Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > comp.lang.clipper.visual-objects > #3322 > unrolled thread

Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's

Started byD.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com>
First post2012-04-15 10:50 +0200
Last post2012-04-18 12:04 +0200
Articles 20 on this page of 27 — 11 participants

Back to article view | Back to comp.lang.clipper.visual-objects


Contents

  Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's D.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com> - 2012-04-15 10:50 +0200
    Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's "Fred Killet" <killet-nospam@killetsoft.de> - 2012-04-15 12:34 +0200
      Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's D.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com> - 2012-04-16 09:10 +0200
    Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's "Danilo Giuliani" <softdevo@tiscali.it> - 2012-04-15 15:58 +0200
      Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's D.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com> - 2012-04-16 09:13 +0200
    Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's "Willie Moore" <williem@wmconsulting.com> - 2012-04-16 08:06 -0500
      Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's D.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com> - 2012-04-17 11:57 +0200
        Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's Karl Faller <k.faller_withoutthat_@onlinehome.de> - 2012-04-17 14:54 +0200
          Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's Massimo Bighelli <info@arcasistemi.it> - 2012-04-17 16:25 +0200
          Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's D.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com> - 2012-04-17 17:49 +0200
        Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's Massimo Bighelli <info@arcasistemi.it> - 2012-04-17 18:31 +0200
          Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's D.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com> - 2012-04-17 20:56 +0200
            Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's Massimo Bighelli <info@arcasistemi.it> - 2012-04-17 23:42 +0200
              Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's D.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com> - 2012-04-18 12:12 +0200
                Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's Willie Moore <williem@wmconsulting.com> - 2012-04-18 14:09 +0000
                  Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's D.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com> - 2012-04-18 17:04 +0200
                    Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's Willie Moore <williem@wmconsulting.com> - 2012-04-18 18:39 +0000
                    Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's "Ginny Caughey" <gcaughey@hotmail.com> - 2012-04-18 14:59 -0400
                Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's Massimo Bighelli <info@arcasistemi.it> - 2012-04-18 22:16 +0200
                  Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's "richard.townsendrose" <richard.townsendrose@gmail.com> - 2012-04-25 05:58 -0700
                    Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's D.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com> - 2012-04-25 22:38 +0200
                      Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's Mathias <mathias.hakansson@consultec.se> - 2012-04-25 22:22 -0700
                        Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's D.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com> - 2012-04-26 23:26 +0200
                          Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's "Willie Moore" <williem@wmconsulting.com> - 2012-04-26 18:08 -0500
                          Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's Mathias <mathias.hakansson@consultec.se> - 2012-04-27 01:21 -0700
        Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's "Paul D B" <polleke@NOMORESPAMhnt.be> - 2012-04-18 11:29 +0200
          Re: Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's D.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com> - 2012-04-18 12:04 +0200

Page 1 of 2  [1] 2  Next page →


#3322 — Deciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's

FromD.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com>
Date2012-04-15 10:50 +0200
SubjectDeciding to go from VO to Vulcan - list with pro's and con's
Message-ID<uf1lo75vou3nvhss0pi08eb5a74ibecm1g@4ax.com>
I recently bought Vulcan 2.10 to renew my testing and see if and where
I can use Vulcan.


If you're still (only) working in VO, in short my conclusion so far: I
think that there will be a moment when you encounter something you can
not really solve with VO. That doesn't mean you need to convert
everything to Vulcan, but it means you do need knowledge to use .Net
classes, via C#, Vulcan or any other language. This may be tomorrow or
years after now, but it's a good idea to be prepared.

Most people find Visual Studio, the most logical solution to use .Net
languages, pleasant to work in. I quite strongly disagree, not because
of VS but especially because all code (.PRG=.MEF in VO) which you can
edit per entity in random order and combination in VO has to be loaded
in the editor full. 

You will see in the page below that concerning this edit methods from
out of 11 points I find 10 points a (major) disadvantage of VS versus
VO. Debugging is better in VS, there are some other small advantages. 

Major advantage is of course the availability of code and samples and
the access to the .Net classes. Currently I think that the loss in
productivity due to the program based editor is not justified by the
advantages.

You'll see the (dis)advantages in green/red (and orange). I am most
interested in any reaction - or in other words: I'd be glad to change
the 'reds' for Visual Studio/.Net/Vulcan in 'greens'

See:

www.ic2.com/Cavo/VoVSVulcan.html

Dick

[toc] | [next] | [standalone]


#3323

From"Fred Killet" <killet-nospam@killetsoft.de>
Date2012-04-15 12:34 +0200
Message-ID<4f8aa43a$0$6622$9b4e6d93@newsspool2.arcor-online.net>
In reply to#3322
Hi D.J.W.

what is about 64 Bit programs and using UTF8 / Unicode strings in Visual 
Studio / Vulcan / .Net? Theese two points are for me the most important 
reason to change from VO to an other programming language.

Regards, Fred
-- 


Fred Killet
killet-nospam@killetsoft.de
"D.J.W. van Kooten" <public@ic2remove.this.com> schrieb im Newsbeitrag 
news:uf1lo75vou3nvhss0pi08eb5a74ibecm1g@4ax.com...
>I recently bought Vulcan 2.10 to renew my testing and see if and where
> I can use Vulcan.
>
>
> If you're still (only) working in VO, in short my conclusion so far: I
> think that there will be a moment when you encounter something you can
> not really solve with VO. That doesn't mean you need to convert
> everything to Vulcan, but it means you do need knowledge to use .Net
> classes, via C#, Vulcan or any other language. This may be tomorrow or
> years after now, but it's a good idea to be prepared.
>
> Most people find Visual Studio, the most logical solution to use .Net
> languages, pleasant to work in. I quite strongly disagree, not because
> of VS but especially because all code (.PRG=.MEF in VO) which you can
> edit per entity in random order and combination in VO has to be loaded
> in the editor full.
>
> You will see in the page below that concerning this edit methods from
> out of 11 points I find 10 points a (major) disadvantage of VS versus
> VO. Debugging is better in VS, there are some other small advantages.
>
> Major advantage is of course the availability of code and samples and
> the access to the .Net classes. Currently I think that the loss in
> productivity due to the program based editor is not justified by the
> advantages.
>
> You'll see the (dis)advantages in green/red (and orange). I am most
> interested in any reaction - or in other words: I'd be glad to change
> the 'reds' for Visual Studio/.Net/Vulcan in 'greens'
>
> See:
>
> www.ic2.com/Cavo/VoVSVulcan.html
>
> Dick 

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3328

FromD.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com>
Date2012-04-16 09:10 +0200
Message-ID<k2hno718u3uala26at4c3hme7j84p63d56@4ax.com>
In reply to#3323
On Sun, 15 Apr 2012 12:34:30 +0200, "Fred Killet"
<killet-nospam@killetsoft.de> wrote:

Hello Fred,
>
>what is about 64 Bit programs and using UTF8 / Unicode strings in Visual 
>Studio / Vulcan / .Net? Theese two points are for me the most important 
>reason to change from VO to an other programming language.
>
Below what Willie and Frank wrote about 64 bit Vulcan. I would say
Vulcan does not produce 64 bit code but with a trick it works on a
full 64 bit Windows. For 64 bit you should probably use C#.

About Unicode, this is a phrase from the Vulcan help file:

"Vulcan.NET does not allow a STRING to be cast to a PSZ, not only
because it is dangerous, but also because strings in any .NET language
are Unicode strings, and PSZs in Vulcan.NET are 8-bit character
strings, for compatibility with Visual Objects." There's also a
HelloWorld sample in Vulcan, showing a Windows MessageBox() function,
in both ANSI and Unicode formats.

You won't be able to store Unicode in a simple dbf of course (unless
when using memofields).

Dick

=====================

If you are using Vulcan with winforms and NOT using memo files, VOGUI
or the 
VO runtime functions that deal with usuals you can add this to your 
postbuild event:
"C:\Program Files\Microsoft SDKs\Windows\v6.0A\bin\corflags.exe" 
"$(TargetPath)" /32BIT-

That will set your program to run "All CPU" instead of 32bit. The
warning 
though with this is that you cannot use USUALS or functions that calls
USUALS or you will get runtime errors. I use the postbuild event to
mark my 
web dlls as "all cpu" so they will run on my ISP's platform. But to
use that 
you have to follow the rules.

-----
in addittion to what Willie said I run the following batch job. The
first 
step is to build a monolithic exe file instead of one exe and many
dll's.

Then I remove the 32-bit flag.

c:\programme\microsoft\ILMerge\ilmerge /allowdup 
/out:"D:\Install\MyProgram.exe" 
"D:\VIDE2\Projects\MyProject\Bin\Release\MyProgramm.exe" 
"D:\VIDE2\Projects\MyProject\Bin\Release\MyDll.dll_1" 
"D:\VIDE2\Projects\MyProject\Bin\Release\MyDll.dll_2" "C:\Program 
Files\Vulcan.NET 2.0\Redist\Assemblies\v4.0\VulcanRT.dll" "C:\Program 
Files\Vulcan.NET 2.0\Redist\Assemblies\v4.0\VulcanRTFuncs.dll" 
/targetplatform:v4,C:\WINDOWS\Microsoft.NET\Framework\v4.0.30319
pause
"C:\Program Files\Microsoft SDKs\Windows\v6.1\Bin\corflags" 
"D:\Install\MyProgram.exe" /32BIT-
pause

On install I have to copy only one exe. No dll conflict anymore. It
runs as 
32bit program on 32bit OS and as 64bit program on 64bit OS without any
change. My customers are happy about it.

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3324

From"Danilo Giuliani" <softdevo@tiscali.it>
Date2012-04-15 15:58 +0200
Message-ID<4f8ad419$0$6827$5fc30a8@news.tiscali.it>
In reply to#3322
I did a few years ago the transition from VO to Vulcan, and after a moment 
of confusion, now I'm happy with the move and would not turn back. I have 
done things in Vulcan VO I would not have even dreamed of tenatare. Have a 
great adventure.

Danilo

"D.J.W. van Kooten"  ha scritto nel messaggio 
news:uf1lo75vou3nvhss0pi08eb5a74ibecm1g@4ax.com...

I recently bought Vulcan 2.10 to renew my testing and see if and where
I can use Vulcan.


If you're still (only) working in VO, in short my conclusion so far: I
think that there will be a moment when you encounter something you can
not really solve with VO. That doesn't mean you need to convert
everything to Vulcan, but it means you do need knowledge to use .Net
classes, via C#, Vulcan or any other language. This may be tomorrow or
years after now, but it's a good idea to be prepared.

Most people find Visual Studio, the most logical solution to use .Net
languages, pleasant to work in. I quite strongly disagree, not because
of VS but especially because all code (.PRG=.MEF in VO) which you can
edit per entity in random order and combination in VO has to be loaded
in the editor full.

You will see in the page below that concerning this edit methods from
out of 11 points I find 10 points a (major) disadvantage of VS versus
VO. Debugging is better in VS, there are some other small advantages.

Major advantage is of course the availability of code and samples and
the access to the .Net classes. Currently I think that the loss in
productivity due to the program based editor is not justified by the
advantages.

You'll see the (dis)advantages in green/red (and orange). I am most
interested in any reaction - or in other words: I'd be glad to change
the 'reds' for Visual Studio/.Net/Vulcan in 'greens'

See:

www.ic2.com/Cavo/VoVSVulcan.html

Dick 

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3329

FromD.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com>
Date2012-04-16 09:13 +0200
Message-ID<4fhno796u4ja4tqu6ks3tgeurbelf7g8pm@4ax.com>
In reply to#3324
On Sun, 15 Apr 2012 15:58:48 +0200, "Danilo Giuliani"
<softdevo@tiscali.it> wrote:

Hello Danilo,

>I did a few years ago the transition from VO to Vulcan, and after a moment 
>of confusion, now I'm happy with the move and would not turn back. I have 
>done things in Vulcan VO I would not have even dreamed of tenatare. Have a 
>great adventure.
>
I assume you refer to access to .Net classes, which I see as the main
(or probably only) real advantage for a (partial) move too?

If I wouldn't be thrown back in the Clipper era of editing full .PRG's
at a time I'd feel a lot happier with .Net.

Dick

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3331

From"Willie Moore" <williem@wmconsulting.com>
Date2012-04-16 08:06 -0500
Message-ID<jmh5h0$b4b$1@speranza.aioe.org>
In reply to#3322
Dick,

I made the jump to VS and Vulcan when VS was still at VS 2005. I really 
dislike going back into VO now. I am so used to using VS, I hate having to 
relearn where things are in VO. I still use VO to maintain my libraries but 
do no new coding in VO. A lot of your frustrations I believe are coming from 
the VS learning curve which can be steep. VS can be as organized / 
Disorganized as the programmer makes it. Personally, I keep folders under my 
project to hold similar prgs. That makes it easy to find things in the 
solution explorer. BTW you can "undock" the solution explorer and make it as 
large / small as you want. You don’t have to keep the default locations as 
supplied by VS. If you want more of the VO look then you can move your 
solution explorer to the left side of your window and move the tools to 
float off of the right side.

Being that VS is file based instead of repo based, there are differences. 
The main thing is that you have to included the #using just like you have to 
do in VB and C#. Of course there are ways around that too. You can tell 
Vulcan to automatically include namespaces in every prg without having to 
use #USING by placing them in assembly.prg. Personally I like seeing the 
#USING at the prg level because that lets me know what the real dependencies 
are for each prg.

The bottom line for me is that I like using VS and Vulcan. VO was / is a 
great language and Vulcan is the way to keep the language you like but 
allows you to push forward into the world of dotNet and all of the classes 
that come with it. I dumpled the VOGUI classes as fast as I could when I got 
to Vulcan in favor of Winforms (WPF wasing an option when I converted). All 
of my new work uses WPF.

Regards,
Willie
Vulcan VIP

"D.J.W. van Kooten"  wrote in message 
news:uf1lo75vou3nvhss0pi08eb5a74ibecm1g@4ax.com...

I recently bought Vulcan 2.10 to renew my testing and see if and where
I can use Vulcan.


If you're still (only) working in VO, in short my conclusion so far: I
think that there will be a moment when you encounter something you can
not really solve with VO. That doesn't mean you need to convert
everything to Vulcan, but it means you do need knowledge to use .Net
classes, via C#, Vulcan or any other language. This may be tomorrow or
years after now, but it's a good idea to be prepared.

Most people find Visual Studio, the most logical solution to use .Net
languages, pleasant to work in. I quite strongly disagree, not because
of VS but especially because all code (.PRG=.MEF in VO) which you can
edit per entity in random order and combination in VO has to be loaded
in the editor full.

You will see in the page below that concerning this edit methods from
out of 11 points I find 10 points a (major) disadvantage of VS versus
VO. Debugging is better in VS, there are some other small advantages.

Major advantage is of course the availability of code and samples and
the access to the .Net classes. Currently I think that the loss in
productivity due to the program based editor is not justified by the
advantages.

You'll see the (dis)advantages in green/red (and orange). I am most
interested in any reaction - or in other words: I'd be glad to change
the 'reds' for Visual Studio/.Net/Vulcan in 'greens'

See:

www.ic2.com/Cavo/VoVSVulcan.html

Dick 

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3333

FromD.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com>
Date2012-04-17 11:57 +0200
Message-ID<d5fqo7l5k5est9o0gmru1d2inmkfm48ske@4ax.com>
In reply to#3331
On Mon, 16 Apr 2012 08:06:39 -0500, "Willie Moore"
<williem@wmconsulting.com> wrote:

Hello Willie,
>
>I made the jump to VS and Vulcan when VS was still at VS 2005. I really 
>dislike going back into VO now. I am so used to using VS, I hate having to 
>relearn where things are in VO. I still use VO to maintain my libraries but 
>do no new coding in VO. A lot of your frustrations I believe are coming from 
>the VS learning curve which can be steep. 

I have no problem with the learning curve at all. Of course, getting
used to some other shortcuts, menu's etc. is always less comfortable
than keep using what you know. So it's logical you don't want to go
back.

I've tried to summarize as objective as possible in
www.ic2.com/Cavo/VoVSVulcan.html which environment is the most
efficient and comfortable to work in. Out of (now) 30 points 19 are
better (or as good as) in VO and only 8 better (or as good as) in VS.
The more I discover, the more 'reds' in VS.

I may have no choice in a few years and there are some small programs
which would benefit from the access to .Net classes. So it doesn't
matter what I think of it, it's there and having to use it is having
to get used to working far less efficient.

But so far everyone who says how great VS is failed to tell me why
(except .Net access).

Dick

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3334

FromKarl Faller <k.faller_withoutthat_@onlinehome.de>
Date2012-04-17 14:54 +0200
Message-ID<njpqo75563q788vkv4b71j835jpnnm3afo@4ax.com>
In reply to#3333
Dick,
>But so far everyone who says how great VS is failed to tell me why
>(except .Net access).
<g>. 
May i cite a friend of mine, CEO of a not so small company: "i decided
NOT to buy SAP for our company but another tool. I never slept so bad,
as the weeks after. Why? Because, if something would go wrong with the
other product, my head would certainly fall. OTOH, i was sure, _with_
SAP, we would fail-  but that wouldn't matter, as "everyone" uses
it..."

Karl

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3335

FromMassimo Bighelli <info@arcasistemi.it>
Date2012-04-17 16:25 +0200
Message-ID<jmjug4$3oq$1@speranza.aioe.org>
In reply to#3334
snip
"..., if something would go wrong with the other product, my head would 
certainly fall. OTOH, i was sure, _with_ SAP, we would fail - but that 
wouldn't matter, as "everyone" uses it..."
snip

great !!!

Massimo

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3336

FromD.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com>
Date2012-04-17 17:49 +0200
Message-ID<ev3ro7lpar423ngj0p3dpos38pfsn7g3ep@4ax.com>
In reply to#3334
On Tue, 17 Apr 2012 14:54:15 +0200, Karl Faller
<k.faller_withoutthat_@onlinehome.de> wrote:

Hello Karl,


>May i cite a friend of mine, CEO of a not so small company: "i decided
>NOT to buy SAP for our company but another tool. I never slept so bad,
>as the weeks after. Why? Because, if something would go wrong with the
>other product, my head would certainly fall. OTOH, i was sure, _with_
>SAP, we would fail-  but that wouldn't matter, as "everyone" uses
>it..."
>
Very recognizable. I think most of us have the same problem with our
own software: if there's also a solution by MS or SAP or whoever, most
companies choose indeed a solution with less service and functionality
which they consider "safe". So I am glad I have hardly had to spent
any money on M$ products as long as our company exists<g>.

I am still working for multinational companies and part of the work
is....things they can't achieve with their SAP implementation (or not
within reasonable costs/timeframe).

Dick

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3337

FromMassimo Bighelli <info@arcasistemi.it>
Date2012-04-17 18:31 +0200
Message-ID<jmk5tn$o4c$1@speranza.aioe.org>
In reply to#3333
Dick,

here I am, and looked at you table.
Well, I partially agree the concept of your comparison, but you should 
add a new column, separating VS from Vulcan.
I know nothing about Vulcan, so my comment are VS related only.
When I will start triyng Vulcan, maybe, I will probably agree with you 
on a greater number of points.

1. not very important
2. agreed
3. agreed, one of the main points related to the repo, but don't forget 
the relevant part of habits in managing the code entities
4. it's the same point 3
5. agreed partially, see my comment on point 3
6. agreed, I miss this
7.8. don't know, not interested in such features, so not important to me
9.10. agreed, ok, there is no repo
11. one click to zip what I need, a file based repo is easy, isn't it?
13.14. no comment
15. msdn is my help and SH-F1 is ok (I don't know Vulcan)
16.17 intellisense IS immediate and complete and filter able :-)
17.19.20 well, debugging with F5-F9-F11... it'a dream, readability, 
speed and the completeness of the overview of what's happening...
21.22 no comment on Vulcan, it's ok here in C# and VB
23. agreed, but never used to extend basic classes, so I don't miss this 
feature
24.25. no comment
26. no, see my comment on point 11
27. no comment
28. you can change this in options keyboard
29. VO is fine and elegant with it's colored repo, habits..., I don't 
loose my productivity because the output window
30. no comment on Vulcan, the editor automatically indents... I never 
touch TAB at a new line :-)  and it's smart enough

VO was great, IS GREAT, for my work and for my productivity, because the 
langauge, because the repo, and so on...
Now I think I will be productive and happy with VS, despite the missing 
repo, because the other (many) advantages the new environment brings to me.

Regards

Massimo







Il 17/04/2012 11:57, D.J.W. van Kooten ha scritto:
> On Mon, 16 Apr 2012 08:06:39 -0500, "Willie Moore"
> <williem@wmconsulting.com>  wrote:
>
> Hello Willie,
>>
>> I made the jump to VS and Vulcan when VS was still at VS 2005. I really
>> dislike going back into VO now. I am so used to using VS, I hate having to
>> relearn where things are in VO. I still use VO to maintain my libraries but
>> do no new coding in VO. A lot of your frustrations I believe are coming from
>> the VS learning curve which can be steep.
>
> I have no problem with the learning curve at all. Of course, getting
> used to some other shortcuts, menu's etc. is always less comfortable
> than keep using what you know. So it's logical you don't want to go
> back.
>
> I've tried to summarize as objective as possible in
> www.ic2.com/Cavo/VoVSVulcan.html which environment is the most
> efficient and comfortable to work in. Out of (now) 30 points 19 are
> better (or as good as) in VO and only 8 better (or as good as) in VS.
> The more I discover, the more 'reds' in VS.
>
> I may have no choice in a few years and there are some small programs
> which would benefit from the access to .Net classes. So it doesn't
> matter what I think of it, it's there and having to use it is having
> to get used to working far less efficient.
>
> But so far everyone who says how great VS is failed to tell me why
> (except .Net access).
>
> Dick

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3338

FromD.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com>
Date2012-04-17 20:56 +0200
Message-ID<gqdro7dm9pc4vn6c2fshaas15h6acv6bm7@4ax.com>
In reply to#3337
On Tue, 17 Apr 2012 18:31:56 +0200, Massimo Bighelli
<info@arcasistemi.it> wrote:

Hello Massimo,

>here I am, and looked at you table.

Thank you for taking the time to do that. It is not only for myself
(although if on any point I learn that I am wrong and VS would
actually be better than I now conclude would be nice). Also anyone
still working in VO can learn what they give up and what they gain
from leaving VO.

>Well, I partially agree the concept of your comparison, but you should 
>add a new column, separating VS from Vulcan.

You're right here; however, most users will go from VO to VS+Vulcan or
VS+C# etc and face both changes. I think that coming from VO, Vulcan
will make your code look far more familiair but there are a few
limitations to Vulcan compared to C#.

>3. agreed, one of the main points related to the repo, but don't forget 
>the relevant part of habits in managing the code entities

No matter how I organize code, I will always see my whole program
loaded instead of what I want to see and have a chance to see multiple
outlined methods I don't want to see between the code I want to edit.
Unless I create 150.000 programs (C# files) which I think has some
disavantages too <g>.

>11. one click to zip what I need, a file based repo is easy, isn't it?

I've not checked if it can be replaced so quickly (I mean: what about
dependencies; what happens when I put back too few files).  I've added
your Zip command but kept the colour red; it is always more work than
a (manual or VOPP) export from VO.

>15. msdn is my help and SH-F1 is ok (I don't know Vulcan)
>16.17 intellisense IS immediate and complete and filter able :-)

Maybe you only get that in the 16.000 euro Ultimate version? If I
click Shift F1 on a keyword in a C# program I always get "Code and
Text Editor" help, no context help for C#. On the Install Help content
it says Visual C# - local. 

Plus most of the time I have to wait looking at "The documentation
cache is still being constructed. Please try again in a few seconds."
for a few seconds, even in a very small C# program. And tooltips are
giving me not much info on not too many places.

That simply doesn't happen in VO. Maybe I can show you if you happen
to visit Devcon?

>21.22 no comment on Vulcan, it's ok here in C# and VB
(22 only for Ultimate).

>28. you can change this in options keyboard
Sure. But they are less efficient (like (un)comment with just 1 single
shortcut key in VO and minimal 2 -modified- single shortcut keys in VS

>29. VO is fine and elegant with it's colored repo, habits..., I don't 
>loose my productivity because the output window

Well, this is normally not a problem I admit. But I assure you it's
unworkable if you have just transported 68 aef's from VO and this
window shows >100.000 errors while I see NOTHING of the compilation
status anywhere in the VS screen. It's all so poorly done....

>30. no comment on Vulcan, the editor automatically indents... I never 
>touch TAB at a new line :-)  and it's smart enough
I have not done much in C#; will try a few things; first impression
was that after an IF + enter it did NOT indent. I'll take your word
for it (or the Ultimate version??)

Dick

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3339

FromMassimo Bighelli <info@arcasistemi.it>
Date2012-04-17 23:42 +0200
Message-ID<jmko3v$9lr$1@speranza.aioe.org>
In reply to#3338
Come on Dick,

Vulcan will be my next step...

I started with C# plus VB because we were in the position to re-project 
our main app (for two big companies), our co-workers are VB and C# men, 
jumping to SQL at the same time.
Vulcan was not reliable at that time.

> No matter how I organize code, I will always see my whole program
> loaded instead of what I want to see and have a chance to see multiple
> outlined methods I don't want to see between the code I want to edit.
> Unless I create 150.000 programs (C# files) which I think has some
> disavantages too<g>.

Yes. Hence my different approach. Now I write class based files, 
accurately naming methods. It's not so bad in the end.

> ... what happens when I put back too few files)

sometimes I zip the whole solution folder, (sometimes only few 
subfolders) and unzip when at home, and it's common to send via email a 
modified class I re-wrote at night, complete with the new resource form.

>> 15. msdn is my help and SH-F1 is ok (I don't know Vulcan)
>> 16.17 intellisense IS immediate and complete and filter able :-)
>
> Maybe you only get that in the 16.000 euro Ultimate version? If I
> click Shift F1 on a keyword in a C# program I always get "Code and
> Text Editor" help, no context help for C#. On the Install Help content
> it says Visual C# - local.

Intellisense is the same in Pro version
To be honest, I deeply use the on-line MSDN library (select the word and 
press F1) and other usefull portals looking for examples.

> Plus most of the time I have to wait looking at "The documentation
> cache is still being constructed. Please try again in a few seconds."

Never saw such a message. I don't know what you are talking about.
Intellisense is faster than my typing... and I never complete my typing, 
pressing TAB the selected voice in the tooltip is in my code.

> That simply doesn't happen in VO. Maybe I can show you if you happen
> to visit Devcon?

:-) I beleve you. I know VO since 1.0, day after day, for every day of 
my life.

>> 28. you can change this in options keyboard
> Sure. But they are less efficient (like (un)comment with just 1 single
> shortcut key in VO and minimal 2 -modified- single shortcut keys in VS

you can find some single shortcut not already used, or delete some 
shortcut you don't use (I use CTRL-0 and CTRL-9)

>> 29. VO is fine and elegant with it's colored repo, habits..., I don't
>> loose my productivity because the output window
>
> Well, this is normally not a problem I admit. But I assure you it's
> unworkable if you have just transported 68 aef's from VO and this
> window shows>100.000 errors while I see NOTHING of the compilation
> status anywhere in the VS screen. It's all so poorly done....

well, this was the first impression when I transported, and the second 
too... My customers forced me to have a different approach: there was no 
chance to wait for Vulcan.
Now my Plan_Ges is running 24x7 on MSSQLserver, customers are (quite) 
happy, it's "brute" and a lot of work will be done in the underworld. In 
certain circumstances would be better an xBase language rather than VB 
or C#, and it's time to give Vulcan a second chance.

> first impression
> was that after an IF + enter it did NOT indent. I'll take your word
> for it (or the Ultimate version??)

pro is the same

>
> Dick

Massimo

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3343

FromD.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com>
Date2012-04-18 12:12 +0200
Message-ID<8m3to71f8obd4g83flsil6kmfgad467rn1@4ax.com>
In reply to#3339
On Tue, 17 Apr 2012 23:42:28 +0200, Massimo Bighelli
<info@arcasistemi.it> wrote:

Hello Massimo,

>> Plus most of the time I have to wait looking at "The documentation
>> cache is still being constructed. Please try again in a few seconds."
>
>Never saw such a message. I don't know what you are talking about.
>Intellisense is faster than my typing... and I never complete my typing, 
>pressing TAB the selected voice in the tooltip is in my code.


There are entries on Google on this. I have studied a few but still
have no clue. My PC is fast enough, I don't know what causes this. For
what I can see, Intellisense is slow and incomplete. And believe me,
that was the last I expected. I have a normal VS2010 Professional
installation and this is how it works (or better: works not).

Geoff would probably have written that I have a special "Dick"
version....Anyhow I am used to non functioning MS products but you
understand I am not exactly looking forward to having to face this
daily.

Dick

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3346

FromWillie Moore <williem@wmconsulting.com>
Date2012-04-18 14:09 +0000
Message-ID<1528870278356450651.546521williem-wmconsulting.com@news.aioe.org>
In reply to#3343
Dick,

While the intellisence is not as complete as c#, I find it quite usable and
snappy on my machine. I use the autocomplete quite a lot. Fabrics has done
a great job extending it. 

Regards,
Willie

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3347

FromD.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com>
Date2012-04-18 17:04 +0200
Message-ID<j3lto71ilu5k2rd2q9ffoumfumqp7r6vbc@4ax.com>
In reply to#3346
On Wed, 18 Apr 2012 14:09:39 +0000 (UTC), Willie Moore
<williem@wmconsulting.com> wrote:

Hello Willie,
>
>While the intellisence is not as complete as c#, I find it quite usable and
>snappy on my machine. I use the autocomplete quite a lot. Fabrics has done
>a great job extending it. 

I mainly compare it to VO as you understand and while almost every
place in my VO code I get full information about the method and it's
paramaters I get far less info in VS.

Just an example. If I type:

IF SUBSTR3( 

I get the full function with parameters in VO and VS. So far so good.

But now I start typing the paramaters. As soon as I am typing my
second paramater, the tooltip in VO highlights that parameter while
the Vulcan tooltip disappears. I use that A LOT when I have a lot of
parameters to see what I need to type now and it's another example of
why I find VS so much less productive. I will have to go back of the
pre 2.8 times of counting the variables and keep looking back to what
to I have to type now.

In C# I tried to see what happens when I type input.substring( but I
do not get a tooltip at all although Do you get any tooltips there?
And if so, do you have an idea why I don't get it? As context help
isn't working either I have to copy everything I type in Google to see
paramaters.... a major productivity killer when you're new to a
labguage.

Dick

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3348

FromWillie Moore <williem@wmconsulting.com>
Date2012-04-18 18:39 +0000
Message-ID<1084202136356466692.267365williem-wmconsulting.com@news.aioe.org>
In reply to#3347
Dick,

In C#, When I type this.textbox1.text.substring I get a box below my line
with the prototype of the parameters. As I type a parameter and hit , the
next parameter is highlighted in my tooltip.
Maybe you have that option turned off in VS. 

Vulcan's intellisence is still lacking c# in this example but I still find
Vulcan very productive to work in. 

Regards,
Willie
Vulcan VIP

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3349

From"Ginny Caughey" <gcaughey@hotmail.com>
Date2012-04-18 14:59 -0400
Message-ID<4f8f0f31$0$486$c3e8da3$a8a65a91@news.astraweb.com>
In reply to#3347
Hi Dick,

I'm delighted to see you're learning C#. It's a great and low-risk way to 
extend big legacy VO apps with .NET functionality.

The IDEs are different from each other, and after over 10 years in .NET I am 
much more productive in even beta versions of Visual Studio than I am in VO, 
but that's not really important. If you need .NET functionality (and 
eventually most people who continue developing new code for Windows will) 
then Visual Studio is the right IDE. You won't be writing .NET code the way 
you used to write VO code anyway once you really get into .NET development 
and application architecture.

Ginny

"D.J.W. van Kooten"  wrote in message 
news:j3lto71ilu5k2rd2q9ffoumfumqp7r6vbc@4ax.com...

On Wed, 18 Apr 2012 14:09:39 +0000 (UTC), Willie Moore
<williem@wmconsulting.com> wrote:

Hello Willie,
>
>While the intellisence is not as complete as c#, I find it quite usable and
>snappy on my machine. I use the autocomplete quite a lot. Fabrics has done
>a great job extending it.

I mainly compare it to VO as you understand and while almost every
place in my VO code I get full information about the method and it's
paramaters I get far less info in VS.

Just an example. If I type:

IF SUBSTR3(

I get the full function with parameters in VO and VS. So far so good.

But now I start typing the paramaters. As soon as I am typing my
second paramater, the tooltip in VO highlights that parameter while
the Vulcan tooltip disappears. I use that A LOT when I have a lot of
parameters to see what I need to type now and it's another example of
why I find VS so much less productive. I will have to go back of the
pre 2.8 times of counting the variables and keep looking back to what
to I have to type now.

In C# I tried to see what happens when I type input.substring( but I
do not get a tooltip at all although Do you get any tooltips there?
And if so, do you have an idea why I don't get it? As context help
isn't working either I have to copy everything I type in Google to see
paramaters.... a major productivity killer when you're new to a
labguage.

Dick 

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3350

FromMassimo Bighelli <info@arcasistemi.it>
Date2012-04-18 22:16 +0200
Message-ID<jmn7es$qoe$1@speranza.aioe.org>
In reply to#3343
Dick

> For what I can see, Intellisense is slow and incomplete. And believe me,
> that was the last I expected. I have a normal VS2010 Professional
> installation and this is how it works (or better: works not).

are you talking about Vulcan intellisense ?
I don't know.
I re-learned programming in VB(.net) after 20 years, mantaining my OOP 
base, just looking at intellisense, a wonderfull teacher.
The same in C#.
Few weeks, following intellisense and recording the class structures of 
the framework.

> Geoff would probably have written that I have a special "Dick"
> version....

probably... sure! :-)

> Anyhow I am used to non functioning MS products but you
> understand I am not exactly looking forward to having to face this
> daily.

Vulcan is growing, and this will not happen, I'm confident.
In the meantime I'm happy with the the full advantages VS give me in VB 
and C#.
Don't give up!
Follow Willie's and Ginny advises, and beleve me (I am a VO man from the 
beginning): VS is good enuogh, despite the missing repo.

Massimo

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#3369

From"richard.townsendrose" <richard.townsendrose@gmail.com>
Date2012-04-25 05:58 -0700
Message-ID<5f0afd48-1897-46bf-b6a7-6784bfdb5222@12g2000vba.googlegroups.com>
In reply to#3350
Hi all

Dick is right .. it is all about productivity

and there isn't anything that i need that i dont have in VO

Richard

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


Page 1 of 2  [1] 2  Next page →

Back to top | Article view | comp.lang.clipper.visual-objects


csiph-web