Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica > #9697 > unrolled thread

Extract coefficients of a trig polynomial

Started bySam Takoy <sam.takoy@yahoo.com>
First post2012-04-19 07:55 +0000
Last post2012-04-21 04:30 +0000
Articles 5 — 5 participants

Back to article view | Back to comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica


Contents

  Extract coefficients of a trig polynomial Sam Takoy <sam.takoy@yahoo.com> - 2012-04-19 07:55 +0000
    Re: Extract coefficients of a trig polynomial danl@wolfram.com - 2012-04-20 11:49 +0000
    Re: Extract coefficients of a trig polynomial Ray Koopman <koopman@sfu.ca> - 2012-04-20 11:51 +0000
    Re: Extract coefficients of a trig polynomial Yi Wang <tririverwangyi@gmail.com> - 2012-04-20 11:54 +0000
    Re: Extract coefficients of a trig polynomial "Dr. Wolfgang Hintze" <weh@snafu.de> - 2012-04-21 04:30 +0000

#9697 — Extract coefficients of a trig polynomial

FromSam Takoy <sam.takoy@yahoo.com>
Date2012-04-19 07:55 +0000
SubjectExtract coefficients of a trig polynomial
Message-ID<jmoge7$46g$1@smc.vnet.net>
Hi,

Suppose I have an expression that is a trigonometric polynomial in
theta. Is there a way to neatly pick out the coefficients of the
polynomial. I find that FourierCoefficient takes quite a bit of time,
probably because it does a lot of integrations. My coefficients are
very complicated expressions but do not depend on theta.

Many thanks in advance,

Sam

PS: expr = (1/1536)(1536 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]-72 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho]^2
BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]-80 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]-384 \
[Epsilon] \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]]-144 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\
[Rho]]-80 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]]+10 \[Epsilon]^3 \
[Rho]^3 BesselJ[1,\[Rho]]-96 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]
Cos[2 \[Theta]]-120 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \
[Theta]]-384 \[Epsilon] \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \[Theta]]-192 \
[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \[Theta]]-120 \[Epsilon]^3 \
[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \[Theta]]+15 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^3
BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \[Theta]]-24 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\
[Rho]] Cos[4 \[Theta]]-48 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]
Cos[4 \[Theta]]-48 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[4 \
[Theta]]-48 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[4 \[Theta]]+6 \
[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^3 BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[4 \[Theta]]-8 \[Epsilon]^3 \
[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]] Cos[6 \[Theta]]-8 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]
BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[6 \[Theta]]+\[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^3 BesselJ[1,\
[Rho]] Cos[6 \[Theta]])

[toc] | [next] | [standalone]


#9712

Fromdanl@wolfram.com
Date2012-04-20 11:49 +0000
Message-ID<jmrifg$lea$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#9697
On Thursday, April 19, 2012 2:55:51 AM UTC-5, Sam Takoy wrote:
> Hi,
> 
> Suppose I have an expression that is a trigonometric polynomial in
> theta. Is there a way to neatly pick out the coefficients of the
> polynomial. I find that FourierCoefficient takes quite a bit of time,
> probably because it does a lot of integrations. My coefficients are
> very complicated expressions but do not depend on theta.
> 
> Many thanks in advance,
> 
> Sam
> 
> PS: expr = (1/1536)(1536 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]-72 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho]^2
> BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]-80 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]-384 \
> [Epsilon] \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]]-144 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\
> [Rho]]-80 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]]+10 \[Epsilon]^3 \
> [Rho]^3 BesselJ[1,\[Rho]]-96 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]
> Cos[2 \[Theta]]-120 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \
> [Theta]]-384 \[Epsilon] \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \[Theta]]-192 \
> [Epsilon]^2 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \[Theta]]-120 \[Epsilon]^3 \
> [Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \[Theta]]+15 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^3
> BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \[Theta]]-24 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\
> [Rho]] Cos[4 \[Theta]]-48 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]
> Cos[4 \[Theta]]-48 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[4 \
> [Theta]]-48 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[4 \[Theta]]+6 \
> [Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^3 BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[4 \[Theta]]-8 \[Epsilon]^3 \
> [Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]] Cos[6 \[Theta]]-8 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]
> BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[6 \[Theta]]+\[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^3 BesselJ[1,\
> [Rho]] Cos[6 \[Theta]])

Not sure, but possibly this will do what you have in mind.

In[206]:= trigs = Union[Cases[expr, Cos[(_.)*\[Theta]], Infinity]]

Out[206]= {Cos[2*\[Theta]], Cos[4*\[Theta]], Cos[6*\[Theta]]}

In[207]:= (Coefficient[expr, #1]*#1 & ) /@ trigs

Out[207]= {(1/
    1536)*((-96*\[Epsilon]^2*\[Rho]^2*BesselJ[0, \[Rho]] - 
      120*\[Epsilon]^3*\[Rho]^2*BesselJ[0, \[Rho]] - 
           384*\[Epsilon]*\[Rho]*BesselJ[1, \[Rho]] - 
      192*\[Epsilon]^2*\[Rho]*BesselJ[1, \[Rho]] - 
      120*\[Epsilon]^3*\[Rho]*BesselJ[1, \[Rho]] + 
           15*\[Epsilon]^3*\[Rho]^3*BesselJ[1, \[Rho]])*
    Cos[2*\[Theta]]), 
   (1/1536)*((-24*\[Epsilon]^2*\[Rho]^2*BesselJ[0, \[Rho]] - 
      48*\[Epsilon]^3*\[Rho]^2*BesselJ[0, \[Rho]] - 
           48*\[Epsilon]^2*\[Rho]*BesselJ[1, \[Rho]] - 
      48*\[Epsilon]^3*\[Rho]*BesselJ[1, \[Rho]] + 
      6*\[Epsilon]^3*\[Rho]^3*BesselJ[1, \[Rho]])*
        Cos[
     4*\[Theta]]), ((-8*\[Epsilon]^3*\[Rho]^2*BesselJ[0, \[Rho]] - 
      8*\[Epsilon]^3*\[Rho]*BesselJ[1, \[Rho]] + 
           \[Epsilon]^3*\[Rho]^3*BesselJ[1, \[Rho]])*Cos[6*\[Theta]])/
  1536}

Daniel Lichtblau
Wolfram Research

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#9717

FromRay Koopman <koopman@sfu.ca>
Date2012-04-20 11:51 +0000
Message-ID<jmrik9$lgf$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#9697
On Apr 19, 12:55 am, Sam Takoy <sam.ta...@yahoo.com> wrote:
> Hi,
>
> Suppose I have an expression that is a trigonometric polynomial in
> theta. Is there a way to neatly pick out the coefficients of the
> polynomial. I find that FourierCoefficient takes quite a bit of time,
> probably because it does a lot of integrations. My coefficients are
> very complicated expressions but do not depend on theta.
>
> Many thanks in advance,
>
> Sam
>
> PS: expr = (1/1536)(1536 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]-72 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho]^2
> BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]-80 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]-384 \
> [Epsilon] \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]]-144 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\
> [Rho]]-80 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]]+10 \[Epsilon]^3 \
> [Rho]^3 BesselJ[1,\[Rho]]-96 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]
> Cos[2 \[Theta]]-120 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \
> [Theta]]-384 \[Epsilon] \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \[Theta]]-192 \
> [Epsilon]^2 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \[Theta]]-120 \[Epsilon]^3 \
> [Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \[Theta]]+15 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^3
> BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \[Theta]]-24 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\
> [Rho]] Cos[4 \[Theta]]-48 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]
> Cos[4 \[Theta]]-48 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[4 \
> [Theta]]-48 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[4 \[Theta]]+6 \
> [Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^3 BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[4 \[Theta]]-8 \[Epsilon]^3 \
> [Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]] Cos[6 \[Theta]]-8 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]
> BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[6 \[Theta]]+\[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^3 BesselJ[1,\
> [Rho]] Cos[6 \[Theta]])

CoefficientList[ TrigExpand[expr], {Cos[=E8], Sin[=E8]} ]

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#9722

FromYi Wang <tririverwangyi@gmail.com>
Date2012-04-20 11:54 +0000
Message-ID<jmrip2$lhi$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#9697
Hi, Sam,

The following may help. But it may be not as general as you want.

Coefficient[expr, #] & /@ {Cos[2 \[Theta]], Cos[4 \[Theta]], 
  Cos[6 \[Theta]]}

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#9731

From"Dr. Wolfgang Hintze" <weh@snafu.de>
Date2012-04-21 04:30 +0000
Message-ID<jmtd5k$sh4$1@smc.vnet.net>
In reply to#9697
On 19 Apr., 09:55, Sam Takoy <sam.ta...@yahoo.com> wrote:
> Hi,
>
> Suppose I have an expression that is a trigonometric polynomial in
> theta. Is there a way to neatly pick out the coefficients of the
> polynomial. I find that FourierCoefficient takes quite a bit of time,
> probably because it does a lot of integrations. My coefficients are
> very complicated expressions but do not depend on theta.
>
> Many thanks in advance,
>
> Sam
>
> PS: expr = (1/1536)(1536 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]-72 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho]^2
> BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]-80 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]-384 \
> [Epsilon] \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]]-144 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\
> [Rho]]-80 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]]+10 \[Epsilon]^3 \
> [Rho]^3 BesselJ[1,\[Rho]]-96 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]
> Cos[2 \[Theta]]-120 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \
> [Theta]]-384 \[Epsilon] \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \[Theta]]-192 \
> [Epsilon]^2 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \[Theta]]-120 \[Epsilon]^3 \
> [Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \[Theta]]+15 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^3
> BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[2 \[Theta]]-24 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\
> [Rho]] Cos[4 \[Theta]]-48 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]]
> Cos[4 \[Theta]]-48 \[Epsilon]^2 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[4 \
> [Theta]]-48 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho] BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[4 \[Theta]]+6 \
> [Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^3 BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[4 \[Theta]]-8 \[Epsilon]^3 \
> [Rho]^2 BesselJ[0,\[Rho]] Cos[6 \[Theta]]-8 \[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]
> BesselJ[1,\[Rho]] Cos[6 \[Theta]]+\[Epsilon]^3 \[Rho]^3 BesselJ[1,\
> [Rho]] Cos[6 \[Theta]])
>
>

Hi,

to avoid special characters I'm gong to rewrite expr as

In[14]:=
expr = (1/1536)*(1536*BesselJ[0, r] - 72*q^2*r^2*BesselJ[0, r] -
80*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0, r] - 384*q*r*BesselJ[1, r] -
144*q^2*r*BesselJ[1, r] - 80*q^3*r*BesselJ[1, r] +
10*q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1, r] - 96*q^2*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[2*t] -
    120*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[2*t] - 384*q*r*BesselJ[1,
r]*Cos[2*t] - 192*q^2*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[2*t] - 120*q^3*r*BesselJ[1,
r]*Cos[2*t] + 15*q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[2*t] -
24*q^2*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[4*t] - 48*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[4*t]
-
    48*q^2*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[4*t] - 48*q^3*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[4*t]
+ 6*q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[4*t] - 8*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[6*t]
- 8*q^3*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[6*t] + q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[6*t])

Out[14]=
(1/1536)*(1536*BesselJ[0, r] - 72*q^2*r^2*BesselJ[0, r] -
80*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0, r] - 384*q*r*BesselJ[1, r] -
144*q^2*r*BesselJ[1, r] - 80*q^3*r*BesselJ[1, r] +
10*q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1, r] - 96*q^2*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[2*t] -
   120*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[2*t] - 384*q*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[2*t]
- 192*q^2*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[2*t] - 120*q^3*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[2*t]
+ 15*q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[2*t] - 24*q^2*r^2*BesselJ[0,
r]*Cos[4*t] - 48*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[4*t] -
   48*q^2*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[4*t] - 48*q^3*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[4*t] +
6*q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[4*t] - 8*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[6*t] -
8*q^3*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[6*t] + q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[6*t])

> I would use Cases with apropriate patterns like this
>
> First make a list out of your expression:
>
In[15]:=
el = List @@ (List @@ expr)[[2]]

Out[15]=
{1536*BesselJ[0, r], -72*q^2*r^2*BesselJ[0, r], -80*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0,
r], -384*q*r*BesselJ[1, r], -144*q^2*r*BesselJ[1, r],
-80*q^3*r*BesselJ[1, r], 10*q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1, r],
-96*q^2*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[2*t], -120*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0,
r]*Cos[2*t],
  -384*q*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[2*t], -192*q^2*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[2*t],
-120*q^3*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[2*t], 15*q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[2*t],
-24*q^2*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[4*t], -48*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0,
r]*Cos[4*t], -48*q^2*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[4*t],
  -48*q^3*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[4*t], 6*q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[4*t],
-8*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[6*t], -8*q^3*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[6*t],
q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[6*t]}
>
> Then collect all terms the desired patterns in Cos[]
>
> Cos with any agrument:
>
In[22]:=
c1 = Cases[el, _*Cos[_]]

Out[22]=
{-96*q^2*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[2*t], -120*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0,
r]*Cos[2*t], -384*q*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[2*t], -192*q^2*r*BesselJ[1,
r]*Cos[2*t], -120*q^3*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[2*t], 15*q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1,
r]*Cos[2*t], -24*q^2*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[4*t],
  -48*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[4*t], -48*q^2*r*BesselJ[1,
r]*Cos[4*t], -48*q^3*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[4*t], 6*q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1,
r]*Cos[4*t], -8*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[6*t], -8*q^3*r*BesselJ[1,
r]*Cos[6*t], q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[6*t]}
>
> Cos[2 times anything] and so on
>
In[17]:=
Cases[el, _*Cos[2*_]]

Out[17]=
{-96*q^2*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[2*t], -120*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0,
r]*Cos[2*t], -384*q*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[2*t], -192*q^2*r*BesselJ[1,
r]*Cos[2*t], -120*q^3*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[2*t], 15*q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1,
r]*Cos[2*t]}
>
In[18]:=
Cases[el, _*Cos[4*_]]

Out[18]=
{-24*q^2*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[4*t], -48*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0,
r]*Cos[4*t], -48*q^2*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[4*t], -48*q^3*r*BesselJ[1,
r]*Cos[4*t], 6*q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[4*t]}
>
In[19]:=
Cases[el, _*Cos[6*_]]

Out[19]=
{-8*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0, r]*Cos[6*t], -8*q^3*r*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[6*t],
q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1, r]*Cos[6*t]}
>
 Finally, here is the list of terms without Cos
>
In[21]:=
c0 = Complement[el, c1]

Out[21]=
{1536*BesselJ[0, r], -72*q^2*r^2*BesselJ[0, r], -80*q^3*r^2*BesselJ[0,
r], -384*q*r*BesselJ[1, r], -144*q^2*r*BesselJ[1, r],
-80*q^3*r*BesselJ[1, r], 10*q^3*r^3*BesselJ[1, r]}
>
> Hope this helps.
>
> Regards,
> Wolfgang

[toc] | [prev] | [standalone]


Back to top | Article view | comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica


csiph-web