Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]

Groups > comp.compilers > #1319

Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery

Show key headers only | View raw

On 7/17/2014 1:03 PM, Ivan Godard wrote:

> [The problem with LALR error recovery is that the generated parser
> combines states that are the same if your program is valid, but they
> are from different grammar rules, so you'd want to produce different
> error messages.  The size of LR(1) parser tables was an issue on a 64K
> PDP-11, but they're trivial now, and I don't know of any reason other
> than inertia to use LALR rather than LR(1). -John]
>

This suggests that LALR with sufficient error handling is of the same
size as LR(1), so I'll rephrase my question in those terms: what is
the ruleset size difference between good and no error handling for the
same language? I am concerned with ruleset size here, not table size.
Ruleset size matters to the language designer, which I have repeatedly
been in my career. Too large a ruleset makes a language intellectually
intractable and impractical to extend; one of the charges against
Algol68 was that it was too big, compared to Algol60; the WG2.1 group
of then should see the C++ spec we have now :-(

In my recursive descent compilers, I have always done semantic analysis
on the fly while doing the parse, which lets me give semantically apt
diagnostics where appropriate rather than "left parenthesis expected",
or, worse, the "right bracket cannot appear here" kind of diagnostic.

Doing semantics on the fly also permits a language to have a
semantic-directed grammar, where what can follow "foo" depends on what
"foo" is. Such grammars have much greater expressiveness than pure
BNF-style syntax, although that beauty may be in the eye of the beholder.

[Error rules in yacc parsers are really for error recovery, not error
reporting.  They let the parser resynchronize at a boundary such as a
semicolon between statements.  LALR can only tell you that the parse
failed, and it can give you a set of tokens that would be valid where
the parse failed, but that set is often too large due to the way the
states are created.  It's certainly easier to produce diagnostics in a
RD parser.  What's hard is to verify that the language it accepts is
the language you want, and that it correctly catches any invalid
input. -John]

Back to comp.compilers | Previous | Next — Previous in thread | Next in thread | Find similar | Unroll thread

Thread

LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Seima Rao <seimarao@gmail.com> - 2014-07-10 05:30 +0530
  Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Ivan Godard <ivan@ootbcomp.com> - 2014-07-16 16:39 -0400
    Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Evangelos Drikos <drikosev@otenet.gr> - 2014-07-17 20:15 +0300
      Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Ivan Godard <ivan@ootbcomp.com> - 2014-07-17 13:03 -0700
        Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Ivan Godard <ivan@ootbcomp.com> - 2014-07-17 13:57 -0700
          Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery wclodius@earthlink.net (William Clodius) - 2014-07-18 13:41 -0600
            Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Stefan Monnier <monnier@iro.umontreal.ca> - 2014-07-18 21:09 -0400
              Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Hans-Peter Diettrich <DrDiettrich1@aol.com> - 2014-07-19 12:04 +0200
                Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Stefan Monnier <monnier@iro.umontreal.ca> - 2014-07-20 10:28 -0400
                Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Hans-Peter Diettrich <DrDiettrich1@netscape.net> - 2014-07-21 10:46 +0200
                Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Stefan Monnier <monnier@iro.umontreal.ca> - 2014-08-06 21:32 -0400
            Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery arnold@skeeve.com (Aharon Robbins) - 2014-07-20 06:05 +0000
    Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery George Neuner <gneuner2@comcast.net> - 2014-07-17 18:49 -0400
      Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery wclodius@earthlink.net (William Clodius) - 2014-07-18 13:41 -0600
        Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Hans Aberg <haberg-news@telia.com> - 2014-07-19 15:29 +0200
          Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Evangelos Drikos <drikosev@otenet.gr> - 2014-07-20 00:40 +0300
            Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Hans Aberg <haberg-news@telia.com> - 2014-07-20 01:38 +0200
              Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Evangelos Drikos <drikosev@otenet.gr> - 2014-07-21 15:20 +0300
                Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Hans Aberg <haberg-news@telia.com> - 2014-07-21 18:39 +0200
                Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Evangelos Drikos <drikosev@otenet.gr> - 2014-08-26 13:44 +0300
                Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Hans Aberg <haberg-news@telia.com> - 2014-08-29 11:13 +0200
                Re: split tokens; was LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Evangelos Drikos <drikosev@otenet.gr> - 2014-09-03 16:57 +0300
                Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Hans Aberg <haberg-news@telia.com> - 2014-09-03 19:07 +0200
        Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery George Neuner <gneuner2@comcast.net> - 2014-07-20 01:19 -0400
          Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery wclodius@earthlink.net (William Clodius) - 2014-07-20 21:43 -0600
            Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery wclodius@earthlink.net (William Clodius) - 2014-07-21 21:44 -0600
          Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Chris Dodd <cdodd@acm.org> - 2014-07-21 06:07 +0000
            Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery George Neuner <gneuner2@comcast.net> - 2014-07-25 21:58 -0400
              Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Chris Dodd <cdodd@acm.org> - 2014-07-26 21:16 +0000
                Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Hans-Peter Diettrich <DrDiettrich1@netscape.net> - 2014-07-28 14:43 +0200
                Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Chris Dodd <cdodd@acm.org> - 2014-07-29 19:38 +0000
  Re: LR(1) Parsing : Error Handling & Recovery Eric <news@fx29.iad.highwinds-media.com> - 2014-07-16 16:40 -0400

csiph-web