
highway with his wife, and suddenly as the road turned, he saw an 
incredible green valley.  As he looked down into the valley, the whole 
story of the book came into his mind.  He said later it was so clear in 
his brain that he could write down the first 3 chapters without even 
thinking about it.  He went back, closed himself into a room and as they 
gave him food he gave out the pages of manuscript to print.  It took him 
3 months to write down the book, that took less than a millisecond to 
appear in his mind.  This show how incredible high is the speed between 
the brain and the Information Ocean, because in his brain it was not 
like a book, but rather as a film or movie.
- in the "flow" as described by Mih=E1ly Cs=EDkszentmih=E1lyi.

Consciousness  dampens this  direct communication channel.  
Consciousness makes this direct channel noisy and effectively shuts it 
down.  I would even say, that a conscious brain is a brain that lost its 
high speed connection to Information Ocean.  It is basically on an 
autopilot to do the daily chores without to much creativity or thought.  
A conscious brain is an algorithmic brain, preprogrammed like Trurl's 
machine to do all things starts with "n".

To open a channel to Information Ocean, all those individual drops of 
exocapsulated informations where the exoskeletons are the protons, 
electron, etc=85 has to entangle in the brain.  It is entangled in the =
brain, because of the structure of the brain and Penrose with Hameroff =
wrote extensively about it.  I agree with the mechanism,  but have an =
opposite view on its purpose.  Penrose and Hameroff thinks that the =
entangled water is  in the microtubules where computation takes place =
and consciousness arise.  My thinking is, that consciousness is there =
with the same process, but as a fragmented process all the time.  The =
entanglement in the brain becomes a communication channel to Information =
Ocean when consciousness steps aside, with that it allows the =
entanglement to be enhanced and that enhancement opens the channel.  =
When the conscious mind comes back - the person wakes up, the creative =
moment passed, the flow is broken -, the entanglement gets fragmented =
and the channel to Information Ocean closes.

Can this channel activity to Information Ocean enhanced and learned ?  =
Well with more dreaming sure.  An example of it is Benzol with his =
snake.  To get to the stage of flow is also a help, but this channel is =
a rather "slow" speed, compared to the speed of the other two, but still =
much higher than what a conscious mind is able to produce.  I still =
remember my physics professor, Miklos Dede, who were able to get to this =
flow by will.  Whenever a hard question was posted to him, he looked =
somewhere to the upper right, his bright eyes fixed there on something, =
then came back to reality and told the best answer in a very fluent way, =
like if he would read it from a book, without hesitation.  Of course on =
the long run genetical engineering is the tool to make this channel =
enhancement possible in the everyday life.

Mathematica can be a helper application to clear the road that leads to =
less conscious thinking, that is helping the brain to get to the =
creative moment stage.  But just as with almost everything else practice =
makes the Master, and to experience flow, mastery is a requirement.

J=E1nos

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11635

FromVince Virgilio <blueschi@gmail.com>
Date2012-09-06 08:18 +0000
Message-ID<k29m8p$aba$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
To borrow a pithy from Wheeler: It-from-Bit?

On Sunday, September 2, 2012 4:37:27 AM UTC-4, J=E1nos L=F6bb wrote:
. . . about itty-bitty stuff.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11640

FromJános Löbb <janos@lobb.com>
Date2012-09-07 08:55 +0000
Message-ID<k2ccq1$f0i$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
Yep.  Mostly as  described here by Cahill and Klinger:
http://arxiv.org/pdf/gr-qc/9605018v1.pdf
See the text between equations (20) and (21).

flux ~ flow of information in Information Ocean.
condensation ~  emerged structure in Reality to extend the flux into the material World.

Inspiration to it came from S. Lem: Solaris, Invincible

On Sep 6, 2012, at 4:14 AM, Vince Virgilio wrote:

> To borrow a pithy from Wheeler: It-from-Bit?
>
> On Sunday, September 2, 2012 4:37:27 AM UTC-4, J=E1nos L=F6bb wrote:
> . . . about itty-bitty stuff.
>

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11655

FromJohn Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com>
Date2012-09-07 09:01 +0000
Message-ID<k2cd5p$f5n$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
On Thursday, September 6, 2012 2:19:40 AM UTC-6, Vince Virgilio wrote:
> To borrow a pithy from Wheeler: It-from-Bit?

That's a great example of how psychology drives the preferences of scientists and mathematicians. Dualism is a powerful psychological drive in human beings, but it gets little support from reality. Is it true that Pluto is a planet? That's a big deal to some people, but it matters little. "Planet" is the name of a simple (and rather shifty) story we tell about celestial objects. "Pluto" is the name of another story, but that's much more complex. The concrete reality behind the story is easier to find, and we can relate it to other stories (e.g. "methane"). Dualism is actually a barrier to real understanding here.

The powerful instinct to dualism misleads in other ways. Many people have a superstitious faith in its elaboration, (two-valued) logic. But while logic is useful in elucidating the relationships between hypotheses, it cannot determine truth. Logic steps from falsehood to falsehood as easily as it steps from truth to truth.

Then note that Boole believed his algebra (a further elaboration of dualism) to represent the "Laws of Thought". But we've constructed machines that can evaluate Boolean expressions trillions of times faster and more accurately than we humans can. Actual thought based on Boolean mechanism remains elusive. I thus think Boole's belief has been comprehensibly falsified.

One might note that bits are decent raw material for some kinds of mathematical modeling. Still, they have unfortunate limitations. A newly synthesized simple molecule can find its "ground" configuration in picoseconds, while a highly complex binary supercomputer takes hours or days to compute the same thing. It thus seems unreasonable to think that bits are fundamental to anything physical.

The gnurdiest fortune cookie fortune I ever saw read "Digital devices are composed of analog components." A fine piece of wisdom.

Wheeler was an example of the kind of theoretical "physicist" who forgets that physics is fundamentally, well, physical. The mathematical stories we tell are not fundamental: in the end, they are only stories. The physical phenomena themselves are fundamental.

But clearly, dualism is an expression of a very important cognitive mechanism for the practice of mathematics. So, while we might wish to dismiss it as a bad metal habit, that would surely be a mistake. Indeed, this message is full of dualism: while dualism isn't very true to how the world works, it seems essential to human communication. Can we, in mathematics and science education, learn to better exploit this mechanism while also teaching awareness of its profound difficulties?

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11661

FromJános Löbb <janos@lobb.com>
Date2012-09-08 07:09 +0000
Message-ID<k2eqv1$k8c$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
The bit as the measuring unit of information is a human creation, just 
as the meter is for distance.  It is a human abstraction, to describe a 
physical attribute.  It is a "secondary" abstraction, made by humans, 
who themselves are built from "primary" abstractions called elementary 
particles.  Does not matter how hard do I look an elementary particle, 
or even a mountainy, I do not see just from the "outside" the 
intelligence that is capable to make this secondary abstraction.  Now a 
machine is a "tertiary" abstraction, and being so it is much more 
convoluted and complicated and  slower than a primary one, for example a 
simple molecule.  A computer, a machine does not have a connection to 
Information Ocean, like a human has, because it is not built from 
humans, but by humans.  So a machine is stuck at the secondary or 
tertiary abstraction level and till humans are not building that special 
parts - like a human brain -, for the machine to communicate to 
Information Ocean, the machine will never able to do more, just to build 
things starting with "n", - like numeric :-)  Telling otherwise the 
information in Information Ocean is not really that bit that we humans 
use to measure information content, just as distance is not really the 
same as the meter to measure it.  Probably we would run into similar 
difficulties with human perceivable information as we go down the scale 
as we had with distance as we approached the atomic scale.


On Sep 7, 2012, at 4:55 AM, John Doty wrote:

> On Thursday, September 6, 2012 2:19:40 AM UTC-6, Vince Virgilio wrote:
>> To borrow a pithy from Wheeler: It-from-Bit?
>
> That's a great example of how psychology drives the preferences of 
scientists and mathematicians. Dualism is a powerful psychological drive 
in human beings, but it gets little support from reality. Is it true 
that Pluto is a planet? That's a big deal to some people, but it matters 
little. "Planet" is the name of a simple (and rather shifty) story we 
tell about celestial objects. "Pluto" is the name of another story, but 
that's much more complex. The concrete reality behind the story is 
easier to find, and we can relate it to other stories (e.g. "methane"). 
Dualism is actually a barrier to real understanding here.
>
> The powerful instinct to dualism misleads in other ways. Many people 
have a superstitious faith in its elaboration, (two-valued) logic. But 
while logic is useful in elucidating the relationships between 
hypotheses, it cannot determine truth. Logic steps from falsehood to 
falsehood as easily as it steps from truth to truth.
>
> Then note that Boole believed his algebra (a further elaboration of 
dualism) to represent the "Laws of Thought". But we've constructed 
machines that can evaluate Boolean expressions trillions of times faster 
and more accurately than we humans can. Actual thought based on Boolean 
mechanism remains elusive. I thus think Boole's belief has been 
comprehensibly falsified.
>
> One might note that bits are decent raw material for some kinds of 
mathematical modeling. Still, they have unfortunate limitations. A newly 
synthesized simple molecule can find its "ground" configuration in 
picoseconds, while a highly complex binary supercomputer takes hours or 
days to compute the same thing. It thus seems unreasonable to think that 
bits are fundamental to anything physical.
>
> The gnurdiest fortune cookie fortune I ever saw read "Digital devices 
are composed of analog components." A fine piece of wisdom.
>
> Wheeler was an example of the kind of theoretical "physicist" who 
forgets that physics is fundamentally, well, physical. The mathematical 
stories we tell are not fundamental: in the end, they are only stories. 
The physical phenomena themselves are fundamental.
>
> But clearly, dualism is an expression of a very important cognitive 
mechanism for the practice of mathematics. So, while we might wish to 
dismiss it as a bad metal habit, that would surely be a mistake. Indeed, 
this message is full of dualism: while dualism isn't very true to how 
the world works, it seems essential to human communication. Can we, in 
mathematics and science education, learn to better exploit this 
mechanism while also teaching awareness of its profound difficulties?
>

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11677

FromJohn Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com>
Date2012-09-08 07:48 +0000
Message-ID<k2et93$kme$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
On Friday, September 7, 2012 2:56:37 AM UTC-6, J=E1nos L=F6bb wrote:
> Yep.  Mostly as  described here by Cahill and Klinger:
>
> http://arxiv.org/pdf/gr-qc/9605018v1.pdf
>
> See the text between equations (20) and (21).
>
>
>
> flux ~ flow of information in Information Ocean.
>
> condensation ~  emerged structure in Reality to extend the flux into the material World.
>
>
>
> Inspiration to it came from S. Lem: Solaris, Invincible

But there's no physics here. It's all fantasy. There's nothing in this that can be detected or measured by any achievable enhancement of human senses.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11682

FromRalph Dratman <ralph.dratman@gmail.com>
Date2012-09-09 09:13 +0000
Message-ID<k2hmis$pu0$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
I agree with John Doty. Without experimental verification, there would be
no distinction between our description of the world and some endless
discussion about dancing angels.

But we do possess the ability to make measurements -- to compare
received theory and recorded facts with our ideas. Performed continually
all around us, the tests and re-tests lead to an amazingly consistent
picture of our world as a real place with real physical laws.

Even more surprisingly, the functioning of human technology demonstrates
our great mastery of the situations and substances of that world. Can you
doubt the little GPS in your car, and what we put in the skies to make it
work? Do we now have a large robot functioning on Mars? Did we build a fire
beside which the sun is a cold mist, and find within it a rare and tiny gem
named Higgs?

And here we encounter a genuine paradox: the confirmation -- ubiquitous,
vivid, inarguable -- of the General Theory of Unreasonable Effectiveness.

Ralph Dratman


 John Doty wrote,

> But there's no physics here. It's all fantasy. There's nothing in this
> that can be detected or measured by any achievable enhancement of human
> senses.
>

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11700

FromJohn Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com>
Date2012-09-11 06:33 +0000
Message-ID<k2mm0n$4v4$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
> Mathematical Platonism is modern form is no more than a belief that
> the natural world is governed by "laws", which are discovered by human beings but exist independently of them and can be expressed in
> mathematical form.

The natural world is, of course, the domain of science, not mathematics. The imagined world of Platonic mathematics is most definitely *not* the natural world, as it is inaccessible to the methods of science. But mathematics as a product of human thought is most definitely accessible to cognitive science.

> Like all metaphysics worth its salt, this belief can neither be
> validated nor refuted. Anybody who thinks that it can be
> "comprehensively demolished" is either using rhetorics more fitting to a political than a philosophical dispute or else should catch up on
> his Hume.

A hypothesis that won't stand up to test deserves little respect. (my Bayesian colleagues can even argue this mathematically). But mathematics is a human practice, occurring in the real world, accessible to experiment. Thus, to a scientist, you are in fact demolishing your  view by insisting that it cannot be demolished.

> Philosophically I am close to Quine, and so I
> believe that ontologically there is no fundamental difference between
> the objects studied by mathematicians, such as groups or sets, and the ones studied by physicists such as atoms or electrons.

There are absolutely fundamental differences. Physical objects are accessible to experiment. The properties of groups result entirely from the definition of "group". But no amount of reasoning can tell you much about the properties of atoms given only the definition of "atom".

> They are all human posits which we use to "explain" the sense data
> which arise from some independent reality. But as the the actual
> nature of this reality we can only speculate and in doing so we can
> rely on nothing more then our aesthetic judgement.

No. I agree completely that aesthetic judgement directs mathematics, but science is directed by evidence. We often see that aesthetic judgement undisciplined by real world evidence is wrong.

> So what
> exactly is the evolutionary path from a near "laboratory animal" to
> Riemann or Perelman?

I think it's similar to the evolutionary path from laboratory animal to elite athelete. Sports like ice skating are not really like anything humans evolved to do, but involve physical and cognitive "modules" evolved for other purposes, combined in novel ways. Scientific understanding of this has made it possible to teach atheletes to perform feats once thought impossible, like "quadruple jumps". I see no reason this shouldn't also apply to mathematics.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11709

FromAndrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com>
Date2012-09-12 07:02 +0000
Message-ID<k2pc1b$998$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
On 11 Sep 2012, at 08:34, John Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com> wrote:

>> So what
>> exactly is the evolutionary path from a near "laboratory animal" to
>> Riemann or Perelman?
>
> I think it's similar to the evolutionary path from laboratory animal 
to elite athelete. Sports like ice skating are not really like anything 
humans evolved to do, but involve physical and cognitive "modules" 
evolved for other purposes, combined in novel ways. Scientific 
understanding of this has made it possible to teach atheletes to perform 
feats once thought impossible, like "quadruple jumps". I see no reason 
this shouldn't also apply to mathematics.

Oh, so presumably you have now explained the "mystery of Ramanujan" 
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Srinivasa_Ramanujan)?

Andrzej=

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11718

FromAndrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com>
Date2012-09-12 07:29 +0000
Message-ID<k2pdkr$9g1$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
As I have written before, I don't think this is an appropriate space for 
explaining the basic ideas on modern philosophy to people who clearly 
have never heard of them. Instead I suggest reading:

=
http://www.igewem.tu-dresden.de/die_tu_dresden/fakultaeten/philosophische_
fakultaet/iph/thph/braeuer/lehre/metameta/Quine%20-%20On%20What%20There%20=
Is.pdf

and

http://faculty.unlv.edu/jwood/wm/Quine.pdf

It might (or might not) become clear what I have been hinting at: that 
is that the idea of a sharp distinction between "experiment" and 
"theory" etc. are illusionary. The results of every experiment have to 
be judged by a human mind and interpreted in the light of some theory 
and there will always be many alternatives "explaining" whatever 
"evidence" is provided by an experiment. One of such theories that can 
never be completely discounted is that the experimenter himself is 
hallucinating (or is taking part in a group hallucination -such things 
have known to happen on a massive scale), or the results are due to some 
deliberate deception, etc, etc. In the end the choice between one such 
theory and another is not based on yet another experiment (you cannot 
refute either the "hand of God" or "evolutionary development" by any 
experiment) but on considerations like simplicity (it is simpler to 
believe that what you see in front of you when you get up in the morning 
is "really there" than that it is the result of very elaborate 
deception, involving holography etc., even though the later might 
actually be the case), which are based on aesthetics. The Copernican 
system was chosen over the Ptolemaic one, not because it was better 
confirmed by experiment but because it was simpler. One can "explain" 
everything that general relativity explains without using non-Euclidean 
geometry - but again the same thing happens. This sort of thing has been 
discussed in the philosophy of science since the beginning of this 
century so much that it has now become passe (look up Karl Popper, Imre 
Lakatos, Paul Feyerabend, Michael Polanyi etc, etc=85). There is no 
point repeating all this stuff on a forum devoted to Mathematica.

Andrzej Kozlowski



On 11 Sep 2012, at 08:34, John Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com> wrote:

>> Mathematical Platonism is modern form is no more than a belief that
>> the natural world is governed by "laws", which are discovered by 
human beings but exist independently of them and can be expressed in
>> mathematical form.
>
> The natural world is, of course, the domain of science, not 
mathematics. The imagined world of Platonic mathematics is most 
definitely *not* the natural world, as it is inaccessible to the methods 
of science. But mathematics as a product of human thought is most 
definitely accessible to cognitive science.
>
>> Like all metaphysics worth its salt, this belief can neither be
>> validated nor refuted. Anybody who thinks that it can be
>> "comprehensively demolished" is either using rhetorics more fitting 
to a political than a philosophical dispute or else should catch up on
>> his Hume.
>
> A hypothesis that won't stand up to test deserves little respect. (my 
Bayesian colleagues can even argue this mathematically). But mathematics 
is a human practice, occurring in the real world, accessible to 
experiment. Thus, to a scientist, you are in fact demolishing your  view 
by insisting that it cannot be demolished.
>
>> Philosophically I am close to Quine, and so I
>> believe that ontologically there is no fundamental difference between
>> the objects studied by mathematicians, such as groups or sets, and 
the ones studied by physicists such as atoms or electrons.
>
> There are absolutely fundamental differences. Physical objects are 
accessible to experiment. The properties of groups result entirely from 
the definition of "group". But no amount of reasoning can tell you much 
about the properties of atoms given only the definition of "atom".
>
>> They are all human posits which we use to "explain" the sense data
>> which arise from some independent reality. But as the the actual
>> nature of this reality we can only speculate and in doing so we can
>> rely on nothing more then our aesthetic judgement.
>
> No. I agree completely that aesthetic judgement directs mathematics, 
but science is directed by evidence. We often see that aesthetic 
judgement undisciplined by real world evidence is wrong.
>
>> So what
>> exactly is the evolutionary path from a near "laboratory animal" to
>> Riemann or Perelman?
>
> I think it's similar to the evolutionary path from laboratory animal 
to elite athelete. Sports like ice skating are not really like anything 
humans evolved to do, but involve physical and cognitive "modules" 
evolved for other purposes, combined in novel ways. Scientific 
understanding of this has made it possible to teach atheletes to perform 
feats once thought impossible, like "quadruple jumps". I see no reason 
this shouldn't also apply to mathematics.
>

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11748

FromJohn Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com>
Date2012-09-15 07:44 +0000
Message-ID<k31bla$mnp$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
On Wednesday, September 12, 2012 1:03:16 AM UTC-6, Andrzej Kozlowski wrote:
> On 11 Sep 2012, at 08:34, John Doty  wrote:
>
>
>
> >> So what
>
> >> exactly is the evolutionary path from a near "laboratory animal" to
>
> >> Riemann or Perelman?
>
> >
>
> > I think it's similar to the evolutionary path from laboratory animal
>
> to elite athelete. Sports like ice skating are not really like anything
>
> humans evolved to do, but involve physical and cognitive "modules"
>
> evolved for other purposes, combined in novel ways. Scientific
>
> understanding of this has made it possible to teach atheletes to perform
>
> feats once thought impossible, like "quadruple jumps". I see no reason
>
> this shouldn't also apply to mathematics.
>
>
>
> Oh, so presumably you have now explained the "mystery of Ramanujan"

Hardy, who was in a better position than either of us to judge, did not appear to find Ramanujan particularly mysterious. According to Hardy, Ramanujan ombined a power of generalization, a feeling for form, and a capacity for rapid modification of his hypotheses". That even sounds like the kind of things we say about athletes ("hand quickness", "peripheral vision", ..., and also sounds like the sort of cognitive modules Nunez talks about. Ramanujan did not obtain his mathematical knowledge by magic: he studied for years, but without conventional direction. So, he became a very unconventional mathematician.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11755

FromJohn Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com>
Date2012-09-15 07:45 +0000
Message-ID<k31bni$mqe$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
On Wednesday, September 12, 2012 1:30:44 AM UTC-6, Andrzej Kozlowski wrote:
> As I have written before, I don't think this is an appropriate space for
>
> explaining the basic ideas on modern philosophy to people who clearly
>
> have never heard of them.

Andrzej,

Of course I've heard of them. But I don't consider mid 20th century "modern" here. Science and mathematics have changed drastically in the last century: philosophy hasn't yet fully digested these developments. However, philosopher/mathematicians like Hersh have made very significant  advances in "humanist" mathematical philosophy.

> http://faculty.unlv.edu/jwood/wm/Quine.pdf

Quine is an interesting fantasist, but I can't consider him any more reliable as a guide to reality than, say, J. R. R. Tolkien. He utterly misunderstands physics. An ontological commitment to the existence of real numbers is certainly unnecessary to a physicist. Real numbers present serious difficulties to physics. We must carefully step around these problems. This has caused a number of physicists (including one who should be well known here) to seek discrete models of "fundamental" physics. From my perspective, approximate numbers are much truer to physics than mathematical reals. But approximation is toxic to much mathematics, and we also like to tap the power of the exact. So we wander from realistic approximation into the unrealism of mathematical "real" numbers and back. Mathematica is an extremely useful tool for this kind of journey: that's why I'm here. But we are also constantly reminded here of the difficulties of mixing exact mathematical reasoning with realistic approximation.

As Hersh points out, part of the difficulty is that there are different kinds of existence. In physics, we frequently "throw out" solutions to the math when they violate informal conditions like causality. Such solutions "exist" in the mathematical sense, but since the correspond to behavior that is never observed in the physical world they do not "exist" in the physical sense.

> It might (or might not) become clear what I have been hinting at: that
>
> is that the idea of a sharp distinction between "experiment" and
>
> "theory" etc. are illusionary.

That's very much a theorist's ideology. This is why it is advisable to keep theorists away from dangerous machinery ;-)

"In theory there is no difference between theory and practice. In practice there is." Regardless of the attribution you choose (Einstein, Berra, ...), this is wisdom.

> There is no
> point repeating all this stuff on a forum devoted to Mathematica.

The original issue of this thread was education. A philosophy that cannot distinguish between reality and hallucination is useless here. But, if we can understand mathematics as a human social construct, we can connect it to human social activities like education.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11758

FromAndrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com>
Date2012-09-16 07:21 +0000
Message-ID<k33umm$qt9$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
On 15 Sep 2012, at 09:36, John Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com> wrote:

> On Wednesday, September 12, 2012 1:03:16 AM UTC-6, Andrzej Kozlowski wrote:
>> On 11 Sep 2012, at 08:34, John Doty  wrote:
>>
>>
>>
>>>> So what
>>
>>>> exactly is the evolutionary path from a near "laboratory animal" to
>>
>>>> Riemann or Perelman?
>>
>>>
>>
>>> I think it's similar to the evolutionary path from laboratory animal
>>
>> to elite athelete. Sports like ice skating are not really like anything
>>
>> humans evolved to do, but involve physical and cognitive "modules"
>>
>> evolved for other purposes, combined in novel ways. Scientific
>>
>> understanding of this has made it possible to teach atheletes to perform
>>
>> feats once thought impossible, like "quadruple jumps". I see no reason
>>
>> this shouldn't also apply to mathematics.
>>
>>
>>
>> Oh, so presumably you have now explained the "mystery of Ramanujan"
>
> Hardy, who was in a better position than either of us to judge, did not appear to find Ramanujan particularly mysterious. According to Hardy, Ramanujan ombined a power of generalization, a feeling for form, and a capacity for rapid modification of his hypotheses". That even sounds like the kind of things we say about athletes ("hand quickness", "peripheral vision", ..., and also sounds like the sort of cognitive modules Nunez talks about. Ramanujan did not obtain his mathematical knowledge by magic: he studied for years, but without conventional direction. So, he became a very unconventional mathematician.
>

Well, the real point is that your whole argument (like almost everything else in your posts on this topic) is based on typical pseudo-science, strongly resembling Marxism. Marx asserted the inevitability of the "proletarian revolution" after which human beings will achieve all their latent capacities and will all be able to become Ramanujans (if they only wish). The fact that nothing of this kind ever happened and that everything that happened contradicted Marx's claims was no argument for marxists, since the "prediction" was open ended. So is, of course, your claim that with "proper training" we could produce Ramanujan's at will. The fact that nothing of this kind has ever happened and that nobody has yet succeeded in any such enterprise  (as well as the existing mass of evidence against these sort of claims) does matter to you, since your claims are also open ended and no amount of failure will disprove them. In the face of this sort of pseudo-scientific unfalisfiable claims all arguments are futile so here I end mine.

Andrzej Kozlowski


[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11761

FromAndrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com>
Date2012-09-16 07:22 +0000
Message-ID<k33unl$qtl$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
>
> Of course I've heard of them. But I don't consider mid 20th century 
"modern" here. Science and mathematics have changed drastically in the 
last century: philosophy hasn't yet fully digested these developments. 
However, philosopher/mathematicians like Hersh have made very 
significant  advances in "humanist" mathematical philosophy.

But these very comments confirm what I have been arguing. "Science and 
mathematics have changed drastically in the last century". Presumably 
you mean "in the last 40 years or so"? Well who could argue with that? 
Indeed, new theorems have been proved, problems solved, phenomena 
discovered. And yet, the sentence is pure vapour - rhetorics for the 
naive.  In fact, nothing has occurred in mathematics that would in any 
fundamental way change our view of the nature of mathematics since 
Goedel (died 1978). The same is true for physics: the last discovery 
that fundamentally  affected our understanding of the nature of the 
subject took place in  1972: it was the first of many experiments that 
confirmed the violation of Bell's inequalities - something that in my 
opinion totally undermines the view of physics you have been arguing 
for. About a year ago I attended a conference where the latest research 
on the fundamental issues affected by this were discussed (such as the 
notion of "independent reality") so can say with confidence that in all 
essential respects the situation remains as it was in 1972. So what are 
these supposed advances in mathematics and physics that have not been 
absorbed by " "humanist" mathematical philosophy?

And what does "humanist" mean in this context? All the philosophers I 
mentioned have been either scientists or mathematicians. Michael Polanyi 
was a great chemist, who would have probably won the Nobel prize (it was 
later won by his son John) if he did not at one point decide that 
philosophy was more important than chemistry (he was right then). 
Polanyi was, of course, a leading exponent of the view that intellectual 
(or aesthetic) judgement is the driving force of scientific discovery. 
You also mention Hersh, presumably Rueben, a mathematician, writer of 
popular articles and an amateur philosopher. Well it is well known that 
Hersh was an admirer of Imre Lakatos, who is well known for denying the 
distinction between mathematics and empirical sciences. He is also known 
for his denial that Darwin's theory satisfies his criteria for being 
considered "scientific" (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imre_Lakatos)


> Quine is an interesting fantasist, but I can't consider him any more 
reliable as a guide to reality than, say, J. R. R. Tolkien.

Well, as far as I am concerned, he has a far better claim to being such 
a guide than anyone involved in this exchange.

>>
>
> The original issue of this thread was education. A philosophy that 
cannot distinguish between reality and hallucination is useless here. 
But, if we can understand mathematics as a human social construct, we 
can connect it to human social activities like education.

The issue was mathematics education of non-mathematicians. You extended 
it beyond its proper limits to the nature of mathematics and 
mathematicians. I consider this a worthless diversion. As far as 
mathematics is concerned the old adage has always been true: "Those who 
can, do. Those who can't, teach. Those who can't teach, teach how to 
teach."

Andrzej Kozlowski

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11775

FromJános Löbb <janos@lobb.com>
Date2012-09-17 04:22 +0000
Message-ID<k368if$1tq$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
On Sep 15, 2012, at 3:38 AM, John Doty wrote:

> On Wednesday, September 12, 2012 1:30:44 AM UTC-6, Andrzej Kozlowski wrote:
>> As I have written before, I don't think this is an appropriate space for
>>
>> explaining the basic ideas on modern philosophy to people who clearly
>>
>> have never heard of them.
>
> Andrzej,
>
> Of course I've heard of them. But I don't consider mid 20th century "modern" here. Science and mathematics have changed drastically in the last century: philosophy hasn't yet fully digested these developments. However, philosopher/mathematicians like Hersh have made very significant  advances in "humanist" mathematical philosophy.
>
>> http://faculty.unlv.edu/jwood/wm/Quine.pdf
>
> Quine is an interesting fantasist, but I can't consider him any more reliable as a guide to reality than, say, J. R. R. Tolkien. He utterly misunderstands physics. An ontological commitment to the existence of real numbers is certainly unnecessary to a physicist. Real numbers present serious difficulties to physics. We must carefully step around these problems. This has caused a number of physicists (including one who should be well known here) to seek discrete models of "fundamental" physics. From my perspective, approximate numbers are much truer to physics than mathematical reals. But approximation is toxic to much mathematics, and we also like to tap the power of the exact. So we wander from realistic approximation into the unrealism of mathematical "real" numbers and back. Mathematica is an extremely useful tool for this kind of journey: that's why I'm here. But we are also constantly reminded here of the difficulties of mixing exact mathematical reasoning with realistic approximation.

To my knowledge,  - that might be very limited -, mathematics is most effective in physics where differential equations can be found and solved.  Also to my knowledge the existence of differential equations and their solutions rely on differentiable functions.  Differentiable function has to be continuous.  Continuity relies on real numbers and real numbers cannot exist without the continuum hypotheses.  The continuum hypotheses cannot be proved or disproved with all the axioms crafted for real numbers. 

Once upon a time I had a short discussion of it with my analysis teacher ZoltE1n Dar=F3czy, who made a name for himself in the area of "function equations" .  His brother S=E1ndor, was a well known physicist by the way under Alex Szalay in Debrecen, so I am sure there were some brotherly and some not so brotherly philosophical discussions between the two as they advanced in their selected area of interest.  It was first semester analysis and in one of the breaks between the two hour long lectures, I told to him, that in a real quantum theory the usual mathematical tools cannot be applied, because as we go down the distance scale, the metric cannot be established preciously in reality because of the Heisenberg relations, neither in the Weierstarss, nor in the Cauchy interpretation.  He smiled at me and replied:  "then you have to trow out the continuum hypotheses, but with it you loose all the power of mathematics in physics".  Then he further said, still smiling:  "Show me a physicist who can tell me preciously how the light is bouncing back from a surface even using all the mathematical tools they have."

>
> As Hersh points out, part of the difficulty is that there are different kinds of existence. In physics, we frequently "throw out" solutions to the math when they violate informal conditions like causality. Such solutions "exist" in the mathematical sense, but since the correspond to behavior that is never observed in the physical world they do not "exist" in the physical sense.
>
>> It might (or might not) become clear what I have been hinting at: that
>>
>> is that the idea of a sharp distinction between "experiment" and
>>
>> "theory" etc. are illusionary.
>
> That's very much a theorist's ideology. This is why it is advisable to keep theorists away from dangerous machinery ;-)
>
> "In theory there is no difference between theory and practice. In practice there is." Regardless of the attribution you choose (Einstein, Berra, ...), this is wisdom.
>
>> There is no
>> point repeating all this stuff on a forum devoted to Mathematica.
>
> The original issue of this thread was education. A philosophy that cannot distinguish between reality and hallucination is useless here. But, if we can understand mathematics as a human social construct, we can connect it to human social activities like education.
>

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11794

FromAndrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com>
Date2012-09-18 07:53 +0000
Message-ID<k39994$9sd$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
On 17 Sep 2012, at 06:23, J=E1nos L=F6bb <janos@lobb.com> wrote:

>  Continuity relies on real numbers and real numbers cannot exist without the continuum hypotheses.

The second part is not true.

Andrzej Kozlowski

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11797

FromAndrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com>
Date2012-09-18 07:53 +0000
Message-ID<k399a3$9sl$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11548
On 17 Sep 2012, at 09:36, Andrzej Kozlowski <akoz@mimuw.edu.pl> wrote:

>
> On 17 Sep 2012, at 06:23, J=E1nos L=F6bb <janos@lobb.com> wrote:
>
>> Continuity relies on real numbers and real numbers cannot exist without the continuum hypotheses.
>
> The second part is not true.
>
> Andrzej Kozlowski


I think there is a confusion of terminology involved. What is generally known as "The Continuum Hpothesis" is a statement about cardinal numbers, known to be undecidable in the Zermelo-Fraenkel set theory (and independent of the axiom of choice). It is a mathematical (or "logical" statement and, is not implied by the existence of real numbers (otherwise it would not be undecidable).

It is clear however that what was meant in the post from which the above quote was taken by "continuum hypothesis" was something quite different: an informal "belief" that the real numbers correspond to some physical reality. That of course is a metaphysical statement, which means that it is also "undecidable" but in a very different sense from the sense in which "The Continuum Hypothesis" us undecidable.

Andrzej Kozlowski

[toc] | [prev] | [standalone]


Back to top | Article view | comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica


csiph-web