Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]

Groups > comp.dcom.telecom > #13330

Re: [telecom] KY: (Opinion) Our 9-1-1 system desperately needs federal money for upgrades

Show all headers | View raw

On Tue, Sep 13, 2022 at 03:50:15PM -0400, Bill Horne wrote:
> Since its inception, 9-1-1 has been a victim of its own success. Ninety-nine
> percent of the time, it just works, and people ignore it. Government leaders
> have an “if it’s not broke, why fix it” mentality.
> 
> Unfortunately, this approach is short-sighted and puts lives at risk. Simply
> put, 9-1-1 will increasingly fail to meet the needs of Kentuckians and
> Americans unless it is upgraded to Next Generation 9-1-1 technology (NG911)
> — and this can only be achieved through an infusion of federal funding.

I am always leery of "VoIP" networks, and this author's opinion
notwithstanding, I don't think they are a good idea for carrying /any/
kind of emergency communications.

There are at least two things wrong with the idea of using IP-based
connections to carry 911 traffic:

1. The basic, fundamental, underlying premise of the Internet's design
   is that any particular packet can wait until a route is available,
   and the packets that transport a 911 Voice-over-Internet-Protocal
   (VoIP) connection *MUST* be given priority over other traffic - but
   there is no mechanism in place to do that. VoIP is fine for my home
   phone (if my ISP ever stops blocking it), but it's *NOT* a reliable
   way to provide the "always on" connections needed for a PSAP to
   talk to those in need of help.

2. Deep down in the glib come-on for the IP network which is supposed
   to provide the virtual circuits that 911 must have, there is a tiny
   little tell-all that gives the project's *REAL* purpose away. The
   NSInet details say that all traffic will be carried over "private"
   or "virtually private" paths. We all know what Virtual Private
   Networks are - but what they are *NOT* is a virtual circuit, and
   the fact that they're going to be used for the "new 911" tells me
   that this allegedly "advanced" system will be composed of a few
   concentrated cubicle farms in each state (if even that), trying to
   use technology to relieve the ever-more-hungry politicians of any
   obligation to hire and pay the multi-lingual, multi-cultural
   specialists that currect E911 PSAPs are supposed to have on duty at
   all times. Of course, if multi-lingual labor can't be found, there
   will always be the temptation to "offshore" the centers overseas ...

You heard it here first.

Bill Horne

--
(Please remove QRM from my email address to write to me directly, and
please note that the Telecom Digest's email address must be modified
in an obvious way to reply to this post via email.)

Back to comp.dcom.telecom | Previous | Next — Previous in thread | Find similar | Unroll thread

Thread

KY: (Opinion) Our 9-1-1 system desperately needs federal money for upgrades  [telecom] Bill Horne <malQRMassimilation@gmail.com> - 2022-09-13 15:50 -0400
  Re: [telecom] KY: (Opinion) Our 9-1-1 system desperately needs  federal money for upgrades Bill Horne <malQRMassimilation@gmail.com> - 2022-09-14 18:29 +0000

csiph-web