Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > comp.mobile.android > #110840 > unrolled thread

What app functionality absolutely requires creating a user-specific online account?

Started byWally J <walterjones@invalid.nospam>
First post2023-11-30 12:54 -0400
Last post2023-12-05 02:33 -0400
Articles 6 — 3 participants

Back to article view | Back to comp.mobile.android


Contents

  What app functionality absolutely requires creating a user-specific online account? Wally J <walterjones@invalid.nospam> - 2023-11-30 12:54 -0400
    Re: What app functionality absolutely requires creating a user-specific online account? "Carlos E. R." <robin_listas@es.invalid> - 2023-11-30 18:24 +0100
      Re: What app functionality absolutely requires creating a user-specific online account? Wally J <walterjones@invalid.nospam> - 2023-12-05 02:44 -0400
        Re: What app functionality absolutely requires creating a user-specific online account? "Carlos E. R." <robin_listas@es.invalid> - 2023-12-05 16:28 +0100
    Re: What app functionality absolutely requires creating a user-specific online account? Arno Welzel <usenet@arnowelzel.de> - 2023-12-04 20:50 +0100
      Re: What app functionality absolutely requires creating a user-specific online account? Wally J <walterjones@invalid.nospam> - 2023-12-05 02:33 -0400

#110840 — What app functionality absolutely requires creating a user-specific online account?

FromWally J <walterjones@invalid.nospam>
Date2023-11-30 12:54 -0400
SubjectWhat app functionality absolutely requires creating a user-specific online account?
Message-ID<ukaeos$3que6$1@paganini.bofh.team>
There are fundamental questions which show clear understanding of Android.
Worse, the sheep led to slaughter often don't understand the fundamentals.

Hence, it's a good question to ask for those who want to understand it.
 Q: *What app functionality requires creating a specific online account?*
 NOTE: I say "specific" to distinguish between things like cell carrier
       service (which requires an "account" but not an online account); 
       and generic google accounts (like those used in many FOSS apps), 
       and mere synchronization tasks (like radio-station favorites).

Example:
a. An example of what definitely needs its own personal account is Email.
b. An example of what does not is installing from the Google Play Store.
c. An example where an account is convenient is calendars & contacts.

To kick things off, I made a quick first-pass list based on my apps:

REQUIRES PERSONAL ACCOUNT:
 Email (e.g., Gmail, Yahoo Mail, AT&T email, ProtonMail, etc.)
 Library card access (e.g., Kanopy, OverDrive, Libby, etc.)
 Internet Messaging (e.g., WhatsApp, Signal, TextNow, etc.)
 VOIP (e.g., Google Voice, TextNow, Skype, Talkatone, etc.)
 Social Media (e.g., Twitter, Telegram, Facebook, etc.)
 Cloud storage (e.g., DropBox, OneDrive, Google Cloud, etc.)

PERSONAL ACCCOUNT is CONVENIENT (but not required):
 All apps which sync data across devices
 Calendar sync
 Contacts sync
 Backup activities
 Purchasing online
 Activity trackers

To be continued... 

[toc] | [next] | [standalone]


#110841

From"Carlos E. R." <robin_listas@es.invalid>
Date2023-11-30 18:24 +0100
Message-ID<ksruqlF8uhgU4@mid.individual.net>
In reply to#110840
On 2023-11-30 17:54, Wally J wrote:
> There are fundamental questions which show clear understanding of Android.
> Worse, the sheep led to slaughter often don't understand the fundamentals.
> 
> Hence, it's a good question to ask for those who want to understand it.
>   Q: *What app functionality requires creating a specific online account?*
>   NOTE: I say "specific" to distinguish between things like cell carrier
>         service (which requires an "account" but not an online account);
>         and generic google accounts (like those used in many FOSS apps),
>         and mere synchronization tasks (like radio-station favorites).
> 
> Example:
> a. An example of what definitely needs its own personal account is Email.
> b. An example of what does not is installing from the Google Play Store.

If you want the full feature set, then yes, it is needed.

For example, you can login to google in a computer, go to apps, Play 
Store, find an app, and click to install on any of your phones.

> c. An example where an account is convenient is calendars & contacts.


Any app that saves settings on the cloud, so that the same settings 
apply to all devices. If you want that feature, a login is required.

Some apps may be developed to alternatively use a private server.


-- 
Cheers,
        Carlos E.R.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#113280

FromWally J <walterjones@invalid.nospam>
Date2023-12-05 02:44 -0400
Message-ID<ukmgsf$15dr9$1@paganini.bofh.team>
In reply to#110841
"Carlos E. R." <robin_listas@es.invalid> wrote 

> For example, you can login to google in a computer, go to apps, Play 
> Store, find an app, and click to install on any of your phones.

Thanks for bringing up that you need an account to have the ability of 
downloading APKs from the PC onto your cellphone with a Google Account.

However... 

I'd call that an "ability" (or maybe a feature) but not a functionality.

The reason is I can do all that too. 
Without creating a Google Account.

So the account isn't needed for the functionality of obtaining an APK while 
on the PC and then installing that APK onto the phone - or - even obtaining 
that APK from the phone (web browsers are on phones too) & installing it.

Here's an example of how simple it is to install on a phone from a PC.
 <https://i.postimg.cc/wvsbcNBz/scrcpy05.jpg> Drag APK from Windows
All you do is slide the APK file from Windows to Android over Wi-Fi.
And that installs it (although you can do the same thing with adb).

And to get it, all you need is to download it off the Google Play Store 
repository without needing to create any Google Account on your phone.

So having a Google Account adds a feature that you like, but it's not 
necessary to have the functionality of pulling APKs off the Google Play 
Store repository and installing them from the PC onto the phone.

Note: As an aside, you can pull F-Droid APKs the way you suggested to use 
the Google Play Store repository - but only some of those APKs are the same 
unique Android package name as those on the Google Play Store repository.

>> c. An example where an account is convenient is calendars & contacts.
> 
> Any app that saves settings on the cloud, so that the same settings 
> apply to all devices. If you want that feature, a login is required.
> 
> Some apps may be developed to alternatively use a private server.

While I agree that _many_ (perhaps even most) app developers would _love_ 
to have you create an account to store your settings on their servers, 
I would argue that there can't be a single app which technically requires 
that. 

You can sync anything if you have a computer to sync it to, right?
That computer can be your own desktop PC, right?

After having said that, I am aware of ownCloud servers, and caldav and 
cardav servers, all of which are free - but most of which are on Linux.

Sadly, the server situation for the Windows PC sucks, IMHO.

If others know of good free cardav, caldav and owncloud servers for the PC, 
let me know as I'll test them out for team & write up a tutorial.
-- 
Each of us on Usenet has a different use model so we learn from each other.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#113886

From"Carlos E. R." <robin_listas@es.invalid>
Date2023-12-05 16:28 +0100
Message-ID<kt8tsnFtug5U5@mid.individual.net>
In reply to#113280
On 2023-12-05 07:44, Wally J wrote:
> "Carlos E. R." <robin_listas@es.invalid> wrote
> 
>> For example, you can login to google in a computer, go to apps, Play
>> Store, find an app, and click to install on any of your phones.
> 
> Thanks for bringing up that you need an account to have the ability of
> downloading APKs from the PC onto your cellphone with a Google Account.
> 
> However...
> 
> I'd call that an "ability" (or maybe a feature) but not a functionality.
> 
> The reason is I can do all that too.
> Without creating a Google Account.

I doubt it.

I click on the google play page and the app is automatically installed 
on any of my phones. No matter where the phone is, LAN or not.

I'm not talking about downloading the APK and installing it "somehow" on 
the phone. That's a different feature.

I like this feature, I want it, I demand having it, and it requires a 
login. Fine with me. I could do without? yes. I decided not to. Fully 
aware, a conscious decision.

...

>>> c. An example where an account is convenient is calendars & contacts.
>>
>> Any app that saves settings on the cloud, so that the same settings
>> apply to all devices. If you want that feature, a login is required.
>>
>> Some apps may be developed to alternatively use a private server.
> 
> While I agree that _many_ (perhaps even most) app developers would _love_
> to have you create an account to store your settings on their servers,
> I would argue that there can't be a single app which technically requires
> that.
> 
> You can sync anything if you have a computer to sync it to, right?
> That computer can be your own desktop PC, right?

I would have to put that computer on internet, which I do not want to. I 
would have to maintain it, which I do not want to. It is way more 
convenient to have an account on the cloud.

I also get features related to appointments with other people that also 
have their calendars. Could not work if my calendar is isolated in my 
own server.

An enterprise can have instead an enterprise wide calendar in their own 
server. Fine, they also have IT people paid to support this. I don't.

...

-- 
Cheers,
        Carlos E.R.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#112816

FromArno Welzel <usenet@arnowelzel.de>
Date2023-12-04 20:50 +0100
Message-ID<kt6orqFf0atU5@mid.individual.net>
In reply to#110840
Wally J, 2023-11-30 17:54:

> There are fundamental questions which show clear understanding of Android.
> Worse, the sheep led to slaughter often don't understand the fundamentals.
> 
> Hence, it's a good question to ask for those who want to understand it.
>  Q: *What app functionality requires creating a specific online account?*
>  NOTE: I say "specific" to distinguish between things like cell carrier
>        service (which requires an "account" but not an online account); 
>        and generic google accounts (like those used in many FOSS apps), 
>        and mere synchronization tasks (like radio-station favorites).
> 
> Example:
> a. An example of what definitely needs its own personal account is Email.
> b. An example of what does not is installing from the Google Play Store.

Wrong. Google Play Store needs to know for which user account the app
should be installed - because there may be paid licenses connected to
that user account or the user may have subscribed to a beta program to
get beta versions of an app.

> c. An example where an account is convenient is calendars & contacts.

Wrong again. Calendars and contacts also belong to a specific account.


-- 
Arno Welzel
https://arnowelzel.de

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#113269

FromWally J <walterjones@invalid.nospam>
Date2023-12-05 02:33 -0400
Message-ID<ukmg84$15cv4$1@paganini.bofh.team>
In reply to#112816
Arno Welzel <usenet@arnowelzel.de> wrote 

> Wrong. Google Play Store needs to know for which user account the app
> should be installed - because there may be paid licenses connected to
> that user account or the user may have subscribed to a beta program to
> get beta versions of an app.

You bring up a good point that only payware requires the Google Account.
Thanks!

It slipped my mind because there's almost nothing in payware that's useful
(IMHO), or, if it's useful (like OSMAND+ is or like Simple Mobile Tools Pro
tools are), then it's often also available for free (e.g., OSMAnd~).

Thanks for correcting that the people who pay for tools, need to lose their
privacy by having a Google Play Account in order to pay for those tools.

I had forgotten that some people pay for tools they can get for free.
Thanks.
 
>> c. An example where an account is convenient is calendars & contacts.
> 
> Wrong again. Calendars and contacts also belong to a specific account.

It's right - but I do agree many people aren't aware why it is right.
Most people just do what the big marketing organizations want them to do.

So I appreciate that you brought it up.

Suffice to say I have calendars on Android & Windows. 
And I have contacts on both.

Yet I have no account.
And they sync fine.

On WI-Fi.
Over my LAN.

(e.g., we have had threads in the past on how to sync Android & Windows
contacts/calendars with Thunderbird/Lightning on the Windows platform)
-- 
Usenet is nothing like working at a high-tech shop in the Silicon Valley.

[toc] | [prev] | [standalone]


Back to top | Article view | comp.mobile.android


csiph-web