Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica > #10031 > unrolled thread

Fine control of evaluation

Started byBrentt <brenttnewman@gmail.com>
First post2012-05-11 04:15 +0000
Last post2012-05-12 08:51 +0000
Articles 2 — 2 participants

Back to article view | Back to comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica


Contents

  Fine control of evaluation Brentt <brenttnewman@gmail.com> - 2012-05-11 04:15 +0000
    Re: Fine control of evaluation A Retey <awnl@gmx-topmail.de> - 2012-05-12 08:51 +0000

#10031 — Fine control of evaluation

FromBrentt <brenttnewman@gmail.com>
Date2012-05-11 04:15 +0000
SubjectFine control of evaluation
Message-ID<joi3pj$n55$1@smc.vnet.net>
Hello, I am struggling with evaluation control and was hoping someone might
point me in the right direction. I vaguely remember seeing something in the
manual or the tutorials addressing this issue, but I can't find the section
I saw it in.

How does one get fine control over things wrapped in Hold and HoldForm. Say
I have some functions

func1[x_]:= f[x];
func2[x_] := g[x];
step1 = HoldForm[ func1[x]+ func2[x] ];

Now say I want the statements wrapped in HoldForm,  func1[x]+ func2[x]  to
evaluate to f[x]+ func2[x]

I thought naturally it would be something like

step2 = HoldForm[ Evaluate[func1[x]]+ func2[x] ] ;

 But then HoldForm seems a bit overzealous about it's task, and outputs
Evaluate[func1[x]]+ func2[x]---it leaves Evaluate unevaluated.  (I tried
wrapping it func1[x] in ReleaseHold to no avail.)

The above is just pseudocode, Maybe there is some specifics about what I
was actually doing that was causing the unintuitive behavior (i.e. HoldForm
holding Evaluate, instead of, well, evaluating.) What I was doing was more
along these lines:
----------------
ubounds= {u,0, pi};
vbounds={v,0,2pi};
t[dir_]:= D[s[u,v],dir_];    (*where dir_ is going to be either u or v*)

(*here is the difficult part:*)
formattedOutput= Integrate[HoldForm[t[u]] , ubounds, vbounds ]
//TraditionalForm;
----------------
The issue is that I want the t[u] wrapped in the HoldForm to evaluate to
D[s[u,v],dir_], and hold that. If I wrap it in Evaluate, HoldForm holds
Evaluate (puzzling), and tries to integrate Evaluate as if it is the
integrand. I've tried all kinds of permutations of HoldForm, Defer,
ReleaseHold, Evaluate, and I haven't had anything to work.

Thank you for any help or pointing me in the right direction

[toc] | [next] | [standalone]


#10053

FromA Retey <awnl@gmx-topmail.de>
Date2012-05-12 08:51 +0000
Message-ID<jol8b4$43t$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#10031
Hi,

> Hello, I am struggling with evaluation control and was hoping someone might
> point me in the right direction. I vaguely remember seeing something in the
> manual or the tutorials addressing this issue, but I can't find the section
> I saw it in.

the general documentation is this (which I consider a must-read):

tutorial/Evaluation

your particular problem is documented here:

ref/Evaluate (possible issues section)

> How does one get fine control over things wrapped in Hold and HoldForm. Say
> I have some functions
>
> func1[x_]:= f[x];
> func2[x_] := g[x];
> step1 = HoldForm[ func1[x]+ func2[x] ];
>
> Now say I want the statements wrapped in HoldForm,  func1[x]+ func2[x]  to
> evaluate to f[x]+ func2[x]
>
> I thought naturally it would be something like
>
> step2 = HoldForm[ Evaluate[func1[x]]+ func2[x] ] ;
>
>   But then HoldForm seems a bit overzealous about it's task, and outputs
> Evaluate[func1[x]]+ func2[x]---it leaves Evaluate unevaluated.  (I tried
> wrapping it func1[x] in ReleaseHold to no avail.)

from the documentation of Evaluate: "Evaluate works only on the first 
level, directly inside a held function:"

> The above is just pseudocode, Maybe there is some specifics about what I
> was actually doing that was causing the unintuitive behavior (i.e. HoldForm
> holding Evaluate, instead of, well, evaluating.) What I was doing was more
> along these lines:
> ----------------
> ubounds= {u,0, pi};
> vbounds={v,0,2pi};
> t[dir_]:= D[s[u,v],dir_];    (*where dir_ is going to be either u or v*)
>
> (*here is the difficult part:*)
> formattedOutput= Integrate[HoldForm[t[u]] , ubounds, vbounds ]
> //TraditionalForm;
> ----------------
> The issue is that I want the t[u] wrapped in the HoldForm to evaluate to
> D[s[u,v],dir_], and hold that. If I wrap it in Evaluate, HoldForm holds
> Evaluate (puzzling), and tries to integrate Evaluate as if it is the
> integrand. I've tried all kinds of permutations of HoldForm, Defer,
> ReleaseHold, Evaluate, and I haven't had anything to work.

What you want to do is to insert evaluated subexpression into a held 
expressions. There are many ways to achieve this, but the most common is 
to use With:

With[{ubounds = ubounds, vbounds = vbounds, expr = t[u]},
  HoldForm[Integrate[expr, ubounds, vbounds]]
  ]

(note that I've wrapped everythin with HoldForm and also inserted 
ubounds and vbounds. Without that Integrate would try to integrate 
HoldForm, which it can't do and I assume you don't even actually want it 
to try...)

hth,

albert

[toc] | [prev] | [standalone]


Back to top | Article view | comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica


csiph-web