Path: csiph.com!news.mixmin.net!news2.arglkargh.de!news.karotte.org!fu-berlin.de!uni-berlin.de!individual.net!not-for-mail From: "Carlos E. R." Newsgroups: comp.mobile.android Subject: Re: Car radio Date: Wed, 29 Nov 2023 22:45:51 +0100 Lines: 122 Message-ID: References: Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8; format=flowed Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit X-Trace: individual.net 3FSp+vH571uloCnYpsmL3wO8p777Lj8DBo9PQg5Nt1qz1IiSFM Cancel-Lock: sha1:h5goBTqPJ41cF9kT8dq+0ETOd4k= sha256:dps6ON/hzD0VSXXZw695gBO2N2JaMmuTA6saBjJmEUM= User-Agent: Mozilla Thunderbird Content-Language: en-CA, es-ANY In-Reply-To: Xref: csiph.com comp.mobile.android:110829 On 2023-11-29 21:16, Wally J wrote: > "Carlos E. R." wrote > >>> But the _main_ messaging app on Android (for SMS/MMS) does not (as far as I >>> know but I don't know if RCS changes that equation). >> >> No. >> >> There is no need, the app only gets the messages sent by the provider to >> that phone number. There is a password, mind: the SIM card PIN number >> (ok, it can be blanked). > > Thanks for clarifying that RCS doesn't add any extra account requirement. > >> Things change when you want to read/write messages on the computer; they >> can use an authorization by taking a photo with the phone of a dot >> pattern on the computer, but if the computer has independent access, it >> needs a login/pass. > > I use a computer all the time to manage my Android phone, and all I have to > do is accept the "trust challenge" which takes on a variety of forms. > adb pair [IP][Port] [code] > Android 12 Wireless Pairing > Allow wireless debugging 502 Bad Gateway on most photos. > > There's no need to "log into" any account to "manage" my phone on a PC. > > Hell, I can install and delete apps and modify settings, and everything. > Drag APK from Windows > > Since none of that needs an account to be created, I have to wonder what on > earth on an Android phone truly "requires" an account to be created. > > Of course, billions of apps _want_ an account - but that's a completely > different question of wanting you to create one versus actually needing it. > > >>> That means I don't need an "account" to log into but of course, the phone >>> itself is tied to an account on T-Mobile (or Verizon, AT&T, etc.). The >>> MMS/SMS "messaging" app goes through them, but there isn't a login, per se. >> >> There is a login, only that you don't notice it. > > Yes. Let's not get picky (we'll leave that to the iPhone people to play > those games). Suffice to say nobody is getting cellular service for free, > and everyone who is getting it has an account of some format. > > Although it's created with the credit card, in my case anyway, and there's > no login (although if I wanted to get billing paperless their would be). Your "login" is your phone identifying itself to your provider via its phone number and some other codes. And at some point you have to enter the SIM PIN. > >>> As for "Inventory, saving your settings, keeping track of progress", why >>> can't you store that stuff locally on the phone itself? >> >> Of course you can, but the point is "across devices". > > Hmmm... true. But not really. If you're good at computers, you can sync to > your own computers. Why do you need to sync to someone else's computer? Confort, easy of use. Why should I bother putting my own computer online on internet (it must be internet, not my LAN), with some daemon. Not everybody can do that. And it costs money. > > My problem with OwnCloud is that it really doesn't run on Windows. > So I'd have to set up a desktop as a Linux server to use it fruitfully. > >> In the case of "radio apps" you get the same list of favourites or saved >> stations on your different phones, "automatically". >> >> Those things can be, theoretically be saved on google servers (google >> drive) with a google account (I don't know the requirements), or at some >> server of the application provider. > > I haven't set up my own server, but the way I'd approach that problem set, > if I wanted to implement it, would be to set up my router on the net. > > Then I could use my own router as the OwnCloud server and accomplish what > you're seeking. As always, it takes intelligence & effort to maintain > privacy. I haven't expended that effort. But that's how I'd do it if I did. An effort I refuse to undertake. And a privacy leak that is perfectly ignorable. Thy don't get any information that I care about. And yes, I'm not stupid, it is a conscious choice, I am very well aware of what it entails and I choose to do it this way. They offer a service and I accept it freely in sound mind. > >> And it can be absolutely innocent. You save your configuration/status, >> and they never ever have a peek at it or use it for anything at all. It >> is just some feature that in many apps is optional. >> >> Some developers only want to know how many people use the feature, or >> how many subscribe per month. Ie, statistics of some sort. > > Understood that the account need can be innocent - but - you know as well > as I do that plenty of things ask for an account that don't really need it. If it is really really really no needed, then I can say "no". As I say "no" to register to the radio station to listen to their streams. Life would be far easier using their app, which demands registration, and I say no. Radio listening has always been anonymous and I keep it. See? There are limits. On this I see a privacy limit being crossed and I react. Another conscious choice taken with me free will taken in sound mind. -- Cheers, Carlos E.R.