Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica > #11263 > unrolled thread

Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach...

Started by"djmpark" <djmpark@comcast.net>
First post2012-08-08 07:16 +0000
Last post2012-08-15 07:31 +0000
Articles 3 — 3 participants

Back to article view | Back to comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica

This discussion starts older than the indexed window; earlier articles aren't shown. The article labeled Started by below is the oldest one visible, not the original post.


Contents

  Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... "djmpark" <djmpark@comcast.net> - 2012-08-08 07:16 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... John Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com> - 2012-08-14 09:04 +0000
    Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach... Andrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com> - 2012-08-15 07:31 +0000

#11263 — Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach...

From"djmpark" <djmpark@comcast.net>
Date2012-08-08 07:16 +0000
SubjectRe: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach...
Message-ID<jvt3o1$luf$1@smc.vnet.net>
Alexei,

Landau just expresses the frustration that non-mathematicians have when
confronted with mathematical derivations and proofs that strive for rigor.
They may need the results and material but, darn it, it's hard. When they
finish reading a proof they might say: "Well, I suppose so." (Somehow I
can't imagine Landau saying that, but maybe he was speaking for others as
well, or perhaps he was truly frustrated with the presentations."

Let's assume that the mathematical proofs and derivations to be presented
actually are useful with regard to the material. Certain techniques, some
requiring Mathematica, can be a great help.

Background Knowledge: Does the student know what the objects are that the
proof is dealing with? It's one thing to say "Let n be an integer",
something else to say "Let f be a p-linear symmetric mapping." Can we see
some examples? It is one thing to see the derivation of a surprising
relation among objects we thought we knew all about, another thing to end up
with a hazy relation about hazy objects that we didn't know that much about
to begin with. Mathematica can help because we can generate many examples
that should give familiarity with the objects.

Motivation: To really understand most derivations and proofs takes a fair
amount of time. Is the student convinced ahead of time that the result will
be worth the effort? Can he see the problem that the derivation is to solve?
If this is a generalization from an easier problem can he see why one would
want to generalize and why it is not so obvious how to do it?

Known Material and Axioms: Does the reader have a clear knowledge of the
axioms and theorems that go into the derivation? Does he have a clear
distinction between the starting point and what is to be derived? Is he
given references to equations in earlier chapters where the matter is stated
in a different notation and context? And perhaps hard to find - like the
only numbered equation in 25 pages. Does he have to play the role of a real
estate lawyer doing title searches? With Mathematica notebooks space is
inexpensive and all the required material COULD be gathered together perhaps
in a separate window and perhaps in an active form.

Coherent Unit: Is a derivation or proof presented as a coherent unit, or
does it spread out over many pages with incoherent typography? Mathematica
allows a derivation to be presented in outline form and space to be reused
such that it is easy to switch between sections of a derivation or to
display several sections together in adjacent windows. It is possible to
bring the material to the reader when and where they need it.

Active Calculation: Many derivations and proofs in Mathematica can be done
with active calculation using routines and rules provided. People understand
actions much better than successions of static expressions. Carrying out a
derivation actively, as a series of calculated steps, is much more
convincing. Providing the routines for doing this may be a great deal of
work, but they also provide a base for further work in the applied area. The
student studying the proof not only gets the proof but also useful tools.
Rather than a forced purchase she's gotten an extra bonus. Active
calculation also carries out text-proofing, eliminating silly errors and
misprints and producing a document of higher integrity.

Proofs for Mathematicians vs. Proofs for Users: Proofs for mathematicians
carry the burden of correctness and rigor. They can assume quite a bit of
advance knowledge from fellow mathematicians. Proofs for users have an EXTRA
burden of motivation, elaboration and turning the proof into an active
useful tool. If the reader isn't going to use it, then why ask him to read
it in the first place?

Proof Presentation Research: The active and dynamic features of Mathematica
provide means to present proofs and derivations that are not only correct
but easier for readers to follow and use. It is not at all obvious how to do
this. It is very new. Some of the techniques are things I mentioned above.
One good technique with complicated diagrams is to use Checkboxes to turn
various features of the diagram on or off as they pertain to elements of the
proof. There are probably many other techniques that would arise from or be
adapted to special elements in a proof. There is a matter of judgment and
taste - no sense in elaborating the obvious, but what are the sticking
points that need elaboration?

There is a video kindly done for me by Roger Williams illustrating some of
these proof presentation techniques. There are two 8 minute videos but it is
the second that shows the techniques. I've posted these before so some of
you may have already seen them.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-b0B5hp0hAQ 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pm6yrevYcjQ 



David Park
djmpark@comcast.net 
http://home.comcast.net/~djmpark/index.html 


From: Alexei Boulbitch [mailto:Alexei.Boulbitch@iee.lu] 


Dear Community, dear Jon, dear Craig,
After my recent post where I mentioned the letter of L.D. Landau concerning
mathematical education for physicists I received several requests for the
full text. The full (or whatever) text I read years ago in the book of Maiia
Bessarab<http://www.amazon.de/s/ref=ntt_athr_dp_sr_1?_encoding=UTF8&field-au
thor=Maiia%20Bessarab&search-alias=books-de> "Lev Landau: Novel-biography"
which can be found here:
http://www.amazon.de/Lev-Landau-Roman-biografiia-Novel-biography/dp/B001MIKD
24/ref=sr_1_2?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1344239945&sr=1-2
and in few other places on the web. One can also find sites from where it
can be downloaded for free. It is, however, in Russian. Because of your
requests, and since Landau's ideas today are as valid as they have been 80
years ago, I translated the letter into English for those of you who are
interested to read it, cannot do it in Russian though. Please find it below.
I tried to keep the translation as close to Landau original style and
expressions as I could. Sometimes this lead to phrases that in English sound
cumbersome, some sentences look too long, and special expressions are used,
such as "exorcise" and alike. Landau liked strong (often impolite)
expressions. The term "lyrics" is not from this letter, as I realized when
re-read it now. However, it is a true Landau expression he applied to
existence theorems.  I simply picked it up somewhere else.
            Finally I apologize, that my translation is not at all
professional. Have fun. Alexei

This letter has been written to be sent to the rector of one of Moscow
technical universities as a response to its program in mathematics, that
probably had been made public at that time. No more details on the origin
and effect of this text is available*.

             Taking into account the importance of mathematics for
physicists, (as it is of general knowledge, physicists experience a need in
a calculating, analytical mathematics), the mathematicians, however, for
incomprehensible for me reason just fob us logical exercises off as an
involuntary purchase**. In your curriculum this statement is directly
expressed in a special note in the beginning of the program. It seems me
that it is high time to teach physicists things that they consider necessary
for themselves, rather than save their souls against their own wish. I do
not want to argue against the scholastic mediaeval idea that one can
allegedly learn to think by the way of learning unnecessary things.
            I strongly think that all existence theorems, too rigorous
proofs and so on, and so on... should be completely exorcised from the
mathematics studied by physicists. For this reason I will not specially
focus on those numerous points of your program that are in a drastic
contradiction to this point of view. I will only make few additional notes.
            Historical introduction makes a strange impression. It is
self-understood that communicating interesting historical details may only
make the lectures more interesting. It is not clear, however, why this is
considered as a program point. I hope that this is not intended to be
included into tests. The vector analysis is placed between the multiple
integrals. I have nothing against such a combination. I hope, however, that
it makes no damage to a very necessary knowledge of formal formulae of the
vector analysis. The program concerning series is especially overloaded by
unnecessary things, in which the scarce useful information about Fourier
series and integrals sink. The course of the so-called, mathematical
physics*** I would make optional. It is not possible to require
physicists-experimentalists to master such things. One should also say that
the program is too much overloaded. The necessity in the course of the
probability theory is rather doubtful.  Physicists anyway  teach (their
students, AB) all they need within the courses of statistical physics and
quantum mechanics.
            Anyway the presented program is got flooded with uselessness.
For this reason I think that teaching of mathematics needs a most serious
reformation.

*I believe that this letter has been sent to the rector, but made no effect
at all. Landau was not yet that broadly famous at that time. And if he were,
nothing would be changed.
**Involuntary purchase - a practice existed in USSR, when a shop customer
had to buy an unnecessary good, in order to be able to buy a necessary, but
rare one.
*** In the USSR this was the subject unifying partial differential equations
and complex numbers theory.


Alexei BOULBITCH, Dr., habil.
IEE S.A.
ZAE Weiergewan,
11, rue Edmond Reuter,
L-5326 Contern, LUXEMBOURG

Office phone :  +352-2454-2566
Office fax:       +352-2454-3566
mobile phone:  +49 151 52 40 66 44

e-mail: alexei.boulbitch@iee.lu<mailto:alexei.boulbitch@iee.lu>


[toc] | [next] | [standalone]


#11337

FromJohn Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com>
Date2012-08-14 09:04 +0000
Message-ID<k0d4bk$m8d$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11263
On Wednesday, August 8, 2012 1:16:17 AM UTC-6, djmpark wrote:

> Landau just expresses the frustration that non-mathematicians have when
>
> confronted with mathematical derivations and proofs that strive for rigor.
>
> They may need the results and material but, darn it, it's hard.

I don't think so. Landau was much more mathematically sophisticated than you give him credit for. But mathematics is only meaningful to non-mathematicians to the extent that it relates to reality.

Given that the philosophers have comprehensively demolished mathematical Platonism, it seems clear that the objects of mathematical study are products of the human imagination, not present in reality. It is indisputable that these objects are effective at modeling the behavior of real-world objects, but they also have odd properties of their own.

Now, sometimes we can utilize these odd properties in applied mathematics. To generalize a statement by Hadamard, sometimes the path that leads to real world truth takes us through unreal realms of imagination. And then we may also need to be aware of physically unreasonable behaviors of mathematical objects, so as not to misapply them.

But Landau singled out existence proofs. Non-constructive existence proofs are an example of mathematics that is unilluminating to a physicist. A notorious contemporary example is the Navier-Stokes equation: nobody knows if it generally has solutions or not. The Clay Mathematics Institute has offered a $1 million prize for a solution to the existence problem here. But to a physicist, this misses the point. The significance of the Navier-Stokes equation is that functions that satisfy it approximately also approximate real fluid flows. There is no need to know if an exact solution exists, since the Navier-Stokes equation describes the motion of a mathematical fiction: an "ideal fluid". An existence proof here would have no significance to physics. We're more interested in algorithms to efficiently find approximations. We have no doubt that in the real world the fluid will do whatever is inits nature to do, whether an exact Navier-Stokes solution exists or not.

Generally, what Landau seems to object to is the tendency of mathematicians to study and teach meaningless properties of mathematical objects, rather than those properties that connect mathematical objects to reality.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#11343

FromAndrzej Kozlowski <akozlowski@gmail.com>
Date2012-08-15 07:31 +0000
Message-ID<k0fj99$q6d$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#11263
I agree with your interpretation of Landau's letter but I also think 
your remarks about mathematics miss the point of what mathematicians do. 
Mathematicians do not concern themselves with the physical universe - if 
they did they would be something else. The results which they prove are 
meaningful within their own realm. The exact nature of this "meaning" is 
complicated, but it essentially relates to "procedures" (how arguments 
are conducted) than any physical reality. A great deal of mathematics 
(for example, almost all of probability theory) is concerned with 
"infinity", which arguably has no physical meaning at all.


Nevertheless, mathematics turns out to be important for other subjects, 
like physics, finance etc. This is not the right place for a discussion 
of why this is so, but in most cases it is a "side-effect" rather than 
something that mathematicians aim for. Nevertheless this "side effect" 
has shown itself to be of enormous importance. One of the many 
spectacular examples was the invention of group theory, which emerged in 
connection with an existence problem that seemed to have no relation to 
any physical reality (existence of solutions of polynomial equations in 
radicals). In 1910 the mathematician Oswald Veblen and the physicist 
James Jeans were discussing the mathematics curriculum for physicists at 
Princeton university. "We can safely omit group theory" argued Jeans, 
"this theory will never have any significance for physics". Veblen 
resisted and it is well known that this fact had a certain influence on 
the future history of physics.

This example is, in fact, an excellent illustration of the main point 
that people who argue like you do not get. Group theory was not created 
because mathematicians wanted to solve the "physical" problem of solving 
polynomial equations. It was known at least since Newton (and, in fact, 
before) that one could to so approximately. If mathematicians were 
physicists the matter would have stopped there - there was no physical 
reason to be interested in the problem of solving equations in radicals. 
However, the mathematics developed in order to solve this non-physical 
problem turned out to be among the most useful mathematics that has ever 
been invented. One reason was, of course, that working on a solution of 
a mathematical problem almost always leads to understanding that goes 
far beyond the narrow concerns of the problem.

So one reason why existence and non-existence theorems are important is 
that solving them leads to much deeper understanding of mathematics, 
which in turn turns out often to involve unexpected applications in 
other areas. There is also another, more direct reason. Knowing that 
there cannot be a general formula in radicals for the roots of a 
polynomial equation means that we no longer need to try to find one and 
instead can turn our attentions to other approaches. This is itself also 
useful in applications (just this of the number of people who post to 
this forum asking for "explicit" solutions of some equation or other).


There is a huge list of examples I could give of mathematics that has 
"no relation" to any physical reality and yet has had a big impact on 
applications. One example I have already mentioned - probability theory. 
Almost all important results in this field (in which I also include 
stochastic processes etc) involve limit theorems - which do not have a 
"physical reality" for rather obvious reasons. (A nice and easy to 
understand result is the very useful Kolmogorov's zero-one law 
<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kolmogorov's_zero-one_law> ). Probability 
theory is "useful" mainly because of the "inspiration" it provides to 
the practical subject of statistics, although in only a relatively small 
number of cases is this "relationship" an exact, "mathematical" one).

Finally, where on earth did you get the idea that "philosophers have 
comprehensively demolished mathematical Platonism" or indeed that 
philosophers have "comprehensively demolished" any philosophical idea in 
the entire history of philosophy (including, of course, the idea of the 
Creator)? This is an astounding news to not only to me, but also news to 
my wife, who has been a professor of philosophy at one of the world's 
leading universities, has a PhD in the subject from Oxford University, 
etc, etc. It also would be of interest to physicists like Roger Penrose 
who, obviously in blissful ignorance of this great news, remain 
unabashedly "mathematical platonists".
Could you please let us know the name of the philosophers who have 
performed this amazing feat?

Andrzej Kozlowski


On 14 Aug 2012, at 10:21, John Doty <noqsiaerospace@gmail.com> wrote:

> On Wednesday, August 8, 2012 1:16:17 AM UTC-6, djmpark wrote:
>
>> Landau just expresses the frustration that non-mathematicians have when
>>
>> confronted with mathematical derivations and proofs that strive for rigor.
>>
>> They may need the results and material but, darn it, it's hard.
>
> I don't think so. Landau was much more mathematically sophisticated than you give him credit for. But mathematics is only meaningful to non-mathematicians to the extent that it relates to reality.
>
> Given that the philosophers have comprehensively demolished mathematical Platonism, it seems clear that the objects of mathematical study are products of the human imagination, not present in reality. It is indisputable that these objects are effective at modeling the behavior of real-world objects, but they also have odd properties of their own.
>
> Now, sometimes we can utilize these odd properties in applied mathematics. To generalize a statement by Hadamard, sometimes the path that leads to real world truth takes us through unreal realms of imagination. And then we may also need to be aware of physically unreasonable behaviors of mathematical objects, so as not to misapply them.
>
> But Landau singled out existence proofs. Non-constructive existence proofs are an example of mathematics that is unilluminating to a physicist. A notorious contemporary example is the Navier-Stokes equation: nobody knows if it generally has solutions or not. The Clay Mathematics Institute has offered a $1 million prize for a solution to the existence problem here. But to a physicist, this misses the point. The significance of the Navier-Stokes equation is that functions that satisfy it approximately also approximate real fluid flows. There is no need to know if an exact solution exists, since the Navier-Stokes equation describes the motion of a mathematical fiction: an "ideal fluid". An existence proof here would have no significance to physics. We're more interested in algorithms to efficiently find approximations. We have no doubt that in the real world the fluid will do whatever is inits nature to do, whether an exact Navier-Stokes solution exists or not.
>
> Generally, what Landau seems to object to is the tendency of mathematicians to study and teach meaningless properties of mathematical objects, rather than those properties that connect mathematical objects to reality.
>

[toc] | [prev] | [standalone]


Back to top | Article view | comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica


csiph-web