Path: csiph.com!eternal-september.org!feeder.eternal-september.org!aioe.org!bofh.it!news.nic.it!robomod
From: Luca Vercelli <luca.vercelli.to@gmail.com>
Newsgroups: linux.debian.maint.java
Subject: Re: plans for eclipse luna in debian
Date: Fri, 23 Oct 2015 21:00:03 +0200
Message-ID: <qmPJh-1zw-29@gated-at.bofh.it>
References: <pbaVk-2ca-15@gated-at.bofh.it> <qhJ1L-7NG-11@gated-at.bofh.it> <qhJEu-l4-19@gated-at.bofh.it> <qkzpg-6HT-25@gated-at.bofh.it> <qkBho-14t-15@gated-at.bofh.it> <qkYnD-17l-3@gated-at.bofh.it> <qlCO6-1qN-13@gated-at.bofh.it> <qlIAa-1CH-5@gated-at.bofh.it>
Old-Return-Path: <luca.vercelli.to@gmail.com>
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux i686; rv:38.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/38.3.0
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="------------060908000709050108010402"
Approved: robomod@news.nic.it
Lines: 125
Organization: linux.* mail to news gateway
Sender: robomod@news.nic.it
Xref: csiph.com linux.debian.maint.java:8505

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.
--------------060908000709050108010402
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

I suppose the initial Tycho repository should be something like the
attached one.
I downloaded upstream source from
http://git.eclipse.org/c/tycho/org.eclipse.tycho.git/snapshot/org.eclipse.tycho-tycho-0.23.0.tar.xz


Il 20/10/2015 19:06, Markus Koschany ha scritto:
> Am 20.10.2015 um 12:58 schrieb Luca Vercelli:
>> I am not an expert with mh_make, however I see a problem here.
>> Eclipse build depends on Tycho, however Tycho build depends on both
>> Eclipse and Tycho itself!
> Indeed that is nasty. But it looks like the Fedora maintainers have
> solved this issue too. [1] We need to do something similar for Debian to
> break this circular dependency.
>
>> So, two problems:
>> (1) mh_make fails for both projects.
>> Markus, can you explain me how were you able to build the base structure
>> of Eclipse without mh_make? I should do the same with Tycho.
> mh_make often chokes on bigger projects with a lot of unpackaged
> dependencies. I simply ignored as many dependencies as I could and you
> can find the end result in maven.rules and maven.ignoreRules. Then I
> used the current packaging for Eclipse as a template. It should be
> sufficient to start with a minimal debian/rules files. In the first
> phase we only have to modify the maven.* files and debian/control. For
> Tycho you can basically do the same.
>
> If you can answer the question why mh_make fails with Tycho, you will
> know what dependency we should package first. Just let me know what
> dependencies we need for Tycho and I can lend you a hand.
>
>
>> (2) How to build everything?
>> Fedora packagers were able to build just a tiny part of Tycho (a
>> "bootstrap"), then a tiny part of Eclipse, then Tycho, and at last
>> Eclipse. What about Debian?
> AFAIK they provide different build options. The bootstrap is one of them
> but otherwise Eclipse and Tycho build-depend on each other. I don't know
> how to solve this properly yet but I expect we will end up with doing
> something similar. Remember that the optimization step is always the
> last part, so feel free to solve this issue with the least amount of effort.
>
> Markus
>
>
> [1] http://pkgs.fedoraproject.org/cgit/tycho.git/tree/
>


--------------060908000709050108010402
Content-Type: application/gzip;
 name="tycho-debian.tar.gz"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Disposition: attachment;
 filename="tycho-debian.tar.gz"

H4sIAPKBKlYAA+0ca3PjtjFfy1+BjptJcjWphyUrVWxPLnfOa845j+9y05k0k4FISIJNEiwB
OlZ/fXcBkCIpySZl2TftCcn4SGJ3scAusAvsQgGbcBp30ixk8rMnKt1u93gwIPgvlPq/3W5v
2CO9/nGv3x/0elDR7R0d9Yafke5TMVQumVQ0BVZSIdR9cA/V1zv3P1IO/trJZNqZ8LgT0RtG
3KnD7hKRKvLzyw8v//jx7cX5qYYI+aRzfRt1AjalWajca3pLHefzsfOXYE7+9i1x3YSmNAxZ
CI+TjIeBXEjFotOI3rLYcT52R/dlbQnM/NdC8vyQ0finWSxSdrXDBeGh+Q8rgJ7/vVF32B2N
YP4fDweD/fx/jrKfl592sfMfVne18OdCL+teIqJdOgP3z/8e2P1ubf4PR739/H+WckDecKmI
mJLLtxdkymHVJ1OREjVnJKH+DZ0x54B8L9KIaig151KDES7HUHOSUDUnShDQGf39jPwmEsVF
/PsLqP5zzlJGzAfi05hMGGIR8BG4tjNjYv41hJEHGgeEK0loqviU+orwKXxbVLBcaG1MAhF/
AdUxSDAMNceA75H3gmQSGo1LXVJzYJ9CM37KqGKBpkYI+Cfg69CUhwvda5+livK4aFsSmflz
QiX5GeZFIHxyTVPpkd+i+R+23UOyfMZ587tlNBboELFYjUnKInHLNIMn5tsZUXRGpimMmWXb
YtkhPz2xD2dj6DuhoWJpTBW/LYSCQ469hAGO8yHg8awYRtvBldG07cypzNtyb1kqQTxjJMnj
gPswQGbAkDeR8hmPaUgsmFECzTOogH6UNGI4RvicJVLBEEfAZ6pyJixKTqGmX57l6YaxxGUh
i2CA5OkJPvUO8W8fR4GEVk//efGG5FDIMqIB35WBhBJkKY4HJdqpARVkKdVa+CcHhQWZ6e+o
tcBNRYSWnXzETrWKAwu5pmND2sFdqiiVUvgcFcuQz6VwmHPDFVSAkk5YLiwERdll0ogNVFNE
EYpryUxF0XLFwhXahfV6XNF80Et4B+60sy7noGYdhESGgXACCq45e63X+5wtIwFkYJbxgIEG
MWmbyeS1G4NgT0/wL3Qf/9msdQzkM4GZtEBR1HgoUbQqcHpiH4BurhWPIQ2TrUQdJrxctzqU
qoFkfLOZXsAk7nDSQvaIjh95bJQoV2FQ9RDH3rMj+tNaOVuNu0+qfgg6xKecQZvLZ2j5rV47
KawzWkeKqoIFbJ2cR4lakMmC2O1ZPqckV8y9i8LTk1D4mvUVknmFJojwHsDjogs6GzMW6ElW
7k/e15U2a/1yYC5pWmuXG8f4G5MsDkAgnTawlTcXzPeMqS0IAJ9xQEMRgznpuwFPma9E2oqQ
SGce80OeSObpGo9FExYELPW0TgWPpOaDrdsNpaTvpUyK8HZXrAFBJUQod88eh9Xq8eTMjjZl
iQCdFuliV93dAXexEPDig4FSj2WrpCCegvWp3UR6WA6a6O6FsStejUh2QQxpeJni4WOWInan
/bSH9ENymbns3xmPxV0b0PKLSxO+NW6+SG1NIKRZ7M/BPDcarIgpGlBF3UiAj9EIJeewQTcN
Ak6ERoBKW/EZQKTg7DSTNjpQsI1I3eug2WQoEJIwA/eqEU7hi7VBkiJLfdYQQxtKgKUKTH0E
TMZTPsuMW9xMkDiNW/VJRDMWo+ctWo2FzFI25Q0lWgBXX7dqb3VhyKs8IWd8IoR6cNo0J3md
xbyZQjWmNtgxuVEjeilsyKhsJq4c1rzZOtlKq/pNwfIHF3ZpNGjGXxktdwpbclfgb4uWTWC3
O2+5fpQILC1tGwr5dhZXL6rnbCM03tD4ouAftBgf+zzsUyv2/Nef03jGQjF7ijYeiv/0B908
/ts97h+Tbm/Q6+/jv89S9NQkXw68oddze1+RX3+5On9z/vLd+etvSAb+QuwvTiMW8CxyHEJe
kJ/AKHAakvO7JGUpx1M4eLsya7oHMK5L3mQ+JR8YOCZhyMlJCK/erX0Fl/3bWUR5CFuX6IyQ
9/PskPT75K2vSL/bG8LzuDsc974mf+/2ut39evDEZW38R2YTqW5puqMg0APzH6Z9v4j/jPpD
jP+ORsf7+f8c5SAP/wQsYXEA853bCFBFJQ6J9eNZoCvxpFaf/BnrIWKVitAx2/xXZvPzWhOU
p0DH7BvMLtk6JJZqUVnbMbl9b1gHKThcbKBxTdMNNXimgRsluVKfhOwuk7gXwsAPOCE92zD5
8uyUwIs3/EoDFtsKfUxsevqrDXZcGifmgz3c7nr9I69rYfJhMO60JkVlNFhygMf+6ADjCACf
crWG3TF/9WsIFvto+TlgPqzF4FgtP81p5KfmJLsyGjSFvfstbmer3+3Y5DvkWi0g6IPn2vcj
vfVeDhn0/KvyyK42Vgy5lXjP624hDwuoj2z6lea93j0iy8++c7HYz++hz2skdX8PI+HfgJNd
Jv9a+DmZIlEquHED4R8SQ9c8l7Wg+LIq2aKqKt3ic0XCxdc1Uq7VrZF0DaIi7aJuk+hWAeri
q0OU5IZVy+FbEdDHXiH/v4tdwZ+0DbCHo+Hwvvwv6/8Pu93hAPM/+v3j7mdk+KRc2fKJ2/9K
/t8TZQE/4P+NjkajWv7PYHC8z/95luJoq0TsX5oS2Rn8y/NedAbeXQf2ey8cPCKkCfXnzLMG
ilQMlcU60lhHa7C0bpGlm0fzhhrBp6w5tI4vNAe3VpAmvDmOZApNpmyAYeNypGpQl4h26hW4
PnA/p5n0jIkkJWMrYrD+Lo1jofRpfal57RK1IJIHYypj0I6Ute2u9XDa8qJN/xKpXx6/ylk0
uTfeSWzNsgtdrYLdLemZMGJBFd8eRbqWCbATdsuR450QXBObfSq6ux7feqh6V3yvxr+fhucd
qkUlOWG3FJ+Cyx0rQj1itRNma0SfgOZuSS6jkzuhu0yH2IJcPU/BrvXt8PLlcyvkIj9hG2yd
ytwAZ1PQrGmb63NHivGmSRJym5rXmpqJ9S/nmAn9g8HmeH6/BcV2g1JOmGg3HCWHryFGOVWk
HSbmRbdCqCaytMMtgtBt0dqNvI2ut0eCudIKZ332ZKFxJX+iOUm7mLVjpJbQ02p4N7ckRUzV
ImF155cn800+vEkrW7MDWP1ePX/rkLWncnmHXjx9U9ouP0NDT9KEdiA29gCJiD/7HpURvhuA
YnP7sbffH71Uzn/yvJNgl7c/t7r/2R/t4//PUvYz4NMu1Qju07TxwPw/Gg2GRf7PaNjD3384
HvX38/85ysHBAXklIszjwW0+aAHG/+dgDvBuE3pBk5DlN3yk5yD8r7FvMPBmEAu4vigYec47
HWMfG9fKeQcOob5WqMOjlykXeGo1tpdBaej8KCKW0BkgzJVK5LjTyT00sNkml7HjvNNuZhpI
90N+TfHI+4fXd77DG3iujRKOHbzgF2Oo9WsMuB46JLqNMVqrg7XO/THuUvWaHIVS7YYMhObk
qzH0UkUlj3u1Fm9xrdSVj1NLn1ezBpw1+QEV0Grqga6a+KyAZP615aYU8K5SuL7Di3KlihlL
RcwjvRUEiGtXJkt2ZniLbQqehv7AmEHhfja4LpGQtECQVA0sD3f/sT89YpMuxtVEFadQE5uF
cUG5Pa8e28uP5G064Zi19jLks1jr8Xu8sXqS3NhQeFTgyG/x2qn0aMiFmntmtUT9PHMOyGXK
CgUkJ/r6piuZPgWAuZTfV7UZrvLMWSrrJy+9A3LFzCLScOwOyLtsNsODw4bgl6m45QFrCn7F
kpD6jcFfYnKFghUuwyvsNAwdXEaTRcpnc6Vp2Gd9//ybYgHFFfOHyzd9pPEqz7lF+Px5DTw1
uVfcJwWU4ZgGETR+cnX+8vXFuWeV+z582Kwj5vmdSqn7PV6Mv6e7NAi4WalrPwuA1+Dz/f4C
6eWUEspTxJQwUqxEEZVLfgNgKVDOfz5AXzb3wyxgh0SCLuA9dVm+Y4uUyUmE50FIWB7inVSF
vyfwhSSR+ckAvNgdszpBj/wiFPfNjXs073rrqbnCSSj9lCfGNH2XhQE5N1aHmAVWmuu6F/pX
i8h7fUqAPAs/k9AXEcN4XpjYpLaW/iFsQ2M+xU3oVPeQJkkqYNdKHH1zFu0Utl9uxoV2DsmU
UdQfeMqSAC/d4zoPb1evLknp9E8CIbwX/vbdD5zY4zjPIfD/FZ5Y4vF83g6ysqh3yLvPx6/s
//jOf/pHl4fyP4fDld//ON7//sfzFAdNBdF/Xpj/7gv456ZmHayJkpsXc1NsI5SXTzXj3rAY
lha/yP1silbxmSpIm6Mb14Hy8sNpoK1aocGS0wwcgzEtQD2TFQE2NAQP2QOFVE1bWo2Kt8Gr
h6jb4K6LHLfEr4Zvt0XejvdSvHQrzC1aXYlTPgL5EbjboZbii5vxSyGch4Dqt10fRNgQb9iI
5jH0cuQy+mLe1zW34az/mim10Fs5mfHajCyhlJckMPwJA3eDrbTzsdf5fdmXfdmXevkvBg7Z
1gBYAAA=
--------------060908000709050108010402--