Path: csiph.com!x330-a1.tempe.blueboxinc.net!usenet.pasdenom.info!aioe.org!news.stack.nl!newsfeed.xs4all.nl!newsfeed6.news.xs4all.nl!xs4all!post.news.xs4all.nl!not-for-mail
Date: Sat, 11 Feb 2012 07:06:22 +0900
From: umedoblock <umedoblock@gmail.com>
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux i686; rv:9.0) Gecko/20111229 Thunderbird/9.0
MIME-Version: 1.0
To: python-list@python.org
Subject: why does subtype_dict() and getset_get() makes infinite loop ?
Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="------------050800090401050400080004"
Precedence: list
Newsgroups: comp.lang.python
Message-ID: <mailman.5682.1328911614.27778.python-list@python.org>
Lines: 142
NNTP-Posting-Host: 2001:888:2000:d::a6
Xref: x330-a1.tempe.blueboxinc.net comp.lang.python:20195

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.
--------------050800090401050400080004
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-2022-JP
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

Hi, everyone.
I'm umedoblock.

now, I wrote a below sentence.

But I cannot debug below infinite loop.
Do I mistake when I write a c exetension ?
I attached sample code.
Please help me.

==========================================
Python 3.2.2 (default, Jan 27 2012, 03:19:53)
[GCC 4.6.1] on linux2

class Bar_abstract(metaclass=ABCMeta):
    pass

# c extension
# class Bar_base(Bar_abstract):
#     pass

class Bar(Bar_base):
    pass
==========================================

but do this

bar = Bar()
dir(bar)

then python3.2.2 generates a core.
Because subtype_dict() and getset_get() makes infinite loop.

I checked stack with GDB.

==================================================================
#130948 0x0817670a in getset_get (descr=0xb73ae034, obj=0xb73e7e44,
    type=0x88ba4cc) at ../Objects/descrobject.c:148
#130949 0x080719f5 in subtype_dict (obj=0xb73e7e44, context=0x0)
    at ../Objects/typeobject.c:1756
#130950 0x0817670a in getset_get (descr=0xb73ae034, obj=0xb73e7e44,
    type=0x88ba4cc) at ../Objects/descrobject.c:148
#130951 0x080719f5 in subtype_dict (obj=0xb73e7e44, context=0x0)
    at ../Objects/typeobject.c:1756
#130952 0x0817670a in getset_get (descr=0xb73ae034, obj=0xb73e7e44,
    type=0x88ba4cc) at ../Objects/descrobject.c:148
#130953 0x080719f5 in subtype_dict (obj=0xb73e7e44, context=0x0)
    at ../Objects/typeobject.c:1756
==================================================================

GDB show me above code.
Now, I suspect below point PyObject_GetAttrString().

But I cannot debug this infinite loop.
Do I mistake when I write a c exetension ?
I attached sample code.
Please help me.

ojects/object.c:1325

static PyObject *
_generic_dir(PyObject *obj)
{
    PyObject *result = NULL;
    PyObject *dict = NULL;
    PyObject *itsclass = NULL;

    /* Get __dict__ (which may or may not be a real dict...) */
>>> dict = PyObject_GetAttrString(obj, "__dict__");

--------------050800090401050400080004
Content-Type: application/zip;
 name="bar_ext.zip"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Disposition: attachment;
 filename="bar_ext.zip"
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--------------050800090401050400080004--