Groups | Search | Server Info | Keyboard shortcuts | Login | Register [http] [https] [nntp] [nntps]

Groups > comp.compilers > #2415

Segmentation in programming language grammars .. why?

Show all headers | View raw

I see this with many specifications -- redundant non-terminals and rules. I'll
illustrate it with a part of the grammar spec for C17.

Abbreviate opt, statement, labeled-statement, compound-statement,
expression-statement, selection-statement, iteration-statement,
jump-statement, block-item, block-item-list, declaration, expression,
constant-expression, identifier respectively as ?, S, Sx, Sc, Se, Sb, Sl, Sj,
SD, SDs, D, E, Ec, X for

The statement grammar is
(6.8)   S -> Sx | Sc | Se | Sb | Sl | Sj
(6.8.1) Sx -> X ':' S
        Sx -> 'case' Ec ':' S
        Sx -> 'default' ':' S
(6.8.2) Sc -> '{' SDs? '}'
        SDs -> SD | SDs SD
        SD -> D | S
(6.8.3) Se -> E? ';'
(6.8.4) Sb -> 'if' '(' E ')' S
        Sb -> 'if' '(' E ')' S 'else' S
        Sb -> 'switch' '(' E ')' S
(6.8.5) Sl -> 'while' '(' E ')' S
        Sl -> 'do' S 'while' '(' E ')' ';'
        Sl -> 'for' '(' E? ';' E? ';' E? ')' S
        Sl -> 'for' '(' D  E? ';' E? ')' S
(6.8.6) Sj -> 'goto' X ';'
        Sj -> 'continue' ';'
        Sj -> 'break' ';'
        Sj -> 'return' E? ';'

and is segmented into subgroups Sx, Sc, Se, Sb, Sl, Sj of S. Why? Why not just
write it as one segment like this? It's not creating new conflicts in so
doing.

(6.8)
(6.8.1) S -> X ':' S
        S -> 'case' Ec ':' S
        S -> 'default' ':' S
(6.8.2) S -> '{' SDs? '}'
(6.8.3) S -> E? ';'
        SDs -> SD | SDs SD
        SD -> D | S
(6.8.4) S -> 'if' '(' E ')' S
        S -> 'if' '(' E ')' S 'else' S
        S -> 'switch' '(' E ')' S
(6.8.5) S -> 'while' '(' E ')' S
        S -> 'do' S 'while' '(' E ')' ';'
        S -> 'for' '(' E? ';' E? ';' E? ')' S
        S -> 'for' '(' D  E? ';' E? ')' S
(6.8.6) S -> 'goto' X ';'
        S -> 'continue' ';'
        S -> 'break' ';'
        S -> 'return' E? ';'

Back to comp.compilers | Previous | Next — Next in thread | Find similar

Thread

Segmentation in programming language grammars .. why? rockbrentwood@gmail.com - 2019-12-29 21:05 -0800
  Re: Segmentation in programming language grammars .. why? Kaz Kylheku <493-878-3164@kylheku.com> - 2019-12-30 18:04 +0000

csiph-web