Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]


Groups > comp.lang.clipper.visual-objects > #1720 > unrolled thread

OT: MS Security Essentials

Started byD.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com>
First post2011-07-21 09:24 +0200
Last post2011-07-28 23:00 +0200
Articles 13 — 6 participants

Back to article view | Back to comp.lang.clipper.visual-objects


Contents

  OT: MS Security Essentials D.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com> - 2011-07-21 09:24 +0200
    Re: OT: MS Security Essentials Sherlock <sherlock@sherlock.com.au> - 2011-07-21 02:57 -0700
      Re: OT: MS Security Essentials Massimo Bighelli <info@arcasistemi.it> - 2011-07-21 13:22 +0200
      Re: OT: MS Security Essentials D.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com> - 2011-07-21 15:18 +0200
        Re: OT: MS Security Essentials Sherlock <sherlock@sherlock.com.au> - 2011-07-22 02:58 -0700
      Re: OT: MS Security Essentials "Craig Dawson" <craig@control.nospam.net.au> - 2011-07-22 00:01 +1000
        Re: OT: MS Security Essentials Sherlock <sherlock@sherlock.com.au> - 2011-07-22 02:52 -0700
        Re: OT: MS Security Essentials D.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com> - 2011-07-22 14:57 +0200
          Re: OT: MS Security Essentials Sherlock <sherlock@sherlock.com.au> - 2011-07-22 22:51 -0700
    Re: OT: MS Security Essentials "Geoff Schaller" <geoffx@softwarexobjectives.com.au> - 2011-07-23 05:56 +0000
      Re: OT: MS Security Essentials D.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com> - 2011-08-08 15:04 +0200
    Re: OT: MS Security Essentials "Paul D B" <polleke@NOMORESPAMhnt.be> - 2011-07-28 16:15 +0200
      Re: OT: MS Security Essentials D.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com> - 2011-07-28 23:00 +0200

#1720 — OT: MS Security Essentials

FromD.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com>
Date2011-07-21 09:24 +0200
SubjectOT: MS Security Essentials
Message-ID<fljf27dcvc9q04p7npo9i85kj17klqd9tq@4ax.com>
A while ago, Geoff wrote in this NG:

Remove all your AV and install Microsoft security Essentials.
Its Free. Its Good. Its basic - no frills.

I decided to follow his advice and try MS Security Essentials instead
of AVG, also because the % of detected malware was a bit higher than
that of AVG.

This is my conclusion:

- After installation, MSSE started a scan of my whole PC. AVG finished
such a scan in about an hour, MSSE took over 6 hours!

- The good news: MSSE found more viruses than AVG did, all of them
contained in old zip files which never were or never be would
unpacked, but MSSE can not know that, and some programs are not
viruses (like Combofux which is a kind of last resort with persistent
malware but most anti virus programs think this is a virus
- The second good news is that there is an informative link to a site
telling what the virus did.

- Then I selected an action per virus. The dialog for that is very
uncomfortable, like many MS dialog in Windows (e.g. try to change your
path, since Windows 2 it's an sle were hardly 1 directory entry fits;
I always copy it to an editor and paste it back). There are only 3
lines to show the virus history, you can not enlarge the window. I
selected Delete for most as an action. A progress bar started and than
it hang.

- After restarting the PC later, Windows was installing updates. Not
sure if this is the way MSSE finishes it's action or that automatic
updates have been turned on my MSES (I have this turned off). 

- Then 45 minutes of intensive hard disk activity made working nearly
impossible. I could find no option to switch something off and over
600.000 reads/writes/deletions took place in a Windows update
directory. The the MSMPENG process took a large % of my CPU.

- After a while the same 14 virusses which I had either deleted or
allowed were reported again. Same result as the day before. The
progress bar went a further after I decided to kill the MSMPENG
process

- Fortunately the disk activity sounding like a tropical rain shower
did not repeat this morning.but the same 14 virusses were again
reported. I clicked the default action to deal with it and in the
history I found for all that their actions showed Allowed.....

Geoff, sorry, I can not share your conclusion that it's Good when it
does not delete the virusses as requested. I have really tried it (if
it recognizes more malware than AVG and it would have worked well, and
it's free, why not). Of course you will reply that you don't have
these problems and that I am the only one but what could be more
straightforward than deleting a virus....I will give it a try a few
more days to see some day MSES will indeed delete the virusses or
otherwise I'll reinstall AVG.

Dick

[toc] | [next] | [standalone]


#1722

FromSherlock <sherlock@sherlock.com.au>
Date2011-07-21 02:57 -0700
Message-ID<fecb5ea1-a986-4eb5-bbeb-5ef2009d701b@t38g2000prj.googlegroups.com>
In reply to#1720
Dick

Microsoft Essentials II [ there was an early version ] is installed on
all our machines, my home machines and hundreds and hundreds of
clients.
Have never had a problem with it, speed or reporting things you
describe.

Very happy with this product and dumped AVG and replaces with MSE and
we would switch 2 or 3 clients offices/networks a week.

So beats me why you have issues.

Tell my if you run it for your test, run it as ADMINISTRATOR and see
whether you have permissions to remove the 'bugs' detected.

Phil McGuinness
----

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#1723

FromMassimo Bighelli <info@arcasistemi.it>
Date2011-07-21 13:22 +0200
Message-ID<j09267$j9u$1@speranza.aioe.org>
In reply to#1722
Dick,

same as Phil, here.
Essential 2 is OK in Vista and Seven.

Massimo


Il 21/07/2011 11:57, Sherlock ha scritto:
> Dick
>
> Microsoft Essentials II [ there was an early version ] is installed on
> all our machines, my home machines and hundreds and hundreds of
> clients.
> Have never had a problem with it, speed or reporting things you
> describe.
>
> Very happy with this product and dumped AVG and replaces with MSE and
> we would switch 2 or 3 clients offices/networks a week.
>
> So beats me why you have issues.
>
> Tell my if you run it for your test, run it as ADMINISTRATOR and see
> whether you have permissions to remove the 'bugs' detected.
>
> Phil McGuinness
> ----
>
>

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#1724

FromD.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com>
Date2011-07-21 15:18 +0200
Message-ID<8d4g271rl1d43tajug2r99h12ouembbqnd@4ax.com>
In reply to#1722
On Thu, 21 Jul 2011 02:57:20 -0700 (PDT), Sherlock
<sherlock@sherlock.com.au> wrote:

Hello Phil,

>Very happy with this product and dumped AVG and replaces with MSE and
>we would switch 2 or 3 clients offices/networks a week.

Why did you dump AVG in the first place? I've done the switch because
tests show a higher malware protection but for the rest AVG was the
best anti-virus program I had so far.
>
>So beats me why you have issues.

Me too but I have them. 

Then on the detail issues: if you had to write a program which can
easily report up to dozens of lines, would  not the first things you
do is make that control resizable; some owner alignments in it? It
stays 3 lines no matter how big you make the window. I simply don't
understand that a wealthy company as MS makes a virus program which at
least ...should...be very good but the interface is written by someone
who has never worked with Windows before, it seems.

>Tell my if you run it for your test, run it as ADMINISTRATOR and see
>whether you have permissions to remove the 'bugs' detected.
>
Of course; on this PC I've about all rights and permissions set. Hence
my need for a virus program <g>

Dick

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#1728

FromSherlock <sherlock@sherlock.com.au>
Date2011-07-22 02:58 -0700
Message-ID<6d37c6bd-67e5-44d5-b10e-1f9703f774d6@j14g2000prn.googlegroups.com>
In reply to#1724
Dick

snip[  Why did you dump AVG in the first place? I've done the switch
because tests show a higher malware protection but for the rest AVG
was the best anti-virus program I had so far.]

I switched for three reasons.

1/ It works and I think MS know their own system and vulnerabilities
better than anybody else.
2/ It is so simple compared to all the crap that the others try to
add, it is just not required.  Virus these days are more social
engineering than bugs spread the old way. It is bad links to sites and
dump people installation phshing systems.
3/ AVG let me down in service, cost me business and I cost them a hell
of lot more, I hope. I thought the service was pathetic.

snip[ Of course; on this PC I've about all rights and permissions set.
Hence my need for a virus program <g> ]

As I stated a lot of sites are just virus spreaders which the user
helpfully clicks on stuff to introduce issues.
I see Googles latest moves to look locally for viruses may have
advantages as well.

But so far we have had a great run with MSE II and it looks after
itseld.


Phil

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#1726

From"Craig Dawson" <craig@control.nospam.net.au>
Date2011-07-22 00:01 +1000
Message-ID<4e2831d5$0$4417$c30e37c6@pit-reader.telstra.net>
In reply to#1722
Dick,
I've been an advocate of Symantec (and have recommended, sold and installed 
it on my clients servers) for over 15 years but have found in the last few 
months it has become more and more intrusive. Our clients are now 
complaining about it. Even on our servers and pcs here it was becomming a 
right royal pain and just yesterday took the step to remove SEP from our pcs 
(a hassle in itself - but that's another story) and replacing it with MSE.

What a difference! An immediate (at least) 10% increase in performance - can 
compile VO apps faster than ever :)
I have yet to check it over some sample infected files that I use for 
testing but will do so in the coming weeks. On first impressions though it 
looks OK and is very unobtrusive. I agree that the UI is a bit combersome in 
areas but I am sure that will improve over time.

Regards, Craig Dawson.


"Sherlock" <sherlock@sherlock.com.au> wrote in message 
news:fecb5ea1-a986-4eb5-bbeb-5ef2009d701b@t38g2000prj.googlegroups.com...
> Dick
>
> Microsoft Essentials II [ there was an early version ] is installed on
> all our machines, my home machines and hundreds and hundreds of
> clients.
> Have never had a problem with it, speed or reporting things you
> describe.
>
> Very happy with this product and dumped AVG and replaces with MSE and
> we would switch 2 or 3 clients offices/networks a week.
>
> So beats me why you have issues.
>
> Tell my if you run it for your test, run it as ADMINISTRATOR and see
> whether you have permissions to remove the 'bugs' detected.
>
> Phil McGuinness
> ----
>
> 

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#1729

FromSherlock <sherlock@sherlock.com.au>
Date2011-07-22 02:52 -0700
Message-ID<bea07c7e-849c-4a47-b253-f78fbc5a807e@g5g2000prn.googlegroups.com>
In reply to#1726
Craig

These virus fixing programs.. are the new problem.

No long ago it took AVG over a month before they fixed an issue with
my VO app generating false positives.
It cost me 1 client, as they would not believe I did not have a virus
because AVG was perfect.
Out support line for 3 weeks just ran hot with it moving my EXE to the
virus vault.

There is a good resource called  "www.virustotal.com"  where you can
upload a suspect file and it is tested using the top 50 virus
programs.
I do this with a user or IT person who believe they have found the
smoking gun file.
All of them were fine with my EXE file but the old AVG thought it knew
better.
What it was tripping over was ASPACK crunched EXE so switched to UPX
the open source version and it does not complain.

As revenge we converted about 40 AVG sites to MSE.

Phil

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#1730

FromD.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com>
Date2011-07-22 14:57 +0200
Message-ID<3lqi27hsjbnqunbq14q8k39se37qf08ie3@4ax.com>
In reply to#1726
On Fri, 22 Jul 2011 00:01:36 +1000, "Craig Dawson"
<craig@control.nospam.net.au> wrote:

Hello Craig, Phil,

>I've been an advocate of Symantec (and have recommended, sold and installed 
>it on my clients servers) for over 15 years but have found in the last few 
>months it has become more and more intrusive. 


In the past I've used both Norton Internet Security and McAfee and I
got rid of them long ago for the same reasons as you both have. Slow,
bad service, etc. I do not have Phil's problem with AVG concerning the
service as I use the free version: I do not even want the extra's in
the paid version! 

In the meantime I can tell you that MSES has finally seemded to deal
with the 'virusses' it found. Every day until today it warned for the
same virusses but a few less per day. While today I was still thinking
what to do with remaining 2, I found that not answering it means that
MSES deletes the file. For an earlier deletion it recorded an error
code that the file was too big (a few Gb zip file) . If I could show a
few more lines than 3 (don't expect any improvements there Craig, see
the path edit control I mentioned) I could prove you that MSES shows
Allowed to the status of the virus files and later reported them again
but this time with Quarantaine or Deleted. This can NEVER be the case!

That means that the program does not work reliable IMO. When I allow a
file (which I did not with 2 exceptions so that's problem nr 1) it
should not report it again. When I excempt zip files from scanning, it
should not report files in zip files  again, problem nr 2). Any action
with files found on a scan should not require 4 days (problem nr 3).
The program should wait for me to decide, not delete when I don't in a
while (problem nr 4). 

Then an interesting one: as written, I downloaded Combofix.exe, a very
good anti malware program. In my MSES history I have the following
entries:

d:\download\Combofix.exe = Trojan:Win32/Orsam!rts 19-7 (Allowed)
Same 20-7 (2x)

Ok, that's what I want.

Now I scan the file from Explorer. Then I would expect the MSES to
report the same virus, right? But no. It says Scanned 2 files with a
green icon.

Problem nr 5: 2 files? It's not a zip, but a direct executable. Also,
MSES doesn't tell which file it scanned (problem nr 6) That makes you
wonder if the program is scanning the right file and there's no way to
tell.

Problem nr 7: the green light. Even when I allow a file, which could
have been done by accident, MSES should have told me that it found
Trojan:Win32/Orsam!rts but I allowed it. Or something like that.

I keep MSES for now, after all it found the virusses, but I don't
share your optimism about how good it is. It hasn't been slowing me
down since 2 days, that's true, but nor  did AVG.

Dick

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#1735

FromSherlock <sherlock@sherlock.com.au>
Date2011-07-22 22:51 -0700
Message-ID<6f3a2ca7-24ad-4bcf-95fd-844b6b5ff6c4@m5g2000prh.googlegroups.com>
In reply to#1730
snip[ Phil's problem with AVG concerning the service as I use the free
version: I do not even want the extra's in the paid version! ]

This was in the FREE and PAID versions.
After 1 month of non action backwards and forwards and the cost to my
company in labour about $8000 and who knows the cost to clients in
frustration.. I have decided they are not worth dealing with.
THey have now given me and FTP location to submit each build.
At the end of the day it was their problem with ASPACK a well know
commercial product and not our problem.

Dumped ASPACK and AVG and no problems.

Phil

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#1748

From"Geoff Schaller" <geoffx@softwarexobjectives.com.au>
Date2011-07-23 05:56 +0000
Message-ID<4e2a628e$0$46582$c30e37c6@exi-reader.telstra.net>
In reply to#1720
Dick I just cannot fathom why you have such problems when no-one else 
does. The conspiracist inside me would love to believe the 'Dick Switch' 
was thrown merely to frustrate you. My suspicion is that you either 
misread the instructions or misunderstand them in spectacular fashion.

But there is no doubting you have a knack at destroying good software 
enjoyed by millions.

Geoff



"D.J.W. van Kooten" <public@ic2remove.this.com> wrote in message 
news:fljf27dcvc9q04p7npo9i85kj17klqd9tq@4ax.com:

> A while ago, Geoff wrote in this NG:
>
> Remove all your AV and install Microsoft security Essentials.
> Its Free. Its Good. Its basic - no frills.
>
> I decided to follow his advice and try MS Security Essentials instead
> of AVG, also because the % of detected malware was a bit higher than
> that of AVG.
>
> This is my conclusion:
>
> - After installation, MSSE started a scan of my whole PC. AVG finished
> such a scan in about an hour, MSSE took over 6 hours!
>
> - The good news: MSSE found more viruses than AVG did, all of them
> contained in old zip files which never were or never be would
> unpacked, but MSSE can not know that, and some programs are not
> viruses (like Combofux which is a kind of last resort with persistent
> malware but most anti virus programs think this is a virus
> - The second good news is that there is an informative link to a site
> telling what the virus did.
>
> - Then I selected an action per virus. The dialog for that is very
> uncomfortable, like many MS dialog in Windows (e.g. try to change your
> path, since Windows 2 it's an sle were hardly 1 directory entry fits;
> I always copy it to an editor and paste it back). There are only 3
> lines to show the virus history, you can not enlarge the window. I
> selected Delete for most as an action. A progress bar started and than
> it hang.
>
> - After restarting the PC later, Windows was installing updates. Not
> sure if this is the way MSSE finishes it's action or that automatic
> updates have been turned on my MSES (I have this turned off).
>
> - Then 45 minutes of intensive hard disk activity made working nearly
> impossible. I could find no option to switch something off and over
> 600.000 reads/writes/deletions took place in a Windows update
> directory. The the MSMPENG process took a large % of my CPU.
>
> - After a while the same 14 virusses which I had either deleted or
> allowed were reported again. Same result as the day before. The
> progress bar went a further after I decided to kill the MSMPENG
> process
>
> - Fortunately the disk activity sounding like a tropical rain shower
> did not repeat this morning.but the same 14 virusses were again
> reported. I clicked the default action to deal with it and in the
> history I found for all that their actions showed Allowed.....
>
> Geoff, sorry, I can not share your conclusion that it's Good when it
> does not delete the virusses as requested. I have really tried it (if
> it recognizes more malware than AVG and it would have worked well, and
> it's free, why not). Of course you will reply that you don't have
> these problems and that I am the only one but what could be more
> straightforward than deleting a virus....I will give it a try a few
> more days to see some day MSES will indeed delete the virusses or
> otherwise I'll reinstall AVG.
>
> Dick

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#1798

FromD.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com>
Date2011-08-08 15:04 +0200
Message-ID<l8nv37lr4tkfi62boo7a9ucivshlteq1k4@4ax.com>
In reply to#1748
On Sat, 23 Jul 2011 05:56:27 +0000, "Geoff Schaller"
<geoffx@softwarexobjectives.com.au> wrote:

Come on Geoff,

>My suspicion is that you either misread the instructions or misunderstand them in spectacular fashion.

Please stop the bullshit. I misunderstand nothing and I can read a lot
better than you can.


I am currently using MS Security Essentials and after the initial
problems I had (and no doubt others encoutered too) it seems to work
fine. So I have nothing against this MS product (as I do have against
several others).

MS software is full of bugs - just like all other software. Nothing
special here and my only 2 remarks are: 


1 It's time that you start realizing that or admitting. Don't pretend
like MS makes top quality software. Even after that I still won't
blame you to like MS software <g>
2 I simply expect more from a company with that kind of profit figures
(especially for paid produts).

Dick

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#1756

From"Paul D B" <polleke@NOMORESPAMhnt.be>
Date2011-07-28 16:15 +0200
Message-ID<4e316ef9$0$14252$ba620e4c@news.skynet.be>
In reply to#1720
I have installed MSSE last week on two PC's. One a relatively fast one (i5) 
with W7 64 bit, another an old Pentium 4 machine with XP.
In both cases no problem at all. Install is very straightforward. The first 
scan takes a while but not hours (and you can cancel it).
It is a basic program but it works.

Now if you were having 14 virussen on your PC that tells me enough about 
your computer and surfing habits :-) .

Paul



Paul
"D.J.W. van Kooten"  schreef in bericht 
news:fljf27dcvc9q04p7npo9i85kj17klqd9tq@4ax.com...

A while ago, Geoff wrote in this NG:

Remove all your AV and install Microsoft security Essentials.
Its Free. Its Good. Its basic - no frills.

I decided to follow his advice and try MS Security Essentials instead
of AVG, also because the % of detected malware was a bit higher than
that of AVG.

This is my conclusion:

- After installation, MSSE started a scan of my whole PC. AVG finished
such a scan in about an hour, MSSE took over 6 hours!

- The good news: MSSE found more viruses than AVG did, all of them
contained in old zip files which never were or never be would
unpacked, but MSSE can not know that, and some programs are not
viruses (like Combofux which is a kind of last resort with persistent
malware but most anti virus programs think this is a virus
- The second good news is that there is an informative link to a site
telling what the virus did.

- Then I selected an action per virus. The dialog for that is very
uncomfortable, like many MS dialog in Windows (e.g. try to change your
path, since Windows 2 it's an sle were hardly 1 directory entry fits;
I always copy it to an editor and paste it back). There are only 3
lines to show the virus history, you can not enlarge the window. I
selected Delete for most as an action. A progress bar started and than
it hang.

- After restarting the PC later, Windows was installing updates. Not
sure if this is the way MSSE finishes it's action or that automatic
updates have been turned on my MSES (I have this turned off).

- Then 45 minutes of intensive hard disk activity made working nearly
impossible. I could find no option to switch something off and over
600.000 reads/writes/deletions took place in a Windows update
directory. The the MSMPENG process took a large % of my CPU.

- After a while the same 14 virusses which I had either deleted or
allowed were reported again. Same result as the day before. The
progress bar went a further after I decided to kill the MSMPENG
process

- Fortunately the disk activity sounding like a tropical rain shower
did not repeat this morning.but the same 14 virusses were again
reported. I clicked the default action to deal with it and in the
history I found for all that their actions showed Allowed.....

Geoff, sorry, I can not share your conclusion that it's Good when it
does not delete the virusses as requested. I have really tried it (if
it recognizes more malware than AVG and it would have worked well, and
it's free, why not). Of course you will reply that you don't have
these problems and that I am the only one but what could be more
straightforward than deleting a virus....I will give it a try a few
more days to see some day MSES will indeed delete the virusses or
otherwise I'll reinstall AVG.

Dick 

[toc] | [prev] | [next] | [standalone]


#1760

FromD.J.W. van Kooten <public@ic2remove.this.com>
Date2011-07-28 23:00 +0200
Message-ID<83j337toqs1ednmj3a81eh6qklu3anme68@4ax.com>
In reply to#1756
On Thu, 28 Jul 2011 16:15:21 +0200, "Paul D B"
<polleke@NOMORESPAMhnt.be> wrote:

Hello Paul,

>I have installed MSSE last week on two PC's. One a relatively fast one (i5) 
>with W7 64 bit, another an old Pentium 4 machine with XP.
>In both cases no problem at all. Install is very straightforward. The first 
>scan takes a while but not hours (and you can cancel it).

Installation was fast. Scanning not. I've got over 600.000 files on it
among them large HD videos and lots of old backups which I normally
don't delete as long as my disks have ample space. My fast P7 system
needed over 6 hours against over 1 hour for AVG.

>
>Now if you were having 14 virussen on your PC that tells me enough about 
>your computer and surfing habits :-) .
>
No, you didn't read my whole message. All virusses were either found
in old backup zip files (an older version of our mail program left the
attachments from some spam mails in a directory which was backupped)
and a zip file with lots of utilities someone gave me (I think I never
used any of them and a few contained virusses).

Now we are a week further I've helped MSES a bit by opening the old
backup files and deleting the infected zip within. Until that moment I
got the same message daily; MSES is not so good in handling contents
of zip files...

But the bright side is that it further seems to work well (like AVG
did).

Dick

[toc] | [prev] | [standalone]


Back to top | Article view | comp.lang.clipper.visual-objects


csiph-web