Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica > #11422 > unrolled thread

How to make fitting code using NDSolve?

Started byJYeom <cygnis@hanmail.net>
First post2012-08-20 08:16 +0000
Last post2012-10-19 06:48 +0000
Articles 3 — 3 participants

Back to article view | Back to comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica


Contents

  How to make fitting code using NDSolve? JYeom <cygnis@hanmail.net> - 2012-08-20 08:16 +0000
    Re: How to make fitting code using NDSolve? "Kevin J. McCann" <kjm@KevinMcCann.com> - 2012-08-21 01:39 +0000
    Re: How to make fitting code using NDSolve? long.he.dragon@gmail.com - 2012-10-19 06:48 +0000

#11422 — How to make fitting code using NDSolve?

FromJYeom <cygnis@hanmail.net>
Date2012-08-20 08:16 +0000
SubjectHow to make fitting code using NDSolve?
Message-ID<k0sroq$jn4$1@smc.vnet.net>
Hello,
I am trying to fit some basic data to a partial differential equation- here are the data points:

data = {
  {2.113, 2.915*^-7}, {2.256, 2.758*^-7}, {2.303, 2.567*^-7}, {2.493,
   2.343*^-7}, {2.635, 2.085*^-7}, {2.825, 1.838*^-7}, {3.015,
   1.614*^-7}, {3.205, 1.412*^-7}, {3.538, 1.199*^-7}, {3.775,
   1.03*^-7}, {4.108, 8.173*^-8}, {4.487, 6.266*^-8}, {4.915,
   4.695*^-8}, {5.295, 3.349*^-8}, {5.912, 2.34*^-8}, {6.672,
   1.554*^-8}, {7.527, 7.692*^-9}, {8.524, 5.448*^-9}, {9.426,
   4.326*^-9}, {10.23, 3.205*^-9}, {10.99,
   2.083*^-9}, {11.99, -1.608*^-10}
  }

And there are four parameters to fit in our fitting equation:

model[ka_?NumberQ, kr_?NumberQ, kd_?NumberQ,
  kb_?NumberQ] := (model[ka, kr, kd, kb] =
   First[Subscript[Dye, 0] /. NDSolve[{
       Derivative[1][Subscript[Dye, 0]][
         t] ==\[VeryThinSpace]-ka Subscript[Dye, 0][t] +
         kr  Subscript[Dyes, 0][t], Subscript[Dye, 0][0] == 1.22 10^-6,
       Derivative[1][Subscript[Dye, 1]][
         t] == -ka Subscript[Dye, 1][t] + kr  Subscript[Dyes, 1][t],
       Subscript[Dye, 1][0] == 0,
      
       Derivative[1][Subscript[Dyes, 0]][t] ==
        ka  Subscript[Dye, 0][t] - kr  Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] -
         kd  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] -
         kd /2 * Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t],
       Subscript[Dyes, 0][0] == 0,
       Derivative[1][Subscript[Dyes, 1]][t] ==
        ka Subscript[Dye, 1][t] -
         kd Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] -
         kr Subscript[Dyes, 1][t] -
         kd  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t],
       Subscript[Dyes, 1][0] == 0,
      
       Derivative[1][Subscript[CI, 0]][
         t] == -kd Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] -
         kd/2*  Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t] -
         kb Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[HDye, 0][t] -
         kb/2* Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[HDye, 1][t],
       Subscript[CI, 0][0] == 3.18 10^-3,
       Derivative[1][Subscript[CI, 1]][
         t] == -kd Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] -
         kd/2*  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t] -
         kb Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[HDye, 0][t] -
         kb/2*Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[HDye, 1][t],
       Subscript[CI, 1][0] == 0,
      
       Derivative[1][Subscript[HDye, 0]][t] ==
        kd  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] +
         kd/2* Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t] -
         kb  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[HDye, 0][t] -
         kb /2* Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[HDye, 1][t],
       Subscript[HDye, 0][0] == 0,
       Derivative[1][Subscript[HDye, 1]][t] ==
        kd  Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] +
         kd  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t] -
         kb Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[HDye, 0][t] -
         kb  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[HDye, 1][t],
       Subscript[HDye, 1][0] == 0
       }, {Subscript[Dye, 0][t], Subscript[Dyes, 0][t],
       Subscript[CI, 0][t], Subscript[HDye, 0][t],
       Subscript[Dye, 1][t], Subscript[Dyes, 1][t],
       Subscript[CI, 1][t], Subscript[HDye, 1][t]}, {t, 0, 12}]])

In the NDSolve, what we want to fit is Dye0[t]. So we wrote code for fitting using FindFit:

fit = FindFit[data,
  model[ ka, kr, kd, kb][Subscript[Dye,
   0]], {{ka, 10^(-4)}, {kr, 10^(-4)}, {kd, 500}, {kb, 500}},
  Subscript[Dye, 0]]

However, we encountered the error message like this:

FindFit::nrlnum: "The function value {-2.915*10^-7+Subscript[Dye, 0][2.113],-2.758*10^-7+Subscript[Dye, 0][2.256],-2.567*10^-7+Subscript[Dye, 0][2.303],<<16>>,-3.205*10^-9+Subscript[Dye, 0][10.23],-2.083*10^-9+Subscript[Dye,0][10.99],1.608*10^-10+Subscript[Dye, 0][11.99]} is not a list of real numbers with dimensions {22} at {ka,kr,kd,kb} = {0.0001,0.0001,500.,500.}."

The desirable solution for parameter is around ka= 0.67, kr = 10^(-3), kd=1600, kb=1600.

Does anyone know what I am doing wrong?

[toc] | [next] | [standalone]


#11432

From"Kevin J. McCann" <kjm@KevinMcCann.com>
Date2012-08-21 01:39 +0000
Message-ID<k0uoru$n7j$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11422
There are a couple of problems below.One is that you have a number of 
subscripted variables that need to be Symbolized first. Also, your call 
of model in FindFit has both the variables as inputs (ok), and the 
desired output, but the latter is not defined as an output in your 
definition of model.

I prefer to roll my own lsq rather than use FindFit, and have included a 
notebook under separate email. Hope this helps.

Kevin

On 8/20/2012 4:16 AM, JYeom wrote:
> Hello,
> I am trying to fit some basic data to a partial differential equation- here are the data points:
>
> data = {
>    {2.113, 2.915*^-7}, {2.256, 2.758*^-7}, {2.303, 2.567*^-7}, {2.493,
>     2.343*^-7}, {2.635, 2.085*^-7}, {2.825, 1.838*^-7}, {3.015,
>     1.614*^-7}, {3.205, 1.412*^-7}, {3.538, 1.199*^-7}, {3.775,
>     1.03*^-7}, {4.108, 8.173*^-8}, {4.487, 6.266*^-8}, {4.915,
>     4.695*^-8}, {5.295, 3.349*^-8}, {5.912, 2.34*^-8}, {6.672,
>     1.554*^-8}, {7.527, 7.692*^-9}, {8.524, 5.448*^-9}, {9.426,
>     4.326*^-9}, {10.23, 3.205*^-9}, {10.99,
>     2.083*^-9}, {11.99, -1.608*^-10}
>    }
>
> And there are four parameters to fit in our fitting equation:
>
> model[ka_?NumberQ, kr_?NumberQ, kd_?NumberQ,
>    kb_?NumberQ] := (model[ka, kr, kd, kb] =
>     First[Subscript[Dye, 0] /. NDSolve[{
>         Derivative[1][Subscript[Dye, 0]][
>           t] ==\[VeryThinSpace]-ka Subscript[Dye, 0][t] +
>           kr  Subscript[Dyes, 0][t], Subscript[Dye, 0][0] == 1.22 10^-6,
>         Derivative[1][Subscript[Dye, 1]][
>           t] == -ka Subscript[Dye, 1][t] + kr  Subscript[Dyes, 1][t],
>         Subscript[Dye, 1][0] == 0,
>
>         Derivative[1][Subscript[Dyes, 0]][t] ==
>          ka  Subscript[Dye, 0][t] - kr  Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] -
>           kd  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] -
>           kd /2 * Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t],
>         Subscript[Dyes, 0][0] == 0,
>         Derivative[1][Subscript[Dyes, 1]][t] ==
>          ka Subscript[Dye, 1][t] -
>           kd Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] -
>           kr Subscript[Dyes, 1][t] -
>           kd  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t],
>         Subscript[Dyes, 1][0] == 0,
>
>         Derivative[1][Subscript[CI, 0]][
>           t] == -kd Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] -
>           kd/2*  Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t] -
>           kb Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[HDye, 0][t] -
>           kb/2* Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[HDye, 1][t],
>         Subscript[CI, 0][0] == 3.18 10^-3,
>         Derivative[1][Subscript[CI, 1]][
>           t] == -kd Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] -
>           kd/2*  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t] -
>           kb Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[HDye, 0][t] -
>           kb/2*Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[HDye, 1][t],
>         Subscript[CI, 1][0] == 0,
>
>         Derivative[1][Subscript[HDye, 0]][t] ==
>          kd  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] +
>           kd/2* Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t] -
>           kb  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[HDye, 0][t] -
>           kb /2* Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[HDye, 1][t],
>         Subscript[HDye, 0][0] == 0,
>         Derivative[1][Subscript[HDye, 1]][t] ==
>          kd  Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] +
>           kd  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t] -
>           kb Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[HDye, 0][t] -
>           kb  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[HDye, 1][t],
>         Subscript[HDye, 1][0] == 0
>         }, {Subscript[Dye, 0][t], Subscript[Dyes, 0][t],
>         Subscript[CI, 0][t], Subscript[HDye, 0][t],
>         Subscript[Dye, 1][t], Subscript[Dyes, 1][t],
>         Subscript[CI, 1][t], Subscript[HDye, 1][t]}, {t, 0, 12}]])
>
> In the NDSolve, what we want to fit is Dye0[t]. So we wrote code for fitting using FindFit:
>
> fit = FindFit[data,
>    model[ ka, kr, kd, kb][Subscript[Dye,
>     0]], {{ka, 10^(-4)}, {kr, 10^(-4)}, {kd, 500}, {kb, 500}},
>    Subscript[Dye, 0]]
>
> However, we encountered the error message like this:
>
> FindFit::nrlnum: "The function value {-2.915*10^-7+Subscript[Dye, 0][2.113],-2.758*10^-7+Subscript[Dye, 0][2.256],-2.567*10^-7+Subscript[Dye, 0][2.303],<<16>>,-3.205*10^-9+Subscript[Dye, 0][10.23],-2.083*10^-9+Subscript[Dye,0][10.99],1.608*10^-10+Subscript[Dye, 0][11.99]} is not a list of real numbers with dimensions {22} at {ka,kr,kd,kb} = {0.0001,0.0001,500.,500.}."
>
> The desirable solution for parameter is around ka= 0.67, kr = 10^(-3), kd=1600, kb=1600.
>
> Does anyone know what I am doing wrong?
>

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#12110

Fromlong.he.dragon@gmail.com
Date2012-10-19 06:48 +0000
Message-ID<k5qt37$nbr$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11422
Hi   Yeom   

I am facing some similar problem as yours.   Do you have any solution for your original post ?  
Thanks for sharing

Long


On Monday, August 20, 2012 2:16:26 AM UTC-6, JYeom wrote:
> Hello,
>
> I am trying to fit some basic data to a partial differential equation- here are the data points:
>
>
>
> data = {
>
>   {2.113, 2.915*^-7}, {2.256, 2.758*^-7}, {2.303, 2.567*^-7}, {2.493,
>
>    2.343*^-7}, {2.635, 2.085*^-7}, {2.825, 1.838*^-7}, {3.015,
>
>    1.614*^-7}, {3.205, 1.412*^-7}, {3.538, 1.199*^-7}, {3.775,
>
>    1.03*^-7}, {4.108, 8.173*^-8}, {4.487, 6.266*^-8}, {4.915,
>
>    4.695*^-8}, {5.295, 3.349*^-8}, {5.912, 2.34*^-8}, {6.672,
>
>    1.554*^-8}, {7.527, 7.692*^-9}, {8.524, 5.448*^-9}, {9.426,
>
>    4.326*^-9}, {10.23, 3.205*^-9}, {10.99,
>
>    2.083*^-9}, {11.99, -1.608*^-10}
>
>   }
>
>
>
> And there are four parameters to fit in our fitting equation:
>
>
>
> model[ka_?NumberQ, kr_?NumberQ, kd_?NumberQ,
>
>   kb_?NumberQ] := (model[ka, kr, kd, kb] =
>
>    First[Subscript[Dye, 0] /. NDSolve[{
>
>        Derivative[1][Subscript[Dye, 0]][
>
>          t] ==\[VeryThinSpace]-ka Subscript[Dye, 0][t] +
>
>          kr  Subscript[Dyes, 0][t], Subscript[Dye, 0][0] == 1.22 10^-6,
>
>        Derivative[1][Subscript[Dye, 1]][
>
>          t] == -ka Subscript[Dye, 1][t] + kr  Subscript[Dyes, 1][t],
>
>        Subscript[Dye, 1][0] == 0,
>
>      
>
>        Derivative[1][Subscript[Dyes, 0]][t] ==
>
>         ka  Subscript[Dye, 0][t] - kr  Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] -
>
>          kd  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] -
>
>          kd /2 * Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t],
>
>        Subscript[Dyes, 0][0] == 0,
>
>        Derivative[1][Subscript[Dyes, 1]][t] ==
>
>         ka Subscript[Dye, 1][t] -
>
>          kd Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] -
>
>          kr Subscript[Dyes, 1][t] -
>
>          kd  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t],
>
>        Subscript[Dyes, 1][0] == 0,
>
>      
>
>        Derivative[1][Subscript[CI, 0]][
>
>          t] == -kd Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] -
>
>          kd/2*  Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t] -
>
>          kb Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[HDye, 0][t] -
>
>          kb/2* Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[HDye, 1][t],
>
>        Subscript[CI, 0][0] == 3.18 10^-3,
>
>        Derivative[1][Subscript[CI, 1]][
>
>          t] == -kd Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] -
>
>          kd/2*  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t] -
>
>          kb Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[HDye, 0][t] -
>
>          kb/2*Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[HDye, 1][t],
>
>        Subscript[CI, 1][0] == 0,
>
>      
>
>        Derivative[1][Subscript[HDye, 0]][t] ==
>
>         kd  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] +
>
>          kd/2* Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t] -
>
>          kb  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[HDye, 0][t] -
>
>          kb /2* Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[HDye, 1][t],
>
>        Subscript[HDye, 0][0] == 0,
>
>        Derivative[1][Subscript[HDye, 1]][t] ==
>
>         kd  Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[Dyes, 0][t] +
>
>          kd  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[Dyes, 1][t] -
>
>          kb Subscript[CI, 1][t] Subscript[HDye, 0][t] -
>
>          kb  Subscript[CI, 0][t] Subscript[HDye, 1][t],
>
>        Subscript[HDye, 1][0] == 0
>
>        }, {Subscript[Dye, 0][t], Subscript[Dyes, 0][t],
>
>        Subscript[CI, 0][t], Subscript[HDye, 0][t],
>
>        Subscript[Dye, 1][t], Subscript[Dyes, 1][t],
>
>        Subscript[CI, 1][t], Subscript[HDye, 1][t]}, {t, 0, 12}]])
>
>
>
> In the NDSolve, what we want to fit is Dye0[t]. So we wrote code for fitting using FindFit:
>
>
>
> fit = FindFit[data,
>
>   model[ ka, kr, kd, kb][Subscript[Dye,
>
>    0]], {{ka, 10^(-4)}, {kr, 10^(-4)}, {kd, 500}, {kb, 500}},
>
>   Subscript[Dye, 0]]
>
>
>
> However, we encountered the error message like this:
>
>
>
> FindFit::nrlnum: "The function value {-2.915*10^-7+Subscript[Dye, 0][2.113],-2.758*10^-7+Subscript[Dye, 0][2.256],-2.567*10^-7+Subscript[Dye, 0][2.303],<<16>>,-3.205*10^-9+Subscript[Dye, 0][10.23],-2.083*10^-9+Subscript[Dye,0][10.99],1.608*10^-10+Subscript[Dye, 0][11.99]} is not a list of real numbers with dimensions {22} at {ka,kr,kd,kb} = {0.0001,0.0001,500.,500.}."
>
>
>
> The desirable solution for parameter is around ka= 0.67, kr = 10^(-3), kd=1600, kb=1600.
>
>
>
> Does anyone know what I am doing wrong?

[toc] | [prev] | [standalone]


Back to top | Article view | comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica


csiph-web